Preliminar,y Report DEI'ERMINmG LOGICAL REGION BOUNDARIES m FOR AREA-WIDE PLANNING AND D.EVELOPMENT GEORGIA Planning Division Georgia Deparbllent of Commerce 100 State Capitol Atlanta, Georgia FOREWARn The following preliminary report presents and discusses briefly some of the factors which, in our opinion, should be considered by locaJ. groups when determining the geographic boundaries of areas to be organized tor cooperative, area-wide, planning and devel ..,....r.ent activities. It is hoped that this report will serve two purposes. They are first, to act as a preliminary or stop-gap guide to local groups interested in establishing regional or area-wide planning and development organizations, and second, to serve as a tangible starting point tor preparation of a more comprehensive guide to determination of lo$ical regions for cooperative planning activity, by a pooling of knowledge fran the m.a.n:y agencies and organizations in the state which could contribute to such an undertaking. Your comments and criticisms will be welcoo V. R. Stuebing, Jr., Manager Planning Division Georgia DePartment of Commerce 1 CONTENTS Page FORWARD 1 . . . . . . INTRODUCI'ION. 0 . 1 FACTORS INFWENCING REGIONAL DELINEATION 3 . . Natural Environment o .. 3 Cultural Environment. 4 Transportation o 4 Communication. 4 Urbari Centers. 4 Polii;ical BOundaries 5 . . . 'SOME "RQLES OF THUMB" .. . 7 FIGURES 1. Major Drainage Areas 2. Major Soil Areas 3 Interstate Highway System 4. PQpula.tion Centers 5. Areas of' EmPloyment Influences 6. Retail Trade Centers - Areas of' Primary Dominance 7. State Senatorial Districts 8. Congressional Districts . . . APPENDIX I: Excerpt From General Planning Enabling legislation .. APPENDIX II: Sample Resolutions For Creating An Of'f'icial Regional Or Area-Wide Planning Commission ii OO'RODUCTION At the present time there are over 140 city-,, county, or joint city-county planning commissions in Georgia. Each of these local planning commissions is engaged in the preparation of studies, plans, and recommendations dealing with such subjects as the local economy, population, roads and streets, traffic and parking, subdivision development, land-use, recreation, and the like. All of these activities are aimed at anticipating and encouraging devel~nt of a local physical environment that will best serve the present and future needs of the people living and 'WOrking in the local community or area. In addition to this planning activity at the individual city and county level, groups of cities and counties are banding together in several sections of the state - in both formal and informal organizations - to pool avail~ble talents and energies and to strengthen and provide a broader area-wide base and framework for the planning and development of their respective regions. One outstanding example of such a regional or area-wide planning organization is the eleven-coUnty Coosa Valley Area Planning and Development Commission in Northwest Georgia. The program already underwey by this organization includes employment of a full-time professional-technical staff which is working with various local, state, and federal agencies in developing coordinated regional planning for such matters as major highways~regional recreation facilities, regional development and promotion of tourist attractions, agricultural and industrial development, water resource development, and such other matters as can profitably be studied at a regional level. In addition, this staff is providing continuing assistance to local planning and development groups within the area. Several agencies and organizations have advised and assisted in the creation of the regional planning and development groups which have been organized'- to date; 1 they have encouraged the logical groupings of these counties and cities into such organizations based on considerations of mutual interests and various other unifying factors. However, there is a recognized need for a more systematic approach to the identification and delineation of logical and appropriate regional planning areas. For the purpose of assisting in initiation of such an approach and of encouraging additional thought and effort toward this end by local groups and by the agencies and organizations interested in cooperating with and assisting these groups, presented hereafter are same of the factors and conditions which should be considered by local groups when delineating regions for cooperative planning and development activity. 2 FACTORS INFLUENCING REGION DELINEATION There are numerous factors Which should be investigated prior to delineation of planning regions. In addition, there' are varying degrees of thoroughness that may be applied to an investigation of these factors. Some factors would prove very important in one area while less important in another, thus req?iring a subjective judgement as to the criteria that should have the most influence in the .. delineation of the boundaries of a particular region. A number of these factors will be reviewed in the following sections and, in most cases, illustrated on acc~ing maps. Natural Environment The physical features of an area, such as climate, topography, ... rivers, ... lakes, and ... soil conditions, can serve to unify or divide an area. For example, the presence of a large lake may create common objectives among the various communities located in its vicinity. On the other hand, the size and location of the lake ~ completely separate the local communities and thereby establish a natural division which crould serve as a region boundary. A drainage area can have a similar influence upon the unification or separation of an area. Figure 1, which shows the major watershed or drainage areas of Georgia, indicates, for instance, that Jefferson and Johnson Counties, although contiguously located, are in separate major drainage areas. .This would .' be a f.ctor for consideration in ~ ~ establishing a planning region. LikeWise, varia- tions in soil conditions and natural resources .mar serve as a unifying or dividing 3 influence because of the resulting variations in agricultural and other potentials. The major soil areas of Georgia are shown on Figure 2. Cultural Environment The cultural environments consist of the constructions of man and the patterns of human settlement The various for.ms of ... transporation, communic a t i o n 1 ... urban centers, ... political boundaries, and the like are cultural developments. Each plays a role in determining regional unity. Transportation. -- Tbe existence or non-existence of adequate means of transportation, either highway, water-way, or railway connect or disjoint an area. For instance, rapid and convenient means of transportation enable people to travel a number of miles to places of employment and trade. The completion of the Interstate Highway system in Georgia will unite areas that are at present separated by travel-time simply by reducing this travel-time. Figure 3 indicates the location of this highway system. Likewise, the improvements to and extension of navigation on various waterways within the state, such as the Chattahoochee and the Savannah, should also serve as a unifYing factor in particular regions. Communication. -- The areas inc'luded within t;,Ae circulation of newspapers, within the broadcasting range of radio and television stations, and within common telephone exchanges are i~fl~enced by common factors that create interrelations between communities. Urban Centers. -- An urban center may serve as the hub of a. logical planning region. This does not mean, however, that every region must be directly or+ented 4 or tied to a single dominant urban center. It is possible that a logical planning region will contain a number of urban places all sharing certain interrelations and all conscious of a oneness, provided that the region does not become too ex- pansive for effective and convenient association. Figure 4 shows the urban places in Georgia of over 100 persons. An urban center might be the focal point of employment for persons living in various locations of the surrounding area. Figure 5 indicates some of the major employment centers within the state. A particular urban center may serve as the principal shopping area or amuse~nt center for the adjacent communities or be the location for the distribution of farm products. The relationship of an urban place to the surrounding area can be gaged in various ways. Some of the factors which might be investigated when determining the "sphere of influence" of an urban center are the extent of its markets for products produced in the surrounding area, employment attraction area, hospital service area, distance and pattern of free parcel delivery by local stores, and distance and pattern of local newspaper distribution. Political Boundaries. -- A political boundary is perhaps one of the most dominant influences in creating the feeling of oneness in an area. This feeling exists to varying degrees within all levels of political jurisdictions. People share common interests as a direct result of their residing within the same municipal boundaries, county boundaries, state senatorial district, 5 ... congressional district, or 0 judicial circuit The boundaries of these jurisdictions, in most cases, have developed because of administrative necessity rather than by reason of any qualities inherent in the areas themselves. In other words, they are regions by designation rather than by evaluation. Therefore, caution should be exercised in simply designating a large political unit as a planning region. It would seem essential, however, to include the entire area of local political units (municipalities and counties) within the same planning region for obvious reasons of workability. 6 The following "rules-of~thumb 11 are believed to provide sound general guidelines for establishing the boundaries of official regional planning organizations~ 1. The spheres of influence of various natu1;al and cultural environmental factors in the area should be evaluatedo 2o The entire planning region should lie within the borders of the Stateo (It is realized that a planning region might logically extend across the State line in certain instances. For example, there may be a logical orientation around some nattrral resource - Clark Hill ~eservoir, Jim Woodruf Reservoir, etc., =or an urban center = Columbus, Chattanooga, Augusta, etc., - that transcends state borders$ and cooperation in such instances should be encouraged. However, because of the compounded difficulties of formally organizing and carrying out programs across state lines, feasibility should be carefully considered.) 3o The ''county" should be the basic unit or building=block; that is, the entire county should be in the same planning region. 4. Other things being equal, State Senatorial Districts should as nearly as possible remain intact, with planning regions defined so as to include groups of whole Senatorial Districts. 