- Collection:
- Georgia Government Publications
- Serial:
- The performance of state charter schools in Georgia ...
- Title:
- Technical appendix to the performance of state charter schools in Georgia, 2013/2014
- Creator:
- Sass, Tim R
- Contributor to Resource:
- State Charter Schools Commission of Georgia
Georgia. Governor's Office of Student Achievement - Publisher:
- Atlanta, Ga. : State Charter Schools Commission of Georgia
- Date of Original:
- 2015-05-26
- Subject:
- Charter schools--Georgia
- Location:
- United States, Georgia, 32.75042, -83.50018
- Medium:
- annual reports
- Type:
- Text
- Format:
- application/pdf
- Description:
- This report is an appendix to the performance evaluation of Georgia state charter schools
- External Identifiers:
- Call Number GA S375.C4 S1 P4 2013/2014 Appendix
- Metadata URL:
- https://dlg.galileo.usg.edu/id:dlg_ggpd_y-ga-bs375-pc4-bs1-bp4-b2013-s2014-bappendix-belec-p-btext
- Digital Object URL:
- https://dlg.galileo.usg.edu/do:dlg_ggpd_y-ga-bs375-pc4-bs1-bp4-b2013-s2014-bappendix-belec-p-btext
- Language:
- eng
- Holding Institution:
- University of Georgia. Map and Government Information Library
- Rights:
-
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Technical Appendix to
The Performance of State Charter Schools in Georgia, 2013-14
by Tim R. Sass, Ph.D. Distinguished University Professor Department of Economics Andrew Young School of Policy Studies Georgia State University
May 26, 2015
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Table of Contents
I. Proficiency Levels .......................................................................................................................... 1 II. Value Added Models .................................................................................................................. 12
Value-Added Model Estimates .................................................................................................. 14 III. School Effect Estimates Based on Alternative Value-Added Models and School-Level
Growth Percentiles Based on Alternative Measures and Samples ......................................147 A. State Charter School Effects -- Statewide Comparisons from Alternate Value-Added Models..................................................................................................................................... 148 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading .............................................................................. 148 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA ..................................................................................... 150 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math .................................................................................. 152 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science............................................................................... 154 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Social Studies ..................................................................... 156 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading .......................................................................... 158 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA ................................................................................. 160 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math ............................................................................. 162 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science........................................................................... 164 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies ................................................................. 166 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature ................................................. 168 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 American Literature.................................................. 170 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry .................................................... 172 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology ...................................................................... 174 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra................................................... 176 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Economics................................................................. 178 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Math II ...................................................................... 180 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science ........................................................ 182 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History ............................................................... 184 B. State Charter School Effects -- District Comparisons from Alternate Value-Added Models..................................................................................................................................... 186 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading .............................................................................. 186 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA ..................................................................................... 210
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math .................................................................................. 233 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science............................................................................... 256 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading .......................................................................... 301 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA ................................................................................. 330 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math .............................................................................. 360 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science........................................................................... 387 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies ................................................................. 414 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature ................................................. 441 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry .................................................... 453 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology ...................................................................... 457 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra................................................... 461 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science ........................................................ 468 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History ............................................................... 475
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
I. Proficiency Levels
Table 1: Percentage of Students Meeting/Exceeding Proficiency Targets on CRCT by Subject and Grade Level
System Name
Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School
CRCT Reading
N Tested
% Did not meet the standard
% Meets the standard
% Exceeds the standard
% Met or Exceeded the standard
798
13.3
42.4
44.4
86.7
38
13.2
63.2
23.7
86.8
109
0.0
31.2
68.8
100.0
133
12.0
37.6
50.4
88.0
41
9.8
65.9
24.4
90.2
45
6.7
44.4
48.9
93.3
41
4.9
53.7
41.5
95.1
76
13.2
59.2
27.6
86.8
93
2.2
28.0
69.9
97.8
126,745
7.7
46.5
45.9
92.3
809
8.9
42.3
48.8
91.1
31
6.5
48.4
45.2
93.5
115
3.5
34.8
61.7
96.5
134
4.5
35.8
59.7
95.5
24
8.3
54.2
37.5
91.7
24
16.7
41.7
41.7
83.3
45
2.2
46.7
51.1
97.8
79
8.9
62.0
29.1
91.1
91
2.2
25.3
72.5
97.8
124,872
6.4
41.3
52.3
93.6
873
8.4
47.7
44.0
91.6
22
4.5
68.2
27.3
95.5
115
0.9
45.2
53.9
99.1
167
6.0
46.1
47.9
94.0
16
31.3
56.3
12.5
68.8
24
8.3
58.3
33.3
91.7
44
2.3
45.5
52.3
97.7
66
12.1
74.2
13.6
87.9
71
2.8
47.9
49.3
97.2
123,653
5.2
53.1
41.7
94.8
1,089
2.1
42.4
55.5
97.9
1
Cherokee Charter
108
0.9
35.2
63.9
99.1
Heritage Prep Academy
59
1.7
64.4
33.9
98.3
Georgia Connections
232
3.0
34.5
62.5
97.0
Ivy Prep Young Men's
25
16.0
56.0
28.0
84.0
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
25
4.0
52.0
44.0
96.0
CCAT School
23
0.0
43.5
56.5
100.0
Ivy Prep Academy
94
2.1
36.2
61.7
97.9
Pataula Charter
46
4.3
56.5
39.1
95.7
Fulton Leadership
57
3.5
40.4
56.1
96.5
Atlanta Heights
60
0.0
85.0
15.0
100.0
Coweta Charter
39
0.0
38.5
61.5
100.0
Statewide Average
124,746
2.8
47.6
49.6
97.2
Grade 7
Odyssey School
1,378
5.0
51.2
43.8
95.0
Cherokee Charter
113
4.4
32.7
62.8
95.6
Heritage Prep Academy
58
3.4
63.8
32.8
96.6
Georgia Connections
289
2.8
42.6
54.7
97.2
Ivy Prep Young Men's
49
16.3
67.3
16.3
83.7
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
42
0.0
59.5
40.5
100.0
CCAT School
19
5.3
57.9
36.8
94.7
Ivy Prep Academy
88
3.4
48.9
47.7
96.6
Pataula Charter
38
7.9
47.4
44.7
92.1
Fulton Leadership
57
0.0
40.4
59.6
100.0
Atlanta Heights
58
10.3
69.0
20.7
89.7
Statewide Average
127,269
5.3
53.0
41.7
94.7
Grade 8
Odyssey School
1,511
2.9
42.8
54.3
97.1
Cherokee Charter
95
0.0
35.8
64.2
100.0
Heritage Prep Academy
51
7.8
62.7
29.4
92.2
Georgia Connections
312
2.2
42.3
55.4
97.8
Ivy Prep Young Men's
39
0.0
53.8
46.2
100.0
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
37
2.7
43.2
54.1
97.3
CCAT School
25
0.0
56.0
44.0
100.0
Ivy Prep Academy
114
0.9
39.5
59.6
99.1
Pataula Charter
43
2.3
30.2
67.4
97.7
Fulton Leadership
52
0.0
46.2
53.8
100.0
Atlanta Heights
45
4.4
68.9
26.7
95.6
Statewide Average
126,232
3.0
43.7
53.2
97.0
System Name
Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood
N Tested
CRCT ELA
% Did not meet the standard
% Meets the standard
% Exceeds the standard
% Met or Exceeded the standard
797
20.1
52.9
27.0
79.9
38
26.3
52.6
21.1
73.7
109
2.8
46.8
50.5
97.2
132
15.2
53.8
31.1
84.8
41
17.1
63.4
19.5
82.9
45
2.2
55.6
42.2
97.8
42
7.1
66.7
26.2
92.9
76
26.3
59.2
14.5
73.7
93
1.1
47.3
51.6
98.9
127,032
11.5
56.1
32.3
88.5
801
17.1
49.6
33.3
82.9
31
16.1
54.8
29.0
83.9
115
6.1
49.6
44.3
93.9
133
12.8
39.1
48.1
87.2
24
20.8
62.5
16.7
79.2
24
8.3
62.5
29.2
91.7
44
6.8
61.4
31.8
93.2
79
11.4
73.4
15.2
88.6
91
4.4
46.2
49.5
95.6
124,719
11.3
54.0
34.8
88.7
874
10.0
54.7
35.4
90.0
22
9.1
59.1
31.8
90.9
114
1.8
54.4
43.9
98.2
168
9.5
58.9
31.5
90.5
16
25.0
62.5
12.5
75.0
24
12.5
58.3
29.2
87.5
44
0.0
52.3
47.7
100.0
66
3.0
83.3
13.6
97.0
71
1.4
60.6
38.0
98.6
123,571
5.3
55.6
39.2
94.7
1,088
8.2
57.8
34.0
91.8
108
3.7
53.7
42.6
96.3
59
11.9
61.0
27.1
88.1
231
5.6
61.0
33.3
94.4
24
12.5
66.7
20.8
87.5
25
0.0
68.0
32.0
100.0
CCAT School
23
17.4
60.9
21.7
82.6
Ivy Prep Academy
94
3.2
60.6
36.2
96.8
Pataula Charter
46
6.5
76.1
17.4
93.5
Fulton Leadership
55
3.6
63.6
32.7
96.4
Atlanta Heights
60
10.0
73.3
16.7
90.0
Coweta Charter
39
0.0
56.4
43.6
100.0
Statewide Average
124,615
8.2
59.6
32.2
91.8
Grade 7
Odyssey School
1,367
7.1
46.2
46.7
92.9
Cherokee Charter
112
7.1
31.3
61.6
92.9
Heritage Prep Academy
58
3.4
65.5
31.0
96.6
Georgia Connections
286
4.2
40.2
55.6
95.8
Ivy Prep Young Men's
49
22.4
57.1
20.4
77.6
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
42
0.0
52.4
47.6
100.0
CCAT School
19
15.8
52.6
31.6
84.2
Ivy Prep Academy
88
1.1
42.0
56.8
98.9
Pataula Charter
38
5.3
55.3
39.5
94.7
Fulton Leadership
57
0.0
38.6
61.4
100.0
Atlanta Heights
58
8.6
60.3
31.0
91.4
Statewide Average
126,992
6.1
46.6
47.3
93.9
Grade 8
Odyssey School
1,500
6.9
48.9
44.1
93.1
Cherokee Charter
96
2.1
33.3
64.6
97.9
Heritage Prep Academy
51
7.8
68.6
23.5
92.2
Georgia Connections
307
6.2
45.6
48.2
93.8
Ivy Prep Young Men's
39
10.3
51.3
38.5
89.7
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
36
2.8
38.9
58.3
97.2
CCAT School
25
0.0
72.0
28.0
100.0
Ivy Prep Academy
113
2.7
47.8
49.6
97.3
Pataula Charter
43
4.7
48.8
46.5
95.3
Fulton Leadership
52
3.8
55.8
40.4
96.2
Atlanta Heights
45
15.6
57.8
26.7
84.4
Statewide Average
126,011
5.5
50.3
44.3
94.5
System Name
Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood
N Tested
CRCT MATH
% Did not meet the standard
% Meets the standard
% Exceeds the standard
% Met or Exceeded the standard
798
36.8
33.0
30.2
63.2
38
44.7
34.2
21.1
55.3
110
9.1
33.6
57.3
90.9
133
38.3
34.6
27.1
61.7
41
22.0
51.2
26.8
78.0
45
20.0
37.8
42.2
80.0
41
7.3
48.8
43.9
92.7
76
44.7
36.8
18.4
55.3
93
5.4
21.5
73.1
94.6
127,519
19.3
36.7
44.0
80.7
799
33.7
37.9
28.4
66.3
31
22.6
54.8
22.6
77.4
114
20.2
37.7
42.1
79.8
134
33.6
42.5
23.9
66.4
24
45.8
45.8
8.3
54.2
24
29.2
62.5
8.3
70.8
44
9.1
68.2
22.7
90.9
79
34.2
54.4
11.4
65.8
91
4.4
38.5
57.1
95.6
124,706
18.3
42.6
39.0
81.7
870
32.4
44.0
23.6
67.6
22
18.2
36.4
45.5
81.8
114
7.9
45.6
46.5
92.1
166
34.9
46.4
18.7
65.1
17
52.9
35.3
11.8
47.1
24
29.2
33.3
37.5
70.8
44
4.5
40.9
54.5
95.5
66
42.4
51.5
6.1
57.6
71
5.6
50.7
43.7
94.4
123,006
12.3
43.8
43.8
87.7
1,071
24.0
55.6
20.4
76.0
107
8.4
64.5
27.1
91.6
59
16.9
78.0
5.1
83.1
228
20.2
61.4
18.4
79.8
24
25.0
70.8
4.2
75.0
25
16.0
80.0
4.0
84.0
CCAT School
22
27.3
54.5
18.2
72.7
Ivy Prep Academy
94
5.3
55.3
39.4
94.7
Pataula Charter
46
10.9
73.9
15.2
89.1
Fulton Leadership
55
16.4
72.7
10.9
83.6
Atlanta Heights
60
30.0
65.0
5.0
70.0
Coweta Charter
39
25.6
48.7
25.6
74.4
Statewide Average
124,070
15.9
55.8
28.3
84.1
Grade 7
Odyssey School
1,355
15.9
57.3
26.8
84.1
Cherokee Charter
111
9.0
45.9
45.0
91.0
Heritage Prep Academy
58
15.5
70.7
13.8
84.5
Georgia Connections
284
13.0
57.7
29.2
87.0
Ivy Prep Young Men's
49
18.4
55.1
26.5
81.6
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
42
4.8
83.3
11.9
95.2
CCAT School
19
10.5
73.7
15.8
89.5
Ivy Prep Academy
86
10.5
43.0
46.5
89.5
Pataula Charter
38
10.5
52.6
36.8
89.5
Fulton Leadership
56
0.0
51.8
48.2
100.0
Atlanta Heights
58
34.5
48.3
17.2
65.5
Statewide Average
126,420
12.4
50.2
37.4
87.6
Grade 8
Odyssey School
1,485
35.1
48.6
16.3
64.9
Cherokee Charter
94
14.9
56.4
28.7
85.1
Heritage Prep Academy
51
51.0
33.3
15.7
49.0
Georgia Connections
307
37.5
48.5
14.0
62.5
Ivy Prep Young Men's
39
23.1
56.4
20.5
76.9
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
35
25.7
45.7
28.6
74.3
CCAT School
25
24.0
68.0
8.0
76.0
Ivy Prep Academy
111
9.0
50.5
40.5
91.0
Pataula Charter
43
20.9
65.1
14.0
79.1
Fulton Leadership
50
10.0
68.0
22.0
90.0
Atlanta Heights
45
48.9
40.0
11.1
51.1
Statewide Average
125,259
18.5
47.5
34.1
81.5
System Name
Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood
CRCT SCIENCE
N Tested
% Did not meet the standard
% Meets the standard
% Exceeds the standard
% Met or Exceeded the standard
803
31.6
36.1
32.3
68.4
38
52.6
31.6
15.8
47.4
114
5.3
29.8
64.9
94.7
132
27.3
37.1
35.6
72.7
43
32.6
48.8
18.6
67.4
45
6.7
55.6
37.8
93.3
42
16.7
42.9
40.5
83.3
76
38.2
40.8
21.1
61.8
93
5.4
26.9
67.7
94.6
129,662
22.9
41.1
35.9
77.1
823
26.4
39.5
34.1
73.6
31
29.0
45.2
25.8
71.0
116
10.3
39.7
50.0
89.7
132
21.2
40.2
38.6
78.8
24
41.7
41.7
16.7
58.3
24
41.7
54.2
4.2
58.3
45
8.9
60.0
31.1
91.1
80
37.5
38.8
23.8
62.5
91
4.4
26.4
69.2
95.6
127,657
19.1
38.0
42.9
80.9
886
25.4
40.2
34.4
74.6
22
18.2
50.0
31.8
81.8
116
11.2
29.3
59.5
88.8
168
21.4
42.9
35.7
78.6
17
52.9
35.3
11.8
47.1
24
33.3
50.0
16.7
66.7
45
11.1
35.6
53.3
88.9
66
37.9
51.5
10.6
62.1
71
11.3
45.1
43.7
88.7
127,252
18.1
39.8
42.1
81.9
1,111
27.6
54.0
18.4
72.4
112
13.4
52.7
33.9
86.6
60
38.3
60.0
1.7
61.7
232
22.0
64.2
13.8
78.0
25
32.0
64.0
4.0
68.0
25
32.0
64.0
4.0
68.0
CCAT School
24
33.3
54.2
12.5
66.7
Ivy Prep Academy
95
11.6
68.4
20.0
88.4
Pataula Charter
46
37.0
52.2
10.9
63.0
Fulton Leadership
58
27.6
62.1
10.3
72.4
Atlanta Heights
60
46.7
51.7
1.7
53.3
Coweta Charter
39
23.1
38.5
38.5
76.9
Statewide Average
127,590
24.9
52.4
22.7
75.1
Grade 7
Odyssey School
1,408
20.2
46.2
33.5
79.8
Cherokee Charter
114
7.0
31.6
61.4
93.0
Heritage Prep Academy
59
23.7
62.7
13.6
76.3
Georgia Connections
289
17.0
40.5
42.6
83.0
Ivy Prep Young Men's
50
36.0
52.0
12.0
64.0
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
43
14.0
65.1
20.9
86.0
CCAT School
20
25.0
60.0
15.0
75.0
Ivy Prep Academy
89
10.1
41.6
48.3
89.9
Pataula Charter
39
17.9
43.6
38.5
82.1
Fulton Leadership
58
5.2
48.3
46.6
94.8
Atlanta Heights
59
30.5
49.2
20.3
69.5
Statewide Average
129,848
15.8
38.0
46.2
84.2
Grade 8
Odyssey School
1,533
29.2
55.5
15.3
70.8
Cherokee Charter
96
14.6
58.3
27.1
85.4
Heritage Prep Academy
54
42.6
55.6
1.9
57.4
Georgia Connections
315
30.5
54.6
14.9
69.5
Ivy Prep Young Men's
43
37.2
60.5
2.3
62.8
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
37
24.3
73.0
2.7
75.7
CCAT School
26
30.8
61.5
7.7
69.2
Ivy Prep Academy
114
11.4
70.2
18.4
88.6
Pataula Charter
42
14.3
64.3
21.4
85.7
Fulton Leadership
53
20.8
67.9
11.3
79.2
Atlanta Heights
45
42.2
48.9
8.9
57.8
Statewide Average
128,936
22.1
52.9
25.0
77.9
System Name
Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood
CRCT SOCIAL STUDIES
N Tested
% Did not meet the standard
% Meets the standard
% Exceeds the standard
% Met or Exceeded the standard
801
32.2
49.6
18.2
67.8
38
39.5
39.5
21.1
60.5
114
4.4
43.9
51.8
95.6
132
30.3
50.0
19.7
69.7
43
14.0
53.5
32.6
86.0
45
4.4
40.0
55.6
95.6
42
14.3
54.8
31.0
85.7
76
19.7
44.7
35.5
80.3
93
5.4
37.6
57.0
94.6
129,137
16.3
47.7
35.9
83.7
821
30.9
54.0
15.1
69.1
31
25.8
64.5
9.7
74.2
116
10.3
62.1
27.6
89.7
132
24.2
54.5
21.2
75.8
24
33.3
58.3
8.3
66.7
24
37.5
62.5
0.0
62.5
45
8.9
71.1
20.0
91.1
80
30.0
63.8
6.3
70.0
91
5.5
42.9
51.6
94.5
127,178
18.8
51.1
30.0
81.2
881
28.9
52.3
18.7
71.1
22
18.2
50.0
31.8
81.8
116
10.3
52.6
37.1
89.7
167
30.5
56.3
13.2
69.5
17
70.6
17.6
11.8
29.4
24
29.2
70.8
0.0
70.8
45
17.8
42.2
40.0
82.2
66
45.5
53.0
1.5
54.5
71
14.1
64.8
21.1
85.9
126,802
19.3
53.8
26.9
80.7
1,106
35.7
39.4
24.9
64.3
112
10.7
28.6
60.7
89.3
60
56.7
40.0
3.3
43.3
231
35.1
44.6
20.3
64.9
25
52.0
40.0
8.0
48.0
25
24.0
60.0
16.0
76.0
CCAT School
24
41.7
33.3
25.0
58.3
Ivy Prep Academy
95
9.5
18.9
71.6
90.5
Pataula Charter
46
17.4
54.3
28.3
82.6
Fulton Leadership
58
13.8
37.9
48.3
86.2
Atlanta Heights
61
55.7
36.1
8.2
44.3
Coweta Charter
39
23.1
46.2
30.8
76.9
Statewide Average
127,200
20.2
35.1
44.8
79.8
Grade 7
Odyssey School
1,400
30.8
39.4
29.9
69.2
Cherokee Charter
114
6.1
16.7
77.2
93.9
Heritage Prep Academy
59
39.0
57.6
3.4
61.0
Georgia Connections
287
28.9
48.1
23.0
71.1
Ivy Prep Young Men's
50
46.0
44.0
10.0
54.0
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
43
11.6
51.2
37.2
88.4
CCAT School
20
25.0
60.0
15.0
75.0
Ivy Prep Academy
89
6.7
33.7
59.6
93.3
Pataula Charter
39
15.4
25.6
59.0
84.6
Fulton Leadership
58
3.4
29.3
67.2
96.6
Atlanta Heights
59
45.8
37.3
16.9
54.2
Statewide Average
129,400
16.5
30.5
53.0
83.5
Grade 8
Odyssey School
1,525
30.9
50.7
18.4
69.1
Cherokee Charter
96
9.4
40.6
50.0
90.6
Heritage Prep Academy
54
33.3
59.3
7.4
66.7
Georgia Connections
315
25.4
52.1
22.5
74.6
Ivy Prep Young Men's
43
39.5
55.8
4.7
60.5
Ivy Prep Kirkwood
37
18.9
62.2
18.9
81.1
CCAT School
26
23.1
65.4
11.5
76.9
Ivy Prep Academy
114
14.9
57.9
27.2
85.1
Pataula Charter
42
9.5
54.8
35.7
90.5
Fulton Leadership
53
17.0
54.7
28.3
83.0
Atlanta Heights
45
40.0
53.3
6.7
60.0
Statewide Average
128,365
19.4
44.4
36.2
80.6
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Table 2: Percentage of Students Meeting/Exceeding Proficiency Targets on EOCT by Subject
System Name
9TH Grade Literature Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections CCAT School Ivy Prep Academy Pataula Charter Fulton Leadership Statewide Average American Literature Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Georgia Connections CCAT School Ivy Prep Academy Statewide Average Analytic Geometry Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections CCAT School Ivy Prep Academy Pataula Charter Statewide Average Math II Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Statewide Average Biology Mountain Education Odyssey School
END OF COURSE TEST
N Tested
Mean Scale % Did Not
Score
Meet the
standard
% Met the standard
% Exceeded the standard
37
434.86
8.1
64.9
27.0
1,198
443.14
9.2
45.7
45.2
96
420.64
22.9
53.1
24.0
26
451.58
3.8
46.2
50.0
313
444.85
8.6
44.1
47.3
21
443.71
4.8
57.1
38.1
15
446.53
13.3
33.3
53.3
36
457.78
5.6
36.1
58.3
60
443.77
5.0
48.3
46.7
112,505
439.72
12.3
45.1
42.6
83 728 128 248
9 10 93,689
434.49 442.66 428.39 448.85
-438.90 441.55
8.4 7.0 14.8 4.0 -0.0 7.5
63.9 49.0 60.9 48.4 -70.0 50.7
27.7 44.0 24.2 47.6 -30.0 41.9
11 999
36 9
252 17 15 20
97,659
390.82 372.99 369.67
-382.20 373.12 377.93 418.20 390.04
63.6 84.9 83.3 -77.0 82.4 80.0 15.0 65.4
27.3 13.7 16.7 -21.4 17.6 20.0 70.0 28.9
9.1 1.4 0.0 -1.6 0.0 0.0 15.0 5.7
41 5
37 4,946
395.88 --
383.78 388.02
63.4 --
91.9 77.4
36.6 --
8.1 22.2
0.0 --
0.0 0.3
62
418.42
27.4
51.6
21.0
1,218
406.83
44.8
42.2
13.0
11
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Provost Academy
131
390.03
70.2
26.7
3.1
Cherokee Charter
25
437.12
16.0
52.0
32.0
Georgia Connections
314
426.20
24.5
46.8
28.7
CCAT School
14
421.21
14.3
78.6
7.1
Ivy Prep Academy
14
416.79
35.7
42.9
21.4
Statewide Average
109,030
430.47
25.0
41.1
33.9
US History
Mountain Education
104
420.19
27.9
44.2
27.9
Odyssey School
697
401.57
52.2
31.6
16.2
Provost Academy
146
381.03
68.5
26.0
5.5
Georgia Connections
238
399.96
53.8
33.2
13.0
CCAT School
26
393.69
53.8
34.6
11.5
Ivy Prep Academy
10
387.10
60.0
40.0
0.0
Statewide Average
93,645
434.88
27.2
32.6
40.2
Economics
Mountain Education
159
430.50
19.5
50.9
29.6
Odyssey School
56
410.91
42.9
37.5
19.6
Provost Academy
146
395.78
52.1
40.4
7.5
Georgia Connections
143
416.84
28.0
51.7
20.3
CCAT School
14
403.00
50.0
35.7
14.3
Statewide Average
59,564
439.61
18.8
39.1
42.1
II. Value Added Models
A value-added model of the following form was used to estimate school effects:
(1)
where Aist represents the achievement level of student i in school s at time t,
is a vector of
prior test scores, is a vector of student characteristics, is a school fixed effect, and is a
random error term. One can view the school fixed effect as the difference between a student's
actual test score ( ) and the score a student would be expected to earn based on their
individual characteristics and past history of test scores
, averaged over all
students at a school. By construction, the average school has a fixed effect of zero and the
performance of all other schools is measured relative to this average. Thus a positive estimated
value for a school's fixed effect indicates they increase student achievement more than the
average school while a negative value indicates they are less effective than the average school.
Three versions of the value-added model were estimated. The first employed all available student characteristics in the vector X. Estimates from this model are presented in the main report. The second removed indicators for student racial/ethnic categories. The third eliminated the X vector entirely and only included the vector of prior test scores. Each of the three value-added models was applied to 16 different samples representing five CRCT subjects
12
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
at the elementary level, five CRCT subjects at the middle school level and six subject-specific end-of-course exams at the high school level. Estimates for the 48 model/sample combinations are provided below.
There are two things worth noting in the value-added model estimates. First, virtually all of the coefficients on the demographic characteristics have the expected sign. Second, most all of the coefficients on the demographic variables are statistically significant, indicating they have a non-zero impact on current test scores, even after controlling for prior test scores.
13
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Value-Added Model Estimates
Elementary Reading Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.0275**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.1754** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2971** (0.0027)
Lagged Science Score 0.1789** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1468** (0.0028)
Grade 5
0.0017 (0.0051)
Female
0.0606** (0.0026)
Foreign Born
0.0649** (0.0085)
Black
-0.0431** (0.0041)
Hispanic
-0.0073 (0.0056)
Asian
0.0194 (0.0402)
American Indian
-0.0161 (0.0275)
Multi-Racial
0.0099 (0.0074)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0634** (0.0074)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0403** (0.0037)
14
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gifted
0.1325** (0.0044)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0074 (0.0069)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0867 (0.0592)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0341** (0.0083)
Deaf
-0.2310**
(0.0469)
Visual Impairment
0.0445 (0.0578)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.0853** (0.0165)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1240** (0.0069)
Deaf and Blind
-0.1647** (0.0060)
Autism
-0.1534** (0.0166)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0065 (0.0780)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.2375** (0.0917)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1062** (0.0098)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.2128** (0.0250)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3536 (0.1882)
15
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.7415** (0.0061)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0345** (0.0064)
Changed Schools
0.0116 (0.0062)
age_within_grade
-0.0014** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0038* (0.0016)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0038** (0.0005)
Constant
0.3892**
(0.0488)
Observations
226255
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
16
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.0286**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.1746** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2980** (0.0027)
Lagged Science Score 0.1824** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1458** (0.0028)
Grade 5
0.0016 (0.0051)
Female
0.0605** (0.0026)
Foreign Born
0.0645** (0.0085)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0593** (0.0074)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0472** (0.0036)
Gifted
0.1335** (0.0044)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0033 (0.0061)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0847 (0.0591)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0323** (0.0083)
Deaf
-0.2301**
(0.0471)
17
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Visual Impairment
0.0455 (0.0577)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.0828** (0.0165)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1226** (0.0069)
Deaf and Blind
-0.1458** (0.0058)
Autism
-0.1495** (0.0166)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0057 (0.0779)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.2355* (0.0918)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1025** (0.0099)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.2143** (0.0250)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3610 (0.1902)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.7658** (0.0056)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0347** (0.0064)
Changed Schools
0.0100 (0.0063)
age_within_grade
-0.0013** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0051**
18
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0016)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0045** (0.0005)
Constant
0.4420**
(0.0483)
Observations
226255
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
19
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.0406**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.2006** (0.0026)
Lagged Reading Score 0.3141** (0.0026)
Lagged Science Score 0.1815** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1467** (0.0028)
Constant
-0.0146**
(0.0002)
Observations
226255
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
20
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary ELA Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.0999**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.2644** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2214** (0.0024)
Lagged Science Score 0.1486** (0.0028)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1046** (0.0028)
Grade 5
0.0076 (0.0053)
Female
0.1296** (0.0025)
Foreign Born
0.0396** (0.0083)
Black
0.0115** (0.0039)
Hispanic
0.0078 (0.0051)
Asian
0.0901* (0.0385)
American Indian
0.0581* (0.0294)
Multi-Racial
0.0091 (0.0071)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0899** (0.0073)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0512** (0.0034)
21
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gifted
0.1755** (0.0047)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0590** (0.0071)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0503 (0.0614)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0246** (0.0079)
Deaf
-0.0923*
(0.0375)
Visual Impairment
0.0327 (0.0512)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1195** (0.0165)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1452** (0.0063)
Deaf and Blind
-0.2758** (0.0059)
Autism
-0.0902** (0.0155)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0430 (0.0843)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0761 (0.0756)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1205** (0.0096)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.1766** (0.0251)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3332** (0.1156)
Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.3995**
22
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0057)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0423** (0.0061)
Changed Schools
0.0053 (0.0061)
age_within_grade
-0.0026** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0069** (0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0001 (0.0004)
Constant
-0.0294
(0.0425)
Observations
226051
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
23
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.0996**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.2647** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2211** (0.0024)
Lagged Science Score 0.1477** (0.0028)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1048** (0.0028)
Grade 5
0.0076 (0.0053)
Female
0.1297** (0.0025)
Foreign Born
0.0391** (0.0083)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0900** (0.0073)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0489** (0.0034)
Gifted
0.1750** (0.0047)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0589** (0.0065)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0498 (0.0613)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0251** (0.0079)
Deaf
-0.0923*
(0.0375)
24
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Visual Impairment
0.0320 (0.0512)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1200** (0.0165)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1456** (0.0063)
Deaf and Blind
-0.2818** (0.0056)
Autism
-0.0914** (0.0155)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0439 (0.0844)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0750 (0.0754)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1217** (0.0096)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.1762** (0.0251)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3316** (0.1154)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.3928** (0.0053)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0422** (0.0061)
Changed Schools
0.0056 (0.0061)
age_within_grade
-0.0026** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0065**
25
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0001 (0.0004)
Constant
-0.0419
(0.0422)
Observations
226051
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
26
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.1155**
(0.0023)
Lagged ELA Score
0.3094** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2413** (0.0025)
Lagged Science Score 0.1401** (0.0028)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1025** (0.0028)
Constant
-0.0107**
(0.0001)
Observations
226051
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
27
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Math Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.4792**
(0.0030)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0991** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.0351** (0.0025)
Lagged Science Score 0.0912** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0466** (0.0031)
Grade 5
0.0017 (0.0081)
Female
-0.0226** (0.0027)
Foreign Born
0.0682** (0.0086)
Black
-0.0504** (0.0040)
Hispanic
-0.0463** (0.0058)
Asian
0.0162 (0.0388)
American Indian
0.0025 (0.0277)
Multi-Racial
-0.0345** (0.0070)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0635** (0.0084)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0502** (0.0034)
28
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gifted
0.2649** (0.0056)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.1151** (0.0078)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1552* (0.0714)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0098 (0.0088)
Deaf
-0.0437
(0.0362)
Visual Impairment
-0.0215 (0.0654)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.2254** (0.0169)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1378** (0.0070)
Deaf and Blind
0.0152* (0.0070)
Autism
-0.0891** (0.0178)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2131** (0.0818)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0469 (0.0899)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1669** (0.0104)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.2386** (0.0290)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3586** (0.1000)
Sev. Intellectual Dis. 1.8018**
29
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0073)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0473** (0.0062)
Changed Schools
0.0016 (0.0062)
age_within_grade
-0.0031** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0019 (0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0086** (0.0004)
Constant
-0.7746**
(0.0412)
Observations
225334
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
30
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Math Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.4807**
(0.0030)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0981** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.0361** (0.0025)
Lagged Science Score 0.0948** (0.0030)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0455** (0.0031)
Grade 5
0.0014 (0.0081)
Female
-0.0229** (0.0027)
Foreign Born
0.0728** (0.0087)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0643** (0.0083)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0608** (0.0034)
Gifted
0.2669** (0.0056)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.1090** (0.0070)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1529* (0.0710)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0122 (0.0088)
Deaf
-0.0448
(0.0361)
31
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Visual Impairment
-0.0193 (0.0654)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.2220** (0.0169)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1356** (0.0070)
Deaf and Blind
0.0426** (0.0067)
Autism
-0.0841** (0.0178)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2090** (0.0791)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0451 (0.0898)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1618** (0.0104)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.2406** (0.0290)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3674** (0.0985)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
1.8310** (0.0069)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0475** (0.0062)
Changed Schools
-0.0000 (0.0062)
age_within_grade
-0.0031** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0033*
32
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0078** (0.0004)
Constant
-0.7182**
(0.0408)
Observations
225334
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
33
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Math Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.5197**
(0.0030)
Lagged ELA Score
0.1167** (0.0027)
Lagged Reading Score 0.0456** (0.0025)
Lagged Science Score 0.1045** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0610** (0.0032)
Constant
-0.0051**
(0.0002)
Observations
225334
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
34
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Science Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.1185**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0849** (0.0026)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1549** (0.0023)
Lagged Science Score 0.3107** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1444** (0.0030)
Grade 5
0.0105 (0.0080)
Female
-0.0814** (0.0026)
Foreign Born
0.0604** (0.0074)
Black
-0.1246** (0.0038)
Hispanic
-0.0453** (0.0054)
Asian
0.0768* (0.0356)
American Indian
-0.0317 (0.0248)
Multi-Racial
-0.0298** (0.0067)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0442** (0.0079)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0395** (0.0031)
35
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gifted
0.1247** (0.0046)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0181** (0.0067)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0791 (0.0456)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0004 (0.0077)
Deaf
-0.0868*
(0.0373)
Visual Impairment
-0.0365 (0.0496)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1109** (0.0156)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.0927** (0.0062)
Deaf and Blind
-0.3316 (0.2321)
Autism
-0.0616** (0.0141)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2317** (0.0698)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0724 (0.0672)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1068** (0.0091)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.2636** (0.0161)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.0447 (0.0839)
Sev. Intellectual Dis. 1.1760**
36
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0070)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0488** (0.0062)
Changed Schools
0.0014 (0.0075)
age_within_grade
-0.0033** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0140** (0.0016)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0013** (0.0004)
Constant
0.0366
(0.0422)
Observations
233073
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
37
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Science Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.1218**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0825** (0.0026)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1574** (0.0023)
Lagged Science Score 0.3205** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1413** (0.0030)
Grade 5
0.0100 (0.0080)
Female
-0.0819** (0.0026)
Foreign Born
0.0624** (0.0074)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0359** (0.0078)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0615** (0.0031)
Gifted
0.1281** (0.0046)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0384** (0.0062)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0684 (0.0454)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0047 (0.0078)
Deaf
-0.0840*
(0.0374)
38
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Visual Impairment
-0.0346 (0.0495)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1046** (0.0155)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.0883** (0.0062)
Deaf and Blind
-0.3191 (0.2644)
Autism
-0.0506** (0.0142)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2186** (0.0687)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0663 (0.0674)
Other Health Imp.
