TWO GEORGIANS EXPLORE SCANDINAVIA A Comparison of Education for Democracy in Northern Europe and Georgia by RALPH MCGILL and THOMAS C. DAVID GEORGIA PROGRAM FOR THE IMPROVEMENT OF INSTRUCTION IN THE PUBLIO SCHOOLS State Department of Education M. D. COLLINS State Superintendent of Schools Atlanta, Georgia TWO GEORGIANS EXPLORE SCANDINAVIA A Comparison of Education for Democracy in Northern Europe and Georgia by RALPH MCGILL and THOMAS C. DAVID GEORGIA PROGRAM FOR THE IMPROVEMENT OF INSTRUCTION M. E. THOMPSON Director PAUL R. MORROW Director of Re8earch CELIA C. MCCALL Assistant Director of Research State Department of Education M. D. COLLINS State Superintendent of Schools Atlanta, Georgia 1988 FOREWORD This publication is presented to teachers, pupils and other citizens who are interested in solving the difficult economic and agricultural problems of Georgia. The experience of the Scandinavian democracies in solving the same problems is enlightening and encouraging. The fundamental place of education in the ultimate solution of these problems is the justification for this publication. Readers will find these articles by Mr. Ralph McGill and Mr. Thomas C. David both timely and interesting; their thoughtful consideration by forward-looking Georgians hi invited. M. D. COLLINS, State Superintendent of Schools. S. V. SANFORD, Chancellor of the University System of Georgia. TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION, ADERHOLD____________________________ 7 II. SCANDINAVIAN STUDIES, McGILL 11 Education and Legislation Deal with the Problems of the People__________________________________________ 11 Making Happy Landowners by Co-operation and Legislation -_____________________________________________ 16 Problems of Agriculture Are Solved by Intel- ligence and Co-operation 21 Intelligent Co-operation Makes Tenants into Successful Landowners 26 How the Danish Farmer Plans His Farm Program __"___________________________________________________________ 31 Paper Making and Forest Conservation in Scandinavia and Georgia______________________________ 35 Consumer Co-operatives 40 Social Problems and Education 47 Problems of Labor and CapitaL 51 III. A GEORGIAN AMONG THE DANES, DAVID 57 How the Danish Farmer Lives 57 The Danish Farmer Plans________________________________ 64 The Small Farm Owner Is SuccessfuL__________ 71 We Go to the Apple Show 76 The Danes Are Adaptable 80 The Danes Are Thrifty 85 Grundtvig, the Savior of Denmark 90 Agricultural Education Among the Danes 97 Denmark Is Fascinating 101 Denmark, a Land of Small Farms 104 Great Are the Danish Co-operatives 107 The Nature of the Danish Folk High SchoollL113 5 :~ . I. INTRODUCTION O. C. ADERHOLD, Professor of Rural and Agricultural Educa- tion, College of Education, University of Georgia The purpose of this publication is to provide teachers and others with the reactions of two Georgia citizens who have made observations of the democratic way of living in Denmark, Norway and Sweden. They have written simple and interesting stories of the lives of these peoples and have shown, definitely and concretely, how the use of intelligence and co-operative action can build nations of prosperous and happy people. The stories written by tnese two men are reproduced for your enjoyment and benefit. The first series of articles was written by Mr. Ralph McGill, Sports Editor of the Atlanta Constitution. Mr. McGill is one of the outstanding newspaper men of the country. He was sent to the Scandinavian countries by the Rosenwald Fund. Mr. McGill understands the problems of the South and is concerned that opportunities are provided to solve these problems. The second series of articles was written by Thomas c. David of Danielsville, Georgia, to his sponsor, the Rotary Educational Foundation of Atlanta. Mr. David was graduated from the University of Georgia in 1933 with the degree of Bachelor of Science in Education with a major field of study in agriculture. Since 1933 Mr. David has spent much of his time in educational work. He is genuinely concerned with the problems of rural life in Georgia. His ability, interests, background and education qualify him to write intelligently about the peoples and institutions of the Scandinavian countries. 7 The great masses of our people have come to believe that the spirit of Democracy is America's finest and richest heritage. Dpring the last few years mu~h has been said and written relativ~ to the importance of the public schools placing emphasis upon the development and perpetuation of democratic ideals. Teachers have devoted themselves to getting a better understanding of the meaning of Democracy and the techniques for promoting it among those who are influenced by the teacher and the school. Few peoples and countries of the world believe in the ideals of Democracy today. Denmark, Norway and Sweden have given to the world outstanding examples of Democracy in action. These north European countries, situated among a host of selfish, ignorant and dictator controlled peoples, stand out like beacon lights and present today some 'of the best examples of human relations based upon and guided by the fundamental principles of Democracy. Before reading these articles which picture the successful working together of people in these countries, it might be well to emphasize the important elements that make for Democracy. If the schools of Georgia are concerned with the promotion and development of the spirit of Democracy, then they must become concerned with leading students into real and genuine problems, encouraging the formulation of hypotheses, using experience and factual information in testing inferences, and drawing conclusions and making generalizations based upon evaluated facts. This means that schools need to shift the emphasis from the accumulation 0] subject matter to the discovery and systematic thinking through of real problems. Teaching methods then must emphasize techniques of ~iscov ering problems, techniques of leading. students into problems, methods of stimulating students to draw inferences and formulate hypotheses, techniques and meth- 8 ods of using personal experiences and tested information in the solution of the problems, and techniques of assisting students in drawing conclusions and making appropriate generalizations. A second major characteristic of the spirit of Democ- racy is the emphasis placed upon a genuine concern about the welfare of others who are affected by the solution of the problem at hand. It is recognized that systematic or reflective thinking may take place which would result in conclusions that would be detrimental to both individuals and to society as a whole. This means then, that if the school is to promote Democracy it must not only place great emphasis upon the development of systematic thinking but also a sympathetic concern for those who are affected by the solution of the problem. This systematic concern for others is the basis upon which co-operative programs are built. The articles of Mr. McGill and Mr. David show how the educational programs in Denmark, Norway and Sweden have developed peoples with the ability to solve co-operatively their individual and social problems in a manner that has made for great progress in the last one hundred y~ars. The South, and particularly Georgia, would soon become the "garden spot" of the world, should our educational forces throw their influences to the development of the spirit of Democracy. A careful reading of the articles in this publication will probably stimulate many questions among teachers, students and laymen relative to the public educational program in Georgia, such as: Should the curriculum in Georgia schools be reorganized to place emphasis upon individual, commt;mity, state, national and world problems? Should the problems of soil erosion, wasteful use of forest resources, home beautification, home conveniences, improved crops and livestock, local co-operatives, etc., become basic in the curriculum in Georgia schools? 9 Is there a need for a new type of school to deal with. the problems of out-of-school youth, and adults? Can the teacher training program in Georgia develop teachers to deal with important economic and social problems facing the people in the rural areas of the state? Is there a need for social and economic legislation in Georgia that would encourage more co-operative activities? 10 II. SCANDINAVIAN STUDIES RALPH MCGILL EDUCATION AND LEGISLATION DEAL WITH THE PROBLEMS OF THE PEOPLE It was Ben Hill who said that no matter how expensive education might be, it still was worth more than had been paid for it. After more than two months in SCI;mdinavia, it i~ perfectly obvious that practical education has made possible the progress in social legislation, in co-operation and in agricultural aids which distinguish the scene in north Europe. Before coming to these countries I had read many books in an effort at preparation. Most of them were factually correct. But too many of them sought to pre~ent the system to America as one immediately to be adopted. Their enthusiasm had led them to some exaggerations, notably in the field of co-operation. It is perfectly true that Scandinavia, and notably Sweden and Denmark, have made superior progres~ in social legislation. They have, as one American who had visited here and studied their plans told me before leaving America, "removed the three thorns from the heart of the average man." They had provided for education of all children regardless of the financial statu~ of the parents; they had provided hospitalization for all. Even if one wishes a private room at a hospital with the best doctors, the charge is not more than $15 and $18 per week. That charge includes everything. And the best doctors and the best hospitalization may 11 be had for as little as 50 cents per day. This includes nurses, food and all care. But that must do for a separate article. They had, in addition to these, provided for care in old age. The Three Thorns in a Man's Heart "What are the three thorns in a man's heart?" this American business man had asked. "They are the fear that his children will not be educated; that if illness comes he will not be able to give his wife, his children or himself the .best of care; that when he and his family become old they will be thrown on the mercy of the public. The Scandinavian countries have removed those thorns." He had summed up the situation well. That is the social legislation of which one hears. America could learn some of the methods. There are the systems of rural credits and of co-operation and land tenure which could be studied with profit. But the sincere idealists who have sought to present the entire system as one now fitted for America were dreaming. They had seen these things, and they are inspirational in many respects, but had not looked behind them. Education is behind it. Not merely the education of the ordinary schools, but the adult education which has meant so much to the Scandinavian peoples. I can imagine one of our politicians, speaking with great irony and asking what good the knowledge of a book or of his country's history will do a farmer who is hoeing cotton or ploughing corn. Yet, facts are facts. An educated man with at least some idea of how to rationalize himself with the world about him is better prepared for making his lot a better one and for making his community an improved one. 12 Every Adult Can Read and Write I visited the head of the schools in Norway. "I think it is true," he said, "that in Norway every adult can read and write his country's language." I like to go about these countries because all of them a.re somewhat approximately the size of Georgia as regards population. Sweden, of course, is larger. But not so much that comparison of methods is not possible. The population of Norway, for instance, is not much more than 2,820,000. It is about what Georgia's is. They are a race of mountain people with all their independence and individualism. Through all the history of Norway runs a thread of democracy. It is, as few people stop to think, a new country in that it has been a separate and individual nation only since 1905 when the tie with Sweden was severed. But through all the years of the union Norway had its own parliament. They had parliaments in Norway as early as the ninth century and no,where today is there a loud voice which would seek to change this democratic ideal. Again, it is obvious that it has been education which has nourished and maintained this ideal and has made of these people a literate and articulate people. Norway's System of Public Schools I visited the public schools of Norway. It includes the public school, the primary school as we know it. Then comes the middle school, comparing with our high schoo-Is; then the gymnasium, comparing with our junior colleg~s, and then the university. In addition there are, in this country with a population no larger than Georgia's and-an agricultural area no greater: . Thirty-five agricultural schools. Seven schools for small landholders. 