For tomorrow volume II: comprehensive statewide planning for vocational rehabilitation services in the state of Georgia, 1968

VOLUME II TABLE OF CONTENTS
FOREWORD SUMMARY OF BOTH VOLUMES TABLE OF CONTENTS TASK FORCE REPORTS
Case finding Evaluation, Treatment and/or Training Occupational Placement and Follow-Up Internal Structure and Organization Interagency Cooperation and Coordination Manpower Needs and Potential STAFF CONDUCTED RESEARCH Community Involvement: A Pilot Project A Pilot Project Determining the Effectiveness of a Film for Orienting New VR Clients

Page
i
iii
1
3 23 99 167
2~
343
451
487

J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J

FOREWORD This, the second volume of the Statewide Vocational Rehabilitation Planning Project's Final Report, reflects the diligence of many individuals and groups as they worked to determine the needs of vocational rehabilitation in Georgia. The reports embodied in this volume are the results of meetings, contracted research, surveying designated segments of the citizenry, field studies and other activities too numerous to specify. Volume One attempts to gather the most important points of each of these activities and place their context into a meaningful light in terms of implementing the recommendations that would contribute to the fruition of our task: ... so that by July 1, 1975, or sooner, vocational rehabilitation services will be available to all handicapped individuals in the State. One can readily see after reading the following summary, as it appears in Volume One, that for full appreciation of the two-year study it is necessary to examine both volumes of this document. This is especially important in connection with the recommendations and means of implementing those recommendations which were a result of this study.
i

SUMMARY
The final report of Statewide Planning is divided into two volumes. Volume One is subdivided into five Chapters as follows: Chapter I, Introduction; Chapter II, The Planning Organization; Chapter III, Method of Operation; Chapter IV, Findings and Recommendations; and Chapter V, The Composite Working Plan. Volume II contains supporting information and data including task force research reports and reports of pilot projects necessary in the development of Volume I.
The first Chapter of Volume I contains three major sections: Background, Purpose, and Scope. Under Background, a sketch of the progress of the Georgia Agency over the past decade is given. This includes the tremendous strides in expanding services and facilities for the rehabilitation of disabled people. Highlighted are the significant advances made in the rehabilitation of the mentally ill and the mentally retarded. Note is also made of the fact that Georgia's old agricultural economy is giving way to industry. The Purpose of the Planning Effort is to chart the orderly development of services and resources, both public and non-profit private, so that by July 1, 1975, or sooner, vocational rehabilitation services will be available to all handicapped individuals in the State. The Scope of the Planning Project included a study of not only services provided by the Office of Vocational Rehabilitation, but also the services provided by other governmental agencies at the local, state, and national level, and the services made available through private, non-profit organizations.
Chapter II, The Planning Organization, describes the mechanics of the division of labor and specifies who was responsible for which portion of the overall task. An outline of the Chapter follows:
iii

A. Designated Organization

G. Organizational Chart

The organization designated by the Governor as responsible for statewide planning was the Office of Vocational Rehabilitation of the State Department of Education.
B. Policy Board
This section contains a list of names and affiliations of the members as well as the method of appointment, size, and a description of the functions of the Board. This board was established for the purpose of providing leadership, general guidance, and stimulation necessary for this planning effort.
C. Statewide Advisory Committee
This section contains a list of names and affiliations of the members as well as the method of appointment, size, and a description of the functions of the Committee, The Advisory Committee performed a rather unique role. Not only did they act in an advisory and consulting capacity to the Policy Board and Planning Staff, but individually and collectively played a major part in the actual formulation and implementation of the recommendations resulting from this planning effort.
D. Task Forces
This section describes the area of responsibility of the seven task forces and a list of the names and affiliations of task force members.
E. Subcontractors
Certain data and information was necessary which the Staff or the Task Forces could not feasibly produce; therefore, contracts were let to various specialized organizations to furnish this material. This section briefly describes each contract.
F. The Staff
In this section the influence of staff turnover is discussed in relation to periodic reorganization and redirection of project activities.

This Chapter is concluded with a chart specifying the organizational structure of the entire planning effort.
Chapter III, Method of Operation, describes the operational procedures in detail. The two-year interval of the Statewide Planning Project was divided into four phases by category of function. A flow chart (Chart , page ) contains an outline of the activities in these four phases and the relationship between them and the various categorical functions. This chart reflects that activities in three categories, organization, research, and pilot projects, were being pursued simultaneously throughout all four phases. This chart reflects the fact that the fruits of the planning effort were to be contained in the task force reports. The major portion of the research and data collection was done for the purpose of providing the task forces with basic information about the problem in terms of the number of handicapped to be served in terms of the quality of services to be provided and effective methods for providing these services.
Chapter IV, Findings and Recommendations, is divided into three basic sections: (1) Contracted research, (2) Research conducted by Project Staff, and (3) Task Force reports.
There were four areas of research contracted as follows:
1. Population Estimates and Projections. Doctors John Belcher and James D. Tarver, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Georgia, were contracted to provide an estimate of Georgia's population by county, age, sex, and race. They listed two specific objectives of this study: (a) To prepare July 1, 1965 population estimates for Georgia's 159 counties by sex and race for sixteen age classifications, and (b) To prepare 1970 and 1975 population projections for Georgia's 159 counties by sex and race for sixteen age classifications.
The results of these statistics were presented as a monograph with one page for each of Georgia's 159 counties. Figure 1, page , and Figure 2, page , show the population changes from 1965 to 1975 for each county and for each district of the Office of Vocational Rehabilitation.

iv

2. Estimates of Disability in the State of Georgia. Doctor Thomas Porter, Coordinator, Rehabilitation Counselor Training Program, University of Georgia, accepted the contract to study the incidence of disability in Georgia. The purpose of this study was to compile and assimilate data showing the present number of people with physical and emotional impairments. Due to costs in both time and money it was necessary to rely on data already in existence.
Excluding school-age children, the aged, and Welfare and Social Security beneficiaries, this study shows that persons in the designated disability grouping comprise 30.6% of Georgia's total population. Because this data consists mainly of persons who receive assistance and does not include all those who could qualify, these estimates and projections are, in the most instances, considered low.
3. A Follow-up Study of 151 Former OVR Clients Closed in Three Categories. Doctor Fred H. Wright, Georgia State College, was commissioned to conduct a follow-up study of former Vocational Rehabilitation clients closed in three classifications.

In addition to contracted studies discussed above, the staff carried out the following research:
1. A Pilot Project Determining the Effectiveness of a Film for Orienting New VR Clients. A film was produced about Vocational Rehabilitation services which might be used in a client orientation program. A basic assumption was that those clients who see an orientation film about Vocational Rehabilitation will have a better understanding of the rehabilitation process.
A research design was developed to evaluate the effectiveness of this film. The results of this pilot project in terms of client orientation through a film indicate needs in several areas. These can be summarized in the following observations:
a. This study and others prove that clients can learn from such a method of instructions, and, indeed, a better understanding of the rehabilitation process would seem to increase his personal esteem as a member of society.

The objectives of this study were to discover from the client's point of view existing practices of Vocational Rehabilitation in terms of characteristics of the population served, services rendered, status of the client at the time of the survey, relative satisfaction with services, client's perceptions and attitudes toward Vocational Rehabilitation, and recommendations for improvement. It was hoped that the study would shed light on practices typical of Vocational Rehabilitation which may militate against successful rehabilitation.
The following is a summary of recommendations from this study:
a. Re-evaluate the image which VR wishes to portray to the public, both clients and non-clients.
b. Based on the re-evaluation, create and initiate a publicity program to inform the public of VR.
c. Study in depth the factors which caused the latency in case reporting as shown in this study and initiate within the system controls for preventing its recurrence.

b. By standardizing what a client learns about Vocational Rehabilitation at his first contact, there should be less misunderstanding about what services are available, who provides them, and who is eligible for them.
c. This tool appears to be the best method for use with clients covering a wide range of educational background.
d. Implementation of this method of client orientation would not consume an extreme amount of space nor time.
e. The weaknesses in the film are in the process of being corrected.
2. Community Involvement: A Pilot Project. The Planning Project established a Technical Force composed of volunteers with experience in community-wide activities, as well as interest in vocational rehabilitation, to investigate the feasibility and means of attaining an involvement on the grass roots level in the rehabilitation program.

v

For this project, a community was defined as a county. This decision was made because records of schools, disabilities, hospitals, etc., are kept on a county level.

In order to categorically clarify the re:o~endations ~or the purpose of placing pr1or1ty on the 1mplementation presented in Chapter V, the recommendations have been grouped according to logically related functions.

The Technical Force decided upon basic steps which would lead to the ultimate goal of involvement. Members of the local vocational rehabilitation offices were to be asked to enlist the support of various leaders in community life to act as an advisory group in establishing an involvement program. Although the Technical Force would create a format that would possibly be used to initiate a program of community involvement, it was agreed that the Advisory group would have to decide: (1) Whether or not it was felt that such a program was, in fact, wanted, and (2) the actual means by which a program could be established and perpetuated if it was decided it would be worthwhile. To be a meaningful program on a community level, the Technical Force felt it was necessary that an organization within the community should be approached to establish, and maintain an involvement program within its boundaries. The Advisory group (after agreeing on the importance of this program) would suggest such a group to be approached with the request that they take the vocational rehabilitation community involvement program as a continuing project.
Although the Technical Force realized failures and disillusionment in the Pilot Study of two Georgia counties for Community Involvement, it is emphasized that these shortcomings ~ be observed objectively for actual implementation of a realistic program for the remaining counties. Every community will have its own pitfalls; the preceding narrative was recorded so that further planning in this area can take into account basic errors which can be avoided. The conviction of the Planning Project and the steadfastness of the Technical Force remain unchanged: community involvement is a vital part in the total vocational rehabilitation program.
Summaries of the recommendations from the task forces are also contained in this chapter. The combined summaries and recommendations will be discussed in the summary of Chapter V that follows.

The fact that the Governor designated the OVR to carry out the Statewide Planning establishes expectations in the high levels of government that this Agency will offer leadership in developing sound rehabilitation programs. Accepting this responsibility, a specialized Task Force was organized to evaluate the effectiveness of the present organizational structure of the OVR. Based on this study, the Planning Staff concludes that reorganization is vital.
The reorganizing of the structure of the key agency offering the widest range of rehabilitation services must receive first priority since the implementation of the other recommendations is contingent on such a workable organizational structure.
The spirit of the federal planning guidelines requires that there be no duplication of rehabilitation effort in the state. In order to utilize this principle in the provision of quality services, it is imperative that the implementation of Interagency Cooperation recommendations be given subsequent priority to the reorganization of the OVR.
Concurrent and in conjunction with the activation of the plan for Interagency Cooperation would be the implementation of the recommendations contained under the category of Rehabilitation Services and Facilities. Initial efforts to effectuate the Interagency recommendations should, in fact, lay a firm foundation for supporting cooperative efforts in the establishment of these facilities and services.
In view of the fact that all of the Task Forces either implicitly or explicitly emphasized the importance of public awareness, it was obvious that this category of recommendations should be highlighted, even though the element of public awareness is intertwined among all the recommendations. Not only does this establish priority, it gives an opportunity to exemplify the activity of actual implementation of this study and the OVR specifically.
vi

STATEWIDE VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION PLANNING PROJECT
Vernon L. Vinson Project Coordinator
William M. Holbert, Ph.D. Consultant
Miss Karen Butler Research Associate
Charles Long Information Officer
Mrs. Allowee Hatcher Stenographer
Mrs. Audrey Powell Typist
Miss Theresa Anglin Typist

REPORT OF THE TASK FORCE ON CASEFINDING
Statewide Vocational Rehabilitation Planning Project

CASEFINDING
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Background and Problem .................................... 6
Basic Data ........................................ 7 Discussion ........................................................ 20 Summary and Recommendations ..................... 21

6 The basic problem of the task force on
casefinding becomes one of developing procedures that will bring these unknown individuals in need of vocational rehabilitation services in contact with a vocational rehabilitation counselor.

BACKGROUND AND PROBLEM
Casefinding is an old, recognized responsibility of the rehabilitation counselor. It is only meagerly treated in most orientation and training programs for counselors, and almost totally neglected as an area of research.
The prime goal of this planning effort is to provide, by 1975 or before, vocational rehabilitation services to all citizens of the State of Georgia who are in need of and could or would benefit from such services. The Rehabilitation Services Administration (formerly Vocational Rehabilitation) estimated a few years ago that there were 3.7 million impaired individuals in this country who are in need of and could benefit from rehabilitation services. They also estimated that there were approximately 500 thousand additional individuals acquiring impairments each year who could benefit from such services. Assuming that Georgia has its proportionate percentage of these individuals, there are now approximately 66,000 people who are in need of services in this State and an additional 10,000 becoming disabled each year. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1967, Georgia rehabilitated 8,750 individuals. The present program is losing ground each year with the backlog growing larger.
Based upon the above information, we will assume that:
1. There is a problem in casefinding-there are "invisible" people who can benefit from rehabilitation services.
2. There are sufficient procedural gaps to warrant planning.
3. There are basic principles of referral that can be developed and practiced.

In order to realistically make recommendations on the development of procedures that will bring these unknown individuals in need of vocational rehabilitation services in contact with a rehabilitation counselor, the committee felt that it needed some basic data regarding the present referral procedures. Dr. Benjamin Wyckoff, Director of the Research Unit, was asked to prepare the following information:
1. Which disability category results in the number of individuals closed "too severe?"
2. Which disability category(ies) yield greatest number rehabilitated?
3. Which referral source(s) produce the greatest number who are accepted for servcies?
4. To what extent are individuals evaluated before closing them as "too severe?"
5. Is there a difference in the percentage of males accepted for services as opposed to females?
6. Is there a relationship between time in referral or applicant status and number accepted for services?
7. What is the relationship of money spent on evaluation between those accepted and closed "too severe?"
8. Is there a relationship between age and those accepted for services and those closed "too severe?"
9. Which referral sources have we saturated; that is, sources that are giving us all the referrals we could expect from them? Which referral sources are not saturated and would indicate they should be saturated further?
10. Is there a tendency for physicians to refer physical restoration cases only? Do educators and welfare workers tend to refer training cases only?

11. When rehabilitation counselors reject referrals, are they in turn, referred to a more appropriate resource?
12. Are clients being served in accordance with geographical distributions of disability categories? For example, if we are fairly sure that tuberculosis is evenly distributed over the State's population, do counselors' caseloads indicate that they are serving most of the clients in this disability category?
Dr. Wyckoff was able to give us information on the first eight of the above items from data processing; however, he did not have sufficient records to supply information on items nine through twelve.

Among the 10,837 cases closed referred, 1,616 indicated "disability too severe" as a reason for closure. This section is concerned primarily with these 1,616 cases. Data from the 10,248 cases who were accepted for services were obtained essentially as a basis of comparison. These included cases closed rehabilitated as well as cases closed otherwise, but all were accepted for services, and then closed during the year in question. The characteristics summarized in this section include the disability as reported, the referral source, sex, the number of months in referred status and expenditures for diagnosis for these clients. Table I gives the number of clients in each disability category. Disabilities are also grouped into four major groupings.

BASIC DATA
This portion of the report was prepared by Dr. Wyckoff, based upon the first eight of the above listed items.
The data presented in this section were obtained by scanning closure records (R-300) for 10,837 clients closed referred and 10,248 clients who were accepted for services and whose cases were closed during the fiscal year ending June, 1967.

Using the number of cases accepted as a basis of comparison, we note that disabilities in the communications group contribute a proportionately small number of cases closed as "too severe." Orthopedic and mental disabilities contribute a relatively high proportion of cases closed as "too severe", while internal and other disabilities, taken as a group, show a slightly lower proportion.
An exceptionally high rate of rejection may also be noted for certain specific disabilities. These include impairment of three or more limbs or entire body, one upper and one lower limb (including side), other and ill-defined orthopedic impairments, psychotic disorders, epilepsy, cardiac and circulatory conditions and respiratory diseases. Cardiac and circulatory conditions represent the highest single category of "Cases Closed Too Severe." The proportion of cases considered "too severe" in this category was also high with one case being rejected for each two cases that were accepted.

