Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Technical Appendix to The Performance of State Charter Schools in Georgia, 2013-14 by Tim R. Sass, Ph.D. Distinguished University Professor Department of Economics Andrew Young School of Policy Studies Georgia State University May 26, 2015 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Table of Contents I. Proficiency Levels .......................................................................................................................... 1 II. Value Added Models .................................................................................................................. 12 Value-Added Model Estimates .................................................................................................. 14 III. School Effect Estimates Based on Alternative Value-Added Models and School-Level Growth Percentiles Based on Alternative Measures and Samples ......................................147 A. State Charter School Effects -- Statewide Comparisons from Alternate Value-Added Models..................................................................................................................................... 148 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading .............................................................................. 148 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA ..................................................................................... 150 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math .................................................................................. 152 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science............................................................................... 154 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Social Studies ..................................................................... 156 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading .......................................................................... 158 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA ................................................................................. 160 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math ............................................................................. 162 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science........................................................................... 164 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies ................................................................. 166 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature ................................................. 168 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 American Literature.................................................. 170 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry .................................................... 172 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology ...................................................................... 174 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra................................................... 176 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Economics................................................................. 178 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Math II ...................................................................... 180 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science ........................................................ 182 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History ............................................................... 184 B. State Charter School Effects -- District Comparisons from Alternate Value-Added Models..................................................................................................................................... 186 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading .............................................................................. 186 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA ..................................................................................... 210 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math .................................................................................. 233 Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science............................................................................... 256 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading .......................................................................... 301 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA ................................................................................. 330 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math .............................................................................. 360 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science........................................................................... 387 Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies ................................................................. 414 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature ................................................. 441 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry .................................................... 453 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology ...................................................................... 457 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra................................................... 461 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science ........................................................ 468 Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History ............................................................... 475 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix I. Proficiency Levels Table 1: Percentage of Students Meeting/Exceeding Proficiency Targets on CRCT by Subject and Grade Level System Name Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School CRCT Reading N Tested % Did not meet the standard % Meets the standard % Exceeds the standard % Met or Exceeded the standard 798 13.3 42.4 44.4 86.7 38 13.2 63.2 23.7 86.8 109 0.0 31.2 68.8 100.0 133 12.0 37.6 50.4 88.0 41 9.8 65.9 24.4 90.2 45 6.7 44.4 48.9 93.3 41 4.9 53.7 41.5 95.1 76 13.2 59.2 27.6 86.8 93 2.2 28.0 69.9 97.8 126,745 7.7 46.5 45.9 92.3 809 8.9 42.3 48.8 91.1 31 6.5 48.4 45.2 93.5 115 3.5 34.8 61.7 96.5 134 4.5 35.8 59.7 95.5 24 8.3 54.2 37.5 91.7 24 16.7 41.7 41.7 83.3 45 2.2 46.7 51.1 97.8 79 8.9 62.0 29.1 91.1 91 2.2 25.3 72.5 97.8 124,872 6.4 41.3 52.3 93.6 873 8.4 47.7 44.0 91.6 22 4.5 68.2 27.3 95.5 115 0.9 45.2 53.9 99.1 167 6.0 46.1 47.9 94.0 16 31.3 56.3 12.5 68.8 24 8.3 58.3 33.3 91.7 44 2.3 45.5 52.3 97.7 66 12.1 74.2 13.6 87.9 71 2.8 47.9 49.3 97.2 123,653 5.2 53.1 41.7 94.8 1,089 2.1 42.4 55.5 97.9 1 Cherokee Charter 108 0.9 35.2 63.9 99.1 Heritage Prep Academy 59 1.7 64.4 33.9 98.3 Georgia Connections 232 3.0 34.5 62.5 97.0 Ivy Prep Young Men's 25 16.0 56.0 28.0 84.0 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 25 4.0 52.0 44.0 96.0 CCAT School 23 0.0 43.5 56.5 100.0 Ivy Prep Academy 94 2.1 36.2 61.7 97.9 Pataula Charter 46 4.3 56.5 39.1 95.7 Fulton Leadership 57 3.5 40.4 56.1 96.5 Atlanta Heights 60 0.0 85.0 15.0 100.0 Coweta Charter 39 0.0 38.5 61.5 100.0 Statewide Average 124,746 2.8 47.6 49.6 97.2 Grade 7 Odyssey School 1,378 5.0 51.2 43.8 95.0 Cherokee Charter 113 4.4 32.7 62.8 95.6 Heritage Prep Academy 58 3.4 63.8 32.8 96.6 Georgia Connections 289 2.8 42.6 54.7 97.2 Ivy Prep Young Men's 49 16.3 67.3 16.3 83.7 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 42 0.0 59.5 40.5 100.0 CCAT School 19 5.3 57.9 36.8 94.7 Ivy Prep Academy 88 3.4 48.9 47.7 96.6 Pataula Charter 38 7.9 47.4 44.7 92.1 Fulton Leadership 57 0.0 40.4 59.6 100.0 Atlanta Heights 58 10.3 69.0 20.7 89.7 Statewide Average 127,269 5.3 53.0 41.7 94.7 Grade 8 Odyssey School 1,511 2.9 42.8 54.3 97.1 Cherokee Charter 95 0.0 35.8 64.2 100.0 Heritage Prep Academy 51 7.8 62.7 29.4 92.2 Georgia Connections 312 2.2 42.3 55.4 97.8 Ivy Prep Young Men's 39 0.0 53.8 46.2 100.0 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 37 2.7 43.2 54.1 97.3 CCAT School 25 0.0 56.0 44.0 100.0 Ivy Prep Academy 114 0.9 39.5 59.6 99.1 Pataula Charter 43 2.3 30.2 67.4 97.7 Fulton Leadership 52 0.0 46.2 53.8 100.0 Atlanta Heights 45 4.4 68.9 26.7 95.6 Statewide Average 126,232 3.0 43.7 53.2 97.0 System Name Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood N Tested CRCT ELA % Did not meet the standard % Meets the standard % Exceeds the standard % Met or Exceeded the standard 797 20.1 52.9 27.0 79.9 38 26.3 52.6 21.1 73.7 109 2.8 46.8 50.5 97.2 132 15.2 53.8 31.1 84.8 41 17.1 63.4 19.5 82.9 45 2.2 55.6 42.2 97.8 42 7.1 66.7 26.2 92.9 76 26.3 59.2 14.5 73.7 93 1.1 47.3 51.6 98.9 127,032 11.5 56.1 32.3 88.5 801 17.1 49.6 33.3 82.9 31 16.1 54.8 29.0 83.9 115 6.1 49.6 44.3 93.9 133 12.8 39.1 48.1 87.2 24 20.8 62.5 16.7 79.2 24 8.3 62.5 29.2 91.7 44 6.8 61.4 31.8 93.2 79 11.4 73.4 15.2 88.6 91 4.4 46.2 49.5 95.6 124,719 11.3 54.0 34.8 88.7 874 10.0 54.7 35.4 90.0 22 9.1 59.1 31.8 90.9 114 1.8 54.4 43.9 98.2 168 9.5 58.9 31.5 90.5 16 25.0 62.5 12.5 75.0 24 12.5 58.3 29.2 87.5 44 0.0 52.3 47.7 100.0 66 3.0 83.3 13.6 97.0 71 1.4 60.6 38.0 98.6 123,571 5.3 55.6 39.2 94.7 1,088 8.2 57.8 34.0 91.8 108 3.7 53.7 42.6 96.3 59 11.9 61.0 27.1 88.1 231 5.6 61.0 33.3 94.4 24 12.5 66.7 20.8 87.5 25 0.0 68.0 32.0 100.0 CCAT School 23 17.4 60.9 21.7 82.6 Ivy Prep Academy 94 3.2 60.6 36.2 96.8 Pataula Charter 46 6.5 76.1 17.4 93.5 Fulton Leadership 55 3.6 63.6 32.7 96.4 Atlanta Heights 60 10.0 73.3 16.7 90.0 Coweta Charter 39 0.0 56.4 43.6 100.0 Statewide Average 124,615 8.2 59.6 32.2 91.8 Grade 7 Odyssey School 1,367 7.1 46.2 46.7 92.9 Cherokee Charter 112 7.1 31.3 61.6 92.9 Heritage Prep Academy 58 3.4 65.5 31.0 96.6 Georgia Connections 286 4.2 40.2 55.6 95.8 Ivy Prep Young Men's 49 22.4 57.1 20.4 77.6 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 42 0.0 52.4 47.6 100.0 CCAT School 19 15.8 52.6 31.6 84.2 Ivy Prep Academy 88 1.1 42.0 56.8 98.9 Pataula Charter 38 5.3 55.3 39.5 94.7 Fulton Leadership 57 0.0 38.6 61.4 100.0 Atlanta Heights 58 8.6 60.3 31.0 91.4 Statewide Average 126,992 6.1 46.6 47.3 93.9 Grade 8 Odyssey School 1,500 6.9 48.9 44.1 93.1 Cherokee Charter 96 2.1 33.3 64.6 97.9 Heritage Prep Academy 51 7.8 68.6 23.5 92.2 Georgia Connections 307 6.2 45.6 48.2 93.8 Ivy Prep Young Men's 39 10.3 51.3 38.5 89.7 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 36 2.8 38.9 58.3 97.2 CCAT School 25 0.0 72.0 28.0 100.0 Ivy Prep Academy 113 2.7 47.8 49.6 97.3 Pataula Charter 43 4.7 48.8 46.5 95.3 Fulton Leadership 52 3.8 55.8 40.4 96.2 Atlanta Heights 45 15.6 57.8 26.7 84.4 Statewide Average 126,011 5.5 50.3 44.3 94.5 System Name Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood N Tested CRCT MATH % Did not meet the standard % Meets the standard % Exceeds the standard % Met or Exceeded the standard 798 36.8 33.0 30.2 63.2 38 44.7 34.2 21.1 55.3 110 9.1 33.6 57.3 90.9 133 38.3 34.6 27.1 61.7 41 22.0 51.2 26.8 78.0 45 20.0 37.8 42.2 80.0 41 7.3 48.8 43.9 92.7 76 44.7 36.8 18.4 55.3 93 5.4 21.5 73.1 94.6 127,519 19.3 36.7 44.0 80.7 799 33.7 37.9 28.4 66.3 31 22.6 54.8 22.6 77.4 114 20.2 37.7 42.1 79.8 134 33.6 42.5 23.9 66.4 24 45.8 45.8 8.3 54.2 24 29.2 62.5 8.3 70.8 44 9.1 68.2 22.7 90.9 79 34.2 54.4 11.4 65.8 91 4.4 38.5 57.1 95.6 124,706 18.3 42.6 39.0 81.7 870 32.4 44.0 23.6 67.6 22 18.2 36.4 45.5 81.8 114 7.9 45.6 46.5 92.1 166 34.9 46.4 18.7 65.1 17 52.9 35.3 11.8 47.1 24 29.2 33.3 37.5 70.8 44 4.5 40.9 54.5 95.5 66 42.4 51.5 6.1 57.6 71 5.6 50.7 43.7 94.4 123,006 12.3 43.8 43.8 87.7 1,071 24.0 55.6 20.4 76.0 107 8.4 64.5 27.1 91.6 59 16.9 78.0 5.1 83.1 228 20.2 61.4 18.4 79.8 24 25.0 70.8 4.2 75.0 25 16.0 80.0 4.0 84.0 CCAT School 22 27.3 54.5 18.2 72.7 Ivy Prep Academy 94 5.3 55.3 39.4 94.7 Pataula Charter 46 10.9 73.9 15.2 89.1 Fulton Leadership 55 16.4 72.7 10.9 83.6 Atlanta Heights 60 30.0 65.0 5.0 70.0 Coweta Charter 39 25.6 48.7 25.6 74.4 Statewide Average 124,070 15.9 55.8 28.3 84.1 Grade 7 Odyssey School 1,355 15.9 57.3 26.8 84.1 Cherokee Charter 111 9.0 45.9 45.0 91.0 Heritage Prep Academy 58 15.5 70.7 13.8 84.5 Georgia Connections 284 13.0 57.7 29.2 87.0 Ivy Prep Young Men's 49 18.4 55.1 26.5 81.6 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 42 4.8 83.3 11.9 95.2 CCAT School 19 10.5 73.7 15.8 89.5 Ivy Prep Academy 86 10.5 43.0 46.5 89.5 Pataula Charter 38 10.5 52.6 36.8 89.5 Fulton Leadership 56 0.0 51.8 48.2 100.0 Atlanta Heights 58 34.5 48.3 17.2 65.5 Statewide Average 126,420 12.4 50.2 37.4 87.6 Grade 8 Odyssey School 1,485 35.1 48.6 16.3 64.9 Cherokee Charter 94 14.9 56.4 28.7 85.1 Heritage Prep Academy 51 51.0 33.3 15.7 49.0 Georgia Connections 307 37.5 48.5 14.0 62.5 Ivy Prep Young Men's 39 23.1 56.4 20.5 76.9 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 35 25.7 45.7 28.6 74.3 CCAT School 25 24.0 68.0 8.0 76.0 Ivy Prep Academy 111 9.0 50.5 40.5 91.0 Pataula Charter 43 20.9 65.1 14.0 79.1 Fulton Leadership 50 10.0 68.0 22.0 90.0 Atlanta Heights 45 48.9 40.0 11.1 51.1 Statewide Average 125,259 18.5 47.5 34.1 81.5 System Name Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood CRCT SCIENCE N Tested % Did not meet the standard % Meets the standard % Exceeds the standard % Met or Exceeded the standard 803 31.6 36.1 32.3 68.4 38 52.6 31.6 15.8 47.4 114 5.3 29.8 64.9 94.7 132 27.3 37.1 35.6 72.7 43 32.6 48.8 18.6 67.4 45 6.7 55.6 37.8 93.3 42 16.7 42.9 40.5 83.3 76 38.2 40.8 21.1 61.8 93 5.4 26.9 67.7 94.6 129,662 22.9 41.1 35.9 77.1 823 26.4 39.5 34.1 73.6 31 29.0 45.2 25.8 71.0 116 10.3 39.7 50.0 89.7 132 21.2 40.2 38.6 78.8 24 41.7 41.7 16.7 58.3 24 41.7 54.2 4.2 58.3 45 8.9 60.0 31.1 91.1 80 37.5 38.8 23.8 62.5 91 4.4 26.4 69.2 95.6 127,657 19.1 38.0 42.9 80.9 886 25.4 40.2 34.4 74.6 22 18.2 50.0 31.8 81.8 116 11.2 29.3 59.5 88.8 168 21.4 42.9 35.7 78.6 17 52.9 35.3 11.8 47.1 24 33.3 50.0 16.7 66.7 45 11.1 35.6 53.3 88.9 66 37.9 51.5 10.6 62.1 71 11.3 45.1 43.7 88.7 127,252 18.1 39.8 42.1 81.9 1,111 27.6 54.0 18.4 72.4 112 13.4 52.7 33.9 86.6 60 38.3 60.0 1.7 61.7 232 22.0 64.2 13.8 78.0 25 32.0 64.0 4.0 68.0 25 32.0 64.0 4.0 68.0 CCAT School 24 33.3 54.2 12.5 66.7 Ivy Prep Academy 95 11.6 68.4 20.0 88.4 Pataula Charter 46 37.0 52.2 10.9 63.0 Fulton Leadership 58 27.6 62.1 10.3 72.4 Atlanta Heights 60 46.7 51.7 1.7 53.3 Coweta Charter 39 23.1 38.5 38.5 76.9 Statewide Average 127,590 24.9 52.4 22.7 75.1 Grade 7 Odyssey School 1,408 20.2 46.2 33.5 79.8 Cherokee Charter 114 7.0 31.6 61.4 93.0 Heritage Prep Academy 59 23.7 62.7 13.6 76.3 Georgia Connections 289 17.0 40.5 42.6 83.0 Ivy Prep Young Men's 50 36.0 52.0 12.0 64.0 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 43 14.0 65.1 20.9 86.0 CCAT School 20 25.0 60.0 15.0 75.0 Ivy Prep Academy 89 10.1 41.6 48.3 89.9 Pataula Charter 39 17.9 43.6 38.5 82.1 Fulton Leadership 58 5.2 48.3 46.6 94.8 Atlanta Heights 59 30.5 49.2 20.3 69.5 Statewide Average 129,848 15.8 38.0 46.2 84.2 Grade 8 Odyssey School 1,533 29.2 55.5 15.3 70.8 Cherokee Charter 96 14.6 58.3 27.1 85.4 Heritage Prep Academy 54 42.6 55.6 1.9 57.4 Georgia Connections 315 30.5 54.6 14.9 69.5 Ivy Prep Young Men's 43 37.2 60.5 2.3 62.8 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 37 24.3 73.0 2.7 75.7 CCAT School 26 30.8 61.5 7.7 69.2 Ivy Prep Academy 114 11.4 70.2 18.4 88.6 Pataula Charter 42 14.3 64.3 21.4 85.7 Fulton Leadership 53 20.8 67.9 11.3 79.2 Atlanta Heights 45 42.2 48.9 8.9 57.8 Statewide Average 128,936 22.1 52.9 25.0 77.9 System Name Grade 3 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 4 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 5 Odyssey School Scholars Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood Pataula Charter Atlanta Heights Coweta Charter Statewide Average Grade 6 Odyssey School Cherokee Charter Heritage Prep Academy Georgia Connections Ivy Prep Young Men's Ivy Prep Kirkwood CRCT SOCIAL STUDIES N Tested % Did not meet the standard % Meets the standard % Exceeds the standard % Met or Exceeded the standard 801 32.2 49.6 18.2 67.8 38 39.5 39.5 21.1 60.5 114 4.4 43.9 51.8 95.6 132 30.3 50.0 19.7 69.7 43 14.0 53.5 32.6 86.0 45 4.4 40.0 55.6 95.6 42 14.3 54.8 31.0 85.7 76 19.7 44.7 35.5 80.3 93 5.4 37.6 57.0 94.6 129,137 16.3 47.7 35.9 83.7 821 30.9 54.0 15.1 69.1 31 25.8 64.5 9.7 74.2 116 10.3 62.1 27.6 89.7 132 24.2 54.5 21.2 75.8 24 33.3 58.3 8.3 66.7 24 37.5 62.5 0.0 62.5 45 8.9 71.1 20.0 91.1 80 30.0 63.8 6.3 70.0 91 5.5 42.9 51.6 94.5 127,178 18.8 51.1 30.0 81.2 881 28.9 52.3 18.7 71.1 22 18.2 50.0 31.8 81.8 116 10.3 52.6 37.1 89.7 167 30.5 56.3 13.2 69.5 17 70.6 17.6 11.8 29.4 24 29.2 70.8 0.0 70.8 45 17.8 42.2 40.0 82.2 66 45.5 53.0 1.5 54.5 71 14.1 64.8 21.1 85.9 126,802 19.3 53.8 26.9 80.7 1,106 35.7 39.4 24.9 64.3 112 10.7 28.6 60.7 89.3 60 56.7 40.0 3.3 43.3 231 35.1 44.6 20.3 64.9 25 52.0 40.0 8.0 48.0 25 24.0 60.0 16.0 76.0 CCAT School 24 41.7 33.3 25.0 58.3 Ivy Prep Academy 95 9.5 18.9 71.6 90.5 Pataula Charter 46 17.4 54.3 28.3 82.6 Fulton Leadership 58 13.8 37.9 48.3 86.2 Atlanta Heights 61 55.7 36.1 8.2 44.3 Coweta Charter 39 23.1 46.2 30.8 76.9 Statewide Average 127,200 20.2 35.1 44.8 79.8 Grade 7 Odyssey School 1,400 30.8 39.4 29.9 69.2 Cherokee Charter 114 6.1 16.7 77.2 93.9 Heritage Prep Academy 59 39.0 57.6 3.4 61.0 Georgia Connections 287 28.9 48.1 23.0 71.1 Ivy Prep Young Men's 50 46.0 44.0 10.0 54.0 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 43 11.6 51.2 37.2 88.4 CCAT School 20 25.0 60.0 15.0 75.0 Ivy Prep Academy 89 6.7 33.7 59.6 93.3 Pataula Charter 39 15.4 25.6 59.0 84.6 Fulton Leadership 58 3.4 29.3 67.2 96.6 Atlanta Heights 59 45.8 37.3 16.9 54.2 Statewide Average 129,400 16.5 30.5 53.0 83.5 Grade 8 Odyssey School 1,525 30.9 50.7 18.4 69.1 Cherokee Charter 96 9.4 40.6 50.0 90.6 Heritage Prep Academy 54 33.3 59.3 7.4 66.7 Georgia Connections 315 25.4 52.1 22.5 74.6 Ivy Prep Young Men's 43 39.5 55.8 4.7 60.5 Ivy Prep Kirkwood 37 18.9 62.2 18.9 81.1 CCAT School 26 23.1 65.4 11.5 76.9 Ivy Prep Academy 114 14.9 57.9 27.2 85.1 Pataula Charter 42 9.5 54.8 35.7 90.5 Fulton Leadership 53 17.0 54.7 28.3 83.0 Atlanta Heights 45 40.0 53.3 6.7 60.0 Statewide Average 128,365 19.4 44.4 36.2 80.6 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Table 2: Percentage of Students Meeting/Exceeding Proficiency Targets on EOCT by Subject System Name 9TH Grade Literature Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections CCAT School Ivy Prep Academy Pataula Charter Fulton Leadership Statewide Average American Literature Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Georgia Connections CCAT School Ivy Prep Academy Statewide Average Analytic Geometry Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Cherokee Charter Georgia Connections CCAT School Ivy Prep Academy Pataula Charter Statewide Average Math II Mountain Education Odyssey School Provost Academy Statewide Average Biology Mountain Education Odyssey School END OF COURSE TEST N Tested Mean Scale % Did Not Score Meet the standard % Met the standard % Exceeded the standard 37 434.86 8.1 64.9 27.0 1,198 443.14 9.2 45.7 45.2 96 420.64 22.9 53.1 24.0 26 451.58 3.8 46.2 50.0 313 444.85 8.6 44.1 47.3 21 443.71 4.8 57.1 38.1 15 446.53 13.3 33.3 53.3 36 457.78 5.6 36.1 58.3 60 443.77 5.0 48.3 46.7 112,505 439.72 12.3 45.1 42.6 83 728 128 248 9 10 93,689 434.49 442.66 428.39 448.85 -438.90 441.55 8.4 7.0 14.8 4.0 -0.0 7.5 63.9 49.0 60.9 48.4 -70.0 50.7 27.7 44.0 24.2 47.6 -30.0 41.9 11 999 36 9 252 17 15 20 97,659 390.82 372.99 369.67 -382.20 373.12 377.93 418.20 390.04 63.6 84.9 83.3 -77.0 82.4 80.0 15.0 65.4 27.3 13.7 16.7 -21.4 17.6 20.0 70.0 28.9 9.1 1.4 0.0 -1.6 0.0 0.0 15.0 5.7 41 5 37 4,946 395.88 -- 383.78 388.02 63.4 -- 91.9 77.4 36.6 -- 8.1 22.2 0.0 -- 0.0 0.3 62 418.42 27.4 51.6 21.0 1,218 406.83 44.8 42.2 13.0 11 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Provost Academy 131 390.03 70.2 26.7 3.1 Cherokee Charter 25 437.12 16.0 52.0 32.0 Georgia Connections 314 426.20 24.5 46.8 28.7 CCAT School 14 421.21 14.3 78.6 7.1 Ivy Prep Academy 14 416.79 35.7 42.9 21.4 Statewide Average 109,030 430.47 25.0 41.1 33.9 US History Mountain Education 104 420.19 27.9 44.2 27.9 Odyssey School 697 401.57 52.2 31.6 16.2 Provost Academy 146 381.03 68.5 26.0 5.5 Georgia Connections 238 399.96 53.8 33.2 13.0 CCAT School 26 393.69 53.8 34.6 11.5 Ivy Prep Academy 10 387.10 60.0 40.0 0.0 Statewide Average 93,645 434.88 27.2 32.6 40.2 Economics Mountain Education 159 430.50 19.5 50.9 29.6 Odyssey School 56 410.91 42.9 37.5 19.6 Provost Academy 146 395.78 52.1 40.4 7.5 Georgia Connections 143 416.84 28.0 51.7 20.3 CCAT School 14 403.00 50.0 35.7 14.3 Statewide Average 59,564 439.61 18.8 39.1 42.1 II. Value Added Models A value-added model of the following form was used to estimate school effects: (1) where Aist represents the achievement level of student i in school s at time t, is a vector of prior test scores, is a vector of student characteristics, is a school fixed effect, and is a random error term. One can view the school fixed effect as the difference between a student's actual test score ( ) and the score a student would be expected to earn based on their individual characteristics and past history of test scores , averaged over all students at a school. By construction, the average school has a fixed effect of zero and the performance of all other schools is measured relative to this average. Thus a positive estimated value for a school's fixed effect indicates they increase student achievement more than the average school while a negative value indicates they are less effective than the average school. Three versions of the value-added model were estimated. The first employed all available student characteristics in the vector X. Estimates from this model are presented in the main report. The second removed indicators for student racial/ethnic categories. The third eliminated the X vector entirely and only included the vector of prior test scores. Each of the three value-added models was applied to 16 different samples representing five CRCT subjects 12 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix at the elementary level, five CRCT subjects at the middle school level and six subject-specific end-of-course exams at the high school level. Estimates for the 48 model/sample combinations are provided below. There are two things worth noting in the value-added model estimates. First, virtually all of the coefficients on the demographic characteristics have the expected sign. Second, most all of the coefficients on the demographic variables are statistically significant, indicating they have a non-zero impact on current test scores, even after controlling for prior test scores. 13 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Value-Added Model Estimates Elementary Reading Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.0275** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.1754** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.2971** (0.0027) Lagged Science Score 0.1789** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1468** (0.0028) Grade 5 0.0017 (0.0051) Female 0.0606** (0.0026) Foreign Born 0.0649** (0.0085) Black -0.0431** (0.0041) Hispanic -0.0073 (0.0056) Asian 0.0194 (0.0402) American Indian -0.0161 (0.0275) Multi-Racial 0.0099 (0.0074) ESOL Enrolled -0.0634** (0.0074) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0403** (0.0037) 14 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gifted 0.1325** (0.0044) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0074 (0.0069) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0867 (0.0592) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0341** (0.0083) Deaf -0.2310** (0.0469) Visual Impairment 0.0445 (0.0578) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.0853** (0.0165) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1240** (0.0069) Deaf and Blind -0.1647** (0.0060) Autism -0.1534** (0.0166) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0065 (0.0780) Significant Dev. Delay -0.2375** (0.0917) Other Health Imp. -0.1062** (0.0098) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.2128** (0.0250) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3536 (0.1882) 15 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.7415** (0.0061) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0345** (0.0064) Changed Schools 0.0116 (0.0062) age_within_grade -0.0014** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0038* (0.0016) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0038** (0.0005) Constant 0.3892** (0.0488) Observations 226255 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 16 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.0286** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.1746** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.2980** (0.0027) Lagged Science Score 0.1824** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1458** (0.0028) Grade 5 0.0016 (0.0051) Female 0.0605** (0.0026) Foreign Born 0.0645** (0.0085) ESOL Enrolled -0.0593** (0.0074) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0472** (0.0036) Gifted 0.1335** (0.0044) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0033 (0.0061) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0847 (0.0591) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0323** (0.0083) Deaf -0.2301** (0.0471) 17 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Visual Impairment 0.0455 (0.0577) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.0828** (0.0165) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1226** (0.0069) Deaf and Blind -0.1458** (0.0058) Autism -0.1495** (0.0166) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0057 (0.0779) Significant Dev. Delay -0.2355* (0.0918) Other Health Imp. -0.1025** (0.0099) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.2143** (0.0250) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3610 (0.1902) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.7658** (0.0056) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0347** (0.0064) Changed Schools 0.0100 (0.0063) age_within_grade -0.0013** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0051** 18 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0016) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0045** (0.0005) Constant 0.4420** (0.0483) Observations 226255 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 19 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.0406** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.2006** (0.0026) Lagged Reading Score 0.3141** (0.0026) Lagged Science Score 0.1815** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1467** (0.0028) Constant -0.0146** (0.0002) Observations 226255 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 20 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary ELA Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.0999** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.2644** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.2214** (0.0024) Lagged Science Score 0.1486** (0.0028) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1046** (0.0028) Grade 5 0.0076 (0.0053) Female 0.1296** (0.0025) Foreign Born 0.0396** (0.0083) Black 0.0115** (0.0039) Hispanic 0.0078 (0.0051) Asian 0.0901* (0.0385) American Indian 0.0581* (0.0294) Multi-Racial 0.0091 (0.0071) ESOL Enrolled -0.0899** (0.0073) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0512** (0.0034) 21 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gifted 0.1755** (0.0047) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0590** (0.0071) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0503 (0.0614) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0246** (0.0079) Deaf -0.0923* (0.0375) Visual Impairment 0.0327 (0.0512) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1195** (0.0165) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1452** (0.0063) Deaf and Blind -0.2758** (0.0059) Autism -0.0902** (0.0155) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0430 (0.0843) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0761 (0.0756) Other Health Imp. -0.1205** (0.0096) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.1766** (0.0251) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3332** (0.1156) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.3995** 22 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0057) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0423** (0.0061) Changed Schools 0.0053 (0.0061) age_within_grade -0.0026** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0069** (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0001 (0.0004) Constant -0.0294 (0.0425) Observations 226051 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 23 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.0996** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.2647** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.2211** (0.0024) Lagged Science Score 0.1477** (0.0028) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1048** (0.0028) Grade 5 0.0076 (0.0053) Female 0.1297** (0.0025) Foreign Born 0.0391** (0.0083) ESOL Enrolled -0.0900** (0.0073) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0489** (0.0034) Gifted 0.1750** (0.0047) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0589** (0.0065) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0498 (0.0613) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0251** (0.0079) Deaf -0.0923* (0.0375) 24 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Visual Impairment 0.0320 (0.0512) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1200** (0.0165) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1456** (0.0063) Deaf and Blind -0.2818** (0.0056) Autism -0.0914** (0.0155) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0439 (0.0844) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0750 (0.0754) Other Health Imp. -0.1217** (0.0096) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.1762** (0.0251) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3316** (0.1154) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.3928** (0.0053) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0422** (0.0061) Changed Schools 0.0056 (0.0061) age_within_grade -0.0026** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0065** 25 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0001 (0.0004) Constant -0.0419 (0.0422) Observations 226051 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 26 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.1155** (0.0023) Lagged ELA Score 0.3094** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.2413** (0.0025) Lagged Science Score 0.1401** (0.0028) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1025** (0.0028) Constant -0.0107** (0.0001) Observations 226051 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 27 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Math Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.4792** (0.0030) Lagged ELA Score 0.0991** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.0351** (0.0025) Lagged Science Score 0.0912** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0466** (0.0031) Grade 5 0.0017 (0.0081) Female -0.0226** (0.0027) Foreign Born 0.0682** (0.0086) Black -0.0504** (0.0040) Hispanic -0.0463** (0.0058) Asian 0.0162 (0.0388) American Indian 0.0025 (0.0277) Multi-Racial -0.0345** (0.0070) ESOL Enrolled -0.0635** (0.0084) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0502** (0.0034) 28 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gifted 0.2649** (0.0056) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.1151** (0.0078) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1552* (0.0714) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0098 (0.0088) Deaf -0.0437 (0.0362) Visual Impairment -0.0215 (0.0654) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.2254** (0.0169) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1378** (0.0070) Deaf and Blind 0.0152* (0.0070) Autism -0.0891** (0.0178) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2131** (0.0818) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0469 (0.0899) Other Health Imp. -0.1669** (0.0104) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.2386** (0.0290) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3586** (0.1000) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 1.8018** 29 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0073) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0473** (0.0062) Changed Schools 0.0016 (0.0062) age_within_grade -0.0031** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0019 (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0086** (0.0004) Constant -0.7746** (0.0412) Observations 225334 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 30 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Math Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.4807** (0.0030) Lagged ELA Score 0.0981** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.0361** (0.0025) Lagged Science Score 0.0948** (0.0030) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0455** (0.0031) Grade 5 0.0014 (0.0081) Female -0.0229** (0.0027) Foreign Born 0.0728** (0.0087) ESOL Enrolled -0.0643** (0.0083) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0608** (0.0034) Gifted 0.2669** (0.0056) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.1090** (0.0070) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1529* (0.0710) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0122 (0.0088) Deaf -0.0448 (0.0361) 31 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Visual Impairment -0.0193 (0.0654) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.2220** (0.0169) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1356** (0.0070) Deaf and Blind 0.0426** (0.0067) Autism -0.0841** (0.0178) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2090** (0.0791) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0451 (0.0898) Other Health Imp. -0.1618** (0.0104) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.2406** (0.0290) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3674** (0.0985) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 1.8310** (0.0069) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0475** (0.0062) Changed Schools -0.0000 (0.0062) age_within_grade -0.0031** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0033* 32 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0078** (0.0004) Constant -0.7182** (0.0408) Observations 225334 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 33 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Math Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.5197** (0.0030) Lagged ELA Score 0.1167** (0.0027) Lagged Reading Score 0.0456** (0.0025) Lagged Science Score 0.1045** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0610** (0.0032) Constant -0.0051** (0.0002) Observations 225334 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 34 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Science Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.1185** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0849** (0.0026) Lagged Reading Score 0.1549** (0.0023) Lagged Science Score 0.3107** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1444** (0.0030) Grade 5 0.0105 (0.0080) Female -0.0814** (0.0026) Foreign Born 0.0604** (0.0074) Black -0.1246** (0.0038) Hispanic -0.0453** (0.0054) Asian 0.0768* (0.0356) American Indian -0.0317 (0.0248) Multi-Racial -0.0298** (0.0067) ESOL Enrolled -0.0442** (0.0079) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0395** (0.0031) 35 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gifted 0.1247** (0.0046) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0181** (0.0067) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0791 (0.0456) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0004 (0.0077) Deaf -0.0868* (0.0373) Visual Impairment -0.0365 (0.0496) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1109** (0.0156) Specific Learning Dis. -0.0927** (0.0062) Deaf and Blind -0.3316 (0.2321) Autism -0.0616** (0.0141) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2317** (0.0698) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0724 (0.0672) Other Health Imp. -0.1068** (0.0091) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.2636** (0.0161) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.0447 (0.0839) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 1.1760** 36 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0070) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0488** (0.0062) Changed Schools 0.0014 (0.0075) age_within_grade -0.0033** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0140** (0.0016) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0013** (0.0004) Constant 0.0366 (0.0422) Observations 233073 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 37 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Science Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.1218** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0825** (0.0026) Lagged Reading Score 0.1574** (0.0023) Lagged Science Score 0.3205** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1413** (0.0030) Grade 5 0.0100 (0.0080) Female -0.0819** (0.0026) Foreign Born 0.0624** (0.0074) ESOL Enrolled -0.0359** (0.0078) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0615** (0.0031) Gifted 0.1281** (0.0046) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0384** (0.0062) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0684 (0.0454) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0047 (0.0078) Deaf -0.0840* (0.0374) 38 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Visual Impairment -0.0346 (0.0495) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1046** (0.0155) Specific Learning Dis. -0.0883** (0.0062) Deaf and Blind -0.3191 (0.2644) Autism -0.0506** (0.0142) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2186** (0.0687) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0663 (0.0674) Other Health Imp. -0.0961** (0.0092) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.2644** (0.0161) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.0459 (0.0827) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 1.2464** (0.0069) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0495** (0.0062) Changed Schools -0.0032 (0.0076) age_within_grade -0.0031** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0178** 39 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0017) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0006 (0.0004) Constant 0.1819** (0.0426) Observations 233073 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 40 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Science Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.1455** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0799** (0.0025) Lagged Reading Score 0.1621** (0.0023) Lagged Science Score 0.3349** (0.0031) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1567** (0.0031) Constant 0.0155** (0.0001) Observations 233073 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 41 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.0599** (0.0025) Lagged ELA Score 0.0805** (0.0026) Lagged Reading Score 0.1648** (0.0025) Lagged Science Score 0.1713** (0.0030) Lagged Social Studies Score 0.3243** (0.0035) Grade 5 0.0099 (0.0095) Female -0.1264** (0.0026) Foreign Born 0.0617** (0.0083) Black -0.0310** (0.0043) Hispanic -0.0289** (0.0056) Asian 0.0652 (0.0366) American Indian 0.0043 (0.0239) Multi-Racial -0.0092 (0.0067) ESOL Enrolled -0.0659** (0.0079) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0718** (0.0033) 42 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gifted 0.1427** (0.0050) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0766** (0.0069) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0779 (0.0565) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0264** (0.0079) Deaf -0.1175** (0.0336) Visual Impairment -0.0094 (0.0498) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1225** (0.0150) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1072** (0.0062) Deaf and Blind -0.1155** (0.0209) Autism -0.1042** (0.0129) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1470* (0.0592) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0923 (0.0663) Other Health Imp. -0.1212** (0.0083) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.1399** (0.0150) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.0231 (0.1042) 43 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Sev. Intellectual Dis. -0.2222** (0.0077) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0472** (0.0062) Changed Schools -0.0033 (0.0070) age_within_grade -0.0025** (0.0002) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0136** (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0025** (0.0005) Constant -0.0862* (0.0431) Observations 232244 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 44 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.0608** (0.0025) Lagged ELA Score 0.0799** (0.0026) Lagged Reading Score 0.1654** (0.0025) Lagged Science Score 0.1736** (0.0030) Lagged Social Studies Score 0.3236** (0.0035) Grade 5 0.0097 (0.0095) Female -0.1265** (0.0026) Foreign Born 0.0645** (0.0083) ESOL Enrolled -0.0666** (0.0079) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0782** (0.0033) Gifted 0.1439** (0.0050) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0720** (0.0062) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0744 (0.0561) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0279** (0.0079) Deaf -0.1179** (0.0336) 45 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Visual Impairment -0.0087 (0.0497) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1207** (0.0150) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1060** (0.0062) Deaf and Blind -0.1113** (0.0125) Autism -0.1012** (0.0129) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1443* (0.0588) Significant Dev. Delay -0.0907 (0.0663) Other Health Imp. -0.1181** (0.0084) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.1397** (0.0150) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.0230 (0.1052) Sev. Intellectual Dis. -0.2043** (0.0074) o.Prof. Intellectual Dis. . . Num. Schools Attended -0.0473** (0.0062) Changed Schools -0.0043 (0.0070) age_within_grade -0.0024** (0.0002) 46 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0145** (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0020** (0.0004) Constant -0.0511 (0.0424) Observations 232244 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 47 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Elementary Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.0910** (0.0025) Lagged ELA Score 0.0695** (0.0025) Lagged Reading Score 0.1676** (0.0026) Lagged Science Score 0.1927** (0.0031) Lagged Social Studies Score 0.3451** (0.0035) Constant 0.0132** (0.0001) Observations 232244 Standard errors in parentheses * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level 48 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Reading Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.0466** (0.0021) Lagged ELA Score 0.1740** (0.0024) Lagged Reading Score 0.2880** (0.0028) Lagged Science Score 0.1786** (0.0025) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1244** (0.0025) tgrde_7 -0.0038 (0.0090) tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black -0.0134 (0.0083) 0.1046** (0.0023) 0.0342** (0.0068) -0.0506** (0.0038) Hispanic -0.0017 (0.0046) Asian -0.0070 (0.0340) American Indian 0.0185 (0.0220) Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled -0.0092 (0.0063) -0.1395** (0.0074) 49 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0378** (0.0030) Gifted 0.1090** (0.0040) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0203** (0.0047) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0897 (0.0480) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0768** (0.0111) Deaf -0.2556** (0.0312) Visual Impairment -0.1320** (0.0505) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1149** (0.0122) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1620** (0.0055) Deaf and Blind -1.0827** (0.0051) Autism -0.1586** (0.0144) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2499** (0.0768) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1440** (0.0081) -0.3398** (0.0206) -0.3223* 50 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.1428) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0345** (0.0051) Changed Schools -0.0015 (0.0083) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0051** (0.0007) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0041** (0.0003) Age-in-grade -0.0026** (0.0002) Constant 0.4241** (0.0318) Observations 344548 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 51 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.0478** (0.0021) Lagged ELA Score 0.1730** (0.0024) Lagged Reading Score 0.2885** (0.0028) Lagged Science Score 0.1824** (0.0025) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1238** (0.0026) tgrde_7 -0.0054 (0.0090) tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted -0.0153 (0.0084) 0.1044** (0.0023) 0.0338** (0.0067) -0.1355** (0.0073) -0.0462** (0.0030) 0.1109** (0.0040) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0008 (0.0044) Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp. -0.0862 (0.0480) -0.0762** (0.0110) 52 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.2532** (0.0311) -0.1323** (0.0505) -0.1110** (0.0122) -0.1608** (0.0055) -1.0679** (0.0050) -0.1533** (0.0144) -0.2488** (0.0761) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1398** (0.0081) -0.3432** (0.0205) -0.3323* (0.1427) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0353** (0.0051) Changed Schools -0.0034 (0.0084) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0066** 53 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0049** (0.0003) Age-in-grade -0.0025** (0.0002) Constant 0.4943** (0.0326) Observations 344548 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 54 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Reading Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.0639** (0.0021) Lagged ELA Score 0.2062** (0.0022) Lagged Reading Score 0.3119** (0.0026) Lagged Science Score 0.1763** (0.0025) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1184** (0.0025) Constant 0.0036** (0.0001) Observations 344548 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 55 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle ELA Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.1150** (0.0022) Lagged ELA Score 0.2964** (0.0024) Lagged Reading Score 0.2130** (0.0022) Lagged Science Score 0.1068** (0.0024) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0964** (0.0025) tgrde_7 0.0018 (0.0091) tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black -0.0087 (0.0089) 0.1743** (0.0024) 0.0261** (0.0062) 0.0066* (0.0031) Hispanic 0.0036 (0.0042) Asian 0.0226 (0.0286) American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled 0.0180 (0.0218) 0.0135* (0.0060) -0.0864** (0.0067) 56 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0440** (0.0029) Gifted 0.1550** (0.0040) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0357** (0.0046) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0065 (0.0446) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0651** (0.0100) Deaf -0.1409** (0.0333) Visual Impairment -0.1143* (0.0476) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1332** (0.0119) Specific Learning Dis. -0.1683** (0.0050) Deaf and Blind -0.7286** (0.0055) Autism -0.0700** (0.0135) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1588* (0.0639) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1616** (0.0079) -0.3068** (0.0219) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.2140 57 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.1790) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0451** (0.0050) Changed Schools 0.0014 (0.0080) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0036** (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present Age-in-grade 0.0001 (0.0003) -0.0021** (0.0002) Constant -0.0384 (0.0292) Observations 343761 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 58 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.1148** (0.0022) Lagged ELA Score 0.2966** (0.0024) Lagged Reading Score 0.2130** (0.0022) Lagged Science Score 0.1064** (0.0023) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0965** (0.0025) tgrde_7 0.0020 (0.0091) tgrde_8 -0.0085 (0.0089) Female 0.1744** (0.0024) Foreign Born 0.0260** (0.0063) ESOL Enrolled -0.0867** (0.0067) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0425** (0.0029) Gifted 0.1547** (0.0040) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0349** (0.0042) Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp. 0.0059 (0.0446) -0.0651** (0.0100) 59 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1412** (0.0333) -0.1144* (0.0477) -0.1336** (0.0119) -0.1684** (0.0050) -0.7313** (0.0054) -0.0707** (0.0135) -0.1595* (0.0640) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1621** (0.0078) -0.3065** (0.0219) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.2135 (0.1792) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0450** (0.0050) Changed Schools 0.0016 (0.0079) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0034** 60 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present Age-in-grade 0.0002 (0.0003) -0.0021** (0.0002) Constant -0.0464 (0.0291) Observations 343761 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 61 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle ELA Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.1382** (0.0022) Lagged ELA Score 0.3436** (0.0023) Lagged Reading Score 0.2408** (0.0021) Lagged Science Score 0.0918** (0.0024) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0853** (0.0025) Constant 0.0099** (0.0001) Observations 343761 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 62 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Math Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.4652** (0.0029) Lagged ELA Score 0.0941** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.0287** (0.0019) Lagged Science Score 0.1185** (0.0024) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0694** (0.0029) tgrde_7 0.0050 (0.0118) tgrde_8 -0.0026 (0.0138) Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic 0.0032 (0.0021) 0.0771** (0.0065) -0.0760** (0.0038) -0.0662** (0.0066) Asian -0.0184 (0.0303) American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled -0.0054 (0.0229) -0.0258** (0.0059) -0.0355** (0.0074) 63 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0429** (0.0029) Gifted 0.3043** (0.0063) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0774** (0.0062) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1454** (0.0492) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0074 (0.0093) Deaf 0.0063 (0.0315) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. 