G.A 1. t.'s.rs rn, dtl'J- L. A. Accident reports Georgia Uniform Motor Vehicle Accident Reports are .m1h: subject to public disclosure under the Open Records Act upon the receipt of a "writtenstatement of need" by a person(s) or entityentitled to the report. A model "statement of need" is contained in Appendix 2. Examples of those entitled to obtainaccident reports include an individual who: Has a personal, professional, or business connection with a party to the accident; owns or leases an interest in property allegedly or actuallydamaged in the accident; Was allegedly or actually injured by the accident; was a witness to the accident; the actual or alleged insurer of a partyto the accident or of property actually or allegedly damaged by the accident; Is a prosecutor or a publicly employed law enforcement officer; Is allegedto be liableto anotherpartyas a resultof the accident; Is an attorney statinghe or she needs the requested reports as part of a criminal case, or an investigation of a potential claim involving contentions that a roadway, railroad crossing, or intersection is unsafe; Is gathering information as a representative of a news media organization; Is conducting research in the public interest for such purposes as accident prevention, prevention of injuries or damages in accidents, determination of fault in an accident or accidents, or other similar purposes; provided, however, this subparagraph will apply only to accident reports on accidents that occurred more than 30 days prior to the request and which shall have the name, streetaddress,telephone number, and driver's license number redacted. Individual driver history compilations and motor vehicle registration information provided by the Georgia Department of MotorVehicle Safety (DMVS) must be withheld. A driver's day and month of birth also may be withheld. However, information gathered from the accident scene, including drivers' license numbers, tag numbers, and vehicle registration numbers mustbe disclosed.' 10I A law Enlon::emenl OlIi....s Guideto Open Records B. Arrest records Arrest and booking records along with a photograph (mug shot) of an individual are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements.' C. Autopsy/coroner reports Autopsy and coroner's reports, except autopsy photographs, are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements." D. Case files (investigative records) 1. Records in an active investigation or pending prosecution, other than initial public arrest reports and initial incident reports, are not required to be released. However, an investigation is no longer deemed to be active when investigative activity has ceased or there is no imminent prosecution. A prosecution is no longer deemed to be pending when all direct litigation has become fmal or otherwise terminated. 2. Records in closed investigations are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements.' E. Citations Uniform Traffic Citations (UTC's) are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements." F. Crime laboratory reports Crime laboratory (GBI Division of Forensic Sciences or "DOFS") reports on "closed cases" are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements." G. Criminal histories Georgia Crime Information Center (GCIC) or other state, federal, or international criminal history compilations must be withheld, except for any portion of a history containing Georgia felony convictions, which must be disclosed. But, when a criminal history record is in a closed investigatory case file, it is subject to the Act's disclosure requirements.! A law Enforcement otIioe(s Guide to Open Records/II H. Department policies and procedures Most departmental policies and procedures are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements. However, departmental policies and procedures which contain information that would divulge the identity of confidential informants or investigations, and information that would jeopardize the life or personal safety of any person are not required to bereleased," I. Driving historieslDepartment of Motor Vehicle Safety records The Georgia Department of Motor Vehicle Safety (DMVS) is prohibited from releasing driving histories or personal information on individual drivers. However, driving histories that have been incorporated by a law enforcement agency into a closed investigatory case file, are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements. to J. Electronic surveillance The "pending investigations/prosecutions" exemption applies to electronic surveillance. This includes attempts, means, methods, results, and even failures, by law enforcement, so long as the investigation and/or prosecution is pending. State law prohibits any publication of information obtained under an electronic surveillance warrant "other than that necessary and essential to the preparation of and actual prosecution for the crime specified in the warrant." Federal law also addresses the disclosure of legally intercepted wire, oral and electronic communications. It provides as follows: An investigator or other officer who has legally obtained such information may disclose it to another investigator or officer if pursuant to the official duties of both. Any person who has legally obtained such information may disclose it while giving testimony under oath in any court proceeding. However, the contents of intercepted communications that have already become "public information" or part of a public record may be disclosed." 