Papp Clinic Project Number: Counly: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 015-96 Coweta Establish a freestanding, multi-specialty ambulatory surgery center Denied by SHPA: 09-04-96 04-20-96 Papp and Newnan Hospital (Intervenor) Papp and Newnan Hospital John Sibley 03-20-97 and 03-21-97 Denied by hearing officer order: 06-12-97 NIA NIA St. Joseph's Hospital of Atlanta Project Number: 028-96 County: Fulton Description: Add a cardiac catheterization laboratory Date of Agency Decision: Approved by SHPA: 12-12-96 Date of Appeal: 10-03-96 Appealed by: Emory and Gwinnett Medical Center (Intervenor) Parties in Appeal: Emory, Gwinnett, Piedmont, and St. Joseph Hearing Officer: John Sibley Hearing Date: 04-28-97, 04-29-97, 04-30-97, and 05-01-97 Hearing Decision: no decision issued to date Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Emory University Hospital Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 039-96 DeKalb Establish a free standing cardiac catheterization facility Denied by SHPA 12-12-96 01-10-97 Emory and Gwinnett Medical Center Emory, Gwinnett Medical Center, Piedmont, and St. Joseph John Sibley 04-28, 29, 30-97 and 05-01-97 no decision issued lo dale NIA NIA Piedmont Hospital Project Number: County: Description: Dale of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 041-96 Fulton Add a cardiac catheterization lab Denied by SHPA 12-12-96 01-10-97 Emory and Gwinnett Medical Center Emory, Gwinnett Medical Center, Piedmont, and St. Joseph John Sibley 04-28, 29, 30-97 and 05-01-97 no decision issued to date NIA NIA 10 Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 030-96 Chatham Establish a free standing multi-specialty ambulatory surgery center Denied by SHPA: 12-04-96 12-30-96 Savannah Surgical and Candler Hospital Savannah Surgical and Candler Jordan Lubin Not scheduled yet NIA NIA NIA Open Fayette MRI Center Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: A ealed to Su erior Court: 050-96 Fayette Establish a freestanding J:v.!RI facility Approved by SHPA: 01-28-97 02-26-97 Piedmont Medical Center (Intervenor) Open Fayette and Piedmont Ellwood F. Oakley 06-18-97 Appeal of Piedmont dismissed: 06-17-97 NIA Alternative Healthcare Model: Integrated Continuwn of Geriatric Services Traces of Tiger (appellant 03-25-97) Tanner Medical Center Tift General Hospital University Hospital Renaissance Marquis (appellant 06-27-97) Windy Hill Hospital New Perry Nursing Home (appellant 03-25-97) Oconee Regional Senior Services (appellant 03-28-97) Georgia Baptist Geriatric Campus 056-96, Rabun, Application Denied 057-96, Carroll, Application Approved 062-96, Tift, Application Approved 064-96, Richmond, Application Approved 072-96, Floyd, Application Denied 073-96, Cobb, Application Approved 075-96, Houston, Application Denied 077-96, Baldwin, Application Denied 078-96, Henry, Application Approved The information below pertains to all the Alternative Health Care Models Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearmg Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: Additional Information: Develop an alternative healthcare model for the continuum of geriatric care 02-28-97 see above see above All of the above listed applications John Sibley Motion hearing 07 -16-97 NIA NIA NIA Renaissance Marquis, Inc./Floyd Medical Center (072-96) have withdrawn their appeal as of06-27-97. 11 Northside Hospital Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Su erior Court: 086-96 Fulton Expansion/Renovation project of 14 post-partum beds to the Women's Center and other areas Approved by SHPA: 03-31-97 04-18-97 Dunwoody Medical Center and North Fulton Regional Hospital Northside, Dunwoody, and North Fulton Walter Van Heiningen 06-30-1997 and 07-01-97 NIA NIA Special Care Units - Hospital within a Hospital Augusta Regional Medical Center Colisewn Medical Center West Paces Medical Center Doctors Hospital of Colwnhus University Hospital (Swnmit East) The Medical Center (Swnmit West) 045-96, Richmond, Application Approved: 12-06-96 046-96, Bibb, Application Approved: 12-06-96 047-96, Fulton, Application Approved: 12-06-96 048-96, Muscogee, Application Approved: 12-06-96 084-96, Richmond, Application Approved: 12-20-96 085-96, Muscogee, Application Approved: 12-20-96 The information below pertains to all the above cases. Description: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Cowt: Develop a special care unit, "Hospital within a Hospital," by converting existing general acute care beds to long tern care beds Vencor, Inc. and Vencor Hospitals of Atlanta Vencor, Inc. and all approved applicants Melvin M. Goldstein 05-6, 7-97 All applications were approved NIA NIA St. Joseph's Hospital of Atlanta Project Number: 004-97 County: Fulton Description: Establish a special care unit, "Hospital within a Hospital," by converting existing general acute care beds to long-term care beds Date of Agency Decision: Approved by SHPA: 04-03-97 Date of Appeal: 04-03-97 Appealed by: Vencor, Inc. and Vencor Hospitals of Atlanta Parties in Appeal: Vencor and Applicant Hearing Officer: Melvin M. Goldstein Hearing Date: 07-21-97 Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA 12 GA H7J.O . Pi C35 1c1cn/e-j State of Georgia Certificate-of-Need Appeals Report August1,1997 Edition One, Volume Two Prepared by: Shaun Patrick Smith Public Information Officer State Health Planning Agency Two Peachtree Street, 34th Floor Atlanta, GA 30303 Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 046-90 Laurens Expand service area to include Treutlen County. Denied by SHPA: 08-23-90 08-30-90 Applicant Only the applicant No appointment yet Appeal hearing not yet scheduled NIA NIA NIA ABC Home Health Services of Nashville Project Number: 063-91 County: Berrien Description: Establish a home health agency serving Berrien and Irwin counties. Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 10-08-91 Date of Appeal: 10-15-91 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Applicant Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled NIA NIA Health Field Services of Middle Georgia Project Number: 119-91 County: Bibb Description: Expand service area to include Houston, Peach, and Twiggs counties. Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-12-91 Date of Appeal: 06-05-92 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Only the applicant Hearing Officer: Walter Van Heiningen Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Healthmaster Home Health Care Project Number: 065-92 County: Paulding Description: Establish a home health agency to serve only Paulding County Date of Agency Decision: Approved by SHPA: 11-10-92 Date of Appeal: 11-25-92, 12-04-92, 12-08-92 Appealed by: family Home Health Care, Liberty Home Health, lnc., and Liberty Home Health Services Parties in Appeal: Healthmaster ofPaulding through banlauptcy Trustee and Liberty Home Health (now Georgia Baptist Health Services) Hearing Officer: Ellwood F. Oakley Hearing Date: Motion hearing held on 06-03-97 Hearing Decision: Georgia Baptist motion to dismiss application ofHealthmaster granted; denied 06-10-97 Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA 2 Pediatric Services ofAmerica Project Number: 123-92 CoW1ty: Fulton Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Carroll, Cherokee, Clayton, Cobb, Coweta, DeKalb, Douglas, Fayette, Forsyth, Fulton, and Gwinnett coill1ties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-23-93 Date of Appeal: 07-13-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Pediatric Services ofAmerica (Fulton and Hall) Kids Medical College, and The HUG Horne Health Agency Hearing Officer: no appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 126-92, 012-93 and 019-93. Comparatively reviewed with project numbers 030-93 and 039-93. Pediatric Services ofAmerica Project Number: 126-92 County: Hall Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Banks, Barrow, Dawson, Habersham, Hall, Jackson, Lumpkin, and White coW1ties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-30-93 Date of Appeal: 07-13-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Pediatric Services of America (Fulton and Hall) Kids Medical College, and The HUG Horne Health Agency Hearing Officer: no appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 123-92, 012-93 and 019-92. Comparatively reviewed with project numbers 030-93 and 039-93. Kids Medical College of Georgia, Inc. Project Number: 019-93 CoW1ty: Cobb Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Carroll, Cherokee, Clayton, Cobb, Coweta, DeKalb, Douglas, Fayette, Forsyth, Fulton, and Gwinnett COW1ties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-23-93 Date of Appeal: 07-21-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Pediatric Services of America (Fulton and Hall) Kids Medical College, and The HUG Horne Health Agency Hearing Officer: no appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 123-92, 012-93 and 126-93. Comparatively reviewed with project numbers 030-93 and 039-93. 3 The HUG Home Health Agency Project Number: 030-93 County: Hall Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Banks, Barrow, Dawson, Habersham, Hall, Jackson, Lumpkin, and White counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-23-93 Date of Appeal: 07-21-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Pediatric Services of America (Fulton and Hall) Kids Medical College, and The HUG Home Health Agency Hearing Officer: no appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Comparatively reviewed with project numbers 123-92, 019-93, 039-93, 012-93 and 126-93. Pediatric Services ofAmerica Project Number: 125-92 County: Richmond Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Burke, Columbia, Jefferson, McDuffie, and Richmond counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-21-93 Date of Appeal: 05-27-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Pediatric Services of America (Richmond and Bibb) and The Hug Home Health Agency Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Pediatric Services ofAmerica Project Number: 127-92 County: Bibb Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Bibb, Crawford, Houston, Jones, Monroe, Peach, and Twiggs counties. Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-05-93 Date of Appeal: 05-11-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Pediatric Services of America (Richmond and Bibb) and The Hug Home Health Agency Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA The HUG Home Health Agency Project Number: 026-93 County: Richmond Description: Develop a home health agency for medically fragile and technology-dependent children to serve Burke, Columbia, Jefferson, McDuffie, and Richmond counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-21-93 Date of Appeal: 06-21-93 4 Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: Additional Information: Applicant Pediatric Services of America (Richmond and Bibb) and The Hug Home Health Agency No appointment yet Appeal hearing not yet scheduled NIA NIA NIA Comparatively reviewed with project number 125-92, Pediatric Services of America Option Care of Southwest Georgia Project Number: 062-93 County: Mitchell Description: Establish a high-technology home health agency to serve Calhoun, Clay, Dougherty, Randolph, and Terrell counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 11-12-93 Date of Appeal: 12-07-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Option Care of Southwest Georgia (Mitchell and Lee Counties) Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Option Care of Southwest Georgia Project Number: 063-93 County: Lee Description: Establish a high-technology home health agency to serve Crisp, Lee, Sumter, and Worth Counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 11-12-93 Date of Appeal: 12-07-93 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Option Care of Southwest Georgia (Mitchell and Lee Counties) Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: Appealed to Su erior Court: Lanier Park Regional Hospital Project Number: 103-93 County: Hall Description: Establish perinatal services Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-03-94 Date of Appeal: 05-25-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Lanier Park Regional and North Georgia Medical Center Hearing Officer: Jordan E. Lubin Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Americare Home Health Services Project Number: 118-93 County: Spalding Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Fayette, Pike, and Spalding Counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-06-94; Approved on remand 11-14-96 5 Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 05-12-94; Appeal ofremand 12-11-96 Applicant in 1994; Georgia Baptist Health Services in 1996 Americare Home Health; Extended Community Home Health; Georgia Baptist Health Services - Formerly lmown as Liberty Home Health Ellwood F. Oakley 04-1 0-97 and 04-11-97 Application approved 05-21-97 by hearing officer order NIA NIA Extended Commmtlty Home Health Project Number: 004-94 County: Fayette Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Clayton., Coweta, Fayette, and Spalding counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 05-06-94; Approved on remand 11-14-96 Date of Appeal: 06-06-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Americare Home Health; Extended Community Home Health; Georgia Baptist Health Services - Formerly lmown as Liberty Home Health Hearing Officer: Ellwood F. Oakley Hearing Date: 04-1 0-97 and 04-11-97 Hearing Decision: Application approved 05-21-97 by hearing officer order Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA ABC Home Health ofAugusta Project Number: 013-94 County: Richmond Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Columbia and Richmond Counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-10-94 Date of Appeal: 07-08-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: University Hospital and Americare of Richmond Hearing Officer: Jordan Lubin Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA R.:view Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 003-94, 008-94, and 023-94 University Hospital Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: Additional Information: 023-94 Richmond Develop a home health agency to serve Columbia and Richmond counties Denied by SHPA: 06-10-94 11-08-94 Applicant University Hospital and the Americare ofRichmond Joran E. Lubin 08-04-97 NIA NIA NIA Joined with project numbers 003-94, 008-94, and 013-94. 