0.0135 (0.0476) -0.0922** (0.0109) -0.0830** (0.0056) Deaf and Blind Autism 0.0076 (0.0069) -0.0547** (0.0145) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0780 (0.0739) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1244** (0.0077) -0.0739** (0.0213) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1679 64 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.1071) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0543** (0.0048) Changed Schools -0.0005 (0.0104) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0006 (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0057** (0.0003) Age-in-grade -0.0026** (0.0002) Constant -0.4858** (0.0308) Observations 341234 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 65 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Math Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.4674** (0.0029) Lagged ELA Score 0.0927** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.0292** (0.0019) Lagged Science Score 0.1239** (0.0024) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0686** (0.0029) tgrde_7 0.0028 (0.0119) tgrde_8 -0.0052 (0.0139) Female 0.0030 (0.0021) Foreign Born 0.0809** (0.0065) ESOL Enrolled -0.0330** (0.0077) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0594** (0.0032) Gifted 0.3085** (0.0064) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0679** (0.0054) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1385** (0.0491) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0057 (0.0093) 66 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Deaf 0.0101 (0.0318) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism 0.0136 (0.0473) -0.0852** (0.0109) -0.0804** (0.0057) 0.0379** (0.0069) -0.0453** (0.0145) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0692 (0.0726) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1167** (0.0077) -0.0766** (0.0213) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1804 (0.1103) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0551** (0.0048) Changed Schools -0.0029 (0.0105) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0025** 67 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0044** (0.0003) Age-in-grade -0.0025** (0.0002) Constant -0.3847** (0.0302) Observations 341234 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 68 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Math Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.5131** (0.0031) Lagged ELA Score 0.1110** (0.0023) Lagged Reading Score 0.0411** (0.0019) Lagged Science Score 0.1341** (0.0026) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.0845** (0.0030) Constant 0.0073** (0.0002) Observations 341234 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 69 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Science Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.1503** (0.0023) Lagged ELA Score 0.0715** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.1117** (0.0019) Lagged Science Score 0.3318** (0.0028) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1670** (0.0031) tgrde_7 0.0004 (0.0133) tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic -0.0007 (0.0131) -0.0900** (0.0021) 0.0515** (0.0060) -0.0800** (0.0035) -0.0400** (0.0046) Asian -0.0095 (0.0291) American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled -0.0215 (0.0203) -0.0205** (0.0057) -0.0493** (0.0071) 70 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0404** (0.0028) Gifted 0.1259** (0.0049) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0335** (0.0046) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0241 (0.0385) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0376** (0.0099) Deaf -0.0856** (0.0287) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind -0.0689 (0.0394) -0.1006** (0.0106) -0.1153** (0.0047) -0.0808** (0.0072) Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0197 (0.0122) -0.1545** (0.0513) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1248** (0.0072) -0.1682** (0.0129) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1586 71 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Sev. Intellectual Dis. (0.0864) 0.2641** (0.0087) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0502** (0.0051) Changed Schools -0.0058 (0.0109) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0120** (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0021** (0.0003) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0023** (0.0002) Constant -0.0370 (0.0323) Observations 354119 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 72 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Science Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.1524** (0.0023) Lagged ELA Score 0.0700** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.1123** (0.0019) Lagged Science Score 0.3377** (0.0028) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1661** (0.0031) tgrde_7 -0.0019 (0.0134) tgrde_8 -0.0035 (0.0132) Female -0.0901** (0.0021) Foreign Born 0.0535** (0.0061) ESOL Enrolled -0.0452** (0.0072) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0560** (0.0029) Gifted 0.1297** (0.0049) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0416** (0.0043) Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp. -0.0170 (0.0379) -0.0365** (0.0099) 73 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Deaf -0.0821** (0.0286) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind -0.0672 (0.0393) -0.0946** (0.0106) -0.1133** (0.0047) -0.0526** (0.0071) Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0114 (0.0123) -0.1497** (0.0511) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1173** (0.0071) -0.1704** (0.0130) Mod. Intellectual Dis. Sev. Intellectual Dis. -0.1621 (0.0871) 0.2816** (0.0087) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0510** (0.0051) Changed Schools -0.0084 (0.0110) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0142** 74 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0008* (0.0004) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0022** (0.0002) Constant 0.0710* (0.0329) Observations 354119 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 75 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Science Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.1770** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0681** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.1121** (0.0019) Lagged Science Score 0.3560** (0.0028) Lagged Soc. Stud. Score 0.1882** (0.0031) Constant 0.0250** (0.0001) Observations 354119 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 76 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates Lagged Math Score 0.0861** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0605** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.1234** (0.0020) Lagged Science Score 0.2084** (0.0032) Lagged Social Studies Score 0.3362** (0.0035) tgrde_7 0.0109 (0.0131) tgrde_8 Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic 0.0054 (0.0130) -0.0853** (0.0024) 0.0374** (0.0065) 0.0096** (0.0035) -0.0117* (0.0051) Asian 0.0295 (0.0273) American Indian -0.0000 (0.0195) Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled 0.0041 (0.0053) -0.0631** (0.0093) 77 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0523** (0.0029) Gifted 0.1233** (0.0057) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0532** (0.0053) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0765 (0.0447) Speech-Language Imp. Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0009 (0.0096) -0.0568* (0.0259) -0.1100** (0.0400) -0.1260** (0.0112) -0.1285** (0.0051) -0.2125** (0.0087) -0.0676** (0.0115) -0.1857** (0.0480) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1359** (0.0071) -0.1720** (0.0139) 78 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Mod. Intellectual Dis. Sev. Intellectual Dis. -0.1520 (0.0816) 0.5233** (0.0102) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0709** (0.0050) Changed Schools 0.0026 (0.0090) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0133** (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0024** (0.0003) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0033** (0.0002) Constant -0.0826* (0.0335) Observations 352798 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 79 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Lagged Math Score 0.0859** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0607** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.1233** (0.0020) Lagged Science Score 0.2077** (0.0032) Lagged Social Studies Score 0.3364** (0.0035) tgrde_7 0.0112 (0.0131) tgrde_8 0.0058 (0.0130) Female -0.0852** (0.0024) Foreign Born 0.0383** (0.0066) ESOL Enrolled -0.0645** (0.0093) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0514** (0.0030) Gifted 0.1232** (0.0057) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0419** (0.0049) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0759 (0.0446) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0008 (0.0096) 80 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Deaf Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0569* (0.0259) -0.1096** (0.0400) -0.1264** (0.0112) -0.1286** (0.0051) -0.2141** (0.0086) -0.0682** (0.0115) -0.1857** (0.0480) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1364** (0.0071) -0.1713** (0.0139) Mod. Intellectual Dis. Sev. Intellectual Dis. -0.1521 (0.0818) 0.5215** (0.0101) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0707** (0.0050) Changed Schools 0.0030 (0.0090) 81 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0130** (0.0008) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0026** (0.0003) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0033** (0.0002) Constant -0.0967** (0.0331) Observations 352798 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 82 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Middle Social Studies Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Lagged Math Score 0.1116** (0.0024) Lagged ELA Score 0.0618** (0.0021) Lagged Reading Score 0.1242** (0.0020) Lagged Science Score 0.2246** (0.0033) Lagged Social Studies Score 0.3590** (0.0036) Constant 0.0259** (0.0001) Observations 352798 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 83 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS 9th Grade Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.0525** (0.0035) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.2580** (0.0034) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1892** (0.0037) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1429** (0.0033) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.1802** (0.0035) Female 0.1061** (0.0038) Foreign Born Black Hispanic -0.0052 (0.0079) -0.0503** (0.0055) -0.0163* (0.0075) Asian 0.0269 (0.0422) American Indian -0.0054 (0.0295) Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted -0.0025 (0.0091) -0.1483** (0.0129) -0.0608** (0.0043) 0.1376** (0.0071) 84 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0376** (0.0078) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1437* (0.0609) Speech-Language Imp. -0.1504** (0.0205) Deaf -0.2510** (0.0407) Visual Impairment -0.1587* (0.0727) Emotional/Behav. Dis. -0.1638** (0.0171) Specific Learning Dis. -0.2022** (0.0086) Deaf and Blind 0.3264** (0.0067) Autism -0.1151** (0.0227) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.4221** (0.0943) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1571** (0.0120) -0.3839** (0.0231) -0.6871** (0.1878) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 85 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0616** (0.0080) Changed Schools -0.0330** (0.0097) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0060** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0142** (0.0011) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0013** (0.0004) Constant 0.2789** (0.0396) Observations 117067 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 86 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS 9th Grade Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.0529** (0.0035) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.2573** (0.0034) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1900** (0.0037) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1460** (0.0033) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.1809** (0.0035) Female 0.1057** (0.0038) Foreign Born -0.0038 (0.0079) ESOL Enrolled -0.1448** (0.0129) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0697** (0.0044) Gifted 0.1398** (0.0072) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0277** (0.0071) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1373* (0.0619) Speech-Language Imp. -0.1511** (0.0206) Deaf -0.2491** (0.0409) Visual Impairment -0.1608* (0.0729) 87 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1590** (0.0171) -0.2005** (0.0086) 0.3230** (0.0067) -0.1098** (0.0228) -0.4171** (0.0936) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1516** (0.0120) -0.3870** (0.0231) -0.6819** (0.1831) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0624** (0.0081) Changed Schools -0.0317** (0.0098) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0059** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0155** (0.0010) 88 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present -0.0020** (0.0004) Constant 0.3284** (0.0395) Observations 117067 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 89 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS 9th Grade Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.0758** (0.0035) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.3092** (0.0034) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.2118** (0.0035) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1401** (0.0033) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.1869** (0.0035) Constant 0.0389** (0.0002) Observations 117067 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 90 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Amer. Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.0260** (0.0036) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.2309** (0.0043) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1909** (0.0040) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1391** (0.0038) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2147** (0.0043) Female 0.0930** (0.0043) Foreign Born Black 0.0053 (0.0101) -0.0455** (0.0057) Hispanic -0.0111 (0.0085) Asian -0.0360 (0.0586) American Indian -0.0296 (0.0360) Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0207 (0.0111) -0.1108** (0.0194) -0.0553** (0.0044) 0.1758** (0.0078) 91 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0619** (0.0104) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1134 (0.1034) Speech-Language Imp. -0.1870** (0.0468) Deaf -0.2520** (0.0628) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.1729 (0.0973) -0.1666** (0.0213) -0.2580** (0.0111) Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0000 (.) -0.1243** (0.0309) -0.3707** (0.0913) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.2234** (0.0141) -0.4741** (0.0376) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1431 (0.3718) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 92 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0516** (0.0122) Changed Schools 0.0005 (0.0090) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0091** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0186** (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0001 (0.0005) Constant -0.0113 (0.0488) Observations 98260 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 93 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Am. Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.0260** (0.0036) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.2301** (0.0043) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1921** (0.0040) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1430** (0.0038) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2151** (0.0043) Female 0.0931** (0.0043) Foreign Born 0.0070 (0.0101) ESOL Enrolled -0.1065** (0.0195) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0632** (0.0044) Gifted 0.1777** (0.0077) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0518** (0.0093) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1122 (0.1033) Speech-Language Imp. -0.1887** (0.0466) Deaf -0.2474** (0.0627) Visual Impairment -0.1722 (0.0976) 94 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.1631** (0.0214) -0.2556** (0.0111) Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0000 (.) -0.1186** (0.0310) -0.3642** (0.0917) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.2182** (0.0141) -0.4749** (0.0375) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1460 (0.3765) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0520** (0.0122) Changed Schools -0.0023 (0.0090) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0091** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0198** (0.0015) 95 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present -0.0004 (0.0005) Constant 0.0215 (0.0487) Observations 98260 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 96 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Amer. Lit. & Comp. Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.0574** (0.0037) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.2859** (0.0044) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.2233** (0.0039) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1315** (0.0037) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2333** (0.0045) Constant -0.0574** (0.0004) Observations 98260 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 97 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Analytic Geometry Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.3744** (0.0055) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0852** (0.0033) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0067* (0.0031) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1993** (0.0043) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0384** (0.0038) Female Foreign Born Black Hispanic -0.0037 (0.0037) 0.0581** (0.0104) -0.0913** (0.0073) -0.0787** (0.0103) Asian -0.0672 (0.0554) American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0064 (0.0420) -0.0446** (0.0096) 0.0789** (0.0208) -0.0428** (0.0049) 0.3106** (0.0117) 98 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0309** (0.0106) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1964* (0.0820) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0017 (0.0334) Deaf 0.0000 (0.0559) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.0840 (0.0720) -0.0604** (0.0194) -0.0753** (0.0101) Deaf and Blind Autism 0.0000 (.) -0.0843* (0.0345) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0928 (0.0845) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.1346** (0.0147) Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0227 (0.0334) 1.2477** (0.0108) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 99 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0902** (0.0120) Changed Schools 0.0780** (0.0118) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0058** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0094** (0.0014) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0073** (0.0005) Constant -0.6733** (0.0502) Observations 104062 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 100 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Analytic Geometry Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.3750** (0.0055) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0851** (0.0033) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0071* (0.0031) Grade 8 Science Score 0.2060** (0.0044) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0390** (0.0039) Female -0.0037 (0.0037) Foreign Born 0.0591** (0.0105) ESOL Enrolled 0.0880** (0.0211) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0627** (0.0053) Gifted 0.3164** (0.0120) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0219* (0.0089) Orthopedic Impairment -0.1867* (0.0805) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0064 (0.0335) Deaf 0.0014 (0.0559) Visual Impairment -0.0761 (0.0721) 101 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.0500** (0.0191) -0.0710** (0.0101) Deaf and Blind Autism 0.0000 (.) -0.0722* (0.0343) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0997 (0.0850) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.1249** (0.0147) Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0189 (0.0335) 1.2608** (0.0110) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0914** (0.0121) Changed Schools 0.0759** (0.0118) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0057** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0119** (0.0015) 102 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present 0.0061** (0.0005) Constant -0.5865** (0.0490) Observations 104062 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 103 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Analytic Geometry Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.4238** (0.0062) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.1151** (0.0036) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0175** (0.0031) Grade 8 Science Score 0.2250** (0.0049) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0570** (0.0042) Constant -0.0818** (0.0010) Observations 104062 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 104 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Coordinate Algebra Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.4197** (0.0047) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0705** (0.0035) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0198** (0.0028) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1780** (0.0038) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0608** (0.0034) Female -0.0518** (0.0036) Foreign Born 0.0462** (0.0090) Black -0.0784** (0.0051) Hispanic -0.0717** (0.0081) Asian -0.0075 (0.0468) American Indian Multi-Racial ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted -0.0357 (0.0306) -0.0423** (0.0092) 0.0478** (0.0120) -0.0451** (0.0047) 0.3375** (0.0106) 105 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0067 (0.0086) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0693 (0.0772) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0116 (0.0255) Deaf -0.0065 (0.0314) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind -0.0383 (0.0572) -0.0412** (0.0146) -0.0500** (0.0077) 0.1360** (0.0062) Autism 0.0227 (0.0211) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.0020 (0.0766) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.0690** (0.0109) Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0423 (0.0216) Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.1473 (0.1312) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 106 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0591** (0.0076) Changed Schools 0.0375** (0.0097) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0027** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0044** (0.0011) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0018** (0.0004) Constant -0.0766 (0.0413) Observations 113579 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 107 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Coordinate Algebra Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.4204** (0.0047) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0694** (0.0035) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0210** (0.0028) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1831** (0.0039) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0619** (0.0034) Female -0.0522** (0.0036) Foreign Born 0.0485** (0.0091) ESOL Enrolled 0.0557** (0.0122) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0617** (0.0047) Gifted 0.3417** (0.0108) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0206** (0.0079) Orthopedic Impairment -0.0592 (0.0782) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0113 (0.0255) Deaf -0.0042 (0.0316) Visual Impairment -0.0418 (0.0572) 108 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind -0.0330* (0.0146) -0.0471** (0.0077) 0.1312** (0.0062) Autism 0.0320 (0.0212) Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0018 (0.0748) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.0590** (0.0108) Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0402 (0.0218) Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.1502 (0.1343) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0603** (0.0076) Changed Schools 0.0389** (0.0098) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0027** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0062** (0.0011) 109 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present 0.0007 (0.0004) Constant -0.0039 (0.0405) Observations 113579 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 110 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Coordinate Algebra Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.4549** (0.0049) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0833** (0.0037) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0247** (0.0029) Grade 8 Science Score 0.2036** (0.0042) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0818** (0.0038) Constant 0.0158** (0.0009) Observations 113579 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 111 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Mathematics II Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.3687** (0.0278) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.1063** (0.0203) Grade 8 Reading Score Grade 8 Science Score 0.0052 (0.0204) 0.1738** (0.0226) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0055 (0.0190) Female -0.0040 (0.0228) Foreign Born 0.0176 (0.0589) Black -0.0503 (0.0303) Hispanic -0.0466 (0.0523) Asian -0.2417 (0.2606) American Indian 0.0517 (0.2021) Multi-Racial -0.1172 (0.0718) ESOL Enrolled 0.0034 (0.0917) Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0410 (0.0270) 0.4138** (0.1324) 112 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0397 (0.0625) Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp. 0.0000 (.) 0.3780* (0.1574) Deaf 0.5320 (0.3116) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. 0.1044 (0.4471) -0.1486* (0.0678) -0.2023** (0.0428) Deaf and Blind 0.0000 (.) Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.1104 (0.1917) -0.7578** (0.1093) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.1317** (0.0492) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.0324 (0.1065) Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 113 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0775 (0.0460) Changed Schools 0.0337 (0.0347) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0058** (0.0010) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0184** (0.0044) Lagged Pct. Present -0.0003 (0.0014) Constant 0.6084** (0.1406) Observations 6841 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 114 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Mathematics II Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.3695** (0.0277) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.1050** (0.0200) Grade 8 Reading Score Grade 8 Science Score 0.0063 (0.0204) 0.1772** (0.0223) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0060 (0.0190) Female -0.0050 (0.0227) Foreign Born 0.0177 (0.0593) ESOL Enrolled 0.0095 (0.0917) Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0324 (0.0265) 0.4203** (0.1329) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0393 (0.0518) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0000 (.) Speech-Language Imp. 0.3643* (0.1608) Deaf 0.5378 (0.3127) Visual Impairment 0.1099 (0.4600) 115 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.1414* (0.0676) -0.2007** (0.0430) Deaf and Blind 0.0000 (.) Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.1128 (0.1920) -0.7611** (0.1091) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.1251* (0.0486) Mild Intellectual Dis. -0.0368 (0.1068) Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0779 (0.0462) Changed Schools 0.0321 (0.0347) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0058** (0.0010) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0193** (0.0044) 116 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present -0.0005 (0.0014) Constant 0.5946** (0.1397) Observations 6841 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 117 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Mathematics II Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.3897** (0.0270) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.1354** (0.0195) Grade 8 Reading Score Grade 8 Science Score 0.0126 (0.0209) 0.1782** (0.0228) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.0187 (0.0185) Constant 0.4537** (0.0166) Observations 6841 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 118 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Biology Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.1328** (0.0040) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0587** (0.0036) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0990** (0.0031) Grade 8 Science Score 0.3104** (0.0044) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2251** (0.0043) Female -0.0699** (0.0037) Foreign Born 0.0494** (0.0087) Black -0.0935** (0.0058) Hispanic -0.0598** (0.0080) Asian -0.0347 (0.0470) American Indian 0.0260 (0.0381) Multi-Racial -0.0157 (0.0109) ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted -0.0119 (0.0130) -0.0343** (0.0045) 0.1900** (0.0089) 119 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0180* (0.0084) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0216 (0.0749) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0509 (0.0267) Deaf -0.0331 (0.0371) Visual Impairment -0.0359 (0.0580) Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. 0.0011 (0.0159) -0.0232* (0.0092) Deaf and Blind Autism 0.0000 (.) 0.1227** (0.0211) Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0245 (0.0771) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.0388** (0.0114) Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0194 (0.0219) Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.2413 (0.2451) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 120 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0898** (0.0090) Changed Schools 0.0012 (0.0116) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0040** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0177** (0.0012) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0027** (0.0004) Constant -0.0682 (0.0440) Observations 114915 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 121 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Biology Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.1336** (0.0040) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0575** (0.0037) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1004** (0.0031) Grade 8 Science Score 0.3166** (0.0045) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2262** (0.0043) Female -0.0704** (0.0037) Foreign Born 0.0508** (0.0087) ESOL Enrolled -0.0021 (0.0134) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0526** (0.0048) Gifted 0.1950** (0.0090) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0166* (0.0078) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0333 (0.0745) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0538* (0.0273) Deaf -0.0284 (0.0378) Visual Impairment -0.0351 (0.0585) 122 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. 0.0122 (0.0159) -0.0195* (0.0092) Deaf and Blind Autism 0.0000 (.) 0.1319** (0.0211) Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0236 (0.0797) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. 0.0000 (.) -0.0285* (0.0113) Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0173 (0.0219) Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.2579 (0.2422) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0906** (0.0089) Changed Schools 0.0027 (0.0117) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0040** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0200** (0.0012) 123 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present 0.0015** (0.0004) Constant 0.0083 (0.0431) Observations 114915 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 124 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Biology Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.1575** (0.0042) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0628** (0.0038) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1014** (0.0032) Grade 8 Science Score 0.3415** (0.0045) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2467** (0.0046) Constant 0.0139** (0.0002) Observations 114915 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 125 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Physical Science Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.2406** (0.0062) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0577** (0.0048) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0554** (0.0046) Grade 8 Science Score 0.3708** (0.0055) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.1242** (0.0049) Female -0.0909** (0.0054) Foreign Born Black Hispanic 0.0235 (0.0150) -0.1068** (0.0072) -0.0727** (0.0124) Asian -0.0636 (0.0631) American Indian 0.0406 (0.0440) Multi-Racial -0.0248 (0.0155) ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted -0.0240 (0.0228) -0.0259** (0.0062) 0.1986** (0.0153) 126 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0217 (0.0136) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0075 (0.0697) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0525 (0.0429) Deaf -0.0793 (0.0659) Visual Impairment -0.1722 (0.1020) Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism -0.0313 (0.0213) -0.0558** (0.0113) -0.1979** (0.0083) 0.0783* (0.0374) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1970 (0.1622) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.0981** (0.0170) -0.1205** (0.0306) -0.7310** (0.2528) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 127 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0790** (0.0131) Changed Schools 0.0078 (0.0130) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0063** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0189** (0.0013) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0032** (0.0005) Constant -0.0394 (0.0509) Observations 59484 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 128 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Physical Science Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.2402** (0.0063) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0563** (0.0048) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0580** (0.0047) Grade 8 Science Score 0.3799** (0.0056) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.1254** (0.0049) Female -0.0913** (0.0054) Foreign Born 0.0281 (0.0156) ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted -0.0091 (0.0242) -0.0469** (0.0062) 0.2024** (0.0153) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0149 (0.0109) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0175 (0.0712) Speech-Language Imp. -0.0542 (0.0426) Deaf -0.0810 (0.0670) Visual Impairment -0.1659 (0.1024) 129 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. Deaf and Blind Autism -0.0212 (0.0213) -0.0503** (0.0114) -0.2053** (0.0085) 0.0906* (0.0377) Traumatic Brain Injury -0.1803 (0.1613) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. Mod. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.0846** (0.0170) -0.1302** (0.0309) -0.7523** (0.2305) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0797** (0.0131) Changed Schools 0.0060 (0.0129) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0062** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0216** (0.0014) 130 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present 0.0019** (0.0005) Constant 0.0494 (0.0505) Observations 59484 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 131 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Physical Science Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.2651** (0.0062) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0616** (0.0048) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0580** (0.0047) Grade 8 Science Score 0.4070** (0.0055) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.1480** (0.0051) Constant 0.0764** (0.0018) Observations 59484 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 132 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Economics Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.1122** (0.0045) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0656** (0.0040) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1102** (0.0036) Grade 8 Science Score 0.2199** (0.0051) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2634** (0.0050) Female -0.1195** (0.0053) Foreign Born 0.0940** (0.0130) Black -0.0886** (0.0069) Hispanic -0.0593** (0.0105) Asian -0.0245 (0.0738) American Indian Multi-Racial -0.0036 (0.0416) -0.0287* (0.0140) ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0088 (0.0269) -0.0266** (0.0060) 0.1572** (0.0097) 133 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0097 (0.0114) Orthopedic Impairment Speech-Language Imp. 0.0269 (0.1071) -0.1214* (0.0594) Deaf -0.0653 (0.0550) Visual Impairment Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.0628 (0.0785) -0.0908** (0.0251) -0.1432** (0.0131) Deaf and Blind 0.0000 (.) Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0106 (0.0359) -0.3560** (0.0894) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1492** (0.0160) -0.1672** (0.0352) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.3866 (0.2358) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 134 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.1018** (0.0168) Changed Schools -0.0396** (0.0144) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0083** (0.0004) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0244** (0.0018) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0039** (0.0005) Constant -0.2783** (0.0481) Observations 91439 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 135 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Economics Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.1131** (0.0045) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0637** (0.0040) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1118** (0.0036) Grade 8 Science Score 0.2264** (0.0051) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2651** (0.0050) Female -0.1192** (0.0053) Foreign Born 0.0952** (0.0131) ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0177 (0.0276) -0.0451** (0.0059) 0.1621** (0.0098) Prim. Lang. Not English -0.0079 (0.0109) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0337 (0.1056) Speech-Language Imp. -0.1262* (0.0600) Deaf -0.0598 (0.0548) Visual Impairment -0.0698 (0.0795) 136 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.0815** (0.0253) -0.1393** (0.0130) Deaf and Blind 0.0000 (.) Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0215 (0.0360) -0.3600** (0.0874) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.1378** (0.0160) -0.1699** (0.0354) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.4282 (0.2396) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.1033** (0.0167) Changed Schools -0.0420** (0.0142) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0083** (0.0004) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0268** (0.0018) 137 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present 0.0031** (0.0005) Constant -0.2317** (0.0477) Observations 91439 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 138 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS Economics Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.1398** (0.0048) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0682** (0.0041) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.1137** (0.0037) Grade 8 Science Score 0.2556** (0.0053) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.2893** (0.0051) Constant -0.1244** (0.0011) Observations 91439 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 139 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS U.S. History Value-Added Model Estimates Grade 8 Math Score 0.0524** (0.0041) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0442** (0.0038) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0697** (0.0038) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1474** (0.0048) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.4432** (0.0060) Female -0.1751** (0.0051) Foreign Born 0.0623** (0.0107) Black -0.0311** (0.0071) Hispanic 0.0275* (0.0107) Asian -0.0248 (0.0590) American Indian -0.0224 (0.0432) Multi-Racial 0.0064 (0.0126) ESOL Enrolled Free/Reduced Lunch Gifted 0.0260 (0.0202) -0.0262** (0.0060) 0.1089** (0.0111) 140 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0113 (0.0129) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0688 (0.1133) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0084 (0.0463) Deaf Visual Impairment -0.0156 (0.0786) 0.1897* (0.0759) Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. -0.0001 (0.0220) -0.0444** (0.0115) Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0000 (.) 