-0.0961** (0.0092)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.2644** (0.0161)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.0459 (0.0827)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
1.2464** (0.0069)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0495** (0.0062)
Changed Schools
-0.0032 (0.0076)
age_within_grade
-0.0031** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0178**
39
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0017)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0006 (0.0004)
Constant
0.1819**
(0.0426)
Observations
233073
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
40
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Science Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.1455**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0799** (0.0025)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1621** (0.0023)
Lagged Science Score 0.3349** (0.0031)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1567** (0.0031)
Constant
0.0155**
(0.0001)
Observations
233073
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
41
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.0599**
(0.0025)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0805** (0.0026)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1648** (0.0025)
Lagged Science Score 0.1713** (0.0030)
Lagged Social Studies Score
0.3243** (0.0035)
Grade 5
0.0099 (0.0095)
Female
-0.1264** (0.0026)
Foreign Born
0.0617** (0.0083)
Black
-0.0310** (0.0043)
Hispanic
-0.0289** (0.0056)
Asian
0.0652 (0.0366)
American Indian
0.0043 (0.0239)
Multi-Racial
-0.0092 (0.0067)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0659** (0.0079)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0718** (0.0033)
42
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gifted
0.1427** (0.0050)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0766** (0.0069)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0779 (0.0565)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0264** (0.0079)
Deaf
-0.1175**
(0.0336)
Visual Impairment
-0.0094 (0.0498)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1225** (0.0150)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1072** (0.0062)
Deaf and Blind
-0.1155** (0.0209)
Autism
-0.1042** (0.0129)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1470* (0.0592)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0923 (0.0663)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1212** (0.0083)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.1399** (0.0150)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.0231 (0.1042)
43
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
-0.2222** (0.0077)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0472** (0.0062)
Changed Schools
-0.0033 (0.0070)
age_within_grade
-0.0025** (0.0002)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0136** (0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0025** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.0862*
(0.0431)
Observations
232244
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
44
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.0608**
(0.0025)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0799** (0.0026)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1654** (0.0025)
Lagged Science Score 0.1736** (0.0030)
Lagged Social Studies Score
0.3236** (0.0035)
Grade 5
0.0097 (0.0095)
Female
-0.1265** (0.0026)
Foreign Born
0.0645** (0.0083)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0666** (0.0079)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0782** (0.0033)
Gifted
0.1439** (0.0050)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0720** (0.0062)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0744 (0.0561)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0279** (0.0079)
Deaf
-0.1179**
(0.0336)
45
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Visual Impairment
-0.0087 (0.0497)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1207** (0.0150)
Specific Learning Dis. -0.1060** (0.0062)
Deaf and Blind
-0.1113** (0.0125)
Autism
-0.1012** (0.0129)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1443* (0.0588)
Significant Dev. Delay -0.0907 (0.0663)
Other Health Imp.
-0.1181** (0.0084)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.1397** (0.0150)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.0230 (0.1052)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
-0.2043** (0.0074)
o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . .
Num. Schools Attended -0.0473** (0.0062)
Changed Schools
-0.0043 (0.0070)
age_within_grade
-0.0024** (0.0002)
46
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0145** (0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0020** (0.0004)
Constant
-0.0511
(0.0424)
Observations
232244
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
47
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Elementary Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.0910**
(0.0025)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0695** (0.0025)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1676** (0.0026)
Lagged Science Score 0.1927** (0.0031)
Lagged Social Studies Score
0.3451** (0.0035)
Constant
0.0132**
(0.0001)
Observations
232244
Standard errors in parentheses
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level
48
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Reading Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.0466**
(0.0021)
Lagged ELA Score
0.1740** (0.0024)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2880** (0.0028)
Lagged Science Score
0.1786** (0.0025)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1244** (0.0025)
tgrde_7
-0.0038 (0.0090)
tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black
-0.0134 (0.0083)
0.1046** (0.0023)
0.0342** (0.0068)
-0.0506** (0.0038)
Hispanic
-0.0017 (0.0046)
Asian
-0.0070 (0.0340)
American Indian
0.0185 (0.0220)
Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled
-0.0092 (0.0063)
-0.1395** (0.0074)
49
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0378** (0.0030)
Gifted
0.1090** (0.0040)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0203** (0.0047)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0897 (0.0480)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0768** (0.0111)
Deaf
-0.2556** (0.0312)
Visual Impairment
-0.1320** (0.0505)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1149** (0.0122)
Specific Learning Dis.
-0.1620** (0.0055)
Deaf and Blind
-1.0827** (0.0051)
Autism
-0.1586** (0.0144)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2499** (0.0768)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1440** (0.0081)
-0.3398** (0.0206)
-0.3223*
50
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.1428)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0345** (0.0051)
Changed Schools
-0.0015 (0.0083)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0051** (0.0007)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0041** (0.0003)
Age-in-grade
-0.0026** (0.0002)
Constant
0.4241**
(0.0318)
Observations
344548
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
51
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.0478**
(0.0021)
Lagged ELA Score
0.1730** (0.0024)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2885** (0.0028)
Lagged Science Score
0.1824** (0.0025)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1238** (0.0026)
tgrde_7
-0.0054 (0.0090)
tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
-0.0153 (0.0084)
0.1044** (0.0023)
0.0338** (0.0067)
-0.1355** (0.0073)
-0.0462** (0.0030)
0.1109** (0.0040)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0008 (0.0044)
Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp.
-0.0862 (0.0480)
-0.0762** (0.0110)
52
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.2532** (0.0311)
-0.1323** (0.0505)
-0.1110** (0.0122)
-0.1608** (0.0055)
-1.0679** (0.0050)
-0.1533** (0.0144)
-0.2488** (0.0761)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1398** (0.0081)
-0.3432** (0.0205)
-0.3323* (0.1427)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0353** (0.0051)
Changed Schools
-0.0034 (0.0084)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0066**
53
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0049** (0.0003)
Age-in-grade
-0.0025** (0.0002)
Constant
0.4943**
(0.0326)
Observations
344548
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
54
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.0639**
(0.0021)
Lagged ELA Score
0.2062** (0.0022)
Lagged Reading Score 0.3119** (0.0026)
Lagged Science Score
0.1763** (0.0025)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1184** (0.0025)
Constant
0.0036**
(0.0001)
Observations
344548
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
55
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle ELA Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.1150**
(0.0022)
Lagged ELA Score
0.2964** (0.0024)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2130** (0.0022)
Lagged Science Score
0.1068** (0.0024)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0964** (0.0025)
tgrde_7
0.0018 (0.0091)
tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black
-0.0087 (0.0089)
0.1743** (0.0024)
0.0261** (0.0062)
0.0066* (0.0031)
Hispanic
0.0036 (0.0042)
Asian
0.0226 (0.0286)
American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled
0.0180 (0.0218)
0.0135* (0.0060)
-0.0864** (0.0067)
56
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0440** (0.0029)
Gifted
0.1550** (0.0040)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0357** (0.0046)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0065 (0.0446)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0651** (0.0100)
Deaf
-0.1409** (0.0333)
Visual Impairment
-0.1143* (0.0476)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1332** (0.0119)
Specific Learning Dis.
-0.1683** (0.0050)
Deaf and Blind
-0.7286** (0.0055)
Autism
-0.0700** (0.0135)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1588* (0.0639)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1616** (0.0079)
-0.3068** (0.0219)
Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.2140
57
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.1790)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0451** (0.0050)
Changed Schools
0.0014 (0.0080)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0036** (0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present Age-in-grade
0.0001 (0.0003)
-0.0021** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.0384
(0.0292)
Observations
343761
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
58
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.1148**
(0.0022)
Lagged ELA Score
0.2966** (0.0024)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2130** (0.0022)
Lagged Science Score
0.1064** (0.0023)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0965** (0.0025)
tgrde_7
0.0020 (0.0091)
tgrde_8
-0.0085 (0.0089)
Female
0.1744** (0.0024)
Foreign Born
0.0260** (0.0063)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0867** (0.0067)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0425** (0.0029)
Gifted
0.1547** (0.0040)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0349** (0.0042)
Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp.
0.0059 (0.0446)
-0.0651** (0.0100)
59
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.1412** (0.0333)
-0.1144* (0.0477)
-0.1336** (0.0119)
-0.1684** (0.0050)
-0.7313** (0.0054)
-0.0707** (0.0135)
-0.1595* (0.0640)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1621** (0.0078)
-0.3065** (0.0219)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.2135 (0.1792)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0450** (0.0050)
Changed Schools
0.0016 (0.0079)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0034**
60
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present Age-in-grade
0.0002 (0.0003)
-0.0021** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.0464
(0.0291)
Observations
343761
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
61
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.1382**
(0.0022)
Lagged ELA Score
0.3436** (0.0023)
Lagged Reading Score 0.2408** (0.0021)
Lagged Science Score
0.0918** (0.0024)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0853** (0.0025)
Constant
0.0099**
(0.0001)
Observations
343761
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
62
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Math Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.4652**
(0.0029)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0941** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.0287** (0.0019)
Lagged Science Score
0.1185** (0.0024)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0694** (0.0029)
tgrde_7
0.0050 (0.0118)
tgrde_8
-0.0026 (0.0138)
Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic
0.0032 (0.0021)
0.0771** (0.0065)
-0.0760** (0.0038)
-0.0662** (0.0066)
Asian
-0.0184 (0.0303)
American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled
-0.0054 (0.0229)
-0.0258** (0.0059)
-0.0355** (0.0074)
63
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0429** (0.0029)
Gifted
0.3043** (0.0063)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0774** (0.0062)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1454** (0.0492)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0074 (0.0093)
Deaf
0.0063
(0.0315)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
0.0135 (0.0476)
-0.0922** (0.0109)
-0.0830** (0.0056)
Deaf and Blind Autism
0.0076 (0.0069)
-0.0547** (0.0145)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0780 (0.0739)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1244** (0.0077)
-0.0739** (0.0213)
Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1679
64
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.1071)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0543** (0.0048)
Changed Schools
-0.0005 (0.0104)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0006 (0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0057** (0.0003)
Age-in-grade
-0.0026** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.4858**
(0.0308)
Observations
341234
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
65
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Math Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.4674**
(0.0029)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0927** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.0292** (0.0019)
Lagged Science Score
0.1239** (0.0024)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0686** (0.0029)
tgrde_7
0.0028 (0.0119)
tgrde_8
-0.0052 (0.0139)
Female
0.0030 (0.0021)
Foreign Born
0.0809** (0.0065)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0330** (0.0077)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0594** (0.0032)
Gifted
0.3085** (0.0064)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0679** (0.0054)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1385** (0.0491)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0057 (0.0093)
66
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Deaf
0.0101
(0.0318)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism
0.0136 (0.0473)
-0.0852** (0.0109)
-0.0804** (0.0057)
0.0379** (0.0069)
-0.0453** (0.0145)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0692 (0.0726)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1167** (0.0077)
-0.0766** (0.0213)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1804 (0.1103)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0551** (0.0048)
Changed Schools
-0.0029 (0.0105)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0025**
67
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0044** (0.0003)
Age-in-grade
-0.0025** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.3847**
(0.0302)
Observations
341234
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
68
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Math Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.5131**
(0.0031)
Lagged ELA Score
0.1110** (0.0023)
Lagged Reading Score 0.0411** (0.0019)
Lagged Science Score
0.1341** (0.0026)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0845** (0.0030)
Constant
0.0073**
(0.0002)
Observations
341234
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
69
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Science Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.1503**
(0.0023)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0715** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1117** (0.0019)
Lagged Science Score
0.3318** (0.0028)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1670** (0.0031)
tgrde_7
0.0004 (0.0133)
tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic
-0.0007 (0.0131)
-0.0900** (0.0021)
0.0515** (0.0060)
-0.0800** (0.0035)
-0.0400** (0.0046)
Asian
-0.0095 (0.0291)
American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled
-0.0215 (0.0203)
-0.0205** (0.0057)
-0.0493** (0.0071)
70
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0404** (0.0028)
Gifted
0.1259** (0.0049)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0335** (0.0046)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0241 (0.0385)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0376** (0.0099)
Deaf
-0.0856** (0.0287)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind
-0.0689 (0.0394)
-0.1006** (0.0106)
-0.1153** (0.0047)
-0.0808** (0.0072)
Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.0197 (0.0122)
-0.1545** (0.0513)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1248** (0.0072)
-0.1682** (0.0129)
Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1586
71
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
(0.0864)
0.2641** (0.0087)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0502** (0.0051)
Changed Schools
-0.0058 (0.0109)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0120** (0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0021** (0.0003)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0023** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.0370
(0.0323)
Observations
354119
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
72
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Science Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.1524**
(0.0023)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0700** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1123** (0.0019)
Lagged Science Score
0.3377** (0.0028)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1661** (0.0031)
tgrde_7
-0.0019 (0.0134)
tgrde_8
-0.0035 (0.0132)
Female
-0.0901** (0.0021)
Foreign Born
0.0535** (0.0061)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0452** (0.0072)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0560** (0.0029)
Gifted
0.1297** (0.0049)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0416** (0.0043)
Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp.
-0.0170 (0.0379)
-0.0365** (0.0099)
73
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Deaf
-0.0821** (0.0286)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind
-0.0672 (0.0393)
-0.0946** (0.0106)
-0.1133** (0.0047)
-0.0526** (0.0071)
Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.0114 (0.0123)
-0.1497** (0.0511)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1173** (0.0071)
-0.1704** (0.0130)
Mod. Intellectual Dis. Sev. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1621 (0.0871)
0.2816** (0.0087)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0510** (0.0051)
Changed Schools
-0.0084 (0.0110)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0142**
74
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
(0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0008* (0.0004)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0022** (0.0002)
Constant
0.0710*
(0.0329)
Observations
354119
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
75
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Science Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.1770**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0681** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1121** (0.0019)
Lagged Science Score
0.3560** (0.0028)
Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1882** (0.0031)
Constant
0.0250**
(0.0001)
Observations
354119
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
76
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates
Lagged Math Score
0.0861**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0605** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1234** (0.0020)
Lagged Science Score
0.2084** (0.0032)
Lagged Social Studies Score
0.3362** (0.0035)
tgrde_7
0.0109 (0.0131)
tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic
0.0054 (0.0130)
-0.0853** (0.0024)
0.0374** (0.0065)
0.0096** (0.0035)
-0.0117* (0.0051)
Asian
0.0295 (0.0273)
American Indian
-0.0000 (0.0195)
Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled
0.0041 (0.0053)
-0.0631** (0.0093)
77
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0523** (0.0029)
Gifted
0.1233** (0.0057)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0532** (0.0053)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0765 (0.0447)
Speech-Language Imp. Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.0009 (0.0096)
-0.0568* (0.0259)
-0.1100** (0.0400)
-0.1260** (0.0112)
-0.1285** (0.0051)
-0.2125** (0.0087)
-0.0676** (0.0115)
-0.1857** (0.0480)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1359** (0.0071)
-0.1720** (0.0139)
78
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Mod. Intellectual Dis. Sev. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1520 (0.0816)
0.5233** (0.0102)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0709** (0.0050)
Changed Schools
0.0026 (0.0090)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0133** (0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0024** (0.0003)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0033** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.0826*
(0.0335)
Observations
352798
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
79
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Lagged Math Score
0.0859**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0607** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1233** (0.0020)
Lagged Science Score
0.2077** (0.0032)
Lagged Social Studies Score
0.3364** (0.0035)
tgrde_7
0.0112 (0.0131)
tgrde_8
0.0058 (0.0130)
Female
-0.0852** (0.0024)
Foreign Born
0.0383** (0.0066)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0645** (0.0093)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0514** (0.0030)
Gifted
0.1232** (0.0057)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0419** (0.0049)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0759 (0.0446)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0008 (0.0096)
80
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.0569* (0.0259)
-0.1096** (0.0400)
-0.1264** (0.0112)
-0.1286** (0.0051)
-0.2141** (0.0086)
-0.0682** (0.0115)
-0.1857** (0.0480)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1364** (0.0071)
-0.1713** (0.0139)
Mod. Intellectual Dis. Sev. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1521 (0.0818)
0.5215** (0.0101)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0707** (0.0050)
Changed Schools
0.0030 (0.0090)
81
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0130** (0.0008)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0026** (0.0003)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0033** (0.0002)
Constant
-0.0967**
(0.0331)
Observations
352798
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
82
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Middle Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Lagged Math Score
0.1116**
(0.0024)
Lagged ELA Score
0.0618** (0.0021)
Lagged Reading Score 0.1242** (0.0020)
Lagged Science Score
0.2246** (0.0033)
Lagged Social Studies Score
0.3590** (0.0036)
Constant
0.0259**
(0.0001)
Observations
352798
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
83
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS 9th Grade Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0525**
(0.0035)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.2580** (0.0034)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1892** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1429** (0.0033)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.1802** (0.0035)
Female
0.1061** (0.0038)
Foreign Born Black Hispanic
-0.0052 (0.0079)
-0.0503** (0.0055)
-0.0163* (0.0075)
Asian
0.0269 (0.0422)
American Indian
-0.0054 (0.0295)
Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
-0.0025 (0.0091)
-0.1483** (0.0129)
-0.0608** (0.0043)
0.1376** (0.0071)
84
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0376** (0.0078)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1437* (0.0609)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.1504** (0.0205)
Deaf
-0.2510** (0.0407)
Visual Impairment
-0.1587* (0.0727)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1638** (0.0171)
Specific Learning Dis.
-0.2022** (0.0086)
Deaf and Blind
0.3264** (0.0067)
Autism
-0.1151** (0.0227)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.4221** (0.0943)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1571** (0.0120)
-0.3839** (0.0231)
-0.6871** (0.1878)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
85
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0616** (0.0080)
Changed Schools
-0.0330** (0.0097)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0060** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0142** (0.0011)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0013** (0.0004)
Constant
0.2789**
(0.0396)
Observations
117067
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
86
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS 9th Grade Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0529**
(0.0035)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.2573** (0.0034)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1900** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1460** (0.0033)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.1809** (0.0035)
Female
0.1057** (0.0038)
Foreign Born
-0.0038 (0.0079)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.1448** (0.0129)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0697** (0.0044)
Gifted
0.1398** (0.0072)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0277** (0.0071)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1373* (0.0619)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.1511** (0.0206)
Deaf
-0.2491** (0.0409)
Visual Impairment
-0.1608* (0.0729)
87
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
-0.1590** (0.0171)
-0.2005** (0.0086)
0.3230** (0.0067)
-0.1098** (0.0228)
-0.4171** (0.0936)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1516** (0.0120)
-0.3870** (0.0231)
-0.6819** (0.1831)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0624** (0.0081)
Changed Schools
-0.0317** (0.0098)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0059** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0155** (0.0010)
88
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0020** (0.0004)
Constant
0.3284**
(0.0395)
Observations
117067
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
89
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS 9th Grade Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0758**
(0.0035)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.3092** (0.0034)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.2118** (0.0035)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1401** (0.0033)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.1869** (0.0035)
Constant
0.0389**
(0.0002)
Observations
117067
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
90
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Amer. Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0260**
(0.0036)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.2309** (0.0043)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1909** (0.0040)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1391** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2147** (0.0043)
Female
0.0930** (0.0043)
Foreign Born Black
0.0053 (0.0101)
-0.0455** (0.0057)
Hispanic
-0.0111 (0.0085)
Asian
-0.0360 (0.0586)
American Indian
-0.0296 (0.0360)
Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0207 (0.0111)
-0.1108** (0.0194)
-0.0553** (0.0044)
0.1758** (0.0078)
91
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0619** (0.0104)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1134 (0.1034)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.1870** (0.0468)
Deaf
-0.2520** (0.0628)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.1729 (0.0973)
-0.1666** (0.0213)
-0.2580** (0.0111)
Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.0000 (.)
-0.1243** (0.0309)
-0.3707** (0.0913)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.2234** (0.0141)
-0.4741** (0.0376)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1431 (0.3718)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
92
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0516** (0.0122)
Changed Schools
0.0005 (0.0090)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0091** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0186** (0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0001 (0.0005)
Constant
-0.0113
(0.0488)
Observations
98260
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
93
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Am. Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0260**
(0.0036)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.2301** (0.0043)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1921** (0.0040)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1430** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2151** (0.0043)
Female
0.0931** (0.0043)
Foreign Born
0.0070 (0.0101)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.1065** (0.0195)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0632** (0.0044)
Gifted
0.1777** (0.0077)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0518** (0.0093)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1122 (0.1033)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.1887** (0.0466)
Deaf
-0.2474** (0.0627)
Visual Impairment
-0.1722 (0.0976)
94
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.1631** (0.0214)
-0.2556** (0.0111)
Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.0000 (.)
-0.1186** (0.0310)
-0.3642** (0.0917)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.2182** (0.0141)
-0.4749** (0.0375)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1460 (0.3765)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0520** (0.0122)
Changed Schools
-0.0023 (0.0090)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0091** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0198** (0.0015)
95
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0004 (0.0005)
Constant
0.0215
(0.0487)
Observations
98260
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
96
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Amer. Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0574**
(0.0037)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.2859** (0.0044)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.2233** (0.0039)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1315** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2333** (0.0045)
Constant
-0.0574**
(0.0004)
Observations
98260
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
97
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Analytic Geometry Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.3744**
(0.0055)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0852** (0.0033)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0067* (0.0031)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1993** (0.0043)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0384** (0.0038)
Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic
-0.0037 (0.0037)
0.0581** (0.0104)
-0.0913** (0.0073)
-0.0787** (0.0103)
Asian
-0.0672 (0.0554)
American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0064 (0.0420)
-0.0446** (0.0096)
0.0789** (0.0208)
-0.0428** (0.0049)
0.3106** (0.0117)
98
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0309** (0.0106)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1964* (0.0820)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0017 (0.0334)
Deaf
0.0000
(0.0559)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.0840 (0.0720)
-0.0604** (0.0194)
-0.0753** (0.0101)
Deaf and Blind Autism
0.0000 (.)
-0.0843* (0.0345)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0928 (0.0845)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1346** (0.0147)
Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0227 (0.0334)
1.2477** (0.0108)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
99
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0902** (0.0120)
Changed Schools
0.0780** (0.0118)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0058** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0094** (0.0014)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0073** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.6733**
(0.0502)
Observations
104062
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
100
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Analytic Geometry Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.3750**
(0.0055)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0851** (0.0033)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0071* (0.0031)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.2060** (0.0044)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0390** (0.0039)
Female
-0.0037 (0.0037)
Foreign Born
0.0591** (0.0105)
ESOL Enrolled
0.0880** (0.0211)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0627** (0.0053)
Gifted
0.3164** (0.0120)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0219* (0.0089)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.1867* (0.0805)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0064 (0.0335)
Deaf
0.0014
(0.0559)
Visual Impairment
-0.0761 (0.0721)
101
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.0500** (0.0191)
-0.0710** (0.0101)
Deaf and Blind Autism
0.0000 (.)
-0.0722* (0.0343)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0997 (0.0850)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1249** (0.0147)
Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0189 (0.0335)
1.2608** (0.0110)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0914** (0.0121)
Changed Schools
0.0759** (0.0118)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0057** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0119** (0.0015)
102
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0061** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.5865**
(0.0490)
Observations
104062
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
103
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Analytic Geometry Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.4238**
(0.0062)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.1151** (0.0036)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0175** (0.0031)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.2250** (0.0049)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0570** (0.0042)
Constant
-0.0818**
(0.0010)
Observations
104062
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
104
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Coordinate Algebra Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.4197**
(0.0047)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0705** (0.0035)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0198** (0.0028)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1780** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0608** (0.0034)
Female
-0.0518** (0.0036)
Foreign Born
0.0462** (0.0090)
Black
-0.0784** (0.0051)
Hispanic
-0.0717** (0.0081)
Asian
-0.0075 (0.0468)
American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
-0.0357 (0.0306)
-0.0423** (0.0092)
0.0478** (0.0120)
-0.0451** (0.0047)
0.3375** (0.0106)
105
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0067 (0.0086)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0693 (0.0772)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0116 (0.0255)
Deaf
-0.0065
(0.0314)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind
-0.0383 (0.0572)
-0.0412** (0.0146)
-0.0500** (0.0077)
0.1360** (0.0062)
Autism
0.0227 (0.0211)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0020 (0.0766)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0690** (0.0109)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0423 (0.0216)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.1473 (0.1312)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
106
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0591** (0.0076)
Changed Schools
0.0375** (0.0097)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0027** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0044** (0.0011)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0018** (0.0004)
Constant
-0.0766
(0.0413)
Observations
113579
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
107
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Coordinate Algebra Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.4204**
(0.0047)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0694** (0.0035)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0210** (0.0028)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1831** (0.0039)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0619** (0.0034)
Female
-0.0522** (0.0036)
Foreign Born
0.0485** (0.0091)
ESOL Enrolled
0.0557** (0.0122)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0617** (0.0047)
Gifted
0.3417** (0.0108)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0206** (0.0079)
Orthopedic Impairment -0.0592 (0.0782)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0113 (0.0255)
Deaf
-0.0042
(0.0316)
Visual Impairment
-0.0418 (0.0572)
108
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind
-0.0330* (0.0146)
-0.0471** (0.0077)
0.1312** (0.0062)
Autism
0.0320 (0.0212)
Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0018 (0.0748)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0590** (0.0108)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0402 (0.0218)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.1502 (0.1343)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0603** (0.0076)
Changed Schools
0.0389** (0.0098)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0027** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0062** (0.0011)
109
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0007 (0.0004)
Constant
-0.0039
(0.0405)
Observations
113579
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
110
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Coordinate Algebra Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.4549**
(0.0049)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0833** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0247** (0.0029)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.2036** (0.0042)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0818** (0.0038)
Constant
0.0158**
(0.0009)
Observations
113579
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
111
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Mathematics II Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.3687**
(0.0278)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.1063** (0.0203)
Grade 8 Reading Score Grade 8 Science Score
0.0052 (0.0204)
0.1738** (0.0226)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0055 (0.0190)
Female
-0.0040 (0.0228)
Foreign Born
0.0176 (0.0589)
Black
-0.0503 (0.0303)
Hispanic
-0.0466 (0.0523)
Asian
-0.2417 (0.2606)
American Indian
0.0517 (0.2021)
Multi-Racial
-0.1172 (0.0718)
ESOL Enrolled
0.0034 (0.0917)
Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0410 (0.0270)
0.4138** (0.1324)
112
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0397 (0.0625)
Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp.
0.0000 (.)
0.3780* (0.1574)
Deaf
0.5320
(0.3116)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
0.1044 (0.4471)
-0.1486* (0.0678)
-0.2023** (0.0428)
Deaf and Blind
0.0000 (.)
Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.1104 (0.1917)
-0.7578** (0.1093)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1317** (0.0492)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.0324 (0.1065)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
113
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0775 (0.0460)
Changed Schools
0.0337 (0.0347)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0058** (0.0010)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0184** (0.0044)
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0003 (0.0014)
Constant
0.6084**
(0.1406)
Observations
6841
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
114
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Mathematics II Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.3695**
(0.0277)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.1050** (0.0200)
Grade 8 Reading Score Grade 8 Science Score
0.0063 (0.0204)
0.1772** (0.0223)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0060 (0.0190)
Female
-0.0050 (0.0227)
Foreign Born
0.0177 (0.0593)
ESOL Enrolled
0.0095 (0.0917)
Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0324 (0.0265)
0.4203** (0.1329)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0393 (0.0518)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0000 (.)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.3643* (0.1608)
Deaf
0.5378
(0.3127)
Visual Impairment
0.1099 (0.4600)
115
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.1414* (0.0676)
-0.2007** (0.0430)
Deaf and Blind
0.0000 (.)
Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.1128 (0.1920)
-0.7611** (0.1091)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1251* (0.0486)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
-0.0368 (0.1068)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0779 (0.0462)
Changed Schools
0.0321 (0.0347)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0058** (0.0010)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0193** (0.0044)
116
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
-0.0005 (0.0014)
Constant
0.5946**
(0.1397)
Observations
6841
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
117
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Mathematics II Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.3897**
(0.0270)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.1354** (0.0195)
Grade 8 Reading Score Grade 8 Science Score
0.0126 (0.0209)
0.1782** (0.0228)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.0187 (0.0185)
Constant
0.4537**
(0.0166)
Observations
6841
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
118
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Biology Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.1328**
(0.0040)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0587** (0.0036)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0990** (0.0031)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.3104** (0.0044)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2251** (0.0043)
Female
-0.0699** (0.0037)
Foreign Born
0.0494** (0.0087)
Black
-0.0935** (0.0058)
Hispanic
-0.0598** (0.0080)
Asian
-0.0347 (0.0470)
American Indian
0.0260 (0.0381)
Multi-Racial
-0.0157 (0.0109)
ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
-0.0119 (0.0130)
-0.0343** (0.0045)
0.1900** (0.0089)
119
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0180* (0.0084)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0216 (0.0749)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0509 (0.0267)
Deaf
-0.0331
(0.0371)
Visual Impairment
-0.0359 (0.0580)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
0.0011 (0.0159)
-0.0232* (0.0092)
Deaf and Blind Autism
0.0000 (.)
0.1227** (0.0211)
Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0245 (0.0771)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0388** (0.0114)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0194 (0.0219)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.2413 (0.2451)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
120
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0898** (0.0090)
Changed Schools
0.0012 (0.0116)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0040** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0177** (0.0012)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0027** (0.0004)
Constant
-0.0682
(0.0440)
Observations
114915
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
121
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Biology Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.1336**
(0.0040)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0575** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1004** (0.0031)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.3166** (0.0045)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2262** (0.0043)
Female
-0.0704** (0.0037)
Foreign Born
0.0508** (0.0087)
ESOL Enrolled
-0.0021 (0.0134)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0526** (0.0048)
Gifted
0.1950** (0.0090)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0166* (0.0078)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0333 (0.0745)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0538* (0.0273)
Deaf
-0.0284
(0.0378)
Visual Impairment
-0.0351 (0.0585)
122
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
0.0122 (0.0159)
-0.0195* (0.0092)
Deaf and Blind Autism
0.0000 (.)
0.1319** (0.0211)
Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0236 (0.0797)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0285* (0.0113)
Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0173 (0.0219)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.2579 (0.2422)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0906** (0.0089)
Changed Schools
0.0027 (0.0117)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0040** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0200** (0.0012)
123
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0015** (0.0004)
Constant
0.0083
(0.0431)
Observations
114915
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
124
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Biology Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.1575**
(0.0042)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0628** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1014** (0.0032)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.3415** (0.0045)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2467** (0.0046)
Constant
0.0139**
(0.0002)
Observations
114915
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
125
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Physical Science Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.2406**
(0.0062)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0577** (0.0048)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0554** (0.0046)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.3708** (0.0055)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.1242** (0.0049)
Female
-0.0909** (0.0054)
Foreign Born Black Hispanic
0.0235 (0.0150)
-0.1068** (0.0072)
-0.0727** (0.0124)
Asian
-0.0636 (0.0631)
American Indian
0.0406 (0.0440)
Multi-Racial
-0.0248 (0.0155)
ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
-0.0240 (0.0228)
-0.0259** (0.0062)
0.1986** (0.0153)
126
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0217 (0.0136)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0075 (0.0697)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0525 (0.0429)
Deaf
-0.0793
(0.0659)
Visual Impairment
-0.1722 (0.1020)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism
-0.0313 (0.0213)
-0.0558** (0.0113)
-0.1979** (0.0083)
0.0783* (0.0374)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1970 (0.1622)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0981** (0.0170)
-0.1205** (0.0306)
-0.7310** (0.2528)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
127
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0790** (0.0131)
Changed Schools
0.0078 (0.0130)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0063** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0189** (0.0013)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0032** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.0394
(0.0509)
Observations
59484
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
128
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Physical Science Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.2402**
(0.0063)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0563** (0.0048)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0580** (0.0047)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.3799** (0.0056)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.1254** (0.0049)
Female
-0.0913** (0.0054)
Foreign Born
0.0281 (0.0156)
ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
-0.0091 (0.0242)
-0.0469** (0.0062)
0.2024** (0.0153)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0149 (0.0109)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0175 (0.0712)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.0542 (0.0426)
Deaf
-0.0810
(0.0670)
Visual Impairment
-0.1659 (0.1024)
129
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism
-0.0212 (0.0213)
-0.0503** (0.0114)
-0.2053** (0.0085)
0.0906* (0.0377)
Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1803 (0.1613)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0846** (0.0170)
-0.1302** (0.0309)
-0.7523** (0.2305)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0797** (0.0131)
Changed Schools
0.0060 (0.0129)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0062** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0216** (0.0014)
130
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0019** (0.0005)
Constant
0.0494
(0.0505)
Observations
59484
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
131
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Physical Science Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.2651**
(0.0062)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0616** (0.0048)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0580** (0.0047)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.4070** (0.0055)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.1480** (0.0051)
Constant
0.0764**
(0.0018)
Observations
59484
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
132
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Economics Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.1122**
(0.0045)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0656** (0.0040)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1102** (0.0036)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.2199** (0.0051)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2634** (0.0050)
Female
-0.1195** (0.0053)
Foreign Born
0.0940** (0.0130)
Black
-0.0886** (0.0069)
Hispanic
-0.0593** (0.0105)
Asian
-0.0245 (0.0738)
American Indian Multi-Racial
-0.0036 (0.0416)
-0.0287* (0.0140)
ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0088 (0.0269)
-0.0266** (0.0060)
0.1572** (0.0097)
133
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0097 (0.0114)
Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp.
0.0269 (0.1071)
-0.1214* (0.0594)
Deaf
-0.0653
(0.0550)
Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.0628 (0.0785)
-0.0908** (0.0251)
-0.1432** (0.0131)
Deaf and Blind
0.0000 (.)
Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.0106 (0.0359)
-0.3560** (0.0894)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1492** (0.0160)
-0.1672** (0.0352)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.3866 (0.2358)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
134
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.1018** (0.0168)
Changed Schools
-0.0396** (0.0144)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0083** (0.0004)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0244** (0.0018)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0039** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.2783**
(0.0481)
Observations
91439
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
135
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Economics Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.1131**
(0.0045)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0637** (0.0040)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1118** (0.0036)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.2264** (0.0051)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2651** (0.0050)
Female
-0.1192** (0.0053)
Foreign Born
0.0952** (0.0131)
ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0177 (0.0276)
-0.0451** (0.0059)
0.1621** (0.0098)
Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0079 (0.0109)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0337 (0.1056)
Speech-Language Imp. -0.1262* (0.0600)
Deaf
-0.0598
(0.0548)
Visual Impairment
-0.0698 (0.0795)
136
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.0815** (0.0253)
-0.1393** (0.0130)
Deaf and Blind
0.0000 (.)
Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.0215 (0.0360)
-0.3600** (0.0874)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.1378** (0.0160)
-0.1699** (0.0354)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.4282 (0.2396)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.1033** (0.0167)
Changed Schools
-0.0420** (0.0142)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0083** (0.0004)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0268** (0.0018)
137
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0031** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.2317**
(0.0477)
Observations
91439
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
138
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS Economics Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.1398**
(0.0048)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0682** (0.0041)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1137** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.2556** (0.0053)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.2893** (0.0051)
Constant
-0.1244**
(0.0011)
Observations
91439
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
139
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS U.S. History Value-Added Model Estimates
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0524**
(0.0041)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0442** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0697** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1474** (0.0048)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.4432** (0.0060)
Female
-0.1751** (0.0051)
Foreign Born
0.0623** (0.0107)
Black
-0.0311** (0.0071)
Hispanic
0.0275* (0.0107)
Asian
-0.0248 (0.0590)
American Indian
-0.0224 (0.0432)
Multi-Racial
0.0064 (0.0126)
ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted
0.0260 (0.0202)
-0.0262** (0.0060)
0.1089** (0.0111)
140
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0113 (0.0129)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0688 (0.1133)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0084 (0.0463)
Deaf Visual Impairment
-0.0156 (0.0786)
0.1897* (0.0759)
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
-0.0001 (0.0220)
-0.0444** (0.0115)
Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.0000 (.)
0.1889** (0.0345)
-0.3276** (0.0979)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0515** (0.0163)
-0.1431** (0.0299)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1544 (0.2926)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
141
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.0999** (0.0125)
Changed Schools
-0.0059 (0.0097)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0059** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0265** (0.0015)
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0065** (0.0006)
Constant
-0.4722**
(0.0559)
Observations
97375
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
142
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS U.S. History Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0523**
(0.0041)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0435** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0705** (0.0038)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1500** (0.0048)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.4434** (0.0060)
Female
-0.1750** (0.0051)
Foreign Born
0.0649** (0.0108)
ESOL Enrolled
0.0273 (0.0203)
Free/Reduced Lunch
-0.0297** (0.0059)
Gifted
0.1095** (0.0111)
Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0379** (0.0111)
Orthopedic Impairment 0.0697 (0.1134)
Speech-Language Imp. 0.0059 (0.0462)
Deaf Visual Impairment
-0.0120 (0.0792)
0.1865* (0.0758)
143
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis.
0.0006 (0.0220)
-0.0430** (0.0115)
Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury
0.0000 (.)
0.1921** (0.0344)
-0.3238** (0.0975)
Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
-0.0489** (0.0164)
-0.1453** (0.0298)
Mod. Intellectual Dis.
-0.1573 (0.2952)
Sev. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Prof. Intellectual Dis.
0.0000 (.)