18 Seven horticultural schools. Five schools of dairying. Five schools of forestry. Sixty-two schools for housewifery. Many of them are small and operate during the winter when the farmers are free. Their total attendance is no greater than that of the Georgia agricultural schools, or such at least, is my estimate, the exact Georgia figures not being at hand. But it is important to note that they are located, these 124 schools which are in addition to the regular school system, in strategic points where the people can reach them without too much expense. They are conducted much more simply and are schools, and not "rah, rah, rah" machines with football teams and the like. Produce Farmers, Not County Agents They strive, too, to produce farmers and not a supply of county agents who will take state jobs and remain carefully away from the farm. I found, in the public school, or primary school, they were teaching the usual studies and in addition one foreign language-English. Just last year a law was passed that no primary teacher would be graduated from the teacher's school without a teaching knowledge of English. It is a nation of readers-as are all Scandinavian people. There are in Norway, as aforesaid, less than 3,000,000 people. It is estimated there are 700,000 families. The total circulation of all the newspapers of .this nation is 1,200,000, or about two newspapers per family. There are, for these people who number no more than those of Georgia, 1,300 public libraries, 4,700 school libraries. They are supported by appropriations from the state. It is estimated that Norwegian people read about three and a half books per capita per year. There are bookstores everywhere and the publishers issue cheap editions 14 of new works. It is possible to buy Miss Margaret Mitchell's Gone with the Wind for about $2.25 in a paper binding. It is a large book. The average length novels of the best sellers are to be had for lessand there are issued popular editions of books published in the past year at about $1.00. Rental libraries thrive. Schools Make Communities More Attractive That is a part of the picture. Getting back to the schools, there are in addition to the ordinary school system and the agricultural schools, 29 Folk High Schools, copied from Denmark; 30 young people's schools and 36 provincial schools which work on the folk school plan. All these schools afm at adult education. They make the rural sections and communities more attractive. They bring the world there and so few of them leave the farm to go seeking the world. The students must be at least 17 years of age. There are few books beyond the song book and a few books on literature. They are passed out during the lectures. There are lectures and discussions. As in Denmark, they go into history and literature and learn of its men of prominence. They learn arithmetic. They have courses of history-economics-all this has brought a cultural dovelopment to Norway as it has to other Scandinavian . countrieswhere the folk schools were adopted from Denmark andits idea. Experiments? Well, they have been going on in Denmark for more than 100 years and they are 70 years old in Norway. ~ They are attended primarily by farm people. The agricultural schools give credit for work in the folk schools.. There is no doubt but they have had a tremendous influence in rural sections. Everywhere in Norway one finds the halls of adult education. There are 100 study circles under the direction of the board of education. 15 There are now "winter schools" for rural communities just opening this year to be carried on as folk schools. I saw one of the study circles. It reminded me very much of the two or three clubs in Atlanta, Georgia. There was a topic assigned and a paper read and a discussion. The members here were farmers and the paper was read on the Oslo conference-a conference of the Scandinavian nations. These Men Won't Listen to Demagogues These men would not listen to a political demagogue. At least, they would not listen with much patience. There are such study circles in all sections of the country. They are not large groups; usually there are in these study circles about 12 or 14 men. The women have about the same number. There are groups such as Dr. Cullen B. Gosnell has attempted from Emory University-forums in which all the people .in rural communities participate. Back of all progress there must be an enlightened people. Before the tenant farmer can be rescued from his state, before the "three thorns" may be pulled from the heart and mind of the average citizen, there must be an education to prepare the way. I think democracy thrives best with education. And that Lincoln had some of this in mind when he spoke of a government of the people, for the people and by the people. MAKING HAPPY LANDOWNERS BY CO-OPERATION AND LEGISLATION Now and then figures can be dramatic. As, for instance, some official reports from the United States, from Norway, Sweden and Denmark. While the South is engaged in a struggle to restore to many of her landlesS peoples ownership of farm land as 16 an incentive toward better economics and better citizenship, these reports become news. Denmark has increased, through government aid, the number of farms by more than 20,000, the crop area by more than 1,000,000 and the timber area by more than 430,000 acre~. Sweden, where industrialism arrived fairly recently, has created, since 1905, more than 45,000 new agricultural holdings. They are all free holders, a8 in Denmark. In Norway, the past two years saw 12,000 new people on new farms. In the last generation about 50,000 new holdings were created. The plans call for 20,000 new ones in the next ten years. Farms in Georgia Decrease 18 Per Cent The Georgia experiment station report of 1935, Georgia Land Use Problems, stated that in the last decade the number:-of farms in the state decreased about 18 per cent. In the rich Piedmont cotton belt a full two-fifths of the crop area was lost between 1919 and 1932. It showed that two-thirds of all farm operators were tenants and that of all operators one-third were sharecroppers. It showed that two-thirds of all counties lost population between 1920 and 1930. The government report showed a decrease of 17.7 per cent in farms in the state between 1920 and 1930, and from 1930 to 1935 a decrease of minus 2 per cent. More than 55;000 farms disappeared in the first decade mentioned and from 1930 to 1935 there were more than 5,000 to go out of cultivation. Tennessee is a state which produces, as does Georgia, cotton and tobacco. Tennessee's Losses an:d Gains Shown Tennessee showed losses in 1910-20, 1920-30 but gained back some farms in 1930-35: The number of tenants increased Substantially each decade. 17 Kentucky, a tobacco and grain state, regained some of her farms in the 1930-35 period but showed a substantial increase in tenant operators. Mississippi, with a decrease in the number of operated farms during 1920-30 of 25 per cent, improved in the latter period of 1930-35 but still had a minus percentage for that period. The South presents the worst picture, generally, although the slowing up of tenancy has been somewhat encouraging. It is admitted, of course, that the mere renting of land is not in itself an agricultural evil. But the lease system and the system of tenancy which it created, with a shifting nonprofitable sector of rural population, was an abuse and an evil which left in its wake, and which is still leaving in its wake, eroded land, wornout land and wasted, ruined forests. Legislation Aids Farming People The figures of the Scandinavian peoples and countries are interesting because, while land legislation designed to restore land to landowners who farm it and to correct the abuse of land and the loss of crop area is new in America, it has been in operation here for 25 or 30 years and the results are to be seen, not as probabilities, but as actualities. Progress has been accomplished. Yet in no one of these countries is there, of course, satisfaction, calm Utopian days, and surcease from all pain and problems. The number of books and magazine articles written presenting Scandinavia as a sort .of perfect dream world, already is beginning to exasperate state officials even though it be excellent for tourist purposes. Scandinavian countries are trying new methods. Their "new deal" has been going on for many, many years. It has been a constant trying of methods with a discarding of many of them. The old problem of income for the 18 farmer, of high wages for the industrial worker and low ,rents fQr one and all, the high cost of food and all the other problems are to be found here. But despite all this, these countries have made progress in sociallegislation, in farm rehabilitation and in developing a general culture that is high. Agricultural Help Forging Ahead The methods in the agricultural rehabilitation have been fiomewhat similar. In Norway and in Sweden there never were the number of tenants that Denmark knew. Yet the problem of building up agriculture has gone ahead, not backward. Land has been added to the crop a'rea. Forests have been maintain'ed despite annual cuttings. Denmark began aiding farmers to own land as early as 1899 when loans were available-. Sweden began in 1905. Norway started at about the same time. The government has not attempted to do it all. Always there have been administrative agencies, national, county and local. ' The successful applicant, who must meet a rigid list of requirements, is allowed two loans. He is permitted one for the land and one for the buildings, improvements and equipment. He may borrow up to nine-tenths of the appraised value of the land. Most of the farms are small ones. The maximum loan for these is $2,278. It is secured by a first mortgage on the entire holding. Nothing is paid for five years except interest. Thereafter interest and payments on the principal are made at the low rate of 2l4. per cent semi-annually. , Larger Loans onBig Farms For larger farms the loan is of course larger, reaching $8,040. The rate of repayment, which begins after five years, is extended over thirty years. 