Exceptionally low rates of rejection as "too severe" are seen in the case of blindness in one eye, speech impairments and disorders of the digestive and genitourinary systems. Table I also breaks the 8,750 closed rehabilitated during the fiscal year ending June, 1967 into category percentages.

8
TABLE I FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTIONS OF DIFFERENT DISABILITY GROUPINGS OF CASES CLOSED REFERRED DUE TO SEVERITY OF HANDICAP AND CLOSED REHABILITATED

DISABILITY

CLOSED "TOO SEVERE" NUMBER ACCEPTED REHABILITATED

Connnunications:

Blindness, both eyes, no light

6

65

perception

Blindness, both eyes (with correction

37

318

not more than 20,200 in better eye,

or limitation in field within 20

degrees, but not VR 10)

Blindness, one eye, other eye defective

4

92

Blindness, one eye, other eye good

6

220

Other visual impairments

22

260

Deafness, unable to talk

4

32

Deafness, able to talk

8

111

Other hearing impairments

10

194

Speech impairments

2

72

Total Communications:

99

1,364

1,190

Percent of Communications of Total of All Disabilities

6.2%

13.4%

13.6%

Orthopedic:

Three or more limbs or entire body

47

One upper and one lower limb

44

(incl. side)

One or both upper limbs

35

One or both lower limbs

114

Other and ill-defined impairments

132

Amputation involving:

One upper and one lower major

1

extremity

Both major upper extremities

1

One major upper extremity

6

One or both major lower extremities

21

Other and unspecified parts

1

Total Orthopedic

402

105 50
247 614 509
11
3 88 315 17
1,959

1,460

Percent of Orthopedic of Total of All Disabilities

25 3/o

19 3/o

16.7%

9
TABLE J (CON'T)
FREQL:ENCY DISTRIBUTIONS OF DIFFERENT DISABILITY GROUPINGS OF CASES CLOSED REFERRED DUE TO SEVERITY OF HANDICAP AND CLOSED REHABILITATED

DISABILITY

CLOSED "TOO SEVERE" NUMBER ACCEPTED REHAB'LITATED

Mental:
Psychotic disorders Psychoneurotic disorders Other mental disorders Mental retardation
Total Mental

144

512

86

693

64

414

158

765

452

2,384

1,980

Percent of Mental of Total of All Disabilities

28 o5/o

23,5/o

22.6%

Internal and Other Disabilities:

Other conditions resulting from

12

neoplasms

Allergic, endocrine system, metabolic

47

and nutritional diseases

Blood and blood-forming organs

6

Other specified disorders of the

70

nervous system (epilepsy)

Cardiac and circulatory conditions

276

Respiratory diseases

76

Digestive system

39

Conditions of genito-urinary system

32

Other diseases

75

Total of Internal and Other Disabilities

633

234
377
11
140
545 241 1,435 954 551
4,488

4,120

Percent of Internal and Other Disabilities of Total of All Disabilities

39 9/o

44o2%

47.1%

Grand Total

1,616

10,247

8,750

10
Table II gives distributions of cases accepted and cases closed as "too severe" from different categories of referral sources. As would be expected, the largest number of cases rejected as "too severe" comes from the Social Security Administration, where approximately two cases were rejected for each case accepted. Other referral sources with relatively high rates of rejection were welfare and correctional. The lowest rates of rejection are seen in referrals from artificial appliance companies and from educational institutions.

TABLE II
FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION OF REFERRAL SOURCE OF CASES CLOSED REFERRED "TOO SEVERE" AND CASES ACCEPTED

REFERRAL SOURCE
Educational Institution Hospitals and Sanitariums Health Physicians Social Security Administration Welfare State Employment Service Artificial Appliance Company Individual except client himself Self-referred Persons Other Source Correctional \.Jorkmen' s Compensation Total

CLOSED "TOO SEVERE"
41 113 45 171 636 310
17 1
113 71 42 56 0
1,616

ACCEPTED
1 062 1 198
390 3,145
331 1 084
186 145 1 154 916 463 171
2 10,247

ll
Table III shows that approximately half of the cases closed as "too severe" were in the referred status and half in the applicant status. Table IV gives a breakdown by sex and shows a substantially higher number and higher proportion of male clients closed as too severe.

TABLE III
NUMBER OF CLIENTS CLOSED FROM 00 AND 02 STATUS DUE TO SEVERITY OF HANDICAP

(Referred) (Applicant)

STATUS 00 02

NUMBER 805 811

Total

1,616

TABLE IV
BREAKDOWN BY SEX OF NUMBER OF CASES CLOSED REFERRED DUE TO SEVERITY OF HANDICAP

Male Female

CLOSED "TOO SEVERE" 999 617

ACCEPTED 4,860 5,388

Total

1,616

10,248

12

TABLE V
NUMBER OF MONTHS IN 00 AND 02 STATUS FOR CLIENTS CLOSED REFERRED DUE TO SEVERITY
OF HANDICAP

TABLE VI
DOLLARS SPENT ON CASES CLOSED REFERRED DUE TO SEVERITY OF HANDICAP

MONTHS IN 00-02 STATUS
00 01-03 04-06 07-09 10-12 13-15 16-18 19-21 22-24 25-27 28-30 31-33 34-36 37-39 40-42 43-45 46-48 49-51 52-54 55-57 58-60 61-63 64-66 67-69 70-72 73-75 76-78 79-81 82-84
85 -87
Mean

''TOO SEVERE"
111 555 291 160 107
71
52 72 47 38 17 19 11 13 15
6 11
6 3 6 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0
9.19
4.76

CASES ACCEPTED
2 529 4 897 1 214
504 319 193 124 106
79 58 51 47 29 26 15 14 10 13
4 6 4 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0
1
4.14
1. 46;'d~

DOLLARS SPENT ON CASES CLOSED "TOO SEVERE"
$ 00-09 10-49 50-99
100-149 150-199 200-249 250-299 300-349 350-399 400-449 450-499 500-549 550-599 600-649 650-699 700-749 750-799 800-849 850-899 900-949 950-999
Mean
Median

"TOO SEVERE"
1,125 298 110 37 15 7 7 0 2 2 5 1 1 1 2 1 0 0 1 0 1
$26.23
0-9

CASES ACCEPT:
3 896 4 631
969 289 152
85 63 43 39 20 12
5 9 8 2 5 1 4 3 1 11
$35.66
10-19

Tables V and VI show the distribution of time in referred status and dollars spent on diagnosis for these cases.

* (50% of cases are more than 4.76 months) ** (50% of cases are more than 1.46 months)

13 TABLE VII

AGE
10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 Total

CASES ACCEPTED

Percent

Number

of Total

96

.9%

1,709

16.7

1 121

10.9

972

8.5

1 002

9.8

1 072

10.5

1 137

11.1

1 077

10.5

863

8.4

676

6.6

361

3.5

117

1.1

25

.2

18

.17

2

01

10,248

100.00%

CASES REJECTED "TOO SEVERE"

Percent

Number

of Total

6

0 3 7"/o

184

11.4

92

5.7

71

4.4

103

6.4

139

8.6

175

10.8

222

13.7

274

17.0

218

13.5

114

7.1

8

.5

10

.6

0

0

0

0

1,616

100.00%

Data on the age of clients are presented in Table VII and Figure I. The percentage of clients in each age group is presented for clients rejected as "too severe" and clients accepted. The graph shows, for example, that 4.4 percent of the clients rejected as "too severe" fall in the 25 to 29 age group, whereas 17 percent of these clients fall

in the 50 to 54 age group. A striking increase is seen in going from the 25year to the 54-year ages. By contrast, this trend is not seen in the curve for cases accepted. The pattern indicates that counselors are more and more likely to view the clients' disability as "too severe" as the age of the clients increases in this range.

LEGEND:
Solid Lines Indicate Cases Accepted Broken Lines Indicate Cases Closed Referred "too severe"

20 -

.....::1

,...

~ H
0 15
H
~
0
H 10
z
w
u
~
w 5-

. . . ..
.

I
. . . I

..

I

I

.. .. I
.... . . I



I

. .~ I

I I
.. . I
. I
I
~ I

-------...-----

.. ~ -- ..-

~ , , , , ',


' ' ' ' '
' ."


......
.p-

I

p..,

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

t;

I

I I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

~

0"1

~

0"1

~

0"1

~

0"1

~

0"1

~

0"1

~

0"1

~

M

M

N

N

("')

("')

~

~

Ll"\

Ll"\

\0

\0

I'

I'

00

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

0

Ll"\

0

Ll"\

0

Ll"\

0

Ll"\

0

Ll"\

0

Ll"\

0

Ll"\

0

M

M

N

N

("')

("')

~

~

Ll"\

Ll"\

\0

\0

I'

I'

00

AGE GR0 Up I NGS

FIGURE 1 FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION BY AGE GROUPS OF CASES CLOSED REFERRED DUE TO THE SEVERITY OF HANDICAP
AND CASES ACCEPTED

Table VIII reveals that of the 897 clients accepted for services from public elementary or high schools, 493 of them were classified as mental. On scanning a sample of these cases from this referral source there is a good indication that almost 100 percent of these individuals were accepted on the basis of retardation. Counselors should give serious consideration to emphasizing to the public school teachers not only the wide variety of services available from Vocational Rehabilitation, but also the variety of disabilities that are eligible for these services. With the necessary emphasis in the Cooperative Work Study Programs between Special Education Departments and Vocational Rehabilitation, there is a possibility that principals, teachers, and other school staff members have gotten the impression that the Vocational Rehabilitation program is somewhat restricted to the retarded.
Table IX indicates that of tne 10,788 cases closed referred in 1966 and 1967, 1,702 were closed because the counselor was unable to locate them. Spot checks of the actual cases indicate that clients included in this category had been in referred status up to three years. Since rehabi~itation clients tend to change addresses fairly often, it would seem that a system should be developed where these individuals who do change addresses would inform the counselor. More than one fourth of the cases closed referred was due to the client's refusal of services. It would be interesting to know if "refused services" means that the client refused vocational rehabilitation services, per se, or refused the categorical services offered by the counselor.
Table VIII also reveals that of the 751 individuals referred by the State mental hospital, more than one third were closed referred. This seems to indicate that the screening teams at the hospital should have further information on the guidelines for eligibility requirements of the agency. On the same table, referrals from the Social Security Administration total 2,568, and of this number only 330 were accepted for services or 2,238 were closed referred. These figures indicate that some study should be given to the screening procedures that the Social Security Administration utilizes.

TABLE VIII REFERRAL SOURCES FOR CLIENTS IN SIX DISABILITY CATEGORIES Cases Closed Referred or Accepted for Service and Closed in 1966-67

ACCEPTED FOR SERVICE

CLOSED REFERRED

REFERRAL SOURCE

u z

H

0

0::

~

u z
H

0
~
p... 0

H

E-<--1
E--1

~

~~;I:
ZE--1 0::0

:::J
(/)
H !>

0-<:: ;""I":

;I: E--1
0:: 0

p::.:.J.
~

Ez--1 ";:;"::":

E"z""--z10
H<I;

u z

H

0

0::

~

u z
H

0

H

0"P"-1"

-E<--1
E--1

~

~~
ZE--1 0::0

:::J
(/)
H !>

0::
;J
;I:

;I: E--1
0:: 0

:p::.J..
~

Ez--1 ";:";:"::

E"z""--z10
H<I;

1

2 1

1

4

2 3

1

1 2

3 2 2

1

:6 29 140 7 493 142

3 1

2 15

34 3

1 4

73 2

1

1 477 1

97

2

93

5

12 4 71 13 94 236

4

9 1 26 5

6 4 2 10 8

1

6

36 13

1

12 3 1 6

~4 10 38 3 46 118

1

4

3 4

3

1 1

1

1 1 1

5 5

103 41 136 7 599 322

1

1

3 14

1 14

66 4

1

270 2

29 1

1

2 1 1 116

13 3 32 5 144 121

4

10 2 12 31

23625 6

3

9

51 32

6

2 8

36 6 45 1 60 105

4

6

1

5 2

1

7

1 2 5
2

1 4 1

1

4

1 1

2

1
5 4 2 1 22 12 220 56 417 44 356 2053

1

3

5

43 4

58 25 267 14 209 728

College or university Other college Private vocational school Public vocational school Public elementary or high school Private elementary or high school School for 2hysically or mentally handicaE Other educational institution
State mental hos2ital Other mental hospital State or local T.B. hospital or sani tariUIT Other T. B. hospital or sanitarium General hospital Hos2. or other S2 facility for chronic cc Other hospital or clinic n.e.c. Rehabilitation center State Crippled Children's Azency 'State local public health dept. or agenc_.1
Arthritis & rheumatoid organizations (pvt.
Blind organizations (private) Cancer organizations (private) Cerebral palsy organizations _(privatel
Crippled children & adult orgns. (private'
Deaf and hearing organizations (privatel Epilepsy organizations (private) Heart on!anizations (nrivate) Mental retardation organizations (private' Mental health organizations (private) Multiple sclerosis organizations (private Poliomyelitis oraanizations (private) Tuberculosis organizations (private) 'n'>Other health agencies or organizations Physicians not elsewhere classifiable

TABLE VIII (Continued) REFERRAL SOURCES FOR CLIENTS IN SIX DISABILITY CATEGORIES
Cases Closed Referred or Accepted for Service and Closed in 1966-67

ACCEPTED FOR SERVICE

CLOSED REFERRED

REFERRAL SOURCE

u z

H

0

0:::

zc..?

w~ p...,

H
E--<
~

.....:1

.....:IW
~:::::
ZE--<

H 0::: ~
w::r::

:0:r::
E--< 0::: 0

E--<
;::J
p...,
~

~
Ez--< ~

w0:::0
z z E--<~
H~

u z

H

0

0:::

.....:1

zc..?

w~ p...,

H
E--<
~

.....:1

.....:IW
~:::::
ZE--<

~ ;::J {/) H
>

H 0:::
<t;
:w:r::

0::r::
E--< 0::: 0

E--<
;::J
p...,
~

~
Ez--<
w;s

0:::0
~ E--<~
%Z
H<l;

1 4 129 13 51 101
1 1

1

1

82 17 643 30 443 1023

3

1

Insurance company
Social Security Administration
State temEorary disability insurance agency State Workmen's Compensation agency
u.s. Bureau of Employment Compensation

3 18 164 28 115 586 1 4

258 23 319 13 228 765

1

1

1 1

1 1 1 1 7 10

1 2 16

1 3 7 15

Public welfare agencies (state local govt.l Private welfare agencies United Mine Workers Welfare Relief Other Labor Union Welfare Civic organizations and clubs Community advisory center

6 34 2 29 56 5647 9 16 48 14 31 68
7 4 8 15
1 13 3 16 42

40 23 103 2 141 169

9 18

4 7

20 11 53 7 36 67

6 18

15 17

18 6 34 4 39 59

Selective Service System ~incl. local bds.2
State Vocational Rehabilitation Agency
State Employment Service
Public official (local state Fed. n.e.c.)
u.s. Civil Service Commission
Government agencies ~other than above2

18 12 113 1 1

2 12 5 4 80

1

2

9 67 196 36 161 535

8 62 165 129 90 314

2 4 5 6 11

1 3 2 18

9 6 11

6 18

1

119 28 228 19 188 345

94 20 155 23 117 257

5 1 10 1 2 9

Artificial appliance companies Employer Labor union Individual except client himself Self-referred persons n.e.c. Other not elsewhere classifiable

3 12

4 1
3 123 16

3 5 4 3 30 2 359 37

Criminal Court Judges (public offenders) Parole officials (public offenders) Other (public offenders)