Num. Schools Attended -0.1003** (0.0125)
Changed Schools
-0.0079 (0.0096)
Diff. from Modal Age
-0.0058** (0.0003)
Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0274** (0.0015)
144
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lagged Pct. Present
0.0062** (0.0005)
Constant
-0.4454**
(0.0551)
Observations
97375
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
145
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
HS U.S. History Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only
Grade 8 Math Score
0.0700**
(0.0045)
Grade 8 ELA Score
0.0338** (0.0037)
Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0564** (0.0040)
Grade 8 Science Score 0.1945** (0.0047)
Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score
0.4723** (0.0063)
Constant
-0.0524**
(0.0006)
Observations
97375
Standard errors in parentheses
Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01
146
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
III. School Effect Estimates Based on Alternative Value-Added Models and School-Level Growth Percentiles Based on Alternative Measures and Samples
All of the analyses in the main report are based on estimated school effects from the full value-added model that includes all available demographic controls. The following charts and tables report estimates based on the two alternative specifications of the value-added model, one that excludes indicators for race and ethnicity and one that eliminates all demographic variables (and thus only includes lagged test scores).
The school-level student growth measures in the main report are averages of the individual student growth percentiles for students attending a given school. They are based on the full sample of students with SGP information. Results using three alternative school-level growth measures are presented below. The first uses school average SGPs, but only includes students used in the full value added model estimation (denoted "value-added sample"). This excludes, for example, students with missing demographic information. The second alternative employs this same sample, but uses the school-level median SGP, rather than the mean. The third alternative employs the full sample but utilizes the school median SGP.
Finally, a summary table provides statewide percentile rankings of schools using a common sample of students and each of five different measures (school effects from the three different value-added model specifications and both school median and school mean SGPs).
147
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
Atlanta Heights Cherokee Pataula Coweta Odyssey GA Connections
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
A. State Charter School Effects -- Statewide Comparisons from Alternate Value- Added Models
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
148
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Atlanta Heights Cherokee Odyssey GA Connections Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Georgia Connections Academy
0.0992
0.0419
56
84
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.0980
0.0799
60
84
Odyssey School
0.0978
0.0161
53
84
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0304
0.0493
55
61
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0110
0.0646
51
44
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0830
0.0392
51
21
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1469
0.0497
49
9
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.2167
0.0891
52
2
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.2260
0.0925
51
2
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
80 96 63 73 43 45 26 51 40
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1088
0.0421
56
86
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.0990
0.0804
60
84
Odyssey School
0.0548
0.0162
53
71
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0455
0.0496
55
67
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0256
0.0650
51
39
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0774
0.0395
51
23
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1517
0.0500
49
7
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.1947
0.0897
52
3
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.2432
0.0931
51
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
80 96 63 73 43 45 26 51 40
149
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Cherokee GA Connections Pataula Atlanta Heights Odyssey Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
150
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Cherokee Pataula Odyssey GA Connections Atlanta Heights Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.1515
0.0770
53
94
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0532
0.0475
50
72
Odyssey School
0.0519
0.0156
49
71
Atlanta Heights Charter School
0.0266
0.0479
48
61
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0094
0.0627
49
51
Georgia Connections Academy
0.0048
0.0401
50
49
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.1023
0.0379
47
15
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.1389
0.0892
46
9
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.2613
0.0859
48
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
86 68 67 53 63 73 49 42 54
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.1564
0.0781
53
94
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0581
0.0482
50
74
Atlanta Heights Charter School
0.0117
0.0486
48
55
Georgia Connections Academy
0.0019
0.0407
50
49
Odyssey School
0.0002
0.0157
49
48
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0182
0.0636
49
41
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.1011
0.0384
47
16
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.1922
0.0905
46
4
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.2095
0.0871
48
2
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
86 68 53 73 67 63 49 42 54
151
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Odyssey Atlanta Heights Cherokee Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
152
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Odyssey Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Atlanta Heights Cherokee Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.0970
0.0779
54
71
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0423
0.0481
50
59
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0027
0.0634
42
50
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.1533
0.0384
48
19
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.2015
0.0484
38
12
Odyssey School
-0.2305
0.0157
38
9
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.2404
0.0869
36
8
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.3244
0.0408
34
3
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.4610
0.0891
42
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
80 64 28 53 16 16 13
8 30
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.0720
0.0792
54
65
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0304
0.0488
50
57
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0326
0.0644
42
42
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.1551
0.0390
48
18
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.2299
0.0492
38
8
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.2691
0.0883
36
6
Odyssey School
-0.2892
0.0159
38
4
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.3477
0.0415
34
3
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.4547
0.0905
42
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
80 64 28 53 16 13 16
8 30
153
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Atlanta Heights Cherokee GA Connections Odyssey Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
154
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Atlanta Heights Cherokee Odyssey GA Connections Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0989
0.0461
50
74
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.0745
0.0749
58
70
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0173
0.0602
47
44
Odyssey School
-0.0596
0.0149
44
33
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.0810
0.0392
42
28
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.1218
0.0364
47
21
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1563
0.0462
48
15
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.4450
0.0857
41
1
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.4936
0.0836
43
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
47 82 30 15 10 27 33 8 12
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
0.1073
0.0464
50
77
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.0567
0.0755
58
66
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0433
0.0607
47
37
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.0822
0.0395
42
28
Odyssey School
-0.0982
0.0150
44
25
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.1087
0.0366
47
23
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1705
0.0466
48
13
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.4041
0.0864
41
1
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.5374
0.0843
43
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
47 82 30 10 15 27 33 8 12
155
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Atlanta Heights Odyssey Cherokee Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Social Studies
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
156
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Atlanta Heights Odyssey Cherokee Pataula Coweta
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Commissioned
Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Mean SGP
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Percentile
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.2153
0.0744
58
87
85
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0889
0.0458
50
68
56
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0131
0.0598
47
53
46
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0896
0.0361
51
33
60
Odyssey School
-0.1556
0.0148
38
21
14
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1805
0.0459
45
16
36
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.2538
0.0390
34
8
6
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.4458
0.0851
28
1
2
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.5416
0.0830
35
1
8
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Commissioned Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Mean SGP
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Percentile
Scholars Academy Charter School
0.1849
0.0754
58
85
85
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0960
0.0464
50
70
56
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0116
0.0606
47
48
46
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0722
0.0366
51
35
60
Odyssey School
-0.1979
0.0150
38
14
14
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1988
0.0466
45
14
36
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.2579
0.0395
34
8
6
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.3870
0.0863
28
2
2
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.6086
0.0841
35
1
8
157
Fulton Leadership
GACoCwoentnaections
PPOrrdeeypp..ss--eyYKirokunwgooMdens
Iv y Iv y
Cherokee Pataula
Ivy Prep. CCAT
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
158
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. CCAT Cherokee Pataula Ivy PrOedpy.s-seYyoung Mens IvyFuPGlrtAeoCpn.oCo-LwneeKtnaiaredkcetriwsoohnoisdp
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.2530
0.0461
62
98
Coweta Charter Academy
0.2135
0.0978
55
98
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1901
0.0263
56
97
Odyssey School
0.1566
0.0108
53
96
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
0.1100
0.0603
52
90
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
0.1088
0.0582
51
90
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0583
0.0544
51
74
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0409
0.0340
51
67
CCAT School
0.0403
0.0747
48
67
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.0002
0.0355
55
51
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.0578
0.0445
49
27
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.0787
0.0468
49
19
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
95 50 61 38 25 18 19 21 7 52 10 9
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
0.2143
0.0988
55
98
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1818
0.0265
56
97
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.1655
0.0465
62
96
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
0.1351
0.0609
52
94
Odyssey School
0.1157
0.0108
53
91
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
0.0564
0.0587
51
75
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0472
0.0550
51
72
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0426
0.0343
51
70
CCAT School
0.0407
0.0754
48
69
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
0.0204
0.0359
55
59
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.0103
0.0450
49
47
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.0873
0.0473
49
16
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
50 61 95 25 38 18 19 21 7 52 10 9
159
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT Pataula Ivy Prep. IvyChPrereop.k-eeYoung Mens IvGyOAdPryCsoesnp.en-yecKtiiroknwsood Coweta Atlanta Heights Fulton Leadership
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
160
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT Pataula Ivy PrIevpy. -PrYeop.ung Mens Cherokee Odyssey GFAulCtCooonwneLtneaeactidoernsship Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.2218
0.0443
50
98
Atlanta Heights Charter School
0.1491
0.0447
48
96
Coweta Charter Academy
0.1395
0.0934
50
96
Odyssey School
0.1264
0.0103
49
94
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1089
0.0250
50
91
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
0.1066
0.0579
48
91
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0624
0.0323
47
81
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
0.0381
0.0555
46
72
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.0236
0.0338
45
40
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0306
0.0520
49
35
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.1105
0.0427
42
6
CCAT School
-0.1995
0.0707
40
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
72 50 68 66 74 51 44 36 27 62 9 5
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
0.1653
0.0590
48
97
Atlanta Heights Charter School
0.1368
0.0455
48
95
Coweta Charter Academy
0.1177
0.0952
50
93
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.0952
0.0451
50
89
Georgia Connections Academy
0.0825
0.0255
50
87
Odyssey School
0.0790
0.0104
49
86
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0517
0.0329
47
77
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
0.0288
0.0344
45
65
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.0426
0.0566
46
29
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0453
0.0530
49
28
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.0466
0.0435
42
27
CCAT School
-0.2132
0.0721
40
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
51 50 68 72 74 66 44 27 36 62 9 5
161
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT GCAowCeotnanections Odyssey AtPlaatnatualaHeights IvFyCulthProerenop.Lkee-aeKdirerkswhiopod Ivy Prep. Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
162
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT GACCoownenteactions Odyssey FPulattoanulLaeadership Atlanta Heights Ivy CPrheerp.o-keKeirkwood Ivy Prep. Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
0.1010
0.0515
42
79
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
0.0566
0.0315
47
69
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0265
0.0301
48
44
Fulton Leadership Academy
-0.0386
0.0414
45
40
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.0499
0.0537
36
36
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0638
0.0479
42
32
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.0737
0.0412
38
30
Odyssey School
-0.0799
0.0096
38
28
Coweta Charter Academy
-0.1753
0.0861
50
7
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.1875
0.0232
34
7
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.2287
0.0393
38
3
CCAT School
-0.2806
0.0663
37
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
27 50 57 40 10 25 12 13 67
5 14 11
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
0.0991
0.0525
42
79
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
0.0104
0.0321
47
58
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0360
0.0307
48
41
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.0775
0.0548
36
29
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.0884
0.0421
38
25
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0901
0.0489
42
24
Fulton Leadership Academy
-0.1027
0.0422
45
20
Odyssey School
-0.1398
0.0097
38
12
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.1420
0.0401
38
12
Coweta Charter Academy
-0.1884
0.0879
50
5
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.2303
0.0237
34
3
CCAT School
-0.2846
0.0677
37
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
27 50 57 10 12 25 40 13 14 67
5 11
163
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Fulton Leadership Pataula Ivy Prep. GA Connections Odyssey Atlanta Heights Cherokee Coweta
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
164
FGultAOodCnyoLsnesnaeedycteirosnhisp Atlanta Heights Cherokee Coweta
Mens
Young
-
Ivy Prep. Pataula
-PrKeirp.kwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Prep. Iv y
Iv y
CCAT
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
0.0886
0.0873
50
77
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0573
0.0300
47
69
Atlanta Heights Charter School
0.0105
0.0415
48
53
Odyssey School
-0.0307
0.0095
44
39
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.0794
0.0233
42
26
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.0943
0.0314
44
22
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0976
0.0484
47
21
Fulton Leadership Academy
-0.1017
0.0405
48
20
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.1601
0.0507
41
12
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.1849
0.0536
43
8
CCAT School
-0.2693
0.0641
35
3
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.2722
0.0392
40
2
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
51 27 33 13 8 13 30 37 6 11 3 6
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
0.1032
0.0881
50
81
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0647
0.0303
47
71
Atlanta Heights Charter School
0.0127
0.0419
48
54
Odyssey School
-0.0610
0.0095
44
30
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.0938
0.0235
42
22
Fulton Leadership Academy
-0.1023
0.0409
48
21
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.1080
0.0489
47
20
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.1088
0.0512
41
19
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.1582
0.0317
44
10
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.2312
0.0541
43
4
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.2377
0.0396
40
4
CCAT School
-0.2421
0.0647
35
3
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
51 27 33 13 8 37 30 6 13 11 6 3
165
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Odyssey CCAT Coweta Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. Pataula Fulton Leadership Cherokee
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
166
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
GA Connections Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
Odyssey Coweta CCAT Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. Pataula Fulton Leadership Cherokee
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.2577
0.0303
51
93
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.1177
0.0409
53
78
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0104
0.0488
47
51
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.0117
0.0318
39
46
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.1125
0.0541
35
24
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1570
0.0418
45
17
Coweta Charter Academy
-0.2374
0.0881
50
8
CCAT School
-0.2460
0.0647
38
8
Odyssey School
-0.2657
0.0096
38
7
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.3528
0.0235
34
3
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.4151
0.0511
28
2
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.4908
0.0396
27
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
64 75 39 11 4 31 58 8 9 3 2 1
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.2615
0.0306
51
94
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.1234
0.0413
53
81
Pataula Charter Academy
-0.0016
0.0493
47
49
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.0678
0.0321
39
32
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls
-0.1469
0.0546
35
18
Atlanta Heights Charter School
-0.1504
0.0422
45
18
CCAT School
-0.2198
0.0653
38
11
Coweta Charter Academy
-0.2296
0.0890
50
9
Odyssey School
-0.2923
0.0097
38
5
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership
-0.3562
0.0517
28
3
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.3697
0.0238
34
2
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
-0.4490
0.0399
27
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
64 75 39 11 4 31 8 58 9 2 3 1
167
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost Ivy Prep. Mountain Ed. Cherokee CCAT GA Connections Odyssey Fulton Leadership Pataula
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
168
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost Ivy Prep. Mountain Ed. Cherokee CCAT GA Connections Odyssey Fulton Leadership Pataula
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
0.3380
0.0902
68
99
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.2808
0.0684
64
98
Odyssey School
0.2344
0.0182
56
97
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1571
0.0358
55
92
CCAT School
0.0928
0.1217
55
79
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0709
0.1070
44
73
Mountain Education Center School
0.0702
0.0886
46
73
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
-0.0013
0.1295
47
49
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.0472
0.0548
46
34
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
99 98 84 75 76 12 20 24 19
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
0.3717
0.0921
68
99
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.2424
0.0698
64
96
Odyssey School
0.2190
0.0179
56
96
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1707
0.0366
55
92
CCAT School
0.1630
0.1243
55
92
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0809
0.1093
44
75
Mountain Education Center School
0.0706
0.0906
46
72
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
0.0401
0.1323
47
62
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.0532
0.0560
46
31
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
99 98 84 75 76 12 20 24 19
169
Mountain Ed. GA Connections Odyssey
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 American Literature
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
170
Mountain Ed. GA Connections Odyssey
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Odyssey School
0.2330
0.0243
50
95
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1611
0.0438
52
87
Mountain Education Center School
-0.1423
0.0632
44
15
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.1530
0.0531
35
14
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
70 79 27 2
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Odyssey School
0.1939
0.0248
50
91
Georgia Connections Academy
0.1448
0.0447
52
83
Mountain Education Center School
-0.1361
0.0647
44
16
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.1557
0.0544
35
13
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
70 79 27 2
171
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
CCAT GA Connections Odyssey
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
172
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
GA Connections Odyssey CCAT
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
0.3292
0.1337
78
92
Odyssey School
-0.2343
0.0200
43
14
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.2495
0.0441
42
11
CCAT School
-0.2954
0.1381
36
5
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.3886
0.0893
29
2
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
99 28 21
6 1
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
0.3199
0.1370
78
91
CCAT School
-0.2469
0.1415
36
12
Odyssey School
-0.2780
0.0204
43
8
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.3004
0.0451
42
6
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4536
0.0913
29
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
99 6 28 21 1
173
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost Odyssey GA Connections CCAT Cherokee Mountain Ed.
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
174
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost Odyssey GA Connections Mountain Ed. Cherokee CCAT
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
0.0147
0.0725
48
56
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0442
0.1090
41
44
CCAT School
-0.0584
0.1278
56
40
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.0797
0.0353
40
35
Odyssey School
-0.1864
0.0168
34
15
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.2244
0.0474
35
9
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
60 36 84 30 11 14
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
CCAT School
0.0451
0.1294
56
62
Cherokee Charter Academy
-0.0458
0.1104
41
42
Mountain Education Center School
-0.0552
0.0732
48
39
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.1065
0.0358
40
31
Odyssey School
-0.2051
0.0168
34
12
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.2623
0.0479
35
7
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
84 36 60 30 11 14
175
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost Odyssey Mountain Ed. GA Connections Cherokee Pataula Fulton Leadership
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
176
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost Odyssey GA Connections Mountain Ed. Cherokee Pataula Fulton Leadership
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.2209
0.0660
50
89
Pataula Charter Academy
0.1313
0.1249
66
80
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0835
0.1249
60
72
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.0529
0.0371
51
41
Mountain Education Center School
-0.0611
0.1248
49
39
Odyssey School
-0.0668
0.0170
48
36
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.3419
0.0453
34
2
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
53 96 86 57 48 42 4
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.2053
0.0673
50
87
Pataula Charter Academy
0.0713
0.1276
66
71
Cherokee Charter Academy
0.0309
0.1276
60
63
Mountain Education Center School
-0.1062
0.1276
49
25
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.1102
0.0379
51
24
Odyssey School
-0.1343
0.0169
48
19
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.3651
0.0461
34
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
53 96 86 48 57 42 4
177
Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
GA Connections Odyssey
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Economics
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
178
Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
GA Connections Odyssey
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
0.1109
0.0571
61
68
Odyssey School
-0.3176
0.0375
52
12
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.3937
0.0576
43
7
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4625
0.0474
34
5
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
82 55 27
8
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
-0.0253
0.0575
61
45
Odyssey School
-0.3457
0.0380
52
10
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.4701
0.0583
43
6
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.5673
0.0478
34
3
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
82 55 27
8
179
Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Math II
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
180
Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Provost
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
0.3393
0.1357
66
89
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4456
0.1300
37
4
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
96 9
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
0.3662
0.1350
66
88
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4690
0.1298
37
3
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
96 9
181
Pataula
Provost CCAT Odyssey GA Connections Fulton Leadership Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
182
Pataula
Provost CCAT Odyssey GA Connections Fulton Leadership Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
0.5183
0.0945
65
98
Mountain Education Center School
0.1307
0.0676
50
77
Fulton Leadership Academy
-0.0534
0.0717
49
40
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.1863
0.0433
36
19
Odyssey School
-0.2190
0.0280
41
13
CCAT School
-0.3439
0.1075
27
3
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4050
0.0427
29
2
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
95 59 56 10 22
1 3
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
0.5251
0.0960
65
98
Mountain Education Center School
0.0821
0.0684
50
69
Fulton Leadership Academy
0.0067
0.0727
49
54
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.2087
0.0439
36
15
Odyssey School
-0.2403
0.0283
41
11
CCAT School
-0.3061
0.1091
27
5
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4548
0.0431
29
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
95 59 56 10 22
1 3
183
Mountain Ed.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
GA Connections CCAT
Odyssey
Provost
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
184
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
GA Connections Provost
Mountain Ed.
Odyssey
CCAT
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
-0.0596
0.0665
43
43
Odyssey School
-0.3975
0.0267
27
7
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.4740
0.0543
26
4
CCAT School
-0.4877
0.1158
22
3
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.5600
0.0476
22
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
41 6 6 3 2
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters]
School Name
School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect
Standard Error Student Growth State Rank
Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Education Center School
-0.2255
0.0674
43
18
Odyssey School
-0.4281
0.0271
27
7
CCAT School
-0.4555
0.1181
22
5
Provost Academy Georgia
-0.5830
0.0551
26
2
Georgia Connections Academy
-0.6563
0.0483
22
1
Mean SGP State Rank Percentile
41 6 3 6 2
185
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
B. State Charter School Effects -- District Comparisons from Alternate Value- Added Models
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Atlanta Heights
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Atlanta Heights
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
186
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.2415 0.0495
58
99
92
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.1378 0.0439
56
91
83
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.1336 0.0634
55
90
74
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.1333 0.0434
57
90
86
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.1313 0.0461
57
89
84
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.1306 0.0627
60
89
96
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1299 0.0615
58
89
91
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.1164 0.0462
59
87
94
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1134 0.0344
61
87
97
Centennial Place Elementary School
0
0 0.1055 0.0502
57
85
86
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.0894 0.0562
60
82
95
The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele
0
0 0.0862 0.0663
48
81
21
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.0722 0.0375
64
76
99
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.0654 0.0322
60
74
95
Smith Elementary School
0
0 0.0651 0.0309
54
74
68
Continental Colony Elementary School
0
0 0.0463 0.0619
56
67
81
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.0304 0.0678
53
61
55
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0288 0.0465
52
60
52
Whitefoord Elementary School
0
0 0.0198 0.0776
50
56
36
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.0186 0.0622
55
56
71
Beecher Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0032 0.0611
49
47
24
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0137 0.0387
54
43
63
Kimberly Elementary School
0
0 -0.0283 0.0532
50
38
39
Kindezi
0
1 -0.0286 0.0913
52
38
54
187
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Rivers Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Slater Elementary School Humphries Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Heritage Academy Elementary Intown Charter Academy Finch Elementary Deerwood Academy School Fickett Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Bolton Academy Grove Park Intermediate School Burgess-Peterson Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm Thomasville Heights Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Boyd Elementary School KIPP VISION Perkerson Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Connally Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Scott Elementary School Towns Elementary School Fain Elementary School
0
0 -0.0430 0.0450
50
33
31
0
0 -0.0459 0.0677
48
32
20
0
0 -0.0562 0.0510
48
29
19
0
0 -0.0593 0.0486
50
28
32
0
0 -0.0605 0.0642
47
27
15
0
0 -0.0622 0.0499
50
27
34
0
0 -0.0649 0.0525
50
26
38
0
1 -0.0688 0.0823
50
25
35
0
0 -0.0739 0.0471
48
24
20
0
0 -0.0766 0.0466
47
23
17
0
0 -0.0992 0.0498
50
17
36
0
0 -0.0993 0.0502
46
17
12
0
0 -0.1102 0.0595
52
15
51
0
0 -0.1122 0.0634
44
14
6
0
0 -0.1175 0.0471
45
13
8
0
0 -0.1231 0.0424
47
12
17
0
0 -0.1239 0.0724
45
12
9
0
0 -0.1305 0.0446
50
11
36
0
0 -0.1309 0.0547
51
11
42
0
0 -0.1426 0.0642
52
9
50
1
0 -0.1469 0.0497
49
9
26
0
0 -0.1551 0.0659
48
7
19
0
0 -0.1660 0.0565
48
6
19
0
1 -0.1662 0.0703
53
6
58
0
0 -0.1676 0.0486
43
5
4
0
0 -0.1797 0.0471
48
4
19
0
0 -0.1889 0.0568
44
4
7
0
0 -0.1890 0.0630
40
4
1
0
0 -0.1977 0.0677
44
3
5
0
0 -0.2098 0.0672
42
2
3
0
0 -0.2211 0.0546
45
2
9
188
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.2350 0.0807
42
2
2
0
0 -0.2755 0.0525
43
1
5
189
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.2109 0.0498
58
97
92
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.1703 0.0638
55
95
74
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.1666 0.0437
57
94
86
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.1459 0.0630
60
92
96
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.1446 0.0464
57
91
84
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.1414 0.0442
56
91
83
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1406 0.0619
58
91
91
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1373 0.0346
61
90
97
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.1336 0.0465
59
89
94
Centennial Place Elementary School
0
0 0.1176 0.0506
57
87
86
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.1167 0.0566
60
87
95
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.1092 0.0378
64
86
99
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.1046 0.0324
60
85
95
Smith Elementary School
0
0 0.0874 0.0310
54
81
68
The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele
0
0 0.0849 0.0667
48
81
21
Continental Colony Elementary School
0
0 0.0740 0.0623
56
77
81
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.0640 0.0681
53
74
55
Whitefoord Elementary School
0
0 0.0304 0.0781
50
61
36
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.0173 0.0626
55
56
71
Beecher Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0151 0.0616
49
55
24
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0071 0.0467
52
47
52
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0168 0.0390
54
43
63
Kimberly Elementary School
0
0 -0.0241 0.0536
50
40
39
Benteen Elementary School
0
0 -0.0337 0.0681
48
37
20
Rivers Elementary School
0
0 -0.0349 0.0453
50
36
31
190
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Slater Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Heritage Academy Elementary Peyton Forest Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Humphries Elementary School Finch Elementary Deerwood Academy School Fickett Elementary School Kindezi Hutchinson Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Grove Park Intermediate School M. A. Jones Elementary School Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm Thomasville Heights Elementary School Bolton Academy Burgess-Peterson Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School KIPP VISION Gideons Elementary School Boyd Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Toomer Elementary School Connally Elementary School Scott Elementary School Fain Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School Towns Elementary School
0
0 -0.0379 0.0489
50
35
32
0
0 -0.0461 0.0502
50
32
34
0
0 -0.0472 0.0529
50
32
38
0
0 -0.0491 0.0514
48
31
19
0
1 -0.0493 0.0829
50
31
35
0
0 -0.0509 0.0646
47
31
15
0
0 -0.0535 0.0474
48
30
20
0
0 -0.0621 0.0469
47
27
17
0
0 -0.0668 0.0502
50
26
36
0
1 -0.0727 0.0919
52
24
54
0
0 -0.0945 0.0599
52
17
51
0
0 -0.0983 0.0638
44
17
6
0
0 -0.0995 0.0449
50
16
36
0
0 -0.1020 0.0427
47
16
17
0
0 -0.1027 0.0506
46
16
12
0
0 -0.1030 0.0550
51
16
42
0
0 -0.1062 0.0646
52
16
50
0
0 -0.1158 0.0474
45
14
8
0
0 -0.1195 0.0729
45
13
9
0
0 -0.1345 0.0663
48
10
19
0
1 -0.1351 0.0707
53
9
58
0
0 -0.1367 0.0474
48
9
19
0
0 -0.1427 0.0569
48
8
19
0
0 -0.1514 0.0489
43
7
4
1
0 -0.1517 0.0500
49
7
26
0
0 -0.1598 0.0634
40
6
1
0
0 -0.1784 0.0571
44
4
7
0
0 -0.1803 0.0681
44
4
5
0
0 -0.2074 0.0550
45
3
9
0
0 -0.2167 0.0812
42
2
2
0
0 -0.2206 0.0677
42
2
3
191
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.2557 0.0529
43
1
5
192
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
193
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.1501 0.0282
53
93
58
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1142 0.0472
54
87
67
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.0959 0.0630
52
83
47
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.0782 0.0361
50
78
36
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 0.0043 0.0598
45
49
9
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.0003 0.0486
49
48
26
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0067 0.0336
50
46
36
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0140 0.0431
45
43
10
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 -0.0243 0.0288
48
40
21
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0259 0.0392
48
39
20
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.0355 0.0326
45
36
8
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.0440 0.0299
48
33
18
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.0636 0.0382
51
27
45
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.0636 0.0484
38
26
1
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0645 0.0333
43
26
4
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.0672 0.0349
51
26
41
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0707 0.0450
44
24
6
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 -0.0758 0.0345
45
23
10
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.0772 0.0421
51
23
46
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0807 0.0302
44
22
6
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0830 0.0392
51
21
45
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.0887 0.0482
42
20
3
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0944 0.0296
42
19
3
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1571 0.0469
46
7
12
194
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1753 0.0348
44
4
6
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.1460 0.0284
53
92
58
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1086 0.0475
54
86
67
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.0906 0.0634
52
82
47
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.0709 0.0363
50
76
36
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.0006 0.0339
50
50
36
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 -0.0011 0.0602
45
50
9
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0113 0.0434
45
45
10
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.0122 0.0489
49
45
26
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 -0.0181 0.0290
48
43
21
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.0334 0.0301
48
37
18
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.0349 0.0328
45
36
8
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0632 0.0394
48
27
20
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 -0.0653 0.0347
45
26
10
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0694 0.0336
43
25
4
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.0747 0.0351
51
23
41
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0749 0.0453
44
23
6
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0774 0.0395
51
23
45
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0820 0.0304
44
21
6
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.0867 0.0487
38
20
1
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.0874 0.0485
42
20
3
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0880 0.0298
42
19
3
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.0918 0.0423
51
19
46
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.0919 0.0385
51
18
45
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1646 0.0472
46
6
12
195
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1828 0.0350
44
4
6
196
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
197
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Western Elementary School
0
0 0.0587 0.0506
51
72
39
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0304 0.0493
55
61
73
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 0.0145 0.0402
53
54
55
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 0.0032 0.0516
54
49
67
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.0024 0.0381
49
47
28
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 -0.0199 0.0514
48
42
19
Northside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0328 0.0551
50
37
32
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 -0.0431 0.0467
50
33
38
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 -0.0497 0.0510
48
31
23
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.0534 0.0379
50
30
35
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0641 0.0502
45
26
9
Brooks Elementary
0
0 -0.0678 0.0405
53
25
62
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 -0.0803 0.0491
45
22
9
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0950 0.0510
44
18
7
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 -0.0970 0.0420
46
18
12
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0979 0.0491
51
17
43
Glanton Elementary
0
0 -0.1128 0.0576
45
14
8
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1227 0.0439
45
12
9
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.1267 0.0387
48
12
18
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.2142 0.0495
42
2
3
198
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Western Elementary School
0
0 0.0726 0.0510
51
76
39
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0455 0.0496
55
67
73
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 0.0425 0.0405
53
66
55
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 0.0058 0.0520
54
51
67
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.0033 0.0384
49
49
28
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 -0.0146 0.0518
48
44
19
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0173 0.0506