19 On state-owned land leases are provided which are paid at the rate of two per cent semi-annually on the assessed value of the land. He may, at the end of a period of years, buy the land or extend the lease. This has been going on for 35 years. It is not an experiment. Similar legislation has been provided in the other countries. Denmark has added thousands of farms. More than $75,000,000 has been spent. It is coming back. In Sweden 75 per cent of the new holdings have been successful. In Denmark the rate is higher. Imagine what would happen in any southern state if several thousand new farms were added each 10 years and if 75 per cent of them proved going concerns. There are limitations on the government ownerships. The occupant must insure his buildings, must operate and not sub-let; may not sell part of it or buy other land without consent of the Department of Agriculture. He may not mortgage his property through a private agency until he has paid part of his debt to the state and then only to the amount that he has made such repayment. Holdings Free from Debt Seizure It is arranged that his holding may not be seized for debt and this automatically means he cannot obtain credit on his land for some private debt. The machinery for such work is just beginning in America. In these countries it has been going on for almost 40 years. They had their share of failures. They made their share of mistakes. The resettlement and rehabilitation groups in America, the first experiments, proved partially successful. Much should have been learned to avoid the mistakes of those departments in the administration of the present fund. A state can remake its agricultural "plant." These nations have no miracle workers, no special plans. They 20 have had many, many failures. But they have accomplished much. And they, small and lacking in military power and being, by the very nature of their position on the map and their products, competitors, have a difficult struggle to keep all this hard-won social and economic progress. It can't be accomplished in America in a year or two, or three or five. We must expect the hostile press to report the failures of the few and ignore the success of the majority: Meanwhile, adult education and some method for the new farmers to market ahd buy must be developed. That, too, is vital. PROBLEMS OF AGRICULTURE ARE SOLVED BY INTELLIGENCE AND CO-OPERATION In Scandinavia the ag,ricultural experts ask what is going to happen to the new farmers being created in America by the farm tenancy legislation when they bring their first crops to market. "They will not be financially strong as they begin with their new farms," the experts say. "What provision is there for a fair chance to market their products at a profit? Your first consideration must be, not the consumer and his prices, but the producer and his prices. Low prices are fine for city consumers but if the farmer is, as you Bay in America, broke, then everyone becomes broke." This particular conversation was in Norway. "Listen," I said, "I know you are going to talk about community co-operation for the farmers. All I know is that in America most of the co-operative farming, selling and buying is done in the Middle West where Scandinavians settled and that little of it is done in the South. In addition, I'd rather you state the case. I prefer to be a reporter of it, not a propagandist." 21 "House Raisings" and Co-operatives "I have read American history," he said, "and the old 'house raisings' where the neighbors got together and helped build a house were merely community co-operatives. Why can't they do the same in their farming'? "You've heard a lot about co-operatives for the farmer in Denmark and you'll hear some more in Sweden. Our story is more applicable to American than any other country. In the first place we are more like Americans in our individualism and our naturally independent thinking. We are more the individualist than the Dane. "And in Norway agriculture was harder hit by the depression than in Denmark. The prices dropped below those of any other commodity. We had our mortgage sales on farms as you did in America. "That's why I say we are the best study for America. Those Danes have been in line for years. They learned the value of collective buying and selling before anyone else. We were too independent. We wanted to be the individualist. And so we saw the end come, so to speak, with the world depression. "So the Norwegian farmer said, 'Well, I wanted to be free and I was ruined. Now, I want to be free and the way to do it is to have something to weather a storm. I borrowed cheap money and now I'm paying back expensive money. Now my farm is also depreciated in value. The mortgage is unpaid. And about all I've got left is my individualism and my freedom to starve to death in the most painless way possible.' That's what he said." "Don't make a speech," I said, having known the man for two days and therefore being able to suggest. "Tell me what happened." How Government Assisted Farmer "The first thing that happened was that the government saw the need for immediate help. It created a special 22 bank and this relieved the ordinary banks from dealing with questionable debts. The state financed all those who needed help. The country was divided into districts and each one had a governor. The parliament voted the bank 15,000,000 kroner, not quite $4,000,000, and allowed it to borrow up to about $22,000,000 with the state as security. But parliament was smart. No losses were to be carried by the bank. The creditors of the farmers were about to lose all. They agreed to accept the arbitration of the government in each case where the farmer couldn't make it. "Suppose the debt was $5,000. The forced sale would bring about $2,500. This means then-to avoid losing more than that should he struggle along with a farmer who can't even pay interest-he sells or writes off half the debt and gets out with half his money in cash. "The state then made a loan to the farmer of 30 per cent of his new debt of $2,500. It enabled him to m~ke repairs, get machinery, buy seed and take over a debt which he could hope to pay. The creditor was saved a long struggle which, in the end, would bring him nothing to speak of. The government's fair offer saved him time and trouble and expense. The loan is free from interest for three years so he had time to make a start. He pays 3 per cent interest after three years but nothing on the principal until after five years. Other farmers were able, with a loan, to pay back all their debts. At any rate, the private banks were not strained and the farmers were aaved." Farmers Saved for Time Being "That is, they were saved for the time being. But if they could not solve their old problem of marketing they would be headed back fOr the same old trouble. That's what worries me about your new farmers in America. "Well, our farmers organized their district co-operatives. Many of them have no national organization. Some 23 have. The beginnings were small with the entry fee set at about $15 to $25. We haven't grown as has Denmark. Some of our co-operatives are large and ~trong. Others are content to market their own district and let it go at that. In the beginning it was stressed, as now, that it must be a purely voluntary co-operation." Development of Co-operatives "In the beginning of co-operation in bacon, for instance, there were imports to satisfy the home consumption. Today we export. Members of the co-operative "deliver their pigs to the co-operative as they do their cattle and sheep. Only as much is placed on the market as it will stand. The co-operatives are able to borrow money for a start but most of them prefer to start slowly and gradually work toward their own slaughterhouses and storage. The meat that is held back is disposed of later, or it is salted and cured and sold in that fashion on that market. Some is exported. Here we hold down production by fees on foodstuff, allowing only so much at a cheap price. But I think we will change that. "In the beginning the farmers of a community got together.. graded their potatoes, their pigs and other products and sold them at the best price, getting a bette,r one because they had a sizable amount to sell. They were not, as one poor devil is, compelled to take what he can get." That is a part of the story. Probably 70 per cent of the milk-and milk prices have come down each year-is handled by ~o-operatives. They bought together as they sold. The farmers had no fight with any other group, the "middleman" forces not being so strong. The advantage of collective strength and bargaining power in agriculture is obvious. Co-operatives and Politics Each member of a co-operative is allowed one vote. He may own a large farm or a small one, four cows or 30, 24 two pigs or 60. He has one vote. They have learned, have the Scandinavian farmers, to act for themselves. They had a long struggle. It is not something which can be created overnight. It is independent and the co-operative unions are not members of any organization other than their own unions. In Norway the farmers, or Ag,rarian party, vote with the Social-Democrats and keep that party in office despite the fact it, or itself, has no majority. In Sweden, the farmers align with the Social-Democrats. 'But in Denmark, curiously enough, the small farmers support the Social-Democrats, but the middle farmers and the large farmers support the conservatives. The Socialists are peculiar. They believe in private property and high wages and everything a good Socialist is not supposed to believe in. The co-operatives, for the most part, join with the Social-Democrats. In Sweden the consumer co-operatives,' which frequently war with the producers, are almost entirely labor, or Social-Democratic in politics. No Need in America for European System The need in America is not for the European system of co-operation. The need is, however, for some community effort at selling and buying. The small farmer with his small lot of potatoes, his bale or so of cotton, his small lot of bacon, his one beef cow, his vegetables-cannot have the same opportunity as would be possible through organized community selling and buying. It provides that necessary uniformity of supply. There again, must be years of experimenting. It is something which must work itself out. And while the grass is growing, as they say in Norway, a few cows may die. But progress will be present. Whether one agrees or not-it is something about which to think. And out of it may come something beneficial. 25 INTELLIGENT CO-OPERATION MAKES TENANTS INTO SUCCESSFUL LANDOWNERS In all the Scandinavian countries there is interest in the American experiment with farm tenancy and the new laws designed to remove the more able tenant from economic serfdom and make of him an independent American who tills his own soil. Scandinavia, still working out new legislation, casting aside old and trying the new which seems more likely to succeed, provided for ownership of small farms in legislation enacted more than three decades ago. Producer Co-operation But, at the same time there developed in the Scandinavian scene another factor which, their economists say, made it possible for the farmer, and more especially the small farmer, to succeed. That was producer co-operation. Now, there are co-operative societies of all sorts in Scandinavia. They are an important part of the social scene. They are growing in strength and influence. The consumer co-operatives have become "big business" and are not opposed by other large businesses in general. Only in the retail field, where an organization of retail tradesmen oppose the consumer co-operatives, is there real opposition. It must not be thought that the co-operatives rule the business world, as might be thought from books such as Mr. Marquis Childs' on the Swedish co-operative!'