* Including public health nurses, clinics, etc. ** Public or private

TABLE IX
REFERRAL SOURCES FOR CASES CLOSED REFERRED IN 1966-67 BROKEN DOWN BY SIX REASONS FOR CLOSURE
Referral Sources Are Represented by Codes as on Federal R-300

z

P-<

0 H

u ~

i:il

E--<

H

~

H

Q

i:il E--<
~ u
0 ....:l

i:il
>
i:il Cfl
0 0

Cfl
ui:il > H
~

Q z
u 0
z 0

~
z ~

E--<

i:il

H

0

0

Cfl

....:l

H

E--< i:il

P-<
~ u

Q
i:il

~ ~
Cfl

E--<
u ~

....:l
~ z
!:J

H

Cfl

Q

!:J

~

I=Lo i:il ~

H Q
0 z

> 0 0 z

~
i:::ri:l:
E--< 0

OTALS 1702 1616 2620 1021 1339 2490

2

1

2

1

4

2

2 I

2

1

1

I

2

3

2

4

2

304 35 358 121 225 157

1

1

9

3

6

1

1 11

21

1 26

2

5 15

1

42 69 83

5

6 67

7

2 13

3

4

32

6 35

3 13 31

124 24 57 20 23 61

15

9 16

1

2 15

6

3

5

1

1

8

6

8

6

5 11 52

2

3

1

3

7

35 31 57 36 39 53

2

1

2

1

1

3

1

2

1

1

4

2

1

1

2

1

i 2

I

I

College or university Other college Private vocational school Public vocational school Public elementary or high school Private elementary or high school School for physically or mentally handicapped Other educational institution
State mental hospital Other mental hospital State or local T. B. hospital or sanitarium Other T.B. hospital or sanitarium General hospital Hospital or other special facility for chronic con Other hospital or clinic n.e.c. Rehabilitation center State CriQpled Children's Agency ~-state or local oublic health dept. or agency_
Arthritis & rheumatoid organizations (private)
Blind organization (private} Cancer organization (private) Cerebral palsy organization (private) Crippled children and adult organization (private' Deaf and hearing organization (private) Epilepsy organization (private) Heart organization (private) Mental retardation organization (private) Mental health organization (private) Multiple sclerosis organization (private) Poliomyelitis organization (private)

TABLE IX (Continued)
REFERRAL SOURCES FOR CASES CLOSED REFERRED IN 1966-67 BROKEN DOWN BY SIX REASONS FOR CLOSCRE
Referral Sources Are Represented by Codes as on Federal R-300

z

p...

0
H

~ u

~

E--<

H

~
E--<
~ u
0 ....:!

0:::
~ >
~ C/)
0 0

C/)
~ u
H
>
0:::

H
@
0 u

Cz l
~ ::r::

....:!

zc..?

~ z

E--<

~

H

0

0 E--<

p...

C/)

....:! P=l

H
E--<

~

~ u

Cl
~

~
C/)

~ u

....:! P=l
~ z
;::;

H
zCl
~ ::r::

C/)
;::;
~ ~
0:::

H
Cl
0 z

> 0 0 z

0:::
~
::r::
E--< 0

I

!

I

10:

21 21

!
1 41 1 I 17

162 171 299 193 229 239

I

I

I

1

1

258 636' 590 132 153 462

1

2

1

-----
Poliomyelitis oraanization (private) Tuberculosis organization lQrivateJ Other health agency or organization (pub. or pvt.) Physicians not elsewhere classifiable
Insurance company Social Security Administration State temporary disabilit~ insurance agency State Workmen's Compensation Agen~
u.s. Bureau of Employees' Compensation

137 302 264 186 230 474

1

1

2

1

2

1

1

7

6

7

5

2

4

Public welfare agency lstate and local govt.) Private welfare a_gency United Mine Workers' Welfare and Retirement Fund Other Labor Union Welfare Fund Civic organizations and clubs Community adviso~ center

24

2 98 33 40 279

3

6

8

1

4

8

40 17 65 12 18 42

10

4 16

4

7

6

34 17 53

8 16 32

I

8

1

9

2

4

9

8

7 16

7

3

1

126 114 246 108 143 186

88 72 167 76 129 134

3

2

7

4

4

6

Selective Service System {includin_g local boards) State Vocational Rehabilitation Agency State Employment Service Public official (local state federal, n.e.c.)
u.s. Civil Service Commission
Government agency (other than listed above)
Artificial appliance com_Q_al'!Y_ Em_Q_lover Labor union Individual 1 exce2t client himself Self-referred persons, n.e.c. Other, n.e.c.

2

1

2

1

2

164 56 72 35 11 95

Criminal Court Judges (public offenders) Parole officers JRublic offenders} Other (public offenders~

~~ Including public health nurses, clinics, etc.

DISCUSSION
This discussion is based upon several meetings of the members of this task force and the materials prepared by Dr. Wyckoff.

20
The Federal Register was established to implement and explain Public Law 89333 which was passed by Congress in November, 1965. The criteria in this document are: "eligible" or "eligibility" when used in relation to an individual's qualification for vocational rehabilitation services, refers to a certification that
1. the handicapped individual has a physical or mental disability which constitutes a substantial handicap to employment, and

Community education and public relations in general cannot be separated from casefinding. There has been emphasis in this agency upon the importance of enhancing the status of the agency and the counselor in the community. One of the difficulties in enhancing this status has been the fact that our educational contact has indicated that services are available for all people with impairments. There are, in fact, many people with impairments that are not eligible for rehabilitation services or who are so severely handicapped that they cannot reasonably be expected to become employed after rehabilitation services. In reported instances, key community people have referred persons with impairments who were not eligible on the basis of feasibility; that is, there was insufficient assurance that rehabilitation services would result in employment. An example might be an individual with a terminal condition which would not allow time for preparation for employment. In other instances, the referral would not be served on the basis of ineligibility. The medical impairment must constitute a vocational disability. The bilateral leg amputee who is already skilled as a watchmaker might not be eligible. In many cases the referral source receives no feedback as to why the referral was refused service; consequently, ill feelings are incurred.
The Vocational Rehabilitation Act of 1954 defined a physically handicapped individual as "an individual who is under a physical or mental disability which constitutes a substantial handicap to employment, but which is of such a nature that vocational rehabilitation services may reasonably be expected to render him fit to engage in a remunerative occupation."

2. vocational rehabilitation services may reasonably be expected to render him fit to engage in a gainful occupation.
Eligibility no longer is defined in a narrow sense of physical disability or limited to the classical diagnostic concept of mental and emotional diseases or disturbances. It now includes:
"Behavioral disorders characterized by deviant social behavior or impaired ability to carry out normal relationships with family and community, which may result from vocational, educational, cultural, social, environmental--or other factors."
The lack of a grasp of the concept of eligibility as a meaningful and dynamic force in the counseling relationship makes it even more necessary that we give it much additional discussion and interpretation to referral sources. Extended evaluation provisions of the 1965 Amendments seem to point up eligibility as a process rather than a status. This appears to have eliminated a static element and gives to the process a dynamic proportion which did not exist before--at least not in practice. This means that a counselor cannot merely say a client is or is not eligible.
The referral source should also have some knowledge concerning how the client will be received and treated. Only a personal knowledge of institutions and professional workers will provide information as to their respective ways of functioning and availability of services rendered.

21
More thought should be given to informing referral sources on the meaning of eligibility and feasibility so they could do a better job in screening and referring individuals for rehabilitation services. Feedback to referral sources as to the status of the person that they referred is a method of teaching them and keeping them informed as to the criterion for services from Vocational Rehabilitation. Referral sources contributing a high number of persons closed "too severe" should be given special attention.
Orthopedic and mental disabilities contribute a relatively high proportion of cases closed "too severe." This could indicate intensified training for counselors who have exclusive or heavy caseloads from these disability categories.
The fact that higher numbers and percentages of males are closed as "too severe" could be accounted for by the fact that many of the females are closed as housewives, which would generally have less rigid standards of production.
The fact that those clients closed as "too severe" were in referred status substantially longer than those accepted for service indicates that counselors should give speeder evaluation and disposition of cases. This suggests that thought should be given to reducing the counselor's caseloads and territory.
There is an indication that increasing age constitutes a handicap to employment. Special emphasis should be given to educating the employer on the merits of hiring the older handicapped worker, especially in jobs requiring great accuracy and less speed.

The committee recommends that the Georgia Office of Vocational Rehabilitation consider implementing the following recommendations:

SU1'-frlARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The basic problem of the task force on casefinding becomes one of developing procedures that will bring these unknown individuals in need of vocational rehabilitation services in contact with a rehabilitation counselor.

1. With the new emphasis on total rehabilitation services to all ages (from birth to death) toward adjustment and not just a job, as is indicated in the federal reorganization and change in name to Social and Rehabilitation Service, there should be a counselor in each district office to work with parents and guardians of the impaired child. This person would help

them to plan their children's special educational needs and give them help in developing and strengthening every possible potential the child possesses. The person would be identified at the time he became impaired, as early as birth. The rehabilitation (habilitation) program would be a going on process to the time the person reached his optimum adjustment and interdependence.
2. There should be instituted formal and periodic interagency contacts, as well as informal personal relationships, to make the other agencies conscious of Vocational Rehabilitation services. Information should be included in these contacts that would help the referring agency in selecting appropriate cases. Comprehensive guidelines should be developed on the procedures and steps necessary to refer clients to Vocational Rehabilitation. Also included in these comprehensive guidelines should be encouragement to the referral agency to supply the counselor with as much relevant information about the client as possible.
3. University programs including undergraduate, graduate, and postgraduate should include in the curriculum courses that would develop competency in the use of different community resources.
4. Develop a pay scale for counselors that would parallel the supervisor's salary. This would mean a counselor could be rewarded on the basis of his merit as a counselor. It would then not be necessary to be "promoted" to supervisor in order to be rewarded for his ability as a counselor. In a dynamic growing agency there are always higher positions being created which are tempting to the counselor. T'he supervisor is often tempted to transfer effective counselors to these positions. If a counselor is permitted to stay for only a short time in a territory, the people in the community get somewhat discouraged in having to relate to a different individual, and also the new counselor must spend a disproportionate amount of his time in developing relationships with the community.

22
who are in need of such service. This would include spot announcements on radio, television, and in the newspapers, in addition to information on such bulletin boards as the courthouse and housing developments.
6. Transportation should be provided for those who need (particularly in rural areas) it getting in to see the counselor.
7. Increase the number of counselors in territories where there is a backlog of people who have been referred, but not seen. There is evidence that there is a relationship between time spent in referred status and closed "too severe." (See Table V.)
8. The counselor should be encouraged to give prompt feedback on all referred cases. This procedure will not only engender good public relations, but is an excellent opportunity to educate the referral agent in such areas as eligibility and feasibility.
9. The State Plan for Vocational Rehabilitation Services should contain the recommendation that counselors refer those individuals closed "too severe" to an appropriate agency that would have a program which could possibly benefit the person.
The committee feels that if the above recommendations can be implemented into the Georgia Office of Vocational Rehabilitation, individuals who are in need of rehabilitation services will be brought in contact with the counselor in a more efficient manner.

5. Educate the general public in the area of potential services that Vocational Rehabilitation can provide those

REPORT OF THE TASK FORCE ON EVALUATION, TREATMENT, AND TRAINING
Statewide Vocational Rehabilitation Planning Project February, 1968

24 TABLE OF CONTENTS

Letter of Submittal

25

List of Diagrams, Tables and Maps

26

List of Task Force Members

27

I. INTRODUCTION

28

II. AN OVERVIEW OF CURRENT PROGRAMS

29

A. The Flow of Clients Through the Rehabilitation

29

Process

B. Evaluation Procedures

31

C. Treatment and Training Procedures

45

D. Cost of Evaluation, Treatment and Training

54

E. Summary of Findings and Conclusions

58

III. ASSUMPTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

61

A. Assumptions

61

B. Recommendations

61

Selected Bibliography

65

Appendices

67

A. Minutes of Meetings

67

B. Maps

78

25 COPY: LETTER OF SUBMITTAL

February 1, 1968

Mr. Vernon L. Vinson Project Coordinator Statewide Planning Project Office of Vocational Rehabilitation 159 Forrest Avenue, N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30303
Dear Mr. Vinson:
On January 26, 1968, Task Force Two held its last scheduled meeting. At this meeting we reviewed the findings and recommendations related to evaluation, treatment and training. These efforts are summarized in the accompanying report, which has the unanimous approval of those attending this last meeting.
The dedication and hard work of the members of the Task Force, especially its chairman, Dr. Floyd Blevin, have been most inspiring and helpful. The work of the Task Force has been greatly facilitated by the efforts of your staff, and especially the help given by the late Mr. F. E. Wynn and his successor, Miss Karen Butler. The special reports by Dr. Cecil Harbin and Mr. Bobby Todd contributed much material for the Task Force's consideration and for inclusion in our report. To all of these people I gratefully acknowledge my appreciation. The final recommendation of this Task Force is the best indication of the interest and dedication of its members. They have, as you will read, recommended the adjournment rather than disbanding of the Task Force, with perhaps annual or semi-annual meetings in the next seven years to review the movements made toward the objective of providing rehabilitation services to all those who need it by 1975.
I have learned much and enjoyed my association with the planning project staff and the Task Force members. Thank you for this opportunity to work with you, your staff and the Task Force members toward the betterment of rehabilitation services in Georgia.
Sincerely,
Sherwood B. Slater, Ph.D. Consultant to Task Force II

-~" v1um.L vr OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES

PHASE I May--Dec. 1966

PHASE II Jan.--Aug. 1967

PHASE III Aug. --Jan. 1968

PHASE IV Jan. --Apr. 1963

ORGANIZATION
RESEARCH
PILOT PROJECTS TECHNICAL TASK
FORCE

Recruitment Coordinator Staff
Equipment Assembly of Names Policy Board and Advisory Committee Personnel
Data Collection Preparatory to Task Force Needs Planned and Contracted
Population Estimates and Projections for Georgia Counties
Estimates of Disability in the State of Georgia
A Follow-Up Study of 151 Former DVR Clients Closed in Three Categories
Plan for Facilities and Workshops

Policy Board and Advisory Committee Formally Organized and Functioning Task Forces Defined Appointed First Meeting Held
Studies Conducted and Reported

Case finding
Evaluation, Treatment and/or Training
Internal Structure
Interagency Cooperation and Coordination
Hanpower Needs and Potential
Legislation and Finance
Occupational Placement and Follow-Up
Facilities and Workshops Planning Input
Research as required by task forces Referral Source Breakdown Placement Survey, Interagency
Cooperation Survey Current Staff Characteristics, etc. Survey of Personnel Who Left Agency

Task Force

Reports

H

::J

r't
ro

{)Q

ti

,...!lJ
r't

0 ::J

("t
0

"'1 >-' ::J !lJ >-'

:;o

(D

Facilities

'"0 0

and Work-

ti
r't

shops Plan-

ning Report

Staff Survey (Department of Family and Children Services)

Agency Survey (Depa.~t

ment of Public Health)

Client Orientation Project Started

1 Filn_,__D_e_l_i_,,_e_r_e_0------C~o~r-r-J-p-l-c-t-io-n---;o-n-d--A--n--a-ly--s-i-s----------------l
Client Tests Run

Film Contracted

Pi lot Project !Zeports

Community Involvement Planning - Equipment

Reorganized Initial Test County Program

Completion and Analysis

26 LIST OF DIAGRAMS, TABLES AND MAPS

DIAGRAM

1. The Flow of Clients Through the Rehabilitation

Process

30

2. The Flow of Clients Through the Georgia Office

of Vocational Rehabilitation

32

3. Organization and Sources of Medical Personnel

Used by OVR

34

TABLE

1. Medical Association of Georgia (MAG) and Office of

Vocational Rehabilitation (OVR) Listing of Specialists

35

2. Percent Excess Urban Distribution of Specialists with

Cities over 30,000

37

3. Ratios of Acceptance to Rejections at Different Stages

of the Client's Career

42

4. OVR Use of Facilities Providing Work Evaluation

44

5. Adequacy of Case Development by Training Completions

(Percent Judged Adequate)