45
43
9
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 -0.0324 0.0470
50
37
38
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.0342 0.0381
50
37
35
Northside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0352 0.0555
50
36
32
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 -0.0381 0.0514
48
35
23
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 -0.0585 0.0494
45
29
9
Brooks Elementary
0
0 -0.0611 0.0407
53
28
62
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 -0.0794 0.0422
46
22
12
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0842 0.0494
51
21
43
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0925 0.0442
45
18
9
Glanton Elementary
0
0 -0.0943 0.0580
45
18
8
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.0994 0.0389
48
16
18
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.1101 0.0514
44
15
7
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.2307 0.0498
42
2
3
199
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
200
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.3343 0.0743
63
99
98
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.1901 0.0449
62
97
98
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1806 0.0525
53
96
60
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.1683 0.0412
60
95
96
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.1619 0.0386
54
95
71
Midvale Elementary School
0
0 0.1575 0.0549
56
94
78
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.1261 0.0568
58
89
91
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1251 0.0493
61
89
98
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 0.1212 0.0355
53
88
58
Smoke Rise Elementary School
0
1 0.1204 0.0514
53
88
56
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1192 0.0554
58
88
89
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.1145 0.0386
62
87
98
Stone Mountain Elementary School
0
0 0.1048 0.0525
49
85
30
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0942 0.0410
58
83
89
Huntley Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0935 0.0582
53
83
54
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 0.0894 0.0417
60
82
95
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.0824 0.0612
54
79
71
Shadow Rock Elementary School
0
0 0.0756 0.0408
49
77
26
Pine Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0704 0.0439
54
76
64
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo
0
0 0.0650 0.0369
52
74
49
Henderson Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.0590 0.0460
56
72
80
Sagamore Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0570 0.0542
52
71
50
Livsey Elementary School
0
0 0.0493 0.0547
49
68
26
Hawthorne Elementary School
0
0 0.0423 0.0542
53
65
60
201
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Snapfinger Elementary School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Cedar Grove Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Kittredge Magnet School Evansdale Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Vanderlyn Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Allgood Elementary School Clifton Elementary School International Community School Columbia Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Bob Mathis Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Browns Mill Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School
0
0 0.0420 0.0447
50
65
33
0
1 0.0414 0.0636
52
65
47
0
0 0.0383 0.0481
53
64
56
0
0 0.0334 0.0525
53
62
58
0
0 0.0256 0.0547
52
59
49
0
0 0.0246 0.0393
53
59
57
0
0 0.0241 0.0514
50
59
34
0
0 0.0219 0.0523
47
57
16
0
0 0.0174 0.0392
45
56
10
0
0 0.0168 0.0559
50
55
38
0
0 0.0166 0.0348
59
55
94
0
0 0.0162 0.0408
50
55
33
0
0 0.0149 0.0412
57
54
88
0
0 0.0089 0.0476
53
52
55
0
0 0.0056 0.0411
58
50
92
0
0 0.0048 0.0396
55
50
72
0
0 0.0017 0.0421
48
48
21
0
1 0.0013 0.0612
52
48
53
0
0 -0.0026 0.0463
47
47
16
0
0 -0.0044 0.0595
44
47
7
0
1 -0.0081 0.0557
49
45
23
0
0 -0.0102 0.0471
48
44
22
0
0 -0.0136 0.0481
49
43
30
0
0 -0.0257 0.0598
45
39
10
0
1 -0.0305 0.0562
51
37
46
0
0 -0.0342 0.0385
53
36
58
0
0 -0.0347 0.0491
50
36
35
0
0 -0.0347 0.0588
48
36
22
0
0 -0.0405 0.0663
52
34
53
0
0 -0.0407 0.0385
46
34
12
0
0 -0.0420 0.0466
47
34
17
202
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Princeton Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Toney Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Redan Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Oakview Elementary Stoneview Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Stone Mill Elementary School Midway Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
0 -0.0561 0.0356
46
29
11
0
0 -0.0564 0.0370
49
29
29
0
0 -0.0578 0.0576
48
29
20
0
0 -0.0583 0.0427
49
28
27
0
0 -0.0614 0.0392
45
27
8
0
0 -0.0628 0.0497
49
27
25
0
0 -0.0679 0.0500
45
25
10
0
0 -0.0682 0.0346
45
25
9
0
0 -0.0788 0.0565
50
22
35
0
0 -0.0804 0.0346
46
22
11
0
0 -0.0870 0.0355
41
21
2
0
1 -0.0893 0.0458
45
19
9
0
0 -0.0954 0.0539
48
18
23
0
0 -0.1019 0.0377
42
16
4
0
0 -0.1041 0.0568
47
16
15
0
0 -0.1109 0.0697
47
15
16
0
0 -0.1178 0.0708
47
13
17
0
0 -0.1230 0.0420
41
12
2
0
0 -0.1277 0.0427
44
11
6
0
0 -0.1406 0.0484
43
9
5
0
0 -0.1482 0.0510
46
9
13
0
0 -0.1500 0.0484
45
8
10
0
0 -0.1585 0.0525
45
6
8
0
0 -0.1679 0.0530
43
5
4
0
0 -0.1823 0.0425
45
4
9
0
1 -0.1937 0.0638
42
3
3
1
0 -0.2167 0.0891
52
2
51
0
0 -0.2181 0.0411
38
2
1
1
0 -0.2260 0.0925
51
2
40
0
1 -0.2460 0.0446
48
1
20
203
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.3331 0.0747
63
99
98
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.2292 0.0451
62
99
98
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.2071 0.0415
60
97
96
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1790 0.0529
53
96
60
Midvale Elementary School
0
0 0.1719 0.0552
56
95
78
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.1629 0.0388
54
94
71
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 0.1531 0.0358
53
93
58
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.1471 0.0571
58
92
91
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1382 0.0496
61
90
98
Smoke Rise Elementary School
0
1 0.1284 0.0518
53
89
56
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1274 0.0558
58
89
89
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.1261 0.0413
58
88
89
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 0.1248 0.0419
60
88
95
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.1244 0.0384
62
88
98
Stone Mountain Elementary School
0
0 0.1175 0.0529
49
87
30
Huntley Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1080 0.0586
53
85
54
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo
0
0 0.0932 0.0371
52
83
49
Shadow Rock Elementary School
0
0 0.0925 0.0410
49
82
26
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.0851 0.0349
59
81
94
Sagamore Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0805 0.0545
52
79
50
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.0773 0.0616
54
78
71
Pine Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0731 0.0442
54
77
64
Livsey Elementary School
0
0 0.0663 0.0550
49
75
26
Snapfinger Elementary School
0
0 0.0627 0.0450
50
74
33
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0620 0.0484
53
73
56
204
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Henderson Mill Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Vanderlyn Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Fairington Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Avondale Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Columbia Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Allgood Elementary School International Community School Chesnut Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Toney Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Hambrick Elementary School
0
0 0.0607 0.0463
56
73
80
0
0 0.0558 0.0545
53
71
60
0
0 0.0482 0.0414
58
68
92
0
0 0.0462 0.0526
47
67
16
0
0 0.0439 0.0398
55
67
72
0
0 0.0356 0.0550
52
64
49
0
0 0.0328 0.0529
53
62
58
0
0 0.0320 0.0410
50
62
33
0
0 0.0309 0.0395
53
61
57
0
1 0.0258 0.0638
52
60
47
0
0 0.0233 0.0479
53
59
55
0
0 0.0216 0.0518
50
58
34
0
1 0.0214 0.0616
52
58
53
0
0 0.0199 0.0563
50
57
38
0
0 0.0178 0.0413
57
56
88
0
0 0.0144 0.0668
52
55
53
0
0 0.0090 0.0474
48
53
22
0
0 0.0085 0.0599
44
53
7
0
0 -0.0007 0.0592
48
50
22
0
0 -0.0011 0.0466
47
50
16
0
1 -0.0064 0.0560
49
48
23
0
1 -0.0090 0.0566
51
46
46
0
0 -0.0216 0.0422
48
41
21
0
0 -0.0217 0.0602
45
41
10
0
0 -0.0239 0.0394
45
40
10
0
0 -0.0278 0.0387
46
39
12
0
0 -0.0299 0.0494
50
38
35
0
0 -0.0305 0.0580
48
38
20
0
0 -0.0324 0.0500
49
37
25
0
0 -0.0342 0.0484
49
37
30
0
0 -0.0461 0.0469
47
32
17
205
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Panola Way Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Redan Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Oakview Elementary Stoneview Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Midway Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
0
0 -0.0464 0.0395
45
32
8
0
0 -0.0526 0.0386
53
30
58
0
0 -0.0530 0.0358
46
30
11
0
0 -0.0603 0.0348
45
28
9
0
0 -0.0693 0.0504
45
25
10
0
0 -0.0714 0.0348
46
24
11
0
1 -0.0792 0.0461
45
22
9
0
0 -0.0865 0.0429
49
20
27
0
0 -0.0890 0.0371
49
19
29
0
0 -0.0894 0.0569
50
19
35
0
0 -0.0919 0.0571
47
18
15
0
0 -0.0919 0.0712
47
18
17
0
0 -0.0994 0.0543
48
16
23
0
0 -0.1091 0.0701
47
15
16
0
0 -0.1150 0.0487
45
14
10
0
0 -0.1163 0.0422
41
13
2
0
0 -0.1181 0.0429
44
13
6
0
0 -0.1247 0.0356
41
11
2
0
0 -0.1390 0.0487
43
9
5
0
0 -0.1405 0.0514
46
8
13
0
0 -0.1417 0.0378
42
8
4
0
0 -0.1453 0.0533
43
7
4
0
0 -0.1612 0.0428
45
6
9
0
0 -0.1700 0.0529
45
5
8
1
0 -0.1947 0.0897
52
3
51
0
1 -0.1947 0.0642
42
3
3
0
0 -0.1977 0.0414
38
3
1
0
1 -0.2223 0.0448
48
2
20
1
0 -0.2432 0.0931
51
1
40
206
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
207
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.0732 0.0915
52
76
53
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.0542 0.0860
57
70
86
Early County Elementary School
0
0 0.0219 0.0333
55
57
77
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0110 0.0646
51
44
43
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1111 0.0543
48
15
22
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1488 0.0663
45
8
8
208
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.0914 0.0865
57
82
86
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.0586 0.0919
52
72
53
Early County Elementary School
0
0 -0.0039 0.0334
55
48
77
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0256 0.0650
51
39
43
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1463 0.0545
48
7
22
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1543 0.0667
45
7
8
209
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
210
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.1770 0.0475
57
97
97
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 0.1642 0.0698
57
95
97
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.1564 0.0611
57
94
97
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.1530 0.0542
57
94
97
The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele
0
0 0.1501 0.0639
48
93
57
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.1334 0.0600
53
91
87
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1172 0.0586
57
88
96
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.1171 0.0310
55
88
92
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1089 0.0331
53
87
88
Kindezi
0
1 0.1071 0.0880
52
86
80
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.0663 0.0445
53
76
84
Whitefoord Elementary School
0
0 0.0498 0.0748
44
70
24
Centennial Place Elementary School
0
0 0.0330 0.0484
48
64
56
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 0.0326 0.0506
48
64
59
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.0318 0.0418
54
64
89
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 0.0266 0.0479
48
61
53
Bolton Academy
0
0 0.0196 0.0454
49
57
60
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.0101 0.0446
48
52
55
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.0063 0.0361
54
50
90
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 0.0055 0.0529
53
49
84
Continental Colony Elementary School
0
0 0.0049 0.0597
50
49
70
Deerwood Academy School
0
0 0.0015 0.0451
49
48
62
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 -0.0066 0.0424
49
45
66
Kimberly Elementary School
0
0 -0.0258 0.0515
46
38
37
Smith Elementary School
0
0 -0.0276 0.0295
47
37
47
211
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Humphries Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Garden Hills Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Kipp Strive Academy Thomasville Heights Elementary School Charles R. Drew Charter School D. H. Stanton Elementary School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Hutchinson Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Beecher Hills Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Finch Elementary M. A. Jones Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Towns Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Grove Park Intermediate School Rivers Elementary School Connally Elementary School Slater Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Scott Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Boyd Elementary School Fain Elementary School KIPP VISION
0
0 -0.0286 0.0623
44
37
24
0
0 -0.0311 0.0492
46
35
42
0
0 -0.0324 0.0448
44
35
25
0
0 -0.0459 0.0611
46
30
40
0
1 -0.0523 0.0605
46
28
41
0
0 -0.0576 0.0619
55
27
92
0
1 -0.0609 0.0374
45
27
34
0
0 -0.0674 0.0778
40
24
9
0
1 -0.0737 0.0653
46
23
38
0
0 -0.0768 0.0573
52
23
80
0
0 -0.0776 0.0482
49
22
65
0
0 -0.0797 0.0590
40
21
9
0
0 -0.0809 0.0483
43
21
23
0
0 -0.0831 0.0657
47
20
44
0
0 -0.0931 0.0454
43
18
18
0
0 -0.1013 0.0482
40
16
9
0
0 -0.1063 0.0611
47
14
50
0
0 -0.1110 0.0454
47
13
45
0
0 -0.1120 0.0648
34
13
1
0
0 -0.1153 0.0428
46
12
38
0
0 -0.1173 0.0410
43
12
23
0
0 -0.1206 0.0434
44
11
29
0
0 -0.1213 0.0548
46
11
39
0
0 -0.1245 0.0467
43
11
20
0
0 -0.1388 0.0635
40
9
8
0
0 -0.1405 0.0468
44
8
27
0
0 -0.1415 0.0657
41
8
11
0
1 -0.1429 0.0794
47
8
46
0
0 -0.1658 0.0542
43
5
21
0
0 -0.1728 0.0527
40
4
8
0
1 -0.2460 0.0673
48
1
58
212
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.3137 0.0506
35
1
2
213
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.2085 0.0620
57
98
97
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.1960 0.0550
57
97
97
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 0.1717 0.0709
57
96
97
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.1657 0.0315
55
95
92
The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele
0
0 0.1390 0.0649
48
91
57
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1384 0.0336
53
91
88
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.1336 0.0609
53
91
87
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.1288 0.0482
57
90
97
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1279 0.0595
57
89
96
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.0879 0.0451
53
81
84
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.0639 0.0425
54
75
89
Whitefoord Elementary School
0
0 0.0610 0.0759
44
74
24
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 0.0541 0.0514
48
73
59
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.0539 0.0366
54
72
90
Kindezi
0
1 0.0500 0.0893
52
71
80
Centennial Place Elementary School
0
0 0.0497 0.0491
48
70
56
Bolton Academy
0
0 0.0412 0.0460
49
67
60
Continental Colony Elementary School
0
0 0.0347 0.0605
50
64
70
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 0.0343 0.0537
53
64
84
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.0301 0.0453
48
61
55
Deerwood Academy School
0
0 0.0138 0.0457
49
56
62
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 0.0117 0.0486
48
55
53
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.0023 0.0431
49
50
66
Smith Elementary School
0
0 -0.0002 0.0300
47
48
47
Toomer Elementary School
0
0 -0.0112 0.0620
46
43
40
214
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Humphries Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Kimberly Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Kipp Strive Academy KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad D. H. Stanton Elementary School Garden Hills Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Charles R. Drew Charter School Benteen Elementary School Beecher Hills Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Finch Elementary Miles Intermediate School Dunbar Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Rivers Elementary School Slater Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Scott Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Towns Elementary School Connally Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Perkerson Elementary School Boyd Elementary School Fain Elementary School KIPP VISION
0
0 -0.0201 0.0632
44
41
24
0
0 -0.0214 0.0628
55
40
92
0
0 -0.0274 0.0499
46
37
42
0
0 -0.0295 0.0523
46
36
37
0
0 -0.0350 0.0490
49
34
65
0
1 -0.0356 0.0613
46
34
41
0
1 -0.0428 0.0662
46
32
38
0
0 -0.0433 0.0789
40
31
9
0
0 -0.0515 0.0454
44
29
25
0
0 -0.0516 0.0582
52
29
80
0
1 -0.0592 0.0379
45
27
34
0
0 -0.0599 0.0667
47
26
44
0
0 -0.0608 0.0598
40
26
9
0
0 -0.0649 0.0461
47
25
45
0
0 -0.0665 0.0490
43
24
23
0
0 -0.0757 0.0460
43
21
18
0
0 -0.0807 0.0435
46
20
38
0
0 -0.0938 0.0620
47
18
50
0
0 -0.1011 0.0416
43
16
23
0
0 -0.1015 0.0440
44
16
29
0
0 -0.1030 0.0474
43
16
20
0
0 -0.1141 0.0490
40
13
9
0
0 -0.1154 0.0667
41
13
11
0
0 -0.1169 0.0644
40
12
8
0
0 -0.1219 0.0658
34
11
1
0
0 -0.1224 0.0555
46
11
39
0
1 -0.1236 0.0806
47
11
46
0
0 -0.1239 0.0475
44
11
27
0
0 -0.1438 0.0550
43
8
21
0
0 -0.1614 0.0535
40
6
8
0
1 -0.2149 0.0682
48
2
58
215
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.2983 0.0514
35
1
2
216
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
217
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.1876 0.0604
53
98
85
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.0410 0.0348
46
67
36
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 0.0378 0.0580
45
67
31
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.0367 0.0273
42
66
15
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.0242 0.0472
45
60
35
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.0162 0.0457
46
56
38
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 -0.0050 0.0334
44
45
26
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0056 0.0380
42
45
14
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0061 0.0325
46
45
42
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.0279 0.0367
46
37
38
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.0297 0.0289
43
36
19
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0676 0.0435
44
24
27
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0779 0.0291
45
22
31
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0877 0.0321
39
19
7
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 -0.1015 0.0278
41
16
12
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1023 0.0379
47
15
49
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.1036 0.0407
40
15
8
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.1098 0.0286
41
13
10
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.1124 0.0417
41
13
11
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.1156 0.0315
42
12
17
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1283 0.0465
37
10
4
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1393 0.0334
42
8
14
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.1606 0.0336
42
6
13
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1622 0.0451
39
6
7
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.1798 0.0472
36
4
2
218
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.1758 0.0613
53
96
85
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.0277 0.0276
42
61
15
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 0.0256 0.0588
45
60
31
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.0235 0.0353
46
59
36
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.0098 0.0479
45
53
35
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.0057 0.0464
46
51
38
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 0.0022 0.0339
44
49
26
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0005 0.0330
46
48
42
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.0169 0.0293
43
42
19
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0354 0.0385
42
34
14
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.0673 0.0372
46
24
38
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0715 0.0441
44
23
27
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0850 0.0295
45
19
31
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0946 0.0326
39
18
7
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 -0.0994 0.0282
41
17
12
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1011 0.0384
47
16
49
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.1068 0.0290
41
15
10
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.1105 0.0320
42
14
17
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.1115 0.0413
40
14
8
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.1125 0.0423
41
14
11
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1361 0.0472
37
9
4
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1520 0.0339
42
7
14
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.1739 0.0340
42
5
13
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1761 0.0457
39
5
7
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.1968 0.0479
36
3
2
219
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
220
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0532 0.0475
50
72
68
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 0.0358 0.0494
51
65
75
Brooks Elementary
0
0 0.0330 0.0390
47
64
47
Western Elementary School
0
0 0.0327 0.0490
49
64
62
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 0.0225 0.0451
48
59
58
Northside Elementary School
0
0 0.0202 0.0532
47
58
52
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 -0.0045 0.0496
44
45
28
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.0296 0.0368
41
36
12
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 -0.0314 0.0502
44
35
28
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 -0.0620 0.0387
44
26
27
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.0643 0.0364
39
25
6
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0785 0.0494
40
22
9
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0898 0.0423
46
19
37
Glanton Elementary
0
0 -0.1030 0.0556
47
15
44
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 -0.1070 0.0405
40
14
10
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.1406 0.0479
39
8
6
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.1443 0.0372
41
7
11
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.1572 0.0473
41
6
10
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 -0.1972 0.0475
37
2
3
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.2272 0.0484
40
2
10
221
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0581 0.0482
50
74
68
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 0.0520 0.0501
51
71
75
Western Elementary School
0
0 0.0512 0.0497
49
71
62
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 0.0320 0.0457
48
63
58
Brooks Elementary
0
0 0.0307 0.0396
47
62
47
Northside Elementary School
0
0 0.0090 0.0540
47
53
52
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 -0.0042 0.0503
44
46
28
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 -0.0288 0.0510
44
36
28
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 -0.0313 0.0393
44
36
27
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.0340 0.0373
41
35
12
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.0470 0.0369
39
30
6
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0554 0.0429
46
27
37
Glanton Elementary
0
0 -0.0796 0.0564
47
20
44
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 -0.0969 0.0410
40
17
10
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0996 0.0501
40
17
9
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.1151 0.0377
41
13
11
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.1429 0.0480
41
8
10
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.1587 0.0486
39
6
6
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.1668 0.0491
40
6
10
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 -0.1801 0.0482
37
4
3
222
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
223
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.1762 0.0374
63
97
99
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1730 0.0716
56
96
95
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.1728 0.0548
59
96
99
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1712 0.0513
54
96
90
Rainbow Elementary School
0
0 0.1347 0.0527
57
91
97
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1061 0.0534
47
86
51
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 0.1025 0.0343
49
85
66
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.1008 0.0371
52
85
81
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.1007 0.0398
55
84
94
Woodridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0847 0.0496
51
80
79
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.0808 0.0593
56
79
95
Brockett Elementary School
0
0 0.0786 0.0506
56
79
94
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0717 0.0463
53
77
86
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.0681 0.0434
54
76
92
Columbia Elementary School
0
0 0.0621 0.0454
47
75
50
Flat Shoals Elementary School
0
0 0.0603 0.0550
53
74
85
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.0564 0.0613
51
73
75
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.0554 0.0397
55
73
92
Pleasantdale Elementary School
0
0 0.0516 0.0412
48
71
53
Avondale Elementary School
0
0 0.0501 0.0539
51
71
77
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo
0
0 0.0501 0.0355
46
71
36
Fairington Elementary School
0
0 0.0475 0.0462
51
70
74
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.0458 0.0335
54
69
88
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 0.0456 0.0399
51
69
78
Midvale Elementary School
0
0 0.0421 0.0529
49
68
63
224
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Smoke Rise Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Oakview Elementary Leadership Preparatory Academy Stone Mountain Elementary School International Community School Huntley Hills Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Oak Grove Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Rock Chapel Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Snapfinger Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Princeton Elementary School
0
1 0.0359 0.0490
47
65
48
0
0 0.0353 0.0423
47
65
46
0
0 0.0338 0.0463
47
64
48
0
0 0.0302 0.0405
48
63
57
0
1 0.0279 0.0590
49
62
60
0
0 0.0255 0.0504
53
61
87
0
1 0.0238 0.0537
47
60
49
0
0 0.0232 0.0561
50
60
68
0
0 0.0218 0.0570
55
58
92
0
0 0.0211 0.0395
50
58
72
0
0 0.0196 0.0394
48
57
60
0
0 0.0182 0.0477
55
57
93
0
0 0.0158 0.0398
46
55
36
0
0 0.0147 0.0550
47
54
51
0
0 0.0093 0.0383
49
51
64
0
0 0.0068 0.0640
52
50
83
0
0 0.0038 0.0432
50
49
70
0
0 0.0021 0.0474
48
48
58
0
0 0.0006 0.0520
47
47
44
0
0 -0.0025 0.0393
53
46
87
0
0 -0.0088 0.0449
48
44
55
0
0 -0.0091 0.0408
44
44
24
0
0 -0.0117 0.0332
47
43
50
0
0 -0.0149 0.0502
48
42
52
0
0 -0.0158 0.0509
45
41
31
0
0 -0.0161 0.0369
45
41
32
0
0 -0.0247 0.0442
47
39
47
0
0 -0.0282 0.0369
51
37
76
0
0 -0.0289 0.0672
45
37
30
0
0 -0.0295 0.0378
46
36
41
0
0 -0.0323 0.0343
45
35
34
225
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Panola Way Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Livsey Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Toney Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Midway Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Redan Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Kingsley Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Ashford Park Elementary School
0
0 -0.0352 0.0380
45
34
34
0
0 -0.0389 0.0334
41
32
13
0
0 -0.0420 0.0445
43
31
20
0
0 -0.0451 0.0357
50
30
68
0
0 -0.0487 0.0577
42
29
16
0
0 -0.0491 0.0517
44
29
29
0
0 -0.0525 0.0527
47
28
44
0
0 -0.0610 0.0380
47
26
50
0
0 -0.0642 0.0467
43
25
21
0
0 -0.0687 0.0414
44
24
30
0
0 -0.0702 0.0548
45
24
31
0
0 -0.0760 0.0556
43
23
20
0
0 -0.0761 0.0362
46
23
35
0
0 -0.0792 0.0483
45
22
35
0
0 -0.0807 0.0410
48
21
59
0
0 -0.0822 0.0509
43
21
20
0
0 -0.0850 0.0343
41
20
10
0
0 -0.0887 0.0524
47
19
45
0
0 -0.0998 0.0682
48
17
55
0
0 -0.1035 0.0481
42
15
17
0
1 -0.1077 0.0539
46
14
43
0
1 -0.1135 0.0430
43
12
18
1
0 -0.1389 0.0892
46
9
42
0
0 -0.1481 0.0467
47
7
51
0
1 -0.1574 0.0442
39
6
6
0
0 -0.1590 0.0399
40
6
8
0
1 -0.1904 0.0619
38
3
4
1
0 -0.2613 0.0859
48
1
54
0
0 -0.2931 0.0494
38
1
5
226
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.2069 0.0555
59
98
99
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.1970 0.0375
63
98
99
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1710 0.0727
56
96
95
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1691 0.0521
54
96
90
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.1537 0.0404
55
94
94
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 0.1456 0.0348
49
93
66
Rainbow Elementary School
0
0 0.1396 0.0535
57
92
97
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.1290 0.0339
54
90
88
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1278 0.0542
47
89
51
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.1203 0.0440
54
88
92
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.1079 0.0376
52
86
81
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.1063 0.0402
55
85
92
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.1028 0.0470
53
84
86
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.0988 0.0602
56
83
95
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 0.0882 0.0405
51
81
78
Brockett Elementary School
0
0 0.0871 0.0514
56
81
94
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo
0
0 0.0859 0.0360
46
81
36
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.0823 0.0649
52
80
83
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.0786 0.0620
51
79
75
Columbia Elementary School
0
0 0.0776 0.0461
47
78
50
Woodridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0763 0.0503
51
78
79
Flat Shoals Elementary School
0
0 0.0732 0.0558
53
77
85
Midvale Elementary School
0
0 0.0641 0.0537
49
75
63
Meadowview Elementary School
0
0 0.0633 0.0579
55
75
92
Huntley Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0630 0.0570
50
75
68
227
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Oak Grove Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Smoke Rise Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Rock Chapel Elementary School Oakview Elementary International Community School Stone Mountain Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Snapfinger Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School
0
0 0.0601 0.0401
50
74
72
0
0 0.0573 0.0388
49
73
64
0
0 0.0564 0.0468
51
73
74
0
1 0.0547 0.0598
49
73
60
0
1 0.0521 0.0497
47
72
48
0
0 0.0516 0.0547
51
71
77
0
0 0.0414 0.0417
48
67
53
0
0 0.0389 0.0400
48
66
60
0
0 0.0379 0.0429
47
65
46
0
0 0.0371 0.0484
55
65
93
0
0 0.0335 0.0411
48
64
57
0
1 0.0332 0.0545
47
63
49
0
0 0.0327 0.0512
53
63
87
0
0 0.0277 0.0399
53
61
87
0
0 0.0272 0.0403
46
60
36
0
0 0.0256 0.0558
47
60
51
0
0 0.0244 0.0527
47
59
44
0
0 0.0240 0.0470
47
59
48
0
0 0.0197 0.0439
50
58
70
0
0 0.0097 0.0413
44
53
24
0
0 0.0016 0.0510
48
49
52
0
0 -0.0024 0.0375
45
47
32
0
0 -0.0030 0.0480
48
47
58
0
0 -0.0034 0.0337
47
47
50
0
0 -0.0089 0.0448
47
44
47
0
0 -0.0122 0.0456
48
43
55
0
0 -0.0161 0.0372
51
42
76
0
0 -0.0256 0.0385
45
38
34
0
0 -0.0266 0.0348
45
38
34
0
0 -0.0266 0.0339
41
38
13
0
0 -0.0284 0.0682
45
37
30
228
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Livsey Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Toney Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Midway Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the McLendon Elementary School Dresden Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Montclair Elementary School Redan Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Ashford Park Elementary School
0
0 -0.0295 0.0535
47
36
44
0
0 -0.0338 0.0516
45
35
31
0
0 -0.0365 0.0490
45
34
35
0
0 -0.0451 0.0585
42
31
16
0
0 -0.0456 0.0451
43
31
20
0
0 -0.0463 0.0383
46
30
41
0
0 -0.0488 0.0532
47
29
45
0
0 -0.0495 0.0361
50
29
68
0
0 -0.0506 0.0385
47
29
50
0
0 -0.0519 0.0416
48
28
59
0
0 -0.0546 0.0564
43
28
20
0
0 -0.0596 0.0420
44
26
30
0
0 -0.0657 0.0525
44
25
29
0
0 -0.0698 0.0516
43
23
20
0
0 -0.0723 0.0474
43
22
21
0
1 -0.0786 0.0547
46
21
43
0
0 -0.0787 0.0692
48
20
55
0
1 -0.0806 0.0436
43
20
18
0
0 -0.0850 0.0555
45
19
31
0
0 -0.0886 0.0365
46
19
35
0
0 -0.0889 0.0473
47
19
51
0
0 -0.0951 0.0346
41
18
10
0
0 -0.1093 0.0488
42
15
17
0
1 -0.1328 0.0448
39
9
6
0
0 -0.1405 0.0405
40
8
8
1
0 -0.1922 0.0905
46
4
42
0
1 -0.1943 0.0628
38
4
4
1
0 -0.2095 0.0871
48
2
54
0
0 -0.2798 0.0501
38
1
5
229
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
230
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.1271 0.0882
50
90
70
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 0.0603 0.0644
43
74
23
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.0316 0.0829
44
63
26
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.0094 0.0627
49
51
63
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.0208 0.0523
46
40
39
Early County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1096 0.0322
39
14
6
231
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.0940 0.0894
50
82
70
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.0666 0.0841
44
76
26
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 0.0514 0.0653
43
71
23
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0182 0.0636
49
41
63
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.0726 0.0530
46
22
39
Early County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1385 0.0326
39
8
6
232
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Atlanta Heights
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Atlanta Heights
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
233
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.2690 0.0622
61
94
95
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.2684 0.0618
65
94
98
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.2221 0.0448
65
90
98
Rivers Elementary School
0
0 0.1883 0.0440
58
87
90
The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele
0
0 0.1764 0.0647
56
86
86
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1401 0.0603
55
80
82
Kindezi
0
1 0.1259 0.0891
54
77
80
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.1068 0.0423
57
73
87
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 0.1033 0.0512
52
72
73
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.0919 0.0481
53
70
76
Humphries Elementary School
0
0 0.0893 0.0630
48
69
54
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.0729 0.0335
54
66
79
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 0.0639 0.0536
54
63
78
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.0496 0.0548
55
60
83
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.0436 0.0314
51
59
65
Smith Elementary School
0
0 0.0048 0.0301
51
51
66
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.0037 0.0619
52
50
72
Gideons Elementary School
0
0 -0.0055 0.0459
52
48
73
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0132 0.0461
48
47
55
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 -0.0202 0.0712
51
45
67
Kimberly Elementary School
0
0 -0.0246 0.0521
50
44
61
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 -0.0317 0.0429
52
42
71
Deerwood Academy School
0
0 -0.0372 0.0459
52
41
71
Fickett Elementary School
0
0 -0.0373 0.0486
46
41
46
Bolton Academy
0
0 -0.0524 0.0461
51
38
66
234
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Beecher Hills Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Morningside Elementary School Charles R. Drew Charter School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Boyd Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Dobbs Elementary School Connally Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Fain Elementary School KIPP VISION Slater Elementary School Towns Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Springdale Park Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Whitefoord Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Finch Elementary Perkerson Elementary School Centennial Place Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Scott Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.0527 0.0596
51
38
68
0
0 -0.0535 0.0660
45
37
41
0
0 -0.0621 0.0365
51
36
65
0
1 -0.0774 0.0378
44
32
37
0
1 -0.0831 0.0661
44
31
35
0
0 -0.0968 0.0554
44
29
36
0
0 -0.1001 0.0494
44
28
35
0
0 -0.1127 0.0433
46
25
44
0
0 -0.1218 0.0488
42
24
29
0
0 -0.1462 0.0551
37
20
15
0
0 -0.1571 0.0622
32
19
5
0
0 -0.1598 0.0614
44
18
36
0
0 -0.1726 0.0496
38
16
16
0
0 -0.1730 0.0533
35
16
11
0
1 -0.1750 0.0685
47
16
50
0
0 -0.1857 0.0474
35
14
10
0
0 -0.1937 0.0670
38
13
16
1
0 -0.2015 0.0484
38
12
16
0
0 -0.2053 0.0450
37
12
15
0
0 -0.2090 0.0415
31
12
4
0
0 -0.2122 0.0764
39
11
20
0
0 -0.2123 0.0630
37
11
15
0
0 -0.2126 0.0580
37
11
14
0
0 -0.2291 0.0459
34
9
8
0
0 -0.2409 0.0474
35
8
11
0
0 -0.3007 0.0490
38
5
17
0
0 -0.3035 0.0638
32
5
6
0
1 -0.3110 0.0795
40
4
23
0
0 -0.3442 0.0670
28
3
2
0
0 -0.3837 0.0787
21
2
1
0
0 -0.3999 0.0512
31
2
4
235
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Continental Colony Elementary School
0
0 -0.4612 0.0603
19
1
1
236
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.2986 0.0628
65
96
98
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.2522 0.0456
65
93
98
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.2474 0.0632
61
93
95
Rivers Elementary School
0
0 0.2247 0.0447
58
91
90
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.1670 0.0430
57
85
87
The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele
0
0 0.1655 0.0657
56
84
86
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1446 0.0613
55
81
82
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.1176 0.0557
55
76
83
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 0.1159 0.0521
52
76
73
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1121 0.0340
54
75
79
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.1061 0.0319
51
74
65
Humphries Elementary School
0
0 0.0910 0.0640
48
70
54
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 0.0705 0.0544
54
65
78
Smith Elementary School
0
0 0.0667 0.0306
51
64
66
Kindezi
0
1 0.0642 0.0905
54
64
80
Gideons Elementary School
0
0 0.0352 0.0467
52
58
73
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.0265 0.0489
53
56
76
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.0112 0.0628
52
53
72
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.0110 0.0370
51
53
65
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0072 0.0468
48
52
55
Fickett Elementary School
0
0 -0.0010 0.0494
46
49
46
Bolton Academy
0
0 -0.0066 0.0468
51
48
66
Benteen Elementary School
0
0 -0.0067 0.0671
45
48
41
Deerwood Academy School
0
0 -0.0245 0.0466
52
44
71
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 -0.0247 0.0724
51
44
67
237
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Beecher Hills Elementary School Kimberly Elementary School Imagine Wesley International Academy KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Miles Intermediate School Charles R. Drew Charter School Boyd Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Connally Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Slater Elementary School KIPP VISION Springdale Park Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Fain Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Towns Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Finch Elementary Centennial Place Elementary School Intown Charter Academy F. L. Stanton Elementary School Scott Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.0257 0.0606
51
44
68
0
0 -0.0275 0.0530
50
43
61
0
1 -0.0432 0.0436
52
40
71
0
1 -0.0569 0.0671
44
37
35
0
0 -0.0747 0.0440
46
34
44
0
1 -0.0926 0.0384
44
30
37
0
0 -0.0966 0.0563
44
29
36
0
0 -0.1044 0.0496
42
27
29
0
0 -0.1321 0.0502
44
22
35
0
0 -0.1431 0.0624
44
20
36
0
0 -0.1477 0.0560
37
19
15
0
0 -0.1507 0.0632
32
19
5
0
0 -0.1559 0.0504
38
18
16
0
0 -0.1662 0.0481
35
16
10
0
1 -0.1702 0.0696
47
16
50
0
0 -0.1704 0.0457
37
16
15
0
0 -0.1784 0.0589
37
15
14
0
0 -0.1798 0.0542
35
15
11
0
0 -0.1850 0.0640
37
14
15
0
0 -0.1937 0.0776
39
12
20
0
0 -0.1966 0.0422
31
12
4
0
0 -0.2039 0.0681
38
11
16
0
0 -0.2297 0.0481
35
9
11
1
0 -0.2299 0.0492
38
8
16
0
0 -0.2391 0.0466
34
7
8
0
0 -0.2664 0.0498
38
6
17
0
1 -0.2855 0.0808
40
5
23
0
0 -0.2970 0.0649
32
4
6
0
0 -0.3608 0.0681
28
2
2
0
0 -0.3712 0.0799
21
2
1
0
0 -0.4002 0.0521
31
2
4
238
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Continental Colony Elementary School
0
0 -0.4240 0.0613
19
1
1
239
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Cherokee
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Cherokee
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
240
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.2875 0.0464
60
95
93
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.1265 0.0354
54
77
77
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 0.1163 0.0586
50
75
62
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.1120 0.0618
58
74
90
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.1116 0.0278
53
74
74
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 0.0958 0.0281
51
71
65
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.0914 0.0479
58
70
90
Avery Elementary School
0
0 0.0667 0.0289
50
64
60
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 0.0320 0.0443
50
56
61
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.0308 0.0338
51
56
67
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 0.0268 0.0328
45
55
42
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 0.0240 0.0338
52
54
73
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.0166 0.0292
51
46
68
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.0188 0.0321
46
46
46
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0211 0.0383
51
45
67
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0500 0.0422
45
38
40
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.0503 0.0372
45
38
43
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0720 0.0456
48
33
54
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0862 0.0294
45
30
41
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.1065 0.0412
48
27
52
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.1174 0.0328
45
25
41
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1533 0.0384
48
19
53
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1863 0.0338
45
14
41
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.3183 0.0477
27
4
2
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.4183 0.0470
31
1
4
241
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.3043 0.0471
60
96
93
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.1106 0.0359
54
74
77
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 0.1084 0.0596
50
74
62
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.1079 0.0282
53
74
74
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.0987 0.0628
58
72
90
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 0.0979 0.0286
51
72
65
Avery Elementary School
0
0 0.0795 0.0293
50
67
60
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.0695 0.0487
58
65
90
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 0.0387 0.0343
52
58
73
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 0.0378 0.0450
50
58
61
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 0.0349 0.0333
45
58
42
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.0180 0.0344
51
54
67
Little River Elem.