0.1889** (0.0345) -0.3276** (0.0979) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.0515** (0.0163) -0.1431** (0.0299) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1544 (0.2926) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) 141 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.0999** (0.0125) Changed Schools -0.0059 (0.0097) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0059** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0265** (0.0015) Lagged Pct. Present 0.0065** (0.0006) Constant -0.4722** (0.0559) Observations 97375 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 142 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS U.S. History Value-Added Model Estimates, without Race/Ethnicity Grade 8 Math Score 0.0523** (0.0041) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0435** (0.0038) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0705** (0.0038) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1500** (0.0048) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.4434** (0.0060) Female -0.1750** (0.0051) Foreign Born 0.0649** (0.0108) ESOL Enrolled 0.0273 (0.0203) Free/Reduced Lunch -0.0297** (0.0059) Gifted 0.1095** (0.0111) Prim. Lang. Not English 0.0379** (0.0111) Orthopedic Impairment 0.0697 (0.1134) Speech-Language Imp. 0.0059 (0.0462) Deaf Visual Impairment -0.0120 (0.0792) 0.1865* (0.0758) 143 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Emotional/Behav. Dis. Specific Learning Dis. 0.0006 (0.0220) -0.0430** (0.0115) Deaf and Blind Autism Traumatic Brain Injury 0.0000 (.) 0.1921** (0.0344) -0.3238** (0.0975) Significant Dev. Delay Other Health Imp. Mild Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) -0.0489** (0.0164) -0.1453** (0.0298) Mod. Intellectual Dis. -0.1573 (0.2952) Sev. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Prof. Intellectual Dis. 0.0000 (.) Num. Schools Attended -0.1003** (0.0125) Changed Schools -0.0079 (0.0096) Diff. from Modal Age -0.0058** (0.0003) Lagged Num. Disc. Inc. -0.0274** (0.0015) 144 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lagged Pct. Present 0.0062** (0.0005) Constant -0.4454** (0.0551) Observations 97375 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 145 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix HS U.S. History Value-Added Model Estimates, Lagged Scores Only Grade 8 Math Score 0.0700** (0.0045) Grade 8 ELA Score 0.0338** (0.0037) Grade 8 Reading Score 0.0564** (0.0040) Grade 8 Science Score 0.1945** (0.0047) Grade 8 Soc. Stud. Score 0.4723** (0.0063) Constant -0.0524** (0.0006) Observations 97375 Standard errors in parentheses Standard errors adjusted for clustering at the school level * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 146 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix III. School Effect Estimates Based on Alternative Value-Added Models and School-Level Growth Percentiles Based on Alternative Measures and Samples All of the analyses in the main report are based on estimated school effects from the full value-added model that includes all available demographic controls. The following charts and tables report estimates based on the two alternative specifications of the value-added model, one that excludes indicators for race and ethnicity and one that eliminates all demographic variables (and thus only includes lagged test scores). The school-level student growth measures in the main report are averages of the individual student growth percentiles for students attending a given school. They are based on the full sample of students with SGP information. Results using three alternative school-level growth measures are presented below. The first uses school average SGPs, but only includes students used in the full value added model estimation (denoted "value-added sample"). This excludes, for example, students with missing demographic information. The second alternative employs this same sample, but uses the school-level median SGP, rather than the mean. The third alternative employs the full sample but utilizes the school median SGP. Finally, a summary table provides statewide percentile rankings of schools using a common sample of students and each of five different measures (school effects from the three different value-added model specifications and both school median and school mean SGPs). 147 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Atlanta Heights Cherokee Pataula Coweta Odyssey GA Connections Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix A. State Charter School Effects -- Statewide Comparisons from Alternate Value- Added Models Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 148 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Atlanta Heights Cherokee Odyssey GA Connections Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Georgia Connections Academy 0.0992 0.0419 56 84 Scholars Academy Charter School 0.0980 0.0799 60 84 Odyssey School 0.0978 0.0161 53 84 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0304 0.0493 55 61 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0110 0.0646 51 44 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0830 0.0392 51 21 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1469 0.0497 49 9 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.2167 0.0891 52 2 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.2260 0.0925 51 2 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 80 96 63 73 43 45 26 51 40 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Georgia Connections Academy 0.1088 0.0421 56 86 Scholars Academy Charter School 0.0990 0.0804 60 84 Odyssey School 0.0548 0.0162 53 71 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0455 0.0496 55 67 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0256 0.0650 51 39 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0774 0.0395 51 23 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1517 0.0500 49 7 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.1947 0.0897 52 3 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.2432 0.0931 51 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 80 96 63 73 43 45 26 51 40 149 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Cherokee GA Connections Pataula Atlanta Heights Odyssey Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 150 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Cherokee Pataula Odyssey GA Connections Atlanta Heights Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Scholars Academy Charter School 0.1515 0.0770 53 94 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0532 0.0475 50 72 Odyssey School 0.0519 0.0156 49 71 Atlanta Heights Charter School 0.0266 0.0479 48 61 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0094 0.0627 49 51 Georgia Connections Academy 0.0048 0.0401 50 49 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.1023 0.0379 47 15 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.1389 0.0892 46 9 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.2613 0.0859 48 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 86 68 67 53 63 73 49 42 54 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Scholars Academy Charter School 0.1564 0.0781 53 94 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0581 0.0482 50 74 Atlanta Heights Charter School 0.0117 0.0486 48 55 Georgia Connections Academy 0.0019 0.0407 50 49 Odyssey School 0.0002 0.0157 49 48 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0182 0.0636 49 41 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.1011 0.0384 47 16 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.1922 0.0905 46 4 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.2095 0.0871 48 2 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 86 68 53 73 67 63 49 42 54 151 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Odyssey Atlanta Heights Cherokee Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 152 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Odyssey Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Atlanta Heights Cherokee Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Scholars Academy Charter School 0.0970 0.0779 54 71 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0423 0.0481 50 59 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0027 0.0634 42 50 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.1533 0.0384 48 19 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.2015 0.0484 38 12 Odyssey School -0.2305 0.0157 38 9 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.2404 0.0869 36 8 Georgia Connections Academy -0.3244 0.0408 34 3 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.4610 0.0891 42 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 80 64 28 53 16 16 13 8 30 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Scholars Academy Charter School 0.0720 0.0792 54 65 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0304 0.0488 50 57 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0326 0.0644 42 42 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.1551 0.0390 48 18 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.2299 0.0492 38 8 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.2691 0.0883 36 6 Odyssey School -0.2892 0.0159 38 4 Georgia Connections Academy -0.3477 0.0415 34 3 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.4547 0.0905 42 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 80 64 28 53 16 13 16 8 30 153 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Atlanta Heights Cherokee GA Connections Odyssey Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 154 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Atlanta Heights Cherokee Odyssey GA Connections Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 0.0989 0.0461 50 74 Scholars Academy Charter School 0.0745 0.0749 58 70 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0173 0.0602 47 44 Odyssey School -0.0596 0.0149 44 33 Georgia Connections Academy -0.0810 0.0392 42 28 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.1218 0.0364 47 21 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1563 0.0462 48 15 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.4450 0.0857 41 1 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.4936 0.0836 43 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 47 82 30 15 10 27 33 8 12 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 0.1073 0.0464 50 77 Scholars Academy Charter School 0.0567 0.0755 58 66 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0433 0.0607 47 37 Georgia Connections Academy -0.0822 0.0395 42 28 Odyssey School -0.0982 0.0150 44 25 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.1087 0.0366 47 23 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1705 0.0466 48 13 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.4041 0.0864 41 1 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.5374 0.0843 43 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 47 82 30 10 15 27 33 8 12 155 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Atlanta Heights Odyssey Cherokee Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Social Studies Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 156 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Atlanta Heights Odyssey Cherokee Pataula Coweta Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Commissioned Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Mean SGP Standard Error Student Growth State Rank State Rank Percentile Percentile Percentile Scholars Academy Charter School 0.2153 0.0744 58 87 85 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0889 0.0458 50 68 56 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0131 0.0598 47 53 46 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0896 0.0361 51 33 60 Odyssey School -0.1556 0.0148 38 21 14 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1805 0.0459 45 16 36 Georgia Connections Academy -0.2538 0.0390 34 8 6 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.4458 0.0851 28 1 2 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.5416 0.0830 35 1 8 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Commissioned Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Mean SGP Standard Error Student Growth State Rank State Rank Percentile Percentile Percentile Scholars Academy Charter School 0.1849 0.0754 58 85 85 Coweta Charter Academy 0.0960 0.0464 50 70 56 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0116 0.0606 47 48 46 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0722 0.0366 51 35 60 Odyssey School -0.1979 0.0150 38 14 14 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1988 0.0466 45 14 36 Georgia Connections Academy -0.2579 0.0395 34 8 6 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.3870 0.0863 28 2 2 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.6086 0.0841 35 1 8 157 Fulton Leadership GACoCwoentnaections PPOrrdeeypp..ss--eyYKirokunwgooMdens Iv y Iv y Cherokee Pataula Ivy Prep. CCAT Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 158 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. CCAT Cherokee Pataula Ivy PrOedpy.s-seYyoung Mens IvyFuPGlrtAeoCpn.oCo-LwneeKtnaiaredkcetriwsoohnoisdp Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Fulton Leadership Academy 0.2530 0.0461 62 98 Coweta Charter Academy 0.2135 0.0978 55 98 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1901 0.0263 56 97 Odyssey School 0.1566 0.0108 53 96 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls 0.1100 0.0603 52 90 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership 0.1088 0.0582 51 90 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0583 0.0544 51 74 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0409 0.0340 51 67 CCAT School 0.0403 0.0747 48 67 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.0002 0.0355 55 51 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.0578 0.0445 49 27 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.0787 0.0468 49 19 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 95 50 61 38 25 18 19 21 7 52 10 9 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 0.2143 0.0988 55 98 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1818 0.0265 56 97 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.1655 0.0465 62 96 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls 0.1351 0.0609 52 94 Odyssey School 0.1157 0.0108 53 91 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership 0.0564 0.0587 51 75 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0472 0.0550 51 72 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0426 0.0343 51 70 CCAT School 0.0407 0.0754 48 69 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 0.0204 0.0359 55 59 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.0103 0.0450 49 47 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.0873 0.0473 49 16 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 50 61 95 25 38 18 19 21 7 52 10 9 159 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT Pataula Ivy Prep. IvyChPrereop.k-eeYoung Mens IvGyOAdPryCsoesnp.en-yecKtiiroknwsood Coweta Atlanta Heights Fulton Leadership Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 160 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT Pataula Ivy PrIevpy. -PrYeop.ung Mens Cherokee Odyssey GFAulCtCooonwneLtneaeactidoernsship Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Fulton Leadership Academy 0.2218 0.0443 50 98 Atlanta Heights Charter School 0.1491 0.0447 48 96 Coweta Charter Academy 0.1395 0.0934 50 96 Odyssey School 0.1264 0.0103 49 94 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1089 0.0250 50 91 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls 0.1066 0.0579 48 91 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0624 0.0323 47 81 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership 0.0381 0.0555 46 72 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.0236 0.0338 45 40 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0306 0.0520 49 35 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.1105 0.0427 42 6 CCAT School -0.1995 0.0707 40 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 72 50 68 66 74 51 44 36 27 62 9 5 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls 0.1653 0.0590 48 97 Atlanta Heights Charter School 0.1368 0.0455 48 95 Coweta Charter Academy 0.1177 0.0952 50 93 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.0952 0.0451 50 89 Georgia Connections Academy 0.0825 0.0255 50 87 Odyssey School 0.0790 0.0104 49 86 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0517 0.0329 47 77 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 0.0288 0.0344 45 65 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.0426 0.0566 46 29 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0453 0.0530 49 28 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.0466 0.0435 42 27 CCAT School -0.2132 0.0721 40 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 51 50 68 72 74 66 44 27 36 62 9 5 161 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT GCAowCeotnanections Odyssey AtPlaatnatualaHeights IvFyCulthProerenop.Lkee-aeKdirerkswhiopod Ivy Prep. Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 162 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT GACCoownenteactions Odyssey FPulattoanulLaeadership Atlanta Heights Ivy CPrheerp.o-keKeirkwood Ivy Prep. Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership 0.1010 0.0515 42 79 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 0.0566 0.0315 47 69 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0265 0.0301 48 44 Fulton Leadership Academy -0.0386 0.0414 45 40 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.0499 0.0537 36 36 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0638 0.0479 42 32 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.0737 0.0412 38 30 Odyssey School -0.0799 0.0096 38 28 Coweta Charter Academy -0.1753 0.0861 50 7 Georgia Connections Academy -0.1875 0.0232 34 7 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.2287 0.0393 38 3 CCAT School -0.2806 0.0663 37 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 27 50 57 40 10 25 12 13 67 5 14 11 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership 0.0991 0.0525 42 79 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 0.0104 0.0321 47 58 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0360 0.0307 48 41 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.0775 0.0548 36 29 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.0884 0.0421 38 25 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0901 0.0489 42 24 Fulton Leadership Academy -0.1027 0.0422 45 20 Odyssey School -0.1398 0.0097 38 12 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.1420 0.0401 38 12 Coweta Charter Academy -0.1884 0.0879 50 5 Georgia Connections Academy -0.2303 0.0237 34 3 CCAT School -0.2846 0.0677 37 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 27 50 57 10 12 25 40 13 14 67 5 11 163 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Fulton Leadership Pataula Ivy Prep. GA Connections Odyssey Atlanta Heights Cherokee Coweta Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 164 FGultAOodCnyoLsnesnaeedycteirosnhisp Atlanta Heights Cherokee Coweta Mens Young - Ivy Prep. Pataula -PrKeirp.kwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Prep. Iv y Iv y CCAT Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 0.0886 0.0873 50 77 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0573 0.0300 47 69 Atlanta Heights Charter School 0.0105 0.0415 48 53 Odyssey School -0.0307 0.0095 44 39 Georgia Connections Academy -0.0794 0.0233 42 26 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.0943 0.0314 44 22 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0976 0.0484 47 21 Fulton Leadership Academy -0.1017 0.0405 48 20 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.1601 0.0507 41 12 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.1849 0.0536 43 8 CCAT School -0.2693 0.0641 35 3 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.2722 0.0392 40 2 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 51 27 33 13 8 13 30 37 6 11 3 6 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 0.1032 0.0881 50 81 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0647 0.0303 47 71 Atlanta Heights Charter School 0.0127 0.0419 48 54 Odyssey School -0.0610 0.0095 44 30 Georgia Connections Academy -0.0938 0.0235 42 22 Fulton Leadership Academy -0.1023 0.0409 48 21 Pataula Charter Academy -0.1080 0.0489 47 20 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.1088 0.0512 41 19 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.1582 0.0317 44 10 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.2312 0.0541 43 4 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.2377 0.0396 40 4 CCAT School -0.2421 0.0647 35 3 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 51 27 33 13 8 37 30 6 13 11 6 3 165 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens GA Connections Odyssey CCAT Coweta Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. Pataula Fulton Leadership Cherokee Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 166 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 GA Connections Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Odyssey Coweta CCAT Atlanta Heights Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. Pataula Fulton Leadership Cherokee Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Cherokee Charter Academy 0.2577 0.0303 51 93 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.1177 0.0409 53 78 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0104 0.0488 47 51 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.0117 0.0318 39 46 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.1125 0.0541 35 24 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1570 0.0418 45 17 Coweta Charter Academy -0.2374 0.0881 50 8 CCAT School -0.2460 0.0647 38 8 Odyssey School -0.2657 0.0096 38 7 Georgia Connections Academy -0.3528 0.0235 34 3 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.4151 0.0511 28 2 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.4908 0.0396 27 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 64 75 39 11 4 31 58 8 9 3 2 1 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Cherokee Charter Academy 0.2615 0.0306 51 94 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.1234 0.0413 53 81 Pataula Charter Academy -0.0016 0.0493 47 49 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.0678 0.0321 39 32 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girls -0.1469 0.0546 35 18 Atlanta Heights Charter School -0.1504 0.0422 45 18 CCAT School -0.2198 0.0653 38 11 Coweta Charter Academy -0.2296 0.0890 50 9 Odyssey School -0.2923 0.0097 38 5 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadership -0.3562 0.0517 28 3 Georgia Connections Academy -0.3697 0.0238 34 2 Heritage Preparatory Academy School -0.4490 0.0399 27 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 64 75 39 11 4 31 8 58 9 2 3 1 167 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Ivy Prep. Mountain Ed. Cherokee CCAT GA Connections Odyssey Fulton Leadership Pataula Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 168 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Ivy Prep. Mountain Ed. Cherokee CCAT GA Connections Odyssey Fulton Leadership Pataula Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 0.3380 0.0902 68 99 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.2808 0.0684 64 98 Odyssey School 0.2344 0.0182 56 97 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1571 0.0358 55 92 CCAT School 0.0928 0.1217 55 79 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0709 0.1070 44 73 Mountain Education Center School 0.0702 0.0886 46 73 Ivy Preparatory Academy School -0.0013 0.1295 47 49 Provost Academy Georgia -0.0472 0.0548 46 34 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 99 98 84 75 76 12 20 24 19 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 0.3717 0.0921 68 99 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.2424 0.0698 64 96 Odyssey School 0.2190 0.0179 56 96 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1707 0.0366 55 92 CCAT School 0.1630 0.1243 55 92 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0809 0.1093 44 75 Mountain Education Center School 0.0706 0.0906 46 72 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 0.0401 0.1323 47 62 Provost Academy Georgia -0.0532 0.0560 46 31 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 99 98 84 75 76 12 20 24 19 169 Mountain Ed. GA Connections Odyssey School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 American Literature Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 170 Mountain Ed. GA Connections Odyssey School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Odyssey School 0.2330 0.0243 50 95 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1611 0.0438 52 87 Mountain Education Center School -0.1423 0.0632 44 15 Provost Academy Georgia -0.1530 0.0531 35 14 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 70 79 27 2 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Odyssey School 0.1939 0.0248 50 91 Georgia Connections Academy 0.1448 0.0447 52 83 Mountain Education Center School -0.1361 0.0647 44 16 Provost Academy Georgia -0.1557 0.0544 35 13 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 70 79 27 2 171 Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost CCAT GA Connections Odyssey Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 172 Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost GA Connections Odyssey CCAT Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 0.3292 0.1337 78 92 Odyssey School -0.2343 0.0200 43 14 Georgia Connections Academy -0.2495 0.0441 42 11 CCAT School -0.2954 0.1381 36 5 Provost Academy Georgia -0.3886 0.0893 29 2 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 99 28 21 6 1 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 0.3199 0.1370 78 91 CCAT School -0.2469 0.1415 36 12 Odyssey School -0.2780 0.0204 43 8 Georgia Connections Academy -0.3004 0.0451 42 6 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4536 0.0913 29 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 99 6 28 21 1 173 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Odyssey GA Connections CCAT Cherokee Mountain Ed. Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 174 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Odyssey GA Connections Mountain Ed. Cherokee CCAT Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School 0.0147 0.0725 48 56 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0442 0.1090 41 44 CCAT School -0.0584 0.1278 56 40 Georgia Connections Academy -0.0797 0.0353 40 35 Odyssey School -0.1864 0.0168 34 15 Provost Academy Georgia -0.2244 0.0474 35 9 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 60 36 84 30 11 14 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile CCAT School 0.0451 0.1294 56 62 Cherokee Charter Academy -0.0458 0.1104 41 42 Mountain Education Center School -0.0552 0.0732 48 39 Georgia Connections Academy -0.1065 0.0358 40 31 Odyssey School -0.2051 0.0168 34 12 Provost Academy Georgia -0.2623 0.0479 35 7 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 84 36 60 30 11 14 175 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Odyssey Mountain Ed. GA Connections Cherokee Pataula Fulton Leadership Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 176 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Odyssey GA Connections Mountain Ed. Cherokee Pataula Fulton Leadership Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Fulton Leadership Academy 0.2209 0.0660 50 89 Pataula Charter Academy 0.1313 0.1249 66 80 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0835 0.1249 60 72 Georgia Connections Academy -0.0529 0.0371 51 41 Mountain Education Center School -0.0611 0.1248 49 39 Odyssey School -0.0668 0.0170 48 36 Provost Academy Georgia -0.3419 0.0453 34 2 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 53 96 86 57 48 42 4 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Fulton Leadership Academy 0.2053 0.0673 50 87 Pataula Charter Academy 0.0713 0.1276 66 71 Cherokee Charter Academy 0.0309 0.1276 60 63 Mountain Education Center School -0.1062 0.1276 49 25 Georgia Connections Academy -0.1102 0.0379 51 24 Odyssey School -0.1343 0.0169 48 19 Provost Academy Georgia -0.3651 0.0461 34 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 53 96 86 48 57 42 4 177 Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost GA Connections Odyssey Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Economics Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 178 Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost GA Connections Odyssey Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School 0.1109 0.0571 61 68 Odyssey School -0.3176 0.0375 52 12 Georgia Connections Academy -0.3937 0.0576 43 7 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4625 0.0474 34 5 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 82 55 27 8 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School -0.0253 0.0575 61 45 Odyssey School -0.3457 0.0380 52 10 Georgia Connections Academy -0.4701 0.0583 43 6 Provost Academy Georgia -0.5673 0.0478 34 3 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 82 55 27 8 179 Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Math II Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 180 Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Provost Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School 0.3393 0.1357 66 89 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4456 0.1300 37 4 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 96 9 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School 0.3662 0.1350 66 88 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4690 0.1298 37 3 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 96 9 181 Pataula Provost CCAT Odyssey GA Connections Fulton Leadership Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 182 Pataula Provost CCAT Odyssey GA Connections Fulton Leadership Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 0.5183 0.0945 65 98 Mountain Education Center School 0.1307 0.0676 50 77 Fulton Leadership Academy -0.0534 0.0717 49 40 Georgia Connections Academy -0.1863 0.0433 36 19 Odyssey School -0.2190 0.0280 41 13 CCAT School -0.3439 0.1075 27 3 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4050 0.0427 29 2 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 95 59 56 10 22 1 3 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 0.5251 0.0960 65 98 Mountain Education Center School 0.0821 0.0684 50 69 Fulton Leadership Academy 0.0067 0.0727 49 54 Georgia Connections Academy -0.2087 0.0439 36 15 Odyssey School -0.2403 0.0283 41 11 CCAT School -0.3061 0.1091 27 5 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4548 0.0431 29 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 95 59 56 10 22 1 3 183 Mountain Ed. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 GA Connections CCAT Odyssey Provost Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) 184 School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 GA Connections Provost Mountain Ed. Odyssey CCAT Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School -0.0596 0.0665 43 43 Odyssey School -0.3975 0.0267 27 7 Provost Academy Georgia -0.4740 0.0543 26 4 CCAT School -0.4877 0.1158 22 3 Georgia Connections Academy -0.5600 0.0476 22 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 41 6 6 3 2 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [State Charters] School Name School Effect School Effect School Mean School Effect Standard Error Student Growth State Rank Percentile Percentile Mountain Education Center School -0.2255 0.0674 43 18 Odyssey School -0.4281 0.0271 27 7 CCAT School -0.4555 0.1181 22 5 Provost Academy Georgia -0.5830 0.0551 26 2 Georgia Connections Academy -0.6563 0.0483 22 1 Mean SGP State Rank Percentile 41 6 3 6 2 185 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix B. State Charter School Effects -- District Comparisons from Alternate Value- Added Models Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Reading APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Atlanta Heights State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Atlanta Heights State Charters Local Charters Traditional 186 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.2415 0.0495 58 99 92 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.1378 0.0439 56 91 83 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.1336 0.0634 55 90 74 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.1333 0.0434 57 90 86 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.1313 0.0461 57 89 84 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.1306 0.0627 60 89 96 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1299 0.0615 58 89 91 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.1164 0.0462 59 87 94 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1134 0.0344 61 87 97 Centennial Place Elementary School 0 0 0.1055 0.0502 57 85 86 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.0894 0.0562 60 82 95 The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele 0 0 0.0862 0.0663 48 81 21 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.0722 0.0375 64 76 99 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.0654 0.0322 60 74 95 Smith Elementary School 0 0 0.0651 0.0309 54 74 68 Continental Colony Elementary School 0 0 0.0463 0.0619 56 67 81 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.0304 0.0678 53 61 55 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0288 0.0465 52 60 52 Whitefoord Elementary School 0 0 0.0198 0.0776 50 56 36 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.0186 0.0622 55 56 71 Beecher Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0032 0.0611 49 47 24 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0137 0.0387 54 43 63 Kimberly Elementary School 0 0 -0.0283 0.0532 50 38 39 Kindezi 0 1 -0.0286 0.0913 52 38 54 187 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Rivers Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Slater Elementary School Humphries Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Heritage Academy Elementary Intown Charter Academy Finch Elementary Deerwood Academy School Fickett Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Bolton Academy Grove Park Intermediate School Burgess-Peterson Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm Thomasville Heights Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Boyd Elementary School KIPP VISION Perkerson Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Connally Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Scott Elementary School Towns Elementary School Fain Elementary School 0 0 -0.0430 0.0450 50 33 31 0 0 -0.0459 0.0677 48 32 20 0 0 -0.0562 0.0510 48 29 19 0 0 -0.0593 0.0486 50 28 32 0 0 -0.0605 0.0642 47 27 15 0 0 -0.0622 0.0499 50 27 34 0 0 -0.0649 0.0525 50 26 38 0 1 -0.0688 0.0823 50 25 35 0 0 -0.0739 0.0471 48 24 20 0 0 -0.0766 0.0466 47 23 17 0 0 -0.0992 0.0498 50 17 36 0 0 -0.0993 0.0502 46 17 12 0 0 -0.1102 0.0595 52 15 51 0 0 -0.1122 0.0634 44 14 6 0 0 -0.1175 0.0471 45 13 8 0 0 -0.1231 0.0424 47 12 17 0 0 -0.1239 0.0724 45 12 9 0 0 -0.1305 0.0446 50 11 36 0 0 -0.1309 0.0547 51 11 42 0 0 -0.1426 0.0642 52 9 50 1 0 -0.1469 0.0497 49 9 26 0 0 -0.1551 0.0659 48 7 19 0 0 -0.1660 0.0565 48 6 19 0 1 -0.1662 0.0703 53 6 58 0 0 -0.1676 0.0486 43 5 4 0 0 -0.1797 0.0471 48 4 19 0 0 -0.1889 0.0568 44 4 7 0 0 -0.1890 0.0630 40 4 1 0 0 -0.1977 0.0677 44 3 5 0 0 -0.2098 0.0672 42 2 3 0 0 -0.2211 0.0546 45 2 9 188 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.2350 0.0807 42 2 2 0 0 -0.2755 0.0525 43 1 5 189 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.2109 0.0498 58 97 92 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.1703 0.0638 55 95 74 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.1666 0.0437 57 94 86 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.1459 0.0630 60 92 96 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.1446 0.0464 57 91 84 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.1414 0.0442 56 91 83 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1406 0.0619 58 91 91 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1373 0.0346 61 90 97 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.1336 0.0465 59 89 94 Centennial Place Elementary School 0 0 0.1176 0.0506 57 87 86 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.1167 0.0566 60 87 95 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.1092 0.0378 64 86 99 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.1046 0.0324 60 85 95 Smith Elementary School 0 0 0.0874 0.0310 54 81 68 The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele 0 0 0.0849 0.0667 48 81 21 Continental Colony Elementary School 0 0 0.0740 0.0623 56 77 81 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.0640 0.0681 53 74 55 Whitefoord Elementary School 0 0 0.0304 0.0781 50 61 36 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.0173 0.0626 55 56 71 Beecher Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0151 0.0616 49 55 24 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0071 0.0467 52 47 52 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0168 0.0390 54 43 63 Kimberly Elementary School 0 0 -0.0241 0.0536 50 40 39 Benteen Elementary School 0 0 -0.0337 0.0681 48 37 20 Rivers Elementary School 0 0 -0.0349 0.0453 50 36 31 190 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Slater Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Heritage Academy Elementary Peyton Forest Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Humphries Elementary School Finch Elementary Deerwood Academy School Fickett Elementary School Kindezi Hutchinson Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Grove Park Intermediate School M. A. Jones Elementary School Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm Thomasville Heights Elementary School Bolton Academy Burgess-Peterson Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School KIPP VISION Gideons Elementary School Boyd Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Toomer Elementary School Connally Elementary School Scott Elementary School Fain Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School Towns Elementary School 0 0 -0.0379 0.0489 50 35 32 0 0 -0.0461 0.0502 50 32 34 0 0 -0.0472 0.0529 50 32 38 0 0 -0.0491 0.0514 48 31 19 0 1 -0.0493 0.0829 50 31 35 0 0 -0.0509 0.0646 47 31 15 0 0 -0.0535 0.0474 48 30 20 0 0 -0.0621 0.0469 47 27 17 0 0 -0.0668 0.0502 50 26 36 0 1 -0.0727 0.0919 52 24 54 0 0 -0.0945 0.0599 52 17 51 0 0 -0.0983 0.0638 44 17 6 0 0 -0.0995 0.0449 50 16 36 0 0 -0.1020 0.0427 47 16 17 0 0 -0.1027 0.0506 46 16 12 0 0 -0.1030 0.0550 51 16 42 0 0 -0.1062 0.0646 52 16 50 0 0 -0.1158 0.0474 45 14 8 0 0 -0.1195 0.0729 45 13 9 0 0 -0.1345 0.0663 48 10 19 0 1 -0.1351 0.0707 53 9 58 0 0 -0.1367 0.0474 48 9 19 0 0 -0.1427 0.0569 48 8 19 0 0 -0.1514 0.0489 43 7 4 1 0 -0.1517 0.0500 49 7 26 0 0 -0.1598 0.0634 40 6 1 0 0 -0.1784 0.0571 44 4 7 0 0 -0.1803 0.0681 44 4 5 0 0 -0.2074 0.0550 45 3 9 0 0 -0.2167 0.0812 42 2 2 0 0 -0.2206 0.0677 42 2 3 191 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.2557 0.0529 43 1 5 192 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 193 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.1501 0.0282 53 93 58 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1142 0.0472 54 87 67 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.0959 0.0630 52 83 47 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.0782 0.0361 50 78 36 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 0.0043 0.0598 45 49 9 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.0003 0.0486 49 48 26 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0067 0.0336 50 46 36 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0140 0.0431 45 43 10 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 -0.0243 0.0288 48 40 21 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0259 0.0392 48 39 20 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.0355 0.0326 45 36 8 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.0440 0.0299 48 33 18 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.0636 0.0382 51 27 45 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.0636 0.0484 38 26 1 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0645 0.0333 43 26 4 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.0672 0.0349 51 26 41 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0707 0.0450 44 24 6 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 -0.0758 0.0345 45 23 10 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.0772 0.0421 51 23 46 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0807 0.0302 44 22 6 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0830 0.0392 51 21 45 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.0887 0.0482 42 20 3 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0944 0.0296 42 19 3 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1571 0.0469 46 7 12 194 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1753 0.0348 44 4 6 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.1460 0.0284 53 92 58 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1086 0.0475 54 86 67 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.0906 0.0634 52 82 47 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.0709 0.0363 50 76 36 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.0006 0.0339 50 50 36 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 -0.0011 0.0602 45 50 9 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0113 0.0434 45 45 10 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.0122 0.0489 49 45 26 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 -0.0181 0.0290 48 43 21 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.0334 0.0301 48 37 18 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.0349 0.0328 45 36 8 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0632 0.0394 48 27 20 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 -0.0653 0.0347 45 26 10 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0694 0.0336 43 25 4 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.0747 0.0351 51 23 41 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0749 0.0453 44 23 6 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0774 0.0395 51 23 45 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0820 0.0304 44 21 6 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.0867 0.0487 38 20 1 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.0874 0.0485 42 20 3 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0880 0.0298 42 19 3 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.0918 0.0423 51 19 46 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.0919 0.0385 51 18 45 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1646 0.0472 46 6 12 195 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1828 0.0350 44 4 6 196 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 197 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Western Elementary School 0 0 0.0587 0.0506 51 72 39 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0304 0.0493 55 61 73 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 0.0145 0.0402 53 54 55 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 0.0032 0.0516 54 49 67 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.0024 0.0381 49 47 28 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 -0.0199 0.0514 48 42 19 Northside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0328 0.0551 50 37 32 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 -0.0431 0.0467 50 33 38 Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 -0.0497 0.0510 48 31 23 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.0534 0.0379 50 30 35 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0641 0.0502 45 26 9 Brooks Elementary 0 0 -0.0678 0.0405 53 25 62 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 -0.0803 0.0491 45 22 9 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0950 0.0510 44 18 7 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 -0.0970 0.0420 46 18 12 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0979 0.0491 51 17 43 Glanton Elementary 0 0 -0.1128 0.0576 45 14 8 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1227 0.0439 45 12 9 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.1267 0.0387 48 12 18 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.2142 0.0495 42 2 3 198 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Western Elementary School 0 0 0.0726 0.0510 51 76 39 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0455 0.0496 55 67 73 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 0.0425 0.0405 53 66 55 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 0.0058 0.0520 54 51 67 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.0033 0.0384 49 49 28 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 -0.0146 0.0518 48 44 19 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0173 0.0506 45 43 9 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 -0.0324 0.0470 50 37 38 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.0342 0.0381 50 37 35 Northside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0352 0.0555 50 36 32 Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 -0.0381 0.0514 48 35 23 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 -0.0585 0.0494 45 29 9 Brooks Elementary 0 0 -0.0611 0.0407 53 28 62 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 -0.0794 0.0422 46 22 12 