47

6. OVR Use of Facilities by Types of Services and

Sponsorship

49

7. Use of Facilities by Sponsorship

50

8. Case Services Expenditures for Georgia and the Forty-

Nine Other States (1964-66)

55

MAPS (Appendix B)

78

27

TASK FORCE TWO (Evaluation, Treatment and/or Training)

Mr. R. V. Bankston Case Worker 415 Pine Avenue Building Albany, Georgia 31702
Dr. Robert L. Bennett Medical Director Warm Springs Foundation Warm Springs, Georgia 31830
Dr. Floyd Edward Bliven Professor of Surgery (Orthopedics) Medical College of Georgia Augusta, teorgia 30902
Dr. Charles K. Bush, Jr. Director, Hospital Services
Branch 47 Trinity Avenue, S.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30334
Mr. William A. Craft Disability Determination Unit Vocationai Rehabilitation 805 Peachtree Street Atlanta, Georgia 30308
Dr. Bird Daniel 203 Donehoo Street Statesboro, Georgia 30458
Dr. Cecil Harbin Veterans Administration Hospital 1670 Clairmont Road, N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30329
Dr. Calvin Jackson 209 Broad Street Manchester, Georgia 31816
Dr. Donald J. McKenzie 818 Gordon Avenue Thomasville, Georgia 31792
Dr. Clifford Montgomery Butler, Georgia 31006

Dr. John Mooney Statesboro, Georgia 30458
Dr. Lamar B. Peacock 478 Peachtree Street, N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30308
Mr. Oliver G. Prince 433 Waterford Road, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30318
Mr. Bob Todd State Department of Education 50 Whitehall Street, S.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30303
Mr. W. A. Tomlin Counselor Georgia Rehabilitation Center Warm Springs, Georgia 31830
Dr. Thomas 0. Vinson 126 Trinity Place Decatur, Georgia 30030
Dr. Vance Watt 900 Gordon Avenue Thomasville, Georgia 31792
CONSULTANT
Dr. Sherwood Slater Department of Sociology Emory University 1364 Clifton Road, N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30322

28
continued success in treating acute illnesses, and the concomitant increased incidence of chronic and degenerative diseases, the high rate of traffic injuries, and the eligibility of persons with primarily non-physical handicaps have placed increased and different kinds of demands on existing services.

It is at this point, and with these changes in mind that this task force has sought to answer the following questions related to the current state of evaluation, treatment and training:

1. How are clients' impairments and disabilities being assessed medically, vocationally, and psychologically today?

2. Is the medical diagnosis complete and satisfactory?

3. Is the medical advisory board fulfilling its proper role?

4. Are we using all the doctors we
should?

I. INTRODUCTION
The responsibilities of this task force are 1) the examination of existing evaluation, treatment and training procedures, facilities, and practices, 2) the projection of future needs, 3) the recommendation of changes, expansions and improvements in existing rehabilitation programs, and 4) coordination of medical and vocational programs so that by 1975, for all in need of such services, they will be readily available.
Since the first vocational rehabilitation legislation in the 1920s, the State of Georgia has been in the "rehabilitation business" and has maintained itself as one of the leading states in this area of endeavor. Through the years a number of advances, both social and technological, have altered the processes of and the prospects for successful rehabilitation. For the most part, the cases referred to vocational rehabilitation agencies today were previously excluded; clients with certain disabilities offered unique challenges in the past, but today the same clients constitute relatively "routine cases." The

5. Is the geographic distribution of doctors the best that we could have?
6. Are we using all the hospitals we should?
7. How well are the training facilities fulfilling their job?
These questions relate to the existing situation, and indicate the areas of concern when assessing current evaluation, treatment and training programs. Additional questions, related to the anticipated needs and practices as they would exist in 1975 are raised, specifically:
1. How can the assessment of clients' medical, vocational and psychological impairments and disabilities be improved?
2. How can we get the excellent doctors who do not now work with Vocational Rehabilitation to do so?
3. What additional types of training facilities should we be using?
These two sets of questions served as the basis for our deliberations by providing a focus for discussion and investigation and suggesting further questions that we sought to answer.

A. The Flow of Clients through Rehabilitation Program

II. AN OVERVIEW OF CURRENT PROGRAMS
The express purpose of rehabilitation programs is the provision of services to disabled individuals that 'maximize" the opportunity for the development of his
potentials. 1 A wide variety of both
public and private agencies provide these services in the State of Georgia. Some agencies concentrate upon particular disability groups (e.g., blindness, congenital defects, deafness), certain age or social categories of impaired individuals, or specialize in the services they provide to various groups (e.g., physical restoration centers, training schools, evaluation agencies, casework and counseling). This review of current programs concentrates on the State of Georgia, Office of Vocational Rehabilitation (OVR). The concentration on a single agency, in this case the OVR, is necessitated by the limitations of available and reliable data. In the State of Georgia, however, the OVR expends more funds and provides services to more of the disabled population than any other single agency treating this population. When possible other agencies and services have been considered in this examination of current programs.

For any agency a necessary condition for the provision of rehabilitation services to individuals is the presence of some impairment. Impairment is defined as a condition or state which limits or precludes usual functions or activities. Some rehabilitation agencies focus upon the impairment and seek by treatment, training and/ or by the provision of appliances to remove, compensate or substitute for lost functions. If in addition, the individual has not adapted to the impairment which is so severe as to limit functioning or activity in significant areas of the individual's life situations, the impairment constitutes a disability. Since disability is relative to the life situation of the impaired person, judgments must be made on an individualistic basis as to the extent to which the impairment imposes disability on that person. Thus, inherent in any rehabilitation agency's determination of the eligibility of potential clients for their services, the following questions need to be answered:
1. To what extent does an impairment exist?
2. Is the impairment sufficiently limiting to constitute a disability for this particular individual?
3. Is the individual's impairment treatable, removable, or compensable?
4. Can the individual with a dis-
ability be rehabilitated?

The stated purpose of the OVR is "to provide or make available by purchase such services for which provisions are made under public law authorizing and supporting public programs of Vocational Rehabilitation to individuals who are physically or mentally impaired and w2o have a substantial employment handicap. This section will examine the current programs of the OVR, particularly as they relate to the provision of services (including evaluation, treatment and training) to clients.

An affirmative response to all of these
questions, stated in terms of the agency's definition of rehabilitation (e.g., physical restoration, independent living, vocational rehabilitation) implies acceptance for servcies. Thus, the first stages in the flow of clients through a rehabilitation agency involve the steps of establishing impairment, determining disability, and estimation of rehabilitation potential. This initial set of steps in the flow of clients through an agency is shown in Diagram 1.

1. Office of Vocational Rehabilitation, Manual of Policies, Sec. 1.01. 2. Ibid.

30
DIAGRAM I THE FLOW OF CLIENTS THROUGH THE REHABILITATION PROCESS

Congenital and Acquired Conditions
Is the impairment a
disability?

Deaths
No No No No

31

The increment in Georgia's population is by natural increase (births) and immigration; decrement occurs from mortality and migration. At any point of time the population contains a number of persons who are impaired. When identified, and the determination is made that their condition does constitute impairment (whether physical, mental, emotional, social) the question is raised if this person's impairment is so severe as to constitute a disability. If the person is not found to be impaired, he retains his former status in the population. If he is found to be impaired, but to an extent that is not determined to be disabling, he is not eligible for rehabilitation services, except possibly for those that provide for the correction or alteration of the impairment. The objective of rehabilitation is the return of the individual to a suitable place in society. If completely successful, the individual can be expected to be an independent, productive member of society. If the agency fails to meet its objective fully, the individual, by definition, returns to a less than optimal position.
When the OVR is examined the distinction between productive, independent persons and non-productive, dependent persons becomes more salient, particularly in view of the stated objectives of the agency. Specifically, the OVR defines eligibility for services on the basis of employment or productive work potential, although a broad interpretation is practiced. The OVR has formalized the flow of clients through the agency in its "case status classification."3 This formalized flow of clients, with the added distinction of productive/non-productive populations is shown in Diagram 2.
The span of time from a client's first contact with the agency until his case is closed and no further services are offered constitutes his career in the agency. While, in terms of overall planning the total client career is of concern, this task force concentrates only on the stages related to evaluation, treatment and training. Other very important questions are more appropriately the concern of other task forces (e.g., How do we find potential clients? Which of these are

eligible for the range of services provided by the agency? Which of these are excluded from all or part of the services? Which ones and by whom are they placed in gainful employment?). Therefore, the status of applicant (02) through the status of ready for employment (20) is considered to constitute the portion of the client's career which circumscribes evaluation, treatment and training processes.
B. Evaluation Procedures
As presently constituted there are three statuses that specifically include as the primary objective evaluation of the client. These are Applicant (02), Six-month Extended Evaluation (04), and Eighteen-Month Extended Evaluation (06). These evaluation periods are provided in order to establish the three conditions of eligibility for vocational rehabilitation services or rehabilitation potential.
1. The presence of ~ physical and/or mental impairment
2. The existence of a substantial handicap to employment
3. The determination of a reasonable expectation that vocational rehabilitation services will render the client fit for gainful employment.
The first determination in the evaluation process is the determination of an impairment, the stability of the impairing condition and the prognosis. As presently constituted the impairment may be physical or mental, but in all cases there must be a General Medical Report (Form R-3) filed. This form, completed by the rehabilitation counselor and the physician, gives information about the client's medical history and his present physical condition. This General Medical Report is supplemented by additional medical examination reports by specialists when the medical consultant and/or the counselor have "reason to believe such examination is necessary."4 In each instance the specialist reports to the agency the pres-

3. ~., Sec. 4.03.

4. Ibid., Sec. 6.03.

Diagram 2 The Flow of Clients Through the Georgia Office of Vocational Rehabilitation

I (oo) Referred

reques~ signed

for services

' I {022 A2plicant I

o{ certification

selected::-1

severity

disabilities

I I (04)

(06)

6 mos. evaluation Ills mos. evaluation

I

I

I (10) Ace;epted I
I
plan written

(08)
Closed after evaluation

.-

I

I
(30)
Closed before plan initiated

services begun

I ' 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

' I (14)
Couns c>l ing

'(16)
Physical

'(18)
Training

I Guidance
Placement
I

Restoration
I

preparation complete
I

(20)

I II (24) Services Interrupted

employment begun

(28) Closed after plan initiated (not rehabilitated)

I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 11 11 11 1 1111I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
Plan completed so far as possible
substantial counseling
one or more other services
suitable employment 30 days or more
I

(26) Closed em2loyed
I

( ) OVR STATUS

ent condition, the nature of any indicated treatment, and the work limitations imposed by the impairing condition.
The task force raised a number of specific questions regarding the current medical evaluation procedures. Specifically, we were concerned with the following questions:
1. Is the medical report complete and satisfactory?
2. Is the medical advisory board fulfilling its proper role?
3. Are we (OVR) using all the physicians we should?
4. Is the geographic distribution of physicians the best that we (OVR) could have?
5. Are we using all the hospitals we (OVR) should?
We discussed at length, during the first deliberations of the task force, the questions related to medical evaluation (see the minutes of the meeting of September 8, 1967 in Appendix A). Concrete data were not readily available from which a definitive answer to the first of these questions could be obtained. It was quite clear, however, from the testimony of members of the task force and OVR personnel that there was great variation in the quality and utility of the completed General Medical Reports. The conclusion was, as stated in the approved minutes, "that many of our (OVR's) medical reports are worthless and perhaps they could be revised so that pertinent facts could be presented on a form and then a narrative be attached."
The discussion related to the second question of the role of the Medical Advisory Board was considered in conjunction with the third question about the extent to which physicians were being used by the program as presently constituted. The arrangement and functions of physicians at various levels are shown in Diagram 3. From among the licensed physicians in the State, in each client's case there will be a "Primary Physician" who completes for that client the General Medical Examination. This

33
is the basic medical evaluation data obtained for all clients. The counselor and/or the OVR Medical Consultant, on the basis of the information from the Primary Physician and other sources, select when deemed necessary, a member of the "Panel of Medical Specialists," or a "Special Medical Facility," to further examine the client, and thereby provide additional information.for the evaluation of the impairment. The approval of medical personnel and facilities is under the control of the Medical Advisory Board.
The task force examined in some detail the distribution and use of medical specialists and consultants in the evaluation of clients for OVR services. The attempt has been made by OVR to obtain an adequate number and geographical distribution of specialists for use in the medical evaluation of applicants. The number and distribution of various medical specialists on the Panel of Specialists, which is approved by the Medical Advisory Committee, were examined. It was apparent from the maps and the testimony of members of the task force that in some cases clients had to travel as much as one hundred miles to obtain examinations by approved specialists. This was considered an undue burden on clients, and the task force considered the questions of adequacy of coverage in areas and specialties, and modifications of the process for selecting specialists.
Using the Medical Association of Georgia Roster of January, 1967, the distribution of selected specialties in the State were compared to those on the OVR Panel of Specialists. The comparison maps are found in Appendix B. The specialties examined and the number in each listing are shown in Table 1. The coverage by specialty varies considerably from a low of 20 percent of the pathologists to a high of 154 percent of the chest and thoracic surgeons listed by the Medical Association of Georgia who are on the OVR panel with an average of 77 percent for the 16 specialties. When the nine counties with cities of over 30,000 are examined, it is found that the major portions of the difference between specialists on the OVR panel and those listed by the Medical Association of Georgia Roster occur in these urban areas (see Table 2). The only excep-

34
DIAGRAM 3 ORGANIZATION AND SOURCES OF MEDICAL PERSONNEL USED BY OVR

MEDICAL ADVISORY BOARD

I Appoints I

1r

r------------,

.,. I
L-

- -C-O- U-N-S-EL-O-R-.J~----

MEDICAL CONSULTANT

1r EVALUATES
MEDICAL
,. INFORMATION

I Selects J
l

'

L A_QJ)_oint s J

l Approves

PANEL OF SPECIALISTS
~ PROVIDE MEDICAL ,
INFORMATION
~I"

~r
MEDICAL FACILITIES
J

PRIMARY PHYSICIAN COMPLETES R-3

LICENSED PHYSICIANS IN GEORGIA

35

TABLE I
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION OF GEORGIA (MAG) AND OFFICE OF VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION (OVR) LISTING OF SPECIALISTS

SPECIALTY
Allergy Chest and Thoracic Surgery Dennatology E.E.N.T E.N.T. Gvnecology Internal Medicine and
Cardiology Neurology and Neurosurgery Orthopedic Surgery Pathology Physical Medicine Plastic Surgery Proctology Psychiatry and Neuro-
psychiatry Radiology Surgery Urology

NUMBER MAG
7 13 30 152 250 400 36 77 65
8 10
6 97 103 393 73

NUMBER OVR
8 20 17 65 153 240 28 60 13
6 11 4 72 32 420 76

RATIO OVR/MAG
114 154
57 43 61 60 78 78 20 75 110 67 74 31 107 104

36

tions found are in orthopedic surgery (18 percent of the underdistribution is in urban areas), internal medicine (70 percent) and radiology (45 percent); in all other specialties more than 75 percent of the underdistribution is in urban areas. In the instance of orthopedic surgery the distributions of the OVR and MAG listed physicians are not greatly dissimilar, since 9 out of 17 not on the OVR list are in counties contiguous to Fulton. A better estimate is that 71 percent of the underdistribution of orthopedic surgeons is in urban areas. In the case of internal medicine the underdistribution is not critical because this is the largest number of any specialty group (240) on the OVR panel. The most serious underdistribution occurs among radiologists, although this may not be a frequently used specialty. While for the most part the distribution of specialists may be inadequate in certain geographical areas, it does not seem to be based on inadequacies of the current system but more likely it reflects the general maldistribution of physicians in rural and less urbanized areas. This conclusion is further supported by examination of the distribution of all physicians by counties and the physicians population ratio (see Map 2,
Appendix B).