0
0 0.0116 0.0297
51
53
68
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.0059 0.0326
46
49
46
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0203 0.0388
51
45
67
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0459 0.0429
45
39
40
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0813 0.0299
45
32
41
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0835 0.0463
48
32
54
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.1032 0.0418
48
28
52
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.1037 0.0333
45
28
41
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.1123 0.0378
45
26
43
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1551 0.0390
48
18
53
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1926 0.0343
45
13
41
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.3103 0.0485
27
4
2
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.4214 0.0478
31
1
4
242
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
243
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 0.4427 0.0502
70
99
99
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 0.1424 0.0508
55
80
82
Brooks Elementary
0
0 0.1160 0.0395
50
75
63
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 0.1033 0.0428
57
72
87
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 0.1017 0.0506
52
72
69
Northside Elementary School
0
0 0.0844 0.0540
47
68
49
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 0.0685 0.0413
52
65
73
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0423 0.0481
50
59
64
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 0.0169 0.0456
46
53
46
Glanton Elementary
0
0 -0.0020 0.0562
48
49
52
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.0443 0.0482
41
39
28
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0543 0.0479
41
37
25
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.0717 0.0376
43
33
34
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.1097 0.0490
47
26
48
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.1151 0.0372
45
25
41
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.1307 0.0500
39
23
21
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 -0.1489 0.0479
37
20
14
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.1787 0.0372
37
15
13
Western Elementary School
0
0 -0.2312 0.0500
39
9
21
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 -0.2595 0.0394
36
7
12
244
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 0.4629 0.0510
70
99
99
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 0.1376 0.0516
55
79
82
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 0.1367 0.0435
57
79
87
Brooks Elementary
0
0 0.1159 0.0401
50
76
63
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 0.1025 0.0514
52
73
69
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 0.0858 0.0419
52
69
73
Northside Elementary School
0
0 0.0689 0.0549
47
65
49
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0304 0.0488
50
57
64
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 0.0250 0.0463
46
56
46
Glanton Elementary
0
0 0.0134 0.0571
48
53
52
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.0375 0.0382
43
41
34
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0460 0.0487
41
39
25
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0622 0.0498
47
36
48
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.0771 0.0490
41
33
28
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.0801 0.0378
45
33
41
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.1363 0.0508
39
21
21
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 -0.1439 0.0487
37
20
14
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.1936 0.0378
37
12
13
Western Elementary School
0
0 -0.2107 0.0508
39
11
21
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 -0.2208 0.0400
36
10
12
245
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
246
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
Indian Creek Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Stone Mill Elementary School Rockbridge Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Austin Elementary School Rock Chapel Elementary School Marbut Elementary School Columbia Elementary School Vanderlyn Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Snapfinger Elementary School Briar Vista Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Wynbrooke Elementary School Kittredge Magnet School Woodridge Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Fernbank Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Briarlake Elementary School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.6166 0.4382 0.4087 0.2856 0.2407 0.1809 0.1369 0.1290 0.1173 0.1084 0.0995 0.0973 0.0862 0.0804 0.0746 0.0718 0.0646 0.0531 0.0477 0.0387 0.0371 0.0317 0.0273 0.0167
School Effect Standard Error
0.0350 0.0675 0.0620 0.0517 0.0515 0.0731 0.0440 0.0483 0.0375 0.0462 0.0401 0.0557 0.0626 0.0437 0.0604 0.0366 0.0347 0.0339 0.0500 0.0421 0.0407 0.0583 0.0514 0.0554
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
77
99
99
68
99
99
59
98
92
65
95
98
64
92
98
64
86
97
56
79
86
57
78
88
56
75
85
56
73
84
54
72
78
54
71
78
55
69
83
50
67
62
62
66
96
48
65
55
58
64
91
59
61
91
55
60
81
51
58
68
58
58
90
51
56
66
49
55
56
53
53
74
247
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Robert Shaw Theme School Montgomery Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Avondale Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Laurel Ridge Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School International Community School Leadership Preparatory Academy Panola Way Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Cedar Grove Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Livsey Elementary School
0
0 0.0125 0.0467
54
52
80
0
0 0.0004 0.0405
51
50
65
0
0 -0.0130 0.0372
48
47
55
0
0 -0.0239 0.0540
48
44
53
0
0 -0.0298 0.0472
51
43
67
0
0 -0.0526 0.0543
54
38
79
0
0 -0.0566 0.0544
45
37
39
0
1 -0.0610 0.0548
52
36
70
0
0 -0.0678 0.0695
45
35
41
0
1 -0.0686 0.0496
47
34
48
0
0 -0.0687 0.0577
48
34
52
0
0 -0.0688 0.0512
44
34
35
0
0 -0.0720 0.0536
44
33
35
0
0 -0.0825 0.0471
45
31
38
0
0 -0.0866 0.0474
46
30
45
0
0 -0.0869 0.0377
46
30
43
0
1 -0.0932 0.0531
45
29
40
0
1 -0.1051 0.0596
49
27
59
0
0 -0.1085 0.0385
41
26
28
0
0 -0.1098 0.0565
49
26
56
0
0 -0.1116 0.0427
43
26
31
0
0 -0.1171 0.0338
41
25
27
0
0 -0.1183 0.0397
41
25
24
0
0 -0.1227 0.0447
46
24
44
0
0 -0.1359 0.0347
41
22
28
0
0 -0.1372 0.0361
42
22
28
0
0 -0.1464 0.0469
42
20
30
0
0 -0.1555 0.0421
41
19
27
0
0 -0.1580 0.0398
45
18
39
0
0 -0.1667 0.0372
39
17
21
0
0 -0.1681 0.0536
47
17
50
248
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Chapel Hill Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Toney Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Redan Elementary School Midway Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Montclair Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Oak Grove Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Oakview Elementary Jolly Elementary School Midvale Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Hambrick Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Clifton Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
0 -0.1831 0.0484
37
15
15
0
0 -0.1831 0.0338
43
15
32
0
0 -0.1861 0.0562
36
14
13
0
0 -0.1867 0.0526
34
14
8
0
0 -0.1921 0.0533
44
14
35
0
0 -0.1931 0.0415
38
14
17
0
0 -0.2117 0.0500
36
11
13
0
0 -0.2142 0.0385
36
11
13
0
0 -0.2172 0.0379
34
10
9
0
0 -0.2259 0.0359
39
9
20
0
0 -0.2263 0.0490
35
9
10
0
0 -0.2358 0.0519
34
8
8
0
0 -0.2364 0.0454
36
8
13
1
0 -0.2404 0.0869
36
8
13
0
0 -0.2405 0.0346
33
8
7
0
0 -0.2415 0.0422
34
8
9
0
1 -0.2699 0.0448
37
6
14
0
0 -0.2767 0.0486
37
6
13
0
0 -0.2861 0.0403
38
5
17
0
0 -0.2946 0.0510
30
5
3
0
0 -0.2975 0.0528
36
5
13
0
0 -0.3052 0.0409
31
4
3
0
0 -0.3070 0.0383
30
4
3
0
0 -0.3238 0.0538
36
3
12
0
0 -0.3547 0.0647
51
3
67
0
0 -0.3806 0.0403
28
2
2
0
0 -0.4080 0.0454
25
1
1
1
0 -0.4610 0.0891
42
1
30
0
0 -0.4613 0.0580
26
1
1
0
1 -0.7245 0.0435
32
1
6
249
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.7340 0.0350
77
99
99
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.4877 0.0628
59
99
92
Kelley Lake Elementary School
0
0 0.4243 0.0686
68
99
99
Stone Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.2751 0.0525
65
94
98
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.2693 0.0523
64
94
98
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.2161 0.0447
56
90
86
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.1869 0.0407
54
86
78
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.1862 0.0344
59
86
91
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1782 0.0742
64
86
97
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1508 0.0490
57
82
88
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.1359 0.0414
58
79
90
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 0.1353 0.0352
58
79
91
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.1257 0.0381
56
78
85
Columbia Elementary School
0
0 0.1197 0.0470
56
77
84
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.1196 0.0613
62
77
96
Dresden Elementary School
0
0 0.1166 0.0370
48
76
55
Flat Shoals Elementary School
0
0 0.1117 0.0566
54
74
78
Snapfinger Elementary School
0
0 0.0907 0.0444
50
70
62
DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter
0
1 0.0838 0.0636
55
69
83
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.0797 0.0563
53
68
74
Pleasantdale Elementary School
0
0 0.0749 0.0427
51
66
68
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 0.0665 0.0412
51
64
65
Brockett Elementary School
0
0 0.0573 0.0523
49
62
56
250
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Robert Shaw Theme School Woodridge Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Laurel Ridge Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School International Community School Avondale Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Cary Reynolds Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Livsey Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0439 0.0475
54
59
80
0
0 0.0437 0.0508
55
59
81
0
0 0.0339 0.0377
48
57
55
0
0 0.0218 0.0593
51
55
66
0
0 0.0093 0.0480
51
52
67
0
0 0.0052 0.0552
54
51
79
0
1 -0.0026 0.0557
52
49
70
0
1 -0.0236 0.0504
47
45
48
0
0 -0.0312 0.0574
49
43
56
0
0 -0.0391 0.0552
45
41
39
0
0 -0.0403 0.0586
48
40
52
0
1 -0.0404 0.0539
45
40
40
0
0 -0.0415 0.0549
48
40
53
0
0 -0.0479 0.0707
45
38
41
0
0 -0.0494 0.0544
44
38
35
0
0 -0.0496 0.0454
46
38
44
0
0 -0.0649 0.0383
46
35
43
0
0 -0.0653 0.0521
44
35
35
0
1 -0.0736 0.0606
49
34
59
0
0 -0.0810 0.0365
42
32
28
0
0 -0.0830 0.0404
45
32
39
0
0 -0.0836 0.0544
47
32
50
0
0 -0.0873 0.0481
46
31
45
0
0 -0.0928 0.0376
39
30
21
0
0 -0.0952 0.0434
43
30
31
0
0 -0.0964 0.0478
45
29
38
0
0 -0.1055 0.0403
41
27
24
0
0 -0.1060 0.0391
41
27
28
0
0 -0.1104 0.0542
44
26
35
0
0 -0.1146 0.0344
41
25
27
0
0 -0.1160 0.0476
42
25
30
251
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Princeton Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Oakcliff Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Toney Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Oak Grove Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Midway Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Redan Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Rowland Elementary School Midvale Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Oakview Elementary Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Hambrick Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
0 -0.1349 0.0353
41
21
28
0
0 -0.1465 0.0391
36
19
13
0
0 -0.1554 0.0492
37
18
15
0
0 -0.1585 0.0428
41
18
27
0
0 -0.1592 0.0365
39
17
20
0
0 -0.1648 0.0427
34
17
9
0
0 -0.1664 0.0343
43
16
32
0
0 -0.1677 0.0571
36
16
13
0
0 -0.1723 0.0422
38
16
17
0
0 -0.1783 0.0384
34
15
9
0
0 -0.1884 0.0350
33
13
7
0
0 -0.1888 0.0508
36
13
13
0
0 -0.2005 0.0534
34
12
8
0
1 -0.2016 0.0456
37
11
14
0
0 -0.2209 0.0409
38
10
17
0
0 -0.2222 0.0462
36
10
13
0
0 -0.2284 0.0527
34
9
8
0
0 -0.2359 0.0657
51
8
67
0
0 -0.2362 0.0498
35
8
10
0
0 -0.2412 0.0388
30
7
3
0
0 -0.2461 0.0537
36
7
13
1
0 -0.2691 0.0883
36
6
13
0
0 -0.2828 0.0494
37
5
13
0
0 -0.2845 0.0547
36
5
12
0
0 -0.2852 0.0518
30
5
3
0
0 -0.2960 0.0416
31
4
3
0
0 -0.3606 0.0409
28
2
2
0
0 -0.3854 0.0462
25
2
1
0
0 -0.4269 0.0589
26
1
1
1
0 -0.4547 0.0905
42
1
30
0
1 -0.6669 0.0442
32
1
6
252
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
253
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.2712 0.0892
66
94
99
Early County Elementary School
0
0 0.0425 0.0326
45
59
41
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.0027 0.0634
42
50
28
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1617 0.0527
33
18
7
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.2104 0.0839
34
11
8
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.3170 0.0651
21
4
1
254
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.2169 0.0905
66
90
99
Early County Elementary School
0
0 0.0072 0.0330
45
52
41
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0326 0.0644
42
42
28
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1906 0.0852
34
13
8
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.2257 0.0534
33
9
7
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.3503 0.0662
21
3
1
255
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
256
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.5104 0.0645
58
99
84
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.2599 0.0351
62
95
93
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.2087 0.0558
67
91
98
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 0.1993 0.0659
62
90
94
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1600 0.0318
54
86
68
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.1297 0.0581
60
81
91
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.1260 0.0430
52
81
55
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 0.0966 0.0364
48
74
34
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.0770 0.0631
60
71
90
Centennial Place Elementary School
0
0 0.0681 0.0466
57
68
78
Kindezi
0
1 0.0295 0.0816
52
57
59
Dunbar Elementary School
0
0 0.0270 0.0588
57
56
80
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.0121 0.0301
50
52
46
Fain Elementary School
0
0 0.0096 0.0506
55
51
71
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.0049 0.0406
46
50
21
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 -0.0109 0.0451
47
46
27
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 -0.0124 0.0487
58
45
83
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0259 0.0425
51
42
51
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 -0.0275 0.0525
49
42
38
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0377 0.0587
55
39
74
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 -0.0388 0.0577
55
39
73
Rivers Elementary School
0
0 -0.0477 0.0419
49
36
39
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 -0.0704 0.0510
51
31
47
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0943 0.0422
47
26
27
257
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bolton Academy Deerwood Academy School Smith Elementary School Imagine Wesley International Academy Humphries Elementary School Finch Elementary Beecher Hills Elementary School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Atlanta Heights Charter School Miles Intermediate School Kimberly Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Boyd Elementary School Slater Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Scott Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Towns Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Connally Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Peyton Forest Elementary School
0
0 -0.1061 0.0439
48
23
31
0
0 -0.1226 0.0433
49
21
40
0
0 -0.1269 0.0285
47
20
26
0
1 -0.1287 0.0411
47
19
30
0
0 -0.1296 0.0567
55
19
71
0
0 -0.1465 0.0430
48
16
34
0
0 -0.1467 0.0570
53
16
64
0
0 -0.1509 0.0614
46
16
23
1
0 -0.1563 0.0462
48
15
33
0
0 -0.1588 0.0406
48
15
35
0
0 -0.1709 0.0483
47
13
31
0
0 -0.1966 0.0595
45
11
20
0
0 -0.2178 0.0635
46
9
21
0
0 -0.2488 0.0564
40
6
7
0
0 -0.2535 0.0461
41
6
8
0
0 -0.2565 0.0520
40
6
6
0
0 -0.2578 0.0443
43
6
11
0
0 -0.2580 0.0555
42
6
11
0
0 -0.2595 0.0459
43
5
13
0
0 -0.2636 0.0567
40
5
6
0
0 -0.2683 0.0456
42
5
10
0
0 -0.2805 0.0570
43
4
14
0
0 -0.2977 0.0703
36
4
2
0
0 -0.3146 0.0446
38
3
4
0
0 -0.3189 0.0631
36
3
2
0
0 -0.3247 0.0436
40
3
6
0
0 -0.3306 0.0610
43
2
12
0
1 -0.3326 0.0749
41
2
9
0
0 -0.3588 0.0511
38
2
3
0
0 -0.3703 0.0394
37
1
2
0
0 -0.3758 0.0468
35
1
2
258
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.4114 0.0757
37
1
3
0
0 -0.4416 0.0487
33
1
1
259
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.5135 0.0650
58
99
84
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.2998 0.0353
62
96
93
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.2052 0.0563
67
91
98
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 0.1895 0.0664
62
89
94
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.1840 0.0321
54
88
68
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.1497 0.0434
52
84
55
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.1368 0.0585
60
81
91
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.1068 0.0636
60
77
90
Centennial Place Elementary School
0
0 0.0860 0.0470
57
73
78
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 0.0818 0.0366
48
72
34
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.0557 0.0409
46
65
21
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.0468 0.0304
50
63
46
Dunbar Elementary School
0
0 0.0228 0.0592
57
55
80
Fain Elementary School
0
0 0.0030 0.0510
55
50
71
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.0009 0.0529
49
50
38
Kindezi
0
1 -0.0025 0.0823
52
49
59
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 -0.0122 0.0491
58
46
83
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 -0.0281 0.0455
47
42
27
Rivers Elementary School
0
0 -0.0311 0.0423
49
41
39
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0320 0.0592
55
41
74
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0336 0.0428
51
40
51
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 -0.0609 0.0582
55
33
73
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 -0.0673 0.0515
51
32
47
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 -0.0838 0.0425
47
28
27
Smith Elementary School
0
0 -0.0909 0.0288
47
26
26
260
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bolton Academy Deerwood Academy School Beecher Hills Elementary School Humphries Elementary School Imagine Wesley International Academy Miles Intermediate School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Finch Elementary Atlanta Heights Charter School Kimberly Elementary School Benteen Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Slater Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School Boyd Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Scott Elementary School Towns Elementary School Connally Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Peyton Forest Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0961 0.0442
48
25
31
0
0 -0.1072 0.0436
49
23
40
0
0 -0.1212 0.0575
53
21
64
0
0 -0.1265 0.0572
55
20
71
0
1 -0.1364 0.0414
47
18
30
0
0 -0.1394 0.0409
48
17
35
0
0 -0.1485 0.0619
46
16
23
0
0 -0.1617 0.0434
48
14
34
1
0 -0.1705 0.0466
48
13
33
0
0 -0.1728 0.0487
47
12
31
0
0 -0.1958 0.0640
46
10
21
0
0 -0.2033 0.0600
45
9
20
0
0 -0.2391 0.0464
41
7
8
0
0 -0.2452 0.0569
40
7
7
0
0 -0.2456 0.0560
42
7
11
0
0 -0.2457 0.0447
43
7
11
0
0 -0.2498 0.0459
42
6
10
0
0 -0.2575 0.0572
40
6
6
0
0 -0.2580 0.0575
43
6
14
0
0 -0.2582 0.0524
40
6
6
0
0 -0.2837 0.0463
43
4
13
0
0 -0.2869 0.0708
36
4
2
0
0 -0.2983 0.0439
40
4
6
0
0 -0.3123 0.0450
38
3
4
0
1 -0.3168 0.0756
41
3
9
0
0 -0.3424 0.0636
36
2
2
0
0 -0.3465 0.0615
43
2
12
0
0 -0.3582 0.0515
38
2
3
0
0 -0.3593 0.0397
37
2
2
0
0 -0.3602 0.0472
35
2
2
0
0 -0.4154 0.0763
37
1
3
261
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bethune Elementary School
0
0 -0.4370 0.0491
33
1
1
262
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
263
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.2556 0.0309
60
95
90
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1595 0.0440
52
85
58
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.1082 0.0336
55
77
72
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.0972 0.0353
52
74
56
Canton Elementary
0
0 0.0535 0.0355
54
64
67
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.0402 0.0322
47
61
28
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.0326 0.0302
50
58
45
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 0.0230 0.0268
49
55
36
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 0.0067 0.0319
49
50
41
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 -0.0034 0.0262
50
47
46
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 -0.0167 0.0558
46
44
25
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0260 0.0580
49
42
37
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0339 0.0417
47
40
31
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0352 0.0310
49
40
39
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0452 0.0275
49
37
39
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.0692 0.0448
40
31
6
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0700 0.0277
49
31
40
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0964 0.0398
45
26
18
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1218 0.0364
47
21
27
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1296 0.0321
44
19
15
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.1507 0.0387
41
16
9
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.2422 0.0446
41
7
9
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.2441 0.0451
44
7
16
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.2685 0.0429
39
5
5
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.3360 0.0276
34
2
1
264
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.2740 0.0311
60
95
90
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1857 0.0444
52
88
58
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.1172 0.0339
55
79
72
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.0727 0.0356
52
70
56
Canton Elementary
0
0 0.0446 0.0358
54
62
67
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.0386 0.0324
47
60
28
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 0.0374 0.0270
49
59
36
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.0368 0.0304
50
59
45
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 0.0275 0.0322
49
56
41
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 0.0063 0.0264
50
51
46
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 -0.0049 0.0563
46
48
25
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0205 0.0585
49
44
37
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0220 0.0313
49
43
39
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0245 0.0420
47
42
31
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0248 0.0277
49
42
39
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.0545 0.0451
40
35
6
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.0573 0.0280
49
34
40
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.0850 0.0401
45
27
18
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1087 0.0366
47
23
27
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.1238 0.0324
44
20
15
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.1495 0.0390
41
16
9
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.2378 0.0450
41
7
9
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.2480 0.0455
44
6
16
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.2613 0.0432
39
5
5
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.3101 0.0278
34
3
1
265
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
266
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
Atkinson Elementary School White Oak Elementary School Poplar Road Elementary School Arnco-Sargent Elementary School Arbor Springs Elementary Coweta Charter Academy Brooks Elementary Glanton Elementary Northside Elementary School Jefferson Parkway Elementary School Thomas Crossroads Elementary School Newnan Crossing Elementary School Willis Road Elementary Canongate Elementary School Western Elementary School Elm Street Elementary School Moreland Elementary School Ruth Hill Elementary School Welch Elementary School Eastside Elementary School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.1874 0.1395 0.1119 0.1057 0.1023 0.0989 0.0497 0.0406 0.0307 0.0121 0.0114 0.0111 0.0066 0.0060 0.0018 -0.0222 -0.0337 -0.1517 -0.1563 -0.2412
School Effect Standard Error
0.0473 0.0375 0.0411 0.0477 0.0436 0.0461 0.0381 0.0541 0.0515 0.0454 0.0461 0.0348 0.0362 0.0394 0.0469 0.0483 0.0461 0.0466 0.0352 0.0462
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
62
89
93
59
83
88
53
78
66
57
76
81
52
75
58
50
74
47
52
63
57
55
61
72
54
57
70
49
52
40
49
52
39
51
51
50
54
50
66
47
50
27
47
48
27
48
43
32
48
40
33
41
15
7
42
15
10
37
7
3
267
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 0.1952 0.0477
62
89
93
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 0.1679 0.0378
59
86
88
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 0.1376 0.0414
53
82
66
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 0.1133 0.0439
52
78
58
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.1073 0.0464
50
77
47
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 0.1063 0.0481
57
77
81
Brooks Elementary
0
0 0.0646 0.0384
52
68
57
Glanton Elementary
0
0 0.0505 0.0545
55
64
72
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 0.0395 0.0351
51
60
50
Northside Elementary School
0
0 0.0344 0.0519
54
58
70
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 0.0328 0.0365
54
58
66
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 0.0306 0.0397
47
57
27
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 0.0304 0.0464
49
57
39
Western Elementary School
0
0 0.0106 0.0473
47
52
27
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.0109 0.0458
49
47
40
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 -0.0258 0.0487
48
42
32
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0271 0.0464
48
42
33
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.1537 0.0470
41
15
7
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.1588 0.0355
42
14
10
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.2164 0.0466
37
9
3
268
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
269
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.4208 0.0417
65
99
98
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.3028 0.0334
69
97
99
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.2700 0.0597
64
96
96
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.2535 0.0327
55
95
73
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.2032 0.0388
57
90
79
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1598 0.0464
63
86
96
Pleasantdale Elementary School
0
0 0.1401 0.0396
62
83
94
Hawthorne Elementary School
0
0 0.1259 0.0495
58
81
81
Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School
0
0 0.0982 0.0483
60
74
89
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.0641 0.0387
55
67
72
Cary Reynolds Elementary School
0
0 0.0572 0.0343
56
66
77
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.0431 0.0555
57
62
79
Livsey Elementary School
0
0 0.0431 0.0510
50
62
45
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0391 0.0504
53
61
64
Midvale Elementary School
0
0 0.0386 0.0506
52
60
57
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0224 0.0381
47
55
29
Brockett Elementary School
0
0 0.0158 0.0493
53
54
62
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0040 0.0489
58
49
82
Henderson Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0001 0.0422
53
48
65
Avondale Elementary School
0
0 -0.0330 0.0510
51
40
53
Kelley Lake Elementary School
0
0 -0.0427 0.0640
60
37
91
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.0489 0.0433
54
36
67
Dunwoody Elementary School
0
0 -0.0507 0.0372
47
35
30
Evansdale Elementary School
0
0 -0.0533 0.0382
51
35
50
Chapel Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0555 0.0456
51
34
53
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 -0.0594 0.0330
53
33
61
Princeton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0634 0.0326
46
33
25
270
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Canby Lane Elementary School International Community School Museum School Avondale Estates Sagamore Hills Elementary School Marbut Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Snapfinger Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Midway Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Oakview Elementary Leadership Preparatory Academy Stone Mill Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Idlewood Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Woodward Elementary School
0
0 -0.0635 0.0397
52
33
59
0
1 -0.0664 0.0506
49
32
40
0
1 -0.0731 0.0697
44
30
17
0
0 -0.0748 0.0491
43
30
13
0
0 -0.0769 0.0361
50
29
44
0
0 -0.0771 0.0502
49
29
39
0
0 -0.0804 0.0406
53
28
66
0
0 -0.0847 0.0431
49
28
38
0
0 -0.0888 0.0485
49
27
36
0
0 -0.0958 0.0374
50
26
41
0
0 -0.1043 0.0382
50
24
44
0
1 -0.1143 0.0574
46
22
24
0
0 -0.1258 0.0487
47
20
30
0
0 -0.1265 0.0475
41
20
8
0
0 -0.1271 0.0473
45
20
21
0
0 -0.1272 0.0404
49
20
38
0
0 -0.1284 0.0393
47
20
29
0
0 -0.1333 0.0501
54
19
67
0
0 -0.1359 0.0325
48
18
34
0
0 -0.1437 0.0432
49
17
36
0
0 -0.1513 0.0535
41
16
9
0
1 -0.1654 0.0469
40
14
7
0
0 -0.1700 0.0457
43
13
13
0
0 -0.1706 0.0358
46
13
21
0
0 -0.1735 0.0530
40
12
7
0
0 -0.1737 0.0485
48
12
32
0
1 -0.1755 0.0522
41
12
7
0
0 -0.1804 0.0448
47
12
30
0
0 -0.1892 0.0483
45
11
19
0
1 -0.1903 0.0591
43
11
13
0
0 -0.1942 0.0357
45
11
21
0
0 -0.1986 0.0350
43
10
14
0
0 -0.1991 0.0352
43
10
14
271
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Robert Shaw Theme School Allgood Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Briarlake Elementary School Montgomery Elementary School Toney Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Redan Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Hightower Elementary School Columbia Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Stoneview Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
0
0 -0.2014 0.0344
43
10
14
0
0 -0.2030 0.0449
50
10
42
0
0 -0.2048 0.0423
43
10
12
0
0 -0.2067 0.0320
46
9
22
0
0 -0.2096 0.0362
42
9
11
0
0 -0.2211 0.0528
35
8
2
0
0 -0.2257 0.0386
38
8
3
0
0 -0.2328 0.0525
46
8
23
0
0 -0.2342 0.0618
47
7
30
0
0 -0.2439 0.0522
40
7
6
0
0 -0.2541 0.0541
40
6
6
0
0 -0.2582 0.0361
43
5
11
0
0 -0.2633 0.0457
37
5
3
0
0 -0.2852 0.0552
38
4
4
0
0 -0.3049 0.0622
40
3
6
0
0 -0.3094 0.0368
40
3
7
0
0 -0.3142 0.0436
46
3
21
0
1 -0.3261 0.0417
40
3
7
0
0 -0.3325 0.0399
40
2
7
0
0 -0.3428 0.0323
39
2
4
0
1 -0.3610 0.0422
35
2
2
0
0 -0.4075 0.0384
36
1
2
0
0 -0.4107 0.0454
32
1
1
1
0 -0.4450 0.0857
41
1
8
1
0 -0.4936 0.0836
43
1
12
272
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.4614 0.0420
65
99
98
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.3614 0.0332
69
99
99
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.3224 0.0329
55
98
73
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.2925 0.0600
64
96
96
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.2581 0.0391
57
95
79
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1709 0.0468
63
86
96
Hawthorne Elementary School
0
0 0.1489 0.0499
58
83
81
Pleasantdale Elementary School
0
0 0.1442 0.0399
62
83
94
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.1235 0.0390
55
79
72
Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School
0
0 0.1091 0.0487
60
78
89
Livsey Elementary School
0
0 0.0965 0.0515
50
75
45
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0700 0.0508
53
69
64
Cary Reynolds Elementary School
0
0 0.0677 0.0344
56
69
77
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0648 0.0384
47
68
29
Midvale Elementary School
0
0 0.0590 0.0510
52
66
57
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.0568 0.0560
57
66
79
Henderson Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.0327 0.0425
53
58
65
Brockett Elementary School
0
0 0.0265 0.0497
53
56
62
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.0226 0.0493
58
55
82
Dunwoody Elementary School
0
0 -0.0049 0.0375
47
48
30
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 -0.0144 0.0333
53
46
61
Evansdale Elementary School
0
0 -0.0148 0.0385
51
45
50
Sagamore Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0385 0.0495
43
39
13
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.0391 0.0436
54
39
67
Chapel Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0438 0.0459
51
37
53
International Community School
0
1 -0.0459 0.0510
49
37
40
Avondale Elementary School
0
0 -0.0513 0.0515
51
35
53
273
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Kelley Lake Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Snapfinger Elementary School Marbut Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Midway Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Oakview Elementary Ashford Park Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Stone Mountain Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Briarlake Elementary School Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0580 0.0645
60
33
91
0
0 -0.0596 0.0400
52
33
59
0
0 -0.0646 0.0329
46
32
25
0
1 -0.0654 0.0702
44
32
17
0
0 -0.0669 0.0409
53
32
66
0
0 -0.0728 0.0364
50
31
44
0
0 -0.0765 0.0435
49
30
38
0
0 -0.0780 0.0505
49
29
39
0
0 -0.0803 0.0489
49
29
36
0
0 -0.0854 0.0377
50
27
41
0
1 -0.0902 0.0578
46
26
24
0
0 -0.1009 0.0385
50
24
44
0
0 -0.1143 0.0479
41
22
8
0
0 -0.1154 0.0407
49
22
38
0
0 -0.1181 0.0395
47
21
29
0
0 -0.1198 0.0505
54
21
67
0
0 -0.1236 0.0327
48
20
34
0
0 -0.1314 0.0477
45
19
21
0
0 -0.1365 0.0540
41
18
9
0
0 -0.1384 0.0491
47
18
30
0
1 -0.1433 0.0527
41
17
7
0
1 -0.1443 0.0473
40
17
7
0
0 -0.1495 0.0534
40
16
7
0
0 -0.1521 0.0435
49
15
36
0
0 -0.1576 0.0347
43
14
14
0
0 -0.1682 0.0489
48
13
32
0
0 -0.1686 0.0361
46
13
21
0
0 -0.1743 0.0359
45
12
21
0
0 -0.1759 0.0451
47
12
30
0
0 -0.1762 0.0461
43
12
13
0
0 -0.1795 0.0353
43
12
14
0
0 -0.1802 0.0532
35
12
2
0
0 -0.1806 0.0389
38
12
3
274
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Jolly Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Dresden Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Toney Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Bob Mathis Elementary School Redan Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Columbia Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
0
1 -0.1847 0.0596
43
11
13
0
0 -0.1869 0.0363
42
11
11
0
0 -0.1951 0.0453
50
10
42
0
0 -0.1953 0.0351
43
10
14
0
0 -0.1958 0.0487
45
10
19
0
0 -0.1971 0.0427
43
10
12
0
0 -0.2061 0.0322
46
9
22
0
0 -0.2173 0.0623
47
8
30
0
0 -0.2199 0.0529
46
8
23
0
0 -0.2391 0.0527
40
7
6
0
0 -0.2462 0.0364
43
7
11
0
0 -0.2483 0.0627
40
6
6
0
0 -0.2639 0.0545
40
5
6
0
0 -0.2743 0.0461
37
5
3
0
0 -0.2748 0.0557
38
5
4
0
1 -0.2873 0.0420
40
4
7
0
0 -0.3034 0.0439
46
3
21
0
0 -0.3036 0.0370
40
3
7
0
1 -0.3278 0.0425
35
2
2
0
0 -0.3360 0.0324
39
2
4
0
0 -0.3387 0.0402
40
2
7
0
0 -0.3858 0.0387
36
1
2
1
0 -0.4041 0.0864
41
1
8
0
0 -0.4076 0.0458
32
1
1
1
0 -0.5374 0.0843
43
1
12
275
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
276
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.2508 0.0858
72
94
99
Early County Elementary School
0
0 -0.0141 0.0308
56
45
76
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0173 0.0602
47
44
30
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1514 0.0816
42
15
10
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.3051 0.0610
35
3
1
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.3120 0.0507
33
3
1
277
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.2109 0.0864
72
91
99
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0433 0.0607
47
37
30
Early County Elementary School
0
0 -0.0583 0.0310
56
33
76
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1304 0.0823
42
19
10
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.3306 0.0615
35
2
1
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.3896 0.0510
33
1
1
278
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Social Studies
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
279
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 0.6708 0.0361
49
99
51
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.5111 0.0448
72
99
99
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.4485 0.0645
56
99
81
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.3894 0.0317
59
98
88
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.3825 0.0573
63
98
94
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.3760 0.0429
60
98
89
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.3184 0.0578
57
96
82
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.3089 0.0627
68
95
98
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.2325 0.0299
56
89
81
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.2159 0.0348
59
87
87
Kindezi
0
1 0.1943 0.0811
58
86
85
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1483 0.0554
60
79
89
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.1388 0.0591
59
77
88
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 0.1169 0.0654
52
73
65
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 0.1056 0.0505
55
72
76
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.1050 0.0521
50
71
58
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.0989 0.0403
54
70
74
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0718 0.0424
48
65
50
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.0550 0.0419
54
61
71
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.0348 0.0408
50
57
56
Fickett Elementary School
0
0 0.0299 0.0458
43
56
29
Boyd Elementary School
0
0 0.0282 0.0514
48
56
49
Smith Elementary School
0
0 0.0149 0.0285
47
53
46
Deerwood Academy School
0
0 -0.0225 0.0431
45
45
35
Heritage Academy Elementary
0
0 -0.0263 0.0483
47
44
42
280
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Slater Elementary School Beecher Hills Elementary School Rivers Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Bolton Academy Centennial Place Elementary School Toomer Elementary School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Hutchinson Elementary School Humphries Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Atlanta Heights Charter School Kimberly Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Towns Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Finch Elementary Fain Elementary School Scott Elementary School Bethune Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Connally Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0410 0.0440
46
41
41
0
0 -0.0449 0.0567
41
40
22
0
0 -0.0464 0.0419
48
40
49
0
0 -0.0660 0.0587
44
36
33
0
0 -0.0722 0.0454
40
35
19
0
0 -0.0949 0.0437
41
31
22
0
0 -0.1175 0.0463
41
28
21
0
0 -0.1195 0.0564
41
27
24
0
0 -0.1309 0.0610
43
25
28
0
0 -0.1353 0.0551
36
24
11
0
0 -0.1382 0.0567
45
23
36
0
0 -0.1581 0.0698
38
20
14
0
0 -0.1673 0.0403
37
18
12
1
0 -0.1805 0.0459
45
16
36
0
0 -0.1902 0.0480
40
15
20
0
0 -0.1985 0.0465
38
14
15
0
0 -0.2063 0.0453
38
13
14
0
0 -0.2125 0.0606
40
12
19
0
0 -0.2189 0.0631
38
11
14
0
0 -0.2224 0.0561
36
11
10
0
0 -0.2379 0.0436
34
9
7
0
1 -0.2382 0.0737
35
9
8
0
0 -0.2400 0.0427
33
9
5
0
0 -0.2570 0.0503
33
8
5
0
0 -0.2577 0.0635
35
8
9
0
0 -0.2593 0.0483
37
8
12
0
0 -0.2664 0.0567
36
7
11
0
0 -0.3138 0.0591
30
4
3
0
0 -0.3366 0.0391
32
3
4
0
0 -0.3462 0.0507
35
3
8
0
0 -0.4329 0.0752
23
1
1
281
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Perkerson Elementary School
0
0 -0.4525 0.0443
25
1
1
282
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 0.6493 0.0366
49
99
51
Neighborhood Charter School
0
1 0.4925 0.0454
72
99
99
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.4448 0.0653
56
99
81
Jackson Elementary School
0
0 0.4165 0.0321
59
98
88
Springdale Park Elementary School
0
0 0.4024 0.0435
60
98
89
Cascade Elementary School
0
0 0.3511 0.0581
63
97
94
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.3409 0.0635
68
97
98
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.3207 0.0584
57
96
82
Brandon Elementary School
0
0 0.2722 0.0303
56
93
81
Morningside Elementary School
0
0 0.2641 0.0353
59
92
87
Kindezi
0
1 0.1597 0.0822
58
81
85
Lin Elementary School
0
0 0.1576 0.0409
54
81
74
Venetian Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1413 0.0562
60
78
89
West Manor Elementary School
0
0 0.1381 0.0528
50
77
58
Cleveland Elementary School
0
0 0.1356 0.0599
59
77
88
Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm
0
0 0.1023 0.0512
55
71
76
Burgess-Peterson Elementary School
0
0 0.1003 0.0663
52
71
65
Parkside Elementary School
0
0 0.0649 0.0425
54
64
71
Garden Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0600 0.0429
48
62
50
Smith Elementary School
0
0 0.0574 0.0289
47
62
46
Fickett Elementary School
0
0 0.0417 0.0464
43
59
29
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.0202 0.0413
50
54
56
Boyd Elementary School
0
0 0.0180 0.0521
48
53
49
Deerwood Academy School
0
0 -0.0064 0.0437
45
49
35
Beecher Hills Elementary School
0
0 -0.0159 0.0574
41
46
22
283
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Heritage Academy Elementary Slater Elementary School Rivers Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Bolton Academy Centennial Place Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Humphries Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Whitefoord Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Kimberly Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Gideons Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Towns Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School Bethune Elementary School Finch Elementary Fain Elementary School Scott Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Connally Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0273 0.0490
47
44
42
0
0 -0.0282 0.0446
46
43
41
0
0 -0.0303 0.0425
48
43
49
0
0 -0.0646 0.0595
44
37
33
0
0 -0.0853 0.0443
41
33
22
0
0 -0.0983 0.0469
41
31
21
0
0 -0.1038 0.0460
40
29
19
0
0 -0.1184 0.0571
41
27
24
0
0 -0.1247 0.0559
36
26
11
0
0 -0.1296 0.0618
43
24
28
0
0 -0.1361 0.0574
45
23
36
0
0 -0.1478 0.0409
37
22
12
0
0 -0.1488 0.0707
38
22
14
0
0 -0.1812 0.0471
38
16
15
0
0 -0.1857 0.0459
38
15
14
0
0 -0.1885 0.0486
40
15
20
0
0 -0.1900 0.0639
38
15
14
1
0 -0.1988 0.0466
45
14
36
0
0 -0.2139 0.0442
34
12
7
0
0 -0.2199 0.0568
36
12
10
0
1 -0.2266 0.0747
35
11
8
0
0 -0.2313 0.0614
40
10
19
0
0 -0.2386 0.0574
36
10
11
0
0 -0.2580 0.0490
37
8
12
0
0 -0.2613 0.0433
33
8
5
0
0 -0.2684 0.0509
33
7
5
0
0 -0.2898 0.0644
35
6
9
0
0 -0.3264 0.0396
32
4
4
0
0 -0.3268 0.0599
30
4
3
0
0 -0.3425 0.0514
35
3
8
0
0 -0.4407 0.0762
23
1
1
284
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Perkerson Elementary School
0
0 -0.4520 0.0449
25
1
1
285
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
286
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.3069 0.0437
63
95
94
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.2308 0.0307
61
89
91
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.1656 0.0334
56
83
79
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.1129 0.0351
44
73
31
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.0492 0.0577
51
60
61
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 0.0192 0.0446
49
54
54
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0019 0.0353
48
50
48
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.0174 0.0300
51
46
60
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 -0.0278 0.0261
55
44
77
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0326 0.0274
49
43
53
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.0343 0.0385
43
43
28
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 -0.0588 0.0554
52
37
63
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 -0.0701 0.0267
44
35
31
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0896 0.0361
51
33
60
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.1024 0.0309
45
30
36
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.1218 0.0414
47
27
44
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 -0.1560 0.0317
44
20
31
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.1579 0.0276
46
20
38
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.1885 0.0448
42
15
26
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.1969 0.0321
46
14
41
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.2121 0.0446
39
12
17
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.2667 0.0426
34
7
6
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.2999 0.0320
45
5
37
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.3085 0.0275
35
4
9
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.3521 0.0395
32
3
4
287
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.3448 0.0443
63
97
94
Arnold Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.2544 0.0311
61
91
91
Macedonia Elementary School
0
0 0.1813 0.0338
56
85
79
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.0838 0.0356
44
67
31
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 0.0573 0.0584
51
62
61
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 0.0379 0.0452
49
58
54
Avery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0055 0.0277
49
49
53
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0118 0.0358
48
47
48
Liberty Elementary School
0
0 -0.0131 0.0264
55
47
77
Clark Creek Elementary School
0
0 -0.0135 0.0304
51
47
60
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.0369 0.0390
43
41
28
Free Home Elementary School
0
0 -0.0414 0.0562
52
40
63
Bascomb Elementary School
0
0 -0.0507 0.0270
44
39
31
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0722 0.0366
51
35
60
Woodstock Elementary School
0
0 -0.0825 0.0313
45
33
36
Johnston Elementary School
0
0 -0.1100 0.0420
47
28
44
Sixes Elementary School
0
0 -0.1304 0.0321
44
24
31
Carmel Elementary School
0
0 -0.1404 0.0280
46
23
38
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.1943 0.0454
42
15
26
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.1966 0.0325
46
14
41
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 -0.2039 0.0452
39
13
17
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.2555 0.0432
34
8
6
Little River Elem.