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0842 0.0494 51 21 43 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0925 0.0442 45 18 9 Glanton Elementary 0 0 -0.0943 0.0580 45 18 8 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.0994 0.0389 48 16 18 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.1101 0.0514 44 15 7 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.2307 0.0498 42 2 3 199 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood State Charters Local Charters Traditional 200 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.3343 0.0743 63 99 98 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.1901 0.0449 62 97 98 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1806 0.0525 53 96 60 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.1683 0.0412 60 95 96 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.1619 0.0386 54 95 71 Midvale Elementary School 0 0 0.1575 0.0549 56 94 78 Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.1261 0.0568 58 89 91 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1251 0.0493 61 89 98 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 0.1212 0.0355 53 88 58 Smoke Rise Elementary School 0 1 0.1204 0.0514 53 88 56 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1192 0.0554 58 88 89 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.1145 0.0386 62 87 98 Stone Mountain Elementary School 0 0 0.1048 0.0525 49 85 30 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0942 0.0410 58 83 89 Huntley Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0935 0.0582 53 83 54 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 0.0894 0.0417 60 82 95 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.0824 0.0612 54 79 71 Shadow Rock Elementary School 0 0 0.0756 0.0408 49 77 26 Pine Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0704 0.0439 54 76 64 Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo 0 0 0.0650 0.0369 52 74 49 Henderson Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.0590 0.0460 56 72 80 Sagamore Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0570 0.0542 52 71 50 Livsey Elementary School 0 0 0.0493 0.0547 49 68 26 Hawthorne Elementary School 0 0 0.0423 0.0542 53 65 60 201 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Snapfinger Elementary School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Cedar Grove Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Kittredge Magnet School Evansdale Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Vanderlyn Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Allgood Elementary School Clifton Elementary School International Community School Columbia Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Bob Mathis Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Browns Mill Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School 0 0 0.0420 0.0447 50 65 33 0 1 0.0414 0.0636 52 65 47 0 0 0.0383 0.0481 53 64 56 0 0 0.0334 0.0525 53 62 58 0 0 0.0256 0.0547 52 59 49 0 0 0.0246 0.0393 53 59 57 0 0 0.0241 0.0514 50 59 34 0 0 0.0219 0.0523 47 57 16 0 0 0.0174 0.0392 45 56 10 0 0 0.0168 0.0559 50 55 38 0 0 0.0166 0.0348 59 55 94 0 0 0.0162 0.0408 50 55 33 0 0 0.0149 0.0412 57 54 88 0 0 0.0089 0.0476 53 52 55 0 0 0.0056 0.0411 58 50 92 0 0 0.0048 0.0396 55 50 72 0 0 0.0017 0.0421 48 48 21 0 1 0.0013 0.0612 52 48 53 0 0 -0.0026 0.0463 47 47 16 0 0 -0.0044 0.0595 44 47 7 0 1 -0.0081 0.0557 49 45 23 0 0 -0.0102 0.0471 48 44 22 0 0 -0.0136 0.0481 49 43 30 0 0 -0.0257 0.0598 45 39 10 0 1 -0.0305 0.0562 51 37 46 0 0 -0.0342 0.0385 53 36 58 0 0 -0.0347 0.0491 50 36 35 0 0 -0.0347 0.0588 48 36 22 0 0 -0.0405 0.0663 52 34 53 0 0 -0.0407 0.0385 46 34 12 0 0 -0.0420 0.0466 47 34 17 202 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Princeton Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Toney Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Redan Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Oakview Elementary Stoneview Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Stone Mill Elementary School Midway Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 0 -0.0561 0.0356 46 29 11 0 0 -0.0564 0.0370 49 29 29 0 0 -0.0578 0.0576 48 29 20 0 0 -0.0583 0.0427 49 28 27 0 0 -0.0614 0.0392 45 27 8 0 0 -0.0628 0.0497 49 27 25 0 0 -0.0679 0.0500 45 25 10 0 0 -0.0682 0.0346 45 25 9 0 0 -0.0788 0.0565 50 22 35 0 0 -0.0804 0.0346 46 22 11 0 0 -0.0870 0.0355 41 21 2 0 1 -0.0893 0.0458 45 19 9 0 0 -0.0954 0.0539 48 18 23 0 0 -0.1019 0.0377 42 16 4 0 0 -0.1041 0.0568 47 16 15 0 0 -0.1109 0.0697 47 15 16 0 0 -0.1178 0.0708 47 13 17 0 0 -0.1230 0.0420 41 12 2 0 0 -0.1277 0.0427 44 11 6 0 0 -0.1406 0.0484 43 9 5 0 0 -0.1482 0.0510 46 9 13 0 0 -0.1500 0.0484 45 8 10 0 0 -0.1585 0.0525 45 6 8 0 0 -0.1679 0.0530 43 5 4 0 0 -0.1823 0.0425 45 4 9 0 1 -0.1937 0.0638 42 3 3 1 0 -0.2167 0.0891 52 2 51 0 0 -0.2181 0.0411 38 2 1 1 0 -0.2260 0.0925 51 2 40 0 1 -0.2460 0.0446 48 1 20 203 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.3331 0.0747 63 99 98 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.2292 0.0451 62 99 98 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.2071 0.0415 60 97 96 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1790 0.0529 53 96 60 Midvale Elementary School 0 0 0.1719 0.0552 56 95 78 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.1629 0.0388 54 94 71 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 0.1531 0.0358 53 93 58 Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.1471 0.0571 58 92 91 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1382 0.0496 61 90 98 Smoke Rise Elementary School 0 1 0.1284 0.0518 53 89 56 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1274 0.0558 58 89 89 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.1261 0.0413 58 88 89 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 0.1248 0.0419 60 88 95 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.1244 0.0384 62 88 98 Stone Mountain Elementary School 0 0 0.1175 0.0529 49 87 30 Huntley Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1080 0.0586 53 85 54 Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo 0 0 0.0932 0.0371 52 83 49 Shadow Rock Elementary School 0 0 0.0925 0.0410 49 82 26 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.0851 0.0349 59 81 94 Sagamore Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0805 0.0545 52 79 50 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.0773 0.0616 54 78 71 Pine Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0731 0.0442 54 77 64 Livsey Elementary School 0 0 0.0663 0.0550 49 75 26 Snapfinger Elementary School 0 0 0.0627 0.0450 50 74 33 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0620 0.0484 53 73 56 204 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Henderson Mill Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Vanderlyn Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Fairington Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Avondale Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Columbia Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Allgood Elementary School International Community School Chesnut Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Toney Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Hambrick Elementary School 0 0 0.0607 0.0463 56 73 80 0 0 0.0558 0.0545 53 71 60 0 0 0.0482 0.0414 58 68 92 0 0 0.0462 0.0526 47 67 16 0 0 0.0439 0.0398 55 67 72 0 0 0.0356 0.0550 52 64 49 0 0 0.0328 0.0529 53 62 58 0 0 0.0320 0.0410 50 62 33 0 0 0.0309 0.0395 53 61 57 0 1 0.0258 0.0638 52 60 47 0 0 0.0233 0.0479 53 59 55 0 0 0.0216 0.0518 50 58 34 0 1 0.0214 0.0616 52 58 53 0 0 0.0199 0.0563 50 57 38 0 0 0.0178 0.0413 57 56 88 0 0 0.0144 0.0668 52 55 53 0 0 0.0090 0.0474 48 53 22 0 0 0.0085 0.0599 44 53 7 0 0 -0.0007 0.0592 48 50 22 0 0 -0.0011 0.0466 47 50 16 0 1 -0.0064 0.0560 49 48 23 0 1 -0.0090 0.0566 51 46 46 0 0 -0.0216 0.0422 48 41 21 0 0 -0.0217 0.0602 45 41 10 0 0 -0.0239 0.0394 45 40 10 0 0 -0.0278 0.0387 46 39 12 0 0 -0.0299 0.0494 50 38 35 0 0 -0.0305 0.0580 48 38 20 0 0 -0.0324 0.0500 49 37 25 0 0 -0.0342 0.0484 49 37 30 0 0 -0.0461 0.0469 47 32 17 205 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Panola Way Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Redan Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Oakview Elementary Stoneview Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Midway Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 0 0 -0.0464 0.0395 45 32 8 0 0 -0.0526 0.0386 53 30 58 0 0 -0.0530 0.0358 46 30 11 0 0 -0.0603 0.0348 45 28 9 0 0 -0.0693 0.0504 45 25 10 0 0 -0.0714 0.0348 46 24 11 0 1 -0.0792 0.0461 45 22 9 0 0 -0.0865 0.0429 49 20 27 0 0 -0.0890 0.0371 49 19 29 0 0 -0.0894 0.0569 50 19 35 0 0 -0.0919 0.0571 47 18 15 0 0 -0.0919 0.0712 47 18 17 0 0 -0.0994 0.0543 48 16 23 0 0 -0.1091 0.0701 47 15 16 0 0 -0.1150 0.0487 45 14 10 0 0 -0.1163 0.0422 41 13 2 0 0 -0.1181 0.0429 44 13 6 0 0 -0.1247 0.0356 41 11 2 0 0 -0.1390 0.0487 43 9 5 0 0 -0.1405 0.0514 46 8 13 0 0 -0.1417 0.0378 42 8 4 0 0 -0.1453 0.0533 43 7 4 0 0 -0.1612 0.0428 45 6 9 0 0 -0.1700 0.0529 45 5 8 1 0 -0.1947 0.0897 52 3 51 0 1 -0.1947 0.0642 42 3 3 0 0 -0.1977 0.0414 38 3 1 0 1 -0.2223 0.0448 48 2 20 1 0 -0.2432 0.0931 51 1 40 206 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 207 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.0732 0.0915 52 76 53 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.0542 0.0860 57 70 86 Early County Elementary School 0 0 0.0219 0.0333 55 57 77 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0110 0.0646 51 44 43 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1111 0.0543 48 15 22 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1488 0.0663 45 8 8 208 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.0914 0.0865 57 82 86 Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.0586 0.0919 52 72 53 Early County Elementary School 0 0 -0.0039 0.0334 55 48 77 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0256 0.0650 51 39 43 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1463 0.0545 48 7 22 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1543 0.0667 45 7 8 209 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 ELA APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 210 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.1770 0.0475 57 97 97 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 0.1642 0.0698 57 95 97 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.1564 0.0611 57 94 97 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.1530 0.0542 57 94 97 The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele 0 0 0.1501 0.0639 48 93 57 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.1334 0.0600 53 91 87 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1172 0.0586 57 88 96 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.1171 0.0310 55 88 92 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1089 0.0331 53 87 88 Kindezi 0 1 0.1071 0.0880 52 86 80 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.0663 0.0445 53 76 84 Whitefoord Elementary School 0 0 0.0498 0.0748 44 70 24 Centennial Place Elementary School 0 0 0.0330 0.0484 48 64 56 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 0.0326 0.0506 48 64 59 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.0318 0.0418 54 64 89 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 0.0266 0.0479 48 61 53 Bolton Academy 0 0 0.0196 0.0454 49 57 60 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.0101 0.0446 48 52 55 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.0063 0.0361 54 50 90 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 0.0055 0.0529 53 49 84 Continental Colony Elementary School 0 0 0.0049 0.0597 50 49 70 Deerwood Academy School 0 0 0.0015 0.0451 49 48 62 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 -0.0066 0.0424 49 45 66 Kimberly Elementary School 0 0 -0.0258 0.0515 46 38 37 Smith Elementary School 0 0 -0.0276 0.0295 47 37 47 211 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Humphries Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Garden Hills Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Kipp Strive Academy Thomasville Heights Elementary School Charles R. Drew Charter School D. H. Stanton Elementary School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Hutchinson Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Beecher Hills Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Finch Elementary M. A. Jones Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Towns Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Grove Park Intermediate School Rivers Elementary School Connally Elementary School Slater Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Scott Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Boyd Elementary School Fain Elementary School KIPP VISION 0 0 -0.0286 0.0623 44 37 24 0 0 -0.0311 0.0492 46 35 42 0 0 -0.0324 0.0448 44 35 25 0 0 -0.0459 0.0611 46 30 40 0 1 -0.0523 0.0605 46 28 41 0 0 -0.0576 0.0619 55 27 92 0 1 -0.0609 0.0374 45 27 34 0 0 -0.0674 0.0778 40 24 9 0 1 -0.0737 0.0653 46 23 38 0 0 -0.0768 0.0573 52 23 80 0 0 -0.0776 0.0482 49 22 65 0 0 -0.0797 0.0590 40 21 9 0 0 -0.0809 0.0483 43 21 23 0 0 -0.0831 0.0657 47 20 44 0 0 -0.0931 0.0454 43 18 18 0 0 -0.1013 0.0482 40 16 9 0 0 -0.1063 0.0611 47 14 50 0 0 -0.1110 0.0454 47 13 45 0 0 -0.1120 0.0648 34 13 1 0 0 -0.1153 0.0428 46 12 38 0 0 -0.1173 0.0410 43 12 23 0 0 -0.1206 0.0434 44 11 29 0 0 -0.1213 0.0548 46 11 39 0 0 -0.1245 0.0467 43 11 20 0 0 -0.1388 0.0635 40 9 8 0 0 -0.1405 0.0468 44 8 27 0 0 -0.1415 0.0657 41 8 11 0 1 -0.1429 0.0794 47 8 46 0 0 -0.1658 0.0542 43 5 21 0 0 -0.1728 0.0527 40 4 8 0 1 -0.2460 0.0673 48 1 58 212 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.3137 0.0506 35 1 2 213 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.2085 0.0620 57 98 97 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.1960 0.0550 57 97 97 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 0.1717 0.0709 57 96 97 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.1657 0.0315 55 95 92 The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele 0 0 0.1390 0.0649 48 91 57 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1384 0.0336 53 91 88 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.1336 0.0609 53 91 87 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.1288 0.0482 57 90 97 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1279 0.0595 57 89 96 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.0879 0.0451 53 81 84 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.0639 0.0425 54 75 89 Whitefoord Elementary School 0 0 0.0610 0.0759 44 74 24 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 0.0541 0.0514 48 73 59 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.0539 0.0366 54 72 90 Kindezi 0 1 0.0500 0.0893 52 71 80 Centennial Place Elementary School 0 0 0.0497 0.0491 48 70 56 Bolton Academy 0 0 0.0412 0.0460 49 67 60 Continental Colony Elementary School 0 0 0.0347 0.0605 50 64 70 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 0.0343 0.0537 53 64 84 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.0301 0.0453 48 61 55 Deerwood Academy School 0 0 0.0138 0.0457 49 56 62 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 0.0117 0.0486 48 55 53 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.0023 0.0431 49 50 66 Smith Elementary School 0 0 -0.0002 0.0300 47 48 47 Toomer Elementary School 0 0 -0.0112 0.0620 46 43 40 214 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Humphries Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Kimberly Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Kipp Strive Academy KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad D. H. Stanton Elementary School Garden Hills Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Charles R. Drew Charter School Benteen Elementary School Beecher Hills Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Finch Elementary Miles Intermediate School Dunbar Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Rivers Elementary School Slater Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Scott Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Towns Elementary School Connally Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Perkerson Elementary School Boyd Elementary School Fain Elementary School KIPP VISION 0 0 -0.0201 0.0632 44 41 24 0 0 -0.0214 0.0628 55 40 92 0 0 -0.0274 0.0499 46 37 42 0 0 -0.0295 0.0523 46 36 37 0 0 -0.0350 0.0490 49 34 65 0 1 -0.0356 0.0613 46 34 41 0 1 -0.0428 0.0662 46 32 38 0 0 -0.0433 0.0789 40 31 9 0 0 -0.0515 0.0454 44 29 25 0 0 -0.0516 0.0582 52 29 80 0 1 -0.0592 0.0379 45 27 34 0 0 -0.0599 0.0667 47 26 44 0 0 -0.0608 0.0598 40 26 9 0 0 -0.0649 0.0461 47 25 45 0 0 -0.0665 0.0490 43 24 23 0 0 -0.0757 0.0460 43 21 18 0 0 -0.0807 0.0435 46 20 38 0 0 -0.0938 0.0620 47 18 50 0 0 -0.1011 0.0416 43 16 23 0 0 -0.1015 0.0440 44 16 29 0 0 -0.1030 0.0474 43 16 20 0 0 -0.1141 0.0490 40 13 9 0 0 -0.1154 0.0667 41 13 11 0 0 -0.1169 0.0644 40 12 8 0 0 -0.1219 0.0658 34 11 1 0 0 -0.1224 0.0555 46 11 39 0 1 -0.1236 0.0806 47 11 46 0 0 -0.1239 0.0475 44 11 27 0 0 -0.1438 0.0550 43 8 21 0 0 -0.1614 0.0535 40 6 8 0 1 -0.2149 0.0682 48 2 58 215 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.2983 0.0514 35 1 2 216 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 217 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.1876 0.0604 53 98 85 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.0410 0.0348 46 67 36 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 0.0378 0.0580 45 67 31 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.0367 0.0273 42 66 15 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.0242 0.0472 45 60 35 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.0162 0.0457 46 56 38 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 -0.0050 0.0334 44 45 26 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0056 0.0380 42 45 14 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0061 0.0325 46 45 42 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.0279 0.0367 46 37 38 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.0297 0.0289 43 36 19 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0676 0.0435 44 24 27 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0779 0.0291 45 22 31 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0877 0.0321 39 19 7 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 -0.1015 0.0278 41 16 12 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1023 0.0379 47 15 49 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.1036 0.0407 40 15 8 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.1098 0.0286 41 13 10 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.1124 0.0417 41 13 11 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.1156 0.0315 42 12 17 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1283 0.0465 37 10 4 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1393 0.0334 42 8 14 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.1606 0.0336 42 6 13 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1622 0.0451 39 6 7 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.1798 0.0472 36 4 2 218 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.1758 0.0613 53 96 85 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.0277 0.0276 42 61 15 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 0.0256 0.0588 45 60 31 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.0235 0.0353 46 59 36 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.0098 0.0479 45 53 35 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.0057 0.0464 46 51 38 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 0.0022 0.0339 44 49 26 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0005 0.0330 46 48 42 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.0169 0.0293 43 42 19 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0354 0.0385 42 34 14 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.0673 0.0372 46 24 38 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0715 0.0441 44 23 27 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0850 0.0295 45 19 31 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0946 0.0326 39 18 7 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 -0.0994 0.0282 41 17 12 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1011 0.0384 47 16 49 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.1068 0.0290 41 15 10 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.1105 0.0320 42 14 17 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.1115 0.0413 40 14 8 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.1125 0.0423 41 14 11 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1361 0.0472 37 9 4 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1520 0.0339 42 7 14 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.1739 0.0340 42 5 13 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1761 0.0457 39 5 7 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.1968 0.0479 36 3 2 219 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 220 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0532 0.0475 50 72 68 Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 0.0358 0.0494 51 65 75 Brooks Elementary 0 0 0.0330 0.0390 47 64 47 Western Elementary School 0 0 0.0327 0.0490 49 64 62 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 0.0225 0.0451 48 59 58 Northside Elementary School 0 0 0.0202 0.0532 47 58 52 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 -0.0045 0.0496 44 45 28 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.0296 0.0368 41 36 12 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 -0.0314 0.0502 44 35 28 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 -0.0620 0.0387 44 26 27 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.0643 0.0364 39 25 6 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0785 0.0494 40 22 9 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0898 0.0423 46 19 37 Glanton Elementary 0 0 -0.1030 0.0556 47 15 44 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 -0.1070 0.0405 40 14 10 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.1406 0.0479 39 8 6 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.1443 0.0372 41 7 11 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.1572 0.0473 41 6 10 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 -0.1972 0.0475 37 2 3 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.2272 0.0484 40 2 10 221 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0581 0.0482 50 74 68 Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 0.0520 0.0501 51 71 75 Western Elementary School 0 0 0.0512 0.0497 49 71 62 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 0.0320 0.0457 48 63 58 Brooks Elementary 0 0 0.0307 0.0396 47 62 47 Northside Elementary School 0 0 0.0090 0.0540 47 53 52 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 -0.0042 0.0503 44 46 28 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 -0.0288 0.0510 44 36 28 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 -0.0313 0.0393 44 36 27 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.0340 0.0373 41 35 12 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.0470 0.0369 39 30 6 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0554 0.0429 46 27 37 Glanton Elementary 0 0 -0.0796 0.0564 47 20 44 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 -0.0969 0.0410 40 17 10 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0996 0.0501 40 17 9 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.1151 0.0377 41 13 11 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.1429 0.0480 41 8 10 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.1587 0.0486 39 6 6 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.1668 0.0491 40 6 10 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 -0.1801 0.0482 37 4 3 222 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional 223 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.1762 0.0374 63 97 99 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1730 0.0716 56 96 95 Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.1728 0.0548 59 96 99 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1712 0.0513 54 96 90 Rainbow Elementary School 0 0 0.1347 0.0527 57 91 97 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1061 0.0534 47 86 51 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 0.1025 0.0343 49 85 66 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.1008 0.0371 52 85 81 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.1007 0.0398 55 84 94 Woodridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0847 0.0496 51 80 79 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.0808 0.0593 56 79 95 Brockett Elementary School 0 0 0.0786 0.0506 56 79 94 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0717 0.0463 53 77 86 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.0681 0.0434 54 76 92 Columbia Elementary School 0 0 0.0621 0.0454 47 75 50 Flat Shoals Elementary School 0 0 0.0603 0.0550 53 74 85 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.0564 0.0613 51 73 75 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.0554 0.0397 55 73 92 Pleasantdale Elementary School 0 0 0.0516 0.0412 48 71 53 Avondale Elementary School 0 0 0.0501 0.0539 51 71 77 Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo 0 0 0.0501 0.0355 46 71 36 Fairington Elementary School 0 0 0.0475 0.0462 51 70 74 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.0458 0.0335 54 69 88 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 0.0456 0.0399 51 69 78 Midvale Elementary School 0 0 0.0421 0.0529 49 68 63 224 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Smoke Rise Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Oakview Elementary Leadership Preparatory Academy Stone Mountain Elementary School International Community School Huntley Hills Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Oak Grove Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Rock Chapel Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Snapfinger Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Princeton Elementary School 0 1 0.0359 0.0490 47 65 48 0 0 0.0353 0.0423 47 65 46 0 0 0.0338 0.0463 47 64 48 0 0 0.0302 0.0405 48 63 57 0 1 0.0279 0.0590 49 62 60 0 0 0.0255 0.0504 53 61 87 0 1 0.0238 0.0537 47 60 49 0 0 0.0232 0.0561 50 60 68 0 0 0.0218 0.0570 55 58 92 0 0 0.0211 0.0395 50 58 72 0 0 0.0196 0.0394 48 57 60 0 0 0.0182 0.0477 55 57 93 0 0 0.0158 0.0398 46 55 36 0 0 0.0147 0.0550 47 54 51 0 0 0.0093 0.0383 49 51 64 0 0 0.0068 0.0640 52 50 83 0 0 0.0038 0.0432 50 49 70 0 0 0.0021 0.0474 48 48 58 0 0 0.0006 0.0520 47 47 44 0 0 -0.0025 0.0393 53 46 87 0 0 -0.0088 0.0449 48 44 55 0 0 -0.0091 0.0408 44 44 24 0 0 -0.0117 0.0332 47 43 50 0 0 -0.0149 0.0502 48 42 52 0 0 -0.0158 0.0509 45 41 31 0 0 -0.0161 0.0369 45 41 32 0 0 -0.0247 0.0442 47 39 47 0 0 -0.0282 0.0369 51 37 76 0 0 -0.0289 0.0672 45 37 30 0 0 -0.0295 0.0378 46 36 41 0 0 -0.0323 0.0343 45 35 34 225 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Panola Way Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Livsey Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Toney Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Midway Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Redan Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Kingsley Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Ashford Park Elementary School 0 0 -0.0352 0.0380 45 34 34 0 0 -0.0389 0.0334 41 32 13 0 0 -0.0420 0.0445 43 31 20 0 0 -0.0451 0.0357 50 30 68 0 0 -0.0487 0.0577 42 29 16 0 0 -0.0491 0.0517 44 29 29 0 0 -0.0525 0.0527 47 28 44 0 0 -0.0610 0.0380 47 26 50 0 0 -0.0642 0.0467 43 25 21 0 0 -0.0687 0.0414 44 24 30 0 0 -0.0702 0.0548 45 24 31 0 0 -0.0760 0.0556 43 23 20 0 0 -0.0761 0.0362 46 23 35 0 0 -0.0792 0.0483 45 22 35 0 0 -0.0807 0.0410 48 21 59 0 0 -0.0822 0.0509 43 21 20 0 0 -0.0850 0.0343 41 20 10 0 0 -0.0887 0.0524 47 19 45 0 0 -0.0998 0.0682 48 17 55 0 0 -0.1035 0.0481 42 15 17 0 1 -0.1077 0.0539 46 14 43 0 1 -0.1135 0.0430 43 12 18 1 0 -0.1389 0.0892 46 9 42 0 0 -0.1481 0.0467 47 7 51 0 1 -0.1574 0.0442 39 6 6 0 0 -0.1590 0.0399 40 6 8 0 1 -0.1904 0.0619 38 3 4 1 0 -0.2613 0.0859 48 1 54 0 0 -0.2931 0.0494 38 1 5 226 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.2069 0.0555 59 98 99 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.1970 0.0375 63 98 99 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1710 0.0727 56 96 95 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1691 0.0521 54 96 90 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.1537 0.0404 55 94 94 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 0.1456 0.0348 49 93 66 Rainbow Elementary School 0 0 0.1396 0.0535 57 92 97 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.1290 0.0339 54 90 88 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1278 0.0542 47 89 51 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.1203 0.0440 54 88 92 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.1079 0.0376 52 86 81 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.1063 0.0402 55 85 92 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.1028 0.0470 53 84 86 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.0988 0.0602 56 83 95 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 0.0882 0.0405 51 81 78 Brockett Elementary School 0 0 0.0871 0.0514 56 81 94 Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo 0 0 0.0859 0.0360 46 81 36 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.0823 0.0649 52 80 83 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.0786 0.0620 51 79 75 Columbia Elementary School 0 0 0.0776 0.0461 47 78 50 Woodridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0763 0.0503 51 78 79 Flat Shoals Elementary School 0 0 0.0732 0.0558 53 77 85 Midvale Elementary School 0 0 0.0641 0.0537 49 75 63 Meadowview Elementary School 0 0 0.0633 0.0579 55 75 92 Huntley Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0630 0.0570 50 75 68 227 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Oak Grove Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Smoke Rise Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Rock Chapel Elementary School Oakview Elementary International Community School Stone Mountain Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Snapfinger Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School 0 0 0.0601 0.0401 50 74 72 0 0 0.0573 0.0388 49 73 64 0 0 0.0564 0.0468 51 73 74 0 1 0.0547 0.0598 49 73 60 0 1 0.0521 0.0497 47 72 48 0 0 0.0516 0.0547 51 71 77 0 0 0.0414 0.0417 48 67 53 0 0 0.0389 0.0400 48 66 60 0 0 0.0379 0.0429 47 65 46 0 0 0.0371 0.0484 55 65 93 0 0 0.0335 0.0411 48 64 57 0 1 0.0332 0.0545 47 63 49 0 0 0.0327 0.0512 53 63 87 0 0 0.0277 0.0399 53 61 87 0 0 0.0272 0.0403 46 60 36 0 0 0.0256 0.0558 47 60 51 0 0 0.0244 0.0527 47 59 44 0 0 0.0240 0.0470 47 59 48 0 0 0.0197 0.0439 50 58 70 0 0 0.0097 0.0413 44 53 24 0 0 0.0016 0.0510 48 49 52 0 0 -0.0024 0.0375 45 47 32 0 0 -0.0030 0.0480 48 47 58 0 0 -0.0034 0.0337 47 47 50 0 0 -0.0089 0.0448 47 44 47 0 0 -0.0122 0.0456 48 43 55 0 0 -0.0161 0.0372 51 42 76 0 0 -0.0256 0.0385 45 38 34 0 0 -0.0266 0.0348 45 38 34 0 0 -0.0266 0.0339 41 38 13 0 0 -0.0284 0.0682 45 37 30 228 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Livsey Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Toney Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Midway Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the McLendon Elementary School Dresden Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Montclair Elementary School Redan Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Ashford Park Elementary School 0 0 -0.0295 0.0535 47 36 44 0 0 -0.0338 0.0516 45 35 31 0 0 -0.0365 0.0490 45 34 35 0 0 -0.0451 0.0585 42 31 16 0 0 -0.0456 0.0451 43 31 20 0 0 -0.0463 0.0383 46 30 41 0 0 -0.0488 0.0532 47 29 45 0 0 -0.0495 0.0361 50 29 68 0 0 -0.0506 0.0385 47 29 50 0 0 -0.0519 0.0416 48 28 59 0 0 -0.0546 0.0564 43 28 20 0 0 -0.0596 0.0420 44 26 30 0 0 -0.0657 0.0525 44 25 29 0 0 -0.0698 0.0516 43 23 20 0 0 -0.0723 0.0474 43 22 21 0 1 -0.0786 0.0547 46 21 43 0 0 -0.0787 0.0692 48 20 55 0 1 -0.0806 0.0436 43 20 18 0 0 -0.0850 0.0555 45 19 31 0 0 -0.0886 0.0365 46 19 35 0 0 -0.0889 0.0473 47 19 51 0 0 -0.0951 0.0346 41 18 10 0 0 -0.1093 0.0488 42 15 17 0 1 -0.1328 0.0448 39 9 6 0 0 -0.1405 0.0405 40 8 8 1 0 -0.1922 0.0905 46 4 42 0 1 -0.1943 0.0628 38 4 4 1 0 -0.2095 0.0871 48 2 54 0 0 -0.2798 0.0501 38 1 5 229 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 230 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.1271 0.0882 50 90 70 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 0.0603 0.0644 43 74 23 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.0316 0.0829 44 63 26 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.0094 0.0627 49 51 63 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.0208 0.0523 46 40 39 Early County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1096 0.0322 39 14 6 231 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.0940 0.0894 50 82 70 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.0666 0.0841 44 76 26 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 0.0514 0.0653 43 71 23 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0182 0.0636 49 41 63 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.0726 0.0530 46 22 39 Early County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1385 0.0326 39 8 6 232 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Math APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Atlanta Heights State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Atlanta Heights State Charters Local Charters Traditional 233 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.2690 0.0622 61 94 95 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.2684 0.0618 65 94 98 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.2221 0.0448 65 90 98 Rivers Elementary School 0 0 0.1883 0.0440 58 87 90 The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele 0 0 0.1764 0.0647 56 86 86 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1401 0.0603 55 80 82 Kindezi 0 1 0.1259 0.0891 54 77 80 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.1068 0.0423 57 73 87 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 0.1033 0.0512 52 72 73 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.0919 0.0481 53 70 76 Humphries Elementary School 0 0 0.0893 0.0630 48 69 54 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.0729 0.0335 54 66 79 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 0.0639 0.0536 54 63 78 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.0496 0.0548 55 60 83 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.0436 0.0314 51 59 65 Smith Elementary School 0 0 0.0048 0.0301 51 51 66 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.0037 0.0619 52 50 72 Gideons Elementary School 0 0 -0.0055 0.0459 52 48 73 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0132 0.0461 48 47 55 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 -0.0202 0.0712 51 45 67 Kimberly Elementary School 0 0 -0.0246 0.0521 50 44 61 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 -0.0317 0.0429 52 42 71 Deerwood Academy School 0 0 -0.0372 0.0459 52 41 71 Fickett Elementary School 0 0 -0.0373 0.0486 46 41 46 Bolton Academy 0 0 -0.0524 0.0461 51 38 66 234 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Beecher Hills Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Morningside Elementary School Charles R. Drew Charter School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Boyd Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Dobbs Elementary School Connally Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Fain Elementary School KIPP VISION Slater Elementary School Towns Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Springdale Park Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Whitefoord Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Finch Elementary Perkerson Elementary School Centennial Place Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Scott Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.0527 0.0596 51 38 68 0 0 -0.0535 0.0660 45 37 41 0 0 -0.0621 0.0365 51 36 65 0 1 -0.0774 0.0378 44 32 37 0 1 -0.0831 0.0661 44 31 35 0 0 -0.0968 0.0554 44 29 36 0 0 -0.1001 0.0494 44 28 35 0 0 -0.1127 0.0433 46 25 44 0 0 -0.1218 0.0488 42 24 29 0 0 -0.1462 0.0551 37 20 15 0 0 -0.1571 0.0622 32 19 5 0 0 -0.1598 0.0614 44 18 36 0 0 -0.1726 0.0496 38 16 16 0 0 -0.1730 0.0533 35 16 11 0 1 -0.1750 0.0685 47 16 50 0 0 -0.1857 0.0474 35 14 10 0 0 -0.1937 0.0670 38 13 16 1 0 -0.2015 0.0484 38 12 16 0 0 -0.2053 0.0450 37 12 15 0 0 -0.2090 0.0415 31 12 4 0 0 -0.2122 0.0764 39 11 20 0 0 -0.2123 0.0630 37 11 15 0 0 -0.2126 0.0580 37 11 14 0 0 -0.2291 0.0459 34 9 8 0 0 -0.2409 0.0474 35 8 11 0 0 -0.3007 0.0490 38 5 17 0 0 -0.3035 0.0638 32 5 6 0 1 -0.3110 0.0795 40 4 23 0 0 -0.3442 0.0670 28 3 2 0 0 -0.3837 0.0787 21 2 1 0 0 -0.3999 0.0512 31 2 4 235 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Continental Colony Elementary School 0 0 -0.4612 0.0603 19 1 1 236 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.2986 0.0628 65 96 98 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.2522 0.0456 65 93 98 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.2474 0.0632 61 93 95 Rivers Elementary School 0 0 0.2247 0.0447 58 91 90 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.1670 0.0430 57 85 87 The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele 0 0 0.1655 0.0657 56 84 86 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1446 0.0613 55 81 82 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.1176 0.0557 55 76 83 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 0.1159 0.0521 52 76 73 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1121 0.0340 54 75 79 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.1061 0.0319 51 74 65 Humphries Elementary School 0 0 0.0910 0.0640 48 70 54 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 0.0705 0.0544 54 65 78 Smith Elementary School 0 0 0.0667 0.0306 51 64 66 Kindezi 0 1 0.0642 0.0905 54 64 80 Gideons Elementary School 0 0 0.0352 0.0467 52 58 73 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.0265 0.0489 53 56 76 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.0112 0.0628 52 53 72 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.0110 0.0370 51 53 65 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0072 0.0468 48 52 55 Fickett Elementary School 0 0 -0.0010 0.0494 46 49 46 Bolton Academy 0 0 -0.0066 0.0468 51 48 66 Benteen Elementary School 0 0 -0.0067 0.0671 45 48 41 Deerwood Academy School 0 0 -0.0245 0.0466 52 44 71 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 -0.0247 0.0724 51 44 67 237 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Beecher Hills Elementary School Kimberly Elementary School Imagine Wesley International Academy KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Miles Intermediate School Charles R. Drew Charter School Boyd Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Connally Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Slater Elementary School KIPP VISION Springdale Park Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Fain Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Towns Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Finch Elementary Centennial Place Elementary School Intown Charter Academy F. L. Stanton Elementary School Scott Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.0257 0.0606 51 44 68 0 0 -0.0275 0.0530 50 43 61 0 1 -0.0432 0.0436 52 40 71 0 1 -0.0569 0.0671 44 37 35 0 0 -0.0747 0.0440 46 34 44 0 1 -0.0926 0.0384 44 30 37 0 0 -0.0966 0.0563 44 29 36 0 0 -0.1044 0.0496 42 27 29 0 0 -0.1321 0.0502 44 22 35 0 0 -0.1431 0.0624 44 20 36 0 0 -0.1477 0.0560 37 19 15 0 0 -0.1507 0.0632 32 19 5 0 0 -0.1559 0.0504 38 18 16 0 0 -0.1662 0.0481 35 16 10 0 1 -0.1702 0.0696 47 16 50 0 0 -0.1704 0.0457 37 16 15 0 0 -0.1784 0.0589 37 15 14 0 0 -0.1798 0.0542 35 15 11 0 0 -0.1850 0.0640 37 14 15 0 0 -0.1937 0.0776 39 12 20 0 0 -0.1966 0.0422 31 12 4 0 0 -0.2039 0.0681 38 11 16 0 0 -0.2297 0.0481 35 9 11 1 0 -0.2299 0.0492 38 8 16 0 0 -0.2391 0.0466 34 7 8 0 0 -0.2664 0.0498 38 6 17 0 1 -0.2855 0.0808 40 5 23 0 0 -0.2970 0.0649 32 4 6 0 0 -0.3608 0.0681 28 2 2 0 0 -0.3712 0.0799 21 2 1 0 0 -0.4002 0.0521 31 2 4 238 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Continental Colony Elementary School 0 0 -0.4240 0.0613 19 1 1 239 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Cherokee State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Cherokee State Charters Local Charters Traditional 240 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.2875 0.0464 60 95 93 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.1265 0.0354 54 77 77 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 0.1163 0.0586 50 75 62 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.1120 0.0618 58 74 90 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.1116 0.0278 53 74 74 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 0.0958 0.0281 51 71 65 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.0914 0.0479 58 70 90 Avery Elementary School 0 0 0.0667 0.0289 50 64 60 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 0.0320 0.0443 50 56 61 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.0308 0.0338 51 56 67 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 0.0268 0.0328 45 55 42 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 0.0240 0.0338 52 54 73 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.0166 0.0292 51 46 68 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.0188 0.0321 46 46 46 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0211 0.0383 51 45 67 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0500 0.0422 45 38 40 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.0503 0.0372 45 38 43 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0720 0.0456 48 33 54 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0862 0.0294 45 30 41 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.1065 0.0412 48 27 52 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.1174 0.0328 45 25 41 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1533 0.0384 48 19 53 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1863 0.0338 45 14 41 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.3183 0.0477 27 4 2 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.4183 0.0470 31 1 4 241 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.3043 0.0471 60 96 93 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.1106 0.0359 54 74 77 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 0.1084 0.0596 50 74 62 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.1079 0.0282 53 74 74 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.0987 0.0628 58 72 90 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 0.0979 0.0286 51 72 65 Avery Elementary School 0 0 0.0795 0.0293 50 67 60 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.0695 0.0487 58 65 90 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 0.0387 0.0343 52 58 73 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 0.0378 0.0450 50 58 61 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 0.0349 0.0333 45 58 42 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.0180 0.0344 51 54 67 Little River Elem. 0 0 0.0116 0.0297 51 53 68 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.0059 0.0326 46 49 46 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0203 0.0388 51 45 67 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0459 0.0429 45 39 40 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0813 0.0299 45 32 41 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0835 0.0463 48 32 54 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.1032 0.0418 48 28 52 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.1037 0.0333 45 28 41 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.1123 0.0378 45 26 43 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1551 0.0390 48 18 53 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1926 0.0343 45 13 41 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.3103 0.0485 27 4 2 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.4214 0.0478 31 1 4 242 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 243 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 0.4427 0.0502 70 99 99 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 0.1424 0.0508 55 80 82 Brooks Elementary 0 0 0.1160 0.0395 50 75 63 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 0.1033 0.0428 57 72 87 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 0.1017 0.0506 52 72 69 Northside Elementary School 0 0 0.0844 0.0540 47 68 49 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 0.0685 0.0413 52 65 73 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0423 0.0481 50 59 64 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 0.0169 0.0456 46 53 46 Glanton Elementary 0 0 -0.0020 0.0562 48 49 52 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.0443 0.0482 41 39 28 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0543 0.0479 41 37 25 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.0717 0.0376 43 33 34 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.1097 0.0490 47 26 48 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.1151 0.0372 45 25 41 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.1307 0.0500 39 23 21 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 -0.1489 0.0479 37 20 14 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.1787 0.0372 37 15 13 Western Elementary School 0 0 -0.2312 0.0500 39 9 21 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 -0.2595 0.0394 36 7 12 244 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 0.4629 0.0510 70 99 99 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 0.1376 0.0516 55 79 82 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 0.1367 0.0435 57 79 87 Brooks Elementary 0 0 