!. Powerful Factors The consumer co-operatives do about 20 to 25 per cent of the food business in Stockholm and about 12 to i4 per cent of the entire retail business in all Sweden. They are a powerful factor which regulates prices and keeps them down. But they do not control private business except in their influence on prices. 26 The producers' co-operatives have not developed in Sweden as have the consumers' societies. It is only in the past few years that the farmers have begun to develop their own co-operative societies. In Denmark the story is reversed. There, because agriculture is the dominant industry, the producers' societies are dominant and the consumers' co-operatives are just beginning to develop and to reach into the cities from the small rural communities where they have been developing. Marketing System Urged In Stockholm, Sweden, Gunnar Myrdal, member of parliament and economist of international' fame, expressed the opinion that the American farm tenancy measures would not succeed as desired unle3s provision was made for the new farmers to market their crops to the best advantage. Other economists to whom I have talked have expressed the opinion the southern states should assist their farmers in the forming of co-operatives, since they inevitably lead to a more prosperous agricultural population, to better farm products and to generally improved agricultural conditions. The consumers' societies, which in Sweden filled a vacancy and supplied a service which did not exist, grew up because of a need for them. They did not oust, especially in the retail foods, any group of food shops. The chain food store really is just making an appearance in Sweden. It did not exist before, and it is, by adopting . the co-operative method of marketing and display, making a sure advance. Little Chance for Farmers It has been found that the southern farmers, especially the smaller ones, have little chance in the present more or less haphazard methods of marketing. 27 "The first state to assist its farmers to form co-operative market groups will outstrip the rival states/' said the head of the co-operative group in Denmark. "What happens? The small farmer produces some butter, a little bacon, some grain. He cannot take it to market and obtain a good price. We found our small farmers, dependent on bacon and butter, trying to save up enough butter for sale. It reached the market in poor condition. They got little for it. "The co-operatives gave him his chance. His little butter or his small amount of milk, or his two or three pigs went in with the butter and milk and the pigs from other small farms. They were sold at the best market, and he received his share, based on what he had contributed." Essence of Democracy "That is the essence of democracy. What is democracy but the action of the whole to obtain the best results for the individual members? "What is a co-operative? What would one be in America? How would you work one in your own state? A group of your farmers, in a certain community would form a society. They would agree to pool their products. "They would agree to grade them and not toss the whole lot, small potatoes, large potatoes, poor butter, good butter, inferior cotton, superior cotton, on the market in one mass. They would market their products intelligently. "They would buy fertilizer in large lots at a better price than they could obtain by buying each a few sacks or each a ton. They could buy their seeds in the same manner. "The result would be a raising in standards, in accom plishments and in an increased prosperity." 28 Enough Problems Now "The small farmer, who has just bought his farm, has enough problems to face without having to carry his own small products to market and fighting the battIe of fluctuating prices and the competition of large farmers with great amounts of produce who may flood the market and make his own small lot of little or no value. "Make him a farm owner, and then make for him an opportunity to be a successful one through co-operative marketing of his products and co-operative purchase of his supplies." That is the method employed by the Scandinavian farmers, particularly the Danish farmers, and now with growing enthusiasm by the farmers of other Scandinavian countries. They are not united with the producers' societies. In many respects they clash. The two are not one. They have grown in the northern countries because there was a need for them. Few American Co-operatives In America there are a few co-operatives. They have been growing slowly, meeting with some setbacks. Cooperatives in Scandinavia experienced dozens of beginnings before they achieved stability. The co-operative wholesale agencies of the great vegetable sections and the well-organized producers of other states cause to be shipped into Georgia each year thousands of dollars worth of products which Georgia could supply if there were organized production. It is something, at least, about which to think. Scandinavia found the small farmer lost in these modern days of marketing and price fluctuations without co-operative effort by the various communities. A. E. Drejer, secretary of the Danish central co-operative committee, says: 29 "Of the 3,600,000 people in Denmark only 400,000 are co-operatives. Yet the co-operative dairies handle 90 per cent of all milk and the co-operative societies handle 50 per cent of the butter, more than 80 per cent of the bacon and 25 per cent of the eggs. About 25 per cent of the import feed stuffs was bought through co-operatives. The co-operative movement has become an institution." Danes Through the Mill The Danish farmer went through, in 1870, about what the farmers of the South are going through today. That is, the latter are realizing that they must add to their farms poultry and cattle and gardens. The small farmers believe that without the co-operatives they would be lost. "I know," they say, "that my products are given the same care and treatment as those from a large farm. Further, the price is fixed, so I get as much for my products as does the larger farmer. I do not have to sell at a smaller price because I have less." The small farmers are organized in their own communities. Most of these societies belong to the national union. Their own credit banks finance them. It cannot be denied they are part of the great agricultural strength of the nation. By making the small farmer a land owner and by making it possible for him to market his products, Denmark has maintained an independent, hard-working group of solid citizens. Ownership Not Enough Whatever the answer may be, it must be admitted that mere provision of opportunity to own land is not enough. The Danish farmers are book farmers. One of them said in a conversation about America: "The farmers of America will learn that books and organization and knowledge of markets are necessary." 30 The Danish farmer reads newspapers and books. The middleman does not get the bulk of the farmers' money. The farmers get it. The large cities of the South are numerous enough to remake agriculture. If the Georgia farmers were so organized they could guarantee certain produce to the grocery stores in Atlanta, Savannah, Augusta and the other cities of the state; if Tennessee could supply Nashville, Chattanooga, Memphis and Knoxville; if Kentucky could fill the grocery bins of Louisville and Lexington and Frankfort and her other cities-agriculture would profit to an extent impossible to estimate. The markets are there in most of the southern statesready cash markets. There is no organization of farmers to fill them. Until the consumers of the cities and the producers of the cities work together, there will be no real solution of local markets for home-raised products. It is a problem that cannot be blinked at. Co-operative societies in various sections of the state and agreements with city merchants might be the answer. If it isn't, then something else must be developed to take its place. HOW THE DANISH FARMER PLANS HIS FARM PROGRAM We had gone to Slangerup, the old capital city. "We will stop at five small farms and go in and talk," said the teacher, who was driving me in a rented car. "I will explain it." And that is how the copy of the Atlanta Constitution of January 23 found its way into five Danish farm homes. It was the copy telling of the Constitution's Plant-to-Prosper competition, designed to supply a great impetus to the agricultural welfare of Georgia. 31 The translation was carefully done. The Danish farmer, whose position is comparative with that of the Georgia and other cotton and tobacco state farmers, in that the Dane also has two cash crops, bacon and butter, seemed to express this attitude and opinion: They Want to Know About U. S. Farmer "We would like to enter such a competition..... It is unusual, is it not, to find a newspaper which is so willing to pay cash to aid the people who read it? .... Tell us about the American farmer, does he have as many worriel'l as we? .... Why do they not live from their own products? " The Danish farmer, dependent on a foreign market, cannot believe any other farmer has his worries. Nor can he understand a farmer who does not first feed himself and his family. That has been the first concern of the Danish farmer-he feeds himself. He eats better than anyone else in Denmark. Danish Farmers Follow Old Plan They looked with interest at the copy of the Constitution. I felt a great pride in the paper, in being a part of it. It becomes more than a job when that job is concerned with a paper which is dedicated to the service beyond that ordinarily supplied by a newspaper. And I thought, sitting before the fires in the homes of Danish farmers, watching them as they had the Constitution's article read to them, of how many farmers in Georgia must be reading it and feeling, in the opportunity offered, a chance to become independent and to help make the state the great prosperous commonwealth it has a right to be. On each farm I asked the old question: "Tell me how you plant to live at home?" The Danish farmer follows the old, old plan. He rotates his crops. He plants with an eye to producing, as far as possible, food for his own stock. He plants to supply his 32 own table with bread and meat and with vegetables and with butter. He grows pigs to sell and he never fails to grow enough pigs to have his own meat. His cows supply milk and butter. He never slavishly follows his two real crops, pigs and butter. He stresses them. They are his cash crops. He lives on his others. He keeps his soil intact and productive. He knows no erosion or soil depletion. No soil here "wears out." It should be kept in mind that more than 90 per cent of the Danish farms are owned by the men who till the soil. Every government of modern years has devoted itself to legislation making this possible. The number of farms has been increased by about 20,000 in 30 years. Many of Them Ask Naive Questions Many of them ask naive questions. One of those to whom we talked owned, or was paying for, 18 acres of land. He had five cows, three horses, chickens, pigs and good machinery. His cottage of stone had three rooms. It was painfully clean. It was whitewashed outside, as were all the farm buildings. "Is it true that this newspaper publisher will pay men 14,000 kroner just to persuade them to grow food for their own table?" they asked. (There are about four "kroner" in the dollar.) I assured them that it was. They wagged their heads, some of them, in an attitude of incredibility. They regard America as a land of wealth and of great promise. Many of them have fantastic ideas