0
0 -0.2759 0.0279
35
7
9
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 -0.2904 0.0325
45
6
37
Boston Elementary School
0
0 -0.3371 0.0401
32
3
4
288
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
289
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
Brooks Elementary Coweta Charter Academy Elm Street Elementary School Atkinson Elementary School Thomas Crossroads Elementary School White Oak Elementary School Glanton Elementary Canongate Elementary School Arnco-Sargent Elementary School Jefferson Parkway Elementary School Arbor Springs Elementary Moreland Elementary School Poplar Road Elementary School Northside Elementary School Newnan Crossing Elementary School Willis Road Elementary Western Elementary School Welch Elementary School Ruth Hill Elementary School Eastside Elementary School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.1535 0.0889 0.0792 0.0773 0.0703 0.0554 0.0047 -0.0032 -0.0070 -0.0315 -0.0612 -0.0803 -0.1062 -0.1063 -0.1225 -0.1392 -0.1538 -0.1673 -0.2057 -0.3777
School Effect Standard Error
0.0379 0.0458 0.0479 0.0472 0.0459 0.0374 0.0537 0.0391 0.0474 0.0456 0.0433 0.0458 0.0408 0.0512 0.0345 0.0359 0.0466 0.0351 0.0461 0.0461
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
53
81
68
50
68
56
50
66
57
51
66
59
52
64
67
55
61
76
48
51
51
47
50
44
51
49
61
43
43
29
41
37
22
41
33
24
47
30
46
39
30
16
40
27
20
45
23
34
44
21
33
39
18
18
37
13
12
39
2
18
290
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Brooks Elementary
0
0 0.1712 0.0384
53
83
68
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0960 0.0464
50
70
56
Thomas Crossroads Elementary School
0
0 0.0892 0.0466
52
68
67
White Oak Elementary School
0
0 0.0838 0.0379
55
67
76
Atkinson Elementary School
0
0 0.0811 0.0478
51
67
59
Elm Street Elementary School
0
0 0.0727 0.0486
50
65
57
Canongate Elementary School
0
0 0.0246 0.0396
47
55
44
Glanton Elementary
0
0 0.0093 0.0544
48
52
51
Arnco-Sargent Elementary School
0
0 -0.0100 0.0480
51
48
61
Arbor Springs Elementary
0
0 -0.0490 0.0439
41
39
22
Jefferson Parkway Elementary School
0
0 -0.0634 0.0462
43
37
29
Moreland Elementary School
0
0 -0.0789 0.0464
41
34
24
Poplar Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0794 0.0413
47
34
46
Newnan Crossing Elementary School
0
0 -0.0901 0.0349
40
32
20
Northside Elementary School
0
0 -0.1038 0.0519
39
29
16
Willis Road Elementary
0
0 -0.1134 0.0364
45
28
34
Western Elementary School
0
0 -0.1479 0.0473
44
22
33
Welch Elementary School
0
0 -0.1718 0.0355
39
17
18
Ruth Hill Elementary School
0
0 -0.2042 0.0467
37
13
12
Eastside Elementary School
0
0 -0.3527 0.0467
39
3
18
291
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
292
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.5774 0.0593
59
99
87
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.2336 0.0416
61
89
92
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1734 0.0482
63
84
94
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1636 0.0461
55
82
76
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.1315 0.0567
59
76
86
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.1281 0.0387
55
76
78
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.1192 0.0386
55
74
76
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1177 0.0505
54
73
74
Sagamore Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1163 0.0492
63
73
94
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.1124 0.0524
56
73
80
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.1080 0.0360
55
72
75
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.0999 0.0618
52
71
66
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0577 0.0430
54
62
71
Huntley Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0573 0.0529
58
61
84
Pleasantdale Elementary School
0
0 0.0309 0.0395
53
56
71
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0217 0.0378
48
55
49
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.0012 0.0360
49
50
52
Henderson Mill Elementary School
0
0 -0.0052 0.0419
45
49
35
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 -0.0100 0.0383
44
48
33
Snapfinger Elementary School
0
0 -0.0226 0.0401
48
45
50
Narvie Harris Elementary School
0
0 -0.0241 0.0323
45
45
36
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo
0
0 -0.0354 0.0342
46
42
39
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 -0.0387 0.0328
43
42
30
Midway Elementary School
0
0 -0.0408 0.0484
46
41
38
Livsey Elementary School
0
0 -0.0416 0.0507
54
41
72
293
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cary Reynolds Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Brockett Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Idlewood Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Jolly Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Dunwoody Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Oakview Elementary Midvale Elementary School
0
0 -0.0441 0.0343
49
41
51
0
0 -0.0639 0.0500
50
36
55
0
0 -0.0730 0.0486
46
34
39
0
0 -0.0908 0.0512
48
33
48
0
1 -0.0960 0.0692
55
31
75
0
0 -0.1120 0.0489
39
29
16
0
0 -0.1136 0.0374
50
28
58
0
0 -0.1192 0.0381
48
27
50
0
0 -0.1254 0.0635
45
26
34
0
0 -0.1261 0.0492
40
26
18
0
0 -0.1289 0.0472
41
26
21
0
0 -0.1316 0.0453
38
25
13
0
0 -0.1374 0.0390
38
24
15
0
0 -0.1400 0.0429
39
23
17
0
0 -0.1419 0.0448
36
23
10
0
0 -0.1464 0.0365
45
22
34
0
0 -0.1485 0.0429
44
21
31
0
0 -0.1534 0.0474
35
21
8
0
0 -0.1583 0.0365
44
20
31
0
0 -0.1652 0.0378
39
19
17
0
1 -0.1717 0.0414
36
17
11
0
0 -0.1770 0.0373
44
16
32
0
1 -0.1990 0.0466
36
14
10
0
1 -0.2115 0.0421
34
12
7
0
0 -0.2143 0.0614
37
12
13
0
0 -0.2162 0.0393
35
12
9
0
0 -0.2182 0.0324
37
11
12
0
0 -0.2187 0.0480
40
11
19
0
0 -0.2269 0.0519
39
10
17
0
0 -0.2282 0.0380
38
10
15
0
0 -0.2287 0.0507
41
10
23
294
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Chesnut Elementary School Woodward Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy International Community School Browns Mill Elementary School Toney Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Redan Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Columbia Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Kittredge Magnet School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
0
1 -0.2351 0.0519
38
10
15
0
0 -0.2362 0.0352
41
10
23
0
0 -0.2375 0.0514
32
9
4
0
0 -0.2380 0.0317
35
9
9
0
0 -0.2435 0.0486
36
9
10
0
0 -0.2451 0.0490
30
9
3
0
0 -0.2483 0.0402
36
9
11
0
0 -0.2641 0.0357
34
8
6
0
0 -0.2676 0.0454
30
7
2
0
0 -0.2677 0.0532
34
7
6
0
1 -0.2752 0.0570
34
7
7
0
1 -0.2862 0.0514
40
6
19
0
0 -0.2926 0.0360
31
6
3
0
0 -0.2967 0.0521
35
5
8
0
0 -0.3014 0.0350
39
5
17
0
0 -0.3017 0.0537
36
5
11
0
0 -0.3088 0.0456
30
4
3
0
0 -0.3157 0.0396
28
4
2
0
0 -0.3196 0.0448
35
4
8
0
0 -0.3242 0.0548
26
4
2
0
1 -0.3343 0.0580
31
3
3
0
0 -0.3354 0.0436
32
3
4
0
0 -0.3781 0.0422
32
2
4
0
0 -0.4176 0.0321
29
2
2
1
0 -0.4458 0.0851
28
1
2
0
0 -0.4544 0.0375
26
1
1
0
0 -0.4838 0.0453
34
1
8
0
0 -0.5079 0.0325
31
1
3
1
0 -0.5416 0.0830
35
1
8
295
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.6088 0.0599
59
99
87
Austin Elementary School
0
0 0.2834 0.0421
61
93
92
Fernbank Elementary School
0
0 0.1961 0.0392
55
86
78
Rockbridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1942 0.0488
63
86
94
Vanderlyn Elementary School
0
0 0.1906 0.0391
55
86
76
Rock Chapel Elementary School
0
0 0.1723 0.0467
55
83
76
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.1636 0.0627
52
82
66
Sagamore Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.1610 0.0498
63
81
94
Briarlake Elementary School
0
0 0.1597 0.0531
56
81
80
Indian Creek Elementary School
0
0 0.1589 0.0360
55
81
75
Laurel Ridge Elementary School
0
0 0.1507 0.0511
54
79
74
Briar Vista Elementary School
0
0 0.1377 0.0574
59
77
86
Huntley Hills Elementary School
0
0 0.0840 0.0536
58
67
84
Oak Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0731 0.0383
48
65
49
Cedar Grove Elementary School
0
0 0.0684 0.0436
54
64
71
Montgomery Elementary School
0
0 0.0418 0.0388
44
59
33
Pleasantdale Elementary School
0
0 0.0380 0.0400
53
58
71
Henderson Mill Elementary School
0
0 0.0369 0.0425
45
58
35
Livsey Elementary School
0
0 0.0274 0.0514
54
55
72
Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo
0
0 0.0140 0.0347
46
53
39
Wynbrooke Elementary School
0
0 0.0131 0.0332
43
52
30
Marbut Elementary School
0
0 0.0034 0.0364
49
51
52
Snapfinger Elementary School
0
0 -0.0102 0.0406
48
48
50
Narvie Harris Elementary School
0
0 -0.0112 0.0327
45
48
36
Cary Reynolds Elementary School
0
0 -0.0303 0.0347
49
43
51
296
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Midway Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Hawthorne Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Idlewood Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Woodridge Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Midvale Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Princeton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0364 0.0490
46
42
38
0
0 -0.0490 0.0507
50
39
55
0
0 -0.0736 0.0386
48
35
50
0
0 -0.0846 0.0492
46
33
39
0
1 -0.0890 0.0702
55
32
75
0
0 -0.1002 0.0498
40
30
18
0
0 -0.1015 0.0496
39
30
16
0
0 -0.1099 0.0379
50
29
58
0
0 -0.1209 0.0519
48
26
48
0
0 -0.1212 0.0394
38
26
15
0
0 -0.1257 0.0377
44
25
32
0
1 -0.1259 0.0420
36
25
11
0
0 -0.1316 0.0369
45
24
34
0
0 -0.1335 0.0454
36
24
10
0
0 -0.1359 0.0478
41
23
21
0
0 -0.1374 0.0434
44
23
31
0
0 -0.1411 0.0459
38
23
13
0
0 -0.1423 0.0644
45
23
34
0
0 -0.1443 0.0480
35
22
8
0
0 -0.1496 0.0382
39
21
17
0
0 -0.1521 0.0369
44
21
31
0
0 -0.1581 0.0434
39
20
17
0
1 -0.1685 0.0426
34
18
7
0
1 -0.1727 0.0473
36
17
10
0
1 -0.1965 0.0526
38
14
15
0
0 -0.1975 0.0622
37
14
13
0
0 -0.2081 0.0514
41
13
23
0
0 -0.2150 0.0355
41
12
23
0
0 -0.2158 0.0486
40
12
19
0
0 -0.2185 0.0398
35
12
9
0
0 -0.2215 0.0328
37
11
12
297
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Flat Shoals Elementary School Oakview Elementary Pine Ridge Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Clifton Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School International Community School Chapel Hill Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Toney Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Redan Elementary School Columbia Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Stoneview Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Montclair Elementary School Kittredge Magnet School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
0
0 -0.2227 0.0526
39
11
17
0
0 -0.2249 0.0385
38
11
15
0
0 -0.2354 0.0407
36
10
11
0
0 -0.2421 0.0321
35
9
9
0
0 -0.2451 0.0492
36
9
10
0
0 -0.2459 0.0521
32
9
4
0
1 -0.2505 0.0578
34
8
7
0
0 -0.2532 0.0539
34
8
6
0
0 -0.2557 0.0496
30
8
3
0
1 -0.2630 0.0521
40
7
19
0
0 -0.2633 0.0460
30
7
2
0
0 -0.2656 0.0362
34
7
6
0
0 -0.2812 0.0528
35
6
8
0
0 -0.2823 0.0364
31
6
3
0
0 -0.3007 0.0353
39
5
17
0
0 -0.3142 0.0544
36
5
11
0
0 -0.3148 0.0454
35
4
8
0
0 -0.3181 0.0556
26
4
2
0
0 -0.3195 0.0462
30
4
3
0
0 -0.3245 0.0442
32
4
4
0
1 -0.3259 0.0588
31
4
3
0
0 -0.3294 0.0401
28
4
2
0
0 -0.3704 0.0427
32
2
4
1
0 -0.3870 0.0863
28
2
2
0
0 -0.4084 0.0324
29
2
2
0
0 -0.4261 0.0329
31
1
3
0
0 -0.4325 0.0380
26
1
1
0
0 -0.4917 0.0459
34
1
8
1
0 -0.6086 0.0841
35
1
8
298
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
299
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Early County Elementary School
0
0 0.2459 0.0306
59
90
87
Clay County Elementary
0
0 0.2314 0.0852
64
89
96
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.0131 0.0598
47
53
46
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.0502 0.0811
51
39
60
Randolph County Elementary School
0
0 -0.1748 0.0504
39
17
17
Calhoun County Elementary School
0
0 -0.2141 0.0606
30
12
2
300
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading
APS Distric
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
301
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 0.3005 0.0392
59
99
80
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 0.0963 0.0436
60
88
91
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 0.0903 0.0357
56
85
58
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.0828 0.0468
56
83
65
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0557 0.0198
61
73
93
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.0364 0.0372
60
65
91
Sutton Middle School
0
0 0.0256 0.0159
58
61
77
Kindezi
0
1 -0.0124 0.1181
52
47
29
Coan Middle School
0
0 -0.0150 0.0403
56
46
58
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.0411 0.0243
56
33
63
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.0444 0.0259
55
32
51
Long Middle School
0
0 -0.0549 0.0248
54
28
43
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
1
0 -0.0578 0.0445
49
27
10
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0629 0.0298
55
25
54
Price Middle School
0
0 -0.0682 0.0361
55
23
48
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0688 0.0325
54
22
39
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 -0.0787 0.0468
49
19
9
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.0828 0.0682
50
17
15
KIPP VISION
0
1 -0.0869 0.0366
53
16
34
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.0896 0.0795
40
15
1
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 -0.1077 0.0373
53
10
30
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.1078 0.0194
50
10
13
Brown Middle School
0
0 -0.1155 0.0247
52
8
29
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.1287 0.0261
52
6
24
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.1361 0.0351
50
5
14
302
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
APS-Forrest Hills Academey
0
0 -0.3663 0.0993
31
1
1
303
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 0.2990 0.0392
59
99
80
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 0.1118 0.0357
56
90
58
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 0.1193 0.0436
60
91
91
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.1052 0.0468
56
89
65
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0600 0.0198
61
76
93
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.0643 0.0372
60
78
91
Sutton Middle School
0
0 0.0253 0.0159
58
62
77
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
1
0 -0.0342 0.0445
49
36
10
Coan Middle School
0
0 0.0091 0.0403
56
56
58
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.0181 0.0243
56
45
63
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.0234 0.0259
55
42
51
Price Middle School
0
0 -0.0470 0.0361
55
29
48
Long Middle School
0
0 -0.0342 0.0248
54
36
43
Kindezi
0
1 0.0107 0.1181
52
57
29
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0431 0.0298
55
30
54
KIPP VISION
0
1 -0.0625 0.0366
53
24
34
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0430 0.0326
54
31
39
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.0589 0.0682
50
25
15
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 -0.0797 0.0373
53
17
30
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 -0.0582 0.0468
49
25
9
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.0837 0.0194
50
16
13
Brown Middle School
0
0 -0.0925 0.0247
52
13
29
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.0684 0.0794
40
21
1
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.1086 0.0262
52
9
24
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.1124 0.0351
50
8
14
304
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
APS-Forrest Hills Academey
0
0 -0.3477 0.0993
31
1
1
305
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
CCAT
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
CCAT
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
306
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
CCAT School
1
0 0.0403 0.0747
48
67
7
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.0046 0.0455
50
53
15
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 -0.0293 0.0243
53
37
37
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 -0.0705 0.0236
52
22
22
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0807 0.0250
52
17
23
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
CCAT School
1
0 0.0315 0.0747
48 66
7
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0014 0.0454
50 52
15
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 -0.0234 0.0242
53 42
37
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0808 0.0250
52 17
23
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 -0.0859 0.0236
52 15
22
307
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
308
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.1456 0.0525
44
95
2
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.1417 0.0656
49
94
10
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1309 0.0669
54
93
42
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.1218 0.0541
51
92
19
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0929 0.0210
55
87
48
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 0.0927 0.0652
51
87
22
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.0926 0.0152
57
87
72
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.0691 0.0183
58
79
77
Canton Elementary
0
0 0.0679 0.0632
48
79
6
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 0.0656 0.0664
46
77
3
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.0422 0.0176
56
68
61
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0409 0.0340
51
67
21
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0302 0.0161
54
63
42
Rusk Middle School
0
0 0.0231 0.0206
55
60
49
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.0014 0.0529
51
52
21
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0172 0.0175
53
45
34
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0386 0.0774
52
34
23
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1495 0.0781
42
4
2
309
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.1304 0.0525
44
93
2
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1175 0.0669
54
91
42
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.1235 0.0656
49
92
10
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.1100 0.0540
51
90
19
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.0797 0.0152
57
84
72
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 0.0552 0.0664
46
73
3
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 0.0832 0.0651
51
85
22
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.0595 0.0183
58
76
77
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0785 0.0210
55
83
48
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.0293 0.0176
56
65
61
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0292 0.0340
51
64
21
Canton Elementary
0
0 0.0610 0.0632
48
77
6
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0151 0.0162
54
59
42
Rusk Middle School
0
0 0.0087 0.0206
55
56
49
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.0106 0.0529
51
49
21
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0293 0.0175
53
38
34
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0568 0.0773
52
26
23
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1673 0.0780
42
3
2
310
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
311
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
Coweta Charter Academy Arnall Middle School Lee Middle School East Coweta Middle School Smokey Road Middle School Madras Middle School Evans Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.2135 0.0657 0.0389 -0.0234 -0.0265 -0.0370 -0.0390
School Effect Standard Error
0.0978 0.0204 0.0197 0.0223 0.0225 0.0186 0.0219
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
55
98
50
59
77
83
58
66
78
54
42
43
55
39
48
56
35
59
53
34
37
312
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.2024 0.0978
55 98
50
Arnall Middle School
0
0 0.0592 0.0204
59 75
83
Lee Middle School
0
0 0.0290 0.0197
58 64
78
East Coweta Middle School
0
0 -0.0355 0.0223
54 35
43
Smokey Road Middle School
0
0 -0.0324 0.0225
55 37
48
Madras Middle School
0
0 -0.0487 0.0186
56 28
59
Evans Middle School
0
0 -0.0476 0.0219
53 29
37
313
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
314
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.2496 0.0708
66
98
99
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1366 0.0872
63
94
97
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 0.1191 0.0202
57
91
68
DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
0
0 0.1168 0.0476
45
91
3
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 0.1100 0.0603
52
90
25
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
1
0 0.1088 0.0582
51
90
18
Tucker Middle School
0
0 0.0668 0.0177
56
78
64
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 0.0558 0.0206
60
73
92
Redan Middle School
0
0 0.0482 0.0226
54
71
46
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 0.0454 0.0199
56
70
64
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 0.0394 0.0167
57
67
69
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 0.0345 0.0205
53
65
36
Henderson Middle School
0
0 0.0283 0.0159
56
63
63
Salem Middle School
0
0 0.0249 0.0192
53
61
33
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 0.0241 0.0411
52
60
28
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 0.0238 0.0208
55
60
49
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 0.0125 0.0179
55
57
50
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 -0.0001 0.0580
52
51
29
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0226 0.0187
54
42
45
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 -0.0264 0.0383
48
40
5
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.0420 0.0211
52
33
26
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.0526 0.0207
51
29
20
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.0569 0.0200
51
27
19
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.0732 0.0215
51
21
21
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0802 0.0198
55
18
53
315
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Cedar Grove Middle School Kittredge Magnet School McNair Middle School International Student Center
0
1 -0.1013 0.0350
52
11
22
0
0 -0.1287 0.0212
45
6
3
0
0 -0.1400 0.0479
59
5
84
0
0 -0.1543 0.0249
48
4
7
0
0 -0.2307 0.0605
21
1
1
316
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.2606 0.0708
66
98
99
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1367 0.0872
63
94
97
DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
0
0 0.1419 0.0476
45
94
3
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 0.1309 0.0603
52
93
25
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 0.1414 0.0202
57
94
68
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 0.0570 0.0206
60
74
92
Tucker Middle School
0
0 0.0793 0.0177
56
83
64
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
1
0 0.1313 0.0581
51
93
18
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 0.0354 0.0167
57
66
69
Redan Middle School
0
0 0.0679 0.0226
54
79
46
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 0.0595 0.0205
53
76
36
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 0.0516 0.0199
56
72
64
Henderson Middle School
0
0 0.0277 0.0159
56
63
63
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 0.0469 0.0411
52
70
28
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 0.0470 0.0208
55
70
49
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.0314 0.0580
52
65
29
Salem Middle School
0
0 0.0468 0.0193
53
70
33
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 0.0021 0.0383
48
53
5
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0021 0.0187
54
52
45
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 0.0092 0.0179
55
56
50
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.0348 0.0200
51
35
19
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.0309 0.0208
51
37
20
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.0233 0.0212
52
42
26
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.0534 0.0215
51
27
21
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 -0.1403 0.0479
59
4
84
317
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Freedom Middle School Cedar Grove Middle School McNair Middle School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School International Student Center
0
0 -0.0664 0.0199
0
0 -0.1076 0.0212
0
0 -0.1332 0.0249
0
1 -0.1027 0.0350
0
0 -0.2234 0.0605
55
22
53
45
9
3
48
5
7
52
11
22
21
1
1
318
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
319
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
Fulton Leadership Academy Amana Academy School Crabapple Middle School Hopewell Middle School Webb Bridge Middle School Elkins Pointe Middle School Northwestern Middle School Taylor Road Middle School Bear Creek Middle School Ridgeview Charter School Main Street Charter Academy Middle Haynes Bridge Middle School Autrey Mill Middle School River Trail Middle School Sandy Springs Middle School Holcomb Bridge Middle School Renaissance Middle School Woodland Middle School Hapeville Charter Middle School McNair Middle School Sandtown Middle School Paul D. West Middle School KIPP South Fulton Academy School Camp Creek Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
School Effect
0.2530 0.1899 0.0873 0.0641 0.0611 0.0475 0.0263 0.0182 0.0102 0.0101 0.0043 -0.0168 -0.0176 -0.0184 -0.0274 -0.0304 -0.0348 -0.0389 -0.0417 -0.0588 -0.0659 -0.0765 -0.0933 -0.0954
School Effect Standard Error
0.0461 0.0422 0.0198 0.0168 0.0165 0.0184 0.0165 0.0189 0.0204 0.0187 0.0409 0.0227 0.0164 0.0159 0.0212 0.0222 0.0179 0.0198 0.0258 0.0227 0.0182 0.0237 0.0385 0.0253
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
62
98
95
60
97
87
60
84
90
58
76
76
63
74
97
58
70
74
58
62
74
59
58
81
52
56
25
56
56
59
51
53
19
55
46
52
58
45
76
61
44
94
52
39
22
53
37
30
50
35
14
52
34
28
46
33
4
49
26
9
50
24
11
50
20
13
54
13
41
49
12
10
320
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.1985 0.0422
60
98
87
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.2748 0.0461
62
99
95
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.0801 0.0197
60
84
90
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.0588 0.0168
58
75
76
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0548 0.0165
63
73
97
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0413 0.0184
58
68
74
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 0.0181 0.0165
58
60
74
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 0.0138 0.0189
59
58
81
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 0.0248 0.0409
51
62
19
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 0.0075 0.0187
56
55
59
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 0.0267 0.0205
52
63
25
River Trail Middle School
0
0 -0.0225 0.0159
61
42
94
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 -0.0245 0.0164
58
41
76
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 -0.0210 0.0227
55
43
52
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 -0.0293 0.0222
53
38
30
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 -0.0212 0.0212
52
43
22
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.0161 0.0179
50
46
14
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.0204 0.0198
52
44
28
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.0245 0.0258
46
41
4
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.0386 0.0227
49
33
9
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.0415 0.0182
50
31
11
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.0654 0.0237
50
22
13
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0744 0.0253
49
19
10
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 -0.0688 0.0385
54
21
41
321
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gwinnett
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
322
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.2059 0.0803
60
98
87
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.1788 0.0169
66
97
99
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.1609 0.0170
65
96
98
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.1576 0.0167
65
96
99
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.1438 0.0157
67
95
99
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.1420 0.0194
63
94
97
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.1345 0.0186
65
94
99
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.1299 0.0189
65
93
98
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1294 0.0153
64
93
98
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.1057 0.0197
60
89
87
Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente
0
0 0.0983 0.1365
46
89
3
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.0964 0.0162
60
89
87
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth
0
0 0.0959 0.0872
58
88
75
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.0956 0.0172
61
88
94
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0902 0.0130
63
85
97
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.0896 0.0129
62
85
96
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.0758 0.0149
65
82
98
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.0746 0.0170
61
81
94
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.0740 0.0186
59
81
86
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0737 0.0139
60
81
89
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0734 0.0139
61
80
94
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0708 0.0145
60
80
88
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.0663 0.0197
61
78
92
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0643 0.0145
59
76
81
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.0630 0.0206
59
75
84
323
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Lilburn Middle School Louise Radloff Middle School North Gwinnett Middle School Dacula Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School
0
0 0.0566 0.0159
60
73
90
0
0 0.0514 0.0151
61
71
93
0
0 0.0474 0.0136
63
70
97
0
0 0.0246 0.0156
59
61
84
1
0 -0.0002 0.0355
55
51
52
324
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.1970 0.0802
60
98
87
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.1795 0.0169
66
97
99
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.1587 0.0170
65
96
98
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.1536 0.0167
65
95
99
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.1440 0.0194
63
95
97
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.1418 0.0157
67
94
99
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1306 0.0153
64
93
98
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.1349 0.0189
65
93
98
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.1347 0.0186
65
93
99
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth
0
0 0.1164 0.0872
58
91
75
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.0924 0.0130
62
87
96
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.0985 0.0172
61
88
94
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0910 0.0130
63
87
97
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.1043 0.0162
60
89
87
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.1129 0.0197
60
90
87
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.0692 0.0149
65
80
98
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0732 0.0139
60
81
89
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0759 0.0139
61
82
94
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.0429 0.0136
63
69
97
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.0866 0.0186
59
86
86
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.0779 0.0206
59
83
84
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0802 0.0145
59
84
81
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0734 0.0145
60
81
88
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.0752 0.0170
61
82
94
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.0686 0.0197
61
80
92
325
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Louise Radloff Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Lilburn Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.0536 0.0151
1
0 0.0148 0.0355
0
0 0.0573 0.0159
0
0 0.0950 0.1364
0
0 0.0289 0.0156
61
73
93
55
58
52
60
75
90
46
87
3
59
64
84
326
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
327
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
Clay County Middle School Pataula Charter Academy Early County Middle School Baker County K12 School Randolph Clay Middle School Calhoun County Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.0610 0.0583 0.0094 0.0085 -0.0778 -0.1243
School Effect Standard Error
0.0655 0.0544 0.0269 0.0729 0.0433 0.0496
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
58
74
77
51
74
19
57
55
73
57
55
70
45
19
3
50
7
16
328
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.0440 0.0544
51 69
19
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.0293 0.0729
57 65
70
Clay County Middle School
0
0 0.0775 0.0655
58 83
77
Early County Middle School
0
0 0.0172 0.0268
57 59
73
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.0628 0.0433
45 23
3
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.1050 0.0496
50 10
16
329
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
330
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
Kindezi Latin Academy Charter School Atlanta Heights Charter School Imagine Wesley International Academy Atlanta Charter Middle School Inman Middle School Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad Bunche Middle School Kipp Strive Academy Sutton Middle School KIPP VISION Intown Charter Academy Coan Middle School Long Middle School Harper-Archer Middle School Brown Middle School Price Middle School King Middle School Charles R. Drew Charter School Young Middle School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso Kennedy Middle School Sylvan Hills Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
0
1
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.2929 0.1679 0.1491 0.1330 0.0999 0.0458 0.0378 0.0341 0.0246 0.0225 0.0038 -0.0063 -0.0158 -0.0235 -0.0281 -0.0371 -0.0380 -0.0406 -0.0507 -0.0588 -0.0630 -0.0695 -0.0876 -0.0913
School Effect Standard Error
0.1128 0.0414 0.0447 0.0447 0.0377 0.0188 0.0342 0.0232 0.0356 0.0152 0.0351 0.0651 0.0385 0.0236 0.0248 0.0235 0.0344 0.0285 0.0311 0.0185 0.0358 0.0337 0.0766 0.0249
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
52
99
85
52
97
87
48
96
50
49
95
65
48
89
57
52
74
88
50
72
73
48
71
54
46
65
35
52
64
86
48
55
56
47
50
41
43
44
16
48
40
53
44
37
21
47
32
44
45
32
28
46
30
34
45
25
27
43
21
14
46
19
31
41
17
7
36
11
1
43
10
12
331
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Heritage Preparatory Academy School APS-Forrest Hills Academey
1
0 -0.1105 0.0427
42
6
9
0
0 -0.2881 0.0948
39
1
3
332
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Kindezi
0
1 0.2210 0.1149
52
98
85
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 0.1676 0.0422
52
97
87
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 0.1368 0.0455
48
95
50
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.1291 0.0455
49
94
65
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 0.1255 0.0348
50
94
73
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0663 0.0192
52
82
88
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 0.0494 0.0384
48
76
57
Bunche Middle School
0
0 0.0446 0.0236
48
74
54
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.0419 0.0358
48
72
56
Sutton Middle School
0
0 0.0381 0.0155
52
71
86
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.0228 0.0363
46
62
35
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 0.0067 0.0664
47
55
41
Brown Middle School
0
0 -0.0140 0.0240
47
45
44
Price Middle School
0
0 -0.0144 0.0351
45
44
28
Long Middle School
0
0 -0.0201 0.0241
48
42
53
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.0245 0.0252
44
40
21
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0266 0.0291
46
39
34
Coan Middle School
0
0 -0.0360 0.0392
43
33
16
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 -0.0434 0.0364
46
29
31
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.0435 0.0188
43
29
14
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0447 0.0317
45
28
27
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
1
0 -0.0466 0.0435
42
27
9
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0978 0.0254
43
9
12
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.1017 0.0781
36
7
1
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.1484 0.0343
41
3
7
333
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
APS-Forrest Hills Academey
0
0 -0.3514 0.0966
39
1
3
334
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
335
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
Portal Middle/High School Southeast Bulloch Middle School William James Middle School Langston Chapel Middle School CCAT School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
School Effect
0.0042 -0.0224 -0.0467 -0.0491 -0.1995
School Effect Standard Error
0.0433 0.0226 0.0239 0.0230 0.0707
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
45
55
25
47
41
42
48
26
55
43
26
14
40
1
5
336
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0098 0.0441
45
48
25
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 -0.0514 0.0230
47
25
42
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0515 0.0244
48
24
55
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 -0.0675 0.0235
43
17
14
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2132 0.0721
40
1
5
337
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
338
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
Hickory Flat Elementary School Holly Springs Elementary School Woodstock Middle School Canton Elementary Booth Middle School Indian Knoll Elementary J. Knox Elementary Cherokee Charter Academy William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho Freedom Middle School Creekland Middle School Mill Creek Middle School Teasley Middle School Clayton Elementary School Rusk Middle School Mountain Road Elementary School Ball Ground Elementary School R. M. Moore Elementary School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.1540 0.0893 0.0842 0.0775 0.0712 0.0709 0.0703 0.0624 0.0490 0.0195 0.0070 -0.0006 -0.0121 -0.0394 -0.0464 -0.0528 -0.0796 -0.0808
School Effect Standard Error
0.0639 0.0501 0.0175 0.0600 0.0146 0.0518 0.0510 0.0323 0.0622 0.0168 0.0155 0.0167 0.0201 0.0774 0.0197 0.0634 0.0745 0.0626
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
46
97
31
42
88
8
53
86
89
42
85
8
50
83
72
42
83
8
46
82
32
47
81
44
40
75
4
47
62
43
47
56
48
48
53
51
46
46
37
53
31
90
48
27
55
39
23
3
37
13
1
45
13
28
339
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1735 0.0650
46
97
31
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.1049 0.0527
42
91
8
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.1039 0.0510
42
91
8
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.0800 0.0178
53
86
89
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.0682 0.0148
50
83
72
Canton Elementary
0
0 0.0617 0.0611
42
81
8
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.0540 0.0518
46
78
32
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0517 0.0329
47
77
44
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 0.0305 0.0633
40
67
4
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.0175 0.0171
47
59
43
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 0.0046 0.0170
48
54
51
Creekland Middle School
0
0 -0.0034 0.0158
47
51
48
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0345 0.0788
53
34
90
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.0424 0.0646
39
30
3
Teasley Middle School
0
0 -0.0446 0.0204
46
28
37
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.0574 0.0759
37
21
1
Rusk Middle School
0
0 -0.0577 0.0200
48
21
55
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.0883 0.0638
45
11
28
340
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
341
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [clayton]
School Name
Elite Scholars Academy School M. D. Roberts Middle School Riverdale Middle School Morrow Middle School Rex Mill Middle School North Clayton Middle School Adamson Middle School Forest Park Middle School Jonesboro Middle School Babb Middle School Unidos Dual Language Charter School Kendrick Middle School Sequoyah Middle School Eddie White Academy Pointe South Middle School Lovejoy Middle School Mundys Mill Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.1386 0.1179 0.0865 0.0620 0.0538 0.0246 0.0212 0.0048 -0.0014 -0.0024 -0.0075 -0.0077 -0.0112 -0.0123 -0.0357 -0.0495 -0.0672
School Effect Standard Error
0.0356 0.0211 0.0225 0.0230 0.0181 0.0210 0.0249 0.0240 0.0212 0.0209 0.0593 0.0217 0.0212 0.0226 0.0212 0.0237 0.0211
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
55
95
97
52
93
88
54
87
94
50
81
71
51
76
79
50
65
74
51
63
75
51
55
75
49
52
65
51
52
78
48
49
48
49
49
66
51
47
82
48
46
49
48
33
51
48
26
54
45
18
25
342
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [clayton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Elite Scholars Academy School
0
1 0.1652 0.0363
55
96
97
M. D. Roberts Middle School
0
0 0.1343 0.0214
52
94
88
Riverdale Middle School
0
0 0.1175 0.0229
54
93
94
Morrow Middle School
0
0 0.0881 0.0234
50
88
71
Rex Mill Middle School
0
0 0.0801 0.0184
51
86
79
North Clayton Middle School
0
0 0.0496 0.0214
50
76
74
Forest Park Middle School
0
0 0.0486 0.0244
51
75
75
Adamson Middle School
0
0 0.0405 0.0253
51
72
75
Babb Middle School
0
0 0.0376 0.0212
51
71
78
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 0.0344 0.0215
51
69
82
Unidos Dual Language Charter School
0
1 0.0326 0.0604
48
68
48
Eddie White Academy
0
0 0.0262 0.0230
48
64
49
Kendrick Middle School
0
0 0.0245 0.0220
49
63
66
Jonesboro Middle School
0
0 0.0224 0.0215
49
62
65
Pointe South Middle School
0
0 -0.0110 0.0216
48
47
51
Lovejoy Middle School
0
0 -0.0137 0.0241
48
45
54
Mundys Mill Middle School
0
0 -0.0372 0.0214
45
32
25
343
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
344
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Museum School Avondale Estates DeKalb School of the Arts Leadership Preparatory Academy Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Stephenson Middle School The Champion Middle Theme School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Chamblee Middle School Druid Hills Middle School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Tucker Middle School Salem Middle School Redan Middle School Peachtree Middle School Kittredge Magnet School Sequoyah Middle School Lithonia Middle School Chapel Hill Middle School Cedar Grove Middle School Freedom Middle School Columbia Middle School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Miller Grove Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
School Effect
0.2514 0.1349 0.1214 0.1173 0.1066 0.0905 0.0874 0.0857 0.0577 0.0554 0.0381 0.0276 0.0189 0.0166 0.0127 0.0037 0.0027 -0.0127 -0.0238 -0.0318 -0.0333 -0.0372 -0.0377 -0.0401
School Effect Standard Error
0.0553 0.0833 0.0676 0.0393 0.0579 0.0193 0.0195 0.0454 0.0197 0.0191 0.0555 0.0169 0.0184 0.0216 0.0159 0.0457 0.0171 0.0179 0.0199 0.0203 0.0190 0.0191 0.0334 0.0198
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
52
99
88
56
95
98
52
94
87
49
92
58
48
91
51
51
88
80
51
87
77
47
87
46
52
79
89
52
77
89
46
72
36
51
66
81
47
61
45
50
60
68
50
59
70
54
55
93
49
54
65
51
46
76
46
40
32
45
35
28
52
34
84
47
32
47
51
32
77
47
30
45
345
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Henderson Middle School Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Stone Mountain Middle School McNair Middle School International Student Center
0
0 -0.0450 0.0152
49
27
60
0
0 -0.0482 0.0206
48
26
50
0
1 -0.0513 0.0365
43
24
12
0
0 -0.0560 0.0202
47
22
41
0
0 -0.1649 0.0238
41
2
6
0
0 -0.3549 0.0563
49
1
67
346
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.3070 0.0563
52
99
88
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.1777 0.0688
52
98
87
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1760 0.0849
56
98
98
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 0.1653 0.0590
48
97
51
DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
0
0 0.1443 0.0463
47
96
46
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 0.1349 0.0400
49
94
58
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 0.1041 0.0199
51
91
77
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 0.0990 0.0196
51
90
80
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.0907 0.0465
54
89
93
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 0.0828 0.0200
52
87
89
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 0.0696 0.0194
52
83
89
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 0.0399 0.0162
50
71
70
Tucker Middle School
0
0 0.0386 0.0172
51
71
81
Salem Middle School
0
0 0.0234 0.0187
47
62
45
Redan Middle School
0
0 0.0182 0.0220
50
59
68
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 0.0098 0.0372
43
56
12
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 0.0029 0.0172
49
54
65
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0073 0.0182
51
50
76
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 -0.0090 0.0202
46
49
32
Henderson Middle School
0
0 -0.0096 0.0154
49
48
60
Cedar Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.0177 0.0206
45
42
28
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.0215 0.0194
47
41
47
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0248 0.0192
52
40
84
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 -0.0282 0.0339
51
38
77
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.0287 0.0202
47
38
45
347
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Stone Mountain Middle School McNair Middle School International Student Center
0
0 -0.0385 0.0209
48
31
50
1
0 -0.0426 0.0566
46
29
36
0
0 -0.0551 0.0206
47
22
41
0
0 -0.1428 0.0243
41
3
6
0
0 -0.3051 0.0569
49
1
67
348