12/ A LawEnfo"",,,,,,nt OtlIcers Guide 10Open Reconls K. Family violence records Reports relating to investigations of family violence are not subject to release under the Open Records Act unless an arrest has been made in the incidenns)." L. In-car camera videotapes Police in-car camera videotapes in "closed cases" are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements." M. Initial incident reports Initial incident and police arrest reports are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements, regardless of whether they are part of an active investigation. Additionally, any report, whether entitled a "supplemental report," "narrative report," or similar document name that is produced as part of an initial incident report or can be characterized as such, is likewise to be disclosed." N. Internal Affairs records Investigative records of a government agency relating to the suspension, firing, or investigation of complaints against a public employee are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements 10 days after the investigative record is submitted to the agency for action or the investigation is otherwise concluded or terminated. IS O. Jail documents Sheriffs are required to keep a record of all persons committed to the jail of the county of which he or she is sheriff. This record must contain the name of the person committed, such person's age, sex, race, under what process such person was committed and from what court the process was issued, the crime with which the person was charged, the date of such person's commitment to jail, the day of such person's discharge, under what order such person was discharged, and the court from which the order issued. This record is subject to the Act's disclosure requirements." P. 911 materials 911 materials and computer-aided dispatch (CAD) records are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements. 17 Q. Probation and parole records All records relative to the statewide probation system are confidential and exempt from release, even by subpoena or under the Open Records Act, unless declassified by a majority vote of the Board of Corrections. All records relative to the supervision of probationers by private corporations also are exempt from release under the Open Records Act. All information, both oral and written, received by the members of the State Board of Pardons and Paroles in the performance of their duties also is confidential and exempt from release, even by subpoena or under the Open Records Act, unless declassified by a majority vote of the State Board of Pardons and Parole. However, an alleged parole or probation violator may review the evidence introduced against him at a fmal hearing on the matter of revocation of parole or conditional release.IS R. Photographs Photographs in "closed cases" are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements. However, autopsy photographs are not subject to disclosure unless requested by a family member who provides proof of kinship or otherwise provides a written release. 19 S. Records from other law enforcement agencies Records from a government agency that are incorporated into a closed case are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements unless excluded by a specific exemption. For example, certain federal records that are required to be kept confidential, Department of Family and Children Services records relating to child abuse, and/or records from the Department of Corrections are generally not subject to public disclosure. Because some records or information received from a federal law enforcement agency may be required to be kept confidential, it is advisable to contact the federal law enforcement agency for guidance regarding public disclosure." 