about it and I am afraid that in the years to come there will be a new folk study abol,lt Slangerup to the effect that in America farmers are paid to grow things for their families to eat. New Declaration of Independence We speak of the independence of the farmer. And yet, it is true that this independence has become more of a tradition and less of a fact as the economic pressure took 33 away land and profit and opportunity. It may be that this plan of the Atlanta Constitution will be a new declaration of independence for the farmers of Georgia. The Danish farmer has his problems. His lot is not the idyllic one which many have pictured it. He has severe problems, surrounded as he is with export and import limitations thrown up by other governments and, of . necessity, by his own. Yet he remains independent. He feeds himself. He may not, in bad years, have too much money. But you may travel the length and breadth of the land and you will not find the dejected, hopeless, discouraged group which makes up a large quota of the American farming population. Doing Something for Farmers For years and years people have been talking about helping the farmers. Now, the Constitution has decided to do something for the farmer. It has taken, according to the people here to whom I have talked, the most logical step-the stimulating of pride and the offering of a tangible reward. The offer supplies an immediate objective. Meanwhile, the Danish farmer, owning his own land, proud of it, interested in everyday affairs, subscribing to newspapers, reading farm journals, entering the annual competitions for bee, pig and dairy products, improving his products, wishes he could enter such a competition as the Constitution is sponsoring. The Danish farmer has learned domestic agriculture and commercial agriculture are two different things. Farming on a commercial basis means crops for the fam- ily and the stock, livestock for milk and meat and a sur- plus for home consumption, agencies for selling his pro- ducts, and a state which maintains agencies actively aiding agriculture. . It is a type of farming possible only to farm owners, and I think, to a literate farm population. 34 It is impossible to see just how tremendous may be the influence of this Constitution plan for the farmers of Georgia. PAPER MAKING AND FOREST CONSERVATION IN SCANDINAVIA AND GEORGIA It was after dinner at the home of one of the editors of a newspaper in Sweden that we sat looking at a birchwood fire and talking. "Tell me about this new pulp mill business that you people in the South are starting," he said. "We here in Sweden are afraid of it." He got up and brought around a copy of the magazine, Fortune, which carried a story of the new industry made possible by the inventive mind of a Georgian, Dr. Charles Herty. The article included maps with little colored dots indicating the various cities where manufacturing plants were in construction or were to be built. "The Scandinavian countries of Sweden, Norway and Finland are beginning to worry," he said. "Is it true that the South can produce wood pulp for newsprint?" I tried to tell him of the southern pine section-of Georgia with its millions of acres of slash pine. But also I thought of the flaming forests each fall, of millions of dollars in grown and young pine trees casting a red light across the skies at night. I tried to tell him of driving into South Georgia and of swirling smoke obscuring the roads by day. The European can never understand many things about the American people because they cannot conceive of the pioneer habit of mind. They do not understand the vastness of America and how this vastness brought about an attitude of mind which seemed to say, "Let the land wash away, cut down the trees, burn the forests, there is plenty' more left." 35 . Now that millions of acres are washed away and forest."l are gone, it is necessary to plan. Yet the old pioneer habit of thinking of the land and the forests as inexhaustible remains. Scandinavian Forests Turned into Money Georgia's forests and the pine sections of the South could be turned into money as they have been in Sweden and Norway and in Finland. The Norwegian paper industry is not of very late date. I like to write of Norway because the population is about the same as Georgia's. Many countries eclipse Norway as paper manufacturers. Norway exports most of her paper products. It is not too idle to think of the South in the future as exporting paper to all the newspapers of America and exporting paper to box companies and to packing companies. Norway has 41 paper mills. In addition, there are pulp mms which produce many tons of pulp for export with America the chief purchaser. What is it worth? Last year Norway received about 200,000,000 kroner for her export trade alone. The Norwegian kroner is worth exactly 25 cents in American money. Which means that Norway received $50,000,000 for her paper and pulp. Meanwhile Sweden is exporting more pulp and paper than Norway and Finland's export paper and pulp trade is growing with amazing rapidity. In Sweden the development of the paper pulp and paper industry is regarded as one of the chief features of the economic development of the nation. In 1935, the latest Swedish figures available. Sweden exported paper pulp alone valued at 270,000,000 kroner. The Swedish kroner if{ worth a bit more than an American quarter. Sweden received more than $65,000,000 for her export pulp. 36 Paper Sales Bring $60,000,000 to Sweden In addition to the pulp exports, the sale of other forms of paper brought in another $60,000,000 to Sweden alone. The report of the Swedish government says, "It was not until the manufacture of wood pulp began to flourish that the paper industry can be considered to have developed into a big industry." The South could, and can, be elevated to a much higher financial position and the general level of income raised by the development of the pulp industry. Yet the work is being carried on by a small group and most of the capital is coming from interests outside the South. Returning to Norway, it is found that 65 per cent of the forests are owned by individual farmers; 20 per cent by the state and municipalities and 15 per cent by private corporations manufacturing pulp and paper. The Norwegian laws as to forestry are similar to those of other Scandinavian countries. In former years the forests were left to the will of their owners. Large tracts of forests on the western coasts were entirely destroyed. A businessman does not permit his employees to destroy the building or the equipment in it. Yet it is safe to say that not a single farm in Georgia and few in the South find their owners particularly concerned about the trees and about the burning of large tracts of forest land by the tenants on the farms. There is nothing which I cherish more than an American citizenship and the traditions of America. Yet I must confess that uncontrolled individualism and independence not always seems to produce the desired result. If it is the theory of rugged individualism that the farmer may let his land go to ruin or may ruthlessly destroy the forests with no replacements, then it isn't producing a good result. There is a higher duty. "Cut What Timber Is Right and Proper" The land, in a sense, is there for a purpose. It is to 37 supply something. And surely the fact that the report of the Georgia Agricultural Department shows literally millions of acres lost to production through abuse is not a striking monument to the individualism of the farmer. I do not submit Norway's laws, which are similar to that of other Scandinavian countries, as perfect or as desirable in the South. But some sort of law is desirable. Norway and the other Scandinavian countries say this to a man who owns forests: "Cut what timber is right and proper. But if you cut unwisely and begin to destroy your forest through greed, we will take away from you the right to cut any trees at all. And until that restriction is lifted, only the forest inspectors may mark trees on your land for cutting." There is excellent co-operation. The Scandinavian farmers seem to realize that the best individualism and independence is that based on possession of land and of forests. They enjoy perfect freedom as long as they obey the law. The Norwegian Forest Association was organized in. 1898, just 40 years ago. In those 40 years it has planted 320 million trees. School children have planted 60 mil lion and young people's societies 20 million trees. In the same period the association has had dug 40 million yards of ditches and brought 300,000 acres of land into a condition which permitted planting of trees. Education is a factor. It is possible these articles have too much to say about education. But one keeps finding it here. \Vhat we can learn from the educational systems of these countries is this: they teach more than lessons in books; there is more to be learned than memorizing certain facts in books; the teaching of civics means more than the teaching of certain printed facts about government and the duties of citizenship. Children Are Taught Value of Forests The children in Sweden and Norway are taken on trips to the forests each year. They are taught that the forests arl 38 more than just the property of the man on whose place they groW. They are a part of the national wealth. They mean more money for the nation so that it may have better schools, better hospitals, and so on. They are taught that any man who abuses his forests is destroying not only his oWn property but also a part of the heritage of the nation. They are taught that such policies create unemployment. There is no movement to destroy the right of private property. But it does rest on a new basis, that of the relative property right. And so, Norway's forests grow and continue to bring in an enormous revenue and to provide work for thousands. That, it seems to me, is independence and individualism more to be desired than that which permits, in the name of individualism, greedy and ruthless destruction of land and forests. It seems to me the great hope of the future in America lies in the South. And wherever I go, I try to see things in the light of what the South might do-of what my own state of Georgia might do-with the same resources and the same opportunity. I recall hearing, two years ago, legislators saying that too much was spent on education, that five and even three months of schooling were enough for rural sections; that what was needed was more work and less education. In Georgia, now, a nine-month school has been guaranteed the rural sections. U ndoubtedly, education is the basis for advancement-an education which teaches a pride in state and nation, an education which raises the general cultural levels of citizenship and community life; an education which teaches practicality and not mere automatic memorizing of facts and figures. Then we can begin to create more forests, more industry, more land and to produce more wealth. The pine lands of Georgia and the coastal South can be turned into enough money to bring about a new era. So can 39 the fisheries of the South. The awakening will come. By edu- cation and planning we can hasten it. * CONSUMER CO-OPERATIVES While we waited for the automobile to arrive, one could see across the street at this Stockholm corner a grocery store with the sign, "Konsum." It is a sign which becomes the most familiar sign in Sweden. It appears in newspaper ads, on wall signs, in books, on pamphlets .... "Konsum." It indicates a store of the Swedish co-operatives. S. A. Stahre, of the Co-operative Union, arrived with his automobile. We started on a trip in which Stahre wanted to show some of the visual effects of co-operative consumers' and wholesalers' stores. He was not a propagandist but was, on the whole, one of the fairest men encountered on the trip to the north countries. "First," he said, "let me say that some of the things which have been printed about us are immensely flattering but somewhat exaggerated. "Our organization of members does about 12 to 14 per cent of the retail trade in Sweden. In Stockholm we do about 20 to 25 per cent of the retail food business. Our membership totals about 30 per cent of the population. Our chief asset is good will. "And lest your readers think that co-operatives are something which is peculiar to the north countries, or to socialistic tendencies, let me say that in England, the bulwark of conservatism, there are more co-operative societies than in all the Scandinavian countries put together; that the same is true of the republic of France and that the same applies to the farmers' co-operatives. England and France have more than all four of the Scandinavian countries put together." * Italics by the editor. 