There were a number of instances where the evidence suggested that physicians were poorly or incompletely oriented to the services provided by the OVR. This was thought to be a factor in inappropriate referrals and possibly related to the inadequacies reported in some medical reports being supplied to OVR. After lengthy discussion of this problem, it was also concluded that a very strong contributing factor to these problems, and in particular that of appropriate referral, is the fault of the OVR in not providing more extensive follow-up and feedback. The problem seems to emerge from the absence of a simple but routine way of informing referral sources of the disposition of referred clients and the various services provided to them. There are some data which bear on this problem, reflecting the different~al importance of referral from physicians. During the three fiscal years, 1961-63, there were 18,622 rehabilitants, of which 7,586 (41 percent) were referred by physicians. The percent of all referrals for OVR services made by physicians is unavailable. When the 2,010 clients who received training during this period are considered separately, only 161 (8 percent) were referred by physicians. By fiscal year the percent of rehabilitants referred from 1961 to 1966 by physicians is shown below:

Another question related to medical evaluation and also to treatment, is the availability and use of hospital facilities. There are 108 hospitals in Georgia and 3 in Chattanooga that are approved by use by the OVR. These are well distributed geographically, with few counties not having a hospital in their own or an adjacent couroty (see Map 4, Appendix B. It was diff~cult to assess the qualitative differences in these facilities, but it was assumed that approval of a facility implied that a minimum acceptable standard of care is being provided. It was concluded, however, that the efforts of OVR to select and approve hospitals is very possibly a duplication of wo~k done by other State agencies. Specifically, the State Department of Health was found to be in a more strategic position to evaluate, license and approve hospital facilities, this being a legally defined responsibility of that agency.

Year

Percent

Cumulative Percent

1961

41

1962

30

1963

41

1964

41

1965

37

1966

36

40.3 40.7 40.8 40.0 39.2

The physicians, as a single source, refer more rehabilitants than any other group making referrals, but in recent years this has been declining. Furthermore, while it is unknown what proportion of all referrals are made by physicians, it is apparent from data available that they are not the principal source of referral for clients who go into training. This would seem to suggest that physicians are more likely to refer candidates who are in need of rehabilitation services other than training, such as physical restoration, prosthetic appliances, etc.

5. Buice and OVR Annual Reports.

SPECIALTY GROUP
Dermatology E.E.N.T. Gynecology Internal Medicine Neurology Orthopedic Surgery Pathology Psychiatry Radiology All Specialties

TABLE 2
PERCENT EXCESS URBAN DISTRIBUTION OF SPECIALISTS BY COUNTIES WITH CITIES OVER 30,000
(City Underscored)

r::: I:Q 0
I:Q (.) H ttl
I:Q;:F::;

~~
;g~
UCI)

COUNTIES AND CITIES

~J
u~

:>-4
~
~ E
(.!) ttl
::;,..a
Or-! Cl~

s 8 ~ (!)
~0::

I

z2
0 r:::
H ttl
~......,
f;:~

ttl
C/).j.J
!@~ CIJ
~~0
~~

~ CIJ
~ ::J
s t!>..o
u0 ::J
Cl) ......,
i!3

zCl ttl
o.j.J
~ CIJ
u S'o
H ;:J 0::~

ALL URBAN COUNTIES

-46

23

8

0

0

108

0 15 - 8

100

11

3

1

2

2

46

5

3

5

78

-1

0

7

4

4

112

2

4

7

139

-2

4

2

4 -6

56

1

0

11

70

13

0

0

0

0

63

5

3

5

89

18

6

0

0

0

18

0

0

12

18

12

6

4

4

4

35

2

8

12

87

0

0

-4

0

0

48

0

4

28

76

4

1

4

4

0

21

4

6

11

55

1

3

3

3 -0.2 58

2

3

10

83

NUMBER OF PHYSICIANS EXCESS (MAG-OVR)
Georgia Urban Co.

13

13

87

69

97

136

160

112

8

7

17

3

52

44

25

19

71

40

530

443

Without a more detailed data analysis it 38 is not possible to determine if this happens because physicians 1) refer clients with better work experience and prior training, 2) for the most part physicians have contact with clients needing physical restoration services alone, or 3) are unaware of the extensive training services provided by the OVR. In conclusion, however, physicians have in the past been a major referral source, and the continued and increased use of this group is necessary to reach as many potential clients as possible.
A second area of vital concern in the evaluation process is psychological evaluations of clients when these are indicated. Unlike medical evaluation it is not a universal requirement for all clients in order to determine eligibility for services. It was deemed to occur frequently enough, and to be of critical importance in those cases where it does occur, to warrant examination by the task force. The OVR recognizes that not all clients served by them require psychological testing. The OVR counselors have been provided with the following basic psychological tests:
1. General Clerical Test
2. Kuder Preference Record
3. Mechanical Comprehension Test
4. Otis Intelligence Test
5. Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test
6. Purdue Pegboard Test
7. Wide Range Achievement Test
8. Weschler Adult Intelligence Scale
Other aptitude tests are utilized by the counselor on an optional basis. In those cases where it is deemed necessary, a referral for psychological evaluation may be made upon recommendation of a consultant or supervisor who has reviewed the case or another professional person who has evaluated the client. The final determination to obtain more extensive psychological evaluation is made by the counselor.

The following describes in detail the prov~s~ons and conditions for psychological evaluation services.* The types of psychological services available are Intellectual Evaluations and Clinical Evaluations. The primary purpose of the Intellectual Evaluation is to provide a measure of the client's current intellectual functioning, to give a description of the pattern of specific strengths and weakresses in intellectual ability, and to furnish an estimate of any intellectual deficit that may be present. This information is used as an aid in reaching a determination as to a client's eligibility for services and/or in developing a vocational rehabilitation plan. The evaluation is based on an interview and on an individually administered Intelligence Scale. In most instances, the Weschler Scale for Children are probably the most appropriate instruments.
The Clinical Evaluation includes the Intellectual Evaluation and a Personality Evaluation based primarily on projective techniques. The purpose of the Clinical Personality Evaluation is to provide an assessment of intellectual and personality factors for use in reaching a determination as to a client's eligibility for services and/or in developing a vocational rehabilitation plan, with consideration of personality dynamics and concomitant strengths and liabilities. Paper-andpencil personality tests may be included in the test battery, but they are not _ utilized as a substitute for projective instruments. Unless there is some good reason to the contrary for which an explanation is given, the Rorschach is usually included in the test battery. The Clinical Personality Evaluation is utilized when more information regarding personality factors is required than would be furnished by the Intellectual Evaluation. As indicated, the counselor has been provided with several tests which he uses with his clients, especially on training cases. There are more difficult cases where the counselor finds there is a need for more data than can be obtained from the psychometric examination he is prepared to administer. In these cases, the counselor purchases psychological evaluations.
* The Task Force gratefully acknowledges the special assistance given by Dr. Cecil Harbin, of the Atlanta Veterans Administration Hospital.

The following guidelines relating to Psychological Evaluations have been developed. They must be obtained when:

of long standing, and individuals whose employment record indicates they are "accident-prone."

1. Mental retardation has to be determined; i.e.,

Psychological Evaluation should be considered when:

a. The applicant's eligibility for rehabilitation is based on mental retardation as the primary impairment.
b. It is suspected that the applicant has subnormal intelligence as a secondary impairment.
2. Long term or expensive training is involved in a rehabilitation plan, i.e.,
a. The job objective under consideration involves college or university training;

1. The counselor needs information or confirmation of the client's abilities, aptitudes, achievements, interests, and personality patterns; i.e.,
a. The counselor or client is undecided about a vocational choice and desires information about the client's aptitudes, interests, achievements, and personality;
b. A tentative job choice has been made, which the counselor or client wishes to confirm through psychological evaluation;

b. The job objective under consideration involves business or vocational school training;
c. The job objective involves more than three months of apprentice on-the-job training;
d. The client's vocational background is not in the field of the skilled work for which he is being considered.
3. An individual is shown or suspected to have certain impairments that require specialized evaluations of his capacities, abilities, skills, interests, and personality; i.e.,

c. The job choice of the client is considered unsuitable by the counselor, who then seeks objective data with which to support or refute the tentative decision.
2. Data on the client's capacities and abilities are lacking, are ambiguous, or are contradictory; i.e.,
a. There is no educational or work record available for the client.
b. The case history shows serious contradictory data in regard to the client's capacities and abilities, and his expressed vocational interests.

a. Persons with actual or suspected brain or head injuries, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, or other conditions involving neuro-muscular disorders;
b. Persons who have mental retardation or emotional disturbances, or for whom it is desirable to determine whether a psychiatric consultation is indicated;
c. Persons with suspected mental deterioration;
d. Persons with other severe impairments which require specialized individual testing, such as the blind, the totally deaf and seriously hard of hearing, the aphasic, the paraplegic, those with severe reading disability, chronic cases

3. Important talents, capacities, abilities or impairments are suspected by the counselor or client; i.e.,
a. A special talent or capacity is suspected, but the case history shows no reliable evidence of its existence;
b. The counselor or client suspects that the latter has a specific impairment which will materially affect his successful pursuit of the vocational objective;
c. The client or counselor seeks to establish the equivalent of a certain level of education for the client, but he does not have the formal credits necessary to substantiate the claim, and the sub-

40

stituted equivalent credits determined

The provLsLon of psychological evalu-

through psychological tests are necessary

ation services as stated in the above

to attain the job objective in the most

guidelines is apparently satisfactory.

expeditious way.

There was no suggestion that there were

difficulties inherent in the program as

outlined above; however, there is appar-

ently some manpower problem in obtaining

a sufficient geographical coverage of

Psychological diagnosis and evaluation may not necessarily be required when:

psychologists in the State (see Map 3, Appendix B). Another pr~blem that is reported is the inordinate amount of time being spent by counselor to admin-

1. The client has very recently been successfully employed and intends to return to his work as soon as physical restoration services have been rendered;

ister the basic psychological and aptitude tests. Careful and extensive discussion led to a number of recommendations for utilization of other personnel to release counselors from the need to admin-

2. The person has been successfully

ister these tests themselves.

employed and is now unable to find similar work because of the prejudice of employers toward the handicapped, and it is necessary for the counselor to convince the employer that the client has the abilities required for the position;

The final area of evaluation considered by the task force was vocational evaluation. As presently operating, "in order for a client to be eligible for (OVR) services, the prognosis for vocational purposes must be a reasonable expectation that (OVR) services will render the indi-

3. The client has been successfully employed and only a minor change is contemplated in the type of work that he will do in the future;

vidual fit to engage in a gainful occupation within a reasonable length of time."6 "Gainful occupation includes employment in the competitive labor market; practice of a profession; self-employment; homemaking,

4. The counselor has a long and rich background of information on jobs held, the jobs are in related types of work, and the client has changed jobs for reasons beyond his control;

farm or family work (including work for which payment is in kind rather than cash); sheltered employment; and home industries or other homebound work of a remunerative nature."7

The vocational evaluation is based on

5. The counselor has a long and rich

data collected by the counselor. He uses

background of educational information, the

such information as the client's personal

caliber of the school which the client has history, family situation, social and

been attending is well established, the

economic status, personality traits, inter-

caliber of the teachers in important sub-

ests, aptitudes, work history, etc. It

jects is well established, and the client

is apparent that the vocational evaluation

does not plan to study or work in areas

is dependent on the counselor and client

unrelated to his background;

cooperating to develop a mutually agree-

able vocational objective for the client.

6. The client is not cooperative and

This vocational objective, stated in

does not desire to be tested. In such

varying degrees of specificity, is req-

cases, testing is contraindicated until

uisite to the provision of any services

the reasons for such uncooperative attitudes are understood and dealt with intel-

beyond diagnosis or evaluation. Six important factors influencing the selec-

ligently.

tion of the vocational objective are

identified:

6. Office of Vocational Rehabilitation, Manual of Policies, Sec. 5.05.
7. Cited from Regulations Governing the Vocational Rehabilitation Program, in the Office of Vocational Rehabilitation, Manual of Policies, Sec. 6.06.

41

1. Educational performance
2. Work experience
3. Avocational interests and abilities
4. Aptitudes and attitudes as demonstrated by appropriate tests
5. Availability of work in the selected vocational objective, and
6. Family or community situations that may affect achievement of the vocational objective.
Obviously, for some clients, several of these factors may not be relevant; e.g., a youngster without a work history, a person who has spent a long period of time in an institution, housewives. Further complications or delays to the vocational evaluation develop from the nature of severe or multiple impairments, the unstabilized nature of an impairment at the time of vocational evaluation, or the need for physical restoration services prior to the definition of a vocational objective.
The difficulty of defining vocational objectives for some clients is recognized, and the provision of six and eighteen months evaluation periods to obtain further information are provided for in the State Plan:
When the counselor is unable to determine that there is a reasonable expectation that (OVR) services may render the individual fit to engage in a gainful occupation and there is a physical or mental impairment which constitutes a substantial handicap to employment, the counselor may initiate an extended evaluation not to exceed eighteen months for those individuals whose disability is: (1) mental retardation, (2) deafness, (3) blindness, (4) paraplegia, quadriplegia, and any other spinal cord injuries or diseases, (5) heart disease, (6) cancer, (7) stroke, (8) epilepsy, (9) mental illness, (10) cerebral palsy, or (11) brain damage, and not in excess of six months in the case of any individual with any other impairment.8

It is permissible, therefore, to provide at least six months extended evaluation services to all clients for whom it is deemed necessary.
The experience in the last fiscal year indicates that relatively few clients are afforded these services. Of 26,588 clients who entered Applicant Status (02) in 1966-67, 12,657 (48 percent) were accepted without receiving extended evaluations, 110 (0.4 percent) entered six months and 187 (0.7 percent) entered eighteen months evaluations. Any interpretation of these figures must take into account the fact that this is the first fiscal year in which extended evaluations have been a part of the State's rehabilitation program. If the 5,893 applicants (22 percent) in 196667 who were rejected before acceptance or extended evaluation are subtracted from the applicants, then of the 20,695 remaining, 12,657 (61 percent) were accepted for six and eighteen months evaluations, respectively. Since there are a large number of clients who had not had final determination of their eligibility or had not been placed in extended evaluation by the end of the fiscal year, it is appropriate to use as the base the 12,954 who had been accepted or placed in extended evaluation. Using this last base, 97.7 percent were accepted for service without extended evaluation, 0.9 percent were placed in six months extended evaluation and 1.4 percent in eighteen months evaluation. It is apparent, whichever the appropriate base used, that a very small proportion of the clients are being placed in extended evaluation. 9
The policy of OVR provides that termination of the extended evaluation periods may occur prematurely for either of the following reasons: (1) when it is determined that there is a reasonable expectation that the client can be rendered fit to engage in a gainful occupation; or (2) it is determined that there is no reasonable likelihood that the client can be rendered fit to engage in a gainful occupation. The data available do not differentiate between premature termination and
8. Manual of Policies, Sec. 6.05.
9. Health, Education and Welfare, VRA Quarterly Cumulative Caseload Report, July-June, 1967.