14/ A law Enfo""menl Otlieara Guide '" Open Reeorda IV. PERSONNEL RECORDS Personnel records of law enforcement personnel are generally subject to public disclosure, but it is permissible to redact: For any person in the records: SocialSecurity number Day/ monthof birth Financial information Insurance/medical information For sworn law enforcement officers: Address Home telephone number Identification of immediate family or dependants In certain circumstances, news agencies, however, may obtain, upon properrequest, SocialSecurity numbers and day/month of birth." The following are examples of personnel records: A. Applications for employment Applications for employment are subjectto the Act's disclosure requirementsafter redaction of the information cited above." B. Background investigations Background investigations are subject to the Act's disclosure requirements with the exception of confidential evaluations, or examinations undertaken in connection with the employee'sappointment or hiring." C. Benefits selections/payroll deductions Employee benefits selections and payroll deductions are exempt from release." D. Birth certificates Birthcertificates are exempt from release." A Law Enforcement Officer'sGuideto Open Rec:ortm.nt Officer, Guldtl to OpenRecord' that records created within their officeberetained as long as required by an approved retention schedule. These schedules are created under the direction of the Archives and History Division of the Georgia Secretary of Stateand with the approval of the StateRecords Committee. Local law enforcement agencies that do not have established record retention schedules should adopt the state's public safety retention schedules for specific record categories. State law enforcement agencies may use their own approved retention schedules or those on the statewide schedule. Questions regarding the use of and creation of retention schedules should be directed to the Records Management Services section of the State Archives of Georgia. They may be reached at (404) 656-2379. Additional information is available at the program's Internet site at http://www.sos.state.ga.uslarchives/rms/grms.htm IX. CONCLUSION Lawenforcement officers shouldremember that the general rule for open records compliance is one of public disclosure. The Open Records Act mandates that law enforcement records are subject to public inspection and copying unless specific exemptions exist to exclude their release. It is improper for law enforcement officers to circumvent the requirements of the OpenRecords Actand to restrict publicaccess to these records. APPENDIX 1 Sample Open Records Request NOTE: If you want to have evidence of the date of delivery, then delivery can be by hand delivery or by certified mail, return receipt requested. [Requestor's letterhead] [Date] [Custodian's name] [Agency's name] [Street address] [City, State, Zip] To whom it may concern: Pursuant to the Georgia Open Records Law (O.C.G.A 50-18-70 et seq.) (the "Law"), you are hereby requested to make available for review and copying all files, records and other documents in your possessions that refer, reflect or relate to _ This request includes, but is not limited to, all documents, notes, correspondence and memoranda evidencing , and all communication and correspondence in whatever tangible medium between _ _ _ _ _ _ and _ and among If this request is denied in whole or in part, we ask that you cite in writing the specific statutory exemption upon which you have relied, as required by law. We also ask that you release all separate portions of otherwise exempt material. Please waive any costs associated with this request, or first inform us about such costs as required by Georgia law. As you know, the Law requires a response by you within three business days of your receipt of this letter and provides sanctions for non-compliance. Sincerely, [Your name] [Your title] [Your fax number] 24/ A l.8w Enlofcemont Otlicer'. Guide to Open Record. APPENDIX 2 Accident Reports: Pursuant to O.C.G.A. 50-18-72a Sample Statement ofNeed Date: _ To: Custodian of the Records From: Re: Motor Vehicle Accident Report No. _ o I have a personal, professional, or business relationship with ' o I own or lease an interest in _ o I was allegedly or actually injured by the accident which is the subject of this report. o I was a witness to the accident which is the subject ofthis report. o I am the actual or alleged insurer ofa party to the accident or of property actually or allegedly damaged by the accident which is the subject of this report. o I am a prosecutor or a publicly employed law enforcement officer. o I am alleged to be liable to another party as a result of the accident which is the sub- ject ofthis report. o I am an attorney and need the requested reports as part of a criminal case, or an in- vestigation of a potential claim involving contentions that a roadway, railroad cross- ing, or intersection is unsafe. o I am a representative for . I am obtaining access to motor vehicle accident reports for the sole purpose of news gathering for my news media organization. o I am conducting research in the public interest for such purposes as accident preven- tion, prevention of injuries or damages in accidents, determination of fault in an accident or accidents, or other similar purposes. Signature A law Enforcement OfIice(1 Guide to Open Reconll/25 APPENDIX 3 . Sample Response' Records Available Sample Responses to Open Records Requests [Agency's