40 What of Co-operatives in America? "All right," I said, "now my obvious question is what yOU think about co-operatives in America?" "I don't know," he said, "I would think agriculture must inevitably develop some co-operatives. I don't know if the plan would work in your cities for the consumers. It may. "Let me say that our consumer co-operatives have grown because there was a need for them. If there is no need for them in America, then they won't develop. If they begin they likely will begin with the trade unions." "Explain how you got your start in the food business in the cities." "I'm glad you asked that. Some of the books written about us make it appear we have wiped out all other business. There is no fight between retail business and the co-operatives. We have grown, side by side. It is interesting to note that now there is beginning new opposition for us in the multiple shops, or chain grocery stores as you call them. They are adopting our measures and methods and are growing. "We do think we keep down prices in retail businesg. And we are in opposition to any monopoly which keeps up prices. "You might say we had virgin territory in our methods of retail food business. We did not, as some people seem to think who come here to visit us, force out of business any other stores. "There were no chain stores in business. We now see them developing, copying our shops and our methods of packaging and display. You may be sure of this-when the co-operative stores cease to give service, to pay dividends to their members and to sell at a lower price, there will be no co-operative progress. Our only reason for survival is service." 41 Higher Prices, Higher Dividends "In Denmark they have, on the whole, somewhat higher prices but dividends of a higher level. Here we keep prices low and the dividends are smaller, about 3 to 5 per cent. "It might be explained that members of the co-operatives are not bound to buy from co-operative stores. Co-operatives are a perfect democracy in that their members control them by votes and in that members are free to buy where they choose. Which brings me back to what I said before, that co-operatives begin to fill a need and exist because they do fill it." The usual methods of the co-operatives are to enter the purchases of each member on books. At the end of the year the member is paid a dividend. It is a nonprofit organization, the only funds kept back being those for a sinking fund to help finance new enterprises. "What business are you in?" "We did in 1937 about 217 million kroners of business in our wholesale co-operative business, selling to retail co-operatives. Our total retail business was about 600 million kroner. The kroner is worth about 27 cents in American money. So you see what the business is in dollars. That represents an increase over the 1936 bus iness which was 195 million kroner and 512 million kroner, respectively. "That turnover in a country of 6,000,000 people was done by 735 co-operative societies all belonging to the co-operative union and having about 4,000 retail outlets. "We are in the food business, in the margarine busi ness, in shoes, in electric light bulbs, in flour, in rubber goods, including boots and galoshes, in office machines, in artificial silk, in the manufacture of diaphane, which is your cellophane; we make refrigerators, washing rna chines, vacuum cleaners." 42 Co-operatives Own Large Department Store "In addition we own and operate the second largest department store in Sweden." All of which may give an idea of what an extent the co-operative societies are in business. With about 30 per cent of the population as members and with 98 per cent of the members regarding his co-operative as a sort of religion, it is obvious what an influence the co-operatives have. The co-operative idea began in England. In the Scandinavian countries its beginnings saw failure after failure. The beginnings sa w the idea ridiculed, opposed most violently by banks and by retail business. There is opposition yet from the smaller retail merchants. But there is none from the banks or from so-called big business. There is a very good reason. Co-operation is big business in Sweden. The trip began with a visit to Luma, the electric light plant. The story of the development of the cooperatives' business is not one flattering to its opposition. Each time they played into the hands of the co-operatives who long ago learned the value of advertising and telling their own story. "When the co-operative announced it planned a lamp plant, the opposition reduced prices. The co-operative shrieked its 'We told you so'." Today the plant is international, supplying co-operatives in three other Scandinavian countries and also co-operatives in Scotland. The same story was true of the rubber factory, where boots and galoshes, a necessity in winter, were to be made. So it was with the other efforts to break down monopolies. The opposition seemed to lose all judgment and played their cards as the co-operatives wanted them played. 43 We saw the flour mill, the bread plant and the macaroni factory, three large separate plants, on the island which the co-operative union owns. There also live 350 families in co-operative flats and one-family houses. Co-operative Union Publishes Magazine The co-operative union publishes a magazine, We. It has a circulation of about 530,000 weekly, the largest circulation of any publication in Sweden. In it are published propaganda articles for the business and also fiction by the leading writers of Sweden. From that beginning the firm went into other fields and now publishes many books by leading economists of all nations and also some popular fiction. We saw the school, three large mansions bought from one of Sweden's most wealthy men and transformed into a school for co-operatives. There come all the workers from the co-operative stores, learning how to keep a shop, learning display, advertising, merchandising. They come at the expense of the c~o-operative and go through schooling. From these schools come the promotions. The Konsum shops look so much like our own smart grocery shops of America that only the sign is different. The general rules are: Membership is open to everybody, they are owned by the members and controlled by them, the return on the share capital is limited to 5 per cent, the surplus is distributed among the customers proportionately to the value of their purchases, the societies observe strict political and religious neutrality, business is done on a cash basis, the societies promote the economic and social education of their members. They sell to nonmembers but the dividend they receive applies on shares in the co-operative. Note the low prices and the practice of selling to the general public. The co-operative wholesalers have to compete with the non-eo-operative wholesaler and if his prices are cheaper they buy from him. 44 Albin Johansson Behind It All Back of it all is a financial and business genius, Albin Johansson. He is given credit for turning the government back from its efforts to create a government monopoly on gasoline and coffee. He has kept peace between the farmers, whose co-operatives must be added to those of the consumer and wholesale union, if one is to get the true picture in Sweden. He heads the co-operative union. Consumer co-operatives in Scandinavia vary in their relationships v.rith farmers. In Sweden the farmer is courted. In Sweden, Norway and Finland the co-operatives largely are supported by members of the trade unions. Trade unions in the large industrial centers have led the way. In Denmarh: all co-operatives have their members largely among farmers. In Copenhagen the movement is gaining but to date the labor leaders are not quite friendly because only in Denmark are the farmers, the small farmers excepted, in the conservative party where they help wield a tremendous influence. r visited the head of the Danish co-operative in the new office building in Copenhagen. "In the past 10 or 15 years we have been making progress. in the cities. Our business is increasing, wholesale and retail, 9 to 10 per cent per year. Our dividends are from 6 to 20 per cent. These are the dividends paid back to the customers. Surely and not so slowly as before the working class people are joining the co-operatives. You must remember we are not industrial as in Sweden and other countries." In Denmark a turnover in 1936 of 195,776,214 kroner. The Danish kroner is worth about 22 cents. The cooperative union operates 22 factories of which two, the coffee "roastery" and the margarine factory, are large ones, doing more than $2,000,000 business each year. In the cities the grocery turnover in 1936 was more than 13,000,000 kroner as against 12 million for the year before. 45 Each small village has its co-operative store, a sort of general store. Books on Co-operatives Written in Europe Many thick books have been written about co-operatives in Europe. Any articles must, of necessity, be sketchy. This one has attempted to give a sort of picture. I think it explains, for the first time, that the food stores began because there were no others like them. They had a virgin field. Today the chain store is developing under private o\vnership. No one, before the co-operatives, had tried modern marketing in food. Co-operatives are inevitably tied in, as far as support goes, with the trade unions. Only in Denmark are the co-operatives a farmers' organization. They have held, as have the chain stores in America, to the cash and carry plan. They do all the business but about 12 to 14 per cent of the retail business in Scandinavia. This, of course, refers only to the consumer co-operative unions and not to the farmers' co-operatives with their bacon, milk and meat "centrals." And conservative England, where they began, has more than the rest of the world put together. There are almost 8,000,000 members in Great Britain and the co-operative trade of the consumer co-operatives is 12 per cent of the total retail trade of Great Britain. Private Business Increases In All Private business continues to increase in all co-oper ative countries. During the period of co-operative growth in Sweden, for instance, the number of private business firms has increased 100 per cent. Merchandising has been improved and perfected by co-operatives in Europe but the standards are not as high, in the food stores for instance, as in the chain food store! 