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
349
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
Amana Academy School Fulton Leadership Academy Crabapple Middle School Webb Bridge Middle School River Trail Middle School Hopewell Middle School Elkins Pointe Middle School KIPP South Fulton Academy School Ridgeview Charter School Haynes Bridge Middle School Northwestern Middle School Bear Creek Middle School Sandtown Middle School Woodland Middle School Sandy Springs Middle School Holcomb Bridge Middle School Taylor Road Middle School Renaissance Middle School Autrey Mill Middle School Paul D. West Middle School McNair Middle School Hapeville Charter Middle School Camp Creek Middle School Main Street Charter Academy Middle
State Local Charter Charter
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.2541 0.2218 0.1508 0.1389 0.1184 0.1160 0.0573 0.0504 0.0503 0.0495 0.0452 0.0380 0.0375 0.0310 0.0292 0.0215 0.0188 0.0122 0.0074 -0.0066 -0.0154 -0.0407 -0.0524 -0.1086
School Effect Standard Error
0.0404 0.0443 0.0188 0.0157 0.0152 0.0161 0.0176 0.0367 0.0179 0.0216 0.0158 0.0195 0.0174 0.0189 0.0203 0.0212 0.0181 0.0171 0.0156 0.0226 0.0217 0.0246 0.0241 0.0391
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
58
99
99
50
98
72
57
97
99
57
95
99
55
93
98
55
92
97
51
78
78
51
75
76
49
75
61
50
75
73
49
73
62
47
72
37
47
71
43
46
69
37
50
67
74
50
63
69
49
61
64
44
59
20
48
57
56
46
50
35
43
44
15
42
30
12
44
23
17
42
7
10
350
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.2863 0.0412
58
99
99
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.1644 0.0192
57
96
99
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.1617 0.0160
57
96
99
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.1406 0.0155
55
95
98
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.1358 0.0164
55
95
97
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.0952 0.0451
50
89
72
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0715 0.0179
51
84
78
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 0.0652 0.0182
49
82
61
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 0.0601 0.0161
49
80
62
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0580 0.0220
50
79
73
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 0.0458 0.0374
51
74
76
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0371 0.0216
50
70
69
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 0.0360 0.0177
47
70
43
Woodland Middle School
0
0 0.0297 0.0192
46
66
37
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 0.0290 0.0207
50
65
74
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 0.0248 0.0199
47
63
37
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 0.0237 0.0184
49
62
64
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 0.0198 0.0159
48
60
56
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 0.0049 0.0174
44
55
20
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.0073 0.0230
46
50
35
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.0160 0.0221
43
43
15
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.0323 0.0250
42
36
12
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0641 0.0246
44
19
17
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 -0.1018 0.0398
42
7
10
351
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gwinnett
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
352
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett]
School Name
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Couch Middle School Alton C. Crews Middle School Twin Rivers Middle School Lanier Middle School McConnell Middle School Glenn C. Jones Middle School Bay Creek Middle School Shiloh Middle School Creekland Middle School Pinckneyville Middle School Grace Snell Middle School North Gwinnett Middle School Five Forks Middle School Snellville Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Moore Middle School Hull Middle School Trickum Middle School Lilburn Middle School Frank N. Osborne Middle School Duluth Middle School Summerour Middle School Sweetwater Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.2489 0.1839 0.1345 0.1298 0.1209 0.1151 0.1098 0.1006 0.0999 0.0998 0.0989 0.0984 0.0932 0.0878 0.0875 0.0834 0.0825 0.0718 0.0709 0.0702 0.0680 0.0618 0.0582 0.0553
School Effect Standard Error
0.0833 0.0185 0.0161 0.0150 0.0159 0.0146 0.0163 0.0181 0.0139 0.0125 0.0165 0.0178 0.0130 0.0178 0.0197 0.1303 0.0189 0.0124 0.0132 0.0151 0.0142 0.0133 0.0162 0.0138
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
47
98
47
57
98
99
54
95
95
54
94
96
56
93
98
54
92
96
55
91
98
53
90
91
53
89
92
54
89
95
53
89
91
52
89
85
54
88
94
53
88
90
51
87
81
53
86
93
51
86
83
52
83
86
52
83
85
53
82
91
53
82
93
52
81
88
53
79
90
50
77
72
353
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Berkmar Middle School Louise Radloff Middle School Richards Middle School Dacula Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0508 0.0187
52
76
86
0
0 0.0505 0.0144
52
76
89
0
0 0.0399 0.0156
49
72
61
0
0 0.0385 0.0149
50
72
73
1
0 -0.0236 0.0338
45
40
27
0
0 -0.0846 0.0781
52
12
84
354
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth
0
0 0.2524 0.0849
47
99
47
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.1708 0.0189
57
97
99
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.1431 0.0164
54
95
95
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.1196 0.0162
56
93
98
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.1171 0.0152
54
92
96
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.1103 0.0166
55
92
98
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1052 0.0148
54
91
96
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.1002 0.0132
54
90
94
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0987 0.0127
54
89
95
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.0954 0.0168
53
89
91
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.0915 0.0184
53
89
91
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.0823 0.0126
52
87
86
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.0819 0.0181
53
86
90
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0818 0.0141
53
86
92
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0744 0.0135
52
85
85
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.0724 0.0200
51
85
81
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.0682 0.0181
52
83
85
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.0639 0.0152
53
81
91
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.0591 0.0192
51
80
83
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.0575 0.0145
53
79
93
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0561 0.0135
52
79
88
Louise Radloff Middle School
0
0 0.0500 0.0146
52
76
89
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.0493 0.0164
53
75
90
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0492 0.0140
50
75
72
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.0403 0.0190
52
71
86
355
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Richards Middle School Dacula Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0354 0.0158
49
70
61
0
0 0.0301 0.0152
50
66
73
1
0 0.0288 0.0344
45
65
27
0
0 -0.0075 0.1327
53
49
93
0
0 -0.0670 0.0796
52
17
84
356
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
x
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Pataula
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Pataula
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
357
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
Clay County Middle School Randolph Clay Middle School Calhoun County Middle School Early County Middle School Pataula Charter Academy Baker County K12 School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
School Effect
0.1742 0.0833 0.0124 0.0106 -0.0306 -0.0758
School Effect Standard Error
0.0626 0.0413 0.0476 0.0256 0.0520 0.0696
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
52
98
88
48
86
57
41
59
7
48
58
55
49
35
62
44
15
19
358
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Middle School
0
0 0.1456 0.0638
52
96
88
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 0.0582 0.0421
48
80
57
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.0077 0.0261
48
49
55
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.0113 0.0485
41
47
7
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.0446 0.0709
44
28
19
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0453 0.0530
49
28
62
359
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
360
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
Kennedy Middle School Kindezi Inman Middle School Imagine Wesley International Academy Coan Middle School Latin Academy Charter School Kipp Strive Academy Atlanta Charter Middle School King Middle School Sutton Middle School Brown Middle School Price Middle School KIPP VISION Bunche Middle School Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad Charles R. Drew Charter School Atlanta Heights Charter School Long Middle School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Harper-Archer Middle School Intown Charter Academy Young Middle School The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso Sylvan Hills Middle School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.2299 0.2099 0.1971 0.1379 0.0943 0.0878 0.0140 0.0006 -0.0172 -0.0209 -0.0231 -0.0268 -0.0336 -0.0415 -0.0443 -0.0696 -0.0737 -0.0810 -0.0839 -0.0972 -0.1091 -0.1182 -0.1390 -0.1606
School Effect Standard Error
0.0713 0.1040 0.0175 0.0412 0.0360 0.0382 0.0332 0.0354 0.0264 0.0140 0.0219 0.0318 0.0323 0.0214 0.0316 0.0287 0.0412 0.0220 0.0328 0.0230 0.0600 0.0171 0.0313 0.0231
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
63
95
98
54
94
83
61
93
97
52
84
74
57
77
88
50
75
66
52
58
75
44
55
35
48
49
56
51
45
68
46
45
47
48
44
58
47
41
52
48
38
54
46
38
44
44
32
37
38
30
12
43
28
32
44
27
33
41
23
22
40
21
19
42
18
28
37
12
11
38
9
12
361
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Heritage Preparatory Academy School APS-Forrest Hills Academey
1
0 -0.2287 0.0393
38
0
0 -0.2718 0.0862
24
3
14
1
1
362
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.2272 0.0178
61
95
97
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 0.2150 0.0728
63
94
98
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 0.1458 0.0421
52
86
74
Kindezi
0
1 0.0964 0.1061
54
79
83
Coan Middle School
0
0 0.0707 0.0368
57
73
88
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 0.0613 0.0390
50
71
66
Sutton Middle School
0
0 0.0228 0.0143
51
60
68
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 -0.0027 0.0339
52
54
75
Price Middle School
0
0 -0.0126 0.0325
48
51
58
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0159 0.0269
48
50
56
Brown Middle School
0
0 -0.0166 0.0223
46
49
47
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 -0.0307 0.0323
46
43
44
KIPP VISION
0
1 -0.0317 0.0330
47
43
52
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.0356 0.0219
48
42
54
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.0527 0.0361
44
35
35
Long Middle School
0
0 -0.0742 0.0224
43
30
32
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.0742 0.0613
40
30
19
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0789 0.0293
44
28
37
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 -0.0884 0.0421
38
25
12
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.0940 0.0234
41
24
22
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 -0.0945 0.0335
44
23
33
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.0994 0.0175
42
21
28
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
1
0 -0.1420 0.0401
38
12
14
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.1487 0.0319
37
10
11
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.1688 0.0236
38
8
12
363
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
APS-Forrest Hills Academey
0
0 -0.3623 0.0879
24
1
1
364
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
365
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
Southeast Bulloch Middle School Portal Middle/High School William James Middle School Langston Chapel Middle School CCAT School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
School Effect
0.0975 0.0701 0.0662 0.0508 -0.2806
School Effect Standard Error
0.0209 0.0400 0.0222 0.0212 0.0663
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
53
78
76
54
71
83
52
70
73
50
67
63
37
1
11
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
William James Middle School
0
0 0.0786 0.0226
52
75
73
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 0.0575 0.0214
53
70
76
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.0538 0.0409
54
69
83
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 0.0315 0.0216
50
63
63
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2846 0.0677
37
1
11
366
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Cherokee
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Cherokee
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
367
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
R. M. Moore Elementary School Mountain Road Elementary School Canton Elementary Woodstock Middle School Creekland Middle School Holly Springs Elementary School J. Knox Elementary Booth Middle School Hickory Flat Elementary School Freedom Middle School Teasley Middle School William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho Indian Knoll Elementary Cherokee Charter Academy Clayton Elementary School Mill Creek Middle School Rusk Middle School Ball Ground Elementary School
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
School Effect
0.2030 0.1828 0.1753 0.1717 0.1694 0.1499 0.1403 0.1376 0.1151 0.1046 0.0611 0.0226 -0.0129 -0.0265 -0.0278 -0.0460 -0.0672 -0.2246
School Effect Standard Error
0.0577 0.0589 0.0550 0.0162 0.0144 0.0464 0.0472 0.0134 0.0593 0.0155 0.0187 0.0574 0.0478 0.0301 0.0714 0.0154 0.0184 0.0700
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
58
93
92
48
91
58
51
90
71
57
89
89
56
89
87
45
87
41
45
85
43
58
84
91
60
81
96
52
80
73
47
70
49
48
59
55
51
50
71
48
44
57
58
43
93
50
37
64
44
32
36
31
3
3
368
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 0.2011 0.0600
48
93
58
Canton Elementary
0
0 0.1973 0.0561
51
93
71
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 0.1851 0.0589
58
91
92
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.1735 0.0166
57
90
89
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.1720 0.0473
45
89
41
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.1639 0.0146
56
88
87
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.1611 0.0605
60
88
96
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.1514 0.0136
58
87
91
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.1269 0.0481
45
83
43
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.1039 0.0159
52
80
73
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 0.0512 0.0585
48
68
55
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.0470 0.0487
51
67
71
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0410 0.0190
47
65
49
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0283 0.0728
58
44
93
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0350 0.0157
50
42
64
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0360 0.0307
48
41
57
Rusk Middle School
0
0 -0.0811 0.0186
44
28
36
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1845 0.0714
31
6
3
369
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Coweta
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Coweta
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
370
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
East Coweta Middle School Smokey Road Middle School Lee Middle School Evans Middle School Arnall Middle School Madras Middle School Coweta Charter Academy
State Local Charter Charter
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
School Effect
0.1404 0.1181 0.0809 -0.0168 -0.0199 -0.0303 -0.1753
School Effect Standard Error
0.0197 0.0200 0.0174 0.0194 0.0181 0.0164 0.0861
School School Mean SGP
Mean Effect State State Rank
Student
Rank Percentile
Growth Percentile
Percentile
57
85
89
56
82
86
53
74
80
46
49
46
51
47
72
49
42
61
50
7
67
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
East Coweta Middle School
0
0 0.1503 0.0201
57
87
89
Smokey Road Middle School
0
0 0.1193 0.0204
56
82
86
Lee Middle School
0
0 0.1176 0.0178
53
81
80
Arnall Middle School
0
0 -0.0034 0.0184
51
54
72
Evans Middle School
0
0 -0.0199 0.0199
46
48
46
Madras Middle School
0
0 -0.0223 0.0168
49
47
61
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1884 0.0879
50
5
67
371
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
372
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.3761 0.0308
59
99
95
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.3206 0.0768
64
97
99
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.2237 0.0422
59
95
94
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.1769 0.0510
51
90
70
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
1
0 0.1010 0.0515
42
79
27
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 0.0734 0.0178
49
72
63
International Student Center
0
0 0.0419 0.0509
40
66
18
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 0.0292 0.0363
49
61
63
Tucker Middle School
0
0 0.0028 0.0155
47
56
50
DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
0
0 -0.0021 0.0419
51
54
71
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0259 0.0166
45
44
40
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0323 0.0176
48
42
54
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.0440 0.0188
44
38
34
Henderson Middle School
0
0 -0.0489 0.0140
48
36
55
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 -0.0499 0.0537
36
36
10
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0584 0.0174
45
35
40
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 -0.0844 0.0182
45
26
42
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 -0.0904 0.0180
43
25
28
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.0934 0.0190
39
25
17
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 -0.0937 0.0157
40
24
19
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.1065 0.0184
40
21
18
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 -0.1134 0.0146
44
19
34
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.1162 0.0176
39
18
15
Redan Middle School
0
0 -0.1521 0.0200
35
11
9
Salem Middle School
0
0 -0.1533 0.0170
35
10
8
373
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Cedar Grove Middle School Chapel Hill Middle School McNair Middle School DeKalb School of the Arts
0
1 -0.1535 0.0337
32
10
4
0
0 -0.1552 0.0188
35
10
7
0
0 -0.1727 0.0183
36
8
10
0
0 -0.1969 0.0222
34
6
5
0
0 -0.3008 0.0623
36
1
9
374
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.3972 0.0313
59
99
95
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.3786 0.0429
59
99
94
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.3743 0.0784
64
98
99
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.2853 0.0520
51
96
70
International Student Center
0
0 0.2112 0.0516
40
94
18
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
1
0 0.0991 0.0525
42
79
27
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 0.0917 0.0182
49
77
63
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 0.0692 0.0371
49
73
63
DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
0
0 0.0459 0.0428
51
66
71
Tucker Middle School
0
0 0.0449 0.0157
47
66
50
Henderson Middle School
0
0 0.0238 0.0143
48
60
55
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 0.0122 0.0180
48
58
54
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 -0.0000 0.0186
45
55
42
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0123 0.0176
45
51
40
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0270 0.0169
45
45
40
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 -0.0388 0.0158
40
40
19
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.0405 0.0192
44
39
34
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 -0.0425 0.0149
44
38
34
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 -0.0546 0.0344
32
35
4
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 -0.0558 0.0184
43
34
28
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 -0.0775 0.0548
36
29
10
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.0896 0.0193
39
25
17
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.1008 0.0180
39
21
15
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.1040 0.0188
40
20
18
Cedar Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.1395 0.0191
35
13
7
375
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Chapel Hill Middle School Salem Middle School Redan Middle School McNair Middle School DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 -0.1439 0.0187
36
12
10
0
0 -0.1464 0.0174
35
11
8
0
0 -0.1487 0.0204
35
10
9
0
0 -0.1834 0.0226
34
6
5
0
0 -0.2381 0.0635
36
3
9
376
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
377
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.3454 0.0141
62
98
98
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.2888 0.0145
63
97
98
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.2509 0.0149
60
96
95
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 0.2474 0.0144
56
96
87
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.1800 0.0174
58
91
92
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.1595 0.0202
58
88
91
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.0975 0.0371
57
78
90
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 0.0954 0.0147
53
78
79
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0700 0.0162
52
71
74
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 0.0618 0.0167
49
70
62
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0500 0.0195
53
67
79
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 0.0327 0.0339
58
62
92
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 -0.0183 0.0189
49
48
59
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 -0.0386 0.0414
45
40
40
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0422 0.0182
41
38
22
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 -0.0862 0.0364
49
26
62
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 -0.1135 0.0165
45
19
39
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.1188 0.0225
38
17
13
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.1191 0.0210
42
17
26
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.1582 0.0176
37
9
11
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.1592 0.0159
36
9
10
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.1708 0.0161
39
8
15
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.1878 0.0201
35
6
7
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.2239 0.0228
32
4
4
378
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.3998 0.0143
62
99
98
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.3356 0.0148
63
98
98
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.3069 0.0152
60
97
95
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 0.2966 0.0147
56
97
87
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.2220 0.0177
58
95
92
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.1989 0.0206
58
93
91
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.1493 0.0378
57
87
90
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 0.1359 0.0149
53
84
79
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.1283 0.0165
52
83
74
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 0.0965 0.0170
49
79
62
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0949 0.0199
53
78
79
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 0.0025 0.0193
49
56
59
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 -0.0133 0.0345
58
51
92
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 -0.0443 0.0372
49
37
62
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0456 0.0185
41
37
22
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 -0.0561 0.0168
45
34
39
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 -0.1027 0.0422
45
20
40
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.1082 0.0214
42
19
26
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.1321 0.0230
38
14
13
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.1613 0.0162
36
9
10
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.1619 0.0179
37
9
11
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.1680 0.0165
39
8
15
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.1778 0.0205
35
7
7
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.1969 0.0233
32
5
4
379
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gwinnett
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
380
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.3856 0.0120
65
99
99
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.3480 0.0149
63
98
98
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.3280 0.0132
63
98
99
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.2489 0.0148
62
96
97
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.2430 0.0150
60
95
96
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.2350 0.0139
60
95
97
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.2059 0.0172
59
94
94
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.1940 0.0168
60
93
95
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.1879 0.0173
57
92
88
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.1848 0.0123
57
92
89
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.1776 0.0166
60
90
95
Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.1770 0.0138
58
90
94
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.1765 0.0176
54
90
83
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1721 0.0135
56
89
86
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.1670 0.0114
57
89
88
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.1585 0.0151
55
88
84
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.1378 0.0115
57
84
90
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.1083 0.0140
55
80
84
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth
0
0 0.0901 0.0768
46
76
47
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0875 0.0128
52
75
73
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.0768 0.0150
54
73
82
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0745 0.0123
51
72
69
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0598 0.0127
50
69
67
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
1
0 0.0566 0.0315
47
69
50
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.0510 0.0144
48
67
58
381
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Snellville Middle School Louise Radloff Middle School Grace Snell Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0455 0.0183
53
66
77
0
0 0.0455 0.0134
50
66
63
0
0 0.0316 0.0166
49
62
62
0
0 -0.0418 0.1170
32
38
3
0
0 -0.2022 0.0721
37
5
11
382
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.4002 0.0122
65
99
99
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.3749 0.0152
63
98
98
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.3090 0.0134
63
97
99
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.2488 0.0153
60
96
96
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.2458 0.0151
62
95
97
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.2160 0.0142
60
94
97
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.2098 0.0116
57
94
88
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.2077 0.0176
59
93
94
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.1928 0.0124
57
92
89
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.1925 0.0170
60
92
95
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.1893 0.0176
57
92
88
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.1818 0.0171
60
91
95
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.1698 0.0154
55
89
84
Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.1650 0.0141
58
88
94
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1592 0.0138
56
88
86
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.1581 0.0179
54
87
83
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.1388 0.0117
57
85
90
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.1284 0.0141
55
84
84
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth
0
0 0.1091 0.0784
46
81
47
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0995 0.0125
51
79
69
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.0812 0.0151
54
75
82
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0717 0.0130
52
73
73
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0691 0.0129
50
73
67
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.0562 0.0147
48
69
58
Louise Radloff Middle School
0
0 0.0508 0.0135
50
68
63
383
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Snellville Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Grace Snell Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0268 0.0187
53
61
77
1
0 0.0104 0.0321
47
58
50
0
0 -0.0043 0.0169
49
53
62
0
0 -0.1268 0.1193
32
15
3
0
0 -0.1990 0.0735
37
4
11
384
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
385
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.0187 0.0381
32
47
3
Clay County Middle School
0
0 -0.0191 0.0577
33
47
4
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0638 0.0479
42
32
25
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.0801 0.0236
39
28
16
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1047 0.0642
34
22
5
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.1327 0.0434
32
14
3
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.0395 0.0389
32
40
3
Clay County Middle School
0
0 -0.0564 0.0589
33
34
4
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.0839 0.0655
34
26
5
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0901 0.0489
42
24
25
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.1009 0.0241
39
21
16
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.1616 0.0443
32
9
3
386
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
387
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 0.2345 0.0388
63
96
98
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.1763 0.0329
60
92
95
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.1143 0.0332
60
83
94
Long Middle School
0
0 0.0969 0.0215
57
79
89
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0288 0.0174
51
60
58
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.0158 0.0325
58
56
91
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 0.0105 0.0415
48
53
33
Price Middle School
0
0 0.0000 0.0303
53
50
68
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0139 0.0229
50
45
45
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.0459 0.0307
53
34
66
Coan Middle School
0
0 -0.0463 0.0350
49
33
38
Sutton Middle School
0
0 -0.0792 0.0141
46
26
23
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.0797 0.0697
62
26
97
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0851 0.0257
49
25
39
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.1034 0.0211
45
20
17
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 -0.1131 0.0314
48
19
32
Brown Middle School
0
0 -0.1216 0.0213
48
16
34
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.1265 0.0290
48
15
36
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.1270 0.0346
40
15
5
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.1563 0.0225
44
12
16
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.1800 0.0596
41
9
6
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.1862 0.0170
43
8
13
Kindezi
0
1 -0.1862 0.1054
52
8
65
Hillside Conant School
0
0 -0.2058 0.1292
31
6
2
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 -0.2095 0.0413
47
5
30
388
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
APS-Forrest Hills Academey Heritage Preparatory Academy School
0
0 -0.2717 0.0862
34
3
3
1
0 -0.2722 0.0392
40
2
6
389
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 0.2217 0.0392
63
95
98
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.1586 0.0332
60
91
95
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.1077 0.0335
60
82
94
Long Middle School
0
0 0.1023 0.0217
57
80
89
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0328 0.0175
51
61
58
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 0.0127 0.0419
48
54
33
Price Middle School
0
0 0.0071 0.0306
53
52
68
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.0033 0.0328
58
51
91
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.0149 0.0310
53
43
66
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0387 0.0231
50
36
45
Sutton Middle School
0
0 -0.0572 0.0142
46
31
23
Coan Middle School
0
0 -0.0639 0.0353
49
29
38
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.0762 0.0703
62
26
97
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0913 0.0260
49
23
39
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.1060 0.0213
45
20
17
Brown Middle School
0
0 -0.1213 0.0215
48
17
34
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.1271 0.0350
40
16
5
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.1369 0.0292
48
14
36
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 -0.1428 0.0317
48
13
32
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.1606 0.0227
44
10
16
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.1629 0.0602
41
10
6
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.1717 0.0172
43
8
13
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 -0.1946 0.0416
47
6
30
Kindezi
0
1 -0.2209 0.1064
52
5
65
Heritage Preparatory Academy School
1
0 -0.2377 0.0396
40
4
6
390
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Hillside Conant School APS-Forrest Hills Academey
0
0 -0.2404 0.1304
31
3
2
0
0 -0.3928 0.0869
34
1
3
391
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
392
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.1743 0.0395
54
91
74
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 -0.0018 0.0210
50
49
48
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 -0.0237 0.0208
47
41
28
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0416 0.0220
47
36
25
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2693 0.0641
35
3
3
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.1739 0.0399
54
92
74
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 -0.0198 0.0212
50
42
48
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0371 0.0222
47
37
25
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 -0.0497 0.0210
47
33
28
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2421 0.0647
35
3
3
393
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
394
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.2306 0.0467
44
96
14
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.1907 0.0469
52
93
62
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.1248 0.0156
51
85
59
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.1121 0.0134
55
83
78
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.1031 0.0162
56
81
84
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0841 0.0183
57
75
88
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0573 0.0300
47
69
27
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 0.0381 0.0589
39
62
5
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0374 0.0142
51
62
59
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0263 0.0154
47
40
27
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 -0.0456 0.0593
52
34
65
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0649 0.0545
54
29
74
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0853 0.0697
49
24
38
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.1048 0.0473
47
20
28
Rusk Middle School
0
0 -0.1222 0.0182
46
16
20
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.1426 0.0578
44
13
14
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.2628 0.0561
41
3
7
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.2868 0.0679
40
2
6
395
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.2590 0.0470
44
96
14
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 0.2020 0.0472
52
95
62
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.1351 0.0157
51
87
59
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.1272 0.0135
55
85
78
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.1110 0.0164
56
82
84
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0826 0.0184
57
76
88
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0647 0.0303
47
71
27
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 0.0601 0.0594
39
70
5
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0474 0.0143
51
66
59
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 -0.0031 0.0598
52
47
65
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0132 0.0156
47
44
27
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.0421 0.0550
54
35
74
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 -0.0601 0.0476
47
30
28
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.0846 0.0703
49
24
38
Rusk Middle School
0
0 -0.1195 0.0183
46
18
20
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.1360 0.0583
44
14
14
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.2391 0.0566
41
4
7
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.2597 0.0685
40
3
6
396
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Coweta
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
397
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
East Coweta Middle School
0
0 0.1365 0.0197
58
87
90
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.0886 0.0873
50
77
51
Arnall Middle School
0
0 0.0223 0.0180
52
58
60
Madras Middle School
0
0 0.0139 0.0165
49
54
38
Smokey Road Middle School
0
0 0.0110 0.0198
49
53
39
Lee Middle School
0
0 0.0010 0.0174
49
50
39
Evans Middle School
0
0 -0.0539 0.0193
45
32
20
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
East Coweta Middle School
0
0 0.1424 0.0198
58
88
90
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 0.1032 0.0881
50
81
51
Arnall Middle School
0
0 0.0374 0.0182
52
62
60
Lee Middle School
0
0 0.0269 0.0175
49
59
39
Madras Middle School
0
0 0.0225 0.0167
49
57
38
Smokey Road Middle School
0
0 0.0086 0.0199
49
53
39
Evans Middle School
0
0 -0.0526 0.0195
45
32
20
398
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
399
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1006 0.0779
44
80
16
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.0845 0.0430
55
75
81
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.0713 0.0310
64
73
98
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.0554 0.0632
53
68
69
Henderson Middle School
0
0 0.0251 0.0140
51
59
54
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 0.0132 0.0182
56
54
85
Tucker Middle School
0
0 -0.0107 0.0156
53
46
70
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 -0.0133 0.0517
40
45
5
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0233 0.0176
50
41
51
International Student Center
0
0 -0.0272 0.0540
43
40
10
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0471 0.0173
51
33
53
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.0556 0.0181
53
31
70
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 -0.0671 0.0157
50
29
49
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.0695 0.0185
50
29
47
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 -0.0781 0.0183
46
27
22
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0809 0.0164
50
25
46
Redan Middle School
0
0 -0.0823 0.0198
51
25
52
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.0839 0.0176
49
25
42
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 -0.0894 0.0178
51
23
57
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 -0.1145 0.0184
48
18
33
Salem Middle School
0
0 -0.1573 0.0169
45
12
18
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
1
0 -0.1601 0.0507
41
12
6
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.1629 0.0189
45
11
17
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 -0.1643 0.0148
45
10
18
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 -0.1668 0.0367
46
10
23
400
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl DeKalb Academy of Technology and the McNair Middle School Cedar Grove Middle School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
1
0 -0.1849 0.0536
43
0
1 -0.1914 0.0341
40
0
0 -0.2005 0.0220
39
0
0 -0.2692 0.0185
36
0
0 -0.3140 0.0424
32
8
11
8
6
6
5
3
3
2
2
401
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Kittredge Magnet School
0
0 0.1489 0.0434
55
89
81
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.1292 0.0786
44
86
16
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.0715 0.0312
64
73
98
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.0695 0.0637
53
73
69
Henderson Middle School
0
0 0.0593 0.0141
51
69
54
International Student Center
0
0 0.0556 0.0541
43
67
10
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 0.0378 0.0184
56
63
85
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.0273 0.0522
40
59
5
Tucker Middle School
0
0 0.0100 0.0157
53
53
70
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0041 0.0178
50
47
51
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0265 0.0174
51
40
53
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 -0.0402 0.0184
46
35
22
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 -0.0416 0.0156
50
35
49
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.0548 0.0183
53
32
70
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.0668 0.0187
50
28
47
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 -0.0693 0.0180
51
27
57
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.0780 0.0177
49
25
42
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0814 0.0166
50
25
46
Redan Middle School
0
0 -0.0864 0.0200
51
24
52
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 -0.0992 0.0185
48
21
33
Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
1
0 -0.1088 0.0512
41
19
6
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 -0.1275 0.0149
45
16
18
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 -0.1281 0.0344
40
16
6
Leadership Preparatory Academy
0
1 -0.1344 0.0371
46
14
23
Salem Middle School
0
0 -0.1480 0.0171
45
12
18
402
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School McNair Middle School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Cedar Grove Middle School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts
0
0 -0.1674 0.0190
45
0
0 -0.2010 0.0222
39
1
0 -0.2312 0.0541
43
0
0 -0.2579 0.0186
36
0
0 -0.2952 0.0428
32
9
17
6
5
4
11
3
3
2
2
403
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
404
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.2305 0.0372
61
96
95
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.1295 0.0147
56
86
85
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.1209 0.0149
53
84
71
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.1105 0.0176
55
82
79
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 0.0608 0.0179
55
71
79
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.0570 0.0142
54
69
77
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0474 0.0162
52
65
62
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 0.0382 0.0145
53
63
70
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0275 0.0196
51
59
59
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0256 0.0201
51
59
55
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 0.0005 0.0361
53
50
67
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0164 0.0223
51
44
57
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 -0.0323 0.0341
58
39
90
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 -0.0370 0.0165
46
38
24
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 -0.0488 0.0147
47
32
27
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.0542 0.0173
46
32
23
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 -0.0544 0.0168
48
31
34
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 -0.0739 0.0186
46
28
24
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 -0.1017 0.0405
48
20
37
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.1044 0.0195
44
20
15
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.1266 0.0156
46
15
22
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.1389 0.0207
45
13
19
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.2005 0.0161
42
6
8
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.2192 0.0228
43
4
12
405
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.2630 0.0376
61
97
95
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.1571 0.0150
53
90
71
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.1552 0.0148
56
90
85
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.1350 0.0177
55
87
79
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.0842 0.0143
54
76
77
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0743 0.0163
52
74
62
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 0.0680 0.0146
53
72
70
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 0.0574 0.0181
55
68
79
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0466 0.0197
51
66
59
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0464 0.0202
51
66
55
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 0.0350 0.0364
53
61
67
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 -0.0102 0.0166
46
45
24
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 -0.0245 0.0149
47
41
27
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 -0.0328 0.0169
48
38
34
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0329 0.0224
51
38
57
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 -0.0648 0.0344
58
29
90
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 -0.0657 0.0188
46
29
24
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.0678 0.0175
46
28
23
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 -0.1023 0.0409