7 5. The optimum size for. a planning region would probably ' range between five and fifteen counties, with a maximum distance of one hundred high~ miles between the farthest points in a planning region. 8 T E N N. N. c. --- --- -------1 :! I: GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE :I PLANNING DIVISION FIGURE I Rl DGE Ll NES OF MAJOR DRAINAGE AREAS .' .. . ; 1: .:I !..: ...J I f L 0 R 'l t: D A N. c. GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE PLANNING DIVISION -------1 1 I' '! I: FIGURE 2 MAJOR SOIL AREAS OF GEORGIA 0 : i I I i i 'i ! I ' II 'I I I l; i i! ~f~----~L~--~~o:_______~R~------~------~0~-------A-------------j~,, II ::;:;oo--- - - - ' T E N N. N. I \ ' C:.ILYC c. -- - - -- - ------~ -- ---------, GEORGIA i I' DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE II Pl-ANNING DIVISION 'I :! ' FIGURE 3 I I: INTERSTATE HIGHWAY '! SYSTEM I I : i < < .J ----- L 0 R ----v / JCIMIIIIIS ./ scatvc .. i I I ; ! : , I . ! 'i 'i I I II j I I D A Ii:!:: .J . .. !! Ii < ,,I, ll co I~ '! I'! i < I 'I 'i I :I _J :I :, < I, ,I I DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE PLANNING DIVISION 1961 f L 0 R I: . I I. D A ---- --- - ___!! T E N N. N. c. --- -I II i I GEORGIA I'!' :I' DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE '' I\ PLANNING DIVISION FIGURE 5 AREAS OFEMPLOYMENIINFLUENCE :rI' 'I I < .J < GA..t..OY T'....O.,.AS 8111001'1.$ ' '-... f L 0 R "'':1"',, / ~ D A i I ' () {:: ~ ~ ~ ~ I, I, 'I '! ..: - - = - - - --------- ---~-- ~------ -~--------~~- T E N N. N. c. < ~-----------L--~~~ ~au~c.E.. ~ C:..~o1t4l,:~w FR.o&.J't"112:k'5 JekO\.J,...F'I..,c\o "" Ea.Jo.st W. Sw... a.oa.a L 0 R --------, GEORGIA 'I'' DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE PLANNING DIVISION 1\ FIGURE 6 I RETAIL TRADE CENTERS OF GEORGIA: ~ ~. . I ARE/'5 OF PRIMARY DOMINANCE :' iI ( l, i 'I . I 11 . I ! ; " 8ul LOCH '""-- 1 \ '\ _..- . .sAv~'NNA);j 'rA,HNA:~- -7'~, ... I"' \_.-. ~..... I \ ""'- A I 1-- "Y "-., ! ~ ~ 41 8 . i D A (J {: ~ ; i ~ ;:! ~ I' II I; i j '! j _J =---------- T E N N. N. c. ---------, GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE 11 I I PLANNING DIVISION FIGURE 7 STATE SENATORIAL Dl STRICTS ''I''' :I < I: '1 '; 1> < I' / < 't "Y .J C:.0L.QUITT --r--P"#""- ~ G R"0Y I ' ' r L 0 R v (: ~ ~ i i ~ ~ I ' I: j:' I i! A :! j !J ~-------- T E N N. N. c. GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE PLANNING DIVISION ------1 i I I ~ ; I I! I I. I! I FIGURE 8 CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICTS i I I I '! II . < -- __ ........ v- .J ~ --r J j J"' M'IIS. A.PPl..l"''C. L_IJ--~ i l >. conu &ACON l ~ .. _/ ~ '; ~---- - ~ r ~ 8- ~ tOe< )~. _..__/~"' .-.T..:INSON \ --\ \ i ' ""t..--...,.Jr- 611:ANTL.(l' C,i,..fNN w.t..-.c. l , TN() ... A') L \ \ ,_ [(HQ~ '> ) ~ \ I' 'I I' r L 0 R D A ... !i Section 2. Term of Office. The term of office for all members shall be five {5) years, except that the initial appointment by the shall (Name of County) be for a term of~--~~~~--~~~--~~--~ years. Any vacancy in member(See attached schedule of terms) ship shall be filled for the unexpired term by the governing authority making the appointment which has become vacant. The appointing authority shall also have the power to remove any member it may appoint for cause, on written charges, after public hearing. All members shall serve without compensation. Section 3 Or~anization, Rules, Staff and Finances. The Commission shall elect a Chairman and Vice Chairman from among its appointive members. The term of office of the Chairman and Vice op.airman shall be for one (1) year or until re-elected or their successors are elected. The Commission shall appoint a secretary who may be an employee of the Commission. The Commission shall meet at least once each month at the call of the Chairman and at such other times as the Chairman or Board may determine, shall adopt rules for the transaction of business and shall keep a record of its resolutions, transactions, findings, and determinations, which record shall be a public record. The Commission may appoint such employees and staff as it may deem necessary for its work. In the performance of its duties, the planning commission may cooperate with, contract with, or accept funds from Federal, State, or local, public or semi-public agencies or private individuals or corporations, may spend such funds, and may carry out such cooperative undertakings and contracts. It may make expenditures for the purchase of required equipment and supplies. The expenditure of the Commission, exclusive of gifts to the commission and contract receipts, shall be within the amounts appropriated for the purpose by the participating governing authorities. Section 4. Powers and Duties. It shall be the function and duty of the Commission to make such careful and comprehensive surveys and studies of existing conditions and probable future developments and to prepare such plans tor physical, 2 social, and economic growth as Will best promote the public health, safety, morals, convenience, prosperity, or the general welfare as well as efficiency and economy in the development of the entire Georgia area (Section of State) and each political subdivision therein. In general, the Commission shall have such powers and duties and res~onsibilities as set forth in the General Planning Enabling Act of 1957, as amended (Act No. 258). BE IT FU