0.1159 0.0401 50 76 63 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 0.1025 0.0514 52 73 69 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 0.0858 0.0419 52 69 73 Northside Elementary School 0 0 0.0689 0.0549 47 65 49 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0304 0.0488 50 57 64 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 0.0250 0.0463 46 56 46 Glanton Elementary 0 0 0.0134 0.0571 48 53 52 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.0375 0.0382 43 41 34 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0460 0.0487 41 39 25 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0622 0.0498 47 36 48 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.0771 0.0490 41 33 28 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.0801 0.0378 45 33 41 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.1363 0.0508 39 21 21 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 -0.1439 0.0487 37 20 14 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.1936 0.0378 37 12 13 Western Elementary School 0 0 -0.2107 0.0508 39 11 21 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 -0.2208 0.0400 36 10 12 245 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood State Charters Local Charters Traditional 246 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name Indian Creek Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Stone Mill Elementary School Rockbridge Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Austin Elementary School Rock Chapel Elementary School Marbut Elementary School Columbia Elementary School Vanderlyn Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Snapfinger Elementary School Briar Vista Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Wynbrooke Elementary School Kittredge Magnet School Woodridge Elementary School Pleasantdale Elementary School Fernbank Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Briarlake Elementary School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.6166 0.4382 0.4087 0.2856 0.2407 0.1809 0.1369 0.1290 0.1173 0.1084 0.0995 0.0973 0.0862 0.0804 0.0746 0.0718 0.0646 0.0531 0.0477 0.0387 0.0371 0.0317 0.0273 0.0167 School Effect Standard Error 0.0350 0.0675 0.0620 0.0517 0.0515 0.0731 0.0440 0.0483 0.0375 0.0462 0.0401 0.0557 0.0626 0.0437 0.0604 0.0366 0.0347 0.0339 0.0500 0.0421 0.0407 0.0583 0.0514 0.0554 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 77 99 99 68 99 99 59 98 92 65 95 98 64 92 98 64 86 97 56 79 86 57 78 88 56 75 85 56 73 84 54 72 78 54 71 78 55 69 83 50 67 62 62 66 96 48 65 55 58 64 91 59 61 91 55 60 81 51 58 68 58 58 90 51 56 66 49 55 56 53 53 74 247 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Robert Shaw Theme School Montgomery Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Avondale Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Laurel Ridge Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School International Community School Leadership Preparatory Academy Panola Way Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Cary Reynolds Elementary School Cedar Grove Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Livsey Elementary School 0 0 0.0125 0.0467 54 52 80 0 0 0.0004 0.0405 51 50 65 0 0 -0.0130 0.0372 48 47 55 0 0 -0.0239 0.0540 48 44 53 0 0 -0.0298 0.0472 51 43 67 0 0 -0.0526 0.0543 54 38 79 0 0 -0.0566 0.0544 45 37 39 0 1 -0.0610 0.0548 52 36 70 0 0 -0.0678 0.0695 45 35 41 0 1 -0.0686 0.0496 47 34 48 0 0 -0.0687 0.0577 48 34 52 0 0 -0.0688 0.0512 44 34 35 0 0 -0.0720 0.0536 44 33 35 0 0 -0.0825 0.0471 45 31 38 0 0 -0.0866 0.0474 46 30 45 0 0 -0.0869 0.0377 46 30 43 0 1 -0.0932 0.0531 45 29 40 0 1 -0.1051 0.0596 49 27 59 0 0 -0.1085 0.0385 41 26 28 0 0 -0.1098 0.0565 49 26 56 0 0 -0.1116 0.0427 43 26 31 0 0 -0.1171 0.0338 41 25 27 0 0 -0.1183 0.0397 41 25 24 0 0 -0.1227 0.0447 46 24 44 0 0 -0.1359 0.0347 41 22 28 0 0 -0.1372 0.0361 42 22 28 0 0 -0.1464 0.0469 42 20 30 0 0 -0.1555 0.0421 41 19 27 0 0 -0.1580 0.0398 45 18 39 0 0 -0.1667 0.0372 39 17 21 0 0 -0.1681 0.0536 47 17 50 248 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Chapel Hill Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Toney Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Redan Elementary School Midway Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Montclair Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Oak Grove Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Oakview Elementary Jolly Elementary School Midvale Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Hambrick Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Clifton Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 0 -0.1831 0.0484 37 15 15 0 0 -0.1831 0.0338 43 15 32 0 0 -0.1861 0.0562 36 14 13 0 0 -0.1867 0.0526 34 14 8 0 0 -0.1921 0.0533 44 14 35 0 0 -0.1931 0.0415 38 14 17 0 0 -0.2117 0.0500 36 11 13 0 0 -0.2142 0.0385 36 11 13 0 0 -0.2172 0.0379 34 10 9 0 0 -0.2259 0.0359 39 9 20 0 0 -0.2263 0.0490 35 9 10 0 0 -0.2358 0.0519 34 8 8 0 0 -0.2364 0.0454 36 8 13 1 0 -0.2404 0.0869 36 8 13 0 0 -0.2405 0.0346 33 8 7 0 0 -0.2415 0.0422 34 8 9 0 1 -0.2699 0.0448 37 6 14 0 0 -0.2767 0.0486 37 6 13 0 0 -0.2861 0.0403 38 5 17 0 0 -0.2946 0.0510 30 5 3 0 0 -0.2975 0.0528 36 5 13 0 0 -0.3052 0.0409 31 4 3 0 0 -0.3070 0.0383 30 4 3 0 0 -0.3238 0.0538 36 3 12 0 0 -0.3547 0.0647 51 3 67 0 0 -0.3806 0.0403 28 2 2 0 0 -0.4080 0.0454 25 1 1 1 0 -0.4610 0.0891 42 1 30 0 0 -0.4613 0.0580 26 1 1 0 1 -0.7245 0.0435 32 1 6 249 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.7340 0.0350 77 99 99 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.4877 0.0628 59 99 92 Kelley Lake Elementary School 0 0 0.4243 0.0686 68 99 99 Stone Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.2751 0.0525 65 94 98 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.2693 0.0523 64 94 98 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.2161 0.0447 56 90 86 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.1869 0.0407 54 86 78 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.1862 0.0344 59 86 91 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1782 0.0742 64 86 97 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1508 0.0490 57 82 88 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.1359 0.0414 58 79 90 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 0.1353 0.0352 58 79 91 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.1257 0.0381 56 78 85 Columbia Elementary School 0 0 0.1197 0.0470 56 77 84 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.1196 0.0613 62 77 96 Dresden Elementary School 0 0 0.1166 0.0370 48 76 55 Flat Shoals Elementary School 0 0 0.1117 0.0566 54 74 78 Snapfinger Elementary School 0 0 0.0907 0.0444 50 70 62 DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter 0 1 0.0838 0.0636 55 69 83 Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.0797 0.0563 53 68 74 Pleasantdale Elementary School 0 0 0.0749 0.0427 51 66 68 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 0.0665 0.0412 51 64 65 Brockett Elementary School 0 0 0.0573 0.0523 49 62 56 250 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Robert Shaw Theme School Woodridge Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Laurel Ridge Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School International Community School Avondale Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Henderson Mill Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Cary Reynolds Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Livsey Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Sagamore Hills Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0439 0.0475 54 59 80 0 0 0.0437 0.0508 55 59 81 0 0 0.0339 0.0377 48 57 55 0 0 0.0218 0.0593 51 55 66 0 0 0.0093 0.0480 51 52 67 0 0 0.0052 0.0552 54 51 79 0 1 -0.0026 0.0557 52 49 70 0 1 -0.0236 0.0504 47 45 48 0 0 -0.0312 0.0574 49 43 56 0 0 -0.0391 0.0552 45 41 39 0 0 -0.0403 0.0586 48 40 52 0 1 -0.0404 0.0539 45 40 40 0 0 -0.0415 0.0549 48 40 53 0 0 -0.0479 0.0707 45 38 41 0 0 -0.0494 0.0544 44 38 35 0 0 -0.0496 0.0454 46 38 44 0 0 -0.0649 0.0383 46 35 43 0 0 -0.0653 0.0521 44 35 35 0 1 -0.0736 0.0606 49 34 59 0 0 -0.0810 0.0365 42 32 28 0 0 -0.0830 0.0404 45 32 39 0 0 -0.0836 0.0544 47 32 50 0 0 -0.0873 0.0481 46 31 45 0 0 -0.0928 0.0376 39 30 21 0 0 -0.0952 0.0434 43 30 31 0 0 -0.0964 0.0478 45 29 38 0 0 -0.1055 0.0403 41 27 24 0 0 -0.1060 0.0391 41 27 28 0 0 -0.1104 0.0542 44 26 35 0 0 -0.1146 0.0344 41 25 27 0 0 -0.1160 0.0476 42 25 30 251 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Princeton Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Oakcliff Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Toney Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Oak Grove Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Midway Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Redan Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Rowland Elementary School Midvale Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Oakview Elementary Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Hambrick Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 0 -0.1349 0.0353 41 21 28 0 0 -0.1465 0.0391 36 19 13 0 0 -0.1554 0.0492 37 18 15 0 0 -0.1585 0.0428 41 18 27 0 0 -0.1592 0.0365 39 17 20 0 0 -0.1648 0.0427 34 17 9 0 0 -0.1664 0.0343 43 16 32 0 0 -0.1677 0.0571 36 16 13 0 0 -0.1723 0.0422 38 16 17 0 0 -0.1783 0.0384 34 15 9 0 0 -0.1884 0.0350 33 13 7 0 0 -0.1888 0.0508 36 13 13 0 0 -0.2005 0.0534 34 12 8 0 1 -0.2016 0.0456 37 11 14 0 0 -0.2209 0.0409 38 10 17 0 0 -0.2222 0.0462 36 10 13 0 0 -0.2284 0.0527 34 9 8 0 0 -0.2359 0.0657 51 8 67 0 0 -0.2362 0.0498 35 8 10 0 0 -0.2412 0.0388 30 7 3 0 0 -0.2461 0.0537 36 7 13 1 0 -0.2691 0.0883 36 6 13 0 0 -0.2828 0.0494 37 5 13 0 0 -0.2845 0.0547 36 5 12 0 0 -0.2852 0.0518 30 5 3 0 0 -0.2960 0.0416 31 4 3 0 0 -0.3606 0.0409 28 2 2 0 0 -0.3854 0.0462 25 2 1 0 0 -0.4269 0.0589 26 1 1 1 0 -0.4547 0.0905 42 1 30 0 1 -0.6669 0.0442 32 1 6 252 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 253 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.2712 0.0892 66 94 99 Early County Elementary School 0 0 0.0425 0.0326 45 59 41 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.0027 0.0634 42 50 28 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1617 0.0527 33 18 7 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.2104 0.0839 34 11 8 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.3170 0.0651 21 4 1 254 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.2169 0.0905 66 90 99 Early County Elementary School 0 0 0.0072 0.0330 45 52 41 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0326 0.0644 42 42 28 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1906 0.0852 34 13 8 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.2257 0.0534 33 9 7 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.3503 0.0662 21 3 1 255 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Science APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 256 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile KIPP VISION 0 1 0.5104 0.0645 58 99 84 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.2599 0.0351 62 95 93 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.2087 0.0558 67 91 98 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 0.1993 0.0659 62 90 94 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1600 0.0318 54 86 68 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.1297 0.0581 60 81 91 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.1260 0.0430 52 81 55 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 0.0966 0.0364 48 74 34 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.0770 0.0631 60 71 90 Centennial Place Elementary School 0 0 0.0681 0.0466 57 68 78 Kindezi 0 1 0.0295 0.0816 52 57 59 Dunbar Elementary School 0 0 0.0270 0.0588 57 56 80 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.0121 0.0301 50 52 46 Fain Elementary School 0 0 0.0096 0.0506 55 51 71 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.0049 0.0406 46 50 21 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 -0.0109 0.0451 47 46 27 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 -0.0124 0.0487 58 45 83 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0259 0.0425 51 42 51 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 -0.0275 0.0525 49 42 38 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0377 0.0587 55 39 74 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 -0.0388 0.0577 55 39 73 Rivers Elementary School 0 0 -0.0477 0.0419 49 36 39 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 -0.0704 0.0510 51 31 47 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0943 0.0422 47 26 27 257 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bolton Academy Deerwood Academy School Smith Elementary School Imagine Wesley International Academy Humphries Elementary School Finch Elementary Beecher Hills Elementary School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Atlanta Heights Charter School Miles Intermediate School Kimberly Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Boyd Elementary School Slater Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Scott Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Towns Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Connally Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Peyton Forest Elementary School 0 0 -0.1061 0.0439 48 23 31 0 0 -0.1226 0.0433 49 21 40 0 0 -0.1269 0.0285 47 20 26 0 1 -0.1287 0.0411 47 19 30 0 0 -0.1296 0.0567 55 19 71 0 0 -0.1465 0.0430 48 16 34 0 0 -0.1467 0.0570 53 16 64 0 0 -0.1509 0.0614 46 16 23 1 0 -0.1563 0.0462 48 15 33 0 0 -0.1588 0.0406 48 15 35 0 0 -0.1709 0.0483 47 13 31 0 0 -0.1966 0.0595 45 11 20 0 0 -0.2178 0.0635 46 9 21 0 0 -0.2488 0.0564 40 6 7 0 0 -0.2535 0.0461 41 6 8 0 0 -0.2565 0.0520 40 6 6 0 0 -0.2578 0.0443 43 6 11 0 0 -0.2580 0.0555 42 6 11 0 0 -0.2595 0.0459 43 5 13 0 0 -0.2636 0.0567 40 5 6 0 0 -0.2683 0.0456 42 5 10 0 0 -0.2805 0.0570 43 4 14 0 0 -0.2977 0.0703 36 4 2 0 0 -0.3146 0.0446 38 3 4 0 0 -0.3189 0.0631 36 3 2 0 0 -0.3247 0.0436 40 3 6 0 0 -0.3306 0.0610 43 2 12 0 1 -0.3326 0.0749 41 2 9 0 0 -0.3588 0.0511 38 2 3 0 0 -0.3703 0.0394 37 1 2 0 0 -0.3758 0.0468 35 1 2 258 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix D. H. Stanton Elementary School Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.4114 0.0757 37 1 3 0 0 -0.4416 0.0487 33 1 1 259 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile KIPP VISION 0 1 0.5135 0.0650 58 99 84 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.2998 0.0353 62 96 93 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.2052 0.0563 67 91 98 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 0.1895 0.0664 62 89 94 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.1840 0.0321 54 88 68 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.1497 0.0434 52 84 55 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.1368 0.0585 60 81 91 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.1068 0.0636 60 77 90 Centennial Place Elementary School 0 0 0.0860 0.0470 57 73 78 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 0.0818 0.0366 48 72 34 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.0557 0.0409 46 65 21 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.0468 0.0304 50 63 46 Dunbar Elementary School 0 0 0.0228 0.0592 57 55 80 Fain Elementary School 0 0 0.0030 0.0510 55 50 71 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.0009 0.0529 49 50 38 Kindezi 0 1 -0.0025 0.0823 52 49 59 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 -0.0122 0.0491 58 46 83 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 -0.0281 0.0455 47 42 27 Rivers Elementary School 0 0 -0.0311 0.0423 49 41 39 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0320 0.0592 55 41 74 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0336 0.0428 51 40 51 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 -0.0609 0.0582 55 33 73 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 -0.0673 0.0515 51 32 47 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 -0.0838 0.0425 47 28 27 Smith Elementary School 0 0 -0.0909 0.0288 47 26 26 260 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bolton Academy Deerwood Academy School Beecher Hills Elementary School Humphries Elementary School Imagine Wesley International Academy Miles Intermediate School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Finch Elementary Atlanta Heights Charter School Kimberly Elementary School Benteen Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Fickett Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School Slater Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School Boyd Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Perkerson Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Scott Elementary School Towns Elementary School Connally Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Peyton Forest Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0961 0.0442 48 25 31 0 0 -0.1072 0.0436 49 23 40 0 0 -0.1212 0.0575 53 21 64 0 0 -0.1265 0.0572 55 20 71 0 1 -0.1364 0.0414 47 18 30 0 0 -0.1394 0.0409 48 17 35 0 0 -0.1485 0.0619 46 16 23 0 0 -0.1617 0.0434 48 14 34 1 0 -0.1705 0.0466 48 13 33 0 0 -0.1728 0.0487 47 12 31 0 0 -0.1958 0.0640 46 10 21 0 0 -0.2033 0.0600 45 9 20 0 0 -0.2391 0.0464 41 7 8 0 0 -0.2452 0.0569 40 7 7 0 0 -0.2456 0.0560 42 7 11 0 0 -0.2457 0.0447 43 7 11 0 0 -0.2498 0.0459 42 6 10 0 0 -0.2575 0.0572 40 6 6 0 0 -0.2580 0.0575 43 6 14 0 0 -0.2582 0.0524 40 6 6 0 0 -0.2837 0.0463 43 4 13 0 0 -0.2869 0.0708 36 4 2 0 0 -0.2983 0.0439 40 4 6 0 0 -0.3123 0.0450 38 3 4 0 1 -0.3168 0.0756 41 3 9 0 0 -0.3424 0.0636 36 2 2 0 0 -0.3465 0.0615 43 2 12 0 0 -0.3582 0.0515 38 2 3 0 0 -0.3593 0.0397 37 2 2 0 0 -0.3602 0.0472 35 2 2 0 0 -0.4154 0.0763 37 1 3 261 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bethune Elementary School 0 0 -0.4370 0.0491 33 1 1 262 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 263 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.2556 0.0309 60 95 90 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1595 0.0440 52 85 58 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.1082 0.0336 55 77 72 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.0972 0.0353 52 74 56 Canton Elementary 0 0 0.0535 0.0355 54 64 67 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.0402 0.0322 47 61 28 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.0326 0.0302 50 58 45 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 0.0230 0.0268 49 55 36 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 0.0067 0.0319 49 50 41 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 -0.0034 0.0262 50 47 46 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 -0.0167 0.0558 46 44 25 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0260 0.0580 49 42 37 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0339 0.0417 47 40 31 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0352 0.0310 49 40 39 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0452 0.0275 49 37 39 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.0692 0.0448 40 31 6 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0700 0.0277 49 31 40 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0964 0.0398 45 26 18 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1218 0.0364 47 21 27 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1296 0.0321 44 19 15 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.1507 0.0387 41 16 9 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.2422 0.0446 41 7 9 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.2441 0.0451 44 7 16 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.2685 0.0429 39 5 5 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.3360 0.0276 34 2 1 264 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.2740 0.0311 60 95 90 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1857 0.0444 52 88 58 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.1172 0.0339 55 79 72 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.0727 0.0356 52 70 56 Canton Elementary 0 0 0.0446 0.0358 54 62 67 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.0386 0.0324 47 60 28 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 0.0374 0.0270 49 59 36 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.0368 0.0304 50 59 45 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 0.0275 0.0322 49 56 41 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 0.0063 0.0264 50 51 46 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 -0.0049 0.0563 46 48 25 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0205 0.0585 49 44 37 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0220 0.0313 49 43 39 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0245 0.0420 47 42 31 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0248 0.0277 49 42 39 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.0545 0.0451 40 35 6 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.0573 0.0280 49 34 40 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.0850 0.0401 45 27 18 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1087 0.0366 47 23 27 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.1238 0.0324 44 20 15 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.1495 0.0390 41 16 9 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.2378 0.0450 41 7 9 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.2480 0.0455 44 6 16 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.2613 0.0432 39 5 5 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.3101 0.0278 34 3 1 265 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 266 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name Atkinson Elementary School White Oak Elementary School Poplar Road Elementary School Arnco-Sargent Elementary School Arbor Springs Elementary Coweta Charter Academy Brooks Elementary Glanton Elementary Northside Elementary School Jefferson Parkway Elementary School Thomas Crossroads Elementary School Newnan Crossing Elementary School Willis Road Elementary Canongate Elementary School Western Elementary School Elm Street Elementary School Moreland Elementary School Ruth Hill Elementary School Welch Elementary School Eastside Elementary School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.1874 0.1395 0.1119 0.1057 0.1023 0.0989 0.0497 0.0406 0.0307 0.0121 0.0114 0.0111 0.0066 0.0060 0.0018 -0.0222 -0.0337 -0.1517 -0.1563 -0.2412 School Effect Standard Error 0.0473 0.0375 0.0411 0.0477 0.0436 0.0461 0.0381 0.0541 0.0515 0.0454 0.0461 0.0348 0.0362 0.0394 0.0469 0.0483 0.0461 0.0466 0.0352 0.0462 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 62 89 93 59 83 88 53 78 66 57 76 81 52 75 58 50 74 47 52 63 57 55 61 72 54 57 70 49 52 40 49 52 39 51 51 50 54 50 66 47 50 27 47 48 27 48 43 32 48 40 33 41 15 7 42 15 10 37 7 3 267 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 0.1952 0.0477 62 89 93 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 0.1679 0.0378 59 86 88 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 0.1376 0.0414 53 82 66 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 0.1133 0.0439 52 78 58 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.1073 0.0464 50 77 47 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 0.1063 0.0481 57 77 81 Brooks Elementary 0 0 0.0646 0.0384 52 68 57 Glanton Elementary 0 0 0.0505 0.0545 55 64 72 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 0.0395 0.0351 51 60 50 Northside Elementary School 0 0 0.0344 0.0519 54 58 70 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 0.0328 0.0365 54 58 66 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 0.0306 0.0397 47 57 27 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 0.0304 0.0464 49 57 39 Western Elementary School 0 0 0.0106 0.0473 47 52 27 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.0109 0.0458 49 47 40 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 -0.0258 0.0487 48 42 32 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0271 0.0464 48 42 33 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.1537 0.0470 41 15 7 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.1588 0.0355 42 14 10 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.2164 0.0466 37 9 3 268 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional 269 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.4208 0.0417 65 99 98 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.3028 0.0334 69 97 99 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.2700 0.0597 64 96 96 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.2535 0.0327 55 95 73 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.2032 0.0388 57 90 79 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1598 0.0464 63 86 96 Pleasantdale Elementary School 0 0 0.1401 0.0396 62 83 94 Hawthorne Elementary School 0 0 0.1259 0.0495 58 81 81 Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School 0 0 0.0982 0.0483 60 74 89 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.0641 0.0387 55 67 72 Cary Reynolds Elementary School 0 0 0.0572 0.0343 56 66 77 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.0431 0.0555 57 62 79 Livsey Elementary School 0 0 0.0431 0.0510 50 62 45 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0391 0.0504 53 61 64 Midvale Elementary School 0 0 0.0386 0.0506 52 60 57 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0224 0.0381 47 55 29 Brockett Elementary School 0 0 0.0158 0.0493 53 54 62 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0040 0.0489 58 49 82 Henderson Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0001 0.0422 53 48 65 Avondale Elementary School 0 0 -0.0330 0.0510 51 40 53 Kelley Lake Elementary School 0 0 -0.0427 0.0640 60 37 91 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.0489 0.0433 54 36 67 Dunwoody Elementary School 0 0 -0.0507 0.0372 47 35 30 Evansdale Elementary School 0 0 -0.0533 0.0382 51 35 50 Chapel Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0555 0.0456 51 34 53 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 -0.0594 0.0330 53 33 61 Princeton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0634 0.0326 46 33 25 270 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Canby Lane Elementary School International Community School Museum School Avondale Estates Sagamore Hills Elementary School Marbut Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Snapfinger Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Midway Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Oakview Elementary Leadership Preparatory Academy Stone Mill Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Idlewood Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Woodward Elementary School 0 0 -0.0635 0.0397 52 33 59 0 1 -0.0664 0.0506 49 32 40 0 1 -0.0731 0.0697 44 30 17 0 0 -0.0748 0.0491 43 30 13 0 0 -0.0769 0.0361 50 29 44 0 0 -0.0771 0.0502 49 29 39 0 0 -0.0804 0.0406 53 28 66 0 0 -0.0847 0.0431 49 28 38 0 0 -0.0888 0.0485 49 27 36 0 0 -0.0958 0.0374 50 26 41 0 0 -0.1043 0.0382 50 24 44 0 1 -0.1143 0.0574 46 22 24 0 0 -0.1258 0.0487 47 20 30 0 0 -0.1265 0.0475 41 20 8 0 0 -0.1271 0.0473 45 20 21 0 0 -0.1272 0.0404 49 20 38 0 0 -0.1284 0.0393 47 20 29 0 0 -0.1333 0.0501 54 19 67 0 0 -0.1359 0.0325 48 18 34 0 0 -0.1437 0.0432 49 17 36 0 0 -0.1513 0.0535 41 16 9 0 1 -0.1654 0.0469 40 14 7 0 0 -0.1700 0.0457 43 13 13 0 0 -0.1706 0.0358 46 13 21 0 0 -0.1735 0.0530 40 12 7 0 0 -0.1737 0.0485 48 12 32 0 1 -0.1755 0.0522 41 12 7 0 0 -0.1804 0.0448 47 12 30 0 0 -0.1892 0.0483 45 11 19 0 1 -0.1903 0.0591 43 11 13 0 0 -0.1942 0.0357 45 11 21 0 0 -0.1986 0.0350 43 10 14 0 0 -0.1991 0.0352 43 10 14 271 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Robert Shaw Theme School Allgood Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Briarlake Elementary School Montgomery Elementary School Toney Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Redan Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Hightower Elementary School Columbia Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Stoneview Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 0 0 -0.2014 0.0344 43 10 14 0 0 -0.2030 0.0449 50 10 42 0 0 -0.2048 0.0423 43 10 12 0 0 -0.2067 0.0320 46 9 22 0 0 -0.2096 0.0362 42 9 11 0 0 -0.2211 0.0528 35 8 2 0 0 -0.2257 0.0386 38 8 3 0 0 -0.2328 0.0525 46 8 23 0 0 -0.2342 0.0618 47 7 30 0 0 -0.2439 0.0522 40 7 6 0 0 -0.2541 0.0541 40 6 6 0 0 -0.2582 0.0361 43 5 11 0 0 -0.2633 0.0457 37 5 3 0 0 -0.2852 0.0552 38 4 4 0 0 -0.3049 0.0622 40 3 6 0 0 -0.3094 0.0368 40 3 7 0 0 -0.3142 0.0436 46 3 21 0 1 -0.3261 0.0417 40 3 7 0 0 -0.3325 0.0399 40 2 7 0 0 -0.3428 0.0323 39 2 4 0 1 -0.3610 0.0422 35 2 2 0 0 -0.4075 0.0384 36 1 2 0 0 -0.4107 0.0454 32 1 1 1 0 -0.4450 0.0857 41 1 8 1 0 -0.4936 0.0836 43 1 12 272 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.4614 0.0420 65 99 98 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.3614 0.0332 69 99 99 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.3224 0.0329 55 98 73 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.2925 0.0600 64 96 96 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.2581 0.0391 57 95 79 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1709 0.0468 63 86 96 Hawthorne Elementary School 0 0 0.1489 0.0499 58 83 81 Pleasantdale Elementary School 0 0 0.1442 0.0399 62 83 94 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.1235 0.0390 55 79 72 Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School 0 0 0.1091 0.0487 60 78 89 Livsey Elementary School 0 0 0.0965 0.0515 50 75 45 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0700 0.0508 53 69 64 Cary Reynolds Elementary School 0 0 0.0677 0.0344 56 69 77 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0648 0.0384 47 68 29 Midvale Elementary School 0 0 0.0590 0.0510 52 66 57 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.0568 0.0560 57 66 79 Henderson Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.0327 0.0425 53 58 65 Brockett Elementary School 0 0 0.0265 0.0497 53 56 62 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.0226 0.0493 58 55 82 Dunwoody Elementary School 0 0 -0.0049 0.0375 47 48 30 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 -0.0144 0.0333 53 46 61 Evansdale Elementary School 0 0 -0.0148 0.0385 51 45 50 Sagamore Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0385 0.0495 43 39 13 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.0391 0.0436 54 39 67 Chapel Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0438 0.0459 51 37 53 International Community School 0 1 -0.0459 0.0510 49 37 40 Avondale Elementary School 0 0 -0.0513 0.0515 51 35 53 273 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Kelley Lake Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Snapfinger Elementary School Marbut Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Midway Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Oakview Elementary Ashford Park Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Narvie Harris Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Huntley Hills Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo Stone Mountain Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Idlewood Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Briarlake Elementary School Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0580 0.0645 60 33 91 0 0 -0.0596 0.0400 52 33 59 0 0 -0.0646 0.0329 46 32 25 0 1 -0.0654 0.0702 44 32 17 0 0 -0.0669 0.0409 53 32 66 0 0 -0.0728 0.0364 50 31 44 0 0 -0.0765 0.0435 49 30 38 0 0 -0.0780 0.0505 49 29 39 0 0 -0.0803 0.0489 49 29 36 0 0 -0.0854 0.0377 50 27 41 0 1 -0.0902 0.0578 46 26 24 0 0 -0.1009 0.0385 50 24 44 0 0 -0.1143 0.0479 41 22 8 0 0 -0.1154 0.0407 49 22 38 0 0 -0.1181 0.0395 47 21 29 0 0 -0.1198 0.0505 54 21 67 0 0 -0.1236 0.0327 48 20 34 0 0 -0.1314 0.0477 45 19 21 0 0 -0.1365 0.0540 41 18 9 0 0 -0.1384 0.0491 47 18 30 0 1 -0.1433 0.0527 41 17 7 0 1 -0.1443 0.0473 40 17 7 0 0 -0.1495 0.0534 40 16 7 0 0 -0.1521 0.0435 49 15 36 0 0 -0.1576 0.0347 43 14 14 0 0 -0.1682 0.0489 48 13 32 0 0 -0.1686 0.0361 46 13 21 0 0 -0.1743 0.0359 45 12 21 0 0 -0.1759 0.0451 47 12 30 0 0 -0.1762 0.0461 43 12 13 0 0 -0.1795 0.0353 43 12 14 0 0 -0.1802 0.0532 35 12 2 0 0 -0.1806 0.0389 38 12 3 274 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Jolly Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Dresden Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Toney Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Bob Mathis Elementary School Redan Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Columbia Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 0 1 -0.1847 0.0596 43 11 13 0 0 -0.1869 0.0363 42 11 11 0 0 -0.1951 0.0453 50 10 42 0 0 -0.1953 0.0351 43 10 14 0 0 -0.1958 0.0487 45 10 19 0 0 -0.1971 0.0427 43 10 12 0 0 -0.2061 0.0322 46 9 22 0 0 -0.2173 0.0623 47 8 30 0 0 -0.2199 0.0529 46 8 23 0 0 -0.2391 0.0527 40 7 6 0 0 -0.2462 0.0364 43 7 11 0 0 -0.2483 0.0627 40 6 6 0 0 -0.2639 0.0545 40 5 6 0 0 -0.2743 0.0461 37 5 3 0 0 -0.2748 0.0557 38 5 4 0 1 -0.2873 0.0420 40 4 7 0 0 -0.3034 0.0439 46 3 21 0 0 -0.3036 0.0370 40 3 7 0 1 -0.3278 0.0425 35 2 2 0 0 -0.3360 0.0324 39 2 4 0 0 -0.3387 0.0402 40 2 7 0 0 -0.3858 0.0387 36 1 2 1 0 -0.4041 0.0864 41 1 8 0 0 -0.4076 0.0458 32 1 1 1 0 -0.5374 0.0843 43 1 12 275 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 276 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.2508 0.0858 72 94 99 Early County Elementary School 0 0 -0.0141 0.0308 56 45 76 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0173 0.0602 47 44 30 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1514 0.0816 42 15 10 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.3051 0.0610 35 3 1 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.3120 0.0507 33 3 1 277 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.2109 0.0864 72 91 99 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0433 0.0607 47 37 30 Early County Elementary School 0 0 -0.0583 0.0310 56 33 76 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1304 0.0823 42 19 10 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.3306 0.0615 35 2 1 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.3896 0.0510 33 1 1 278 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 4 and 5 Social Studies APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 279 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 0.6708 0.0361 49 99 51 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.5111 0.0448 72 99 99 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.4485 0.0645 56 99 81 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.3894 0.0317 59 98 88 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.3825 0.0573 63 98 94 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.3760 0.0429 60 98 89 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.3184 0.0578 57 96 82 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.3089 0.0627 68 95 98 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.2325 0.0299 56 89 81 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.2159 0.0348 59 87 87 Kindezi 0 1 0.1943 0.0811 58 86 85 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1483 0.0554 60 79 89 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.1388 0.0591 59 77 88 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 0.1169 0.0654 52 73 65 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 0.1056 0.0505 55 72 76 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.1050 0.0521 50 71 58 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.0989 0.0403 54 70 74 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0718 0.0424 48 65 50 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.0550 0.0419 54 61 71 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.0348 0.0408 50 57 56 Fickett Elementary School 0 0 0.0299 0.0458 43 56 29 Boyd Elementary School 0 0 0.0282 0.0514 48 56 49 Smith Elementary School 0 0 0.0149 0.0285 47 53 46 Deerwood Academy School 0 0 -0.0225 0.0431 45 45 35 Heritage Academy Elementary 0 0 -0.0263 0.0483 47 44 42 280 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Slater Elementary School Beecher Hills Elementary School Rivers Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Bolton Academy Centennial Place Elementary School Toomer Elementary School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Hutchinson Elementary School Humphries Elementary School Whitefoord Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Atlanta Heights Charter School Kimberly Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Towns Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Gideons Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Finch Elementary Fain Elementary School Scott Elementary School Bethune Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School Connally Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0410 0.0440 46 41 41 0 0 -0.0449 0.0567 41 40 22 0 0 -0.0464 0.0419 48 40 49 0 0 -0.0660 0.0587 44 36 33 0 0 -0.0722 0.0454 40 35 19 0 0 -0.0949 0.0437 41 31 22 0 0 -0.1175 0.0463 41 28 21 0 0 -0.1195 0.0564 41 27 24 0 0 -0.1309 0.0610 43 25 28 0 0 -0.1353 0.0551 36 24 11 0 0 -0.1382 0.0567 45 23 36 0 0 -0.1581 0.0698 38 20 14 0 0 -0.1673 0.0403 37 18 12 1 0 -0.1805 0.0459 45 16 36 0 0 -0.1902 0.0480 40 15 20 0 0 -0.1985 0.0465 38 14 15 0 0 -0.2063 0.0453 38 13 14 0 0 -0.2125 0.0606 40 12 19 0 0 -0.2189 0.0631 38 11 14 0 0 -0.2224 0.0561 36 11 10 0 0 -0.2379 0.0436 34 9 7 0 1 -0.2382 0.0737 35 9 8 0 0 -0.2400 0.0427 33 9 5 0 0 -0.2570 0.0503 33 8 5 0 0 -0.2577 0.0635 35 8 9 0 0 -0.2593 0.0483 37 8 12 0 0 -0.2664 0.0567 36 7 11 0 0 -0.3138 0.0591 30 4 3 0 0 -0.3366 0.0391 32 3 4 0 0 -0.3462 0.0507 35 3 8 0 0 -0.4329 0.0752 23 1 1 281 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Perkerson Elementary School 0 0 -0.4525 0.0443 25 1 1 282 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 0.6493 0.0366 49 99 51 Neighborhood Charter School 0 1 0.4925 0.0454 72 99 99 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.4448 0.0653 56 99 81 Jackson Elementary School 0 0 0.4165 0.0321 59 98 88 Springdale Park Elementary School 0 0 0.4024 0.0435 60 98 89 Cascade Elementary School 0 0 0.3511 0.0581 63 97 94 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.3409 0.0635 68 97 98 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.3207 0.0584 57 96 82 Brandon Elementary School 0 0 0.2722 0.0303 56 93 81 Morningside Elementary School 0 0 0.2641 0.0353 59 92 87 Kindezi 0 1 0.1597 0.0822 58 81 85 Lin Elementary School 0 0 0.1576 0.0409 54 81 74 Venetian Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1413 0.0562 60 78 89 West Manor Elementary School 0 0 0.1381 0.0528 50 77 58 Cleveland Elementary School 0 0 0.1356 0.0599 59 77 88 Bazoline E. Usher/Collier Heights Elm 0 0 0.1023 0.0512 55 71 76 Burgess-Peterson Elementary School 0 0 0.1003 0.0663 52 71 65 Parkside Elementary School 0 0 0.0649 0.0425 54 64 71 Garden Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0600 0.0429 48 62 50 Smith Elementary School 0 0 0.0574 0.0289 47 62 46 Fickett Elementary School 0 0 0.0417 0.0464 43 59 29 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.0202 0.0413 50 54 56 Boyd Elementary School 0 0 0.0180 0.0521 48 53 49 Deerwood Academy School 0 0 -0.0064 0.0437 45 49 35 Beecher Hills Elementary School 0 0 -0.0159 0.0574 41 46 22 283 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Heritage Academy Elementary Slater Elementary School Rivers Elementary School Dunbar Elementary School Bolton Academy Centennial Place Elementary School M. A. Jones Elementary School Toomer Elementary School Hutchinson Elementary School The John Hope-Charles Walter Hill Ele Humphries Elementary School Miles Intermediate School Whitefoord Elementary School Peyton Forest Elementary School Dobbs Elementary School Kimberly Elementary School Benteen Elementary School Atlanta Heights Charter School Gideons Elementary School Thomasville Heights Elementary School Intown Charter Academy Towns Elementary School Continental Colony Elementary School Bethune Elementary School Finch Elementary Fain Elementary School Scott Elementary School Grove Park Intermediate School F. L. Stanton Elementary School Connally Elementary School D. H. Stanton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0273 0.0490 47 44 42 0 0 -0.0282 0.0446 46 43 41 0 0 -0.0303 0.0425 48 43 49 0 0 -0.0646 0.0595 44 37 33 0 0 -0.0853 0.0443 41 33 22 0 0 -0.0983 0.0469 41 31 21 0 0 -0.1038 0.0460 40 29 19 0 0 -0.1184 0.0571 41 27 24 0 0 -0.1247 0.0559 36 26 11 0 0 -0.1296 0.0618 43 24 28 0 0 -0.1361 0.0574 45 23 36 0 0 -0.1478 0.0409 37 22 12 0 0 -0.1488 0.0707 38 22 14 0 0 -0.1812 0.0471 38 16 15 0 0 -0.1857 0.0459 38 15 14 0 0 -0.1885 0.0486 40 15 20 0 0 -0.1900 0.0639 38 15 14 1 0 -0.1988 0.0466 45 14 36 0 0 -0.2139 0.0442 34 12 7 0 0 -0.2199 0.0568 36 12 10 0 1 -0.2266 0.0747 35 11 8 0 0 -0.2313 0.0614 40 10 19 0 0 -0.2386 0.0574 36 10 11 0 0 -0.2580 0.0490 37 8 12 0 0 -0.2613 0.0433 33 8 5 0 0 -0.2684 0.0509 33 7 5 0 0 -0.2898 0.0644 35 6 9 0 0 -0.3264 0.0396 32 4 4 0 0 -0.3268 0.0599 30 4 3 0 0 -0.3425 0.0514 35 3 8 0 0 -0.4407 0.0762 23 1 1 284 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Perkerson Elementary School 0 0 -0.4520 0.0449 25 1 1 285 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 286 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.3069 0.0437 63 95 94 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.2308 0.0307 61 89 91 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.1656 0.0334 56 83 79 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.1129 0.0351 44 73 31 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.0492 0.0577 51 60 61 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 0.0192 0.0446 49 54 54 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0019 0.0353 48 50 48 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.0174 0.0300 51 46 60 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 -0.0278 0.0261 55 44 77 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0326 0.0274 49 43 53 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.0343 0.0385 43 43 28 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 -0.0588 0.0554 52 37 63 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 -0.0701 0.0267 44 35 31 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0896 0.0361 51 33 60 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.1024 0.0309 45 30 36 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.1218 0.0414 47 27 44 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 -0.1560 0.0317 44 20 31 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.1579 0.0276 46 20 38 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.1885 0.0448 42 15 26 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.1969 0.0321 46 14 41 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.2121 0.0446 39 12 17 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.2667 0.0426 34 7 6 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.2999 0.0320 45 5 37 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.3085 0.0275 35 4 9 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.3521 0.0395 32 3 4 287 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.3448 0.0443 63 97 94 Arnold Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.2544 0.0311 61 91 91 Macedonia Elementary School 0 0 0.1813 0.0338 56 85 79 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.0838 0.0356 44 67 31 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 0.0573 0.0584 51 62 61 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 0.0379 0.0452 49 58 54 Avery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0055 0.0277 49 49 53 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0118 0.0358 48 47 48 Liberty Elementary School 0 0 -0.0131 0.0264 55 47 77 Clark Creek Elementary School 0 0 -0.0135 0.0304 51 47 60 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.0369 0.0390 43 41 28 Free Home Elementary School 0 0 -0.0414 0.0562 52 40 63 Bascomb Elementary School 0 0 -0.0507 0.0270 44 39 31 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0722 0.0366 51 35 60 Woodstock Elementary School 0 0 -0.0825 0.0313 45 33 36 Johnston Elementary School 0 0 -0.1100 0.0420 47 28 44 Sixes Elementary School 0 0 -0.1304 0.0321 44 24 31 Carmel Elementary School 0 0 -0.1404 0.0280 46 23 38 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.1943 0.0454 42 15 26 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.1966 0.0325 46 14 41 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 -0.2039 0.0452 39 13 17 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.2555 0.0432 34 8 6 Little River Elem. 0 0 -0.2759 0.0279 35 7 9 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 -0.2904 0.0325 45 6 37 Boston Elementary School 0 0 -0.3371 0.0401 32 3 4 288 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 289 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name Brooks Elementary Coweta Charter Academy Elm Street Elementary School Atkinson Elementary School Thomas Crossroads Elementary School White Oak Elementary School Glanton Elementary Canongate Elementary School Arnco-Sargent Elementary School Jefferson Parkway Elementary School Arbor Springs Elementary Moreland Elementary School Poplar Road Elementary School Northside Elementary School Newnan Crossing Elementary School Willis Road Elementary Western Elementary School Welch Elementary School Ruth Hill Elementary School Eastside Elementary School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.1535 0.0889 0.0792 0.0773 0.0703 0.0554 0.0047 -0.0032 -0.0070 -0.0315 -0.0612 -0.0803 -0.1062 -0.1063 -0.1225 -0.1392 -0.1538 -0.1673 -0.2057 -0.3777 School Effect Standard Error 0.0379 0.0458 0.0479 0.0472 0.0459 0.0374 0.0537 0.0391 0.0474 0.0456 0.0433 0.0458 0.0408 0.0512 0.0345 0.0359 0.0466 0.0351 0.0461 0.0461 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 53 81 68 50 68 56 50 66 57 51 66 59 52 64 67 55 61 76 48 51 51 47 50 44 51 49 61 43 43 29 41 37 22 41 33 24 47 30 46 39 30 16 40 27 20 45 23 34 44 21 33 39 18 18 37 13 12 39 2 18 290 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Brooks