letterhead] Date ofresponse must be within three business days ofwhen request was received by the department. September I, 2002 - : ~John Q. Public 123 Main St. Anytown, Ga 30001 Reference: Complete murder investigation case file ofJane Doe Dear Mr. Public: The following is in response to your Open Records request, received by the [Department] on August 30, i:lf 2002, regarding the above referenced item. A search / The response should include the date the request was received. for the requested information was made and six case volumes have been identified and are available for review. In addition, the [Department] expects to exempt the following information from dissemination: / List all information that is exempt from dissemination and cite the specific Georgia Law that exempts the information. The list ofexemptions must appear in the initial letter sent to the requestor. 1. Social Security numbers, month and day of birth [See O.C.G.A. 50-I8-72(a)(I l.3XA)] 11 2. Any record or related material which identifies any confidential source [See O.C.G.A. 50-1872 (aX3)] Please contact [Specify name] at [Telephone num- ber] to make arrangements to review the records. If you wish to retain a copy of the records or would like the records to be sent directly to you, an invoice for the total administrative costs associated with the preparation ofthe records is enclosed. Sincerely, [Respondent's name] [Title] 26/ A lJIw Enforcement Ollice(s Guide to Open Records APPENDIX 3 Sample Responses to Open Records Requests Sample Response: Cost Estimate Ifthe invoice is the initialletter, the V date ofresponse must be within three businessdays of when request was received by the department. [Agency's letterhead] September I, 2002 V John Q. Public 123 Main St. Anytown, Ga. 3000I If the invoice is the Iinitial letter ofresponse,be sure to list all informationthat is exempt from dissemination as depicted in the previous sample. Reference: Completemurder investigationcase file ofJane Doe Dear Mr. Public: The invoiceshould be an itemized listing of the charges. Search, retrievaland review may be In response to your Open Records request, received by the [Department] on August 30, 2002, this will acknowledge the availability of the records requested on the above referencedsubject. The charge to provide copiesofthe records is as follows: chargedon an hourlybasis less l;lf2002 ORA Record # GI96L Qty Cost V the first 15 min- utes. The hourly Search,retrieval and review 0 f 1.0 records @ $24.09/hour $18.07 chargemay not exceed the salary ofthe lowest paid full-time employee Photocopying of case file @ 0.5 $14.l2/hour Page(s)@ .25/page 320 $7.10 $80.00 capableof fulfilling the request. Where no charge is Photographs@ S3/print 20 Other: Videotape@ SIO/copy I $60.00 $10.00 specifiedin the Mailing costs (estimate) $5.00 law for a record, the cost per page Total Cost $180.17 may not exceed 25 cents per page. O.C.G.A. 50-18- 71(cXd) The methodof paymentand requirements should come from department policy. [Records custodian] [Department] [Street address] [City, State, Zip] A l.IIw Enforcement Officers Guide to Open Records 127 APPENDIX 4 Sample Open Records Request Response Flow Chart "No Record Found" letter "Case Open" letter t---i~ "Case Pending" letter L-_~--r------' 28/ A LJN Enforcement OlIicer's Guide to Open Records APPENDIX 5 o Telephone Request o Request madein Person Requestor Name: Requestor Address: Sample Open Records Request Log Sheet Date: _ Time: _ _ Requestor Phone: -'-( ~ _ Typeof Records Requested: _ NameofIndividual (victim/suspect): _ DateofIncident: _ Countywhere occurred: _ CaseNumber (if available): _ Other information: _ Prepared By:_ _-::-_.,.-----:-::;--;--_ _ DepartmentEmployee " l8w Enforcement OtIice(s Guide to Open Rec:onls/29 GEORGIA LAW ENFORCEMENT AND THE OPEN RECORDS ACT A Law Enforcement Officer's Guide to Open Records in Georgia It is indeed my privilege to help provide to the members of Georgia's law enforcement community this valuable guidebook regarding Georgia's "open records" laws. This booklet will provide you with the resources needed to achieve a basic understanding ofGeorgia's Open Records Act, and will also provide you with guidance regarding some ofthe most frequent concerns about Open Records Act compliance, especially in the law enforcement context. The Office ofthe Attorney General has an important role to play regarding all of Georgia's "sunshine laws, " including those regarding access to public records. We take these responsibilities very seriously, and the Attorney General has long served as the government's watchdog on the enforcement ofopen government laws. Georgia has some ofthe strongest open government laws in the nation, a fact we should all be proud of I strongly believe that government operates best when it operates openly. As members ofthe law enforcement community, we must always be vigilant to ensure that the public