42

full tenure in the evaluation period. It is logical to assume that since this is the first year of eighteen months evaluations any terminations that occurred during this year were in less than the full period of eighteen months; the logical distinction is not possible for the clients in the six months extended evaluation~ Of the 187 clients that entered eighteen months evaluations during 1966-67, 53 (28 percent) were accepted for further OVR services and 13 (7 percent) were rejected; an acceptance to rejection ratio of 4:1, with 121 (65 percent) still in evaluation. From the 110 in six months evaluations, 35 (32 percent) were accepted, 11 (10 percent) were rejected, 64 (58 percent) still remain; an acceptance to rejection ratio of about 3:1. When these acceptance to rejection ratios for extended evaluations are compared to other stages

of the client's career, as shown in Table 3, the ratios for extended evaluations fall between the extremes of other stages. It would seem that the tentative conclusion that the extended evaluation program has yielded a relatively high proportion of rehabilitation prospects is in order. We do not know, however, what the ratio for the total cohort wi!l be, or the reason for this performance. When it is realized that this group is likely to be the most problematic, it is possible that a selectivity bias is operating to provide extended evaluation to the "best of the worst", or the evaluation process itself has been most effective in evoking from the clients high levels of performance relative to their expected performance. As a new, and apparently critical, program it should be subjected to immediate and continuing assessment,

TABLE 3
RATIOS OF ACCEPTANCE TO REJECTIONS AT DIFFERENT STAGES OF THE CLIENT'S CAREER
1966-67

CHANGES IN STAGES

APPROXIMATE RATIO

Referrals becoming Applicants/Referrals rejected; i.e.

5:1

(Status 00 -+ Status 02)/(Status 00 -+ Status 08)

Applicants accepted/Applicants rejected; i.e.,

2:1

(Status 02 -+ Status 10)/(Status 02 -+ Status 08)

Accepted from 6 mos. evaluation/Rejected from 6 mos. evaluation;

3:1

i.e., (Status 04 -+ Status 10) I (Status 04 .... Status 08)

Accepted from 18 mos. evaluation/Rejected from 18 mos. evaluation;

4:1

i.e., (Status 06 .. Status 10)/(Status 06 .. Status 10)

Accepted to closed rehabilitated/Accepted to closed not

6:1

rehabilitated; i.e., (Status 10 + Status 26)/(Status 10 -+

Status 28 and 30)

43

Another explanation of the small proportion of clients being placed in extended evaluation is the possible lack of facilities for extended evaluation. Still another explanation is the effectiveness of short-term as opposed to extended evaluation programs. The availability of vocational evaluation facilities was examined using data reported in the Utilization Summary of Facilities and Workshops in Georgia. The relevant findings are reported in Table 4.

In relation to discharges, almost 4 out of 5 discharges from private facilities, 1 out of 2 from the OVR facilities, and 1 out of 3 from public facilities are clie~ts discharged to employment. Of all the discharges from the three kinds of facilities with work evaluation programs, over half (52 percent) went into employment. Only 1 out of 20 of all discharged clients went into extended workshop placements, with most of these coming from public facilities and fewest of these from OVR facilities. About 1 out of 8 of the discharged clients went into training, with most of these coming from OVR facilities which discharged 1 out of 4 into training.

There are 59 agencies included in the utilization report; 41 (70 percent) of the 59 reported that they provided some form of vocational evaluation services in combination with other evaluation and/or training services. There are no facilities reported to offer vocational evaluation services alone. Of the 41 facilities providing vocational evaluation services 16 (39 percent) are sponsored by the OVR, 14 (34 percent) are other public sponsored facilities, and 11 (27 percent) are private nonprofit facilities. As Table 4 shows, the 39 of 41 facilities reporting served 20,229 clients in the survey period (1966); of which 16 percent were served by 10 private facilities, 42 percent by 13 public facilities, and 42 percent by 16 OVR sponsored facilities. Almost half (47.7 percent) of the clients served in facilities with vocational evaluation were OVR referrals. The relative number of OVR clients to all clients was highest in OVR facilities (3 out of 4) and about 3 out of 10 in the public and private facilities. Of the 39 agencies reporting clients served, 24 also reported discharges. The lowest ratio of discharges to served is in the OVR facilities (1:3.8), followed by the public facilities (1:1.9), and the lowest ratio is in private facilities (1:1.5). Finally, the differences in kind of discharge are examined; discharges to employment (competitive+ homemaking+ homebound), extended workshop placement, and training.

These data indicate that the OVR has tended to use their own facilities which provide work evaluation rather than private agencies; 65 percent of the OVR referrals are to their own, 25 percent to public and 10 percent to private facilities.* Yet the agencies least used report the best results in terms of overall discharges and discharges to employment. This, however, may be the result of the multiplicity of services given rather than differences in work evaluation procedures alone. The OVR facilities are discharging fewer clients relative to those served, but more than any other kind of facilities, they are discharging clients into training. A number of very crucial data is not available from this source (e.g., average client stay, discharges by types of service, services provided OVR referrals) which would be helpful in determining the reasons for the few number of clients placed in extended evaluations.

*N.B.:

This is not to be construed as a
discussion of clients receiving work evaluation, but only about agencies providing this service,
since there are no data broken down by the clients receiving
different kinds of services.

44

TABLE 4 OVR USE OF FACILITIES PROVIDING WORK EVALUATION

No. of Facilities No. of Clients Served OVR REFERRALS No. of Facilities No. of OVR Clients % OVR Clients Discharges Facilities Reporting No. of Clients Served No. of Clients Discharged % of Clients Discharged Disposition No. into Employment % into Employment No. into Workshops % into Workshops No. into Training
to into Training

FACILITIES SPONSORSHIP

OVR

PUBLIC

PRIVATE

16

14

11

8,400

14 6,288
74.9

10 2,435
28.6

10 925 28.0

13 3,589
948 26.4

3 2,501 1,350
54.0

8 1,196
794 66.4

479 50.5
20 2.1 241 25.4

508 37.6
94 7.0 103 7.6

630 79.3
38 4.8
54 6.8

ALL FACILITIES
41 20, 229
34 9,648 47.7
24 7,286 3,092 42.4
1,617 52.3 152 4.9 398 12.9

1No information for one facility. Source: VRA-32 Reports

45

The findings related to the evaluation

has reviewed the case or another profes-

stage of the client career have provided

sional person who has evaluated the client.

the basis for several recommendations that The final responsibility for making a re-

are reported later. In conclusion, it is

ferral for psychotherapy rests with the

apparent that for the most part the process counselor who must decide that the client's

of evaluation except for possibly psycho-

emotional problems are interfering with

social areas has been well developed, and

the rehabilitative process.

judging by the outcomes, evaluation in com-

bination with treatment and training produces a respectable ratio of eventual suc-

Individual psychotherapy is used to pro-

cesses to failures.

vide personal guidance and adjustment

training with the goal of enabling the

handicapped client to engage in a remuner-

ative occupation. The service involves

the utilization and application of psycho-

logical principles and appropriate tech-

C. Treatment and Training Procedures

niques in providing help to individual clients in cooperation with the efforts

Once the client has completed the evaluation process and has been determined to be eligible for rehabilitation services, the further steps in his career are treatment and training. This section considers the current practices and procedures in these areas of client services. As presently constituted, the OVR can provide

of the rehabilitation counselor. These principles and techniques, for example, may include individual psychotherapy/ counseling, conditioning ~ethqds, habit training, and learning techniques which provide for improved motivation, communication, learning, adjustment, adaptation and vocational attainment.

as part of its services a wide array of

treatments; medical, surgical, psycho-

logical, vocational adjustment, appli-

Group psychotherapy is considered when-

ances, etc. Usually such services are

ever the client is particularly in need of

limited to: (1) treatment of impairments

help with problems of socialization which

(physical or mental) that handicap the

can be acquired through group opportuni-

client's occupational performance (2)

ties for social reality testing. This

relatively stable impairments, and (3)

service involves the utilization and appli-

impairments amenable to treatment within

cation of psychological principles and

a reasonable period of time (usually 12

appropriate techniques in group psycho-

months). In the case of physical restor-

therapy/counseling, group dynamics or con-

ation the following specific services are

ditioning methods, milieu therapy and

currently available: (1) medical treat-

learning techniques which provide for

ment, (2) specialists' services in the

improved socialization, acceptance of

fields suitable to the specific med~cal

training, supervision, and help, motiva-

or surgical problems, (3) nursing serv-

tion, communication, adjustment, social

ices, (4) hospitalization. (5) dentistry,

adaptation and vocational attainment.

(6) drugs and supplies, (7) physical and

These services are arranged in cooperation

occupational therapy, and (8) prosthetic appliances.l3

with the rehabilitation counselor's plan and goals for the clients involved.

In the examination of evaluation procedures the availability of medical personnel is discussed, and will not be reexamined. In addition to medical treatment, where the provision of services is within the usual limitations stated above, psychiatric treatment (psychotherapy) is available. A referral for psychotherapy is made upon the recommendation of a consultant who
13. Manual of Policies, Sec. 8.30.

Personal and/or social and/or work adjustment may be provided for clients to the extent necessary to achieve the client's placement into a vocation. Comprehensive evaluation needs to be completed prior to writing a plan for adjustment training in order that appropriate, specific methods of training can be outlined in the plan. Personal adjustment training may include training in areas such as personal hygiene,

'+0

Having completed the objective assess-

He randomly sampled 2,159 OVR clients who

ment of evaluation procedures, it is reasonable to raise the question of how they

received training in the three years, 1961-63. Of these 2,010 were closed as

are working. For the most part the preceding has focused upon the process stated in expected terms (i.e., what the present program should be), however, the other question that needs to be asked is how

rehabilitated (93 percent) and 149 were closed not rehabilitated. Of the total 2,159 clients sampled, 1,871 (87 percent) completed training; 94 percent of them completed training and were closed as

are these programs being implemented. The

rehabilitated. Of the' 288 (13 percent)

ratio of closed rehabilitated to closed not rehabilitated is 6:1, which is the highest "success" to "failure" ratio of

not completing training, 61 percent were closed rehabilitated. Unfortunately, comparisons of the rehabilitated and not

any stage of the program for which data

rehabilitated groups for factors relevant

is available (see Table 3, supra). The

to evaluation are not available. Some

most selective stage is the evaluation

data do, however, suggest a number of

period (applicant to accepted status) in

important aspects.

which the ratio of acceptance to rejec-

tions is 2:1. The question is then raised if within the evaluation process, only

First the facilities used to evaluate physical and mental capacities are exam-

"sure bets" are being taken to the detri-

ined.11 During the five-year period (1961-

ment of more problematic clients. Is the

65) almost half (47 percent) of the sample

quality of evaluation, and the requisite

was evaluated in appraisal clinics or reha-

knowledge, of such caliber that there is

bilitation centers. Similar proportions

a high degree of certainty that those ac-

received physical and mental capacities

cepted for services would fail to be "reha- evaluations in the two kinds of facilities;

bilitated" if denied these OVR services,

21 percent and 26 percent, respectively.

and conversely those denied the services

Appraisal clinics were used about equally

would fail even though given them? The

for mental capacities (14 percent) and

answer to this critical question is one

physical capacities (16 percent) evalu-

that requires an experimental approach,

ations. Rehabilitation centers were more

and is beyond immediate solution. There

than twice as frequently the facility used

are data available from one study which

for evaluation of mental capacities (12

reflects, tangentially on this issue.

percent) than physical capacities (5 percent). The author cautions that in inter-

In the "Follow-up Study and Evaluation

preting these data it must be noted that

of Training Provided Clients by the Georgia in many instances the clients received

Office of Vocational Rehabilitation," the adequacy of case development was examined.

both physical and mental capacities evaluations.

Buice states:

The principal contribution of this study

The data are taken from responses to relevant questions of the counselor interview schedule and from the interviewer's evaluation of those interviews. The questions were related to the aids the counselor used in the evaluation

to our concern with evaluation, is the adequacy of evaluation ("case development") which the author examined. Table 5 presents a reanalysis of the data he provides. There is virtually no difference in the counselors' judgments of adequacy of evaluations for those clients completing and

of the client in areas of physical

those not completing training. The ade-

capacity, intellect, emotional sta-

quacies of these evaluations as judged by

bility, background, motivation and

the research interviewer are less than the

home situation . Judgment of ade-

counselors' in a number of areas; e.g.,

quacy was based upon the different

physical restoration, intellectual and

aids used in each case and whether

the the

aid was adequate

considered essential evaluation of the cl

t i

o e

n

t.

10

emotional evaluations. It is interesting to note that in the remaining areas of background, motivation and home situation

10. Buice, p. 54.

11. Ibid., Table 19, p. 58.

47 TABLE 5 ADEQUACY OF CASE DEVELOPMENT BY TRAINING COMPLETIONS (Percent Judged Adequate)

EVALUATION AREA PhYsical Restoration Intellectual Emotional Background Motivation Home Situation
N

TRAINING COMPLETED
98 94 99 100 100 100 1,871

TRAINING NOT COMPLETED 98 94 100 100 100 100 288

BOTH COMPLETED BY COUNSELOR 98 94 99 100 100 100 2,159

NOT COMPLETED BY INTERVIEWER'>':
89 74 95 100 99 100 2,159

*Rating based on aids used by counselor Source: Buice (Tables 1, 18, 31)

evaluations, objective measures are not readily obtainable, yet both counselors and interviewers rate these at or near 100 percent adequacy. This is more significant when the reasons for not completing training are examined. Half of those failing to complete training were discontinued for reasons similar or related to these more subjective areas of evaluation; namely, lack of motivation (17 percent), emotional instability (12 percent), home situation (11 percent) and failure to adjust (10 percent). These were also the most frequent single reasons given for discontinuing training. 12
Although limited in applicability, the findings of this study suggest a number of directions for concern with the evaluation process as presently constituted. As defined, counselors admit to a less than adequate intellectual evaluation of clients going into training. This may be confirmation of the previous finding that under the present provisions of
12. Ibid., p. 85.

services, the administration of psychological tests is an undue burden on counselors. Secondly, and more critical, the areas that account for the most discontinuity between objective and outcome (i.e., failure to complete training) are attributed to areas which are judged by both counselors and interviewers to be most adequate with the evaluation aids available. This finding suggests two possible aspects of the evaluation process that need to be considered in any future developments. First, the aids currently being used do not provide reliable information about the client that contributes to the accurate prediction of outcome, or secondly, the aids provide reliable data, but these are not related to the factors that account for failures to complete training. The area of psychosocial evaluation would appear then, on the basis of the data available, to be the poorest developed or the least reliable. It is singled out above all other areas of evaluation as apparently the most inadequate.

48
grooming, dress, manners and appropriate behavioral reaction patterns. Social adjustment training may include training in areas such as social relationships, table manners, r~lationships with peer group and authority figures, recreation, use of leisure time, and dating. Work adjustment training may include training in such areas as how to conduct an employment interview, how to maintain appropriate relationships with other employees, how to accept supervision and authority, how to establish a proper employeeemployer relationship, punctuality, employee-employer obligations, remedial academic instructions to improve vocational proficiency, and/or any other training to develop adequate worker traits, habits and attitudes leading to a vocation.
Training in the above areas may be secured through numerous means and resources such as in the pre-vocational special education classroom, in training stations within the school, in vocational education classes, in training stations in community businesses, through individual and group counseling provided by a psychologist and vocational rehabilitation staff member, and/or through facilities and service~ provided in institutional sett~ngs. 14
As with evaluation the area of treatment can be divided into medical, psychological, personal and vocational therapies. In addition to the distribution of physicians and hospitals (already discussed) there are a number of other services and facilities that are used in treatment and training.
In a recent survey of rehabilitation facilities there were 59 offering a wide spectrum of services. 15 To reduce complexities in analysis, the following groupings have been made:
14. Ibid., Sec. 8.22.

Sponsorship
1. Office of Vocational Rehabilitation (OVR)
2. Public Supported (PUB), including City County State (other than OVR) Other Public
3. Private, Non-profit (PRIV), including Community non-profit associations Church affiliated Other non-profit
Services
1. Medical, Psychological and Social Evaluation and Treatment (Dx/Rx), including Physical and medical evaluation Medical management Physical therapy Occupational therapy Speech and hearing services Medical consultation Psychological services, diagnostic and treatment Social services
2. Vocational Evaluation (VocEv)
3. Vocational Training and Treatment (VocTr) including Pre-vocational and vocational training Vocational counseling/rehabilitation counseling Personal adjustment training, including mobility Job conditioning Job placement Extended employment Transitional employment Others
The combination of the three types of service in various arrangements is the basis for the analysis presented in Tables 4, 6 and 7. Of the 59 facilities reported, 35 (60 percent) provide all three types of services, 15 (18 percent) provide two types of services, and 13 (22 percent) provide only one type of service. The sponsorship of the facilities is about evenly divided between OVR (30 percent), Public (34 percent) and Private (36 percent); 18, 20 and 21 facilities respectively.