6 Americare Home Health Services Project Number: 119-93 County: Clarke Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Bartow, Clarke, Jackson, Madison, and Oconee counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-09-94 Date of Appeal: 06-17-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Barrow Medical Center; Athens Regional Medical Center Hearing Officer: Walter Van Heiningen Hearing Date: 06-27-97 Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA ABC Home Health of Danielsville Project Number: 015-94 County: Madison Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Banks, Franklin, and Madison counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-09-94 Date of Appeal: 07-08-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Barrow Medical Center; Athens Regional Medical Center Hearing Officer: Walter Van Heiningen Hearing Date: 06-27-97 Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 119-93, 016-94, and 019-94 ABC Home Health of Gainesville Project Number: 016-94 County: Hall Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Habersham and Hall counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-09-94 Date of Appeal: 07-08-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Barrow Medical Center; Athens Regional Medical Center Hearing Officer: Walter Van Heiningen Hearing Date: 06-27-97 Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 119-93 and 015-94 Athens Regional Medical Center Project Number: 019-94 County: Cobb Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Barrow, Clarke, Jackson, Madison, Oconee counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-09-94 Date ofAppeal: 06-28-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Barrow Medical Center; Athens Regional Medical Center Hearing Officer: Walter Van Heiningen Hearing Date: 06-27-97 Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA 7 Additional Information: Joined with project numbers 119-93, 015-94, and 016-94. Comparatively reviewed with project numbers 028-94 and 030-94. Barrow Medical Center Project Number: County: Description: Date of Agency Decision: Date of Appeal: Appealed by: Parties in Appeal: Hearing Officer: Hearing Date: Hearing Decision: Review Board Decision: Appealed to Superior Court: 028-94 Barrow Develop a home health agency to serve Barrow, Jackson, and Oconee counties Denied by SHPA: 06-09-94 06-15-94 Applicant Barrow Medical Center; Athens Regional Medical Center Walter Van Heiningen 06-27-97 NIA NIA NIA Chattooga Home Health Agency Project Number: 030-94 County: Jackson Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Banks, Barrow, Jackson, Madison, and Oconee counties from headquarters in Jackson county. Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-09-94 Date of Appeal: 06-23-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Barrow Medical Center; Athens Regional Medical Center Hearing Officer: Walter Van Heiningen Hearing Date: 06-27-97 Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Comparatively reviewed with project numbers 119-93, 015-94, 016-94, 019- 93, and 028-94 ABC Home Health of Hiawassee Project Number: 017-94 County: Towns Description: Develop a home health agency to serve Rabun, Towns, Union, and White counties Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 07 -11-94 Date of Appeal: 08-08-94 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Applicant Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project number 034-94 Southside Community Health Center Home Health Agency Project Number: 061-94 County: Fulton Description: Expand home health service to include Clayton and DeKalb counties Date of Agency Decision: Approved by SHPA: 09-30-94 Date of Appeal: 09-26-94 Appealed by: Visiting Nurse Health Systems of Atlanta, Inc. Parties in Appeal: Applicant and VNA of Atlanta Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled 8 Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA HCA Colisewn Medical Centers Project Number: 091-94 County: Bibb Description: Merge HCA Coliseum Psychiatric Hospital with HCA Coliseum Medical Centers Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 01-27-95 Date of Appeal: 02-22-95 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Applicant and Charter Lake Hospital Hearing Officer: No appointment yet Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Satilla Regional Cancer Treatment Project Number: 138-94 CoWlty: Wayne Description: Develop an outpatient radiation therapy center Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-22-95 Date of Appeal: 07-24-95 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Satilla and Southeast Georgia Medical Center Hearing Officer: Melvin W. Goldstein Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project number 022-95 Southeast Georgia Regional Medical Center Project Number: 022-95 County: Wayne Description: Develop a freestanding radiation therapy center Date of Agency Decision: Denied by SHPA: 06-22-95 Date of Appeal: 07-24-95 Appealed by: Applicant Parties in Appeal: Applicant and Satilla Hearing Officer: Melvin W. Goldstein Hearing Date: Appeal hearing not yet scheduled Hearing Decision: NIA Review Board Decision: NIA Appealed to Superior Court: NIA Additional Information: Joined with project number 138-94 Austell Ambulatory Surgery Center Project Number: 001-96 Cow1ty: Cobb Description: Establish a freestanding, multi-specialty ambulatory surgery center Date of Agency Decision: Approved by SHPA: 07-16-96 Date of Appeal: 08-09-96 Appealed by: Promina Cobb Hospital, Northwest GA Health System, Inc., and Promina NW Parties in Appeal: Austell and Promina Hearing Officer: Ellwood F. Oakley Hearing Date: 12-1 7-96, 01-07-97, and 02-28-97 Hearing Decision: Approved by hearing officer order 05-13-97 Review Board Decision: N/A 9