we are sworn to protect and to serve is also protected in its rights to know what its government is doing. Moreover, it is often the case that law enforcement personnel are the most visible part of "government" that people encounter on a regular basis. It is critical, then, that you be as well informed as possible regarding the laws governing the access ofthe public to the information that government has. The purpose of this guidebook is to provide a brief, general and nontechnical discussion ofGeorgia's Open Records Act, so that all members ofGeorgia's law enforcement community can better understand how this law works and how it protects the rights ofall ofGeorgia's citizens to be well informed about their government. APPENDIX 6 Sample Open Records Cost Worksheet Thisworksheet can be usedto determine costestimates or serve as an invoice or receipt. The following are the actualcosts incurred in complying with the request to copy[AgencyJrecords pursuantto O.e.G.A. 501870. (Thereis no chargefor the firstquarterhourof timeexpended in recordpreparation.) The Open Records Act allowsan agency to waiveall feesshouldit so choose. The Act also authorizes an agency to charge up to 25 per page, provided that it uses the most economical means of copying reasonably available. There is no charge for simple inspection 0 records that are routinely subjectto publicdisclosure. No feesother than thosedirectly attributable to providing accessshallbe assessedwhererecordsare madeavailable by electronic means. _ _ Number of hours of search, retrieval & review ~ (First 15 minutes - No charge) _ _ Total hours of preparation _ _ Number of hours copying ___ Number of copies of audio tapes x [cost per copy] =$ _ _ Number of copies of video tapes x [cost per copy] =$ _ _ Number of copies of photographs x [cost per copy] =$ _ _ Number of CD-ROM's with digital photographs x [cost per CD-ROM] = $ Other agency cost (specify) Postage + [actual cost] =$ + [actual cost] =$ GRAND TOTAL =$ Case number/Description of records: Preparer's name: Amount received: $ Date: Received by: Signature Date: .. Hourly rate: The hourlycharge for administrative/clerical tasks may not exceedthe salaryof the lowestpaid, full-time employee who, in the discretion of the custodian of the records, has the necessary skill and training to perform the request Copyrate: An agency may not chargemorethan 2S per pagefor each copy. 30 I A LawEnforcement Officer'. Guide toOpen Record. APPENDIX 7 Information Exempt fromPublicDisclosure Publicdisclosure is not required for certainrecords and information, The following is a list of records and information exempt from release and the corresponding legal authority. Any agency or person who provides accessto information in good faith relianceon the requirements ofthe Open Records Act shall not be liable in any actionon accountof havingprovided access. ** ** Before relying on an exemption,you must assure yourselfthat it applies EXEMPTION AIDSIHIV infonnation AUTHORITY DISCRETIONARY OR MANDATORY SQ.I8-72(aX2), 31-22-9.1(a) Mandatory (2), 24-9-47(b) Autopsy photographs (unless 4S-16-27(d) from family member with proof ofldnship) Mandatory Background investigations of 50-2712(e) applicants to the Lottery Corporation Mandatory Birth certificates 31-1Q.2S(a) Burglar/fire alarminformation 50-18-72 (a)(11.2) Carpooling information SO-1872(a)(14) Mandatory Discretionary Discretionary Confidential informants SO-18-72(a)(3) Discretionary Creditreport 15U.S.C. 1681b(aX4XO) Mandatory Confidential evaluations or SO-18-72(aXS) examinations in connection with new appointments or hires Discretionary II law Enforcement Officers Guideto Open Records I 31 APPENDIX 7 Information Exempt fromPublicDisclosure ** ** Before relying on an exemption,you must assure yourself that it applies EXEMPTION AUTHORITY DISCRETIONARY OR MANDATORY Confidential recordsconcerning 49-5-4O(b), but disclosure Mandatory reportsofchild abuse may be requiredby juvenile court order under 49-5-41 (b) or by law ifchild is de- ceasedpursuantto 49-541 (c) Confidential grandjury testi- Federal RuleCriminal Pro- Mandatory mony cedure6(e),Kesslerv. State, 249 Ga. 462,474 (1982) Criminal historyrecordsother 35-3-34(a) (I)(A), 35-3-34 Mandatory than in-Georgia felonyconvic- (d.1),35-3-38, 28 U.S.C. tious 534 (NCICrecord)(but see ChapterllI(G) ofthis man- ual regarding disclosure when in closedcase fileand ChapterIV(G)whenin a personnel file) Deferred compensation salary 45-18-36(b) deductions Department of Corrections (classified inmatefiles) 42-5-36(c) Department ofCorrections 42-536(b) (classified investigative reports and intelligence data prepared by InternalAffairs) Department ofHumanof'Re- 37-3-166(a) sourcesclinicalrecords Mandatory Mandatory Mandatory Mandatory Driver's licenseinformation to 40.5-2(b) the extentit is obtainedfrom Department ofMotorVehicle Safety Mandatory 32 f A L.... Enfon:ement Otlieer'sGuide10Open R