46 in America. Cellophane wraps, for instance, are just beginning to be employed. It has been progressive but it has created nothing new. Co-operation, I think, is a state of mind. It grows slowly. It comes because a need is felt for it. As for America-apparently there has been no need in the minds of the people of the income class who have made those in Europe. The consumer co-operative officials frankly say they sec small chance for consumer co-operative development in America. Thus far this has been an attempt to tell the story, as briefly as possible, of what has happened in Sweden. I would close with a personal observation which is that in America the farmers, and especially those who are being rescued from the tenant class and given a new start in life, arc those with the greatest claim to a need for some sort of co-operative plan for marketing their products. SOCIAL PROBLEMS AND EDUCATION Each of the north countries in Europe-the Scandinavian countries of Sweden, Norway, Denmark and Finland, have achieved remarkable results with temperance in lands where heavy consumption of hard liquors used to be the rule. And just as one bumps into education in looking at what has been done in the system of land tenure, cooperation, and all the social legislation, so does one bump into it looking at the reduction in alcoholic drinks and in drunkenness. Norway and Finland tried prohibition and ran into an increase in crime and smuggling and drunkenness. !'\orway got rid of prohibition and even the temperance party doesn't care for that method. Sweden and Denmark, by different methods, set to work to educate the people not to drink to excess. 47 Eighty years ago the Swedes drank about 10 gallons of hard drink per capita per year. In 1913 it had dropped to about hvo gallons per capita and in 1936 it was down to a little more than fiv,; litres, or about five quarts. "You can do more with education than with laws," said a member of the liquor control board, when I talked with him regarding a hotel and cafe strike which closed everyone in the entire nation with not more than three or four exceptions. And they of a minor nature. It already has been told how, under the Swedish law, a citizen may not purchase more than one-fourth of a pint to be consumed on the premises and that only with a real meal. He may purchase, through the control stores, not more than four litres per month snd 80 per cent of the customers are permitted less. "Is there any way the law is cheated?" I asked a Swedish newspaperman. Citizens Cheat Little on Liquor Laws "Just one poor small cheat may be had," he said. "The stranger within our g'ate~, may obtain a temporary permil and then turn over his purchases to a friend in Sweden, That's all. And that isn't much of a cheat. Rather that that, and the small amoJ1nts sailors manage to bring in for themselves and their friends th~ law is airtight. Ani don't think those sailors bring in cases. They get by wit! a bottle or so." He rang up a member of the control board. "There's a newspaperman here from America," he said "\vho isn't interested in obtaining a T:ermit but wants V see how the law works." So, that's how it happened I went down and watchei while the Swedish control board worked at the problel 48 which has made one of the most temperate nations on earth out of one of the hardest drinking nations. Drinks may be bought with meals-but meals must be bought and the total number of drinks permitted will average about three. That's the hotel and cafe problem which has brought on a nationwide lockout, or strike, seeking to change public opinion-not to change the temperance laws but merely to permit the hotel and cafe men a larger amount of liquors to be sold at a profit. This story is concerned with what happens at a control office when a tourist or a Swede comes in for a permit. Watches Work of Control Board The office is in the monopoly administration building, each district having one. One enters. It is something like a bank office. There are chairs. There are small desks with pen and ink and blanks. At one end of the room is a long counter, or desk, behind which are the officials. I watched the procedure. A tourist came in. His wife was with him. They represented a large American firm and he was on a trip through Europe seeing some of the agencies. He told one of the officials that he was a visitor from America that thought it was queer to have so much formality about getting a bottle of scotch in his room and that he had come to see about it. "Fill out one of these blanks, please," said the officials. He walked to one of the desks with it and the official who was ihowing me through handed me one of the blanks. It required name and address, permanent address, age, nationality. Then there was the question: "Why do yoU require spirits?" 49 The American bu~~ine~;small had the answer for them. "To drink it," he wrote in his form. After it was handed in he waited-while the files were arranged It was a wait of about 15 minutes during which time he. and others who had come in, waited in this plain roon: yvhich did not promote the desire to drink. Eventually number cards were presented to about If people-the American among them-and they were con elucted to another room. Under Age of 25 Only 1 Litre Granted There the prospective purchasers waited until their numbers were called. They then went, separately, inti one of the several offices. From them came the murmur of voices. Each was being quizzed. Those not over 25 were tali they would be permitted only one litre per month-ni more. That was final. Those over 25 were asked ques tions about why they wanted it. The American, by saying that his wife was along, tha: he was expecting to entertain friends and member:iJ 0' his firm, was permitted four litres. The Swedes were no' faring as well. l\i(ost of them got cards for less. Once they had their cards they still had to go to thl liquor store to make the purchase. And when the nex month came around they had to go back with anoth6 application to fill out. The system would not work in America any more thai did the experiment of prohibition. The reason is th~ America has not been subjected to a system of educatiol It was not so many years ago that the Swedes were almo! swept into prohibition. They avoided it and substitute! control of consumption through law bolstered by eduC! tion. Most of the Swedes regard their present system I the most workable one possible. 50 Temperance Courses in Every Institution Temperance instruction is given in every institution coming under the control of the board of education. It is not a fanatical, emotional education. It is a calm and sane teaching of temperance. It teaches the effects of overindulgence on the individual and the community. It is important to notice that it is combined naturally with the teaching of other subjects. It is not, let it be said again, made a special subject; there is no signing of pledges or any "drive" to force the question. It is made a matter of intelligence, not of the emotions. The same idea is carried on in adult education. There are even correspondence courses in temperance. Temperance is not to be confused with prohibition. Temperance, it has been found, makes for abstinence more often than does prohibition. Somewhere, somehow, the Scandinavian people got the idea, years ago, of proceeding by education in their matters of government and their social life. It is incorrect to view these nations as Utopias. They have their problems, among them being many that are our problems. But they do seem to solve them, or make progress toward solution, by reason and not emotional experiments for which there is lacking adequate mental preparation. The problem of alcohol, with lowered consumption and less drunkenness, the problem of prostitution with no. organized vice and the lowest rate of venereal infection in the world, would seem to indicate that education works more effectively than any other one factor, and that laws, when prepared for by education, are therefore more effective. PROBLEMS OF LABOR AND CAPITAL There seems to be no good reason for ignoring current events while on a search for the sources and methods of 51 workable social legislation, as employed by the nortl countries. And the most interesting of the current events is thE hotel strike in Sweden which has been going on for ~ couple of weeks at this writing and likely will go on fOI another month or two. This is a hotel strike and at the same time a piece of labor warfare which must go down in history as exhibit A in effectiveness, good humor, and perhaps, something of an innovation. The hotels in Stockholm are closed. The Grand hotel is locked. So are all the Grand's associates in the business of housing the paying guest. Every hotel in Sweden is closed, a few of the winter sports hotels, and the small "pension" type expected. Not only that, but all the cafes are closed. Everyone of the famous restaurants has the word "stangt" written on the door. In the entire city there are just three cafes open and they employ unorganized labor. The city of Stockholm is the capital city of a rather well-known, prosperous European country. And as soon as the strike went on, with some 30,000 people "out," I hurried to Stockholm to inquire into the whys and the wherefores. It required more than a day or so. Or even a week. Because this is the unique strike, or lockout, of the present era. No Violence in Swedi~h Strikes It is a very good thing, too, that it has come, this strike. There are a number of reasons. It will do, in the first place, to illustrate how sanity prevails in labor and capital conflicts in a democratic country governed by a Social Democrat government. They simllly don't have violence. This is one of the oddest strikes on record in this, or any other country. 52 But at the same time it is a very effective one, and it is nation wide. It might be well to say just here that Sweden and Denmark have made more progress in democratic, social legislation than any other nation. They don't have slums, they don't have illiteracy, they don't have poverty as we know it, and they manage to take care of health, education, poor relief and industrial conditions in a manner which is exciting and admirable. Yet they are not yet Utopias as some of our enthusiastic writers who visit here would have us believe. The Swedes have co-operatives as one of the most potent forces in their national and economic life. Yet co-operatives do not make up more than 12 to 14 per cent of the retail business of the nation. Trade unions flourish here as nowhere else. Yet of 1,600,000 employed only 700,000 are in organized labor. They have their strikes. Your worker here is an ardent Social-Democrat. Yet, do not think for a moment he is a Socialist. He believes in private property with an intensity that makes housing here and the home-ownership of land one of the big stories. Liquor Laws Lie Behind "Lockout" The liquor laws of Sweden, models for all others, are behind this unique strike in the hotel and cafe trades. It is a strike by the owners-not the workers. So, perhaps it is best to term it a "lockout." This isn't exactly a correct term, but it comes nearer to explaining it, perhaps. The hotels were locked up by their owners. So were the eafes. The really unique feature of it all is that the workers thought the owners were exactly right. They agreed, the workers did, that the owners were in a tight spot. But they wanted more wages. But they insisted on their raise and when it wasn't forthcoming they notified their 53 employers they would have to go out. So the employers, in sorrow and not in anger, locked their doors. Now, the city of Stockholm is a city of about 700,000, if we include its populous areas known as "Greater Stockholm." And it is a bit