15. Utilization Summaries of Facilities and Workshops, VRA-32 Reports for Georgia.

49

The comprehensive facilities offering all three types of services had the highest proportion of discharges (42.7 percent), of which over half of the clients were discharged into employment (51.7 percent). The other facilities reporting had a lower rate of discharge (25 percent), but had more clients being discharged into employment (71.4 percent). The same was found with regard to discharges into training, with the comprehensive facilities discharging 12.8 percent and the other- discharging 14.3 percent into training. In absolute numbers, however, the comprehensive facilities account for much greater numbers of client discharges.

span of the client's career with which the OVR is concerned. While OVR facilities discharge fewer clients relative to those served, the proportions discharged into training and employment are higher than either the public or private facilities (75.9 percent). Half of the discharges from OVR facilities are into employment, with only a s'lightly larger proportion of discharges from private facilities going into employment; 50.5 percent to 51.~ percent, respectively. Far more clients from OVR facilities are discharged into training, and fewer into extended workshop placement than either public or private facilities.

As seen in Table 6, the facilities providing all three types of service are most used (90 percent) by the OVR for treatment and training of this group of 10,438 OVR referrals; the majority (60 percent) being treated and trained in OVR sponsored facilities. The next greatest usage is of facilities offering only diagnostic and treatment services (5 percent), but these are mostly private ones as OVR sponsors only one facility providing this single service. From the 59 facilities, discharge information was provided by 25, with most of these facilities (20) offering all three types of services. Four facilities offered vocational training and treatment only, and one offered vocational evaluation, and vocational treatment and training. There were no facilities that provided vocational evaluation alone; this occurred in some combination with other services (see Table 4, supra).

It is concluded that the OVR has used its own facilities, and that these have performed at a level equal to or better than facilities with other kinds of sponsorship. It is not possible to determine, from the available data, if this is the result of more effective services or greater selectivity. For the present it would appear that OVR has developed a group of facilities that in comparison with other facilities are performing effectively. The important question is raised, however, of the adequacy of these services to meet present and anticipated needs.
Two special surveys, conducted as part of the Statewide Planning Project, provide information that relates to the perceived adequacy of existing facilities; the "Counselor Questionnaires" (CQ) and the "Agency Survey Report" (ASR). In the first (CQ) survey the respondents were asked:

In Table 7 facilities have been grouped by sponsorship without regard to types of services provided. As anticipated the largest proportion of OVR referrals in any group of facilities are in the OVR sponsored ones (75.4 percent), and fewest in private ones (5.6 percent). On the other hand more private facilities received OVR referrals than any other sponsorship. When performance in terms of discharges reported is examined, it is found that the OVR facilities have the lowest ratio of discharges to served (26.4 percent). Possibly this is explained by the more precise conditions required to close cases and the prolonged

1. What facilities, if they were available in suitable locations with adequate capacity, are most needed by you in your work?
2. What are the most important areas toward which this planning effort could be directed?
The responses to the two questions were combined from 351 counselors in the OVR with the following needs relatgd to treatment and training identified: 1
16. Counselor Questionnaire, Table III, p. 5.

TABU!; 6
DVR USE OF FACILITIES BY TYPES OF SERVICES AND SPONSORSHIP (SOURCE VRA-32 REPORTS FOR GEORGIA)

TYPES OF SERVICES PROVIDED

No. of Total

Dx/Rx Voc.Ev. Voc. Tr. Spon. Fac. Served

Yes

Yes

Yes

DVR

16

8,400

PUB. 14

a 8,521

PRIV

5

1 694

TOTAL 35 18,615

DVR Refer. 6,288 2,435
676 9,399

%DVR Clients
74.9 28.6 39.9 50.5

No.Fac. With DVR

Dischargir

No.

NQ.

Disch. Sen

14

948

3, 5l

10

1,350

2, 5(

10

715

9~

34

3,013

7;01

Yes

Yes

No

DVR

0

PUB.

0

PRIV. 2

1 388

134

9.7

1

TOTAL 2

1,388

134

9.7

1

Yes

No

Yes

DVR

1

150

150

PUB.

2 1,750

79

PRIV,

2

319

5

TOTAL

5 2,219

234

No

Yes

Yes

DVR

0

PUB.

0

PRIV.

4

226a

115

TOTAL

4

226

115

No

No

Yes

DVR

0

PUB.

1

113

20

PRIV.

2

52

9

TOTAL

3

165

29

Yes

No

No

DVR

1

40

40

PUB.

3 4,380

40

PRIV.

6 21,222

447

TOTAL 10 25,642

527

TOTAL ALL TYPES

59 48,255 10,438

a - one facility made no report of no. served.

100.0 4.5 1.6 10.5
50.9 50.9
17.7 17.3 17.6 100.0
0.9 2.1 2.1 40.1

1 2 1 4

1

79

22

1

79

22

1

5

1

7

2

12

1

2

6

9 51 3,104

11 2
13:
7,424

~lit:z:
~ Disch. lor Served
26.4
54.0
73.7
42.7

Disch. to Employment

No.

%

479

50.5

508

37.6

572

80.0

1,559

51.7

Disc~arge to Workshop

No.

%

20

2.1

94

7.0

31

4.3

145

4.8

Disch. to Train-

ing

No.

%

241

25.4

103

7.6

43

6.0

387

12.8

35.0 35.0
4.4 28.0
8.7

58

73.4

58

73.4

4

80.0

3

42.9

7

58.3

7

7

8.9

0

0

0

0

0

0

11

11

13.9

1

20.0

1

14.3

2

16.7

41.8

1,624

52.3

152

4.9

400

12.9

TABLE 7 USE OF FACILITIES BY SPONSORSHIP

SPONSORSHIP
OVR Public Private

NO. OF

TOTAL

FACILITIES SERVED

18

8,590

20

14,764a

21

24,90la

OVR REFERRED
6,478
2,574 1,3?6

% OVR CLIENTS
75.4
17.4 5.6

NO. OF FACILITIES WITH OVR
16
15 20

NO. DISCHARGED
948
1,355 801

SERVED BY DISCHARGED FACILITY
3,589
2,614 1,221

%
DISCHARGED
26.4
51.8 65.6

:n:> SPONSORSHIP OVR Public Private

DISCHARGED TO EMPLOYMENT

NO.

%

479

50.5

512

37.8

633

51.8

DISCHARGED TO WORKSHOP

NO.

%

20

2.1

94

6.9

38

3.1

DISCHARGED TO TRAINING

NO.

%

241

25.4

104

7.7

55

4.5

aOne facility made no report of number served. Source: Table 5

Workshops

143

Work adjustment and

58

training centers

Evaluation centers

40

Comprehensive rehabili- 33 tation facilities and residences

(33.3%) (13.5%)
( 9.3%) ( 7.7%)

jl
reflect a need for specific treatment and training programs. The bulk of responses from workers in these two agencies related to services to specific disability groups (e.g., mentally handicapped, alcoholics, children). The need for services to the following groups was reported:

Mental illness, retar- 72 dation and illiteracy

(11.0%)

274 (62.8%)

All responses

429

The counselors by their responses suggest the need for treatment and training centers beyond those presently available. The other survey (ASR) requested similar information from workers in the Departments of Public Health, and Family and Children Services. The 652 responses to the following questions were combined:

1. What services do you feel (OVR) should add, delete, emphasize, or de-emphasize?

2. What gaps in service do you see?

3. In your opinion what are the most important areas toward which this planning effort could be directed?

The combined responses from the 173 respondents about areas of needed emphasis related to treatment and training are: 17

Workshop and training programs

53 ( 8.1%)

General medical and den- 33 tal programs and services

( 5.1%)

Visual (training) services

17 ( 2.6%)

103 (15.8%)

All responses

652

A much smaller proportion of these responses from personnel outside of the OVR

17. Agency Survey Report, Tables I and II, pp. 3, 6.

Children and families

27

Special handicapped

22

groups; e.g., stroke,

TB, diabetes

Aged or middle aged

22

( 4.1%) ( 3.4%)
( 3.4%)

143 (21.9%)

If it is assumed that these identify general areas of service needs, it can be argued that they furthermore imply that extension of existing services, facilities and staffs will be necessary. The limited evidence available to us suggests strongly that there are facilities that are available at present, they are being used effectively; but they are not sufficient for current or anticipated demand. Specifically, we refer to the greater demand for treatment and training facilities, and services for current OVR eligible persons, and for other impaired groups which are at present only marginally served or excluded by OVR.
In addition to the training facilities included in the previous discussion there is another group of facilities that is used for vocational training by the OVR. The OVR maintains a listing of approved training facilities, with conditions for inclusion on the list based on accreditation, previous experience with the facility or the OVR's own investigations. These facilities are grouped as follows:
1. Colleges and universities (accredited by the Certification Division of the Georgia State Department of Education);

2 State and area vocational schools (public schools under the supervision of the Division of Vocational Education of the Georgia State Department of Education);

52

3. Private vocational schools (approved

and enlarged facilities and curriculums,

by the OVR Supervisor of Guidance, Training, and raised entrance requirements, in an

and Placement)

effort to improve the quality of training.

4. Business schools (primarily for shorter-term secretarial and stenographic training, approved by the OVR Supervisor of Guidance, Training, and Placement);
5. Employment training (on-the-job training, work under normal job conditions without pay, in situations approved after thorough investigation by the OVR counselor); and
6. Other training situations (e.g., tutorial arrangements, correspondence schools--used in special situations).
There is an order of preference in the use of training facilities; first for public facilities in the State of Georgia, private facilities within the State, and then outof-state facilities.
The recent study of training clients by Buice provides useful information for examining the effectiveness of the various training programs. The study included a sample of OVR clients receiving training in the years from 1961-66. The conclusions of the author, relevant to the concerns of this task force are:
1. The degree of success attained in the rehabilitation of clients is indicative of the fact that the Georgia (OVR) has been aware of the changing and expanding occupational structure, and has provided the needed training services to adequately prepare its clients for secure employment in a competitive labor market
3. Successful efforts have been made to assure clients of quality training through the subjective/objective (sic) selection of both the public and private training institutions of Georgia
5. The (OVR) provides training services in most professions, vocations, and trades, in a myriad of public and private institutions as well as training situations and stations with individuals, business, and industry.
6. The public technical and vocational schools of Georgia have been used to train increasing numbers of (OVR) clients. These schools have increased in number, expanded

7. The (OVR) has been providing most of. its training to clients under (the age of) 35.
8. The older clients, having more dependents, family obligations, and less formal training, were provided vocational and trade training. However, there is indication of a trend toward increasing use of the public technical and vocational schools in training clients, especially those who have as much as 11 and 12 years of formal training.
9. Efforts to rehabilitate mentally ill clients resulted in a significant increase in the percentage of mentally ill clients being provided training services.
10. Efforts have been successful in satisfactorily meeting both the economic and social needs in the provision of training services for clients, as the needs arose. The economic status, vocational adjustment and stability of employment of clients have been improved.
11. Employers are well pleased with the training, adjustment, and work output of the trained (OVR) clients.
12. Clients have benefited from the training through improved social adjustment, improved attitudes, self-evaluation, and a greater feeling of security in the family and in the community.
14. Kinds of training and client impairments are not related except in cases in which the impairment may preclude training for and/or employment in a given occupation.
15. Clients, as they are further removed in time from their training experiences, tend to move into better paying occupations in which they no longer use the specific training provided them by the (OVR). This is interpreted to be a healthy tendency since it reflects the vocational adjustment and flexibility of the clients following their receipt of the (OVR's) training services.

53

16. The vocational evaluation process can be improved by a more adequate assessment of the client's intellectual abilities. This, in turn, should reduce the number of drop-outs or failures to complete training programs.
17. The vocational evaluation process can be improved further by a more extensive use of the aids and resources which are available to the counselor.
18. There is a tendency toward an increase in the use of public facilities and institutions to train (OVR) clients, at all training levels
22. The major reasons for the poor achievement in training, failures, and drop-outs are: (1) the client's lack of motivation, (2) the client's emotional instability and failure in adjusting to training situations, (3) the client's problems and difficulties at home. This implies a need for a more continuous counseling relationship in training cases.
23. The percentage of clients who completed their training programs, increased significantly during the five years (from 1961 to 1966) .
25. The college trainees completing training, have a higher percentage of rehabilitation than those trainees of the other groups who complete training, while the public vocational school trainees have the lowest percentage rehabilitated.
26. The percentage rehabilitated from the group not completing training programs is significantly less than that o f t h ose camp 1et1.ng t ra1.n1. ng programs. 18
The acceptance of these conclusions as validly derived from the findings, suggests that for the most part the OVR has utilized the training aspects of their program quite well. There is a high proportion of successful rehabilitants among those provided training (93 percent) than the overall percent of closed rehabilitated (86 percent). Once again, however, the question about selectivity arises: to what extent are clients not provided training, capable of
18. Buice, pp. 108-11.

utilizing it?; to what extent would clients presently being given training be "rehabilitated" without the provision of such training services? As before when these questions were raised, the answers, though crucial to any consideration of future services, can be answered only through experimentation and research. The design and implementation of such research, and the obtaining of results upon which to assess the maximum effectiveness of training services requires careful planning, control and financial and temporal resources. It is apparent that OVR has, as Buice states in his conclusions, shown a willingness and commitment to program innovations and evaluative research. The expanded and continued research and innovative programs are requisite to the improvement and growth of the OVR.
Another concern of the task force related to the area of training is the projected growth and development of the local and area vocational schools program. As Buice demonstrated, these are second only to colleges and universities in their use as training facilities. The State Department of Education, Division of Vocational Education, is actively engaged in the development of more extensive and higher level vocational training programs for Georgia.
Projections of the future needs for vocational education are based on an estimated 55,000 youngsters in 1967 who presumably need additional skills to enter the labor market, and even greater numbers in the future. It is recognized that the characteristics of these students are greatly variable; ranging from disadvantaged to middle class backgrounds, and a variety of class, ethnic, religious and racial backgrounds. It is estimated that 90 percent of the occupations in Georgia do not require a college degree for entrance. It is the training of individuals for entry into these occupations that is the province of vocational education. A recent report states,
A brief list of occupations reported in the Occupational Outlook Handbook, which offers rapidly increasing employment, for which vocational education should offer training includes stenographers, secretaries, office machine oper-

ators, wholesale salesmen, manufac-

turer's salesmen, real estate sales-

mopetn~,. can1ur

ses aides, h technicians,

ospital privat

e

attenda house-

n

t

s

,

hold workers, child care center attend-

ants, build

i

cooks, ng trad

ch es

ecfrsa, ftcsomsemne, tomlaoignitsetns~nce

and repair servicemen, horticulture

and landscape technologists, farm

machinery repairmen, and instrumen-

tation technicians. This list is by

no means exhaustive, but it does give

an idea of the direction which voca-

tional education might take.l9

54

training is the cost of While the effectiveness

othfestheesseervasicpeecs~s

of the OVR program as presently consti-

tuted has been examined, the question of.

cost efficiency has not. To assess the

cost efficiency of the evaluation, treatment and training aspects of the OVR program, Geq!gia's expenditures for case services in the fiscal years 1964-66 are compared to those of the 49 other states. These data are shown in Table 8, and are taken fr~m the Federal V.R.A. Program Reports for those fiscal years.

It is realistic to consider further development of vocational education programs as highly probable, and as having important effects on the OVR training programs. Specifically, the Division of Vocational Education is currently engaged in a study for arriving at a detailed plan for the direction of vocational education in Georgia for the next five years. This year-long study is for the purpose of developing detailed plans for secondary and post-secondary vocational programs, and facilities, to serve the State's anticipated needs. Many issues have been raised for examination during this proposed study, one of which
has particular interest to the OVR, that
of providing a pre-vocational progLam that will offer an exploratory experience for students.