Elementary 0 0 0.1712 0.0384 53 83 68 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0960 0.0464 50 70 56 Thomas Crossroads Elementary School 0 0 0.0892 0.0466 52 68 67 White Oak Elementary School 0 0 0.0838 0.0379 55 67 76 Atkinson Elementary School 0 0 0.0811 0.0478 51 67 59 Elm Street Elementary School 0 0 0.0727 0.0486 50 65 57 Canongate Elementary School 0 0 0.0246 0.0396 47 55 44 Glanton Elementary 0 0 0.0093 0.0544 48 52 51 Arnco-Sargent Elementary School 0 0 -0.0100 0.0480 51 48 61 Arbor Springs Elementary 0 0 -0.0490 0.0439 41 39 22 Jefferson Parkway Elementary School 0 0 -0.0634 0.0462 43 37 29 Moreland Elementary School 0 0 -0.0789 0.0464 41 34 24 Poplar Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0794 0.0413 47 34 46 Newnan Crossing Elementary School 0 0 -0.0901 0.0349 40 32 20 Northside Elementary School 0 0 -0.1038 0.0519 39 29 16 Willis Road Elementary 0 0 -0.1134 0.0364 45 28 34 Western Elementary School 0 0 -0.1479 0.0473 44 22 33 Welch Elementary School 0 0 -0.1718 0.0355 39 17 18 Ruth Hill Elementary School 0 0 -0.2042 0.0467 37 13 12 Eastside Elementary School 0 0 -0.3527 0.0467 39 3 18 291 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional 292 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.5774 0.0593 59 99 87 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.2336 0.0416 61 89 92 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1734 0.0482 63 84 94 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1636 0.0461 55 82 76 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.1315 0.0567 59 76 86 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.1281 0.0387 55 76 78 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.1192 0.0386 55 74 76 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1177 0.0505 54 73 74 Sagamore Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1163 0.0492 63 73 94 Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.1124 0.0524 56 73 80 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.1080 0.0360 55 72 75 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.0999 0.0618 52 71 66 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0577 0.0430 54 62 71 Huntley Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0573 0.0529 58 61 84 Pleasantdale Elementary School 0 0 0.0309 0.0395 53 56 71 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0217 0.0378 48 55 49 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.0012 0.0360 49 50 52 Henderson Mill Elementary School 0 0 -0.0052 0.0419 45 49 35 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 -0.0100 0.0383 44 48 33 Snapfinger Elementary School 0 0 -0.0226 0.0401 48 45 50 Narvie Harris Elementary School 0 0 -0.0241 0.0323 45 45 36 Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo 0 0 -0.0354 0.0342 46 42 39 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 -0.0387 0.0328 43 42 30 Midway Elementary School 0 0 -0.0408 0.0484 46 41 38 Livsey Elementary School 0 0 -0.0416 0.0507 54 41 72 293 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cary Reynolds Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Brockett Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Hawthorne Elementary School Woodridge Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Idlewood Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Jolly Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Dunwoody Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Princeton Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Flat Shoals Elementary School Oakview Elementary Midvale Elementary School 0 0 -0.0441 0.0343 49 41 51 0 0 -0.0639 0.0500 50 36 55 0 0 -0.0730 0.0486 46 34 39 0 0 -0.0908 0.0512 48 33 48 0 1 -0.0960 0.0692 55 31 75 0 0 -0.1120 0.0489 39 29 16 0 0 -0.1136 0.0374 50 28 58 0 0 -0.1192 0.0381 48 27 50 0 0 -0.1254 0.0635 45 26 34 0 0 -0.1261 0.0492 40 26 18 0 0 -0.1289 0.0472 41 26 21 0 0 -0.1316 0.0453 38 25 13 0 0 -0.1374 0.0390 38 24 15 0 0 -0.1400 0.0429 39 23 17 0 0 -0.1419 0.0448 36 23 10 0 0 -0.1464 0.0365 45 22 34 0 0 -0.1485 0.0429 44 21 31 0 0 -0.1534 0.0474 35 21 8 0 0 -0.1583 0.0365 44 20 31 0 0 -0.1652 0.0378 39 19 17 0 1 -0.1717 0.0414 36 17 11 0 0 -0.1770 0.0373 44 16 32 0 1 -0.1990 0.0466 36 14 10 0 1 -0.2115 0.0421 34 12 7 0 0 -0.2143 0.0614 37 12 13 0 0 -0.2162 0.0393 35 12 9 0 0 -0.2182 0.0324 37 11 12 0 0 -0.2187 0.0480 40 11 19 0 0 -0.2269 0.0519 39 10 17 0 0 -0.2282 0.0380 38 10 15 0 0 -0.2287 0.0507 41 10 23 294 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Chesnut Elementary School Woodward Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School Pine Ridge Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Chapel Hill Elementary School Clifton Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy International Community School Browns Mill Elementary School Toney Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Redan Elementary School Stoneview Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Columbia Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Montclair Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Kittredge Magnet School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 0 1 -0.2351 0.0519 38 10 15 0 0 -0.2362 0.0352 41 10 23 0 0 -0.2375 0.0514 32 9 4 0 0 -0.2380 0.0317 35 9 9 0 0 -0.2435 0.0486 36 9 10 0 0 -0.2451 0.0490 30 9 3 0 0 -0.2483 0.0402 36 9 11 0 0 -0.2641 0.0357 34 8 6 0 0 -0.2676 0.0454 30 7 2 0 0 -0.2677 0.0532 34 7 6 0 1 -0.2752 0.0570 34 7 7 0 1 -0.2862 0.0514 40 6 19 0 0 -0.2926 0.0360 31 6 3 0 0 -0.2967 0.0521 35 5 8 0 0 -0.3014 0.0350 39 5 17 0 0 -0.3017 0.0537 36 5 11 0 0 -0.3088 0.0456 30 4 3 0 0 -0.3157 0.0396 28 4 2 0 0 -0.3196 0.0448 35 4 8 0 0 -0.3242 0.0548 26 4 2 0 1 -0.3343 0.0580 31 3 3 0 0 -0.3354 0.0436 32 3 4 0 0 -0.3781 0.0422 32 2 4 0 0 -0.4176 0.0321 29 2 2 1 0 -0.4458 0.0851 28 1 2 0 0 -0.4544 0.0375 26 1 1 0 0 -0.4838 0.0453 34 1 8 0 0 -0.5079 0.0325 31 1 3 1 0 -0.5416 0.0830 35 1 8 295 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.6088 0.0599 59 99 87 Austin Elementary School 0 0 0.2834 0.0421 61 93 92 Fernbank Elementary School 0 0 0.1961 0.0392 55 86 78 Rockbridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1942 0.0488 63 86 94 Vanderlyn Elementary School 0 0 0.1906 0.0391 55 86 76 Rock Chapel Elementary School 0 0 0.1723 0.0467 55 83 76 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.1636 0.0627 52 82 66 Sagamore Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.1610 0.0498 63 81 94 Briarlake Elementary School 0 0 0.1597 0.0531 56 81 80 Indian Creek Elementary School 0 0 0.1589 0.0360 55 81 75 Laurel Ridge Elementary School 0 0 0.1507 0.0511 54 79 74 Briar Vista Elementary School 0 0 0.1377 0.0574 59 77 86 Huntley Hills Elementary School 0 0 0.0840 0.0536 58 67 84 Oak Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0731 0.0383 48 65 49 Cedar Grove Elementary School 0 0 0.0684 0.0436 54 64 71 Montgomery Elementary School 0 0 0.0418 0.0388 44 59 33 Pleasantdale Elementary School 0 0 0.0380 0.0400 53 58 71 Henderson Mill Elementary School 0 0 0.0369 0.0425 45 58 35 Livsey Elementary School 0 0 0.0274 0.0514 54 55 72 Edward L. Bouie, Sr. Elementary Schoo 0 0 0.0140 0.0347 46 53 39 Wynbrooke Elementary School 0 0 0.0131 0.0332 43 52 30 Marbut Elementary School 0 0 0.0034 0.0364 49 51 52 Snapfinger Elementary School 0 0 -0.0102 0.0406 48 48 50 Narvie Harris Elementary School 0 0 -0.0112 0.0327 45 48 36 Cary Reynolds Elementary School 0 0 -0.0303 0.0347 49 43 51 296 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Midway Elementary School Rainbow Elementary School Evansdale Elementary School Stone Mill Elementary School Museum School Avondale Estates Hawthorne Elementary School Brockett Elementary School Shadow Rock Elementary School Avondale Elementary School Oakcliff Elementary School Dunwoody Elementary School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Idlewood Elementary School Robert Shaw Theme School Woodridge Elementary School Hambrick Elementary School Rowland Elementary School Kelley Lake Elementary School Ashford Park Elementary School Jolly Elementary School Hightower Elementary School Fairington Elementary School Kingsley Elementary School Smoke Rise Elementary School Chesnut Elementary School Knollwood Elementary School Midvale Elementary School Woodward Elementary School Eldridge L. Miller Elementary School Canby Lane Elementary School Princeton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0364 0.0490 46 42 38 0 0 -0.0490 0.0507 50 39 55 0 0 -0.0736 0.0386 48 35 50 0 0 -0.0846 0.0492 46 33 39 0 1 -0.0890 0.0702 55 32 75 0 0 -0.1002 0.0498 40 30 18 0 0 -0.1015 0.0496 39 30 16 0 0 -0.1099 0.0379 50 29 58 0 0 -0.1209 0.0519 48 26 48 0 0 -0.1212 0.0394 38 26 15 0 0 -0.1257 0.0377 44 25 32 0 1 -0.1259 0.0420 36 25 11 0 0 -0.1316 0.0369 45 24 34 0 0 -0.1335 0.0454 36 24 10 0 0 -0.1359 0.0478 41 23 21 0 0 -0.1374 0.0434 44 23 31 0 0 -0.1411 0.0459 38 23 13 0 0 -0.1423 0.0644 45 23 34 0 0 -0.1443 0.0480 35 22 8 0 0 -0.1496 0.0382 39 21 17 0 0 -0.1521 0.0369 44 21 31 0 0 -0.1581 0.0434 39 20 17 0 1 -0.1685 0.0426 34 18 7 0 1 -0.1727 0.0473 36 17 10 0 1 -0.1965 0.0526 38 14 15 0 0 -0.1975 0.0622 37 14 13 0 0 -0.2081 0.0514 41 13 23 0 0 -0.2150 0.0355 41 12 23 0 0 -0.2158 0.0486 40 12 19 0 0 -0.2185 0.0398 35 12 9 0 0 -0.2215 0.0328 37 11 12 297 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Flat Shoals Elementary School Oakview Elementary Pine Ridge Elementary School Flat Rock Elementary School Stone Mountain Elementary School McLendon Elementary School Leadership Preparatory Academy Clifton Elementary School Dunaire Elementary School International Community School Chapel Hill Elementary School Panola Way Elementary School Toney Elementary School Browns Mill Elementary School Dresden Elementary School Bob Mathis Elementary School Murphy Candler Elementary School Meadowview Elementary School Redan Elementary School Columbia Elementary School DeKalb Preparatory Academy Charter Stoneview Elementary School Allgood Elementary School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Montclair Elementary School Kittredge Magnet School Ronald E McNair Discover Learning Aca DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 0 0 -0.2227 0.0526 39 11 17 0 0 -0.2249 0.0385 38 11 15 0 0 -0.2354 0.0407 36 10 11 0 0 -0.2421 0.0321 35 9 9 0 0 -0.2451 0.0492 36 9 10 0 0 -0.2459 0.0521 32 9 4 0 1 -0.2505 0.0578 34 8 7 0 0 -0.2532 0.0539 34 8 6 0 0 -0.2557 0.0496 30 8 3 0 1 -0.2630 0.0521 40 7 19 0 0 -0.2633 0.0460 30 7 2 0 0 -0.2656 0.0362 34 7 6 0 0 -0.2812 0.0528 35 6 8 0 0 -0.2823 0.0364 31 6 3 0 0 -0.3007 0.0353 39 5 17 0 0 -0.3142 0.0544 36 5 11 0 0 -0.3148 0.0454 35 4 8 0 0 -0.3181 0.0556 26 4 2 0 0 -0.3195 0.0462 30 4 3 0 0 -0.3245 0.0442 32 4 4 0 1 -0.3259 0.0588 31 4 3 0 0 -0.3294 0.0401 28 4 2 0 0 -0.3704 0.0427 32 2 4 1 0 -0.3870 0.0863 28 2 2 0 0 -0.4084 0.0324 29 2 2 0 0 -0.4261 0.0329 31 1 3 0 0 -0.4325 0.0380 26 1 1 0 0 -0.4917 0.0459 34 1 8 1 0 -0.6086 0.0841 35 1 8 298 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 299 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Early County Elementary School 0 0 0.2459 0.0306 59 90 87 Clay County Elementary 0 0 0.2314 0.0852 64 89 96 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.0131 0.0598 47 53 46 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.0502 0.0811 51 39 60 Randolph County Elementary School 0 0 -0.1748 0.0504 39 17 17 Calhoun County Elementary School 0 0 -0.2141 0.0606 30 12 2 300 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Reading APS Distric Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 301 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 0.3005 0.0392 59 99 80 Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 0.0963 0.0436 60 88 91 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 0.0903 0.0357 56 85 58 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.0828 0.0468 56 83 65 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0557 0.0198 61 73 93 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.0364 0.0372 60 65 91 Sutton Middle School 0 0 0.0256 0.0159 58 61 77 Kindezi 0 1 -0.0124 0.1181 52 47 29 Coan Middle School 0 0 -0.0150 0.0403 56 46 58 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.0411 0.0243 56 33 63 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.0444 0.0259 55 32 51 Long Middle School 0 0 -0.0549 0.0248 54 28 43 Heritage Preparatory Academy School 1 0 -0.0578 0.0445 49 27 10 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0629 0.0298 55 25 54 Price Middle School 0 0 -0.0682 0.0361 55 23 48 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0688 0.0325 54 22 39 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 -0.0787 0.0468 49 19 9 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.0828 0.0682 50 17 15 KIPP VISION 0 1 -0.0869 0.0366 53 16 34 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.0896 0.0795 40 15 1 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 -0.1077 0.0373 53 10 30 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.1078 0.0194 50 10 13 Brown Middle School 0 0 -0.1155 0.0247 52 8 29 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.1287 0.0261 52 6 24 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.1361 0.0351 50 5 14 302 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix APS-Forrest Hills Academey 0 0 -0.3663 0.0993 31 1 1 303 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 0.2990 0.0392 59 99 80 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 0.1118 0.0357 56 90 58 Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 0.1193 0.0436 60 91 91 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.1052 0.0468 56 89 65 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0600 0.0198 61 76 93 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.0643 0.0372 60 78 91 Sutton Middle School 0 0 0.0253 0.0159 58 62 77 Heritage Preparatory Academy School 1 0 -0.0342 0.0445 49 36 10 Coan Middle School 0 0 0.0091 0.0403 56 56 58 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.0181 0.0243 56 45 63 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.0234 0.0259 55 42 51 Price Middle School 0 0 -0.0470 0.0361 55 29 48 Long Middle School 0 0 -0.0342 0.0248 54 36 43 Kindezi 0 1 0.0107 0.1181 52 57 29 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0431 0.0298 55 30 54 KIPP VISION 0 1 -0.0625 0.0366 53 24 34 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0430 0.0326 54 31 39 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.0589 0.0682 50 25 15 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 -0.0797 0.0373 53 17 30 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 -0.0582 0.0468 49 25 9 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.0837 0.0194 50 16 13 Brown Middle School 0 0 -0.0925 0.0247 52 13 29 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.0684 0.0794 40 21 1 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.1086 0.0262 52 9 24 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.1124 0.0351 50 8 14 304 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix APS-Forrest Hills Academey 0 0 -0.3477 0.0993 31 1 1 305 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) CCAT School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) CCAT School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 306 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile CCAT School 1 0 0.0403 0.0747 48 67 7 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.0046 0.0455 50 53 15 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 -0.0293 0.0243 53 37 37 Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 -0.0705 0.0236 52 22 22 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0807 0.0250 52 17 23 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile CCAT School 1 0 0.0315 0.0747 48 66 7 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0014 0.0454 50 52 15 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 -0.0234 0.0242 53 42 37 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0808 0.0250 52 17 23 Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 -0.0859 0.0236 52 15 22 307 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 308 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.1456 0.0525 44 95 2 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.1417 0.0656 49 94 10 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1309 0.0669 54 93 42 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.1218 0.0541 51 92 19 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0929 0.0210 55 87 48 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 0.0927 0.0652 51 87 22 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.0926 0.0152 57 87 72 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.0691 0.0183 58 79 77 Canton Elementary 0 0 0.0679 0.0632 48 79 6 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 0.0656 0.0664 46 77 3 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.0422 0.0176 56 68 61 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0409 0.0340 51 67 21 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0302 0.0161 54 63 42 Rusk Middle School 0 0 0.0231 0.0206 55 60 49 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.0014 0.0529 51 52 21 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0172 0.0175 53 45 34 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0386 0.0774 52 34 23 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1495 0.0781 42 4 2 309 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.1304 0.0525 44 93 2 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1175 0.0669 54 91 42 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.1235 0.0656 49 92 10 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.1100 0.0540 51 90 19 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.0797 0.0152 57 84 72 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 0.0552 0.0664 46 73 3 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 0.0832 0.0651 51 85 22 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.0595 0.0183 58 76 77 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0785 0.0210 55 83 48 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.0293 0.0176 56 65 61 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0292 0.0340 51 64 21 Canton Elementary 0 0 0.0610 0.0632 48 77 6 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0151 0.0162 54 59 42 Rusk Middle School 0 0 0.0087 0.0206 55 56 49 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.0106 0.0529 51 49 21 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0293 0.0175 53 38 34 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0568 0.0773 52 26 23 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1673 0.0780 42 3 2 310 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 311 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name Coweta Charter Academy Arnall Middle School Lee Middle School East Coweta Middle School Smokey Road Middle School Madras Middle School Evans Middle School State Local Charter Charter 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.2135 0.0657 0.0389 -0.0234 -0.0265 -0.0370 -0.0390 School Effect Standard Error 0.0978 0.0204 0.0197 0.0223 0.0225 0.0186 0.0219 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 55 98 50 59 77 83 58 66 78 54 42 43 55 39 48 56 35 59 53 34 37 312 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.2024 0.0978 55 98 50 Arnall Middle School 0 0 0.0592 0.0204 59 75 83 Lee Middle School 0 0 0.0290 0.0197 58 64 78 East Coweta Middle School 0 0 -0.0355 0.0223 54 35 43 Smokey Road Middle School 0 0 -0.0324 0.0225 55 37 48 Madras Middle School 0 0 -0.0487 0.0186 56 28 59 Evans Middle School 0 0 -0.0476 0.0219 53 29 37 313 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 314 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.2496 0.0708 66 98 99 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1366 0.0872 63 94 97 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 0.1191 0.0202 57 91 68 DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 0 0 0.1168 0.0476 45 91 3 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 0.1100 0.0603 52 90 25 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 1 0 0.1088 0.0582 51 90 18 Tucker Middle School 0 0 0.0668 0.0177 56 78 64 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 0.0558 0.0206 60 73 92 Redan Middle School 0 0 0.0482 0.0226 54 71 46 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 0.0454 0.0199 56 70 64 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 0.0394 0.0167 57 67 69 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 0.0345 0.0205 53 65 36 Henderson Middle School 0 0 0.0283 0.0159 56 63 63 Salem Middle School 0 0 0.0249 0.0192 53 61 33 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 0.0241 0.0411 52 60 28 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 0.0238 0.0208 55 60 49 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 0.0125 0.0179 55 57 50 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 -0.0001 0.0580 52 51 29 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0226 0.0187 54 42 45 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 -0.0264 0.0383 48 40 5 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.0420 0.0211 52 33 26 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.0526 0.0207 51 29 20 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.0569 0.0200 51 27 19 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.0732 0.0215 51 21 21 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0802 0.0198 55 18 53 315 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Cedar Grove Middle School Kittredge Magnet School McNair Middle School International Student Center 0 1 -0.1013 0.0350 52 11 22 0 0 -0.1287 0.0212 45 6 3 0 0 -0.1400 0.0479 59 5 84 0 0 -0.1543 0.0249 48 4 7 0 0 -0.2307 0.0605 21 1 1 316 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.2606 0.0708 66 98 99 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1367 0.0872 63 94 97 DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 0 0 0.1419 0.0476 45 94 3 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 0.1309 0.0603 52 93 25 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 0.1414 0.0202 57 94 68 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 0.0570 0.0206 60 74 92 Tucker Middle School 0 0 0.0793 0.0177 56 83 64 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 1 0 0.1313 0.0581 51 93 18 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 0.0354 0.0167 57 66 69 Redan Middle School 0 0 0.0679 0.0226 54 79 46 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 0.0595 0.0205 53 76 36 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 0.0516 0.0199 56 72 64 Henderson Middle School 0 0 0.0277 0.0159 56 63 63 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 0.0469 0.0411 52 70 28 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 0.0470 0.0208 55 70 49 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.0314 0.0580 52 65 29 Salem Middle School 0 0 0.0468 0.0193 53 70 33 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 0.0021 0.0383 48 53 5 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0021 0.0187 54 52 45 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 0.0092 0.0179 55 56 50 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.0348 0.0200 51 35 19 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.0309 0.0208 51 37 20 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.0233 0.0212 52 42 26 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.0534 0.0215 51 27 21 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 -0.1403 0.0479 59 4 84 317 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Freedom Middle School Cedar Grove Middle School McNair Middle School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School International Student Center 0 0 -0.0664 0.0199 0 0 -0.1076 0.0212 0 0 -0.1332 0.0249 0 1 -0.1027 0.0350 0 0 -0.2234 0.0605 55 22 53 45 9 3 48 5 7 52 11 22 21 1 1 318 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 319 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name Fulton Leadership Academy Amana Academy School Crabapple Middle School Hopewell Middle School Webb Bridge Middle School Elkins Pointe Middle School Northwestern Middle School Taylor Road Middle School Bear Creek Middle School Ridgeview Charter School Main Street Charter Academy Middle Haynes Bridge Middle School Autrey Mill Middle School River Trail Middle School Sandy Springs Middle School Holcomb Bridge Middle School Renaissance Middle School Woodland Middle School Hapeville Charter Middle School McNair Middle School Sandtown Middle School Paul D. West Middle School KIPP South Fulton Academy School Camp Creek Middle School State Local Charter Charter 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 School Effect 0.2530 0.1899 0.0873 0.0641 0.0611 0.0475 0.0263 0.0182 0.0102 0.0101 0.0043 -0.0168 -0.0176 -0.0184 -0.0274 -0.0304 -0.0348 -0.0389 -0.0417 -0.0588 -0.0659 -0.0765 -0.0933 -0.0954 School Effect Standard Error 0.0461 0.0422 0.0198 0.0168 0.0165 0.0184 0.0165 0.0189 0.0204 0.0187 0.0409 0.0227 0.0164 0.0159 0.0212 0.0222 0.0179 0.0198 0.0258 0.0227 0.0182 0.0237 0.0385 0.0253 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 62 98 95 60 97 87 60 84 90 58 76 76 63 74 97 58 70 74 58 62 74 59 58 81 52 56 25 56 56 59 51 53 19 55 46 52 58 45 76 61 44 94 52 39 22 53 37 30 50 35 14 52 34 28 46 33 4 49 26 9 50 24 11 50 20 13 54 13 41 49 12 10 320 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Amana Academy School 0 1 0.1985 0.0422 60 98 87 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.2748 0.0461 62 99 95 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.0801 0.0197 60 84 90 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.0588 0.0168 58 75 76 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0548 0.0165 63 73 97 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0413 0.0184 58 68 74 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 0.0181 0.0165 58 60 74 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 0.0138 0.0189 59 58 81 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 0.0248 0.0409 51 62 19 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 0.0075 0.0187 56 55 59 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 0.0267 0.0205 52 63 25 River Trail Middle School 0 0 -0.0225 0.0159 61 42 94 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 -0.0245 0.0164 58 41 76 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 -0.0210 0.0227 55 43 52 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 -0.0293 0.0222 53 38 30 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 -0.0212 0.0212 52 43 22 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.0161 0.0179 50 46 14 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.0204 0.0198 52 44 28 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.0245 0.0258 46 41 4 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.0386 0.0227 49 33 9 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.0415 0.0182 50 31 11 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.0654 0.0237 50 22 13 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0744 0.0253 49 19 10 KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 -0.0688 0.0385 54 21 41 321 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gwinnett Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional 322 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.2059 0.0803 60 98 87 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.1788 0.0169 66 97 99 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.1609 0.0170 65 96 98 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.1576 0.0167 65 96 99 Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.1438 0.0157 67 95 99 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.1420 0.0194 63 94 97 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.1345 0.0186 65 94 99 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.1299 0.0189 65 93 98 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1294 0.0153 64 93 98 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.1057 0.0197 60 89 87 Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente 0 0 0.0983 0.1365 46 89 3 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.0964 0.0162 60 89 87 New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth 0 0 0.0959 0.0872 58 88 75 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.0956 0.0172 61 88 94 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0902 0.0130 63 85 97 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.0896 0.0129 62 85 96 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.0758 0.0149 65 82 98 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.0746 0.0170 61 81 94 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.0740 0.0186 59 81 86 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0737 0.0139 60 81 89 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0734 0.0139 61 80 94 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0708 0.0145 60 80 88 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.0663 0.0197 61 78 92 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0643 0.0145 59 76 81 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.0630 0.0206 59 75 84 323 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Lilburn Middle School Louise Radloff Middle School North Gwinnett Middle School Dacula Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School 0 0 0.0566 0.0159 60 73 90 0 0 0.0514 0.0151 61 71 93 0 0 0.0474 0.0136 63 70 97 0 0 0.0246 0.0156 59 61 84 1 0 -0.0002 0.0355 55 51 52 324 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.1970 0.0802 60 98 87 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.1795 0.0169 66 97 99 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.1587 0.0170 65 96 98 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.1536 0.0167 65 95 99 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.1440 0.0194 63 95 97 Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.1418 0.0157 67 94 99 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1306 0.0153 64 93 98 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.1349 0.0189 65 93 98 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.1347 0.0186 65 93 99 New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth 0 0 0.1164 0.0872 58 91 75 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.0924 0.0130 62 87 96 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.0985 0.0172 61 88 94 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0910 0.0130 63 87 97 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.1043 0.0162 60 89 87 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.1129 0.0197 60 90 87 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.0692 0.0149 65 80 98 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0732 0.0139 60 81 89 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0759 0.0139 61 82 94 North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.0429 0.0136 63 69 97 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.0866 0.0186 59 86 86 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.0779 0.0206 59 83 84 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0802 0.0145 59 84 81 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0734 0.0145 60 81 88 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.0752 0.0170 61 82 94 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.0686 0.0197 61 80 92 325 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Louise Radloff Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Lilburn Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.0536 0.0151 1 0 0.0148 0.0355 0 0 0.0573 0.0159 0 0 0.0950 0.1364 0 0 0.0289 0.0156 61 73 93 55 58 52 60 75 90 46 87 3 59 64 84 326 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 327 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name Clay County Middle School Pataula Charter Academy Early County Middle School Baker County K12 School Randolph Clay Middle School Calhoun County Middle School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.0610 0.0583 0.0094 0.0085 -0.0778 -0.1243 School Effect Standard Error 0.0655 0.0544 0.0269 0.0729 0.0433 0.0496 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 58 74 77 51 74 19 57 55 73 57 55 70 45 19 3 50 7 16 328 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.0440 0.0544 51 69 19 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.0293 0.0729 57 65 70 Clay County Middle School 0 0 0.0775 0.0655 58 83 77 Early County Middle School 0 0 0.0172 0.0268 57 59 73 Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.0628 0.0433 45 23 3 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.1050 0.0496 50 10 16 329 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 ELA APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 330 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name Kindezi Latin Academy Charter School Atlanta Heights Charter School Imagine Wesley International Academy Atlanta Charter Middle School Inman Middle School Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad Bunche Middle School Kipp Strive Academy Sutton Middle School KIPP VISION Intown Charter Academy Coan Middle School Long Middle School Harper-Archer Middle School Brown Middle School Price Middle School King Middle School Charles R. Drew Charter School Young Middle School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso Kennedy Middle School Sylvan Hills Middle School State Local Charter Charter 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.2929 0.1679 0.1491 0.1330 0.0999 0.0458 0.0378 0.0341 0.0246 0.0225 0.0038 -0.0063 -0.0158 -0.0235 -0.0281 -0.0371 -0.0380 -0.0406 -0.0507 -0.0588 -0.0630 -0.0695 -0.0876 -0.0913 School Effect Standard Error 0.1128 0.0414 0.0447 0.0447 0.0377 0.0188 0.0342 0.0232 0.0356 0.0152 0.0351 0.0651 0.0385 0.0236 0.0248 0.0235 0.0344 0.0285 0.0311 0.0185 0.0358 0.0337 0.0766 0.0249 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 52 99 85 52 97 87 48 96 50 49 95 65 48 89 57 52 74 88 50 72 73 48 71 54 46 65 35 52 64 86 48 55 56 47 50 41 43 44 16 48 40 53 44 37 21 47 32 44 45 32 28 46 30 34 45 25 27 43 21 14 46 19 31 41 17 7 36 11 1 43 10 12 331 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Heritage Preparatory Academy School APS-Forrest Hills Academey 1 0 -0.1105 0.0427 42 6 9 0 0 -0.2881 0.0948 39 1 3 332 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Kindezi 0 1 0.2210 0.1149 52 98 85 Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 0.1676 0.0422 52 97 87 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 0.1368 0.0455 48 95 50 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.1291 0.0455 49 94 65 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 0.1255 0.0348 50 94 73 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0663 0.0192 52 82 88 Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 0.0494 0.0384 48 76 57 Bunche Middle School 0 0 0.0446 0.0236 48 74 54 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.0419 0.0358 48 72 56 Sutton Middle School 0 0 0.0381 0.0155 52 71 86 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.0228 0.0363 46 62 35 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 0.0067 0.0664 47 55 41 Brown Middle School 0 0 -0.0140 0.0240 47 45 44 Price Middle School 0 0 -0.0144 0.0351 45 44 28 Long Middle School 0 0 -0.0201 0.0241 48 42 53 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.0245 0.0252 44 40 21 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0266 0.0291 46 39 34 Coan Middle School 0 0 -0.0360 0.0392 43 33 16 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 -0.0434 0.0364 46 29 31 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.0435 0.0188 43 29 14 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0447 0.0317 45 28 27 Heritage Preparatory Academy School 1 0 -0.0466 0.0435 42 27 9 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0978 0.0254 43 9 12 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.1017 0.0781 36 7 1 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.1484 0.0343 41 3 7 333 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix APS-Forrest Hills Academey 0 0 -0.3514 0.0966 39 1 3 334 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 335 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name Portal Middle/High School Southeast Bulloch Middle School William James Middle School Langston Chapel Middle School CCAT School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 School Effect 0.0042 -0.0224 -0.0467 -0.0491 -0.1995 School Effect Standard Error 0.0433 0.0226 0.0239 0.0230 0.0707 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 45 55 25 47 41 42 48 26 55 43 26 14 40 1 5 336 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0098 0.0441 45 48 25 Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 -0.0514 0.0230 47 25 42 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0515 0.0244 48 24 55 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 -0.0675 0.0235 43 17 14 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2132 0.0721 40 1 5 337 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 338 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name Hickory Flat Elementary School Holly Springs Elementary School Woodstock Middle School Canton Elementary Booth Middle School Indian Knoll Elementary J. Knox Elementary Cherokee Charter Academy William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho Freedom Middle School Creekland Middle School Mill Creek Middle School Teasley Middle School Clayton Elementary School Rusk Middle School Mountain Road Elementary School Ball Ground Elementary School R. M. Moore Elementary School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.1540 0.0893 0.0842 0.0775 0.0712 0.0709 0.0703 0.0624 0.0490 0.0195 0.0070 -0.0006 -0.0121 -0.0394 -0.0464 -0.0528 -0.0796 -0.0808 School Effect Standard Error 0.0639 0.0501 0.0175 0.0600 0.0146 0.0518 0.0510 0.0323 0.0622 0.0168 0.0155 0.0167 0.0201 0.0774 0.0197 0.0634 0.0745 0.0626 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 46 97 31 42 88 8 53 86 89 42 85 8 50 83 72 42 83 8 46 82 32 47 81 44 40 75 4 47 62 43 47 56 48 48 53 51 46 46 37 53 31 90 48 27 55 39 23 3 37 13 1 45 13 28 339 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1735 0.0650 46 97 31 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.1049 0.0527 42 91 8 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.1039 0.0510 42 91 8 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.0800 0.0178 53 86 89 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.0682 0.0148 50 83 72 Canton Elementary 0 0 0.0617 0.0611 42 81 8 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.0540 0.0518 46 78 32 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0517 0.0329 47 77 44 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 0.0305 0.0633 40 67 4 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.0175 0.0171 47 59 43 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 0.0046 0.0170 48 54 51 Creekland Middle School 0 0 -0.0034 0.0158 47 51 48 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0345 0.0788 53 34 90 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.0424 0.0646 39 30 3 Teasley Middle School 0 0 -0.0446 0.0204 46 28 37 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.0574 0.0759 37 21 1 Rusk Middle School 0 0 -0.0577 0.0200 48 21 55 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.0883 0.0638 45 11 28 340 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 341 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [clayton] School Name Elite Scholars Academy School M. D. Roberts Middle School Riverdale Middle School Morrow Middle School Rex Mill Middle School North Clayton Middle School Adamson Middle School Forest Park Middle School Jonesboro Middle School Babb Middle School Unidos Dual Language Charter School Kendrick Middle School Sequoyah Middle School Eddie White Academy Pointe South Middle School Lovejoy Middle School Mundys Mill Middle School State Local Charter Charter 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.1386 0.1179 0.0865 0.0620 0.0538 0.0246 0.0212 0.0048 -0.0014 -0.0024 -0.0075 -0.0077 -0.0112 -0.0123 -0.0357 -0.0495 -0.0672 School Effect Standard Error 0.0356 0.0211 0.0225 0.0230 0.0181 0.0210 0.0249 0.0240 0.0212 0.0209 0.0593 0.0217 0.0212 0.0226 0.0212 0.0237 0.0211 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 55 95 97 52 93 88 54 87 94 50 81 71 51 76 79 50 65 74 51 63 75 51 55 75 49 52 65 51 52 78 48 49 48 49 49 66 51 47 82 48 46 49 48 33 51 48 26 54 45 18 25 342 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [clayton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Elite Scholars Academy School 0 1 0.1652 0.0363 55 96 97 M. D. Roberts Middle School 0 0 0.1343 0.0214 52 94 88 Riverdale Middle School 0 0 0.1175 0.0229 54 93 94 Morrow Middle School 0 0 0.0881 0.0234 50 88 71 Rex Mill Middle School 0 0 0.0801 0.0184 51 86 79 North Clayton Middle School 0 0 0.0496 0.0214 50 76 74 Forest Park Middle School 0 0 0.0486 0.0244 51 75 75 Adamson Middle School 0 0 0.0405 0.0253 51 72 75 Babb Middle School 0 0 0.0376 0.0212 51 71 78 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 0.0344 0.0215 51 69 82 Unidos Dual Language Charter School 0 1 0.0326 0.0604 48 68 48 Eddie White Academy 0 0 0.0262 0.0230 48 64 49 Kendrick Middle School 0 0 0.0245 0.0220 49 63 66 Jonesboro Middle School 0 0 0.0224 0.0215 49 62 65 Pointe South Middle School 0 0 -0.0110 0.0216 48 47 51 Lovejoy Middle School 0 0 -0.0137 0.0241 48 45 54 Mundys Mill Middle School 0 0 -0.0372 0.0214 45 32 25 343 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Young Mens Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional 344 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi Museum School Avondale Estates DeKalb School of the Arts Leadership Preparatory Academy Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Stephenson Middle School The Champion Middle Theme School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Chamblee Middle School Druid Hills Middle School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Tucker Middle School Salem Middle School Redan Middle School Peachtree Middle School Kittredge Magnet School Sequoyah Middle School Lithonia Middle School Chapel Hill Middle School Cedar Grove Middle School Freedom Middle School Columbia Middle School DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School Miller Grove Middle School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 School Effect 0.2514 0.1349 0.1214 0.1173 0.1066 0.0905 0.0874 0.0857 0.0577 0.0554 0.0381 0.0276 0.0189 0.0166 0.0127 0.0037 0.0027 -0.0127 -0.0238 -0.0318 -0.0333 -0.0372 -0.0377 -0.0401 School Effect Standard Error 0.0553 0.0833 0.0676 0.0393 0.0579 0.0193 0.0195 0.0454 0.0197 0.0191 0.0555 0.0169 0.0184 0.0216 0.0159 0.0457 0.0171 0.0179 0.0199 0.0203 0.0190 0.0191 0.0334 0.0198 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 52 99 88 56 95 98 52 94 87 49 92 58 48 91 51 51 88 80 51 87 77 47 87 46 52 79 89 52 77 89 46 72 36 51 66 81 47 61 45 50 60 68 50 59 70 54 55 93 49 54 65 51 46 76 46 40 32 45 35 28 52 34 84 47 32 47 51 32 77 47 30 45 345 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Henderson Middle School Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Stone Mountain Middle School McNair Middle School International Student Center 0 0 -0.0450 0.0152 49 27 60 0 0 -0.0482 0.0206 48 26 50 0 1 -0.0513 0.0365 43 24 12 0 0 -0.0560 0.0202 47 22 41 0 0 -0.1649 0.0238 41 2 6 0 0 -0.3549 0.0563 49 1 67 346 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.3070 0.0563 52 99 88 DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.1777 0.0688 52 98 87 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1760 0.0849 56 98 98 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 0.1653 0.0590 48 97 51 DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 0 0 0.1443 0.0463 47 96 46 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 0.1349 0.0400 49 94 58 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 0.1041 0.0199 51 91 77 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 0.0990 0.0196 51 90 80 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.0907 0.0465 54 89 93 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 0.0828 0.0200 52 87 89 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 0.0696 0.0194 52 83 89 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 0.0399 0.0162 50 71 70 Tucker Middle School 0 0 0.0386 0.0172 51 71 81 Salem Middle School 0 0 0.0234 0.0187 47 62 45 Redan Middle School 0 0 0.0182 0.0220 50 59 68 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 0.0098 0.0372 43 56 12 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 0.0029 0.0172 49 54 65 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0073 0.0182 51 50 76 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 -0.0090 0.0202 46 49 32 Henderson Middle School 0 0 -0.0096 0.0154 49 48 60 Cedar Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.0177 0.0206 45 42 28 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.0215 0.0194 47 41 47 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0248 0.0192 52 40 84 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 -0.0282 0.0339 51 38 77 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.0287 0.0202 47 38 45 347 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi Stone Mountain Middle School McNair Middle School International Student Center 0 0 -0.0385 0.0209 48 31 50 1 0 -0.0426 0.0566 46 29 36 0 0 -0.0551 0.0206 47 22 41 0 0 -0.1428 0.0243 41 3 6 0 0 -0.3051 0.0569 49 1 67 348 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 349 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name Amana Academy School Fulton Leadership Academy Crabapple Middle School Webb Bridge Middle School River Trail Middle School Hopewell Middle School Elkins Pointe Middle School KIPP South Fulton Academy School Ridgeview Charter School Haynes Bridge Middle School Northwestern Middle School Bear Creek Middle School Sandtown Middle School Woodland Middle School Sandy