48
21
37
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.1089 0.0196
44
19
15
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.1340 0.0157
46
15
22
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.1353 0.0209
45
14
19
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.1977 0.0163
42
6
8
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.1999 0.0230
43
6
12
406
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gwinnett
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
407
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.2823 0.0138
58
97
90
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.2085 0.0168
59
95
93
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.1964 0.0180
58
94
91
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.1923 0.0146
57
93
86
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.1703 0.0150
55
91
82
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.1593 0.0148
58
90
91
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.1587 0.0171
57
90
88
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.1559 0.0133
55
90
79
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.1553 0.0164
56
89
84
Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.1369 0.0137
50
88
50
Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE
0
0 0.1334 0.1334
51
86
55
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.1332 0.0151
58
86
91
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.1213 0.0114
52
84
64
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.1134 0.0142
55
83
82
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.1077 0.0128
55
81
82
Louise Radloff Middle School
0
0 0.0977 0.0131
52
79
63
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0952 0.0122
53
78
68
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.0897 0.0164
53
77
70
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0844 0.0122
52
75
60
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.0753 0.0171
56
74
85
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.0684 0.0120
52
72
63
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.0578 0.0137
54
69
75
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.0557 0.0172
54
68
75
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.0493 0.0134
52
66
60
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0411 0.0115
50
64
50
408
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Sweetwater Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Pinckneyville Middle School New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0349 0.0127
51
61
58
0
0 0.0348 0.1219
38
61
4
0
0 0.0237 0.0152
50
58
48
0
0 -0.0389 0.0779
55
38
81
1
0 -0.0943 0.0314
44
22
13
0
0 -0.1669 0.0731
42
10
9
409
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.2683 0.0139
58
97
90
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.2002 0.0169
59
95
93
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.1876 0.0148
57
94
86
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.1852 0.0151
55
93
82
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.1833 0.0182
58
93
91
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.1525 0.0148
58
90
91
Berkmar Middle School
0
0 0.1499 0.0171
57
89
88
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.1450 0.0134
55
89
79
Hull Middle School
0
0 0.1432 0.0115
52
88
64
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.1395 0.0152
58
88
91
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.1374 0.0165
56
87
84
Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.1264 0.0138
50
85
50
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.1084 0.0142
55
82
82
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0966 0.0123
52
79
60
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0924 0.0129
55
78
82
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.0924 0.0166
53
78
70
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0921 0.0123
53
78
68
Louise Radloff Middle School
0
0 0.0898 0.0131
52
78
63
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.0772 0.0173
56
75
85
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.0764 0.0121
52
75
63
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.0617 0.0137
54
70
75
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.0433 0.0135
52
65
60
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.0373 0.0173
54
62
75
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.0363 0.0116
50
62
50
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0327 0.0127
51
61
58
410
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Pinckneyville Middle School New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0258 0.0153
50
58
48
0
0 0.0006 0.0786
55
49
81
0
0 -0.0054 0.1346
51
46
55
0
0 -0.1221 0.1229
38
17
4
1
0 -0.1582 0.0317
44
10
13
0
0 -0.1750 0.0738
42
8
9
411
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
412
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Middle School
0
0 0.0421 0.0578
65
64
99
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0976 0.0484
47
21
30
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.1221 0.0237
50
16
47
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1608 0.0631
42
11
9
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.1993 0.0387
42
7
8
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.2642 0.0432
32
3
2
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County Middle School
0
0 0.0038 0.0583
65
51
99
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.1080 0.0489
47
20
30
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.1443 0.0240
50
13
47
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1528 0.0637
42
11
9
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.2359 0.0390
42
4
8
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.2711 0.0436
32
2
2
413
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies
APS District
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Atlanta Heights
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
414
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.4332 0.0336
68
98
98
Brown Middle School
0
0 0.2742 0.0216
63
95
97
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.2706 0.0333
57
94
86
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.1302 0.0328
56
81
86
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0889 0.0176
49
71
52
Price Middle School
0
0 0.0535 0.0306
54
63
80
Kindezi
0
1 -0.0036 0.1087
58
48
90
Sutton Middle School
0
0 -0.0093 0.0143
48
47
42
Coan Middle School
0
0 -0.0183 0.0353
48
44
42
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.0216 0.0228
52
43
71
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0333 0.0261
51
40
62
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 -0.0414 0.0317
54
37
76
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.0435 0.0310
49
37
53
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0793 0.0293
49
29
48
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.0795 0.0214
42
28
20
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 -0.0893 0.0416
50
27
59
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0998 0.0231
49
26
47
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 -0.1570 0.0418
45
17
31
Hillside Conant School
0
0 -0.1746 0.1348
31
16
2
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.1948 0.0703
44
13
27
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.2093 0.0172
39
13
12
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 -0.2346 0.0391
40
9
13
Long Middle School
0
0 -0.2368 0.0217
39
8
13
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.3863 0.0602
35
2
4
APS-Forrest Hills Academey
0
0 -0.4010 0.0909
26
2
1
415
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Atlanta Charter Middle School Heritage Preparatory Academy School
0
1 -0.4100 0.0350
35
2
5
1
0 -0.4908 0.0396
27
1
1
416
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad
0
1 0.4260 0.0339
68
98
98
Brown Middle School
0
0 0.2778 0.0218
63
95
97
Kipp Strive Academy
0
1 0.2540 0.0336
57
93
86
KIPP VISION
0
1 0.1241 0.0331
56
81
86
Inman Middle School
0
0 0.0916 0.0177
49
72
52
Price Middle School
0
0 0.0644 0.0309
54
65
80
Sutton Middle School
0
0 0.0109 0.0144
48
52
42
The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso
0
0 -0.0120 0.0313
49
46
53
Harper-Archer Middle School
0
0 -0.0244 0.0230
52
42
71
Coan Middle School
0
0 -0.0362 0.0357
48
39
42
King Middle School
0
0 -0.0372 0.0263
51
38
62
Kindezi
0
1 -0.0398 0.1098
58
37
90
Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad
0
0 -0.0621 0.0320
54
32
76
Imagine Wesley International Academy
0
1 -0.0773 0.0420
50
29
59
Bunche Middle School
0
0 -0.0777 0.0216
42
29
20
Charles R. Drew Charter School
0
1 -0.0863 0.0296
49
27
48
Sylvan Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.1206 0.0233
49
21
47
Atlanta Heights Charter School
1
0 -0.1504 0.0422
45
18
31
Kennedy Middle School
0
0 -0.1863 0.0710
44
14
27
Young Middle School
0
0 -0.1914 0.0174
39
13
12
Long Middle School
0
0 -0.2285 0.0219
39
9
13
Latin Academy Charter School
0
1 -0.2372 0.0395
40
8
13
Hillside Conant School
0
0 -0.2427 0.1360
31
8
2
Intown Charter Academy
0
1 -0.3629 0.0608
35
3
4
Atlanta Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.4095 0.0353
35
2
5
417
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Heritage Preparatory Academy School APS-Forrest Hills Academey
1
0 -0.4490 0.0399
27
1
1
0
0 -0.5490 0.0917
26
1
1
418
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
419
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 0.0608 0.0210
55
66
82
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 0.0331 0.0213
48
57
42
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0136 0.0222
48
46
46
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0384 0.0399
52
39
70
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2460 0.0647
38
8
8
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Southeast Bulloch Middle School
0
0 0.0311 0.0212
55
57
82
Langston Chapel Middle School
0
0 0.0133 0.0215
48
52
42
William James Middle School
0
0 -0.0117 0.0224
48
46
46
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0360 0.0403
52
39
70
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2198 0.0653
38
11
8
420
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
421
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.3096 0.0471
45
96
32
Rusk Middle School
0
0 0.2933 0.0184
64
96
97
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.2624 0.0477
46
94
36
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.2577 0.0303
51
93
64
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.1473 0.0164
57
83
87
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.0851 0.0136
54
70
76
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0565 0.0185
55
64
84
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.0342 0.0599
63
57
96
Creekland Middle School
0
0 -0.0628 0.0144
50
33
58
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0640 0.0156
42
32
20
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0663 0.0157
49
32
54
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1203 0.0685
49
22
54
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1621 0.0595
34
16
3
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.2263 0.0570
43
10
23
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.2454 0.0473
44
8
26
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.2622 0.0704
51
7
64
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.2923 0.0584
42
5
20
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.3298 0.0551
48
4
43
422
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Holly Springs Elementary School
0
0 0.3301 0.0475
45
96
32
Rusk Middle School
0
0 0.3006 0.0185
64
96
97
Indian Knoll Elementary
0
0 0.2964 0.0481
46
95
36
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.2615 0.0306
51
94
64
Woodstock Middle School
0
0 0.1544 0.0166
57
84
87
Booth Middle School
0
0 0.1028 0.0137
54
75
76
Hickory Flat Elementary School
0
0 0.0689 0.0604
63
66
96
Teasley Middle School
0
0 0.0582 0.0186
55
63
84
Mill Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0519 0.0157
42
35
20
Creekland Middle School
0
0 -0.0539 0.0145
50
34
58
Freedom Middle School
0
0 -0.0563 0.0159
49
34
54
Ball Ground Elementary School
0
0 -0.1023 0.0692
49
24
54
Mountain Road Elementary School
0
0 -0.1516 0.0600
34
18
3
William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho
0
0 -0.2147 0.0575
43
11
23
J. Knox Elementary
0
0 -0.2445 0.0477
44
7
26
Clayton Elementary School
0
0 -0.2719 0.0710
51
6
64
R. M. Moore Elementary School
0
0 -0.2939 0.0589
42
5
20
Canton Elementary
0
0 -0.3165 0.0555
48
4
43
423
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Coweta
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Coweta
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Coweta
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
424
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Madras Middle School
0
0 0.2220 0.0167
54
91
79
East Coweta Middle School
0
0 0.2184 0.0198
58
90
89
Arnall Middle School
0
0 0.0595 0.0183
52
65
72
Smokey Road Middle School
0
0 -0.0049 0.0200
45
48
33
Lee Middle School
0
0 -0.0951 0.0175
44
26
29
Evans Middle School
0
0 -0.1152 0.0196
43
23
23
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 -0.2374 0.0881
50
8
58
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Madras Middle School
0
0 0.2294 0.0169
54
92
79
East Coweta Middle School
0
0 0.2254 0.0200
58
91
89
Arnall Middle School
0
0 0.0746 0.0184
52
68
72
Smokey Road Middle School
0
0 -0.0061 0.0202
45
48
33
Lee Middle School
0
0 -0.0699 0.0177
44
31
29
Evans Middle School
0
0 -0.1132 0.0198
43
23
23
Coweta Charter Academy
1
0 -0.2296 0.0890
50
9
58
425
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
DeKalb
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep. - Young Mens
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
426
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.5505 0.0786
55
99
81
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.2526 0.0313
59
93
92
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.2465 0.0638
71
92
99
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.1250 0.0522
52
80
70
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.0959 0.0177
53
74
73
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 0.0511 0.0160
48
62
43
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 0.0447 0.0185
50
60
61
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 0.0425 0.0183
51
60
63
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 0.0395 0.0150
48
59
41
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0226 0.0179
48
43
40
Tucker Middle School
0
0 -0.0404 0.0159
46
38
35
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0516 0.0166
49
36
50
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.0557 0.0191
47
35
39
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 -0.0629 0.0184
45
33
32
Henderson Middle School
0
0 -0.0649 0.0141
45
32
33
Redan Middle School
0
0 -0.0706 0.0199
47
31
38
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 -0.0737 0.0185
46
30
34
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.1076 0.0177
44
24
26
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 -0.1125 0.0541
35
24
4
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 -0.1424 0.0180
44
18
26
International Student Center
0
0 -0.1543 0.0532
36
17
5
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.1802 0.0187
40
15
15
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.1817 0.0222
41
15
16
Cedar Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.2169 0.0186
41
11
15
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 -0.2607 0.0344
36
7
6
427
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Leadership Preparatory Academy DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Salem Middle School Kittredge Magnet School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
0
1 -0.2690 0.0371
34
6
4
0
0 -0.2801 0.0429
34
5
4
0
0 -0.2922 0.0171
38
5
9
0
0 -0.3915 0.0435
31
2
2
1
0 -0.4151 0.0511
28
2
2
428
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Museum School Avondale Estates
0
1 0.5724 0.0794
55
99
81
DeKalb School of the Arts
0
0 0.2708 0.0643
71
94
99
DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School
0
1 0.2494 0.0315
59
93
92
Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi
0
0 0.1570 0.0527
52
85
70
Freedom Middle School
0
0 0.1059 0.0178
53
76
73
Chamblee Middle School
0
0 0.0798 0.0186
50
70
61
Peachtree Middle School
0
1 0.0717 0.0152
48
67
41
Sequoyah Middle School
0
0 0.0687 0.0159
48
66
43
Miller Grove Middle School
0
0 0.0486 0.0185
51
61
63
Druid Hills Middle School
0
0 -0.0065 0.0180
48
47
40
Tucker Middle School
0
0 -0.0214 0.0160
46
43
35
The Champion Middle Theme School
0
0 -0.0314 0.0186
45
40
32
Henderson Middle School
0
0 -0.0325 0.0143
45
39
33
Lithonia Middle School
0
0 -0.0478 0.0168
49
35
50
Chapel Hill Middle School
0
0 -0.0532 0.0187
46
34
34
Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School
0
0 -0.0590 0.0193
47
33
39
Redan Middle School
0
0 -0.0687 0.0201
47
31
38
Columbia Middle School
0
0 -0.0972 0.0179
44
25
26
Stephenson Middle School
0
0 -0.1171 0.0181
44
22
26
International Student Center
0
0 -0.1218 0.0533
36
21
5
Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl
1
0 -0.1469 0.0546
35
18
4
Stone Mountain Middle School
0
0 -0.1753 0.0188
40
15
15
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.1792 0.0225
41
15
16
DeKalb Academy of Technology and the
0
1 -0.1946 0.0347
36
13
6
Cedar Grove Middle School
0
0 -0.2001 0.0188
41
13
15
429
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Leadership Preparatory Academy DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Salem Middle School Kittredge Magnet School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi
0
1 -0.2287 0.0374
34
9
4
0
0 -0.2570 0.0433
34
7
4
0
0 -0.2791 0.0172
38
6
9
0
0 -0.3427 0.0438
31
3
2
1
0 -0.3562 0.0517
28
3
2
430
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
431
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 0.4632 0.0344
69
98
99
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.1991 0.0148
57
88
86
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.1460 0.0377
63
83
96
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.1203 0.0151
55
79
82
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.1177 0.0409
53
78
75
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.1011 0.0178
54
75
79
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 0.0917 0.0149
50
72
56
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0509 0.0164
51
62
66
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0318 0.0203
50
56
60
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.0254 0.0143
48
55
45
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 -0.0189 0.0199
49
44
49
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 -0.0551 0.0147
48
35
42
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 -0.0612 0.0188
45
34
33
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.0736 0.0163
44
30
26
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0831 0.0225
45
28
33
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.0840 0.0175
45
28
32
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.1006 0.0158
45
25
31
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 -0.1188 0.0168
40
23
15
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 -0.1315 0.0170
41
20
16
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.1863 0.0181
42
14
19
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.2147 0.0211
38
11
10
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 -0.2396 0.0365
42
8
19
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.2760 0.0196
40
6
14
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.3306 0.0230
35
3
4
432
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
KIPP South Fulton Academy School
0
1 0.4349 0.0348
69
98
99
Webb Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.2198 0.0150
57
91
86
Amana Academy School
0
1 0.1739 0.0380
63
87
96
Hopewell Middle School
0
0 0.1526 0.0152
55
84
82
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.1234 0.0413
53
81
75
Crabapple Middle School
0
0 0.1209 0.0179
54
80
79
Northwestern Middle School
0
0 0.1115 0.0150
50
79
56
Elkins Pointe Middle School
0
0 0.0725 0.0165
51
68
66
Haynes Bridge Middle School
0
0 0.0489 0.0205
50
61
60
River Trail Middle School
0
0 0.0471 0.0145
48
60
45
Holcomb Bridge Middle School
0
0 -0.0030 0.0201
49
48
49
Autrey Mill Middle School
0
0 -0.0310 0.0148
48
40
42
Sandy Springs Middle School
0
0 -0.0541 0.0190
45
34
33
Sandtown Middle School
0
0 -0.0647 0.0164
44
32
26
Ridgeview Charter School
0
1 -0.0946 0.0169
40
25
15
Camp Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.0959 0.0227
45
25
33
Woodland Middle School
0
0 -0.0969 0.0177
45
25
32
Renaissance Middle School
0
0 -0.1043 0.0159
45
24
31
Taylor Road Middle School
0
0 -0.1150 0.0171
41
22
16
Bear Creek Middle School
0
0 -0.1853 0.0183
42
14
19
Main Street Charter Academy Middle
0
0 -0.1954 0.0368
42
13
19
Paul D. West Middle School
0
0 -0.2103 0.0213
38
12
10
McNair Middle School
0
0 -0.2779 0.0198
40
6
14
Hapeville Charter Middle School
0
1 -0.3012 0.0232
35
4
4
433
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gwinnett
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Ivy Prep.
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
434
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.3980 0.0140
60
98
94
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.3212 0.0134
58
96
91
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.3011 0.0122
58
96
91
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.2870 0.0152
61
95
94
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.2790 0.0166
56
95
85
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.2746 0.0173
59
95
93
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.2711 0.0152
58
95
91
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.2670 0.0170
56
94
85
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.2244 0.0148
56
91
85
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.2211 0.0116
55
91
81
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1924 0.0136
53
88
75
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.1717 0.0165
53
85
73
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.1584 0.0182
55
84
82
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.1294 0.0149
54
81
76
Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE
0
0 0.1264 0.1347
45
81
29
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.1203 0.0174
50
79
62
Louise Radloff Middle School
0
0 0.1186 0.0133
53
78
75
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0991 0.0130
51
75
62
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0920 0.0124
48
73
43
Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.0891 0.0139
48
72
41
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.0880 0.0139
51
71
65
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.0767 0.0154
49
69
50
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0627 0.0129
46
66
36
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.0590 0.0143
51
65
67
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0417 0.0123
47
60
39
435
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Hull Middle School Berkmar Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus
0
0 0.0374 0.0786
51
58
66
0
0 0.0292 0.0116
49
56
51
0
0 0.0238 0.0173
47
54
37
1
0 -0.0117 0.0318
39
46
11
0
0 -0.0622 0.1266
30
33
2
0
0 -0.2330 0.0738
38
9
9
436
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Twin Rivers Middle School
0
0 0.3832 0.0141
60
97
94
Frank N. Osborne Middle School
0
0 0.3076 0.0135
58
96
91
North Gwinnett Middle School
0
0 0.3061 0.0122
58
96
91
Alton C. Crews Middle School
0
0 0.3002 0.0153
61
95
94
Five Forks Middle School
0
0 0.2797 0.0168
56
95
85
Glenn C. Jones Middle School
0
0 0.2758 0.0154
58
95
91
Couch Middle School
0
0 0.2750 0.0175
59
95
93
Bay Creek Middle School
0
0 0.2599 0.0171
56
94
85
Lanier Middle School
0
0 0.2183 0.0149
56
91
85
Creekland Middle School
0
0 0.2155 0.0117
55
90
81
McConnell Middle School
0
0 0.1866 0.0137
53
88
75
Grace Snell Middle School
0
0 0.1562 0.0167
53
85
73
Snellville Middle School
0
0 0.1492 0.0184
55
84
82
Summerour Middle School
0
0 0.1218 0.0149
54
81
76
Louise Radloff Middle School
0
0 0.1114 0.0133
53
79
75
Moore Middle School
0
0 0.1019 0.0175
50
74
62
Lilburn Middle School
0
0 0.0890 0.0139
51
71
65
Duluth Middle School
0
0 0.0876 0.0124
48
71
43
Shiloh Middle School
0
0 0.0867 0.0131
51
71
62
Dacula Middle School
0
0 0.0786 0.0140
48
69
41
New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth
0
0 0.0779 0.0794
51
69
66
Pinckneyville Middle School
0
0 0.0768 0.0155
49
68
50
Sweetwater Middle School
0
0 0.0609 0.0129
46
64
36
Richards Middle School
0
0 0.0564 0.0144
51
63
67
Trickum Middle School
0
0 0.0527 0.0124
47
62
39
437
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Hull Middle School Berkmar Middle School Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente
0
0 0.0487 0.0116
49
61
51
0
0 0.0165 0.0174
47
53
37
0
0 -0.0425 0.1360
45
37
29
1
0 -0.0678 0.0321
39
32
11
0
0 -0.2355 0.0745
38
8
9
0
0 -0.2361 0.1277
30
8
2
438
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
439
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.0104 0.0488
47
51
39
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.0387 0.0240
48
39
40
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.0716 0.0391
46
30
35
Clay County Middle School
0
0 -0.1036 0.0583
37
25
7
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1246 0.0637
51
21
63
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.3059 0.0436
34
4
3
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0016 0.0493
47
49
39
Early County Middle School
0
0 -0.0590 0.0242
48
34
40
Randolph Clay Middle School
0
0 -0.1018 0.0395
46
24
35
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.1188 0.0643
51
22
63
Clay County Middle School
0
0 -0.1345 0.0589
37
20
7
Calhoun County Middle School
0
0 -0.3068 0.0441
34
4
3
440
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
CCAT
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
CCAT
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
441
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.2471 0.0611
59
97
93
CCAT School
1
0 0.0928 0.1217
55
79
76
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.0620 0.0254
47
28
24
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 -0.1286 0.0348
42
11
7
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.2507 0.0622
59
96
93
CCAT School
1
0 0.1630 0.1243
55
92
76
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.1015 0.0259
47
17
24
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 -0.1718 0.0356
42
7
7
442
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
443
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
River Ridge High School
0
0 0.0863 0.0267
47
76
26
Sequoyah High School
0
0 0.0806 0.0248
47
75
24
Creekview High School
0
0 0.0760 0.0236
45
74
15
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0709 0.1070
44
73
12
Etowah High School
0
0 0.0345 0.0205
44
60
12
Woodstock High School
0
0 -0.0095 0.0221
44
47
12
Cherokee High School
0
0 -0.0212 0.0211
46
43
19
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Creekview High School
0
0 0.0861 0.0241
45
76
15
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0809 0.1093
44
75
12
Sequoyah High School
0
0 0.0781 0.0253
47
74
24
River Ridge High School
0
0 0.0776 0.0273
47
74
26
Etowah High School
0
0 0.0295 0.0210
44
59
12
Cherokee High School
0
0 -0.0096 0.0216
46
47
19
Woodstock High School
0
0 -0.0241 0.0225
44
42
12
444
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
445
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Chattahoochee High School
0
1 0.2908 0.0238
57
98
88
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.2808 0.0684
64
98
98
Alpharetta High School
0
0 0.2131 0.0240
56
96
85
Riverwood International Charter Schoo
0
0 0.2117 0.0287
59
96
92
Fulton Science Academy High School
0
1 0.2081 0.0900
58
96
90
Westlake High School
0
0 0.1496 0.0227
54
91
73
Johns Creek High School
0
0 0.1480 0.0238
52
90
61
Roswell High School
0
0 0.1297 0.0229
52
87
59
Milton High School
0
0 0.1204 0.0237
51
85
48
Northview High School
0
0 0.0969 0.0252
52
80
59
North Springs High School
0
1 0.0850 0.0272
50
76
44
Cambridge High School
0
0 0.0468 0.0236
49
66
42
Langston Hughes High School
0
0 0.0454 0.0235
51
65
50
McClarin Alternative School
0
0 0.0380 0.1150
49
63
41
Hapeville Charter Career Academy
0
1 0.0331 0.0373
49
60
41
Centennial High School
0
0 0.0138 0.0238
50
53
46
Creekside High School
0
0 -0.0288 0.0259
48
40
29
Tri-Cities High School
0
0 -0.0320 0.0254
50
39
45
Banneker High School
0
0 -0.0378 0.0279
49
38
42
446
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Chattahoochee High School
0
1 0.3025 0.0243
57
98
88
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.2424 0.0698
64
96
98
Alpharetta High School
0
0 0.2247 0.0246
56
96
85
Fulton Science Academy High School
0
1 0.2097 0.0921
58
95
90
Riverwood International Charter Schoo
0
0 0.2067 0.0292
59
94
92
Johns Creek High School
0
0 0.1702 0.0243
52
92
61
Westlake High School
0
0 0.1448 0.0232
54
88
73
Milton High School
0
0 0.1407 0.0242
51
87
48
Roswell High School
0
0 0.1317 0.0234
52
86
59
Northview High School
0
0 0.0978 0.0258
52
80
59
North Springs High School
0
1 0.0867 0.0278
50
77
44
Cambridge High School
0
0 0.0758 0.0241
49
73
42
Langston Hughes High School
0
0 0.0425 0.0240
51
64
50
Hapeville Charter Career Academy
0
1 0.0420 0.0382
49
64
41
McClarin Alternative School
0
0 0.0397 0.1176
49
62
41
Centennial High School
0
0 0.0172 0.0243
50
55
46
Creekside High School
0
0 -0.0422 0.0265
48
35
29
Tri-Cities High School
0
0 -0.0470 0.0259
50
34
45
Banneker High School
0
0 -0.0483 0.0285
49
33
42
447
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Gwinnett
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Ivy Prep.
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
448
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE
0
0 0.2919 0.1151
58
98
89
Peachtree Ridge High School
0
0 0.1390 0.0189
50
89
44
Parkview High School
0
0 0.1210 0.0193
51
85
52
Shiloh High School
0
0 0.1107 0.0221
51
83
48
Brookwood High School
0
0 0.0865 0.0186
48
77
31
Phoenix High School
0
0 0.0851 0.1096
42
76
8
Gwinnett School of Mathematics, Scien
0
1 0.0753 0.0307
49
74
40
North Gwinnett High School
0
0 0.0601 0.0200
49
70
43
Norcross High School
0
0 0.0599 0.0173
51
70
54
Mill Creek High School
0
0 0.0498 0.0164
48
67
32
Duluth High School
0
0 0.0479 0.0201
52
67
60
Grayson High School
0
0 0.0475 0.0198
47
66
25
Lanier High School
0
0 0.0461 0.0266
53
66
66
Collins Hill High School
0
0 0.0311 0.0189
47
60
25
Dacula High School
0
0 0.0206 0.0233
47
55
26
Central Gwinnett High School
0
0 0.0174 0.0205
48
55
32
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
1
0 -0.0013 0.1295
47
49
24
Meadowcreek High School
0
0 -0.0242 0.0176
49
41
39
Archer High School
0
0 -0.0489 0.0208
42
34
8
South Gwinnett High School
0
0 -0.0533 0.0210
45
33
17
Berkmar High School
0
0 -0.0754 0.0185
46
25
21
Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente
0
0 -0.1167 0.1296
42
14
7
Mountain View High School
0
0 -0.1753 0.0228
39
6
4
449
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Peachtree Ridge High School
0
0 0.1488 0.0192
50
88
44
Parkview High School
0
0 0.0997 0.0197
51
81
52
Shiloh High School
0
0 0.0864 0.0226
51
76
48
Brookwood High School
0
0 0.0782 0.0189
48
74
31
Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE
0
0 0.0686 0.1176
58
71
89
North Gwinnett High School
0
0 0.0607 0.0204
49
70
43
Gwinnett School of Mathematics, Scien
0
1 0.0572 0.0313
49
68
40
Mill Creek High School
0
0 0.0428 0.0167
48
64
32
Ivy Preparatory Academy School
1
0 0.0401 0.1323
47
62
24
Lanier High School
0
0 0.0339 0.0272
53
60
66
Grayson High School
0
0 0.0316 0.0202
47
59
25
Norcross High School
0
0 0.0297 0.0176
51
59
54
Duluth High School
0
0 0.0125 0.0204
52
54
60
Collins Hill High School
0
0 0.0120 0.0192
47
53
25
Dacula High School
0
0 -0.0054 0.0238
47
48
26
Central Gwinnett High School
0
0 -0.0295 0.0208
48
40
32
Archer High School
0
0 -0.0519 0.0213
42
31
8
Phoenix High School
0
0 -0.0532 0.1118
42
31
8
South Gwinnett High School
0
0 -0.0707 0.0215
45
26
17
Meadowcreek High School
0
0 -0.0999 0.0177
49
18
39
Berkmar High School
0
0 -0.1231 0.0186
46
13
21
Mountain View High School
0
0 -0.2064 0.0233
39
6
4
Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente
0
0 -0.3642 0.1323
42
1
7
450
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
451
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Clay County 9th Grade Academy School
0
0 0.4370 0.1261
74
99
99
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.3380 0.0902
68
99
99
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.1294 0.1183
40
87
5
Calhoun County High School
0
0 0.1036 0.0773
40
82
5
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 -0.0461 0.0579
53
35
67
Early County High School
0
0 -0.1374 0.0384
39
10
3
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.3717 0.0921
68
99
99
Clay County 9th Grade Academy School
0
0 0.3540 0.1281
74
99
99
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.1600 0.1208
40
91
5
Calhoun County High School
0
0 0.0456 0.0791
40
66
5
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 -0.0570 0.0592
53
30
67
Early County High School
0
0 -0.1460 0.0393
39
10
3
452
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
453
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.2732 0.0772
57
88
84
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 0.1315 0.0362
54
76
74
Statesboro High School
0
0 0.0521 0.0298
45
63
33
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2954 0.1381
36
5
6
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.2110 0.0791
57
85
84
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 0.0686 0.0370
54
66
74
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.0013 0.0306
45
52
33
CCAT School
1
0 -0.2469 0.1415
36
12
6
454
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
455
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.3292 0.1337
78
92
99
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.2466 0.1227
56
87
81
Calhoun County High School
0
0 0.0344 0.0722
47
60
43
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 -0.1360 0.0611
40
27
15
Early County High School
0
0 -0.2741 0.0487
32
7
2
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.3199 0.1370
78
91
99
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.2711 0.1257
56
88
81
Calhoun County High School
0
0 -0.0520 0.0739
47
42
43
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 -0.1866 0.0625
40
21
15
Early County High School
0
0 -0.2763 0.0499
32
8
2
456
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
CCAT
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
CCAT
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
457
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.0036 0.0709
44
54
47
CCAT School
1
0 -0.0584 0.1278
56
40
84
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 -0.1910 0.0343
41
15
34
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.3970 0.1115
36
1
17
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
CCAT School
1
0 0.0451 0.1294
56
62
84
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0180 0.0718
44
50
47
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 -0.2262 0.0347
41
11
34
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.4586 0.1130
36
1
17
458
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Cherokee
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
Cherokee
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
459
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Sequoyah High School
0
0 0.5892 0.0274
72
99
99
River Ridge High School
0
0 0.2824 0.0271
51
93
74
Etowah High School
0
0 0.1247 0.0233
46
77
55
Creekview High School
0
0 0.1137 0.0241
41
73
35
Cherokee High School
0
0 -0.0377 0.0221
40
45
28
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0442 0.1090
41
44
36
Woodstock High School
0
0 -0.0452 0.0249
36
43
18
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Sequoyah High School
0
0 0.6062 0.0278
72
99
99
River Ridge High School
0
0 0.2898 0.0274
51
93
74
Etowah High School
0
0 0.1429 0.0236
46
77
55
Creekview High School
0
0 0.1424 0.0243
41
77
35
Cherokee High School
0
0 -0.0218 0.0223
40
49
28
Woodstock High School
0
0 -0.0368 0.0252
36
44
18
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 -0.0458 0.1104
41
42
36
460
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra
Cherokee
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Cherokee
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
461
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Sequoyah High School
0
0 0.2628 0.0257
65
93
94
Etowah High School
0
0 0.2235 0.0207
62
89
91
River Ridge High School
0
0 0.1890 0.0275
61
86
88
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0835 0.1249
60
72
86
Woodstock High School
0
0 0.0319 0.0232
52
63
60
Creekview High School
0
0 -0.0844 0.0234
43
31
21
Cherokee High School
0
0 -0.0921 0.0222
45
28
28
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Sequoyah High School
0
0 0.2581 0.0263
65
93
94
Etowah High School
0
0 0.2325 0.0211
62
90
91
River Ridge High School
0
0 0.1822 0.0281
61
85
88
Cherokee Charter Academy
1
0 0.0309 0.1276
60
63
86
Woodstock High School
0
0 0.0299 0.0237
52
62
60
Creekview High School
0
0 -0.0688 0.0239
43
36
21
Cherokee High School
0
0 -0.0824 0.0227
45
33
28
462
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
463
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Northview High School
0
0 0.4895 0.0276
70
99
98
Chattahoochee High School
0
1 0.4229 0.0243
71
98
99
Johns Creek High School
0
0 0.4210 0.0255
68
98
97
Roswell High School
0
0 0.3626 0.0231
70
97
99
Milton High School
0
0 0.3461 0.0249
70
96
98
Cambridge High School
0
0 0.2375 0.0248
63
92
92
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.2209 0.0660
50
89
53
Fulton Science Academy High School
0
1 0.2173 0.0898
56
89
76
Alpharetta High School
0
0 0.2162 0.0253
59
88
85
Riverwood International Charter Schoo
0
0 0.0543 0.0263
54
69
69
Westlake High School
0
0 0.0347 0.0220
49
64
48
Centennial High School
0
0 -0.0082 0.0244
53
54
66
Creekside High School
0
0 -0.0235 0.0250
50
51
52
Banneker High School
0
0 -0.0697 0.0267
48
36
40
Tri-Cities High School
0
0 -0.1134 0.0251
47
23
35
North Springs High School
0
1 -0.1282 0.0276
46
18
33
Langston Hughes High School
0
0 -0.1580 0.0218
40
12
12
Hapeville Charter Career Academy
0
1 -0.2456 0.0339
32
6
2
464
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Northview High School
0
0 0.5434 0.0282
70
99
98
Johns Creek High School
0
0 0.4996 0.0260
68
98
97
Chattahoochee High School
0
1 0.4875 0.0248
71
98
99
Roswell High School
0
0 0.3871 0.0236
70
97
99
Milton High School
0
0 0.3851 0.0254
70
97
98
Cambridge High School
0
0 0.2779 0.0253
63
95
92
Alpharetta High School
0
0 0.2577 0.0258
59
93
85
Fulton Science Academy High School
0
1 0.2148 0.0918
56
88
76
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.2053 0.0673
50
87
53
Riverwood International Charter Schoo
0
0 0.0897 0.0268
54
74
69
Centennial High School
0
0 0.0291 0.0250
53
61
66
Westlake High School
0
0 0.0222 0.0225
49
59
48
Creekside High School
0
0 -0.0191 0.0255
50
51
52
Banneker High School
0
0 -0.0727 0.0273
48
36
40
North Springs High School
0
1 -0.0992 0.0282
46
27
33
Tri-Cities High School
0
0 -0.1093 0.0256
47
24
35
Langston Hughes High School
0
0 -0.1531 0.0223
40
14
12
Hapeville Charter Career Academy
0
1 -0.2343 0.0347
32
6
2
465
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
466
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.2872 0.1141
56
94
76
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.1313 0.1249
66
80
96
Clay County 9th Grade Academy School
0
0 0.1247 0.1218
59
79
83
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 0.0226 0.0538
50
60
50
Calhoun County High School
0
0 -0.0462 0.0698
33
43
3
Early County High School
0
0 -0.0723 0.0374
39
35
9
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Baker County K12 School
0
0 0.2805 0.1165
56
95
76
Clay County 9th Grade Academy School
0
0 0.1489 0.1236
59
81
83
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.0713 0.1276
66
71
96
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 -0.0004 0.0550
50
55
50
Early County High School
0
0 -0.0650 0.0382
39
38
9
Calhoun County High School
0
0 -0.0866 0.0714
33
31
3
467
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
468
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 0.1023 0.0387
58
74
86
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0010 0.0625
51
52
63
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.0193 0.0201
46
48
38
CCAT School
1
0 -0.3439 0.1075
27
3
1
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 0.0768 0.0392
58
68
86
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 -0.0184 0.0635
51
49
63
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.0412 0.0203
46
44
38
CCAT School
1
0 -0.3061 0.1091
27
5
1
469
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Fulton
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Fulton Leadership
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
470
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Chattahoochee High School
0
1 0.2481 0.0459
55
89
79
Northview High School
0
0 0.2419 0.0390
59
89
90
Cambridge High School
0
0 0.2249 0.0418
59
87
88
Johns Creek High School
0
0 0.2151 0.0467
59
86
89
Milton High School
0
0 0.1658 0.0326
46
80
40
Riverwood International Charter Schoo
0
0 0.1148 0.0404
55
76
78
Westlake High School
0
0 0.1095 0.0288
56
75
83
Roswell High School
0
0 0.0455 0.0385
52
62
66
Independence Alternative School
0
0 0.0334 0.1014
58
60
86
McClarin Alternative School
0
0 -0.0127 0.0753
51
49
65
Banneker High School
0
0 -0.0371 0.0332
49
44
53
Centennial High School
0
0 -0.0513 0.0330
48
40
49
Tri-Cities High School
0
0 -0.0518 0.0296
48
40
49
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 -0.0534 0.0717
49
40
56
Alpharetta High School
0
0 -0.0988 0.0424
47
32
44
Creekside High School
0
0 -0.1504 0.0319
38
25
13
North Springs High School
0
1 -0.1621 0.0752
41
23
20
Langston Hughes High School
0
0 -0.1977 0.0290
40
17
18
Hapeville Charter Career Academy
0
1 -0.2842 0.0317
37
6
12
471
Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Chattahoochee High School
0
1 0.2820 0.0466
55
91
79
Northview High School
0
0 0.2710 0.0395
59
90
90
Cambridge High School
0
0 0.2532 0.0423
59
89
88
Johns Creek High School
0
0 0.2329 0.0473
59
88
89
Milton High School
0
0 0.1934 0.0330
46
84
40
Riverwood International Charter Schoo
0
0 0.1365 0.0408
55
75
78
Westlake High School
0
0 0.1204 0.0292
56
74
83
Roswell High School
0
0 0.0565 0.0390
52
65
66
Independence Alternative School
0
0 0.0339 0.1028
58
60
86
Fulton Leadership Academy
1
0 0.0067 0.0727
49
54
56
Centennial High School
0
0 -0.0382 0.0333
48
46
49
Tri-Cities High School
0
0 -0.0409 0.0300
48
45
49
Banneker High School
0
0 -0.0449 0.0336
49
43
53
McClarin Alternative School
0
0 -0.0479 0.0764
51
42
65
Alpharetta High School
0
0 -0.0868 0.0430
47
35
44
North Springs High School
0
1 -0.1379 0.0763
41
27
20
Creekside High School
0
0 -0.1424 0.0324
38
27
13
Langston Hughes High School
0
0 -0.1804 0.0294
40
19
18
Hapeville Charter Career Academy
0
1 -0.2303 0.0320
37
12
12
472
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER)
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
Pataula
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
473
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.5183 0.0945
65
98
95
Clay County 9th Grade Academy School
0
0 0.0998 0.1337
61
73
93
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 0.0177 0.0602
58
56
88
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.0187 0.1242
32
48
4
Calhoun County High School
0
0 -0.2064 0.0761
29
16
3
Early County High School
0
0 -0.2540 0.0405
36
9
9
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Pataula Charter Academy
1
0 0.5251 0.0960
65
98
95
Clay County 9th Grade Academy School
0
0 0.0676 0.1335
61
66
93
Randolph Clay High School
0
0 0.0012 0.0610
58
53
88
Baker County K12 School
0
0 -0.0470 0.1259
32
43
4
Calhoun County High School
0
0 -0.2468 0.0771
29
10
3
Early County High School
0
0 -0.2484 0.0408
36
9
9
474
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History
Bulloch
Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only
School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0)
School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7
CCAT
State Charters
Local Charters
Traditional
475
Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix
Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch]
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.1354 0.0869
49
70
60
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 -0.0484 0.0444
38
46
28
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.1953 0.0339
30
21
11
CCAT School
1
0 -0.4877 0.1158
22
3
3
Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls
School Name
State Local School School School School Mean SGP
Charter Charter
Effect
Effect
Mean Effect State State Rank
Standard Student
Rank Percentile
Error Growth Percentile
Percentile
Portal Middle/High School
0
0 0.1232 0.0886
49
68
60
New Southeast Bulloch High School
0
0 -0.0535 0.0452
38
44
28
Statesboro High School
0
0 -0.2094 0.0346
30
20
11
CCAT School
1
0 -0.4555 0.1181
22
5
3
476