odd to find all the restaurants closed and all the hotels locked tight. The only places open are the beer cafes. Beer is regarded as a harmless drink. And the small Kondltorl. which sells coffee and sweet cakes, is to be found, in most instances, on the job. But no food is to be had, no vegetables, no steaks, no Smorgast, no soups or fish dishes. Everything is stangt on account of a labor dispute. The beer cafes, inci. dentally, do not sell any food at all. Just beer. Cause of Strike Not in Newspapers No mention at all is made in the papers of the real cause of the strike. The people laugh about it. The newspapers ran pictures of parliament with members bringing food from home. And the prime minister was in a cartoon which showed him going to his office with a fishing pole over one shoulder and hanging from the pole were sausages, bread and a thermos jug. It was all good-natured. They have got beyond violence in labor disputes here. And that's a very good thing, too, because when your phlegmatic Scandinavian does get angry he is a rather tough customer to handle. The strike, or lockout, just didn't seem right. There ought to be some reason for things and a hotel just doesn't lock up and close up for a couple of months unless there is something fundamentally wrong some where. A city of nearly three-quarters of a million people, and all the other cities in an entire nation doesn't just see all its hotels and restaurants close without some thing being done. And nothing was being done. The workers were sitting in the beer cafes or in the hondltorls or at home. Parliament was in session. The guests, who had been notified 54 before the lockout, were gone. (For two weeks no one has come to Stockholm but now a few are beginning to arrive.) The strike, or lockout, ,vas just an ordinary item. It was buried over on the inside of the paper along with the story about the best recipe for puddings. It just wasn't news. And that, mind you, in a town with six newspapers and in a nation which reads papers as much as any nation on the earth. How Would U. S. Papers Play Strike? I could imagine Atlanta, Georgia, or Dallas, Texas, or Minneapolis, Minnesota, or Louisville, Kentucky, with eYery hotel and restaurant closed, and I could imagine \"here the story would be in the morning and afternoon papers. It wouldn't be inside with the liver pill "ads." So I started asking a few questions here and there. And the result was that out of it came a story concerning old John Barleycorn, the old gentleman with the red nose, who is to be found in every clime and on every land. Here they had him hobbled and branded and used as a sort of minor mint to keep one corner of the state's strong box filled. But Old John, who actually is well-behaved here under a set of laws which are rather sane, in most respects, is at the basis of the strangest strike in all labor history. 55 III. A GEORGIAN AMONG THE DANES~ THOMAS C. DAVID How the Danish Farmer Lives I have just returned from a three day bicycle trip through the southern part of the island of Zealand. I could have made this trip easily in one and a half days of continuous riding, without stopping to talk and work with the people in their fields. But as I myself am a farmer and a student of Danish agriculture, most of my time on this trip was spent in talking with these people who depend on farming for a living. Little less keen than my interest in their methods is my pleasure in visit~ ing their homes, drinking their coffee and enjoying the renowned Danish hospitality. Volumes could be written on the Danish coffee and pastry, but I believe these two topics are generally excluded from papers on agriculture. Traveling south from Helsingor I rode down the coastal highway towards Copenhagen. Cycling along this road re'quired little effort, and although there are no farms to 'be seen on the highway, the beauty of the scenery is well worth anybody's time. Until I reached Copenhagen ( was never more than a kilometer from the water's edge. Beautiful small villas with flower gardens and trees line the road from Relsingor to Copenhagen, making it seem that the two cities have met. Deciding to avoid delay of becoming involved in Copenhagen's traffic, I turned westward and circled the city, passing through many quaint villages of old houses and narrow, winding streets :~ Tbe lotters. from Mr. Thomas C. David of Danielsville. Georgia. are written .......JXJn.or. who have sent him to Denmark for a year to study the Danil!!lh .. IIolpM o~educating its people for ..tisfying and profitable life on the land. It ~ t t he wil.l. upon his re.turn. be able to make use of his knowledll'e Bnd 1IIIIwtL" III bettermg the technIques of agricultural education and farm Iife in 57 paved with intricate patterns in the cobblestones. Between two of these little towns I stopped at a roadside shop where I bought a drink, and enjoyed the lunch I had brought with me sitting in the cool shade of a forest of beech trees. Most or the afternoon I spent riding over small country roads which led me into the very heart of the farming communities. I made slow progress, sometimes retracing my tracks in order to remain near the highway. Everywhere men were busy cutting hay and working in the beet crops, and already the countryside was beginning to look as if it would produce an abundant harvest. I stopped now and then and watched the men as they followed close behind the mowers, stacking hay on big frame racks. Night was drawing on and I decided to spend it in the most inexpensive way possible. For two crowns I had a good dinner at a small seaside hotel, and finished it quickly so that I would have time to look around for a comfortable haystack. After exam ining a few of them and taking note of their location, I selected one in a new-mown field near a fine forest. This one would do. Haystacks in Denmark are long rather than round, and all of them have large holes through the center so that proper curing can take place. Having made a really intimate acquaintance with them, I feel well qualified to describe them. In this stack, with my hat stuffed with straw for a pillow, I spent a comfortable night. When the mosquitoes attacked me I covered myself with hay and slept as soundly as a baby the rest of the night, for when I woke again the sun was shining brightly. My baggage consisted of a razor and a cake of soap, and I rode three kilometers to the sea and put them to use. Breakfast at a nearby farmhouse gave me a good start for the day. I spent that morning as I had the afternoon before, riding slowly through the lanes and watching the farmers 58 at work. At noon I bought a good meal at a farmhouse, and early in the afternoon I began looking for a farm where I could work several hours for my night's lodging and supper. Near Koge I happened upon one that looked interesting, and when I passed the house I made a general survey and noticed that the family was working in a nearby field. I went to them and presented my proposition as well as I could. They seemed interested in my offer, because they immediately presented me with a pitchfork and for three hours we stacked hay, talking all the while. I was learning the methods of these people and at the same time getting an insight into the way they think regarding Americans and other foreigners. They were intensely interested in America, and were constantly asking me if we knew such a method of stacking hay, or if we used this or that implement, and they asked if I had ever worked on a farm. I assured them that I had and they seemed astonished to meet an American who had actually done farm labor. At six o'clock the father said, "Come with me," and we went to the house and were given Danish wine and urcad with honey. After that came the task of milking twenty cows. Not until I had actually demonstrated my ability as a milker would they believe I had ever been close to a cow before, and when I began milking with uoth hands it caused quite a sensation. Milking on an a\'erage Danish farm is different from the methods used in an American dairy. The farmer and I carried two small pails to milk in while the small son of the family urought large containers to the field on a big two-wheel cart. I was interested to see that the cows were not urought to the barn for milking, but were staked in the field and milked on the spot. When each cow had been milked, the yield was weighed, recorded and poured into the larger containers. With this job completed, the cows were tied to longer ropes and staked in the field for the night, and I learned that they would remain there to be brought to the barn for the winter only, or for bad weather in the summer. A water tank mounted on 59 a cart brings water to them every morning and afternoon. I asked the farmer if I might drive the cart to the house and he agreed readily, but before I'd gone very far I realized that the hon;e I was driving didn't understand English. Time only could tell how I would stop him. 'When we came to the barn I pulled on the lines and said "\Vhoa !," but he kept going. There was only one thing to do and I did it! I ran him directly into the wall of the barn, causing the large cans of milk to topple and almost fall off. I had proved myself inadequate for the occasion and it caused a lots of laughter among the spectators. Getting a Danish horse started requires the same tactics one must use on a Georgia mule, but stopping him is a different story. To stop a Danish horse one must imitate the sound of a buzz saw when it hits a knot in a pine plank. After this interlude of horseplay the farmer gave two hours of his time to showing me his farm. We walked over his fields and through his barns. I asked many questions and he willingly gave me such information as I was able to understand. I tried to observe everything as minutely as possible. We came at last to his flower garden. Here he showed me his favorite flowers and pointed out varieties which I had never seen, and he told me that every afternoon he spent a few minutes working here among his flowers. His efforts had reaped fine results for the flower beds \vere a riot of bold colors contrasted with the digniLy of well-groomed hedges and clean, smooth walks. Apple trees and pear trees laden with fruit furnished shade for the garden and were examples of the Danish farmer's ability to combine beauty and utility. The courtyard, too, was planted in flowers. Surrounded by the house and three barns forming a square around it, the whole made a pretty picture. When we had been given wine and bread at six o'clock I thought we were having supper, but now at eight o'clock we were called to the dining room again. This 60 time we really had a supper, for the meal consisted of meat, vegetables, an alw.nehmt supply of buttered bread, and beer, potatoes and hon8Y. For dessert we were given large bowls of strawberries with sugar and cream. I ate heartily thinking this, would be my last opportunity for the night, but no sooner had we finished than we were called to the garden for coffee and c(1kes. Electric lights hanging from branches of the IJear trees were s\\'itched on, and for em hour ',ve 8::tt and tried to make COI1Yel's;,tiol1 by referring to elietlonaries and repeating words and sentences time and again. This exertion added to my day's work made me tired and sleepy, so at ten o'clock I asked if I might go to hed. Leading the way up a circular staircase, my host carried me to the guest room. It seemed that I was heing t;1I~en to tIle attic, for the hall was really the loft, and its walls were hung with onions and potatoes covered the floor. I IV;]S s111'pri;,eo when my host opened a door leading off from this p:mtry-lil