Springs Middle School Holcomb Bridge Middle School Taylor Road Middle School Renaissance Middle School Autrey Mill Middle School Paul D. West Middle School McNair Middle School Hapeville Charter Middle School Camp Creek Middle School Main Street Charter Academy Middle State Local Charter Charter 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.2541 0.2218 0.1508 0.1389 0.1184 0.1160 0.0573 0.0504 0.0503 0.0495 0.0452 0.0380 0.0375 0.0310 0.0292 0.0215 0.0188 0.0122 0.0074 -0.0066 -0.0154 -0.0407 -0.0524 -0.1086 School Effect Standard Error 0.0404 0.0443 0.0188 0.0157 0.0152 0.0161 0.0176 0.0367 0.0179 0.0216 0.0158 0.0195 0.0174 0.0189 0.0203 0.0212 0.0181 0.0171 0.0156 0.0226 0.0217 0.0246 0.0241 0.0391 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 58 99 99 50 98 72 57 97 99 57 95 99 55 93 98 55 92 97 51 78 78 51 75 76 49 75 61 50 75 73 49 73 62 47 72 37 47 71 43 46 69 37 50 67 74 50 63 69 49 61 64 44 59 20 48 57 56 46 50 35 43 44 15 42 30 12 44 23 17 42 7 10 350 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Amana Academy School 0 1 0.2863 0.0412 58 99 99 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.1644 0.0192 57 96 99 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.1617 0.0160 57 96 99 River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.1406 0.0155 55 95 98 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.1358 0.0164 55 95 97 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.0952 0.0451 50 89 72 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0715 0.0179 51 84 78 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 0.0652 0.0182 49 82 61 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 0.0601 0.0161 49 80 62 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0580 0.0220 50 79 73 KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 0.0458 0.0374 51 74 76 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0371 0.0216 50 70 69 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 0.0360 0.0177 47 70 43 Woodland Middle School 0 0 0.0297 0.0192 46 66 37 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 0.0290 0.0207 50 65 74 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 0.0248 0.0199 47 63 37 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 0.0237 0.0184 49 62 64 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 0.0198 0.0159 48 60 56 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 0.0049 0.0174 44 55 20 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.0073 0.0230 46 50 35 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.0160 0.0221 43 43 15 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.0323 0.0250 42 36 12 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0641 0.0246 44 19 17 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 -0.1018 0.0398 42 7 10 351 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gwinnett Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional 352 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett] School Name New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Couch Middle School Alton C. Crews Middle School Twin Rivers Middle School Lanier Middle School McConnell Middle School Glenn C. Jones Middle School Bay Creek Middle School Shiloh Middle School Creekland Middle School Pinckneyville Middle School Grace Snell Middle School North Gwinnett Middle School Five Forks Middle School Snellville Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Moore Middle School Hull Middle School Trickum Middle School Lilburn Middle School Frank N. Osborne Middle School Duluth Middle School Summerour Middle School Sweetwater Middle School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.2489 0.1839 0.1345 0.1298 0.1209 0.1151 0.1098 0.1006 0.0999 0.0998 0.0989 0.0984 0.0932 0.0878 0.0875 0.0834 0.0825 0.0718 0.0709 0.0702 0.0680 0.0618 0.0582 0.0553 School Effect Standard Error 0.0833 0.0185 0.0161 0.0150 0.0159 0.0146 0.0163 0.0181 0.0139 0.0125 0.0165 0.0178 0.0130 0.0178 0.0197 0.1303 0.0189 0.0124 0.0132 0.0151 0.0142 0.0133 0.0162 0.0138 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 47 98 47 57 98 99 54 95 95 54 94 96 56 93 98 54 92 96 55 91 98 53 90 91 53 89 92 54 89 95 53 89 91 52 89 85 54 88 94 53 88 90 51 87 81 53 86 93 51 86 83 52 83 86 52 83 85 53 82 91 53 82 93 52 81 88 53 79 90 50 77 72 353 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Berkmar Middle School Louise Radloff Middle School Richards Middle School Dacula Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0508 0.0187 52 76 86 0 0 0.0505 0.0144 52 76 89 0 0 0.0399 0.0156 49 72 61 0 0 0.0385 0.0149 50 72 73 1 0 -0.0236 0.0338 45 40 27 0 0 -0.0846 0.0781 52 12 84 354 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth 0 0 0.2524 0.0849 47 99 47 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.1708 0.0189 57 97 99 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.1431 0.0164 54 95 95 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.1196 0.0162 56 93 98 Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.1171 0.0152 54 92 96 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.1103 0.0166 55 92 98 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1052 0.0148 54 91 96 North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.1002 0.0132 54 90 94 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0987 0.0127 54 89 95 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.0954 0.0168 53 89 91 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.0915 0.0184 53 89 91 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.0823 0.0126 52 87 86 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.0819 0.0181 53 86 90 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0818 0.0141 53 86 92 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0744 0.0135 52 85 85 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.0724 0.0200 51 85 81 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.0682 0.0181 52 83 85 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.0639 0.0152 53 81 91 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.0591 0.0192 51 80 83 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.0575 0.0145 53 79 93 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0561 0.0135 52 79 88 Louise Radloff Middle School 0 0 0.0500 0.0146 52 76 89 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.0493 0.0164 53 75 90 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0492 0.0140 50 75 72 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.0403 0.0190 52 71 86 355 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Richards Middle School Dacula Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0354 0.0158 49 70 61 0 0 0.0301 0.0152 50 66 73 1 0 0.0288 0.0344 45 65 27 0 0 -0.0075 0.1327 53 49 93 0 0 -0.0670 0.0796 52 17 84 356 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix x Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Pataula State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Pataula State Charters Local Charters Traditional 357 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name Clay County Middle School Randolph Clay Middle School Calhoun County Middle School Early County Middle School Pataula Charter Academy Baker County K12 School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 School Effect 0.1742 0.0833 0.0124 0.0106 -0.0306 -0.0758 School Effect Standard Error 0.0626 0.0413 0.0476 0.0256 0.0520 0.0696 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 52 98 88 48 86 57 41 59 7 48 58 55 49 35 62 44 15 19 358 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Middle School 0 0 0.1456 0.0638 52 96 88 Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 0.0582 0.0421 48 80 57 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.0077 0.0261 48 49 55 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.0113 0.0485 41 47 7 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.0446 0.0709 44 28 19 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0453 0.0530 49 28 62 359 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Math APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 360 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name Kennedy Middle School Kindezi Inman Middle School Imagine Wesley International Academy Coan Middle School Latin Academy Charter School Kipp Strive Academy Atlanta Charter Middle School King Middle School Sutton Middle School Brown Middle School Price Middle School KIPP VISION Bunche Middle School Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad Charles R. Drew Charter School Atlanta Heights Charter School Long Middle School KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad Harper-Archer Middle School Intown Charter Academy Young Middle School The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso Sylvan Hills Middle School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.2299 0.2099 0.1971 0.1379 0.0943 0.0878 0.0140 0.0006 -0.0172 -0.0209 -0.0231 -0.0268 -0.0336 -0.0415 -0.0443 -0.0696 -0.0737 -0.0810 -0.0839 -0.0972 -0.1091 -0.1182 -0.1390 -0.1606 School Effect Standard Error 0.0713 0.1040 0.0175 0.0412 0.0360 0.0382 0.0332 0.0354 0.0264 0.0140 0.0219 0.0318 0.0323 0.0214 0.0316 0.0287 0.0412 0.0220 0.0328 0.0230 0.0600 0.0171 0.0313 0.0231 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 63 95 98 54 94 83 61 93 97 52 84 74 57 77 88 50 75 66 52 58 75 44 55 35 48 49 56 51 45 68 46 45 47 48 44 58 47 41 52 48 38 54 46 38 44 44 32 37 38 30 12 43 28 32 44 27 33 41 23 22 40 21 19 42 18 28 37 12 11 38 9 12 361 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Heritage Preparatory Academy School APS-Forrest Hills Academey 1 0 -0.2287 0.0393 38 0 0 -0.2718 0.0862 24 3 14 1 1 362 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Inman Middle School 0 0 0.2272 0.0178 61 95 97 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 0.2150 0.0728 63 94 98 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 0.1458 0.0421 52 86 74 Kindezi 0 1 0.0964 0.1061 54 79 83 Coan Middle School 0 0 0.0707 0.0368 57 73 88 Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 0.0613 0.0390 50 71 66 Sutton Middle School 0 0 0.0228 0.0143 51 60 68 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 -0.0027 0.0339 52 54 75 Price Middle School 0 0 -0.0126 0.0325 48 51 58 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0159 0.0269 48 50 56 Brown Middle School 0 0 -0.0166 0.0223 46 49 47 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 -0.0307 0.0323 46 43 44 KIPP VISION 0 1 -0.0317 0.0330 47 43 52 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.0356 0.0219 48 42 54 Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.0527 0.0361 44 35 35 Long Middle School 0 0 -0.0742 0.0224 43 30 32 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.0742 0.0613 40 30 19 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0789 0.0293 44 28 37 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 -0.0884 0.0421 38 25 12 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.0940 0.0234 41 24 22 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 -0.0945 0.0335 44 23 33 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.0994 0.0175 42 21 28 Heritage Preparatory Academy School 1 0 -0.1420 0.0401 38 12 14 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.1487 0.0319 37 10 11 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.1688 0.0236 38 8 12 363 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix APS-Forrest Hills Academey 0 0 -0.3623 0.0879 24 1 1 364 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 365 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name Southeast Bulloch Middle School Portal Middle/High School William James Middle School Langston Chapel Middle School CCAT School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 School Effect 0.0975 0.0701 0.0662 0.0508 -0.2806 School Effect Standard Error 0.0209 0.0400 0.0222 0.0212 0.0663 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 53 78 76 54 71 83 52 70 73 50 67 63 37 1 11 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile William James Middle School 0 0 0.0786 0.0226 52 75 73 Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 0.0575 0.0214 53 70 76 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.0538 0.0409 54 69 83 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 0.0315 0.0216 50 63 63 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2846 0.0677 37 1 11 366 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Cherokee State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Cherokee State Charters Local Charters Traditional 367 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name R. M. Moore Elementary School Mountain Road Elementary School Canton Elementary Woodstock Middle School Creekland Middle School Holly Springs Elementary School J. Knox Elementary Booth Middle School Hickory Flat Elementary School Freedom Middle School Teasley Middle School William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho Indian Knoll Elementary Cherokee Charter Academy Clayton Elementary School Mill Creek Middle School Rusk Middle School Ball Ground Elementary School State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 School Effect 0.2030 0.1828 0.1753 0.1717 0.1694 0.1499 0.1403 0.1376 0.1151 0.1046 0.0611 0.0226 -0.0129 -0.0265 -0.0278 -0.0460 -0.0672 -0.2246 School Effect Standard Error 0.0577 0.0589 0.0550 0.0162 0.0144 0.0464 0.0472 0.0134 0.0593 0.0155 0.0187 0.0574 0.0478 0.0301 0.0714 0.0154 0.0184 0.0700 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 58 93 92 48 91 58 51 90 71 57 89 89 56 89 87 45 87 41 45 85 43 58 84 91 60 81 96 52 80 73 47 70 49 48 59 55 51 50 71 48 44 57 58 43 93 50 37 64 44 32 36 31 3 3 368 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 0.2011 0.0600 48 93 58 Canton Elementary 0 0 0.1973 0.0561 51 93 71 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 0.1851 0.0589 58 91 92 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.1735 0.0166 57 90 89 Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.1720 0.0473 45 89 41 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.1639 0.0146 56 88 87 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.1611 0.0605 60 88 96 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.1514 0.0136 58 87 91 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.1269 0.0481 45 83 43 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.1039 0.0159 52 80 73 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 0.0512 0.0585 48 68 55 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.0470 0.0487 51 67 71 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0410 0.0190 47 65 49 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0283 0.0728 58 44 93 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0350 0.0157 50 42 64 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0360 0.0307 48 41 57 Rusk Middle School 0 0 -0.0811 0.0186 44 28 36 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1845 0.0714 31 6 3 369 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Coweta State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Coweta State Charters Local Charters Traditional 370 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name East Coweta Middle School Smokey Road Middle School Lee Middle School Evans Middle School Arnall Middle School Madras Middle School Coweta Charter Academy State Local Charter Charter 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 School Effect 0.1404 0.1181 0.0809 -0.0168 -0.0199 -0.0303 -0.1753 School Effect Standard Error 0.0197 0.0200 0.0174 0.0194 0.0181 0.0164 0.0861 School School Mean SGP Mean Effect State State Rank Student Rank Percentile Growth Percentile Percentile 57 85 89 56 82 86 53 74 80 46 49 46 51 47 72 49 42 61 50 7 67 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile East Coweta Middle School 0 0 0.1503 0.0201 57 87 89 Smokey Road Middle School 0 0 0.1193 0.0204 56 82 86 Lee Middle School 0 0 0.1176 0.0178 53 81 80 Arnall Middle School 0 0 -0.0034 0.0184 51 54 72 Evans Middle School 0 0 -0.0199 0.0199 46 48 46 Madras Middle School 0 0 -0.0223 0.0168 49 47 61 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1884 0.0879 50 5 67 371 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 372 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.3761 0.0308 59 99 95 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.3206 0.0768 64 97 99 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.2237 0.0422 59 95 94 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.1769 0.0510 51 90 70 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 1 0 0.1010 0.0515 42 79 27 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 0.0734 0.0178 49 72 63 International Student Center 0 0 0.0419 0.0509 40 66 18 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 0.0292 0.0363 49 61 63 Tucker Middle School 0 0 0.0028 0.0155 47 56 50 DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 0 0 -0.0021 0.0419 51 54 71 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0259 0.0166 45 44 40 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0323 0.0176 48 42 54 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.0440 0.0188 44 38 34 Henderson Middle School 0 0 -0.0489 0.0140 48 36 55 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 -0.0499 0.0537 36 36 10 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0584 0.0174 45 35 40 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 -0.0844 0.0182 45 26 42 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 -0.0904 0.0180 43 25 28 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.0934 0.0190 39 25 17 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 -0.0937 0.0157 40 24 19 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.1065 0.0184 40 21 18 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 -0.1134 0.0146 44 19 34 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.1162 0.0176 39 18 15 Redan Middle School 0 0 -0.1521 0.0200 35 11 9 Salem Middle School 0 0 -0.1533 0.0170 35 10 8 373 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Academy of Technology and the Cedar Grove Middle School Chapel Hill Middle School McNair Middle School DeKalb School of the Arts 0 1 -0.1535 0.0337 32 10 4 0 0 -0.1552 0.0188 35 10 7 0 0 -0.1727 0.0183 36 8 10 0 0 -0.1969 0.0222 34 6 5 0 0 -0.3008 0.0623 36 1 9 374 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.3972 0.0313 59 99 95 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.3786 0.0429 59 99 94 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.3743 0.0784 64 98 99 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.2853 0.0520 51 96 70 International Student Center 0 0 0.2112 0.0516 40 94 18 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 1 0 0.0991 0.0525 42 79 27 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 0.0917 0.0182 49 77 63 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 0.0692 0.0371 49 73 63 DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 0 0 0.0459 0.0428 51 66 71 Tucker Middle School 0 0 0.0449 0.0157 47 66 50 Henderson Middle School 0 0 0.0238 0.0143 48 60 55 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 0.0122 0.0180 48 58 54 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 -0.0000 0.0186 45 55 42 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0123 0.0176 45 51 40 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0270 0.0169 45 45 40 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 -0.0388 0.0158 40 40 19 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.0405 0.0192 44 39 34 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 -0.0425 0.0149 44 38 34 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 -0.0546 0.0344 32 35 4 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 -0.0558 0.0184 43 34 28 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 -0.0775 0.0548 36 29 10 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.0896 0.0193 39 25 17 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.1008 0.0180 39 21 15 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.1040 0.0188 40 20 18 Cedar Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.1395 0.0191 35 13 7 375 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Chapel Hill Middle School Salem Middle School Redan Middle School McNair Middle School DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 -0.1439 0.0187 36 12 10 0 0 -0.1464 0.0174 35 11 8 0 0 -0.1487 0.0204 35 10 9 0 0 -0.1834 0.0226 34 6 5 0 0 -0.2381 0.0635 36 3 9 376 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 377 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.3454 0.0141 62 98 98 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.2888 0.0145 63 97 98 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.2509 0.0149 60 96 95 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 0.2474 0.0144 56 96 87 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.1800 0.0174 58 91 92 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.1595 0.0202 58 88 91 Amana Academy School 0 1 0.0975 0.0371 57 78 90 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 0.0954 0.0147 53 78 79 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0700 0.0162 52 71 74 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 0.0618 0.0167 49 70 62 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0500 0.0195 53 67 79 KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 0.0327 0.0339 58 62 92 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 -0.0183 0.0189 49 48 59 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 -0.0386 0.0414 45 40 40 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0422 0.0182 41 38 22 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 -0.0862 0.0364 49 26 62 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 -0.1135 0.0165 45 19 39 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.1188 0.0225 38 17 13 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.1191 0.0210 42 17 26 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.1582 0.0176 37 9 11 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.1592 0.0159 36 9 10 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.1708 0.0161 39 8 15 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.1878 0.0201 35 6 7 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.2239 0.0228 32 4 4 378 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.3998 0.0143 62 99 98 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.3356 0.0148 63 98 98 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.3069 0.0152 60 97 95 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 0.2966 0.0147 56 97 87 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.2220 0.0177 58 95 92 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.1989 0.0206 58 93 91 Amana Academy School 0 1 0.1493 0.0378 57 87 90 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 0.1359 0.0149 53 84 79 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.1283 0.0165 52 83 74 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 0.0965 0.0170 49 79 62 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0949 0.0199 53 78 79 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 0.0025 0.0193 49 56 59 KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 -0.0133 0.0345 58 51 92 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 -0.0443 0.0372 49 37 62 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0456 0.0185 41 37 22 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 -0.0561 0.0168 45 34 39 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 -0.1027 0.0422 45 20 40 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.1082 0.0214 42 19 26 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.1321 0.0230 38 14 13 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.1613 0.0162 36 9 10 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.1619 0.0179 37 9 11 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.1680 0.0165 39 8 15 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.1778 0.0205 35 7 7 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.1969 0.0233 32 5 4 379 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gwinnett Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional 380 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.3856 0.0120 65 99 99 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.3480 0.0149 63 98 98 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.3280 0.0132 63 98 99 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.2489 0.0148 62 96 97 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.2430 0.0150 60 95 96 Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.2350 0.0139 60 95 97 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.2059 0.0172 59 94 94 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.1940 0.0168 60 93 95 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.1879 0.0173 57 92 88 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.1848 0.0123 57 92 89 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.1776 0.0166 60 90 95 Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.1770 0.0138 58 90 94 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.1765 0.0176 54 90 83 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1721 0.0135 56 89 86 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.1670 0.0114 57 89 88 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.1585 0.0151 55 88 84 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.1378 0.0115 57 84 90 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.1083 0.0140 55 80 84 New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth 0 0 0.0901 0.0768 46 76 47 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0875 0.0128 52 75 73 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.0768 0.0150 54 73 82 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0745 0.0123 51 72 69 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0598 0.0127 50 69 67 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 1 0 0.0566 0.0315 47 69 50 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.0510 0.0144 48 67 58 381 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Snellville Middle School Louise Radloff Middle School Grace Snell Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0455 0.0183 53 66 77 0 0 0.0455 0.0134 50 66 63 0 0 0.0316 0.0166 49 62 62 0 0 -0.0418 0.1170 32 38 3 0 0 -0.2022 0.0721 37 5 11 382 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.4002 0.0122 65 99 99 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.3749 0.0152 63 98 98 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.3090 0.0134 63 97 99 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.2488 0.0153 60 96 96 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.2458 0.0151 62 95 97 Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.2160 0.0142 60 94 97 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.2098 0.0116 57 94 88 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.2077 0.0176 59 93 94 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.1928 0.0124 57 92 89 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.1925 0.0170 60 92 95 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.1893 0.0176 57 92 88 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.1818 0.0171 60 91 95 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.1698 0.0154 55 89 84 Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.1650 0.0141 58 88 94 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1592 0.0138 56 88 86 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.1581 0.0179 54 87 83 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.1388 0.0117 57 85 90 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.1284 0.0141 55 84 84 New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth 0 0 0.1091 0.0784 46 81 47 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0995 0.0125 51 79 69 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.0812 0.0151 54 75 82 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0717 0.0130 52 73 73 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0691 0.0129 50 73 67 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.0562 0.0147 48 69 58 Louise Radloff Middle School 0 0 0.0508 0.0135 50 68 63 383 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Snellville Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Grace Snell Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0268 0.0187 53 61 77 1 0 0.0104 0.0321 47 58 50 0 0 -0.0043 0.0169 49 53 62 0 0 -0.1268 0.1193 32 15 3 0 0 -0.1990 0.0735 37 4 11 384 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 385 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.0187 0.0381 32 47 3 Clay County Middle School 0 0 -0.0191 0.0577 33 47 4 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0638 0.0479 42 32 25 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.0801 0.0236 39 28 16 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1047 0.0642 34 22 5 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.1327 0.0434 32 14 3 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.0395 0.0389 32 40 3 Clay County Middle School 0 0 -0.0564 0.0589 33 34 4 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.0839 0.0655 34 26 5 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0901 0.0489 42 24 25 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.1009 0.0241 39 21 16 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.1616 0.0443 32 9 3 386 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Science APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 387 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 0.2345 0.0388 63 96 98 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.1763 0.0329 60 92 95 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.1143 0.0332 60 83 94 Long Middle School 0 0 0.0969 0.0215 57 79 89 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0288 0.0174 51 60 58 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.0158 0.0325 58 56 91 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 0.0105 0.0415 48 53 33 Price Middle School 0 0 0.0000 0.0303 53 50 68 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0139 0.0229 50 45 45 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.0459 0.0307 53 34 66 Coan Middle School 0 0 -0.0463 0.0350 49 33 38 Sutton Middle School 0 0 -0.0792 0.0141 46 26 23 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.0797 0.0697 62 26 97 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0851 0.0257 49 25 39 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.1034 0.0211 45 20 17 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 -0.1131 0.0314 48 19 32 Brown Middle School 0 0 -0.1216 0.0213 48 16 34 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.1265 0.0290 48 15 36 Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.1270 0.0346 40 15 5 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.1563 0.0225 44 12 16 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.1800 0.0596 41 9 6 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.1862 0.0170 43 8 13 Kindezi 0 1 -0.1862 0.1054 52 8 65 Hillside Conant School 0 0 -0.2058 0.1292 31 6 2 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 -0.2095 0.0413 47 5 30 388 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix APS-Forrest Hills Academey Heritage Preparatory Academy School 0 0 -0.2717 0.0862 34 3 3 1 0 -0.2722 0.0392 40 2 6 389 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 0.2217 0.0392 63 95 98 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.1586 0.0332 60 91 95 KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.1077 0.0335 60 82 94 Long Middle School 0 0 0.1023 0.0217 57 80 89 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0328 0.0175 51 61 58 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 0.0127 0.0419 48 54 33 Price Middle School 0 0 0.0071 0.0306 53 52 68 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.0033 0.0328 58 51 91 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.0149 0.0310 53 43 66 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0387 0.0231 50 36 45 Sutton Middle School 0 0 -0.0572 0.0142 46 31 23 Coan Middle School 0 0 -0.0639 0.0353 49 29 38 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.0762 0.0703 62 26 97 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0913 0.0260 49 23 39 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.1060 0.0213 45 20 17 Brown Middle School 0 0 -0.1213 0.0215 48 17 34 Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.1271 0.0350 40 16 5 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.1369 0.0292 48 14 36 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 -0.1428 0.0317 48 13 32 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.1606 0.0227 44 10 16 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.1629 0.0602 41 10 6 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.1717 0.0172 43 8 13 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 -0.1946 0.0416 47 6 30 Kindezi 0 1 -0.2209 0.1064 52 5 65 Heritage Preparatory Academy School 1 0 -0.2377 0.0396 40 4 6 390 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Hillside Conant School APS-Forrest Hills Academey 0 0 -0.2404 0.1304 31 3 2 0 0 -0.3928 0.0869 34 1 3 391 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 392 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.1743 0.0395 54 91 74 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 -0.0018 0.0210 50 49 48 Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 -0.0237 0.0208 47 41 28 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0416 0.0220 47 36 25 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2693 0.0641 35 3 3 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.1739 0.0399 54 92 74 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 -0.0198 0.0212 50 42 48 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0371 0.0222 47 37 25 Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 -0.0497 0.0210 47 33 28 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2421 0.0647 35 3 3 393 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 394 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.2306 0.0467 44 96 14 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.1907 0.0469 52 93 62 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.1248 0.0156 51 85 59 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.1121 0.0134 55 83 78 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.1031 0.0162 56 81 84 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0841 0.0183 57 75 88 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0573 0.0300 47 69 27 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 0.0381 0.0589 39 62 5 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0374 0.0142 51 62 59 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0263 0.0154 47 40 27 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 -0.0456 0.0593 52 34 65 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0649 0.0545 54 29 74 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0853 0.0697 49 24 38 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.1048 0.0473 47 20 28 Rusk Middle School 0 0 -0.1222 0.0182 46 16 20 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.1426 0.0578 44 13 14 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.2628 0.0561 41 3 7 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.2868 0.0679 40 2 6 395 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.2590 0.0470 44 96 14 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 0.2020 0.0472 52 95 62 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.1351 0.0157 51 87 59 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.1272 0.0135 55 85 78 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.1110 0.0164 56 82 84 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0826 0.0184 57 76 88 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0647 0.0303 47 71 27 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 0.0601 0.0594 39 70 5 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0474 0.0143 51 66 59 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 -0.0031 0.0598 52 47 65 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0132 0.0156 47 44 27 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.0421 0.0550 54 35 74 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 -0.0601 0.0476 47 30 28 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.0846 0.0703 49 24 38 Rusk Middle School 0 0 -0.1195 0.0183 46 18 20 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.1360 0.0583 44 14 14 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.2391 0.0566 41 4 7 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.2597 0.0685 40 3 6 396 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Coweta School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 397 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile East Coweta Middle School 0 0 0.1365 0.0197 58 87 90 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.0886 0.0873 50 77 51 Arnall Middle School 0 0 0.0223 0.0180 52 58 60 Madras Middle School 0 0 0.0139 0.0165 49 54 38 Smokey Road Middle School 0 0 0.0110 0.0198 49 53 39 Lee Middle School 0 0 0.0010 0.0174 49 50 39 Evans Middle School 0 0 -0.0539 0.0193 45 32 20 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile East Coweta Middle School 0 0 0.1424 0.0198 58 88 90 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 0.1032 0.0881 50 81 51 Arnall Middle School 0 0 0.0374 0.0182 52 62 60 Lee Middle School 0 0 0.0269 0.0175 49 59 39 Madras Middle School 0 0 0.0225 0.0167 49 57 38 Smokey Road Middle School 0 0 0.0086 0.0199 49 53 39 Evans Middle School 0 0 -0.0526 0.0195 45 32 20 398 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional 399 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1006 0.0779 44 80 16 Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.0845 0.0430 55 75 81 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.0713 0.0310 64 73 98 DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.0554 0.0632 53 68 69 Henderson Middle School 0 0 0.0251 0.0140 51 59 54 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 0.0132 0.0182 56 54 85 Tucker Middle School 0 0 -0.0107 0.0156 53 46 70 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 -0.0133 0.0517 40 45 5 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0233 0.0176 50 41 51 International Student Center 0 0 -0.0272 0.0540 43 40 10 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0471 0.0173 51 33 53 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.0556 0.0181 53 31 70 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 -0.0671 0.0157 50 29 49 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.0695 0.0185 50 29 47 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 -0.0781 0.0183 46 27 22 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0809 0.0164 50 25 46 Redan Middle School 0 0 -0.0823 0.0198 51 25 52 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.0839 0.0176 49 25 42 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 -0.0894 0.0178 51 23 57 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 -0.1145 0.0184 48 18 33 Salem Middle School 0 0 -0.1573 0.0169 45 12 18 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 1 0 -0.1601 0.0507 41 12 6 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.1629 0.0189 45 11 17 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 -0.1643 0.0148 45 10 18 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 -0.1668 0.0367 46 10 23 400 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl DeKalb Academy of Technology and the McNair Middle School Cedar Grove Middle School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 1 0 -0.1849 0.0536 43 0 1 -0.1914 0.0341 40 0 0 -0.2005 0.0220 39 0 0 -0.2692 0.0185 36 0 0 -0.3140 0.0424 32 8 11 8 6 6 5 3 3 2 2 401 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Kittredge Magnet School 0 0 0.1489 0.0434 55 89 81 Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.1292 0.0786 44 86 16 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.0715 0.0312 64 73 98 DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.0695 0.0637 53 73 69 Henderson Middle School 0 0 0.0593 0.0141 51 69 54 International Student Center 0 0 0.0556 0.0541 43 67 10 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 0.0378 0.0184 56 63 85 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.0273 0.0522 40 59 5 Tucker Middle School 0 0 0.0100 0.0157 53 53 70 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0041 0.0178 50 47 51 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0265 0.0174 51 40 53 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 -0.0402 0.0184 46 35 22 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 -0.0416 0.0156 50 35 49 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.0548 0.0183 53 32 70 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.0668 0.0187 50 28 47 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 -0.0693 0.0180 51 27 57 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.0780 0.0177 49 25 42 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0814 0.0166 50 25 46 Redan Middle School 0 0 -0.0864 0.0200 51 24 52 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 -0.0992 0.0185 48 21 33 Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 1 0 -0.1088 0.0512 41 19 6 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 -0.1275 0.0149 45 16 18 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 -0.1281 0.0344 40 16 6 Leadership Preparatory Academy 0 1 -0.1344 0.0371 46 14 23 Salem Middle School 0 0 -0.1480 0.0171 45 12 18 402 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School McNair Middle School Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl Cedar Grove Middle School DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts 0 0 -0.1674 0.0190 45 0 0 -0.2010 0.0222 39 1 0 -0.2312 0.0541 43 0 0 -0.2579 0.0186 36 0 0 -0.2952 0.0428 32 9 17 6 5 4 11 3 3 2 2 403 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 404 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Amana Academy School 0 1 0.2305 0.0372 61 96 95 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.1295 0.0147 56 86 85 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.1209 0.0149 53 84 71 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.1105 0.0176 55 82 79 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 0.0608 0.0179 55 71 79 River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.0570 0.0142 54 69 77 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0474 0.0162 52 65 62 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 0.0382 0.0145 53 63 70 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0275 0.0196 51 59 59 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0256 0.0201 51 59 55 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 0.0005 0.0361 53 50 67 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0164 0.0223 51 44 57 KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 -0.0323 0.0341 58 39 90 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 -0.0370 0.0165 46 38 24 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 -0.0488 0.0147 47 32 27 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.0542 0.0173 46 32 23 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 -0.0544 0.0168 48 31 34 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 -0.0739 0.0186 46 28 24 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 -0.1017 0.0405 48 20 37 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.1044 0.0195 44 20 15 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.1266 0.0156 46 15 22 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.1389 0.0207 45 13 19 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.2005 0.0161 42 6 8 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.2192 0.0228 43 4 12 405 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Amana Academy School 0 1 0.2630 0.0376 61 97 95 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.1571 0.0150 53 90 71 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.1552 0.0148 56 90 85 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.1350 0.0177 55 87 79 River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.0842 0.0143 54 76 77 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0743 0.0163 52 74 62 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 0.0680 0.0146 53 72 70 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 0.0574 0.0181 55 68 79 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0466 0.0197 51 66 59 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0464 0.0202 51 66 55 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 0.0350 0.0364 53 61 67 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 -0.0102 0.0166 46 45 24 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 -0.0245 0.0149 47 41 27 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 -0.0328 0.0169 48 38 34 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0329 0.0224 51 38 57 KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 -0.0648 0.0344 58 29 90 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 -0.0657 0.0188 46 29 24 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.0678 0.0175 46 28 23 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 -0.1023 0.0409 48 21 37 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.1089 0.0196 44 19 15 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.1340 0.0157 46 15 22 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.1353 0.0209 45 14 19 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.1977 0.0163 42 6 8 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.1999 0.0230 43 6 12 406 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gwinnett Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional 407 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.2823 0.0138 58 97 90 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.2085 0.0168 59 95 93 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.1964 