The projections and plans of the State

Department of Education have far-reaching

implications for the provision of services

by the OVR. for example,

It is reasonable that an enlarged

ptorogarsasmumoe f'

service occupations that do not require

more than high school level for entry may

provide a more desirable facility for the

training of mildly retarded clients.

D. The Cost of Evaluation, Treatment and Training
The final consideration in the examination of evaluation, treatment and

19. Division of Vocational Education, p. 2.

As Table 8 shows, Georgia spent less per

client for every type of service (except

rehabilitation and adjustment centers) than

the other forty-nine states. While it has

been established that the ratio for "closed

rehabilitctted" to "closed not rehabili-

tated" for Georgia is 6:1, we do not know

the comparable ratios fo although on a per capita

r

the basis

other Geor

state gia is

s'

very high in the number rehabilitated. In

total case services costs per rehabilitant,

Georgia is about 10 percent less than the

rest of the U.S.; $610 and $670 per reha-

bilitant, respectively. The allocation of

these monies to specific types of services

are, however, quite different for Georgia

and the rest of the United States.

From every $100 spent for case services, Georgia spent $9.70 for diagnostic procedures and the rest of the U.S. spent $8.30. From every $100 Georgia spent $35.60 for surgery, treatment, hospitalization and convalescent care (exclusive of rehabilitation and adjustment centers and not part of diagnosis); the rest of
the u.s. spent less than half that amount,
$17.30. Out of every $100 spent on case service, Georgia spent $21.50 for training and related services (e.g., materials, maintenance, transportation, licenses, tools) compared to the $45.70 spent by the other states. Georgia spent $28.60 of every $100 of case services monies for workshops and rehabilitation and adjustment centers; the rest of the states spent $23.20. For the fiscal years 1964-66 Georgia spent twice as much, relative to its case services monies, for treatment and care, half as much for training and related services, and slightly less for diagnostic procedures, prosthetics, workshops, rehabilitation adjustment centers than the other forty-nine states.

TABLE 8
CASE SERVICES EXPENDITURES FOR GEORGIA AND THE FORTY-NINE OTHER STATES (1964-66)

TYPE OF CASE SERVICE Diagnostic Procedures

GEORGIA DOLLARS CLIENTS _(OOO's) SERVED

DOLLARS PER CLIENT

to OF ALL DOLLARS SPENT

GA. OTHER U.S. GA. OTHER U.S.

$ 1,305.6 38,317 $ 34 $ 29

9. n

8 3/o

lo OF ALL CLIENTS SERVED
GA. OTHER u.s.
45 6/o 47.8%

CLIENTS SERVED PER REHABILITANTS

GA. OTHER u.s.

1. 74

1. 94

Surgery and Treatment

2,102.3 15,972

131

145

15.6

8.0

19.0

9.2

.72

.37

Prosthetic Appli&nces

620.1 4,968

125

161

4.6

5.5

5.9

5.5

.23

.23

Hospitalization and Convalescent Care

2,694.5 10,581

255

294

20.0

9.3

Training and Training

1,661.2 6,082

273

421

12.4

28.7

Materials

Maintenance and Transportation

779.0 4,172

187

234

5.8

14.9

Tools, Equipment Licenses etc.

437.5 1,654

265

204

3.3

2.1

Rehabilitation and Ad1ustment Centers

3,741.4 1,823 2,052

461

27.8

19.0

Wor~~shops

102.9

391

263

326

.8

4.2

12.6 7.3 5.0 2.0 2.0 .5

5.2 11.3 10.4
1.7 6.8 2.1

.48

.21

'Jl

VI

.28

.47

19

.42

08

06

08

.27

02

.09

All Case Services

$13,444.5 22' 033"( $ 610~h'( $ 67~b'( iiOO.OO 100.00

99.90 100.00

--

--

- - - --

--

---------

~(Number closed rehabilitated, 1964-66 **Dollars spent on all services per rehabilitant

Source: VRA Program Data

_lV

Of all OVR clients given different case services (i.e., the sum of the clients given each separate case service, not the number of individual clients served) slightly less than half of them were those given diagnostic procedures; 45.6 percent in Georgia and 47.8 percent in the rest
of the u.s. Surgery, hospitalization, and
other care and treatment (except in workshops, rehabilitation and adjustment centers) accounted for 37.5 percent of the Georgia client services, and 19.9 percent for the other states. Training and training related services accounted for 14.3 percent of the Georgia clients served,
and 23.4 percent for the rest of the u.s.
Services given in workshops and rehabilitation and adjustment centers accounted for 2.5 percent of the Georgia client services and 8.9 percent in the other states. Similar trends are seen when the cases served per 100 rehabilitated are examined.
For every 100 rehabilitants in Georgia in 1964-66, there ~ere 174 given diagnostic services and in the rest of the U.S. there were 194 given diagnostic services per 100 rehabilitated. Almost twice as many clients were given surgery, and other treatments per 100 rehabilitated in Georgia than in the rest of the U.S.; 72 and 37 per 100 rehabilitants, respectively. The same differences hold for hospital and convalescent care, where in Georgia 49 per 100 rehabilitants received these services compared to 21 per 100 rehabilitants in the rest of the states. The direction of the differences changes in the provision of training and training related services, workshops and rehabilitation and adjustment center services. Georgia provided training and training materials to 28 clients per 100 rehabilitants compared to the 47 per
100 rehabilitants in the rest of the u.s.
Transportation and maintenance were given to 19 clients per 100 rehabilitants in Georgia, and to 42 per 100 rehabilitants in the rest of the states. Services in rehabilitation and adjustment centers were given to 8 Georgia clients per 100 rehabilitants and 2 Georgia clients per 100 rehabilitants received services in workshops; in the rest of the United States there were 27 clients served in rehabilitation and adjustment centers and 9 clients served in workshops per 100 rehabilitants. The clients given prosthetic services, tools, licenses and equipment per 100 rehabilitants were about the same in Georgia and the rest of the states.

This analysis clearly points to a differential allocation of resources in Georgia and the rest of the United States. Georgia has provided a bulk of services and allocated relatively more of its rehabilitation dollars to surgery, treatment, hospital and convalescent care, and considerably less to training and training related services. In the other forty-nine states the allocation of resources and the proportion of clients given services are more weighted toward training and training related services and less for surgery, treatment and hospital care. Another discrepancy between Georgia and the rest of the states appears in the proportion of rehabilitation dollars and clients served in rehabilitation and adjustment centers. There are proportionally more dollars spent and fewer clients served by these facilities in Georgia than in the
rest of the u.s. It is not known if these
expenditures include those made for plant, equipment and other capital improvements which in part may explain the disproportionality of Georgia's expenses. In recent years Georgia has been building such facilities, whereas they have been long established in other states; e.g., the major state rehabilitation facility at Warm Springs opened in June 1964, the Atlanta Employment and Evaluation Center in October 1965.
The most disturbing aspect of these findings is the maldistribution of resources and clients between treatment and training services. If we assume that this reflects the needs of Georgia's OVR eligible population rather than selectivity of cases for OVR services, the planning for 1975 takes on one perspective. If on the other hand the explanation of this diSproportional distribution is in the selectivity of cases to obtain those who require only physical restoration in order to enter or re-enter gainful employment, the implications for the development of future services for "all those in need of it" portends a serious inadequacy in need of readjustment.
In the course of its deliberations it has become apparent to this task force that the extent and delivery of medical and health services to the less affluent segments of State's population as well as in the rest of the United States is changing markedly by virtue of the provision of health and medical care for aged and the medically indigent under Titles XVIII and XIX. The declared goal of Title XIX by 1975 is to:

'J/

furnish medical assistance in behalf of families with dependent children, and of aged, blind or permanently and totally disabled individuals whose resources are insufficient to meet the costs of necessary medical services and secondly, rehabilitation and other services to help such families and individuals attain or retain capability for independence or selfcare, and finally that states shall progressively broaden the scope, amount and duration of medical care toward a goal of comprehensive service for all medically indigent by 1975. 20
In Georgia such planning is actively being undertaken by the State's Department of Health, and the implementation of such a comprehensive plan has major implications for the future provision of services by OVR and other agencies providing services to the disabled. It is likely that the bulk of surgery, treatment, hospitalization and other physical restoration costs will be borne by other programs and agencies. What then of OVR, given its present penchant for physical restoration services rather than for training services: will there be a 30 to 40 percent decrease in fund allocations to parallel the decline in needs to serve a large portion of its former clientele or can OVR at the same or increased funding levels, provide a broader range of evaluation, treatment and training services to more clients?
If the present emphasis on physical restoration is in response to the heretofore unmet needs of the State's disabled population, and where to the extent of available resources, training has been provided and emphasized, then the implementation of Title XIX will relieve the OVR of a costly and imposing part of its programo If this is the condition that exists, then the funding of OVR at increased or the same levels will permit the allocation of its resources to training, diagnosis and treatment of more complex and non-physical impairments. In exam~n~ng the projections for client disabilities it is quite apparent that in
20. Schaefer, p. 56, italics added.
21. Wyckoff, Fig. 5.

the years to come, the majority of clients will be those with mental impairments;21 the major challenges even without the provisions of Title XIX would be non-physical impairment.
If, and hopefully this is not the case, the high proportion of clients and resources allocated to physical restoration services is the consequences of a deliberate or unintentional selectivity of cases, the implementation of Title XIX has very serious implications for the provision of services by OVR in the future. First, having dealt primarily with the "easy cases" the provision of comprehensive medical care competes for this clientele. Remaining for the OVR is an accumulated clientele of non-physically impaired; those with multiple problems of which physical impairment is but a minor aspect, and those whose physical impairments are great but irreparable. This backlog of "hard cases" will be increased as the problems of medical care for the indigent are attacked, and what remains is an even greater backlog of nonphysical disabilities.
Such a snowballing could have disastrous results if selectivity has been the principle factor in the present emphasis on physical restoration. It suggests that the skills needed to deliver to all types of impaired individuals services that will enable them to attain gainful employment are not currently available or being utilized by the OVR today. It is apparent, given the goals established under Title XIX, that rehabilitation services will no longer primarily deal with needs for physical restoration; this will be taken care of by other programs. The increased emphasis will be on determination of disability through comprehensive evaluation, and the provision of training for vocational and personal independence, and for self-care.
The signs of the changing focus of vocational rehabilitation programs are apparent today; we no longer have a Vocational Rehabilitation Administration, but a new department of Social and Rehabilitation Services. The development of rehabilitation services for the year 1975 are predicated on the assumption thal over the year the commendable achievements of the Georgia OVR and the skills and competencies developed through the years of experience can be translated into rehabili-

58
tation for individuals for whom vocational objectives may not be feasible, but for whom personal independence and the ability to care for themselves is the desired and attainable goalo Thus, to begin any projections for future services we assume that the major emphases of the OVR programs will in all likelihood be on comprehensive evaluation, adjustment and pre-vocational training, vocational training, and training for personal independence and self-care. These services, in their entire range and extent, may not be the province of the State rehabilitation agency; it may more reasonably be the charge of this agency to coordinate on the client's behalf the delivery of needed services by providing some services themselves and purchasing others for the client.
Our examination of the various aspects of evaluation, treatment and training have ranged far and wideo At points we have had an abundance of information, at others a paucity. We have tended to raise more questions than we could answer. Some areas we have discussed and examined long and hard, others most cursorily. Our most obvious conclusion is that the real work is about to begin, for with all our efforts, we have only scratched and picked upon the surface. Recognizing these limitations and inadequacies we have reached a number of conclusions based on our findings, made a number of assumptions and have set forth a number of recommendations for the provision of rehabilitation services in 1975.
E. Summary of Findings and Conclusions
The important findings of this task force are:
EVALUATION
1. There is a great amount of variation in the quality, content and usefulness of the General Medical Reports submitted to OVRo

59

2. For the most part the OVR has achieved a fairly equitable distribution of medical specialists and hospital facilities, to the extent that such services are available in different communities. The inadequacies in the geographical distribution of specialists and facilities are more the reflection of rural-urban differences in the availability of car~ and facilities than in OVR's lack of efforts to obtain maximum coverage.
3. The availability and use of hospitals appear adequate, although there is some apparent duplication of the work of other state agencies in the investigation and approval of these facilities for OVR use.
4. The Medical Advisory Board is ful-
filling its role adequately, but there are a number of specialties that are not represented. Some changes in composition and amendment of the rules for inclusion on the Panel of Specialists are desirable.
5. There is evidence of insufficient orientation of physicians (as well as other professional groups) to the total range of services provided by OVR, particularly those other than physical restoration. Another aspect of this same problem is the lack of feedback to referral sources, providing them with information about the services provided and the disposition of referrals.
6. As presently organized there appears to be a sufficient range of psychological tests available for use by the counselor in evaluating the client's intellectual functioning, personality, and motivation.
7. The policy of having counselors administer basic psychological tests may be too costly in terms of valuable counselor time and the willingness to use these tests whenever there is the least possibility that they could be an aid in the evaluative process. The findings of one study indicate that intellectual evaluations have been one of the most inadequately used aids.

is reflection of a manpower shortage in some areas or a failure to recruit psychologists.
9. In the first year of operation, a very small proportion of applicants (1.5 percent) has been placed in extended evaluation programs, but the results thus far for the group that has been given these services are encouraging. The ratio of acceptances to rejections for OVR services from these programs is about 3.7:1.
10. There are no vocational evaluation facilities reported that do not operate in combination with other kinds of services. Most facilities reporting vocational evaluation services are sponsored by OVR, hut private agencies which are least used by OVR have the best reported results in discharging clients into employment. OVR facilities with work evaluation services discharge more clients into training than similar private or public facilities.
11. The most selective stage of the client career is the evaluation period which has an acceptance to rejection ratio of 2:1, compared to a "closed rehabilitated" to "closed not rehabilitated" ratio of 6: 1.
12. The most frequent reasons for clients not completing training are lack of motivation, emotional instability, home situation and failure to adjust to the training situation. In one study, however, these areas were judged to be almost 100 percent adequately evaluated given the available case diagnosis aids. This raises a serious question ftbout the current quality of psychosocial evaluation and its reliability for predicting client training or vocational potential.
13. It is apparent that for the most part the process of evaluation, possibly except for psychosocial areas, has been well developed, and judging from the outcomes, evaluation in combination with treatment and training produces a respectable ratio of eventual success to failures.

8. There are probably too few psychologists available for testing, therapy and consultation to give adequate coverage to all parts of the State. It is not known, however, the extent to which this

TREATMENT AND TRAINING
14. There is a wide array of treatment services provided by OVR, including medical, psychiatric and hospital care.

60

15. There is a fairly wide array of

ties for this group should be comprehensive

OVR, public and private sponsored facili-

in scope.

ties to provide treatment and training for physical, psychological, vocational and personal adjustment needs. The largest number of facilities reported (60 percent) provide comprehensive treatment, evaluation and training services. The sponsorship of these facilities is about evenly divided between OVR, public and private auspices. The comprehensive facilities are most frequently used by the OVR, and for the most part they are their own facilities. The largest number, but not proportion, of discharges into employment

20. The projections and plans of the State Department of Education have farreaching implications for the provision of services by the OVR. It is reasonable to assume that an enlarged program of services will be more available for clients who are not now using state vocational training. The expansion of the State's vocational education programs should relieve some of the existing problems in finding appropriate training facilities within the State.

are from the comprehensive facilities.

COSTS OF EVALUATION, TREATMENT AND TRAINING

16. The OVR facilities discharge about 3 out of 4 clients into employment or training; higher than facilities under public or private sponsorship. It is concluded that OVR has made good use of its own facilities, and that these yield rehabilitation outcomes equal to or better than facilities under other sponsorship. It is not known if t