0.0180 58 94 91 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.1923 0.0146 57 93 86 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.1703 0.0150 55 91 82 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.1593 0.0148 58 90 91 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.1587 0.0171 57 90 88 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.1559 0.0133 55 90 79 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.1553 0.0164 56 89 84 Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.1369 0.0137 50 88 50 Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE 0 0 0.1334 0.1334 51 86 55 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.1332 0.0151 58 86 91 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.1213 0.0114 52 84 64 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.1134 0.0142 55 83 82 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.1077 0.0128 55 81 82 Louise Radloff Middle School 0 0 0.0977 0.0131 52 79 63 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0952 0.0122 53 78 68 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.0897 0.0164 53 77 70 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0844 0.0122 52 75 60 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.0753 0.0171 56 74 85 North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.0684 0.0120 52 72 63 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.0578 0.0137 54 69 75 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.0557 0.0172 54 68 75 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.0493 0.0134 52 66 60 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0411 0.0115 50 64 50 408 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Sweetwater Middle School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Pinckneyville Middle School New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0349 0.0127 51 61 58 0 0 0.0348 0.1219 38 61 4 0 0 0.0237 0.0152 50 58 48 0 0 -0.0389 0.0779 55 38 81 1 0 -0.0943 0.0314 44 22 13 0 0 -0.1669 0.0731 42 10 9 409 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.2683 0.0139 58 97 90 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.2002 0.0169 59 95 93 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.1876 0.0148 57 94 86 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.1852 0.0151 55 93 82 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.1833 0.0182 58 93 91 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.1525 0.0148 58 90 91 Berkmar Middle School 0 0 0.1499 0.0171 57 89 88 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.1450 0.0134 55 89 79 Hull Middle School 0 0 0.1432 0.0115 52 88 64 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.1395 0.0152 58 88 91 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.1374 0.0165 56 87 84 Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.1264 0.0138 50 85 50 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.1084 0.0142 55 82 82 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0966 0.0123 52 79 60 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0924 0.0129 55 78 82 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.0924 0.0166 53 78 70 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0921 0.0123 53 78 68 Louise Radloff Middle School 0 0 0.0898 0.0131 52 78 63 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.0772 0.0173 56 75 85 North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.0764 0.0121 52 75 63 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.0617 0.0137 54 70 75 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.0433 0.0135 52 65 60 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.0373 0.0173 54 62 75 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.0363 0.0116 50 62 50 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0327 0.0127 51 61 58 410 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Pinckneyville Middle School New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0258 0.0153 50 58 48 0 0 0.0006 0.0786 55 49 81 0 0 -0.0054 0.1346 51 46 55 0 0 -0.1221 0.1229 38 17 4 1 0 -0.1582 0.0317 44 10 13 0 0 -0.1750 0.0738 42 8 9 411 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 412 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Middle School 0 0 0.0421 0.0578 65 64 99 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0976 0.0484 47 21 30 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.1221 0.0237 50 16 47 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1608 0.0631 42 11 9 Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.1993 0.0387 42 7 8 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.2642 0.0432 32 3 2 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County Middle School 0 0 0.0038 0.0583 65 51 99 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.1080 0.0489 47 20 30 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.1443 0.0240 50 13 47 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1528 0.0637 42 11 9 Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.2359 0.0390 42 4 8 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.2711 0.0436 32 2 2 413 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 6, 7 and 8 Social Studies APS District Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Atlanta Heights School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 414 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.4332 0.0336 68 98 98 Brown Middle School 0 0 0.2742 0.0216 63 95 97 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.2706 0.0333 57 94 86 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.1302 0.0328 56 81 86 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0889 0.0176 49 71 52 Price Middle School 0 0 0.0535 0.0306 54 63 80 Kindezi 0 1 -0.0036 0.1087 58 48 90 Sutton Middle School 0 0 -0.0093 0.0143 48 47 42 Coan Middle School 0 0 -0.0183 0.0353 48 44 42 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.0216 0.0228 52 43 71 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0333 0.0261 51 40 62 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 -0.0414 0.0317 54 37 76 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.0435 0.0310 49 37 53 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0793 0.0293 49 29 48 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.0795 0.0214 42 28 20 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 -0.0893 0.0416 50 27 59 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0998 0.0231 49 26 47 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 -0.1570 0.0418 45 17 31 Hillside Conant School 0 0 -0.1746 0.1348 31 16 2 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.1948 0.0703 44 13 27 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.2093 0.0172 39 13 12 Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 -0.2346 0.0391 40 9 13 Long Middle School 0 0 -0.2368 0.0217 39 8 13 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.3863 0.0602 35 2 4 APS-Forrest Hills Academey 0 0 -0.4010 0.0909 26 2 1 415 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Atlanta Charter Middle School Heritage Preparatory Academy School 0 1 -0.4100 0.0350 35 2 5 1 0 -0.4908 0.0396 27 1 1 416 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [aps], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile KIPP West Atlanta Young Scholars Acad 0 1 0.4260 0.0339 68 98 98 Brown Middle School 0 0 0.2778 0.0218 63 95 97 Kipp Strive Academy 0 1 0.2540 0.0336 57 93 86 KIPP VISION 0 1 0.1241 0.0331 56 81 86 Inman Middle School 0 0 0.0916 0.0177 49 72 52 Price Middle School 0 0 0.0644 0.0309 54 65 80 Sutton Middle School 0 0 0.0109 0.0144 48 52 42 The Best Academy at Benjamin S. Carso 0 0 -0.0120 0.0313 49 46 53 Harper-Archer Middle School 0 0 -0.0244 0.0230 52 42 71 Coan Middle School 0 0 -0.0362 0.0357 48 39 42 King Middle School 0 0 -0.0372 0.0263 51 38 62 Kindezi 0 1 -0.0398 0.1098 58 37 90 Coretta Scott King Young Women's Acad 0 0 -0.0621 0.0320 54 32 76 Imagine Wesley International Academy 0 1 -0.0773 0.0420 50 29 59 Bunche Middle School 0 0 -0.0777 0.0216 42 29 20 Charles R. Drew Charter School 0 1 -0.0863 0.0296 49 27 48 Sylvan Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.1206 0.0233 49 21 47 Atlanta Heights Charter School 1 0 -0.1504 0.0422 45 18 31 Kennedy Middle School 0 0 -0.1863 0.0710 44 14 27 Young Middle School 0 0 -0.1914 0.0174 39 13 12 Long Middle School 0 0 -0.2285 0.0219 39 9 13 Latin Academy Charter School 0 1 -0.2372 0.0395 40 8 13 Hillside Conant School 0 0 -0.2427 0.1360 31 8 2 Intown Charter Academy 0 1 -0.3629 0.0608 35 3 4 Atlanta Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.4095 0.0353 35 2 5 417 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Heritage Preparatory Academy School APS-Forrest Hills Academey 1 0 -0.4490 0.0399 27 1 1 0 0 -0.5490 0.0917 26 1 1 418 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 419 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 0.0608 0.0210 55 66 82 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 0.0331 0.0213 48 57 42 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0136 0.0222 48 46 46 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0384 0.0399 52 39 70 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2460 0.0647 38 8 8 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Southeast Bulloch Middle School 0 0 0.0311 0.0212 55 57 82 Langston Chapel Middle School 0 0 0.0133 0.0215 48 52 42 William James Middle School 0 0 -0.0117 0.0224 48 46 46 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0360 0.0403 52 39 70 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2198 0.0653 38 11 8 420 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 421 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.3096 0.0471 45 96 32 Rusk Middle School 0 0 0.2933 0.0184 64 96 97 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.2624 0.0477 46 94 36 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.2577 0.0303 51 93 64 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.1473 0.0164 57 83 87 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.0851 0.0136 54 70 76 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0565 0.0185 55 64 84 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.0342 0.0599 63 57 96 Creekland Middle School 0 0 -0.0628 0.0144 50 33 58 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0640 0.0156 42 32 20 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0663 0.0157 49 32 54 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1203 0.0685 49 22 54 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1621 0.0595 34 16 3 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.2263 0.0570 43 10 23 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.2454 0.0473 44 8 26 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.2622 0.0704 51 7 64 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.2923 0.0584 42 5 20 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.3298 0.0551 48 4 43 422 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Holly Springs Elementary School 0 0 0.3301 0.0475 45 96 32 Rusk Middle School 0 0 0.3006 0.0185 64 96 97 Indian Knoll Elementary 0 0 0.2964 0.0481 46 95 36 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.2615 0.0306 51 94 64 Woodstock Middle School 0 0 0.1544 0.0166 57 84 87 Booth Middle School 0 0 0.1028 0.0137 54 75 76 Hickory Flat Elementary School 0 0 0.0689 0.0604 63 66 96 Teasley Middle School 0 0 0.0582 0.0186 55 63 84 Mill Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0519 0.0157 42 35 20 Creekland Middle School 0 0 -0.0539 0.0145 50 34 58 Freedom Middle School 0 0 -0.0563 0.0159 49 34 54 Ball Ground Elementary School 0 0 -0.1023 0.0692 49 24 54 Mountain Road Elementary School 0 0 -0.1516 0.0600 34 18 3 William G. Hasty, Sr. Elementary Scho 0 0 -0.2147 0.0575 43 11 23 J. Knox Elementary 0 0 -0.2445 0.0477 44 7 26 Clayton Elementary School 0 0 -0.2719 0.0710 51 6 64 R. M. Moore Elementary School 0 0 -0.2939 0.0589 42 5 20 Canton Elementary 0 0 -0.3165 0.0555 48 4 43 423 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Coweta Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Coweta State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Coweta State Charters Local Charters Traditional 424 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Madras Middle School 0 0 0.2220 0.0167 54 91 79 East Coweta Middle School 0 0 0.2184 0.0198 58 90 89 Arnall Middle School 0 0 0.0595 0.0183 52 65 72 Smokey Road Middle School 0 0 -0.0049 0.0200 45 48 33 Lee Middle School 0 0 -0.0951 0.0175 44 26 29 Evans Middle School 0 0 -0.1152 0.0196 43 23 23 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 -0.2374 0.0881 50 8 58 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [coweta], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Madras Middle School 0 0 0.2294 0.0169 54 92 79 East Coweta Middle School 0 0 0.2254 0.0200 58 91 89 Arnall Middle School 0 0 0.0746 0.0184 52 68 72 Smokey Road Middle School 0 0 -0.0061 0.0202 45 48 33 Lee Middle School 0 0 -0.0699 0.0177 44 31 29 Evans Middle School 0 0 -0.1132 0.0198 43 23 23 Coweta Charter Academy 1 0 -0.2296 0.0890 50 9 58 425 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix DeKalb Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. - Kirkwood School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. - Young Mens State Charters Local Charters Traditional 426 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.5505 0.0786 55 99 81 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.2526 0.0313 59 93 92 DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.2465 0.0638 71 92 99 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.1250 0.0522 52 80 70 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.0959 0.0177 53 74 73 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 0.0511 0.0160 48 62 43 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 0.0447 0.0185 50 60 61 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 0.0425 0.0183 51 60 63 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 0.0395 0.0150 48 59 41 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0226 0.0179 48 43 40 Tucker Middle School 0 0 -0.0404 0.0159 46 38 35 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0516 0.0166 49 36 50 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.0557 0.0191 47 35 39 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 -0.0629 0.0184 45 33 32 Henderson Middle School 0 0 -0.0649 0.0141 45 32 33 Redan Middle School 0 0 -0.0706 0.0199 47 31 38 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 -0.0737 0.0185 46 30 34 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.1076 0.0177 44 24 26 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 -0.1125 0.0541 35 24 4 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 -0.1424 0.0180 44 18 26 International Student Center 0 0 -0.1543 0.0532 36 17 5 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.1802 0.0187 40 15 15 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.1817 0.0222 41 15 16 Cedar Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.2169 0.0186 41 11 15 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 -0.2607 0.0344 36 7 6 427 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Leadership Preparatory Academy DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Salem Middle School Kittredge Magnet School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 0 1 -0.2690 0.0371 34 6 4 0 0 -0.2801 0.0429 34 5 4 0 0 -0.2922 0.0171 38 5 9 0 0 -0.3915 0.0435 31 2 2 1 0 -0.4151 0.0511 28 2 2 428 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [dekalb], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Museum School Avondale Estates 0 1 0.5724 0.0794 55 99 81 DeKalb School of the Arts 0 0 0.2708 0.0643 71 94 99 DeKalb PATH Academy Charter School 0 1 0.2494 0.0315 59 93 92 Wadsworth Magnet School for High Achi 0 0 0.1570 0.0527 52 85 70 Freedom Middle School 0 0 0.1059 0.0178 53 76 73 Chamblee Middle School 0 0 0.0798 0.0186 50 70 61 Peachtree Middle School 0 1 0.0717 0.0152 48 67 41 Sequoyah Middle School 0 0 0.0687 0.0159 48 66 43 Miller Grove Middle School 0 0 0.0486 0.0185 51 61 63 Druid Hills Middle School 0 0 -0.0065 0.0180 48 47 40 Tucker Middle School 0 0 -0.0214 0.0160 46 43 35 The Champion Middle Theme School 0 0 -0.0314 0.0186 45 40 32 Henderson Middle School 0 0 -0.0325 0.0143 45 39 33 Lithonia Middle School 0 0 -0.0478 0.0168 49 35 50 Chapel Hill Middle School 0 0 -0.0532 0.0187 46 34 34 Mary McLeod Bethune Middle School 0 0 -0.0590 0.0193 47 33 39 Redan Middle School 0 0 -0.0687 0.0201 47 31 38 Columbia Middle School 0 0 -0.0972 0.0179 44 25 26 Stephenson Middle School 0 0 -0.1171 0.0181 44 22 26 International Student Center 0 0 -0.1218 0.0533 36 21 5 Ivy Prep Academy at Kirkwood for Girl 1 0 -0.1469 0.0546 35 18 4 Stone Mountain Middle School 0 0 -0.1753 0.0188 40 15 15 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.1792 0.0225 41 15 16 DeKalb Academy of Technology and the 0 1 -0.1946 0.0347 36 13 6 Cedar Grove Middle School 0 0 -0.2001 0.0188 41 13 15 429 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Leadership Preparatory Academy DeKalb Elementary School of the Arts Salem Middle School Kittredge Magnet School Ivy Preparatory Young Men's Leadershi 0 1 -0.2287 0.0374 34 9 4 0 0 -0.2570 0.0433 34 7 4 0 0 -0.2791 0.0172 38 6 9 0 0 -0.3427 0.0438 31 3 2 1 0 -0.3562 0.0517 28 3 2 430 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 431 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 0.4632 0.0344 69 98 99 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.1991 0.0148 57 88 86 Amana Academy School 0 1 0.1460 0.0377 63 83 96 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.1203 0.0151 55 79 82 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.1177 0.0409 53 78 75 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.1011 0.0178 54 75 79 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 0.0917 0.0149 50 72 56 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0509 0.0164 51 62 66 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0318 0.0203 50 56 60 River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.0254 0.0143 48 55 45 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 -0.0189 0.0199 49 44 49 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 -0.0551 0.0147 48 35 42 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 -0.0612 0.0188 45 34 33 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.0736 0.0163 44 30 26 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0831 0.0225 45 28 33 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.0840 0.0175 45 28 32 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.1006 0.0158 45 25 31 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 -0.1188 0.0168 40 23 15 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 -0.1315 0.0170 41 20 16 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.1863 0.0181 42 14 19 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.2147 0.0211 38 11 10 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 -0.2396 0.0365 42 8 19 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.2760 0.0196 40 6 14 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.3306 0.0230 35 3 4 432 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile KIPP South Fulton Academy School 0 1 0.4349 0.0348 69 98 99 Webb Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.2198 0.0150 57 91 86 Amana Academy School 0 1 0.1739 0.0380 63 87 96 Hopewell Middle School 0 0 0.1526 0.0152 55 84 82 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.1234 0.0413 53 81 75 Crabapple Middle School 0 0 0.1209 0.0179 54 80 79 Northwestern Middle School 0 0 0.1115 0.0150 50 79 56 Elkins Pointe Middle School 0 0 0.0725 0.0165 51 68 66 Haynes Bridge Middle School 0 0 0.0489 0.0205 50 61 60 River Trail Middle School 0 0 0.0471 0.0145 48 60 45 Holcomb Bridge Middle School 0 0 -0.0030 0.0201 49 48 49 Autrey Mill Middle School 0 0 -0.0310 0.0148 48 40 42 Sandy Springs Middle School 0 0 -0.0541 0.0190 45 34 33 Sandtown Middle School 0 0 -0.0647 0.0164 44 32 26 Ridgeview Charter School 0 1 -0.0946 0.0169 40 25 15 Camp Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.0959 0.0227 45 25 33 Woodland Middle School 0 0 -0.0969 0.0177 45 25 32 Renaissance Middle School 0 0 -0.1043 0.0159 45 24 31 Taylor Road Middle School 0 0 -0.1150 0.0171 41 22 16 Bear Creek Middle School 0 0 -0.1853 0.0183 42 14 19 Main Street Charter Academy Middle 0 0 -0.1954 0.0368 42 13 19 Paul D. West Middle School 0 0 -0.2103 0.0213 38 12 10 McNair Middle School 0 0 -0.2779 0.0198 40 6 14 Hapeville Charter Middle School 0 1 -0.3012 0.0232 35 4 4 433 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gwinnett Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Ivy Prep. State Charters Local Charters Traditional 434 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.3980 0.0140 60 98 94 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.3212 0.0134 58 96 91 North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.3011 0.0122 58 96 91 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.2870 0.0152 61 95 94 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.2790 0.0166 56 95 85 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.2746 0.0173 59 95 93 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.2711 0.0152 58 95 91 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.2670 0.0170 56 94 85 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.2244 0.0148 56 91 85 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.2211 0.0116 55 91 81 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1924 0.0136 53 88 75 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.1717 0.0165 53 85 73 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.1584 0.0182 55 84 82 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.1294 0.0149 54 81 76 Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE 0 0 0.1264 0.1347 45 81 29 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.1203 0.0174 50 79 62 Louise Radloff Middle School 0 0 0.1186 0.0133 53 78 75 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0991 0.0130 51 75 62 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0920 0.0124 48 73 43 Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.0891 0.0139 48 72 41 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.0880 0.0139 51 71 65 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.0767 0.0154 49 69 50 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0627 0.0129 46 66 36 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.0590 0.0143 51 65 67 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0417 0.0123 47 60 39 435 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth Hull Middle School Berkmar Middle School Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente Gwinnett Online Campus 0 0 0.0374 0.0786 51 58 66 0 0 0.0292 0.0116 49 56 51 0 0 0.0238 0.0173 47 54 37 1 0 -0.0117 0.0318 39 46 11 0 0 -0.0622 0.1266 30 33 2 0 0 -0.2330 0.0738 38 9 9 436 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Twin Rivers Middle School 0 0 0.3832 0.0141 60 97 94 Frank N. Osborne Middle School 0 0 0.3076 0.0135 58 96 91 North Gwinnett Middle School 0 0 0.3061 0.0122 58 96 91 Alton C. Crews Middle School 0 0 0.3002 0.0153 61 95 94 Five Forks Middle School 0 0 0.2797 0.0168 56 95 85 Glenn C. Jones Middle School 0 0 0.2758 0.0154 58 95 91 Couch Middle School 0 0 0.2750 0.0175 59 95 93 Bay Creek Middle School 0 0 0.2599 0.0171 56 94 85 Lanier Middle School 0 0 0.2183 0.0149 56 91 85 Creekland Middle School 0 0 0.2155 0.0117 55 90 81 McConnell Middle School 0 0 0.1866 0.0137 53 88 75 Grace Snell Middle School 0 0 0.1562 0.0167 53 85 73 Snellville Middle School 0 0 0.1492 0.0184 55 84 82 Summerour Middle School 0 0 0.1218 0.0149 54 81 76 Louise Radloff Middle School 0 0 0.1114 0.0133 53 79 75 Moore Middle School 0 0 0.1019 0.0175 50 74 62 Lilburn Middle School 0 0 0.0890 0.0139 51 71 65 Duluth Middle School 0 0 0.0876 0.0124 48 71 43 Shiloh Middle School 0 0 0.0867 0.0131 51 71 62 Dacula Middle School 0 0 0.0786 0.0140 48 69 41 New Life Academy of Excellence Duluth 0 0 0.0779 0.0794 51 69 66 Pinckneyville Middle School 0 0 0.0768 0.0155 49 68 50 Sweetwater Middle School 0 0 0.0609 0.0129 46 64 36 Richards Middle School 0 0 0.0564 0.0144 51 63 67 Trickum Middle School 0 0 0.0527 0.0124 47 62 39 437 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Hull Middle School Berkmar Middle School Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE Ivy Preparatory Academy School Gwinnett Online Campus Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente 0 0 0.0487 0.0116 49 61 51 0 0 0.0165 0.0174 47 53 37 0 0 -0.0425 0.1360 45 37 29 1 0 -0.0678 0.0321 39 32 11 0 0 -0.2355 0.0745 38 8 9 0 0 -0.2361 0.1277 30 8 2 438 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 439 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.0104 0.0488 47 51 39 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.0387 0.0240 48 39 40 Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.0716 0.0391 46 30 35 Clay County Middle School 0 0 -0.1036 0.0583 37 25 7 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1246 0.0637 51 21 63 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.3059 0.0436 34 4 3 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0016 0.0493 47 49 39 Early County Middle School 0 0 -0.0590 0.0242 48 34 40 Randolph Clay Middle School 0 0 -0.1018 0.0395 46 24 35 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.1188 0.0643 51 22 63 Clay County Middle School 0 0 -0.1345 0.0589 37 20 7 Calhoun County Middle School 0 0 -0.3068 0.0441 34 4 3 440 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 9th Grade Literature Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) CCAT School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) CCAT School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 441 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.2471 0.0611 59 97 93 CCAT School 1 0 0.0928 0.1217 55 79 76 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.0620 0.0254 47 28 24 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 -0.1286 0.0348 42 11 7 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.2507 0.0622 59 96 93 CCAT School 1 0 0.1630 0.1243 55 92 76 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.1015 0.0259 47 17 24 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 -0.1718 0.0356 42 7 7 442 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 443 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile River Ridge High School 0 0 0.0863 0.0267 47 76 26 Sequoyah High School 0 0 0.0806 0.0248 47 75 24 Creekview High School 0 0 0.0760 0.0236 45 74 15 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0709 0.1070 44 73 12 Etowah High School 0 0 0.0345 0.0205 44 60 12 Woodstock High School 0 0 -0.0095 0.0221 44 47 12 Cherokee High School 0 0 -0.0212 0.0211 46 43 19 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Creekview High School 0 0 0.0861 0.0241 45 76 15 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0809 0.1093 44 75 12 Sequoyah High School 0 0 0.0781 0.0253 47 74 24 River Ridge High School 0 0 0.0776 0.0273 47 74 26 Etowah High School 0 0 0.0295 0.0210 44 59 12 Cherokee High School 0 0 -0.0096 0.0216 46 47 19 Woodstock High School 0 0 -0.0241 0.0225 44 42 12 444 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 445 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Chattahoochee High School 0 1 0.2908 0.0238 57 98 88 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.2808 0.0684 64 98 98 Alpharetta High School 0 0 0.2131 0.0240 56 96 85 Riverwood International Charter Schoo 0 0 0.2117 0.0287 59 96 92 Fulton Science Academy High School 0 1 0.2081 0.0900 58 96 90 Westlake High School 0 0 0.1496 0.0227 54 91 73 Johns Creek High School 0 0 0.1480 0.0238 52 90 61 Roswell High School 0 0 0.1297 0.0229 52 87 59 Milton High School 0 0 0.1204 0.0237 51 85 48 Northview High School 0 0 0.0969 0.0252 52 80 59 North Springs High School 0 1 0.0850 0.0272 50 76 44 Cambridge High School 0 0 0.0468 0.0236 49 66 42 Langston Hughes High School 0 0 0.0454 0.0235 51 65 50 McClarin Alternative School 0 0 0.0380 0.1150 49 63 41 Hapeville Charter Career Academy 0 1 0.0331 0.0373 49 60 41 Centennial High School 0 0 0.0138 0.0238 50 53 46 Creekside High School 0 0 -0.0288 0.0259 48 40 29 Tri-Cities High School 0 0 -0.0320 0.0254 50 39 45 Banneker High School 0 0 -0.0378 0.0279 49 38 42 446 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Chattahoochee High School 0 1 0.3025 0.0243 57 98 88 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.2424 0.0698 64 96 98 Alpharetta High School 0 0 0.2247 0.0246 56 96 85 Fulton Science Academy High School 0 1 0.2097 0.0921 58 95 90 Riverwood International Charter Schoo 0 0 0.2067 0.0292 59 94 92 Johns Creek High School 0 0 0.1702 0.0243 52 92 61 Westlake High School 0 0 0.1448 0.0232 54 88 73 Milton High School 0 0 0.1407 0.0242 51 87 48 Roswell High School 0 0 0.1317 0.0234 52 86 59 Northview High School 0 0 0.0978 0.0258 52 80 59 North Springs High School 0 1 0.0867 0.0278 50 77 44 Cambridge High School 0 0 0.0758 0.0241 49 73 42 Langston Hughes High School 0 0 0.0425 0.0240 51 64 50 Hapeville Charter Career Academy 0 1 0.0420 0.0382 49 64 41 McClarin Alternative School 0 0 0.0397 0.1176 49 62 41 Centennial High School 0 0 0.0172 0.0243 50 55 46 Creekside High School 0 0 -0.0422 0.0265 48 35 29 Tri-Cities High School 0 0 -0.0470 0.0259 50 34 45 Banneker High School 0 0 -0.0483 0.0285 49 33 42 447 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Gwinnett Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Ivy Prep. School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 448 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE 0 0 0.2919 0.1151 58 98 89 Peachtree Ridge High School 0 0 0.1390 0.0189 50 89 44 Parkview High School 0 0 0.1210 0.0193 51 85 52 Shiloh High School 0 0 0.1107 0.0221 51 83 48 Brookwood High School 0 0 0.0865 0.0186 48 77 31 Phoenix High School 0 0 0.0851 0.1096 42 76 8 Gwinnett School of Mathematics, Scien 0 1 0.0753 0.0307 49 74 40 North Gwinnett High School 0 0 0.0601 0.0200 49 70 43 Norcross High School 0 0 0.0599 0.0173 51 70 54 Mill Creek High School 0 0 0.0498 0.0164 48 67 32 Duluth High School 0 0 0.0479 0.0201 52 67 60 Grayson High School 0 0 0.0475 0.0198 47 66 25 Lanier High School 0 0 0.0461 0.0266 53 66 66 Collins Hill High School 0 0 0.0311 0.0189 47 60 25 Dacula High School 0 0 0.0206 0.0233 47 55 26 Central Gwinnett High School 0 0 0.0174 0.0205 48 55 32 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 1 0 -0.0013 0.1295 47 49 24 Meadowcreek High School 0 0 -0.0242 0.0176 49 41 39 Archer High School 0 0 -0.0489 0.0208 42 34 8 South Gwinnett High School 0 0 -0.0533 0.0210 45 33 17 Berkmar High School 0 0 -0.0754 0.0185 46 25 21 Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente 0 0 -0.1167 0.1296 42 14 7 Mountain View High School 0 0 -0.1753 0.0228 39 6 4 449 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [gwinnett], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Peachtree Ridge High School 0 0 0.1488 0.0192 50 88 44 Parkview High School 0 0 0.0997 0.0197 51 81 52 Shiloh High School 0 0 0.0864 0.0226 51 76 48 Brookwood High School 0 0 0.0782 0.0189 48 74 31 Gwinnett InterVention Education (GIVE 0 0 0.0686 0.1176 58 71 89 North Gwinnett High School 0 0 0.0607 0.0204 49 70 43 Gwinnett School of Mathematics, Scien 0 1 0.0572 0.0313 49 68 40 Mill Creek High School 0 0 0.0428 0.0167 48 64 32 Ivy Preparatory Academy School 1 0 0.0401 0.1323 47 62 24 Lanier High School 0 0 0.0339 0.0272 53 60 66 Grayson High School 0 0 0.0316 0.0202 47 59 25 Norcross High School 0 0 0.0297 0.0176 51 59 54 Duluth High School 0 0 0.0125 0.0204 52 54 60 Collins Hill High School 0 0 0.0120 0.0192 47 53 25 Dacula High School 0 0 -0.0054 0.0238 47 48 26 Central Gwinnett High School 0 0 -0.0295 0.0208 48 40 32 Archer High School 0 0 -0.0519 0.0213 42 31 8 Phoenix High School 0 0 -0.0532 0.1118 42 31 8 South Gwinnett High School 0 0 -0.0707 0.0215 45 26 17 Meadowcreek High School 0 0 -0.0999 0.0177 49 18 39 Berkmar High School 0 0 -0.1231 0.0186 46 13 21 Mountain View High School 0 0 -0.2064 0.0233 39 6 4 Gwinnett Intervention Education Cente 0 0 -0.3642 0.1323 42 1 7 450 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 451 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Clay County 9th Grade Academy School 0 0 0.4370 0.1261 74 99 99 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.3380 0.0902 68 99 99 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.1294 0.1183 40 87 5 Calhoun County High School 0 0 0.1036 0.0773 40 82 5 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 -0.0461 0.0579 53 35 67 Early County High School 0 0 -0.1374 0.0384 39 10 3 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.3717 0.0921 68 99 99 Clay County 9th Grade Academy School 0 0 0.3540 0.1281 74 99 99 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.1600 0.1208 40 91 5 Calhoun County High School 0 0 0.0456 0.0791 40 66 5 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 -0.0570 0.0592 53 30 67 Early County High School 0 0 -0.1460 0.0393 39 10 3 452 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Analytic Geometry Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 453 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.2732 0.0772 57 88 84 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 0.1315 0.0362 54 76 74 Statesboro High School 0 0 0.0521 0.0298 45 63 33 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2954 0.1381 36 5 6 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.2110 0.0791 57 85 84 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 0.0686 0.0370 54 66 74 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.0013 0.0306 45 52 33 CCAT School 1 0 -0.2469 0.1415 36 12 6 454 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 455 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.3292 0.1337 78 92 99 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.2466 0.1227 56 87 81 Calhoun County High School 0 0 0.0344 0.0722 47 60 43 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 -0.1360 0.0611 40 27 15 Early County High School 0 0 -0.2741 0.0487 32 7 2 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.3199 0.1370 78 91 99 Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.2711 0.1257 56 88 81 Calhoun County High School 0 0 -0.0520 0.0739 47 42 43 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 -0.1866 0.0625 40 21 15 Early County High School 0 0 -0.2763 0.0499 32 8 2 456 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Biology Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) CCAT School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) CCAT School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 457 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.0036 0.0709 44 54 47 CCAT School 1 0 -0.0584 0.1278 56 40 84 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 -0.1910 0.0343 41 15 34 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.3970 0.1115 36 1 17 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile CCAT School 1 0 0.0451 0.1294 56 62 84 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0180 0.0718 44 50 47 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 -0.2262 0.0347 41 11 34 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.4586 0.1130 36 1 17 458 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Cherokee State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Cherokee State Charters Local Charters Traditional 459 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Sequoyah High School 0 0 0.5892 0.0274 72 99 99 River Ridge High School 0 0 0.2824 0.0271 51 93 74 Etowah High School 0 0 0.1247 0.0233 46 77 55 Creekview High School 0 0 0.1137 0.0241 41 73 35 Cherokee High School 0 0 -0.0377 0.0221 40 45 28 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0442 0.1090 41 44 36 Woodstock High School 0 0 -0.0452 0.0249 36 43 18 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Sequoyah High School 0 0 0.6062 0.0278 72 99 99 River Ridge High School 0 0 0.2898 0.0274 51 93 74 Etowah High School 0 0 0.1429 0.0236 46 77 55 Creekview High School 0 0 0.1424 0.0243 41 77 35 Cherokee High School 0 0 -0.0218 0.0223 40 49 28 Woodstock High School 0 0 -0.0368 0.0252 36 44 18 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 -0.0458 0.1104 41 42 36 460 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Coordinate Algebra Cherokee Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Cherokee School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 461 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Sequoyah High School 0 0 0.2628 0.0257 65 93 94 Etowah High School 0 0 0.2235 0.0207 62 89 91 River Ridge High School 0 0 0.1890 0.0275 61 86 88 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0835 0.1249 60 72 86 Woodstock High School 0 0 0.0319 0.0232 52 63 60 Creekview High School 0 0 -0.0844 0.0234 43 31 21 Cherokee High School 0 0 -0.0921 0.0222 45 28 28 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [cherokee], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Sequoyah High School 0 0 0.2581 0.0263 65 93 94 Etowah High School 0 0 0.2325 0.0211 62 90 91 River Ridge High School 0 0 0.1822 0.0281 61 85 88 Cherokee Charter Academy 1 0 0.0309 0.1276 60 63 86 Woodstock High School 0 0 0.0299 0.0237 52 62 60 Creekview High School 0 0 -0.0688 0.0239 43 36 21 Cherokee High School 0 0 -0.0824 0.0227 45 33 28 462 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 463 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Northview High School 0 0 0.4895 0.0276 70 99 98 Chattahoochee High School 0 1 0.4229 0.0243 71 98 99 Johns Creek High School 0 0 0.4210 0.0255 68 98 97 Roswell High School 0 0 0.3626 0.0231 70 97 99 Milton High School 0 0 0.3461 0.0249 70 96 98 Cambridge High School 0 0 0.2375 0.0248 63 92 92 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.2209 0.0660 50 89 53 Fulton Science Academy High School 0 1 0.2173 0.0898 56 89 76 Alpharetta High School 0 0 0.2162 0.0253 59 88 85 Riverwood International Charter Schoo 0 0 0.0543 0.0263 54 69 69 Westlake High School 0 0 0.0347 0.0220 49 64 48 Centennial High School 0 0 -0.0082 0.0244 53 54 66 Creekside High School 0 0 -0.0235 0.0250 50 51 52 Banneker High School 0 0 -0.0697 0.0267 48 36 40 Tri-Cities High School 0 0 -0.1134 0.0251 47 23 35 North Springs High School 0 1 -0.1282 0.0276 46 18 33 Langston Hughes High School 0 0 -0.1580 0.0218 40 12 12 Hapeville Charter Career Academy 0 1 -0.2456 0.0339 32 6 2 464 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Northview High School 0 0 0.5434 0.0282 70 99 98 Johns Creek High School 0 0 0.4996 0.0260 68 98 97 Chattahoochee High School 0 1 0.4875 0.0248 71 98 99 Roswell High School 0 0 0.3871 0.0236 70 97 99 Milton High School 0 0 0.3851 0.0254 70 97 98 Cambridge High School 0 0 0.2779 0.0253 63 95 92 Alpharetta High School 0 0 0.2577 0.0258 59 93 85 Fulton Science Academy High School 0 1 0.2148 0.0918 56 88 76 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.2053 0.0673 50 87 53 Riverwood International Charter Schoo 0 0 0.0897 0.0268 54 74 69 Centennial High School 0 0 0.0291 0.0250 53 61 66 Westlake High School 0 0 0.0222 0.0225 49 59 48 Creekside High School 0 0 -0.0191 0.0255 50 51 52 Banneker High School 0 0 -0.0727 0.0273 48 36 40 North Springs High School 0 1 -0.0992 0.0282 46 27 33 Tri-Cities High School 0 0 -0.1093 0.0256 47 24 35 Langston Hughes High School 0 0 -0.1531 0.0223 40 14 12 Hapeville Charter Career Academy 0 1 -0.2343 0.0347 32 6 2 465 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 466 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.2872 0.1141 56 94 76 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.1313 0.1249 66 80 96 Clay County 9th Grade Academy School 0 0 0.1247 0.1218 59 79 83 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 0.0226 0.0538 50 60 50 Calhoun County High School 0 0 -0.0462 0.0698 33 43 3 Early County High School 0 0 -0.0723 0.0374 39 35 9 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Baker County K12 School 0 0 0.2805 0.1165 56 95 76 Clay County 9th Grade Academy School 0 0 0.1489 0.1236 59 81 83 Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.0713 0.1276 66 71 96 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 -0.0004 0.0550 50 55 50 Early County High School 0 0 -0.0650 0.0382 39 38 9 Calhoun County High School 0 0 -0.0866 0.0714 33 31 3 467 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 Physical Science Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 468 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 0.1023 0.0387 58 74 86 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0010 0.0625 51 52 63 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.0193 0.0201 46 48 38 CCAT School 1 0 -0.3439 0.1075 27 3 1 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 0.0768 0.0392 58 68 86 Portal Middle/High School 0 0 -0.0184 0.0635 51 49 63 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.0412 0.0203 46 44 38 CCAT School 1 0 -0.3061 0.1091 27 5 1 469 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Fulton Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Fulton Leadership School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 470 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Chattahoochee High School 0 1 0.2481 0.0459 55 89 79 Northview High School 0 0 0.2419 0.0390 59 89 90 Cambridge High School 0 0 0.2249 0.0418 59 87 88 Johns Creek High School 0 0 0.2151 0.0467 59 86 89 Milton High School 0 0 0.1658 0.0326 46 80 40 Riverwood International Charter Schoo 0 0 0.1148 0.0404 55 76 78 Westlake High School 0 0 0.1095 0.0288 56 75 83 Roswell High School 0 0 0.0455 0.0385 52 62 66 Independence Alternative School 0 0 0.0334 0.1014 58 60 86 McClarin Alternative School 0 0 -0.0127 0.0753 51 49 65 Banneker High School 0 0 -0.0371 0.0332 49 44 53 Centennial High School 0 0 -0.0513 0.0330 48 40 49 Tri-Cities High School 0 0 -0.0518 0.0296 48 40 49 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 -0.0534 0.0717 49 40 56 Alpharetta High School 0 0 -0.0988 0.0424 47 32 44 Creekside High School 0 0 -0.1504 0.0319 38 25 13 North Springs High School 0 1 -0.1621 0.0752 41 23 20 Langston Hughes High School 0 0 -0.1977 0.0290 40 17 18 Hapeville Charter Career Academy 0 1 -0.2842 0.0317 37 6 12 471 Georgia Commission Chartered Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [fulton], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Chattahoochee High School 0 1 0.2820 0.0466 55 91 79 Northview High School 0 0 0.2710 0.0395 59 90 90 Cambridge High School 0 0 0.2532 0.0423 59 89 88 Johns Creek High School 0 0 0.2329 0.0473 59 88 89 Milton High School 0 0 0.1934 0.0330 46 84 40 Riverwood International Charter Schoo 0 0 0.1365 0.0408 55 75 78 Westlake High School 0 0 0.1204 0.0292 56 74 83 Roswell High School 0 0 0.0565 0.0390 52 65 66 Independence Alternative School 0 0 0.0339 0.1028 58 60 86 Fulton Leadership Academy 1 0 0.0067 0.0727 49 54 56 Centennial High School 0 0 -0.0382 0.0333 48 46 49 Tri-Cities High School 0 0 -0.0409 0.0300 48 45 49 Banneker High School 0 0 -0.0449 0.0336 49 43 53 McClarin Alternative School 0 0 -0.0479 0.0764 51 42 65 Alpharetta High School 0 0 -0.0868 0.0430 47 35 44 North Springs High School 0 1 -0.1379 0.0763 41 27 20 Creekside High School 0 0 -0.1424 0.0324 38 27 13 Langston Hughes High School 0 0 -0.1804 0.0294 40 19 18 Hapeville Charter Career Academy 0 1 -0.2303 0.0320 37 12 12 472 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Baker Calhoun, Clay, Early and Randolph (BCCER) Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) Pataula School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 State Charters Local Charters Traditional 473 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.5183 0.0945 65 98 95 Clay County 9th Grade Academy School 0 0 0.0998 0.1337 61 73 93 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 0.0177 0.0602 58 56 88 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.0187 0.1242 32 48 4 Calhoun County High School 0 0 -0.2064 0.0761 29 16 3 Early County High School 0 0 -0.2540 0.0405 36 9 9 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bccer], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Pataula Charter Academy 1 0 0.5251 0.0960 65 98 95 Clay County 9th Grade Academy School 0 0 0.0676 0.1335 61 66 93 Randolph Clay High School 0 0 0.0012 0.0610 58 53 88 Baker County K12 School 0 0 -0.0470 0.1259 32 43 4 Calhoun County High School 0 0 -0.2468 0.0771 29 10 3 Early County High School 0 0 -0.2484 0.0408 36 9 9 474 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Schools Serving Grades 9 through 12 U.S. History Bulloch Value-Added School Effects Without Race/Ethnicity School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional Value-Added School Effects With Lagged Scores Only School Value-Added Estimate with 95% Confidence Intervals (Mean Effect Across All Georgia Public Schools = 0) School FE in Std. Dev. Units -.7 -.6 -.5 -.4 -.3 -.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 CCAT State Charters Local Charters Traditional 475 Georgia State Charter Schools Evaluation, 2013-2014 Technical Appendix Estimated School Effects - Without Race/Ethnicity, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch] School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.1354 0.0869 49 70 60 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 -0.0484 0.0444 38 46 28 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.1953 0.0339 30 21 11 CCAT School 1 0 -0.4877 0.1158 22 3 3 Estimated School Effects - Lagged Scores Only, Mean SGPs and Statewide Percentile Ranks [bulloch], All Controls School Name State Local School School School School Mean SGP Charter Charter Effect Effect Mean Effect State State Rank Standard Student Rank Percentile Error Growth Percentile Percentile Portal Middle/High School 0 0 0.1232 0.0886 49 68 60 New Southeast Bulloch High School 0 0 -0.0535 0.0452 38 44 28 Statesboro High School 0 0 -0.2094 0.0346 30 20 11 CCAT School 1 0 -0.4555 0.1181 22 5 3 476